ML20234E429
Text
_
j i
d Y
Jw re==hard, meus servase seeneh
- 7 Divisies of Public tar-mme h, 54, p.ggg meae J. e ek, astias " a*==* te the Odf"I #y8" W ;
4.5e -%.
t b* J %.Mm.w:y an== ear far ambits sneerestime, s&s i.
.. o:
s nM soman arzuort Ey. ? # w.
.; I 43 jo -a.of FIsaac
-l I
asemehed ese etape severtas the sens meer centeessee mar 6,
'I 1964, sessurses she mes11 y*e emports W serveyed the Anashes earthquehe. A scenery, eory =""- $ ef the geestsees asked j
at the esos esafesense une penpared by 305E.
g;..
Milies n====**, Chesumes of the es118ersia 75C une geese se e ass endte poseses poetender aftsameos and empressed his epseses.
.-5:
estas steamstr, useerdges seester masser. Ms aos is the pensees 2
of obsesetas a =% and utit asemmed ser seer sessemeeses.
M.F-
~t aurses the basednese, he ested steh pesde stee he had thee day i.,. d esaned the IWC seder appearses the Camp feedletes seester. A alsy essertog thte IOC enties stee is antested.
e.
asteenemme :
- 1. Psees seasseemse essetten
. / :.3 c.e- /
e asessey. en s s/6/ s.
. V -7
... vwr 4
Ed.'suc L "s.t. teenseer geste setsste 3/7/M'.' "' O ~ ' e3' ' ~1, '"z u wm 3.
s.r. chosesene ganha artsats s/7/M '
F
- ~
- s. ammen mese see e,s user s;/6/ n 4.
amata asas osake artsene s
- %df -
stu... : +
. w.~ :
y,
=p 6.
makt m. Jensest een, puednessa
. m;1 aresens S/1/M
...:a.:i w ^ >. ' b. '
g.
-=
- 7. s.t. shmessete 1er to sesser 3/7/M 5-.;
0
.N
'vp 3 r.=
es sero u eries, ans, ne., e/sete.he '
o r
^
S
... n-7 asbers saammatesa, mas, as, s/seteeks
[' h g
- r. a. etteuse, ans, m.,
- etanha 7
MAy12 e
6
" gQ,,,,a@o,23b
- s. s. semes, art, me., m/atteshs j
- a. w. autth, es,1semme v, sas e/seteshe crJuu g oca m-m n,,
y Notlyr.t3M *: C'L:3Z 3 :0:?w0
'WWO3 J,0J3h3 Z.17 3,
.. l.
4
,.,,,n, u
tn 6
$, 4Ls. a,
.1;a
.e.c q.n
$ " ? '
- f' f.
- e 6
03M333y 4 <gg/
99
,,eeaw....:
8709220389 85i217 PDR FOIA FIRESTOB5-665 PDR 11
. ~.
s
~ l, O
l* /
s..
e g
t
.\\
.%,,,<.<w.,
4 -
+.:
2.J 1...a e.v.
......,,,'y w..-
,.L............
v i
.%.., w.
QC +., a..e 1
,u 1...i='".
l
~9, e v.e.
b' C.4.,* 4 e.sC
- m. 8 c.
t c.... s i
l 1
1 o.
.m....
. *... u,, C.,w..,.
n.
a.
1
... a
..ag
.s..m.2.w"*...'.
C".. C "..w*.t '. '6 O.*. 9 J
..,.k,,A
'.^.""....*.*;,*...*.".9
. ~. ~ -'.%..
0.*" " ".
i
.w i
- - O. #
... 4.e.. O. < l.
.,.j. 0',
.i yv.n,. Ye..
ue C o C.3 4..,. e.,.,,.. S O.
- s.., O,< e i..,.n..,. we...e..
.U...,.,
C n..a.. p.
uc
%..,.yv.v m.
- r..
e p.
p g y*. 4. 4.,.s i i,.. C C v., C... e., n d '"<..
.c....:..O",.."'..#.*."uD..*"...*."...,.$'."..
- d. **#.~1
- 4.."
- m...
v.....
. v.. w 6...
A
%u Sw.. 4:*.
n s.s.
i o
v
.w a..
a1 t...
..v
....w
% -....w
- e. L.,
.i...w......-<.w..6...
. ww 7.
- C C "..'. ', ' '..'.# ^ *
.d ' **"*
'..%.s't o... -.
.,.,..9.", v*s".'-...,.,*..* '.. '. *.. -. '. ' * *.. "
.."CCc.'.'.,.".*..."."..'.".~..~.~.,~,.'.'.8 y
. w w..
- f.
.J
. 4 + %.
- e. C tt.i <,.., a +*.i C,.. a........,.......
c.
..s.,
......t.4..
6 + a.s. s.
4 s,.
/.....%...
2 v,... -.O#...,.,
o
) s,....e C v.
f, -C8,,..,
,... +.
e.
..,.,...4s.
....w..
.ww 4.
w, g,...
.., s.,._. n..r
.e.
..%..,,.2.<.,.
i
- i. )
p..,
~
.w,
.,,,,y co +
.,<r=.
< o. a o
r i
..y.a..:c.......,.......s.. e..
....,... s..a
. _ n m
cr..-:t;C.uahe will.taka.rb.na.
)
De = N,
- d.,
ev
.I.
4
.I= b.9.d.a A
gi.
.,s wuc.d.e.*C.g.,,. 9 s
w.
.h.
.*qa,,.+.
..w.
- e..h
... v
+ %..
1...
- s. v.
,0
.v.
.w...
P.V. y.
O
^0.....
f..
e.
,,, J t
a..
s,-n n. 4.%eaa, p.....,.
s c.
.s.,,
A, sn
.. Cs,4. VC e.
...s..
.e 3...
- a.,.,.. e a i
- .c.%.
.e....
...s.
c i
.....a.
4.,,...,,...
...A.
.e.i..<.,...e
,,C.,9 -..C. CCCn O 3.y C
.4
-.c, a.
- p...
.w...
..w f.
oy
+
,.~4 w
s.... u
., 7 T g.~ +. 1. yv
. 3e.i...e.%..p...,..<.,.,:.4.,..,..
.v.
.....e....i...,,.,..,,.,..
- m.,
6)
,De 4 v 1 Cn'i.y ya. e.*.
s r%.C
,s
.,. 4,
w 7/
EC./ '.'C ' a'c Cve VC.'w e
- i. '. ~ e 1.
.4 - e.".."..'.' C ".,,, 5...c.....,
,9
.g 1'
..... 3%.s wy
.c...g/. ge.
u...m..
-4,.
..3. n. i..d.,.., ~.. N e..
e.,,
a w
e...
si e e
^
- n. o.
9)
- y. yCu study whct haptened in Alachc (re cain-' r '.t'.vd
'* v'-c.*d ro
...ww 10)
FC.?..any pr/.,er pir.r'.
9.9 re 0-w c f e-r'.c e h ~ + e c' n. ' r m A.y
- e. ~. v. sw C,.
,p, c, _..
-v io.
11) 1.*t,' ': vould h:.ppe. ',',,d0 1 e.s m a.s f-'.le d f. e '- W.
6h},,...,.,.,,
v..3...9 U.d= i.9
,p,gg
- h. g
.$.N%.e,,.e.y
.J.9..,
,,,g 4
i g
ee w.
g.e.
,y -..,g 7,-...;.
y.
.)y.
q-.y
- m-
.m_
r -
- w o+~
4.
7 -lgn a
u_______
y.
.t
(
.nwam4.
-e'euo.
O g
ec; b....
<r e e %
- Sf I* b ".
- h*I
",.,0 f $ @
- !.l *),).3[ *,
,.,',0
- * *,,, * f
,e,.ot
, y, a '.. %. p,... '.*e. e,,, n, d.
.e.,.
4'
.ns
,a
.. +
eag. '.
C p,,,
.e.
.m,.s... e., s.
g,,.p,.,
. m..n, yr...,,.
(, s
,j
.o..
e e,
e s.
- s o o s.. '.o.
yo.*
A... w.o.
w.i = g v... s m e..
- s.....
,,..s,
..e 6.. e w w........w.
w w;. w w - -L,.,
...e
..n-w w.w
,,w..
v D
'.,....,.,.4..*..* 7f s'.e,. i e.
w...J
.6....,....i.
.~
?
- 3. e
.ar,,
- sa
.e s
l l
. '.71.'s. E..r.
~
I 4 e e
o 0
1 i
9 e
j t
4 4
v 0
w
(,
s M6, hti e
4 1
,8'
...., ~.,.
~.,,
...s.
u o
% Quake Risk'.
At Bode ra vSite
.W[x w i:.
_'. Ngej
\\
The devastating Alaskan all picture o the earthouake !!he' San Andreas fault, which carthquake has not altered effcet. l cstimate that ai nnst 'is about a mile cast of the the 91. inion of any PG&E cx. 80 perce:t of the buildin;splant site..
pcrts on the safety of the in Anchorage survived un-. The possibility of the' San company's Dodega Ifcad site damaged."
Iur a nuclear power plant Andreas ia u1i shifting its F,. C. Narliare, f o r m o'r courso and rupturing che.
s A' four ' nan technical chief engineering acologist where he said, is so remote team just back from an for the California Depart-that, "for all pracucal pur.
i
[
en the. spot inspection of ment of Water Resources:
poses it may be dis.
Alaska's cart,hquake damage incde tius qmte cicar yestcr' "tThe A 1 a s k a n carth-regarded."
I da y..
quaken and other s h o c k s such as the IDOG shock near The experts and hi;;hlights San Francisco clearly dem.
of their findings:
onstrate the importance of.a Dr. llugo Denioff, profes. fi.rm foundation. It is falla.
i s,cr of seismology at the clous to su;' gest that damage California Institute of Tech. that occurred at Anchorage Dology in Pasadena:
and Valdez cou'd occur.on "The Alaskan carthquake Dodega llcad."
i i
m e r ely reaffirmed know!.
F. F. Naute, PG&E's chief 1
cdge.we already had con. civil eng:ncer:
cerning the mechanisms by "important major struc.
which earthquakes e a u s e lures designed to resist carth-g damage. It is our u n d c r-quak genera,e s. such as power sianding of these mcchnisms, i
i ting stations, wf t h.
and particularly our undct-stood the carthquake and
\\
i standing of the San Andreas subsequent shocks b'one of.
fault system, that permits us the power plants in the carth -
{
to state confidently that the gaake area was forced out Dodega site is safe for a of operation during the carth.
properly designed plant."
- quake because of mechant-l' Dr. George W. Ifousner, cal, electrics! or structural professor of applied mechan-faDure.
les and ch'il engineering at The experts discounted the.
CalTech:
possibility of seis alc wave "I saw r.o evidence of damsgo to the prc 20 sed Bo-significant ' damage to any dega Head plant be:ause the buildings designed and. con. site is located on Ec Dodega 2
i structed.in accordance with Eay side of a 150 foot occan i,
.spproved practice.. News Cliff-reports dramatized t h o s c Benloff said it is "unthink-buildings.which were dam-cble" that any future carth-aged by landslides. These re-quake 1,n the area w o u I d ports have distorted the over occur anyuherc except along i c.. i _
m ll s
s e
1
~ IP.D. Editorial
- f
),-
')
'DbparacAr PAGE 2.. Thyriday, May 7,' 1964 FHE*
' THE $AN FRANC %CC CHRONICLE EDITofta i m. yoi are
, continuhg to dh,;,nte any.
=
o
., one who op,oses the PG&g Masha, Quake Studv
- plant on Bahga ficsd.
u ne s
~au a
, which you s~ aid ifarry W. Gra.
s-
, ham "a,3pcared" beforc the -
hh W.)h
, San Fr a n cisco $@ctrisors oced y uld n r, stard why the Sonoma Coun.
. J.,
ly T a x p a y ers Associadon 3 ty je pt
's N' c rr%e
} those mort qualukd 10 knowFo h
L be W 4. ila 4Is gy b d D t;, C." :
.T the answcTs.nnd icos lyf (M3e Tour expsrts retained by Who didn't. '
Wt are the questions at
- .the Pacific Gas and Elec.
I"*'~,7 " t Y 'j present. Mr. Editor? It seems '.
i 1
.fric Company said k 77
day they svare cor@ yester-W *, p.
~N::ir lo me the most important l
a ced
( > {(.'
W quesuon is the gelogic ar.d f.' n!ter 4tn jngK'etion of Ahts ' 3 D i
- atismic safety of the site. And -
i kan earthquake damage
- W els_ M L t the resolutions cornicg from J
J b that it would be safe to i
a's t t Santa Rosa o'rganisanons at!
+
Ybuild a nuclear power. %
8,.
(9 Q* Y{< %' sQa;M. pA.
say,"Lesve it to ee Aionje.
t'
., plant at Bodega Head.
e Dergy Comm!ssion." B you
- One of the foar. Dr. Ilugo r -
c i
- r. a'J1 recall the SIMc Supreme
" Benioff, scismology professor st the California Institue of. {s}' 3 5 @N hp !.f
)
Cet dedsfon s'ated that the -
4 i e.
4
- i Technolo.;y, said he vastly V N J W G.,
- AEC tuuld dedde only on the
. radiation hazard and that it '
F preferred the controversial d i ;C'"$
- 3. i
/ was up to the Ctllfornia Pul>
utodega site to some place
' ' " ' // / 9
- lic Utiuties Ccmmission to de-
_ farther away from the San A,
r acas fault
- f j 7 "O
/ cme on the s]Le safety - that -
/.
r not even the m'#ty AEC' 1
l "Lo c a tio n s near meth c I'
+ could do that. -
+
1
.' faults often provide better
'f f* I -
y So it seems to me if you
's 4 foundations ior structures Ji 4 want to do the people of this
{
7 from the s ta n d p oIn1 of, DR. HUGO BENIOFF
'
- crediting those who are try.
i e a rth q u a1: e hazards than area a service,instead of dia.
-; locations far*.her away," Dr.
Closer can be safer.
- Ing to get the answers, you.
Beinoff said at a press con.
I ference in the auditorium of O should encourage further hear.
. the PGLE Lutiding.
f ings with presentations by er.
[
'The possibility of the San pcrts to decide this irnpriant 1 Andreas fault's. shifting its enestion of safety.
course and rupturing else-
. ROY K. FAUGHT i
where, such as through the
. Bodega Bay I
Eodega ficad reactor site, is so remote that for all practi.
i-cal purposes it may be disre.
1 garaed." he aeded-ICalifornia Agency Votes
,The scient:st declared he
!To Allow $82Million was ecewn est a fuwe earthquakes would be along i
the Uncs of existing faults.
Y. F. Mauts, PGLE's chief 1h. ? tic ear ower Plant l
solutely convinced" the Boo '
I Q Q y,n,,,[ fp g y ega plant could not be des-j troyed by a ciuake. And even
,,. wm a,,,%,m e,,,,,,,,,,,,
i 8
ISS ANCEEM-The Caufornia Public Uul.
mph sil a t he 13es Commismon condiuonally authortaed can.
- garded the question as
- Haum n of n sammn muelear twer plut "p u r ely theoretical" -the at Camp Pend:eton. Caut.. subject to haal sp
, plant could be shut down Proval of the Atomic Energy Commia iott sately without releasing
- deadly fallout on the Bodega The Atc attenov has inued a permit to SoMhm Cahforna F.dma Co.. San Dino cas area.
A Lettric Co.. Bechtel Corp. and Wesur:g.
- ' Dr. Georg,c W.
Ilopsner.
! professor W sipplied mechon 1 house Electric Corp. to bu!!c the plant. h is ex.
'icii and civil engineer at Cal-l pected to give final approva' anor:!y.
tech. repcried t;.at in AlasXad Bechtel. San Francisco, and Wesunghouse.
-~ i he found "no evidence of sig Pntnourth, are cocontractors en the project.
i nificant damage t cany bulldq, southern Cahtornia Edison. !.cs A.apics. MU own am of the piam and san D ego can uie ings designed and construct.
rm mer2n i
ed in accordance with sp-TMS Plant Mit be ku en u 44 acre site ca proved practice."
~,,.
the Pac fic shoreline m no northwes: cna nr E.-C. Maritave of baeram.
C"*P P'"d!a^
- M *'m' Corps ba.e. It am er.to, enginectmg geologist,
""" " '*4*D 'I MN ".n ca*e wr.s*er ac l Ie N
s J..It is fallacious to sug*
wta Tae Neal c vnp;ri.e t
gest that damage that oc-AEC permit a pee. :.. tan i
curred at Arichorage could.
l-3, occur on Docega licad. The io u n d a tio n snaterials are marhedly d& rent."
(
e 4
l
)
s l'
1 l
_,__,__,___1a_
__u--.a..~~---.~--==*'&
.. em 1
- m. LAS.TL9 STUDV'. p.
-)
4.-
Q'% ?J Q
- 7
<*';f ar
' *'~
y.g t
m.m p
," g Ai4.6.v::s7*
aD{J
%./6t
.w+
l By DON ENGDA!!L
. cialist, ecnoluded from the trip P.D. Staff Writer that buildings properly designed SAN FRANCISCO-. Members suffered no "significar.t dam.
of a Pacific Cas and Electric age."
JCo. earthquake team just back He said Ia r g e landslides from Alaska today reaffirmed caused most of the serious
^
4 their faith in the Bodega Head' building damage but said news nuclear power plant site, reports." distorted the overall Three consultants and a com picture of the earthquake ef.
pany en:tineer said they found fect.
nothingin their study that would "I estimate at least to per l
raise doubts about the safety of cent of the buildings in Anchor-i the Bodega proposal.
. age survived undamaged."
The four men revealed their E. C. Martiave, consulting findings at a press conference engineering geologist. empha.
- ~..
here today.
sized foundaticn mateials as a F. F. Mautz PG&E chief civil factor in building d mage..In engineer who led the team, said Valdez 'he said "the saturated damage in the Alaksan quake soft glacial material.underly.
l was due to poor foundation ing the town and dock.'arca g
l
[
conditions and " failure to follow slumped and slid out into the known structural design and con-harbor."
struction sta6dards for earth.
In Cordova, "which is found.
quke areas."
.ed on rock thet i: rever:ly
{
Mr. Mautz said major dam.hoir.ted. fre-tured and. fr.u'tcr j
age was toe result primarily of.Mr. Mar!!ac said. "na dane t in; and sliding o't the groondsl age to 5:M ";s o:d or new soils failures-" massive slump.
l.
was obsermi cr reported."
i (made possib!c by the presencc{
"of a bluff."
~
l 4.Mr. Mautz ' ontrasted those, c
'icondillons with the granite foun-l Lldction material for the pro.
posed Bodega reactor.
- ] Institute of Technology seismol-Dr. Ilugo Benicff. California 3p y,g, ga[urW '
+
p G,-7, t,,,,,w g7
- egy professor, saa! the Alaskan
.ditor-PG&E's attitude toward trip " reaffirmed much that we a
quakes. Nothing shown by thel the public was early made appar.:
already know about earth-ent in its proposed defilement of Alaskan earthquake would ind Doran Park at Bodega Bay. Here a dlcate that the Bodega Head!
! p pular camping, fishing and just site is not safe."
- plain dip your feet in the sea" i
i Calling the Bodega Head site recreation area is gofng to sprout au "exce!!cnt location for a ugly fowfoot-high. voltage mon-l nuclear reacter" Dr. Benloff 5'O '8' ' So, Senator Kuchel, The l
l
.said the grankic rock providesl Chronicle and all you indignants:
l a good foundation and said thcl please be as interested in the pro.
possibility thr.t the San Andreas p sed deformation of this delight-carthquake fa.h m'ght shift its, ful pubhc natural setting as you g
course and move closer than are over the snterests of - the 1.3 miles from the plant is "so wealthy residents of Weedside, remote that for all practical ALLAN GORLICK.
purpo.*es it may be disregard-Haywa rd.
ed. "
w The third member of the team. Dr. George W. Housner,
' California Institute cf Techno!-
,ogy earthqur.ko' engineering spe-4 O
D
_____________._________L
_i_i._______m.. _.. _ _ _ _. _
__.__m m
m
___ i_
_-._m_.__