ML20210U684
| ML20210U684 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Diablo Canyon  |
| Issue date: | 06/21/1984 |
| From: | Chandler L NRC |
| To: | Eisenhut D, Martin J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V), Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20210U520 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-86-197 NUDOCS 8610100149 | |
| Download: ML20210U684 (2) | |
Text
I.
s l'
June 21, 1984 flote to: Darrell Eisenhut, Director Division of Licensing John B. flartin, Administrator Region V From:
Lawrence J. Chandler Special Litigation Counsel
SUBJECT:
DIABLO CANYON ALLEGATI0tlS The attached documents were discussed with you briefly last week. As you will note, the Joint Intervenors' reply appends a number of new documents which should be examined by the Staff and given appropriate consideration.
In addition, the Joint Intervenors have complained that, even.with deletions of names and other identifying information, PG&E has been able to identify informants and has allegedly taken some type of retaliatory action. For this reason, they have submitted four additional documents only to the Appeal Board and have sought a protective order to avoid disclosing these documents to the Staff and PG8E even with deletions made.
In light of this, we have filed the attached answer with the Appeal Board supporting a more limited form of protec-tive order which would provide for disclosure to the Staff and the licensee the documents in question with the deletion of the names and any identifying infoma-tion relating to the informant.
Dr 9
t rneJ n
dial Litigation Courpel
Enclosures:
- 1. Joint Intervenors' Reply to PGandE and !!RC Staff Responses to !!otions Regarding Design Quality Assurance, Construction Quality Assurance, and Licensee Character and Competence, June 11, 1984
- 2. Errata to June 11, 1984 Reply, June 12, 1984
- 3. Joint Intervenors' Motion for Protective Order, June 11, 1984
- 4. FIRC Staff's Answer to Joint Intervenors' tiotion for Protective Order, June 19, 1984 cc w/ enclosures: Ben Hayes e610100149 860930
[M
-197 PDR
t{
N RECORD OF TELEPHONE CO:NERSATION DATE:
du,7 e.
/984
. PROJECT:
[,l.[/ d,, yon
.S~.'freceu,v, RECORDED 3T: A New //e,,
CLIENT:
,"G f f
'r'dy/ din 4 //4m,
OF 4 *S 14
<*.ner /M T.U.KED WITrt:
ROUTE M:
INFORP.ATION M O.-
A A'. b.a,
,r /.aa/<za,.,
.4 / s;. /, a,.L,.
J. t%A/
1.
c3, A.,
L MAIN SU3JNCT OF CALL: fe /..r< As //l tac a,4 4.irra.4ee d*/I, d;. //d G n s.,,.si d.
.i 7Aa yrvep re of/4. fepy$ anS A a%t's-es4e
- f. rC Av.u swa c
" A N $l*fi' *S r
.r$ c$rs ITDiS DTSCUSSED:
t
(.
,ae./ e,v /4.rsiG dAk4/ f4. K..,e/LN 1,,n.Ltr Afe, one., eA rev.r.ri.,, al.d ~Aan e w//vir;/k r.4 wL./ a,e u 4,rdci V
.f ins.ree,. a.,ap A.w L a,ov//be-ea eriaD L/ Ak f}L,.. sL, af s
,a k eihn war uree/.,se>n. tu. -w///" /<w,J A L,, N nia e., )pJa.
/
mu/ PG/E,.se.nrv/A.o/ / sf s9,5s.,,,L aard, 2'.)enefya)) en c'?
O fA, 6,v eAsn/e, o/a a 4,,6 M s4 sas L.,,&A,;>. Lad 4.'sn,,,,:,f we. 2" // '" ~,,:,ese, EAR A./b,am.ra<n s/(,r,%AiLA g 4.ya.Qft,,eLJa
. 1%.J+AC_ru e AA~./y~
UEwi// rsa,s wa/ s/&s,..., e 7 a.,.,,,
,n.,e / C. e e s,
e
.i n
war /ofk&l/ l A //A Jil /dw 2.aA4,< a / A,ar a,,s,sA.for e/
a i
pa & es)A<*/m,. /rena/<ar, a,,s J a,,',,, A, a. a,,,
f ;,f B aa.!u
/L./* we r,e.u od bv [OhYS >> l9 7 f $** S/ slMM 4.asar-u,.r*Yre vsWYJe/ce r$
/'
a,a p,,,, A,m,,fAls AaAe:.i. a L, d,C A ' /L Ja., han e< cez A /..,ia/. e,vp rwes a / /4 5 La, sC.,,//z.,,e.<,./.6
(' -
f e /,yi1: p a,/r e/se Asc'r/ i, & t'f ** ******'* l.5 til.. On E
5 bh..b 2 t' /N wi s rVi t~e.Nn, h /s'L,,I'/&..., tr4,,*// edh,<< x / sor.sj:
- s
$ b'~ y f/I N,)2.*h. f e
t 's
.3
{ - f.:i f:n:-Q'; ? qs :-a.-~.':) xg a : > + -D.;,. 3,. ;ik;. iz.Q_.u.l.:...y;.;. -n..?; -:.u g..;,..
74
.js~ E -4.. d'. Q*.~.?.C,. 3.sQM,..~w'W~ WB-E.:.J\\...:.....?,,:'**M.*._.
G
,. %. v. t ~.* =: ;..~.*.. h " 2,ij.:.b:C.*:i:
M'
-~-
- n..:.,. a.- -.
~- -
- oP PACIFIC GAS AND E LE C T RIC C O M PANY n statt starct, san raascisco. catireania 94tos Tctresout <ais 78i.42:2 g gy, July 5,1984 Thomas S. Moore, Esq., Chaiman Dr. John H. Buck Dr. W. Reed Johnson Atomic Safety and Licensing Appeal Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Comission 4350 East-West Highway East-West Tower, 5th Floor Bethesda, MD 20814 Re: Docket No. 50-275, OL-DPR-76 Docket No. 50-323 Diablo Canyon Units 1 and 2 Response to Footnote 21 of Memorandum and Order Dated June 28,1984 (ALAB-775)
Gentlemen:
In response to footnote 21 of the decision of the Appeal Board dated June 28,1984 (ALAB-775), the Affidavit of H. W. Karner is enclosed. As can be seen from the Affidavit, the prior responses of applicant to allegations concerning the use of #307 material remain true and correct.
Kindly acknowledge receipt of thir, material on the enclosed copy of this letter and return it in the enclosed addressed envelope.
Very truly yours,
.OtlGINAL SIGNED BY Dan G. Lubbock Enclosure cc: Service List l
1 t
-yg?
y
/
/
l
o UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD In the Matter of.
)
)
)
Docket Nos. 50-275 PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC
)
50-323 COMPANY
)
)
(Diablo Canyon Nuclear Power )
Plant, Units 1 and 2)
)
)
AFFIDAVIT OF H. W. KARNER STATE OF CALIFORNIA
)
)
ss.
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO )
The above, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
My name is Harold W. Karner.
I am employed by Pullman Power Products as Manager, Quality Assurance / Quality Control, at Diablo Canyon Power Plant. On May 31, 1984, I issued an interoffice memorandum to all Pullman QA/QC inspectors onsite which stated, inter alia, that "A-307 bolts with the heads removed are NOT acceptable." My intention when issuing the memo was not to imply that the prior use of A-307 bolts as studs was technically unacceptable, but merely to procedurally stop a practice which had evoked enough controversy that its continuation was not deemed desirable.The memo was written to specifically address DR-5892, which referenced A-490 and A-193 B7 studs, and to provide auditional controls on the type of carbon steel stud material which can be welded without extra case-by-case authorization.
2 1635d.
j
~
The May 31, 1984 memo does not in any way alter the position taken in PGandE's Response to Joint Intervenors' Motion to Reopen the Record on the Issue of Construction Quality Assurance, Attachment C, pages 12-13. A-307 1
Grade B bolts / studs are weldable and have been properly welded and meet all specification and code requirements for weldability, chemical composition, strength, and traceability.
There was no technical reason why I included the statement regarding the use of A-307 Grade B bolts as studs.
I only meant that from that date forward, Pullman welders could no longer make A-307 Grade B studs from A-307 Grade B bolts without prior QA/QC approval.
I have read the preceding two pages and the information outlined therein is true and accurate to the best of ry knowledge.
Dated: July 5,1984 H. W. Karner Subseribed and sworn to i
before me this 5th day l
C. T. NEAL MADISON l
of July,1984 NOTARY PUBUC -CAWORNIA l l
CITY AND COUNTY oF C.T Me+ Mm SAN FRANCISCO
~...~..........m....
~
I Cynthia Neal-Madison Notary Public in and for the City and County of San Franesico SEAL.
State of California My comission expires December 27, 1085 l
1635d.
...