ML20206L492

Summary of 990416 Meeting with Util in Rockville MD to Discuss Matter Re SG Operational Assessments for Current Operating Cycle at Plant,Unit 1

ML20206L492
Person / Time
Site:	Farley
Issue date:	05/10/1999
From:	Jacob Zimmerman NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
To:	NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned)
References
NUDOCS 9905140037
Download: ML20206L492 (30)

Text

fr - 1 o

May 10, 1999 L LICENSEE: Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.

FACILITY: Joseph M. Farley Nuclear Plant (FNP), Units 1 and 2

SUMMARY

OF MEETING HELD ON APRIL 16,1999 i

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) held a meeting with Southern Nuclear l Operating Company, Inc. (SNC), on April 16,1999, at NRC Headquarters in Rockville, l Maryland. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss matters related to steam generator ,

operational assessments for the current operating cycle at Farley Nuclear Plant, Unit 1.

Enclosed are a list of attendees and meeting handouts.

In accordance with Section 2.790 of NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10 of the Code of Federal Regulations, a copy of this meeting summary and its enclosure will be placed in tt.:

NRC's Public Document Room.

1 original signed by:

. Jacob 1. Zimmerman, Project Manager, Section 1 Project Directorate ll Division of Licensing Project Management j Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation p

- Docket No. 50-348

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/encls: See next page -

Distribution:

See next page fl A l

-)4 i

60 h ;i 9905140037 990510 PDR ADOCK 05000348 P PDR , .

DOCUMENT NAME: C:WARLEYWITS0416.WPD To reoche a copy of this document. Indicato in the box C= Copy w/o attachment / enclosure E=Conv wit i attachment / mock sure 4 = No cooy OFFICE PD5 d PDil-1/LA PDil/SC tiellE JZim rman:cn CHawe REmotM DAIE Y// # '/99 [/b'/99- 8//0/99 l OFFICIAL RECORD COPY I

< *C*:0 t UNITED STATES g +1-j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 30866 4 001 May 10,1999

+o * * * * * /

LICENSEE: Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc.

FACILITY: Joseph M. Farley Nuclear Plant (FNP), Unit 1

SUMMARY

OF MEETING HELD ON APRIL 16,1999 The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) held a meeting with Southern Nuclear Operating Company, Inc. (SNC), on April 16,1999, at NRC Headquarters in Rockville, Maryland. The purpose of the meeting was to discuss matters related to steam generator operational assessments for the current operating cycle at Farley Nuclear Plant, Unit 1.

Enclosed are a list of attendees and meeting handouts.

In accordance with Section 2.790 of NRC's " Rules of Practice," Part 2, Title 10 of the Code of Federal Reautations. a copy of this meeting summary and its enclosure will be placed in the NRC's Public Document Room.

mu==v acob 1. Zimmerman, Project Manager, Section 1 Project Directorate ll Division of Licensing Project Management Office of Nuclear Heactor Regulation Docket No. 50-348 l

Enclosures:

As stated cc w/encis: See next page l

l

k N ON 44@MNO f L.. # - Ls .a v._~ __; G4 B

i b-1 Joseph M. Farley Nuclear Plant cc:

Mr. L. M. Stinson Rebecca V. Badham General Managerf SAER Supervisor l Southern Nuclear Operating Company Southem Nuclear Operating Company Post Office Box 470 P. O. Box 470 Ashford, Alabama 36312 Ashford, Alabama 36312 Mr. Mark Ajiuni, Licensing Manager Mr. D. N. Morey Southern Nuclear Operating Company Vice President - Farley Project Post Office Box 1295 Southern Nuclear Operating Birmingham, Alabama 35201-1295 Company, Inc.

Post Office Box 1295 Mr. M. Stanford Blanton Birmingham, Alabama 35201-1295 Balch and Bingham Law Firm Post Office Box 306 1710 Sixth Avenue North Birmingham, Alabama 35201 Mr. J. D. Woodard l

Executive Vice President Southem Nuclear Operating Company Post Office Box 1295 Birmingham, Alabama 35201 State Health Officer Alabama Department of Public Health 434 Monroe Street Montgomery, Alabama 36130-1701 l Chairman Houston County Commission Post Office Box 6406 Dothan, Alabama 36302 Resident inspector U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 7388 N. State Highway 95 Columbia, Alabama 36319

N, 4

LIST OF ATTENDEES U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Brian Sheron, NRR/ADPT ,

. Herb Berkow, NRR/DLPM/LPD2 {

. Rich Emch, NRR/DLPM/LPD2 )

Ramin Assa, NRR/DLPM/LPD2 )

Jack Strosnider, NRR/DE '

Bill Bateman, NRR/DE/EMCB Ted Sullivan, NRR/DE/EMCB Emmett Murphy, NRR/DE/EMCB Phil Rush, NRR/DE/EMCB -

Stephanie Coffin, NRR/DE/EMCB Cheryl Beardsloe, NRR/DE/EMCB Tim Collins, NRR/DSSA l Rich Barrett, NRR/DSSNSPSB Mark Reinhart, NRR/DSSNSPSB Steve Long, NRR/DSSNSPSB

- Edward Throm, NRR/DSSNSPSB Mark Satorius, OEDO Tom Johnson, Farley Resident inspector via conference call Jerry Blake, Region ll via conference call Pierce Skinner, Region il via conference call Southem Nuclear Ooeratina Comoanv. Inc.. et al.

Dave Morey Mark Ajiuni .

Brad Moore

. Sam Casey Rick Mullins Tom Smith Bob Keating, Westinghouse Tom Pittorie, Westinghouse l others Dan Meatheany, EOl i Peter Jackson, Tetra Engineering Tom Harrison, McGraw Hill Enclosure 1

..e

\

MEETING HANDOUTS I

l

__z_r- - - - ~ ~ ~ -

e 9

F a

r l

R De o

c A k

ey t

vp r e 1 i i r

l l

,e l

1 my C

,6 i M 1 nl c a

r 9 a e y 9 t i

l a 9 o L n

d nen g

t h

+

1 :

! f 1 !

AS u n RRn ie s

I t

a yl mk s u

r o

s i

s a

r mats l

s d

u c

y s / t e

D s Do i -

e s e n t

a i

ms e c r l

s n i p

t

/

S o t

i A g

e n ve e r

e p o

f n d

a Ar c o c c i e d s e s n

t s

2

)l s l 1 D ll i.l

DO o p - - A- - S t

e e r

S e Dc e

c S t

3 A u r C y

P c s v ie a e s d a t c

i t t r

i g e m

(" u i

n r mo a an e n a b c a t

in l

i d e

a l

l e

k l c s n e t e

i n I e i i d r s

l e d s e - u b r mtge e e

n a

k n t

s 1

c e

e a

k i

n i r i g n

s ga 1 d s e e 8 l ( t i yt t

? n g e p" c" h o a r )

mp k o D

ima n g b

a l e a

b i t e

1 l

i s er g t i

p c m )

" m i

n a

t i

o n

3 h!;

~

og r p e ACA v Re op A e nby c e u l

l r e o r n a a

t r

a t u l e a 0 d

i r e f

r S i g e t nt o a l e e 8

0 n i

de s r g r n g

n d ig n p u c

yc w80 e c c a t

hp h r n t c

l i

l l

%a t h

e i s t i

f l

u r

e l

e mc e h 3 t

l i

c a

l a

w a l

ne a A m c s g t n P i r t I t 3c (

t a h n i

h Ae 9 s c a t

( P ht 5 6 k t e

1 a a %7% l e w g t

n e r 1

2t t

hh t

/

9 g r

e i t _

Ee e 5 t y

F p w )%

h d e

t -

Pl o e -

Yan r i

s c t 3 s e

)

e nt s

2 6 d A _

dt e 5 w

P a d e myas r e -

4

, ' j .l .

e 9

m

_ (

A ga r

v e

e v S t

e a

D pe t

m h

r e

l G

e a

t e

d n

e t

o r St a

t r

u c

t o

r w:

u '

(

r T

a l

I n u

~ b t

e T m e

=

g r

u e p s

=

b w

i y t e -

.s w

W a

w m

l l

=

-=

=

5 w -

=

=

=

m

=

! l - i

0 va esRGN E r o D n- u O

- B u n C wEewd l

8 0 u l h u a t t i

e p i

n t

e i

s r n c n t

e o c p c d h

e l

a Ea te e r c i

e u t

Os l

s r t a d a g a t i t e C i

l o s io n n i o 3 n d g

n t p (m y o a t s i c n A f a P n a u x a l p t b a

a (m i

d wl o s P a n a n e 6 a tid x s d r 7

%gaino av an P o o

On c d

e n s

g d DE e s

pe d a O t

3 pe v s A t g C P h d i n

c

)

pe p s

r t i

t )h e e c t

r i i

a o n

j i . 1 :

u b1 0 5 S t

n r u1 r

6 E E 0

u s K - -

c t - 2 2 t 2

w f

o c e r u r

n

/

ra l d

u a l

fc c e u n r t i I a e l

a o

n

(

N Bt n s t d H r e a p e u I eg l

y ad e 9 a r z np t o

7

- ki t e f r 0 Ay a o l

d O6 c

a wb s a b S DliP m S i Ci )t t e

l i C e s t y a t

a o T m f S P L i

s n

e

'l ,

4 dE RGN - - R p v e

a e

s r

o Dn e un O t

hu l u wE l wd C

/a c t t ih t

u e p r

ie s r n c

i n

t e o c p t d iP c Ea te e r

i c e u t

aOOs l

RC(

t a

io a

t i

d i

n l

a t

i S n

l o

e n abp r mty sn d i

c n L g s o a a B x t b h e t f a a (m i

i o s c o d ~

e l

n a n e P d x s r o np d r

r a o a a P o o e v p v dn OnR c l

a e ug l D e s

t r a d a O a e gv i

o t s nge op t i C

n h d i n

pe

)

s t p

)h e c

t i

o n

c 9 y 5 S

e 8

. DB e a c

%e v 2 s l

e /

9 r e

g p

s i

g e d A c

i s n o 5 m c

<%a 0 p c

c r

e b

a s

n i d

i d i m e 0r d u s a 1

g jo e

e n c t

- x i

n t

t i 1 p c s o 1 m I medt

- n .

8 u n n d ug m d o

l e

a me it p

mpe d u c

k n o t e g

a a h l O o d

e a

1 D f L

t g S f e p C l

a e n mC w a d

a k o t a g

f T n

e S e xt P s

! l !l

9 M

a x

Y i

m u S m

D V t e

p e t

a .

h r

e m

l a

t e G e

d -

n t

o A M Awllk ..p;w 5

e r

c c

i d

a t

e n

t o

r _

L

\

r e

n T -

ga k

u -

e I

n T

u b

x b e

t e e g .

r i

W a

yt l l

1 m 0 _

! l J4 !i

'i i i.  ! t

L l

l

- W i

e e ll a a k k s a a h g g e e u t O r s e p d o

p miw k er a e n i

n s

e xp a

t i

s e e t

c l a o a e tn d n yd s 7

i f:

a l

a 5 b

og L vp d

e e a -

6 0 k _

g p

a g

d e 1

1

~.

- - A- - M- - P r

N3 v

e A4 .

u l A1 .

o f I o 8 r c 6 t c c

1 i s a c E c i

E e l e E g l i - i d 3 y -

d - 1 a e 2(

k3 a p r d e

np t r c

l e

np t r W 1

g e e o )

e o n o 2 i i bp t n b e a h d b(a E d a px b u c b -

u c b E e t a i

l i

n e i

l i

Me i

l i F c y d yt e d yt P e o ya t l l o c e o e

Y l

d f a a b

s i k a

f b )h k a

f b

u s u u r

s g

e r s

g e r s R e

t a 0

<ta 0

<t a t a t t .

s S

L 0

1 S

L 0

1 S

L o B g B g p B n p a m m b l

e

?

oWper bc F e o t

t no r s r I e f i

s s s r dt u w e c r o r 1 nas e s .

c it s c 1 e e ib > sa 2 s

a u r 3e E p s Af l F p

rp t

Pa P or w _

xe is

,s Y ms ar u t

h R e _

t e e e yl a t m

e a s

1 9 5

d i o _

n 4 a -

3% n a -

A/9 b b P5 u r l S

L B  % s t e

?

o r -

1 3

a  !

n

/

e b,j e. e 1

'2 s 9 0 8

0o 0

2 8

0 m

a o

. [ 0 0

E1 7 F0M.

P8A 1 Y - 8 7

A W.

E C 8

u r

. r N

7

/

1 2 e n

~

/

9 8

7 x p t

/

1 6

A a

l R

F 1 1

8 7

L n n

7-0

,A o

r 6 G e ,B L

O S 7 _

d C S

7 G

y c

c M

a i

n S

a s

t 6

M o

k 4

1 A. t F 1

l ea n

1 8 e ar 2

E F 7 P

Y G l

e mlye R

aU W

ee i n

I W dn 9 i i 8

g at k- t 8

/

1 A .

B 8

t h

t 1 i

o n

M o

n s

o f

o r

yC i

t o

8 4i

/

9 8

m c

l e

T r

g157 1

8 e

n A

W .

9 8

M 3

4 8

1 d

g1788 1

1 7

Al t

8 1G 41A 1

8 Ph m7m.

0 s

= - " - -

• p I P o lj3 . .

I P fDafS a

l i

I R S ie c d e t io e e e r mu o l lq s u u n u S ir e n e n e nt i si f

l t ve n s wc i

d ia g e r e n n ie d c e l

t 8 t t s b s o

a s hre a P oequ mq t

sq i

s u a e p m

c A

s' 1 uu r e e c _

a 1 e l i n

hc n pl e t r l

l oe i

c f e a Ri e d _

wus e m s v o s e e

l l

rp po u r r l t

a r r a ut n ae ep i e b l t

b e gnd i o e c l

r a

t l

e b yl ye t s

s A

t o e o o s w Hrqfu n e M T ai d N s -

c lp i

c U s -

e um S r u R L r e r r E m B pe .e n e G e t

n t 1 n

t P 5 s 7

0 l  ;.

1 1l1ll [:

nBAF i

F TN dy up PNNe RP P r

e R U S e

c a v e s TP H E d s t

ue f

r fr o o

r b

/

D G 1

Ce oe r

bq p a f 5 e u fe an r

e s

sy b

i l

i t

e q

u r

7 0

nA t

a c u e i ic l

uy r e o n A ni c r d e

s u i

nT f yc u

c c

i md e e ie s t du ub s d e nt n c o c e e d n t BA t

os e B me d P p v t u r

r o y s ur e r at s g p s e e t n r e s u e a s

.d a c is e e s

s s s

s c nd i i

d t

s o

n m e

i n e n

t E

ve n t

n t

); 1 u 1 1 [ 1 )! ( a li

.O iT(

s F 3CF o dN.9o e N CSe EmP t

1

. a l t

P o v 6 l p 2By aC T o 6a r C N

n e t

Ep Etn Res r 6a s Ra i x

- t Ma T n i e

/ s )

F n mr NB Yo mA R-xB - a e

n Up y e cc Ys t R a ni d r e B Es s t l

y e yBnt G

i n p -

e a 1 1 T s 5 0 p s

A E 7 7 R c 0 a s s F h S E s s a u n r 6 e H

/

g e y r /

R Rs e s D i s va x s m y

B 2 l u Y u

l e s tn p 1 e r t a

s E o s

- f 7

1 .

.  ! l: li

a EoU c

f - F R c Or s e T c NG S e

p CS o h P 1 e t 1 a 6sp a

a c Gof l gn h 71 t .

ve b r Le a 4 r e s r o E s gn p t

l i i e

c a ub c R b e r hp ap t

ub a F e r is i

wn t io v Cc A nr g ol a l i<e Ld i

oc ep r iy t e n Ee s ni iin t o 5E E c .d nat e f Ra F c l e T

Ea eg r

t u

7 a

i s

c e

un s t Rnyd ib t

e n

d wpa oA t i

F r fb e ou E -

i t

h n c ns s s r r 6 i n e e uFs t s Na l

t Ps Rc e

ri t

s s

i t g e nUh ir o i m a n e n a e s tib a I n a

m1 s i

I t l

l s

I , '

O 4

Distribution for Meetina Summary dated May in. 1000' HARD COPY Docket File <

~ PUBLIC PD 11-1 Rdg.

J. Zimmerman OGC (w/o encl.)

ACRS (w/o encl.)

E-MAIL S. Collins /R. Zimmerman (SJC1/RPZ)

B. Sheron J. Zwolinski/SBlack '

H. Berkow T. Martin (e-mail to SLM3) l M. Satorius, Ril P. Skinner, Ril J. Bartley, Ril J. Blake, Ril J. Strosnider, DE T. Sullivan, EMCB E. Murpny, EMCB  ;

S. Coffin, EMCS P. Rush, EMCB C. Beardstee, EMCB J. Tsao, EMCB R. Barrett, SPSB S. Long, SPSB

.T. Collins, DSSA .

F

'3'1052

. . . . _