ML20133C568
| ML20133C568 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Mcguire, McGuire, 05000000 |
| Issue date: | 06/15/1973 |
| From: | Moseley N US ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION (AEC) |
| To: | Owen W DUKE POWER CO. |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20132B649 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-84-722 NUDOCS 8507200529 | |
| Download: ML20133C568 (8) | |
Text
y 46.4.g%CEDEMdW@$}j%34GK2AMWMFW-M@f4*i$N!LNEFp@M@
e.
4:
- -+
=..-4.w,.;.u,a. m a n..w. _-
-,,. __ g;q w..e.:.
-. - - -.- +- ma
.. =. =
.;+n.
.a.
,=a
- a
~
4 M c'
" K.
UmTED ST ATts
- j. j.fy ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION O Il DIRECTOTa!E OF. C.* ATCH CTI.:aTIC::S X*-
RE G e o es el - luet t 8'8
,. *'f
\\
'd'a g C' /
3 2 P g a C.s f a t E St a t t v, es en t e.w C ST AT4.Ase?A.GEOncea 3:303
- In Reply Refer To:
RO:11:BJC JUN 151973 30-369/73-2 50-370/73-3 h
[
Duke Power Coe:pany Atto:
Mr. W. H. Owen, Vice President Design Engineering 422 South Church Street P. O. Box 2178 j.c -
Charlotte, North Carolina 28201
" [
Centlemen:
S This refers t'o the construction inspection conducted by Messrs. B. J. Cochran.
T. E. Conlon and A. R. Herdt of this office on May 29 - June 1,1973, of i
- N g
activities authorized by AEC Construction Pernit Nos. CPPR-83 and 84 for the
~ "
W McGuire Nuclear l' nits 1 and 2, and to the discussion of our findings held by dl 1
Mr. Cochran with Messrs. J. C. Rogers, J. R. Welles and other nerbers of your g
g staff at the conclusion of the inspection.
q ^:.
Areas examined during the inspection included the quality assurance records
?
of the containc>ent building velding pregran, rceeipt inspection of Class I components and nonconforr.snee and variation notice reports. Within these
+
e areas, the inspectien consisted of selective examination of procedures and representative records, interviews with site and engineering personnel, and
~
observations by the inspectors. '
During the inspection, it was found that certain of your activities appear x
to be in violation of Appendix B to 10 CFR 50 of the AEC regulations,
" Quality Assurance Criteria for Nuclear P ver Plants." These violations and 4,
references to the pertinent requirements are identified in Section I of the 3-enclosure. This notice is sent to you pursuant to the provisions of Section ";q'-
2.201 of the..C's " Sol.4 o f 'r utice. "
-r-2. Ti t i.- 80 Cora of Te" rsi
.g Regulations.
Section 2.241 rer' 1res
,; tr :
-it te this effice uithin 10 d.2ys of yc:.r receipt of t;.;> notice i.:.:;ea n.as=ent or explar.ation o
in reply includine:
(1) corrective stem wh:,-h have been tsven bv vru, and Ak E.
the results acnieved; (2) corrective steps vasen will oe taken to svold k
further violations; and (3) tbc date en full cor,'?incc-v!11 be achieved. ~
k r.
V
?..."Y$,
30 g,. ; -
te gg Q
8507200529 850524
. ~,.
, J ^
JEisNEWTidO@%Yi%IOEF!l@QN!5W4 f$S3%Milf4WfWi'4Wl4 P4WJCRFM3 km;wsXE-n w.:....
n 9
Duke Power Company JUN 151973 Three new unresolved itees resulted free this inspection and are identified in Section III of the enclosure. These items will be exa:: Lined on subsequent inspections,
lie have also examined actions taken with regard to previously identified un-resolved items. Tne status of these items is identified in Section IV of the enclosure.
' A Should you have any questions concerning this letter, you c.ay co==unicate directly with this office.
Very truly yours, f
- o
- } } /
[
,,A V'.
- /.,' [:'s 4 o
' rman C. Moseley Director i
Enclosure :
1 As stated 1
4 41
.k
.t
?
.i*
f2
~- - 1Nk "3h
'. d$
~,,f c
2
GK V"' M iE: @ ?4-t.? g l'C.rg 2 70g gpg+;;pgl.Q t y g y g ygtqg g g g g gyg g g g,p g[ g g y y~;,4 M 4:. g. x z ?h;. y.-. u.a.L, : w d ;q S k__
..y-4.
v
.w-ze gmm;y q;;.fG-.
p,,
- 3. e w y
.g
. ~r w+ m - :% y;,;-. - ; w y :c,Y a 3: :::,
,,,, pw ;a,w. w.;...
y. :..+ -
.a.,.. :.
L
..n
. pg g
- cf l
O fNCIASLTE
~ DOCKET NOS. 50-369 AND 50-370 l
l I.
Enforcetect Action i
A.
Violations l
l Certain items appear to be in violation to 10 CTR 50, l
Appendix E " Quality Assurance Criteria for Nuclear Power Plsnts," as indicated below:
73-2-Al Document Control Contrary to the requirements of Criterion VI, design drawings with dir.cnsional and instruction errors are released for constructien without sufficient review.
The incorrect and confusing infor:stion has caused construction errors in per=anent structures.
73-2-A2 Inspection s
Contrary to the requirements of Criterion X, concrete O
inspectcrs deter-ine the type eix to be placed fro =
design dra ings and issue orders to the batch plant for the type mix and volume of concrete.
73-2-A3 Centain=ent k' eld i nn i
Contrary to the requitements of Criterion IX, welding
~
perforced on the containment liner was not in accordance with the qualified welding procccure, in tnat welding on both sides o'f the veld joint was not being done in sequential passes or sicultaneously.
~
B'.
Safety ite-s None
~~
II.
Licensec Pre icue?- I S-*t'ia' ' '- -
"'*ie" i
A.
_Vio l.t :..
4 None w
c.
B.
Safetv ::c_ _4
~
Ycr.c
=
u e
$ )*
?
=
h T,-
.---_.--r
- 4. m.,,m
.mq fana
~
.u:=, :4 1.-..,w - ;~ - - -.... ::. p _.
_ 7. [ 3 ;
.: gr g a&
\\
m.& & <. gegg.
gp
,hpaq 3-ff; Q gi-j
(;, %%+
~
O...
III. New Unresolved Items 73-2/1 valve Dise petainer Failure of valve di c retainers as reported in RCi-73-1 report.
73-2/2 Accu =ulator Tank Storare he subject tanks were received with pressure rauces which indicated the possibility of an inert gas blanket require-ment for long tern storage. Docu=entation at the site did not clarify the catter.
73-2/3 Radiographs h e licensee is to review contain=cnt' liner veld rcdio-graphs for fi1= cuality specifically for but not lir.i t ed O
= de==itr v ri t1c
eia cever se
=a t ei ar rhic technique number.
IV.
Status of Previous 1v Renorted Unresolved Iter.s 72-4/2 Unit 1 Reactor Pit Leak Chase his ite= re=ains open.
73-1/1 Site QA Ensincer Duties of the OA Engineer are not defined in the QA r.anual.
Itas closed.
73-1/2 verificatien of ::ucicar Valve = te Pec i - 9eciftrattens n
(R0 letters dater June 30 1972. and. bruarv It. 193)
[
E This ite-re i.s (
sn.
c
?
72-4/4 L'eldinc QA Preced;re All of the velding procedures have been revised.
Tnis ite:
7-is closed.
3 4
73-1/3 Ultraronie Procedure for Pressure vessel ::couirr Unit ::o. 1 his i:.
. u.
epen.
&A
M W 4 P TE-' 7 ;I h 'ECE.?* A k. h 7]iM N M 98 N ; N,M Q S Q {B Y O M W *4 y E E Q f y y % 4f.jk.
E v.
,... gn.. y,,.e. m...~~ ~,g.m= 4.gg7.. ; 4 3gg, 5,4:~.:w...;_;. i g_..n,,,, ;;
., ~ _.
w w..
. ~...., -..
l (* =A;~vj g.g J. y.5, ;.,,m... L 2 Li
~
=.
.c
... ;;". i.:.. ::p,1:
- L g. ~-, s... a ;
a, ~' +~:L+ v w u - %v... ' ' W --
....:. a a _;y
- s-
,n
+
G
. 73-1/4 Nondestructive Test Recuirenents for l'.'t No. 1 Pressure Vessel The licensee has been assured by Corbustion Engineering. Inc.
that magnetic particle inspection, as -ell as rsdiceraphic i
exar.instion, is beinc perforr:cd in upp ning the pressure vessel to newer requirc ents. This ite: is closed.
3 i
e e
\\
j I
t I,
9
)
l s
.4 i
J
}
t d
e
- M 4
1 ca f
1 i
.4 i
e 4
h.<
~
l n
-T4
~&
.[~
i
- ~*h 4
- 9x
..,.n
' "s.j
.y 1
/ ' ene
.I.
4 "a
l.-
A.. &. ; n,m.,.,a,
.yp,,-3, y.,~,[y;
. cu
., =~. &
a.
_ jg,.- - -g;
_g wgzgg
_, g,,qq;,
_ _..g;;
4
'j.-; %hC2n ~w v.A, ch.F % M Md.iaGE gik;'r.di W+isAs a =1 % @ W W=
'~
W g
y~
--.+.3-i O
UtilTED STATES OF A'1 ERICA ATOMIC ErlERGY C0rt11SS10:1 BEFORE THE A10'11C SAFETY AND LICE'ISI.gr, BOARD in the !!atter of
)
DUKE PO4ER C0: PA'lY Docl.et los. 50-369, 50-370
)
(Willia. B. !!cGuire !!aclear Statior., )
l Units 1 and 2)
)
l fl0TIEE OF APPEARA';EE
{.
flotice is hereby given that the undersigned atterney herewith e iters an appearar.cc in the captioned ratter.
In accrodance with & 2.713(a),
10 CFR Part 2, the following inforrution is provided:
A. Grey Staples l
Nane United States Atonic Energy l
Address Com:ission Washington, D. C. 20545 O
Telephone f. umber
- Area Code 301 - 973-7268 r
(or IDS Code 119 - 7263) l Admissions
- Suprer.ie Court of Virginia
~
~
U. S. District Ecurt for the Eastern District of Virginia U. S. Court of Appeals for the i
4th Circuit
.A Regulatory Staf f Name of Party i
U. S. Ato.ic Energy Connission
. Washington, D. C. 20545
..s f
2 E'
T
-R.
I s
A. Grey 5tc. tics 1.
Counsel for I.EC Regulatory Staf f l'
k n
i Dated at Eethesda,llaryland
{
this 25th day of June,1973 t,
ao a
e
- r
~^%5'Q K!$*ky%?W 2 Q.%5%#$ f.$$f5QY $ $ 5.G$ W W't* K;?:$?5k& f $
1
.J A gg Kf ' [g }y;.:rzc5
- 5. ~ ;.
- L
> l,?
~ ~~~ L :~- ~ g ey ; G il Q ~. ~- 4 +;_ f, _-
.+
N "~~' G.}.}~
- .y > nJ =l 5~2% %-% Q._.$.
- '"M +'Q:;W;5b > $ &&I W,:hkW
~ ~
?
~
,.w s
UNITED S RATES OF AhiERICA ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION BEFORE Tile ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of
)
)
DUKE POWER COMPANY
)
Docket Nos. 50-369.50-37C
)
(William B. McGuire Nuclear Station, )
Units 1 and 2)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of '"lotice of Appearance for A. Grey Staples",
dated June 25, 1973, in the captioc.d natter, have been serve 1. o. the following by deposit in the United States r:uil, first class or air nail, tnis 26th day of June,1973:
O Robert M. Lazo Esq., Chairman Towsend M. Btinr. Jr., Esq.
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Belser, Belser, Baker & Barwick e
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission P. O. Box 11690 Washington, D. C. 20545 Columbia, South Carolina 29211 a
..c Dr. Emmeth A. Luebke Myron M. Cherry. Esq.
j Atomic Safety and Licensing Scard Jenner and Block Panel One IBM Plaza U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Chicago, Illinois 00603 Washington, D. C. 20545
{
lionorable Glenn C. BlaisdcIl Dr. Cadet H. Hand, Jr., Director County Manager. Mecklenberg County Bodega Marine Lab of California 720 East 4th Stree!
P. O. Box 247 Charlotte, North Carchr.a 2E201 Bodega Bay, California 94923
'I roy B. Conner, Jr., Esq.
Dr. Harry Foreman, Director Reid & P4icst Center for Population Studies 1701 K Street, N. W
/
University of Minnesota Washington, D. C. 2C"06 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55812
~.s
- z.
},.
s 4 :
4, Af,
Y}. P'W~w sww~%.+9myn-agg;g19:qjjygiT37GGWir;WK,;;fp f~gy@
..., 4 y y g g 5
- . Q : 4,.. g ; 3.,.,: q Q ;. p {:; +; ;.: a
^
S Q'j g ~ Q qf.a pp g g p$,; y C ? d:U WM : " d ' 4 0 9 " U h~^ ^ N *';fd c'j
" Nnkq,,.ij;c. -
y.
n s'
f
)
.., 9 J. L. Riley, Esq.
Mr. Frank W. Karas 854 llenley Place Chief. Public Procccclings Staff Charlotte. North Carolina 28207 Office of the Secretary of the Commission Chairman, Atomic Safety ar.d U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Licensing Appeal Board Washington. D. C.
20;45 j
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission Washingten. D. C. 20545
.l i
Chairman. Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel j
U. S. Atomic Energy Commission j
Room 1039 - H Street Washington, D. C.
20545 1
1
,h' A. Grey Staples Counsel for AEC Regulatory Staff 4
1 1
M 1
1 4
i
_o I
l l
f i
e e
e h
1.
- /,?
4 m
f' N,
-