Text

Audit of Environ Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment at St Lucie Unit 2 Nuclear Generating Station, Interim Rept
	ML20066B323
Person / Time
Site:	Saint Lucie
Issue date:	08/31/1982
From:	Borgen R, Holloway E, Yost M; EG&G, INC.
To:	Rosztoczy Z; Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
References
	CON-FIN-A-6415 EGG-EA-6015, NUDOCS 8211060547
	Download: ML20066B323 (38)
	v • d • e

gg $ patch o of scck SS/Sfondf /k EGG-EA-6015 AUGUST 1982 l AUDIT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF I

gg SAFETY-RELATED ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AT THE ST. LUCIE M6/6 UNIT 2 NUCl. EAR GENERATING STATION A/TrC l

gg o

R. A. Borgen E. R. Holloway M. W. Yost

{

l Idaho National Engineering Laboratory Operated by the U.S. Department of Energy 1

i

?&$bt _ .e a i

.,7 0- Na N sumum; .m ,

N" y* .

a.. .a ""*l,W m summes

fI

?

_ . . _ _ ~ if* ~ '

g "? ~ gMW50., - ihr .__,

S !!;g .-.'.

I M ;E 3,M eW,5.% Q W Mige-Md7,_ - .

w s ;wame --

=^'yensme, j t .

, - q ,, , ,

This is an informai report intended for use as a preliminary os working document Prepared for the U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION Under DOE Contract No. DE-AC07-76ID01570 i FIN No. A6415 8211060547 820831

" b b E b ldaho PDR RES

PDR

hEGsG,.

FORM (G&G M (Rew 0452)

INTERIM REPORT Accession No.

Report No. EGG-EA-6015 Crntract Program or Project

Title:

Equipment Qualification Case Reviews Subject of this Document Audit of the Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment at the St. Lucie Unit 2 Nuclear Generating Station Type of Document:

Informal Report Author (s):

R. A. Borgen E. R. Holloway U

D te obo Orrenk:

August 1982 R:sponsible NRC Individual and NRC Office or Division:

Zoltan R. Rosztoczy, NRC-DE This document was prepared primarily for preliminary or internal use. it has not received full review and approval. Since there may be substantive changes, this document should not be considered final.

EG&G Idaho, Inc.

Idaho Falls, Idaho 83415

. Prepared for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C.

Under DOE Contract No. DE-AC07-761D01570 NRC FIN No. A6415 INTERIM REPORT

l 1

i I

i AUDIT OF THE ENVIR0hMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF SAFETY-RELATED ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AT THE ST. LUCIE UNIT 2 NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION Docket No. 50-389 R. A. Borgen E. R. Holloway M. W. Yost Reliability and Statistics Branch Engineering Analysis Division EG&G Idaho, Inc.

4 l

I e

e

l ABSTRACT EG&G Idaho, Inc., and NRC Staff members conducted an onsite and control file audit of the St. Lucie Unit 2 Nuclear Generating Station (SL2) to determine the environmental qualification of safety-related electrical equipment. Results of the audit are summarized in this report.

FOREWORD This report is supplied as part of the " Equipment Qualification Case Reviews" being conducted for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Division of Engineering, Equipment Qualifica-tion Branch, by EG&G Idaho, Inc., Reliability and Statistics Branch.

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission funded the work under the authorization B&R 20-19-40-41-2.

NRC FIN No. A6415 Equipment Qualification Case Reviews 11

CONTENTS ABSTRACT ............................................................. 11 FOREWORD ............................................................. 11

1.0 INTRODUCTION

.................................................... I 2.0 E V AL V AT I O N . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . l 3.0 C O NC L U S I O N S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2

4.0 REFERENCES

...................................................... 2 APPE NDIX A--EQUIPMENT QUALI FICATI ON CONCERNS AND COMMENTS . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 APPENDIX B--SUMMARI ES OF SL2 CENTRAL F ILE REVIEWS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 e

i f

l e

I l

l 5

l 1 iii i

t 1

sq, p y r-- p--- -,w-- .,y--- - - - - - -w.. ,., _--..y- -

n _ -- --

AUDIT OF THE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALIFICATION OF SAFETY-RELATED ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT AT THE ST. LUCIE UNIT 2 NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION

1.0 INTRODUCTION

On July 13-16, 1982, a team composed of representatives of the Relia-bility and Statistics Branch of EG&G Idaho, Inc. and NRC staff conducted an audit of the environmental qualification of safety related electrical equip-ment at the St. Lucie Unit 2 (SL2) Nuclear Generating Station. The work effort consisted of: (a) a pre-audit review of the applicant's submittal,I (b) an audit of the applicant's central files for selected equipment items, and (c) an onsite visual inspection of the equipment items for which the central files were audited. Qualification concerns and comments for indi-vidual equipment items are provided in Appendix A. Surnmaries of the central file reviews are provided in Appendix B.

2.0 EVALUATION General concerns and comments resulting from both the audit and the pre-audit review of the SL2 submittal are as follows:

1. In some cases the applicant's review of the qualification files should have been more thorough and was found only marginally adequate.

2. It was observed during the on-site visual inspection that the applicant may not have accurately verified equipment elevations.

l The HPSI pump is claimed to have an elevation of -l foot in an area where the flood level is -10 feet. The applicant did not know from what point on the HPSI pump the -1 foot elevation was measured and since the base of the pump was at -10 feet, it appears that the pump is much lower than stated. Any equipment not qualified for submergence should be so qualified or verified to be located above flood level.

I 4

3. The applicant will furnish information on the SL2 maintenance and surveillance program, which is still in development, at a later date.

4. The applicant will update the component evaluation sheets (CES) with all the latest field verification data. -

5. Revision 3 of the submittal should contain the zone maps used in .

f equipment qualification; not " typical" maps.

6. Components whose qualified lives are less than 40 years and those needing periodic parts replacement to attain a 40-year qualified ,

life should have notes added specifying replacement intervals, 4 future qualification plans, or a plan of action. Where replace-ment is scheduled, the qualified replacement should be identified.

3.0 CONCLUSION

S As a result of the audit it was concluded that the St. Lucie Unit 2 environmental qualification program is adequate. When the applicant resolves the concerns noted above and in the appendices their program should be complete and in accordance with NRC approved regulations2 and standards.3

4.0 REFERENCES

l. Environmental Qualification Report and Guidebook, Revision 3, St. Lucie Unit 2 Nuclear Generating Station.

2. Interim Staff Position on Environmental Qualification of Safety-Related Electrical Equipment, NUREG-0588.

IEEE Standard for Qualifying Class lE Equipment for Nuclear Power l 3.

Generating Stations, IEEE Std. 323-1974. .

2

e d

APPENDIX A EQUIPMENT QUALIFICATION CONCERNS AND COMMENTS D

3

TABLE A-1. QUALIFICATION CONCERNS AND C0tNENTS FOR EQUIPMENT CLAIMED AS QUALIFIED Component Manuf acturer Model TeG Num4ser CE5 humber Comments fan Motor Westingieuse L-987971 2HVE-eA 0142 Qualification methoo is not given.

2HVE-66 0143 hotes 3. 5.

Valve operator L imitorque SMB-000-2H16C FCV-3301 0472 Notes 1, 3.

FCV-330b 0414 LO-SMB-025 MV-08-14 1031 MV-08-15 1034 DK%H MV-08-16 1037 MV-08-17 1039 Flow Transmitter Bosemount 1153085- FT-09-241 0635 hotes 1, 3, 5, 7.

FT-09-2A2 0636 F T-09-281 0637 FT-09-282 0638 FT-09-2C1 0639 FT-09-2C2 0640 1153H85 FT-2212 0655 Pua , Motor GE SK811052C57 MPSI P 24 0782 Notes 1. 5.

HPSI P 28 0783 w

Valve Operator L imitorque LO-SMB-0-15 MV-08-18A 1041 MV-08-188 1042 MV-08-194 1043 -

MW-08-198 1045 LO-SMu-U0O MV-08-3 1047 Differenttal Pressure kosemount 1133083 PDT-25-14A 1157 fransmitter PDT-en-14e 1158 Pressure fransmitter Rosemount 1153G89 Pi-08-1A 1310 hotes.1, 3, 5.

PT-08-18 1311 Pi-08-3A 1312 PT-08-38 1313 PT-08-5 1314 PT-09-8A 1315 PT-09-88 1316 PT-09-8C 1317 PT-2212 1330 Fan Motor Westinghouse T80P/1908 2HVE-9A 17 % notes 1, 3, 5.

7908 2HVE-96 1798 T08P/7906 2HYS-4A 1806 2HYS-48 1807 Med. Volta 9e Power OKUNITE 8/M D15 8/M D15 1939 Note 1.

Cable Series

. ~

TABLE A-1. (continued)

C w onent Manufacturer Model Tag huder CES number Comments

H2 Recowbtner Westinghouse Model n Hz RMB 2a 1941 Qualification f11e did not support the appitcants H2 Rf4 28 1944 Claim for qualified awaiting Confirmatory data.

Cable Pulling tubricant Bishop Clectric Company bishop #45 CPL / WJ20 Does not perfore safety function but mest not damage Bishop 45 safety related equipment.

Polywater Polywater Polywater 0021 Tertitnal to: See Orawing 8404 See Drawing B404 82G87 0136 Ihese bones were not tested because the equipment 82G88 0137 contained inside were individually reviewed f or B2G89 0138 qualtf tcation.

82690 0139 82G91 0140 Note 1.

82G92 014I 82G87 0136 52G68 0137 82G89 0138 B2G90 0l39 h2G91 0140 B2G92 0141 82154 0158

52166 0159 B2191 0160 82192 0161 52194 0162 B2195 0163 B2197 0164 82198 0165 8257A 0168 52584 0169 82725 0110 82726 0171

a. See Table A-3 for notes.

1

TABLE A-2. QUALIFICATION CONCERNS AND COMMEhTS FOR EQUIPMENT NOT CLAIMED AS QUALIFIED Comfonent Manufacturer Model iaq humber CES humber Comment s Radiation betector General Atomic RC-23 mD-26-40 0018 kD-26-41 0019 General Atomic RD-6 RD-26-3 1426 The RD-6 detectors have not been reste=ed.

RD-26-4 1427 RD-26-5 1428 Notes 1. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. and 8.

RD-26-6 1449 The review of the qualtftcation file sv. eld have been Anchor / Darling 64324-c/001 HCV-09-14 0144 Control Valve Actuator aore thorough and was found only marginally adequate.

series /E93281 HCV-09-18 0745 HCV-09-2n 0146 CES states there are def ectenctes in oocumentation, but HCV-09-28 0747 they are not itsted in CES.

Notes 1. 3. 5, 7.

FCV-26-1 0466 Not qualtfted. Test report not recetted.

Control Valve Waltek-MARK 11 --

Solenold valcor Engr. Co. V52600-515 F 5E-27-10 0617 Post 08A spectfled operabtitty is <41 days, but F 5E-27-11 0618 Dem. operabtitty is only >33 days.

F5E-27-12 0619 F SE-27-13 0620 Does field verlf ted at elevation >26 feet mean the y

F 5E 14 0621 valves util be relocated?

F 5E 15 0622 F5E-27-16 0623 Why will the valves located in the A8 be field F5E-27-17 0624 vertfled >25 feett F5E 27-18 0025 hotes 1. 2. 3. 5. 7. H.

F5E-27-8 0626 F5E-27-9 0627 Target Rock 77CC001 SE-05-1A 0004 5pec. post 08A ope r . is I minute, but dem. post b8A Solenato Valve oper ts Itsted as 32 cycles and no time.

SE-05-18 0005 SE-05-1C 0006 St-05-ID 0u07 Figure 1015 used for specified temperature ano dem.

SE-05-1E 0008 qualtf. temperature. What ts the max. temperature 5E-09-2 0009 the equt;iment is tested to, and coes it envelope b6A 5E-09-3 0010 temperature? Figure 9 is used for spec, pressure <

5E-09-4 0011 and dem. qualif. pressure. What is the mantmum SE-09-5 0012 pressure the equipment is tested toI Target Rock 18E-001 SE-03-1A 1439 CE$ does not state whether the model 78E-007 are Target Rock 78E-006 SE-03-18 1440 qualtited for submergence.

SE-03-1C 1441 SE-03-10 1842 Notes 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 7. and 8.

Solenoid Valve f arget Rock 7BE-007 5E-03-2A 1443

$E-03-28 1444

TABLE A-2. (continued) fase< ment Manuf acturer Model Tag Ni m r CES number Comments *

~

Target Rock 7?CC001 SE-02-01 1952 CE5 does not state whether valves are qualtfled for sebmergence.

Target Rock 740-1005-1/5 SE-02-02 1953 Notes 1. 3. 4. 5, 7. and 8.

Target F.ock 140-003-1/110 SE-02-03 1954 Target Rock 740-003-1/4 SE-02-04 1955 Target Rock 77CC001 SE-08-1 1956 SE-08-2 1957 Limit Switch Namco EA-170 25-25-18 0029 Notes 1. 2. 3, 5. 6. and 6.

25-25-19 0030 Z5-25-120 0031 25-25-124 0032 25-25-122 0033 25-25-123 0034 25-25-118 0035 25 25-119 0036 25-25-94 0041 25-25-95 0042 00 25-25-116 0043 25-25-117 0044 Llatt Switches Namco EA-7402201005 25-25-10 1814 No demonstrated qualtftcation.

Namco EA-740220100 25-25-11 1825 No aging indicated-No quellfIcation status.

Namco EA-740 Series 25-25-12 1831 Outstanding items Itsted as *None".

25-25-13 1832 25-25-14 1833 25-25-85 15 atsstag the spectfled operant 11ty, aging.

25-25-15 1834 and submergence.

25-25-86 1835 25-25-17 1836 Notes 1. 3. 4. 5. and 8.

25-25 1837 25-25-3 1848 25-25-4 1858 25-25-5 1877 Ltatt Suttches Namco EA-740 20100 25-25-6 1904 25-25-7 1982 Nauco EA-740 Serles Z5-25-74 1915 25-25-75 1916 25-25-76 1917

. TABLE A-2. (continued) 1 Crumpnent Manufacturer Model Tag Nus6er CE5 Number Comments

25-25-77 1916 25-25-78 1919 Z5-25-19 1920 Neuco E A-140 20100 25-25-8 1921 Namco EA-740 Series 25-2b80 1922 !

25-25-81 1923 25-25-82 1924 25-25-83 1925 25-25-84 1926 IS-25-85 1927 Z5-25-88 1928 25-25-9 1930 25-25-92 1931 l Z5-25-93 1932 l 25-25-96 1933 25-25-97 1934 Namco EA1801302 25-25-36 1854 Notes 1. 3. 4. 5. 6. and 8.

25-25-37 1855

Manco EA180310302 25-25-38 1856 Namco EA18032302 25-25-39 1748 MCV-14-2 0750 HCV-14-3A 0751 .

, , HCV-14-38 0752 ASC0/NAMCu 5:NF8321A-2-E HCV-14-6 0753 l LS:EA7402010u l ASC0/NAMCO 5:NPS321A6 HCV-14-7 0754 ASCO/NAMLU 5:NP8321A1E HCV-15-1 0758 LS:EA10021302 ASC0/NAMCO LS:fA18021302 HCV-18-1 0759 ASCO/NAMCO ' 5:RFHV202303 HCV-3618 0765 L5:EA18031302 l ASCO/NAMCO 5:RFHV2023031 HCV-3628 0769 LS:EAle031J02 i ASCO/NAMCD 5:liFHV2023031 HCV-3638 0773 l l

l 1

TABLE A-2. (continued) a Component Manufacturer Model Tag humeer Cts huseer Comment s A5CO/hAMCO 5:RTHV2023031 HCV-3648 0777 L5:[A18021302 ASCO/hAE0 5:hP8321Al[L5 LCV-07-11A 0851 LS:EAldO21302 ASC0/NAMCO L5:EA180 LCV-07-118 0852 Valve Operators ASCO/NANCO 5:RFHV2023031 V2515 1657 ASCO/NAMCO 5:RFHV202301 V2516 1658 ASCO/hAMC0 5:RFHE2023031 V3578 1669 Valve Operators ASCO/NAMCO 5:RFHV2023031 V3571 1690 L5:tA17U31100 ASCO/NAMCO V2522 2020 V2523 2021 V2524 2022 FCV-07-1A 2023 FCV-07-18 2024

--* HCV-25-6A 2025 O HCV-25-7A 2026 Local Control Station Gould 8/M AUX FhP 24 PS 0093 Figure C-14 ts used for Spec. Temperature and bem.

AUX FWP 28 P8 0095 Qualif. Temperature. What is the maatsum temperature FCV-25-Il P8 0431 the equipment is tested to and does it envelope pea FCV-25-12 Pu 0433 tegerature with margtnt FCV-25-13 PS 0435 Figure C-18 is used for Spec. Pressure and Dem.

Gould 8/M C9-3A HCV-3512 55 0761 Qualtf. Pressure. What is the maalaus pressure the equipment is tested to and does it envelope 00A Gould 8/M C10-16 HCV-3615 PS 0762 pressuref Gould 8/M C10-1G HCV-3625 PS 0766 What 'if 51* ts spectfled for operability?

Why is only 30 years aging specifled? the goal is Gould 8/M C9-3 HCV-3657 55 0779 40 years even though only 30 years can be demonstrated.

What does

Minimum Lifegual' meant Gould 8/M C10-2A CMGG 2A P8 0181 CHGG 28 PB 0163 The qualtfIcation is lacanelete until the *There tag g /. CMGG 2C P8 0185 Anal

ts complete.

1 Gould - 8/M C8-5 CSP 2A Pd U343 Notes 1, 3, 5, and 8.

Gould S/M C10-46 C5P 28 P6 0345 Gould 8/M C10-2A LF51 F2A P8 0866 LP51 P28 P8 0868

r N

s 4

t.

b y 4 ,

t j <d e e e e

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Coaeonent Mr ufacturer Model Tae meer CES number Coments*

Gould 8/M C10-28 MW-07-2A PS 1020 Gould 8/M MV-07-28 P8 1022

Gould 8/M C10-28 MV-08-1A P8 1024 Mv-Ou-15 PB 1026 Gould 8/M MV-08-12 PS 1028 I

Mv-08-13 PB 1030 Local Control Station Gould 8/M C10-28 Gould 8/M m-08-14 SEL5W 1032 m-08-15 SCL5W 1035 Gould 9/M C9-1E Mv-08-16 SEL5W 1038 Gould 9/M MV-08-17 SEL5W 1040 Mv-09-10 PS 1050 Mv-09-11 PS 1052 Mv-09-12 PS 1054 Mv-09-13 PS 1056

--'- Mv-09-14 P8 1058

" Mv-09-9 PS 1061 MV-14-10 PB 1065 MV-14-11 PS 1067 Mv-14-12 PB 1069 -

Gould 8/M C10-88 Mv.14-13 PS 1071 MV-14 14 P8 1073 Mv-14-15 PS 1075

Mv 14-16 PS 1077 Gould 8/M MV-14 17 55 1079 Mv-14-18 55 1081 MV-14-19 55 1083 MV-14-20 55 1087 i

Mv-14-9 P8 1093 Gould 8/M C9-3G V2504 P8 1651 Gould 8/M C10-28 v2525 P8 1660 Gould 8/M C10-3 V2553 P8 1662 v2554 P8 1664 V2555 PS 1666 Gould 8/M C9-3 V3456 55 1668 Gould 8/M (9 3A V3457 55 1670

TABLE A-2. (continuea) -

Camponent Manuf acturer Model er "

tag hunter . ., CE S Commsents' Gould R?M C9-3G V3a?5 55 1675 Local Control 5tatle V3496 55 1676 w #

Gould 8/M C10-4A V3517 55 1678 Gould 8/M (9 38 v3523 55 1679 j Gould 8/M C94E v3536 55 1681 Gould 9/M C8-1E V3539 55 1683 --

/~

Gould 8/M C9-38 V3540 55 'I

/

V3550 55 1684 1687

/ ,

^

v3551 55 1688 Gould 8/M VM54 55 1707 VM'6 Po -1709

Gould 8/M C9 3A V3658 55 1711 "

q Gould 8/M C8-5 V3e59 $$ 1713

.! Gould 8/M C9-1E v3660 55 1715 Gould 8/M C9-38 V3664 55 1717 l W3665 55 1719 Gould -

8;at C9-9 V5203 55 '1723

~

V5204 55 1724 '

V5205 55~ 1725 4

's ,

/ / Gould 8/M 2p%-105 P8 1790 -

t # 2HVE 6A PB 1794 -

! . 2HVE-68 PB 1795 2MvE-9A PB 1797 S. ~

2HVE-98 PB 1799 FCV-25-29 PS 0449 N" FCV-25-3u PS 0452 4

~

FCV-25-31 78 0454 ', 3 FCV-25-32 Pb 0456 '

FCV-25-33 PS 0458 ~

FCV-25-34 PB 0460)

Gould 8/M C9-48 "^

.FCV-25-3301550475' g f FCV-330A 55 /A75 ,

g w..

_M*'

Y s'

I r y A

~ .--

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Component Manuf acturer Model Tag hum 6er CES Number Ccaments' Starters Gould-Brown Bovert BY FIELD Me-06-14 SIR 1033 Listed as qualtited. but all items are outstanding MV-08-15 STR 1036 and the test report has not been reviewed.

MV-08-194 STR 1044 Mv-08-198 STR 1046 Terminal Blocks Amerece Corporspen 616822 (Series) Qualified 0145 The aging Dem. Qualtf. Cocumentation is not Itsted int Teretnal CES.

Stock s notes 1 and 5.

Neutron Detectorb CE -- 82069 0152 Qualtf tcation has not Deen evaluated. Uwd only f or 82071 0153 Ra trip and ts not requtred to subsequent to a harsh 62075 0154 environment. What is the specified stue the egutpment 82077 0155 is required to operatet what aging has been 82078 0156 performed!

82079 0157 82349 0166 hotes 1. 3. and 8.

82351 0167 Pump Motor bestinghouse 3840787 CHGG P2A 0180 Was aging performed on CHGG pumps?

CHGG P28 0182 CHGG P2C 0184 Notes 1. 3. 4. 5. and 8.

w Westinghouse 5010P39V5WF LPSI P2A 0865 LPSI P28 0867 Fan Motor Reltance 11F882438A3-NE 2HV5-1A 1800 Notes 1. 3. 5. 7. and 5.

Reit erw.e IIF882438A?-ht 2HV5-18 1801 Reit ance IXF882433Al-NE 2HV5-lC 1802 Reliance 116882438A4-NE 2HV5-10 1803 Pump Motor GE SK811043C16 AUX FWP 2A 0092 Temperature and pressuriser qual are octstanding ano AUX FWP 28 0094 require reanalysis but the motor is Itsteo as

. qualifled.

Notes 1. 3. 5. and 7.

Pump Motor Siemens-Allis Et85117-90301 1 C5P Z8 0344 motes 1, 5 and 8.

Camper Operators lii General Controls NH-90 Series / 0-13 0351 Notes 1. 3, 5. and 8. *Ltfe Estension Analsis" is NH-95 0-14 0352 required for operator components so that a maintenance 0-15 0353 schedule can be aetermined.

D-16 03>4 D-2 0359 0-23 0363 l

- - . ~.

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Coseonent Manufacturer Model Tag humber CES number Comment s*

0-24 0364 D-3 0366 D-5A U377 0-58 0378 D-6A 0379 D-68 0380 0-8A 0383 0-98 0394 0-9A 0385 0-98 0346 Flow Transettterb ITT 8ARTON 764 FT-1158 0641 totes 1. 3. 5, 7. and 8.

FT-1168 0642 FT-1178 0643 FT-Il88 0644 Level Transmitterb ITT BARTON 764 ' LT-1104 0908 Notes 1. 3. 5, 7. and 8.

LT-il05 0909 LT-1110I 0910 2

LT-1110Y 0911

- LT-90134 0913 A LT-90138 0914 LT-9013C 0915 LT-90130 0916 'a *'*

LT-9023A 0917 LT-90238 0918 LT-9023C 0919 LT-90230 0920 LT-9113 0921 LT-9123 0922 Pressure Transmitterb ITT 8ARTON 763 PT-8813 1347 PT-8023C is below flood level. The specific qualif t-PT-8123 1348 cation documentation is not given la CLS.

PT-1102 1318 "

PT-11028 1319 motes 1. 3. 5. 7. and 8.

PT-1102C 1320 I PT-11020 1321 PT-1103 1322 i PT-1104 1323 P T-1105 1324 PT-1106 1325 PT-IlO7 1326 PT-1108 1327 PT-8013A 1339 PT-80138 1340 PT-8013C 1341 PT-80130 1342 PT-8023A 1343 4

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Compmient Hanuf acturer Model Tag Nuster CES Number Comments

PT-80238 1344 PT-8023C 1345 PT-80230 1346 Oliterentialgressure !!T 8ARION 764 PDT-1111A 1145 Notes 1. 3. 5. 7. and 8.

Transmitter PDT-11118 1146 PDT-1111C 1147 PDT-11110 1148 PDT-1121A 1149 PDT-11218 1150 PDT-1121C 1151 i PDT-11210 1152 a

Pressure Suitch lii BART0N 580-1 PS-08-12A 1285 Accuracy has not been comonstrateo.

PS-08-128 1286 PS-08-6 1287 Notes 1. 3. 5, 7. and 8.

4 PS-12-17A 1289 P5-12-178 1290 PS-12-17C 1291 1 PS-25-12A 1302 PS-25-128 1305 Pressure Transmitter Rosemount 1153085 PT-07-2A 1306 CES states the transmitters need to be relocated.

PT-07-28 1307 PT-07-2C 1308 Notes 1. 2. 3, 5. and 8.

PT-07-20 1309 Valve Operator Limitorque SMB-000-2H18C HCV-3512 0760 Operability time may not be enveloped on some operators. Thersal lag analysis is required on some Limitorque $H8-1-40 HCV-3635 0770 operators.

L imitorque SMB-00-10 HCV-3636 0171 Notes 1. 7 and 8.

HCV-3637 0772 HCV-3646 0775 Limitorque 3A3272 HCV-3647 0776 Limitorque Sh8-000-2Hl8C HCV-3657 0778 Limitorque SHB-1 HCV-3615 0788 Limitorque Kl37881 HCV-3617 0790 Limitorque 5His-L HCV-3625 0791 Limitorque SMB-UU-10 HCV-3626 U792 HCV-3627 0793

e4 en i .

k.

1 ~.-.~..--.~o .o~...os.~ . - m. ~. -m ~

o --53 3 -- 33 --- 388 -- E.8333338888 88-8------------

8

- - 0 --3 --33--

32.33

- 0 O

t . == < . ~m o-~ m.

o-~m...~..o 1, 77

~~ 7 i 77 i.ii 77 7777777 . 777. 7. .* . . .. .~ .. S. ~

m,

. a. o. 8 8.8 8.8 E. 9 $. .... . . . ... . . . ~. ... . g. .g .

j W ff f E EE REE Et f~EffffffffffE 2 2 22 .O C. O

~o 8 7 ~

i 2

a a@*

a* a

2a* *

h' E hh hh$ k8 o T o

~

A S 4 6 S S S S$ $$ $ $ $

L

=

ee 2 h.

W e.

U 2 .,

U U

., ., 8 U F F 3

F 2 .,

C C U U w F b b b u {

- I h h 8-h h h h h b o u D :m a: : : :e : : : : : : :

e a e a

e a

I @

- e .e. a -

e a e e 3 a .a a a .o .a ..e e a .a a, .a .e a .,o l g

( r-I M C

O

U w

e*

C g

6 6 o o N %6 8 %6 .

W

s. ' . .

CO >

~ ;

H I

t 16

- ~ -. _ -. . --. ., . _ .-

TABLE A-2. (continued) a Manufacturer

Model Tag Num6er CES hunter Comment s Conconent Limitorque SM8-00 V3536 1680 Limitorque SMB-1 40 V3539 1682 Limitorque SMS-1 V3545 1685 Liettorque SMB-2 V3614 1692 CES 1692.1695,1697, and 1700 oo eat state whether V3624 1095 the operator are qualif ted for submergence. The V3634 1697 operators are required to operate for 30 minutes V3644 1700 following a 0% and could be submerged within 40 minutes.

Valve Operator Limitorque SMB-1 V3651 1702 V3652 1704 Ltattorque 58-0 v3654 1706 V3656 1708 V3658 1710 Ltoitorque SM8-00 v3659 1712 v3660 1714

Limitorque 58-0 v3664 1716 N V3665 1718 Temerature Element RDF Corporation Fast Response TE-11111 1520 Qualtitcation testing and evaluation have not been TE-1111Y 1521 completed but equipment is listed as qualif ted.

TE-1112CA 1522 TE-1112C8 1523 Notes 1. 3, 4, 5, and 8.

TE-1112CC 1524 TE-1112CD 1525 TE-1112HA 1526 TE-1112HB 1527 TE-1112HC 1528 TE-1112ND 1529 TE-1115 1530 TE-11211 1531 TE-1121T 1532 TE-1122CA 1533 TE-1122C8 1534 TE-1122CC 1535 TE-1122CD 1536 TE-1122HA 1537 TE-1122HS lb38 TE-1122HC 1539 TE-1122HD 1540 TE-1125 1541 TE-3303W 1542 TE-33031 1543

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Component Maaufacturer Model Tag huseer CES hunter a Cosament s TE 3303Y 1544

, TE-3303Z 1545 TI-33511 1546 TE 3351T 1547 TE-33521 1548 TE-3352Y 1549 Electrical Penetrations Conau Corporatton 7310-10002-03 Penet 84 1189 Penetrations have not been qualtf ted for submergence.

Penet 87 1190 Penet C3 1191 No subnergence test report available.

Penet C7 1192 Penet D3 1193 hotes 1, 3. 7 and 8.

Penet E6 1194 Conan Corporation 7310-Inst Penet D8 1959 Penet 07 1960 Penet E3 1961 Penet El IM2 Penet E2 1963 Penet E10 1964 Penet D5 1965 Conas Corporatton 7310-LvP/C Penet PLEP-1 IM6 Penet ELEP-1

1967 Penet C10 IM8 Penet D6 1969 Penet 09 1970 Conan Corporatton 7310-Inst. Penet E4 1971 Penet E5 1972 Penet E7 1973 Penet E8 1974 Penet E9 1975 Conan Corporation --

Penet Al 1Y76 Penet A2 1977 Penet A3 1978 Penet A4 197V Penet A6 1980 Penet A7 1981 Penet A8 1982 Penet 81 1983 Penet 82 1984 Penet 83 1985 Penet 85 1986 Penet B6 1987 Penet 88 1988 6 e e .e

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Component 8 Manufacturer Mooel Tag Number CES Number Comments Penet 89 1989 Penet C2 1990 Electrical Penetrations Penet C3 1991 Penet C4 1992 Penet C5 1993 Penet C6 1994 Penet C7 1995 Penet C8 1996 Penet C9 1997 Penet DI 1998 Penet D2 1999 Conan Corporation 7310-10003-01 Penet 03 2000 Conductor Modules Conas Corporation BY FIELD CCV-26-1CM 2035 CES 2035 and 2036 describe the same ites (tag nuse>er CCV-26-1CM- 2036 CCV-26-ICM).

CCV-26-3CM 2037 CES 2094 and 2095 descrthe the same iten gtag museer Conan Corporation 2/4/C#16 CCV-26-5CP 2038 v1464CM).

FCV-23-6CM 2039 FCV-2J-4CM 2040 Equipment has not been qualif ted for submerge.ce.

Conas Corporation 3/4/Cel6 FCV-25-3CM 204I FCV-25-4CM 2042 FCV-25-20CM 2043 An accelerated aging time of '5 cycles" coes not tell how long the equipment was aged.

Conan Corporation 1/6/Cf16 F5E-27-8CM 2044 FSE-27-9CM 2045 Notes 1, 3, 4, 7, and 8.

F5E-27-10CM 2046 F5E-27-11CM 2047 F5E-27-12CM 2048 F5E-27-13CM 2049 F 5E-27-14CM 2050 Conan Corporation 3/4/C#16 HCV-14-ICM 2051 HCV-14 2CM 2052 Conan Corporation 2/4/C#16 HCV-361 LCM 2053 HCV-3628CM 2054 MCV-3638CM 2055 HCV-3648CM 2056 LCV-07-IIACM 2057 SE-02-ICM 2058 SE 2CM 2059 SE-u2-3CM 2060 5E-02-4LM 2061

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Component Manuf acturer Model Tag Nud>er CES Numeer Coments*

Conductor Modules Conan Corporation 1/6/C fl6 SE-03-I ACM 2062 SE-03-1BCM 2063 SE-03-1CCM 2064 SE-03-1DCM 2065 5E-03-2 AIM 2066 SE-03-2BCM 2067 SE-u? 4CM 206a Conan Corporation 1/4/Ce16 ff-lil2CACM 2069 TE-Ill2CBCM 2070 TE-1112CCCM 2071 TE-Ill2CDCM 2072 TE-Ill2HACM 2073 TE-Ill2HBCM 2074 TE 1112HCCM 2075 TE-1112HDCM 2076 TE-ll15CM 2071 TE-1122CACM 2078 TE-II22CBCM 2079 TE-II22CCCM 2000 TE-Il22CDCM 2081 N TE-ll22HACM 2082-O TE-1122H8CM 2083 TE 1122HCCM 2084 TE-1122HDCM 2005 TE-1125CM 2006 Conan Corporation LATER TE-07-3ACM 2087 Conan Corporation 1/4/C#16 TE-07-36CM 2088 TE-07-5PCM 2089 Conas Corporation i ATER V1460CM 2090 V1461CM 2091 V1462CM 2092 V1463CM 2093 Vl464CM 2094 V1464CM 2095 Vl465CM 2096 V1466CM 2097 Conductor Mndules Conas Corporation 2/4/Cf16 V251Y M 2098 V2516CM 2099 V2524CM 2100 V3571CM 2101 V3572CM 2l02

TABLE A-2. (continued) a C w ent Manuf acturer Model Tag Nunter CES Nueer Conssents Conas Corporation LATER V5200CM 2l03 Conax Corporation 2/4/Cilb V5201CM 2104 V5202CM 2105 V6 M6CM 2106 16718CM 2107 Conas Corporation L ATE R *t2 RMB 2ACM 2108 Cable

a. Low Voltage power Kerite 8/M D26 Series 8/M D26 Series 1940 Chemical spray not enveloped, and Control Cable Kerite 8/M D54 Series '8/M D54 Series 2006 Kerite 8/tt 032 Series 8/M 052 Series 2007 Qualif tcation for MSL8 has not been completed.

Kerite 8/M D63 Series 8/M D63 Series 2008 What does 'Not Acceptable

for replacement and maletenance wan?

Notes 1, 7, and 8.

b. 600 V rated Instr. Kerite 8/M D62 Series 8/M D62 Series 2009

$ Cable I c. Thermocouple Ext. Kertte 8/M b71 Series 8/M D71 Series 2010 Wire

d. Multi-pair Instr. Kerite 8/M D60 Series 8/M D60 Series 2011 Cable

e. Instrument Cable Kertte 8/M D61 Series 8/M D61 Series 2012

(

Instrument Cable Rockbestos Company Firewall III 8/M 080 Series 2002 Not qualtfted. Transtents and submergence are not Coaxial enveloped.

Notes 1 and 7.

Jumper / Hookup Wire Teledyne Thermatics TEF2EL 280 8/M 09 Series 1375 Thermal lag analysis and aging analysts have not been completed.

Notes 1 and 7.

Spilces Raychem WL5F-N WCSF-N Series 1937 Notes 1, 7 and 8.

H2 Analyzer System Comstp Inc. K-ill/K-IV H2 ANLH System 1933 Dtificult to determine if equipment was tested as a H2 ANLR LCL 1951 unit.

CBLSB Notes 1, 4 and 5.

TABLE A-2. (continued)

Component Manuf acturer Taq Musber 8 Model CES humber Comments Interlocking Relay NEMA 4 Box B2G30 0121 Testing has not been performed but CES states equipment is qualifted.

GE 12HGAllIJ2 B2131 0122 Does "PER COWONENT* for accelerated time and temera-GE CR2940 82G32 0123 ture mean that the equipment components will be aged separately? If so, will they be tested as a conclete GE Ei16 ur.it ?

GE EB25 hotes 1, 3, 4.

AGASTAT E7012PC

(

AGASTAT E 7012PO TEFZEL HIGH TE W WIRING AW IERMINALS HCV-09-1ARELPNL 1947 N HCV-09-18RELPNL 1948 N

HCV-09-2ARELPNL 1949 HCV-09-20RELPNL 1950 t

Electric Heating Coil WATLOW 1.5/30 kW EHC-2HVC FAI 0781 hot qualifted. Equipment is under review.

EHC-2HVE-6A2 4003 hotes 1, 3, 5 and 8.

EHC-2HVE-682 2005 level Switch Hagnetrol A103F-EP LS-06-1A 0874 5tellarity analysis has not been completed.

LS-06-18 0875 hotes 1 and 7.

a. See Table A-3 for notes.

b. CE supplied.

TABLE A-3. COMPONENT EVALUATION SHEET NOTES, FIGURE A-1

1. The "QUALIF METHOD" column (5) does not give meaningful information.

In almost all cases the method is listed as " COMB. TEST & EXTRAPOL'N"

. when other methods were possibly used.

. 2. Outstanding items are listed as none, but some equipment needs to be relocated because of submergence.

3. The entries in the "0THER EQUIPMENT THIS CES APPLIES T0:" block would be more useful if all pertinent equipnent tag numbers were entered.

4. Aging time and temperature are not always listed in the component evaluation sheet (CES). The CES would be more useful if this data were present instead of "SEE TEST REPORT" or "PER COMPONENT."

5. The " REPLACEMENT" and " MAINTAIN" sections should briefly indicate what replacement and maintenance is required to maintain equipment qualifi-cation. The comments "SEE TEST REPORT" or "SEE INSTRUCTION MANUAL" do not tell the reviewer anything if he does not have the test report or instruction manual.

6. In many cases the CES indicates SL2 has not checked or verified that the equipment claimed to be qualified is the equipment actually installed.

7. The " ENVIRONMENT" columns (1) and (2) do not always give the highest or most harsh parameters (i.e., highest specified temperature and highest qualified temperature) so that the reviewer could take a cursory look and feel that the environment may be enveloped. In most cases only the normal value and a reference for the design basis accident (DBA) is given. In some cases the referenced curve used for demonstrated

. qualification is the reference used for specified environment.

23

- - - - , , - .---w - -, -

TABLE A-3. (continued)

8. The " OUTS ITEMS" column (7) usually does not indicate what parameter is outstanding. If qualification has not been confirmed, the equipment is not qualified and the CES should reflect the outstanding items. .

k I

i l

l -

i I

24 l

r t

-. ,,- .n. ,, . . . - - - , . . . _ , . . , , ~ . - - - . . . - . - - . , - . . - - - - - . . . , . . - - . . , . , , , - - - , - - . ,

e s -

4 A/E: E8ASCO SERVICES INC. FACILITY: ST. LUCIE NO. 2 N555: COM USTION ENG. - PWR REve-j UTILITY: FLORIDA POWER & LIGHT COMPONENT EVALUATION SHETT CAPACITY: 890 IsWlE) CEst-EQUIPMENT I EINIR06esENT t DOCUMsNTATION I OUALIF.I H/MI OUTS 1 DESCRIPTION t PARAMETER SPECIFIED DEM. OUALIF.1 SPECIFIED DEM. QUALIF.B METH00 I I ITEM 58

..............................l.................g.......... 2 ----l------3-----------4-----l---5----l--G-1---T--l------------ -*----

TAG NO

I OPinaglL-l i I I f COMS. t / I NONE $ ACCEL TIME:

9 ITV t t t I I TEST & I 8 8 l NORM / TEST I I I I I ERTRA- I f I EQUIPMENT: IDSA 1 0 9 I I POL'N I I I ACCEL TEMP:

TYPE t--------------------*--------------------*-----*---------**--------------*==**---I I TEMPERAT-1 I t I t C0ess. t / I NONE I COMPONENT; I USE I I I I I TEST & 8 9 1 REPLACEMENT:

I l 1 1 I I EXTRA

I I I I f f I I I POL *N 1 1 I MANUFACTURER: 1------------------------------------------------------ --------------------------I MAINTAIN.?

I PRESSURE I I I I I COMS. t / I S.ONE l i i I I I I TEST & I I I MAJo# . 3 I I I l l ERTRA- 1 I I SUSCOMPONENTS:

, SUPPLIiR f I f f I I POL *N I 1 I g...............,.................................................................g MODEL ANO: I RELATIVE I I I I I COMS. I / I NONE $

SERIAL a I HUMIDITY I I I I I TEST & I I I I I I t 1 I EXTRA- t I I i i d

FUNCT. DES: 1 3 I I I POL'N t I

& SERVICE I--*----------------------------------------------*-------------------------------I ICHEMICAL I I I t I COesB. I / l 40NE I t SPRAY I l t i I TEST & I 1 I

) t I I I ? I EXTRA- 1 I I ACCU #. SPEC: I ! I I I l POL *N t t I ng I.................................................................................t Ln l R 2 HRt I l 1 1 COMO. t / I NONE I ACCUR. DEM. I A 30 Of I I I I TEST & I i 1 1D I VRt I I 1 1 EXTRA- I f f I 40VR/RWI t i i t POL *N 1 4 l SPECIFICATIDNS: t-------------------------- ------------------, ---------------*------------------!

I AGE- t i I i f COMB. t / 1 NONE t P.O a: IINST LIFE I I I I i TEST & I I t l(PER 323 .I I I I I EXTRA- I I I SAFETV FUNCTION:

PLANT LOC. 19974 DEF.)B f I I i POL'N I i 1 1---------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------I COORDINATE 5 X- 1 SURNERGEDI I I I I COMS. I / I NONE I Y- 1 VE5/NO I I I I I TEST & I I t Z- I f I t I f EXTRA- t I I AUTtf. REFERENCE t l l t t I I POL'N I 1 1 INSTALLEO (Y/N): t------------------*---------------=--------=-----------------------*---~~~---------------------------

INSTAL. I PARA- SUPPL. I OTHER EQUIPloENT THIS CES APPLIES TO: 1 OPERATING

REFERENCE:

CUALIF EXEMPTN: I leETER REVIEW 'I 8

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

t DP E R A0 t L I T Y t IPREP/DATE .

OUALIF: *lTEMPERATURE t ICHECN/DATE:

SIATUS *fr#E55URE I I

tREL. HUMIDITY f f CUALIFICATION REFERENCE

tCHEM. SPRAY I

REFERENCES:

I

.................************1 RADIATION I IPREP/DATE .

PHYS DwG REF: lAGING f ICHECN/DATE:

Plf45 OWG LOC: ISUBMERCENCE I l MOUNTING . t I SYSTEM EO. DOC. LOC: ISAR !NV CAT: I I 80588 CalEG. I f TAG IAPPINDIX E I I Figure A-1. Component evaluation sheet

O J

h APPENDIX B '

SUMMARIES OF SL2 CENTRAL FILE REVIEWS S

w 27

APPENDIX 8 ,

TUMMARIES OF SL2 CENTRAL FILE REVIEWS WESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC HYDdOGEN RECOMBINER,

. MODEL 8, PLANT IDENTIFICATION N0. 21 The hydrogen recombiners control hydrogen in containment by using heat to cause recombination of liberated hydrogen with free oxygen in the air to form water.

This recombiner is located in the containment at the 62-ft elevation level.

The specified environmental parameters are: temperature, 320*F MSLB, 280*F loss of coolant accident (LOCA); pressure, 42 PSIG; relative humidity, 100%; chemical spray, borated water pH 4.9-7.0; radiation, 1.5 x 107 rads total integrated dose (TID); operability time 30 days post LOCA.

Reports referenced as qualification documentation include Westinghouse Report WCAP 7709-L and WCAP 9346. Tests of a prototype recombiner were conducted at the following values: temperature, 310'F; pressure, 77 psig; relative humidity, 100%; chemical spray, borated water at pH 10; radiation, 2 x 108 rads; and operability time, greater than 60 days. Aging was done by electrical cycling, with the only thermally degradable component, the power cabling, being qualified by another test report.

It is noted that while the above data shows qualification and the referenced test reports contain sufficient information to qualify the hydro-gen recombiners, the correct information was not entered on the component evaluation sheets. Furthermore, discussions with the applicant revealed a

- lack of understanding of what data was needed for qualification. Errors included the use of energized heater skin temperatures for an enveloping

. environmental temperature profile, the application of a pressure transient at a different time than the temperature transient, and the referencing of a NRC approval letter without reading the letter or associated Safety Evaluation Report.

29

It is concluded that the qualification file, as presented, did not support the applicants claim for qualification awaiting confirmatory data.

ANCHOR DARLING HYDRAULIC VALVE ACTUATOR, MODEL N0. 64324-C 0001, PLANT ID NO. HCV-09-1A -

This electrohydraulic control valve actuator operates its associated .

main feedwater isolation valve. This valve must close rapidly upon receipt of a main steam isolation signal (MSIS) and operate slowly during plant operation. It is located on the steam trestle adjacent to the containment building.

The specified environmental parameters associated with a high energy line break (HELB) are: temperature, 340*F; pressure, 18.5 psia; relative humidity, 100%; radiation, 1 x 105 rads TID; operability time, 1 minute post DBA. No chemical spray or submergence parameters are identified.

The qualification documentation includes Anchor Darling Qualification Report No. QR-4, which includes test reports from other manufacturers.

Tests on a prototype actuator were conducted at the following peak values:

temperature, 450*F; radiation, 2.5 x 10 6rads; humidity, 100%; and opera-bility time, 160 minutes post accident. Margins were adequate for all data submitted. Aging conducted at 250*F for 318 hours0.00368 days 0.0883 hours 5.257936e-4 weeks 1.20999e-4 months was shown to yield a qualified life of greater than 40 years. The 10*C rule supported by Arrhenius methodology was used in these calculations. Accessories for the valve actuator were qualified via individual test reports.

Anomolies noted by the applicant included: lack of any pressure data during the steam test, substitution of a pressure switch different than that tested, and disagreement with manufacturer recommendations concerning replacment schedules. Discrepancies noted by the reviewer include lack of -

continuity in the qualifcation file concerning operability time, lack of an action plan concerning qualification data on the proposed pressure switch .

change, and lack of aging calculations on valve accessories. These discrep-ancies were satisfactorily addressed by the applicant before the conclusion of the audit.

30

i It is concluded that the Anchor Darling hydraulic valve actuator still needs additional confimatory data to be qualified; this agrees _with the applicat's conclusion.

' GEERAL ELECTRIC MOTOR, MODEL NO. SK811052C57, PLANT IDENTIFICATION NO. HPSI P-2A This motor runs HPSI Pump 2A which injects borated water into the reactor coolant system in the event of a system break. It is located in the auxiliary building.

The specified environmental parameters are: temperature, ll2*F; rela-tive humidity, 72%; radiation, 3.2 x 105 rads TID; operability time, 180 days post accident. No chemical spray, pressure, or submergence parameters were identified.

1 The report referenced as evidence of qualification is General Electric Topical Report GEK 50401. This report sumarizes data from several sources I concerning similar Sorizontal squirrel cage induction motors. Partial type test data were furnished to substantiate the analysis; however, it should be noted that separate effects testing was employed due to the size of the

! motor. Radiation materials analysis showed radiation resistance greater than 106 rads. Temperature testing of motor components far in excess of the ll2*F environmental parameter were also presented. An operability time of greater than 180 days was demonstrated. Thermal aging at 190*C for 28 days and utilization of Arrhenius methodology showed a qualified life in excess of 40 years.

It is concluded that the General Electric motor, Plant ID No. HPSI P-2A, is qualifed and that the applicant has adequate docunentation in the files to support this conclusion.

(

31 i

i 1

CONAX CORPORATION ELECTRICAL PENETRATION, MODEL NO. 7310-10003-01, PLANT NO. PENET E6 -

This medium voltage instrumentation penetration provides sealed con-ductors through containment and is located in the reactor building at coor-dinates X-635, Y-1467, and Z-24. o The specified accident parameters are: temperature', 420*F; pressure, .

44 psig; relative humidity, 100%; chemical spray,' 1720-2150 ppm boron and 8

65 ppm hydrazine, pH 4.9-7.0; radiation, 2.0 x 10 rads TID; submergence, 26 feet; and operability time of 180 days.

Enviromental testing has been performed on this model of penetration with the exception of submergence, and is reported in Conax test report IPS-585.2. The organization of the qualification file made it difficult to audit, so the applicant had to walk through the file to show the NRC reviewer the methods used for qualification.

The maximum environmental parameters that the penetration was subjected to are: temperature, >425"F 16 hours1.851852e-4 days 0.00444 hours 2.645503e-5 weeks 6.088e-6 months ; pressure, 62 psig; relative humid-ity,100%; chemical- spray, 6200 ppm boron and 50 ppm hydrazine, pH 8.7; radiation, 2 x 10 0rads TID; operability, 200 hours0.00231 days 0.0556 hours 3.306878e-4 weeks 7.61e-5 months at >320*F.

Thermal aging was performed for 100 hours0.00116 days 0.0278 hours 1.653439e-4 weeks 3.805e-5 months at 302 F, providing a pre-aged time of >40 years. Submergence had not been reviewed prior'to the audit. The applicant had recently received a submergence test report from Conax, IPS-850, which they will review for submergence qualification.

Conax has also agreed to provide the applicant with a revised test report of the penetrations, which will be easier to audit and show qualification.

In conclusion, the electrical penetration Plant No. E6 is qualified for its specified environment with the exception of submergence. Submergence -

will be reviewed by August 1982 and this information placed into the qualification file. .

32

GENERAL ATOMIC RADIATION DETECTOR, MODEL NO. RD-23, PLANT ID NO. RD-26-40 This detector is part of the radiation monitoring system (RMS) and pro-vides radiation detection in the reactor building in zone RB17 at coordinate a X-755, Y-1502, and Z-90.

The specified accident parameters are: temperature, 420'F; pressure, 44 psig; relative humidity, 100%; chemical spray, 2150 ppm boron and 65 ppm hydrazine, pH 4.9-7.0; radiation, 1.57 x 105 rads TID y; and operability time of 180 days.

Environmental testing was performed on a General Atomics Radiation Model RD-23 by Wyle Laboratories and is reported in General Atomic Test Report E-254-960.

The maximum environmental parameters that the RD-23 detector was sub-jected to are: temperature, 455'F; pressure, 77 psig; relative humidity, 100%; chemical spray, 3000 ppm boron, pH 10.5; radiation, 2 x 108 rads TID for interface materials; and operability time >l80 days.

No thermal or radiation aging was performed on the detector because it is made of only inorganic materials that are not radiation or temperature sensitive. The limiting " component" is the interface between the detector l

and the signal processor (i.e. mating connectors, shrink tubing, and coaxial cabling) and is addressed in other qualification data packages at SL2.

In conclusion, there should be no problems qualifing this detector upon completion of the items identified in the equipment qualification file.

9 l

33 l

ITT GENERAL CONTROLS DAMPER OPERATOR, MODEL NO. NH-90 SERIES, PLANT 10 NO. D-13 This actuator is part of the ECCS ventilating system and opens dampers on a safety injection actuation signal to allow air to pass thru ECCS filters. It has not been installed, but will be located in the auxiliary s building at coordinates X-561, Y-1533, and Z-43.

The specified accident parameters are: temperature, ll7*F; pressure, atmospheric; relative humidity, 62%; radiation, 3.5 x 104 rads TID; and operability time of <1 minute.

Environmental testing was performed on an ITT General Controls damper operator, Model NH-91, and is reported in ITT General Controls 721.77.095 and INTEL-RT 5204-001. Documentation was provided in the file showing the Model NH 91 and NH95 operators are similar.

The maximum environmental test parameters that the NH-91 operator was subjected to are: temperature, 200*F; pressure, atmospheric; relative humidity, 100%; radiation, 25 x 106 rads TID; operability, operated to safe position in <1 minute.

Thermal and cyclic aging performed was 3 months at 140 F, 200 hours0.00231 days 0.0556 hours 3.306878e-4 weeks 7.61e-5 months at 200*F, 2000 cycles at 100% stroke, and 100,000 cycles at 20% stroke. Chem-ical spray and submergence were not addressed because they are not applicable at this location.

In conclusion, the damper operater, Plant ID No. 013, is qualified for its specified environment, if the proper maintenance is performed. The applicant has agreed to perform " life extention analysis" for operator cons ponents. This analysis will be used to show what maintenance and mainten-ance frequency is required to insure continued operator qualification. -

t 34

s.

TARGET ROCK SOLEN 0ID VALVE OPERATOR, MODEL NO. 78E-009, PLANT ID NO. SE-05-1A This device is used as a system containment isolation sampling valve.

-- The specified accident parameters are: temperature, 420 F; pressure, 44 psig; humidity, 100%; chemical spray, 1720-2150 ppm boron and 65 ppm

, hydrazine at pH 4.9-7.0; radiation, 3.6 x 105 rads TID; operability time, 1 minute.

Environmental testing of this item was reported by Target Rock, test report No. 2375 appendices A thru J.

Thermal aging was performed for 33 days at 350*F. The maximum environ-mental test parameters were: temperature, 385*F; pressure, 66 psig; humid-ity, 100A; chemical spray, 6200 ppm boron and 50 ppm hydrazine, 8.6-10.0 pH; radiation, 3.53 x 10 rads TIU; 14 days test. The qualification metnod was test and analysis. Not present in the applicants qualification is ther-mal lag analysis, which the applicara has stated will be completed on 7-31-82.

LIMITORQUE MOTOR OPERATED VALVE ACTUATOR, MODEL AK021, PLANT ID N0. MV-08-1A Tnis motor-operated valve actuator operates the main steamline isola-tion bypass valve A and is located in the turbine building.

i The specified accident parameters are: temperature, 333*F; pressure, i

16 psig; humidity, 100%; radiation, 1 x 105 rads; and an operability time of 180 days.

Environmental testing for this item was reported by Limitorque Report

, Nos. B0058, 600456, B0027, B0009, and B0003.

35

i Prior to testing the valve actuator was pre-aged at 165'F for

~200 hours. The maximum environmental test parameters were: temperature, 7

385'F; pressure, 66 psig; humidity, 100%; radiation, 2 x 10 rads TID; and a test duration of 30 days; A_ qualified life of 40 years was established by test and analysis.

t It is concluded that the Limitorque motor-operated valve actuator specified is environmentally qualified with adequate margins, and evidence ,

of qualification is maintained in the applicant's files.

RELIANCE FAN MOTOR, MODEL IXF882438A3-NE, PLANT ID NO. 2HVS-1A This device is used for containment heat removal and is located in the reactor building.

The specified accident parameters are: temperature, 420 F; pressure, 44 psig; humidity, 100%; chemical spray, 2150 ppm boron and 65 ppm hydazine pH 4.9-7.0, radiation, 1.57 x 107rads TID; and operability time 180 days.;

Environmental testing for this item was performed by Joy Manufacturing Company as_ detailed in Report No. X-604 dated April 6,1977.

Prior to testing thermal aging was performed at 415*F for 108 hours0.00125 days 0.03 hours 1.785714e-4 weeks 4.1094e-5 months .

The maximum environmental test parameters were: temperature, 415'F; pres-sure, 78 psig; humidity, 100%; chemical spray,.3000 ppm boron-pH 10.5; radi-ation, 1 x 104rads; test duration, 1. year. The qualification method was test and analysis.

It is concluded that the documentation presented in the applicants file supports qualification of this item.

AMERANCE CORPORATION TERMINAL BLOCK, MODEL NO. 61682 ,

This device is used as a terminator for control instrumentation wiring in the turbine building and outside containment penetration areas.

36

The specified accident parameters are: temperature, 333*F for approxi-mately 25 seconds; pressure, 16 psig; humidity, 100%; radiation, 1 x 105 rads TID; operating time, 180 days.

Environmental testing for this item was performed by the Franklin e Research Center and is documented in a test report titled Qualification Tests of Terminal and Fuse Blocks F-C5143. Prior to testing the terminal block was pre-aged for 39.6 days at 329'F. The maximum environmental test parameters were: temperature, 340'F for approximately 2-1/2 hours; pres-0 sure, 113 psig; humidity, 100%; radiation, 2 x 10 rads; test duration, ,

7 days. A qualified life of 40 years was established by test and analysis, it is concluded that the Amerance Terminal Block is environmentally qualified with adequate margins. Evidence of qualification is maintained in the applicant's file.

I l

i 37 l

I 1

-- _ _ - - . - -

ML20066B323

Contents

Text

Title:

1.0 INTRODUCTION

4.0 REFERENCES

1.0 INTRODUCTION

3.0 CONCLUSION

4.0 REFERENCES

REFERENCE:

REFERENCES:

Navigation menu

ML20066B323

Text

Title:

1.0 INTRODUCTION

4.0 REFERENCES

1.0 INTRODUCTION

3.0 CONCLUSION

4.0 REFERENCES

REFERENCE:

REFERENCES:

Navigation menu

Search