IR 05000245/1985013

Physical Protection Insp Repts 50-245/85-13 & 50-336/85-16 on 850408-11.No Violations Noted.Major Areas Inspected: Security Organization & Program Audit,Records & Repts. Safeguards Info Deleted (Ref 10CFR73.21 & 2.790)

ML20134H836
Person / Time
Site:	Millstone
Issue date:	08/20/1985
From:	Dunlap J, Keimig R, Madden W NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:
Shared Package
ML20134H785	List: IR 05000245/1985013 ML20134H782
References
50-245-85-13, 50-336-85-16, NUDOCS 8508290182
Download: ML20134H836 (7)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:, .

      ;

• .

..
*  U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMISSION

REGION I

50-245/85-13 Report N /85-16 50-245 DPR-21 Docket N . License N DPR-65 Licensee: Northeast Nuclear Energy Company P.O. Box 270 Hartford, Connecticut 06101 Facility Name: N111 stone Nuclear Power Station, Units 1 and 2 Inspection At: Waterford. Connecticut Inspection Conducted: April 8-11, 1985 Inspectors: YW w M# W. J. Hadden, Physical Security Inspector date J . Dunlap Physic lx x hta-h rity Inspector date Approved by: "E;Er E. R. Keinig,fChief, ,$pTeguards Section

    [2d-
    ' date h

Nuclear Materials Md Safeguards Branch Inspection Summary: Routine Unannounced Physical Protection Inspection on Apr11 8-11,1985 (Combined Report Nos. 50-245/85-13 and 50-336/85-16) Areas Inspected: Security Organization; Security Program Audit; Records and Reports; Testing and Maintenance; Locks, Keys, and Combinations; Physical Barriers (Protected / Vital Areas); Security System Power Supply; Compensatory Measures; Assessment Aids; Access Control (Personnel / Packages / Vehicles); -4 Detection Aids (Protected / Vital Areas); Alarm Stations; and Communication The inspection involved 50 hours onsite by two NRC region-based inspectors and was conducted during regular hour Results: The Itcensee was in compliance in all areas examine Two inspector followupitems(IFI)wereopened. A previously identified violation and an unresolved item were close pge290102850823 o ADOCK 05000245 PDR ]

      .

.

.
.-
.
      [
.
. .
 ,   Details Persons Contacted E. Mroczka, Station Superintendent (NNEco)

R. Herbert, Station Service Superintendent (NNECo) W. Romberg, Unit 1 Superintendent (NNECo) N. Tasker, Director, System Security, (NUSCO) M. Griffin, Security Agent (NUSCo) P. Weekley, Security Supervisor (NNECo) L. Brown, Security Coordinator (NNECo) A. Maloney, Division Human Resources Manager, Burns Security J. Mayoros, District Manager, Burns Security J. Shedlosky, Senior Resident Inspector, USNRC All of the above were present at the exit intervie The inspectors also interviewed other licensee and contract security service personne . 30703 - Exit Interview The inspector met with licensee representatives at the conclusion of the inspection on April 11, 1985. At that time, the purpose and scope of the inspection were reviewed and the findings presented. At no time during this inspection was written material provided to the licensee by the inspector . 92701 - Followup on Unresolved Item THIS PAR AGR APil C0!iT AINS S f FEGU ARDS INFORMAit0!i AtiD 15 !!01 FOR PUBLIC DISCLOSURE,II15INTENil0llALLY LEFT BtAN . 92702 - Followup on Violations - _ THIS PARAGRAPH CONTAINS SAFEGUA905 INFORMATION AND IS NOT FOR PUBLIC DISCLOSURE, ITIS INTENil0NALLY LEFT BLAN <

. .
.

3 .81022 - Security Organization The licensee's security management structure and chain of command were reviewed by the inspector and found in conformance with the approved Security plan, Contingency Plan, procedures, and applicable regulatory requirements, and were adequate and appropriate for their intended func-tion. The inspector confirmed that sufficient security organization supervisors and personnel were available to meet protection require-ment , 81034 - Security Program Audit The licensee continued to audit the security program in accordance with Chapter 15 of the security plan. A total of 75 manhours were expended by the licensee in completing the Annual Management Security Audit, dated November 21, 1984. One lighting deficiency was identified. The deficiency was immediately correcte . 81038 - Records and Reports Security Event Report records and logs, Vital Area key control custody records and Alarm Response records were spot checked for the period January - April, 1985. All records were complete, properly maintained and readily accessibl . 81042 - Testing and Maintenance The licensee's program for testing and maintenance of security equipment conformed to the requirements of the security plan and licensee proce-dures. Testing and maintenance records were reviewed and security equip-ment was tested at the inspectors' request to ensure that the equipment met regulatory general performance requirements and objectives. The program was considered adequat . 81046 - Locks, Keys, and Combinations The licensee's key and lock control program was being administered in accordance with licensee procedures and the approved security plan. The accountability of vital area keys was confirmed by the inspecto . 81052 - Physical Barriers (Protected Areas) The inspectors confirmed by observation that the physical barriers sur-rounding the protected area were installed and maintained in conformance with the security plan. The inspectors examined approximately two-thirds of the perimeter fencing on April 9, 1985 and found it acceptabl .

.- .

.

1Hl5 PARAGRAPil CONTA)NS 5W, GDS INFORM.\T!DN N G I DISCLDSurd,II15 INTEN1IONAltY LEf1 BLA% , 81054 - physical Barriers (Vital Areas) The inspector observed barriers enclosing the Unit 2 vital areas and found them in conformance with the security pla . 81058 - Security System Power Supply

  '

The inspector confirmed that a power supply system was maintained by the licensee to provide emergency power to physical security equipment in accordance with the security plan. The inspector determined from a review of records that the power supply was maintained and tested in accordance with the licensee's procedure . 81064 - Compensatory Measures A review of records by the inspector determined that compensatory measures, when required, conformed with the security plan and the licensee's security procedures. The measures were adequate for their intended functio . 81066 - Assessment Aids The inspector determined that assessment aids conformed to the security plan and were adequate and appropriate for their intended functio . 81070 - Access Control (Personnel) The inspector observed that the licensee controlled access to the pro- 4 tected and vital areas in accordance with the security plan and security procedure Search equipment was adequate and appropriate for its intended functio . 81072 - Access Control (Packages) The inspector observed that the entry of packages and material into the protected area was controlled in conformance with the security plan and security procedures. Search equipment was adequate and appropriate for its purpos { a i I

l . .. ,

* *

tl

      ' '
. .
.

17. ,81074 - Access Control (Vehicles) The inspector observed that vehicle access to the PA was in accordance with the security plan and security procedures. Vehicles were properly searched and escorted as required. Vehicle searches and personnel pro-cessing were observed frequently by the inspectors during this inspection at the main vehicle access control poin , 80178 - Detection Aids (Protected Areas) The perimeter intrusion detection system detected penetration tests of the isolation zones in accordance with the security plan. Alarm system performance was observed during an inspector requested test conducted on April 9, 198 . 81080 - Detection Aids (Vital Areas) The plant vital areas intrusion tystem detected inspector requested attempted penetrations of the vital area doors. This was demonstrated to the inspectors by testing on April 9, 1985, 20, 81084 - Alarm Stations The inspectors observed both the CAS and SAS operators in the performance of required surveillance and communications duties as required by the security plan and security procedure ... i i THIS PARAGRAPH CONTAINS SAFEGUARDS INFORMAT10ft AND 15 NOT FOR PUBLIC DISCLOSURE,liHilNTENil0NALLY ' LEFIBLAN .

      ,

21, 81088 - Communications The inspectors confirmed communications equipment effectiveness between the CAS/SAS and members of the security organization on post or patro Random tests were accomplished by the Itcensee throughout the inspection at the request of the inspector .

% / vf 3 - U.S. 000 CLEAR fitGULAT0 fly C0tstel8540's rima *A. wespectoa % * w aret nreae+i n IIIIC ron.PIB

 "  * '

M' INSPECTOR'S REPORT 6b'

.  .

Office of Inspection and Enforcement e/ m i 6

     ).
             .
          '

I

~

Qugl-f E f

            '8Poa' "' '*sn e o Art tici%$u vi%oca    '",5,',c'**  ooCas t %0 is.... On tiet%si
      ,   "o 44* ] y'g'y1gp   uO st0 wo ,a bfjllf*/04)[ $uk     f ""'  } }0 f G iy r  ff j 3 A
   ,  \ *~***'"  8 50 d' e 33 (o  @f I la *

_

     ~

_

           ~
            -

c

 #E/ ,,,L L fj)k & O )   o - otttti
 '

b' a - alPtact O 2 to 15 1 i%$PtCviO% Pt af 0 auto av OHGANilATON CODE Of atCe auN,MQ Co%D.a;f-F1 800 08iNwtsf eGaviO% i%S*6C fium '

    '#'

SAQU to alG'3% AL O8 8 Cl Staf 6 Of M4 8 h wo oss in wo oAv vn z atsotNtinsP Croa _ETgh DW L_.aAy n pk M, [[[ / l[ g .I Ptaf onWA%CE APPaAi$at f TAM 1 k

[3  25 M  31    32     13  54 MS aggioga, actog      TYPE OF ACTmf V CON 00Cf to Cw t one tion on%.
  "" W  02 - Sattiv   08 - WGut Vity F'~~to PL ANT SEC  14 - t%0 ping
        .7 - SPitiAt  II - sNytNt vtn  16 - DNyt$ttGatc%

I . hec tonu tel 03 - INCIDE NT L f - CtGo%A6 088tCe ttttta 04 - INsDacEvist Os.vt%oon 12 - SMiPMINT.t aPont 06 - MGUT AUOet OS- MAtACCt t). IMP 0st M 37 3 iNvi a .Op*.N TOTAs %vusta t%scaCEvt%f CONFlat%Cl at PO"' CO%N J F80 ttttin om alPont in ANgy,ttat DAf t

 ' e***"

t ;,n . A T.cN F N aiNG b Ofvosatc%s Ago sett0 IN80aw a riON A . C 0 Div A'cNS ( /* [ ,2[ NacionWlet On alG atPontst%t tomo 80s

/ /  t - Ctt An Litt ta illutD  ACY4N
. t - VIOLAtlope 3 0tviatON   A 8 C D A D  A B C D  M0 Day va wo DA, en SlC
-- -
 ..vouto sot w o  M, di , , o di ' - "5 / / '-"$  CB al AM  I I I g   4Q 41   of  43  44  49 $0  65 woouit istoevav40%       v m , e .gs nawav,og
        ,$ WOOutt huutta l%5P  gg   WODutt ato rottowvP
[k WOOut:4vwstai%s*  gg y   v0Dutt at0 Pott 0*vP
   ! !!. f;. !.}y.!.j! !8, i- s
        .   -
-   e   .     . 9 Il        !!    i i <3;3
     > m  -

a . l.}i <3 - e- m ., 1 9 l I!!!I ik! !

   . . a        3
! ! ! Ik     I il  f ,s iil  IE h i!!!I g[oe  r  1 El ?
. , 5 3,ol7,g3 f  A cafl, ,,  , l,,l , 5 f,Ilo3 fl6
        ,

A p,sg Ave c , I,,1

   *

ii i i , liil * ii i i i liil c ii i n i liil ( ii i i i liil o i , i , i liil o ii i i i li,1 a f 1,t17ioi/16 - eM ii I fiiloiri416 , i /fJ IMa.lS A aei2 /ino c i IiiI l * i .' , , i liil * ii i i i I,il ( i i i , i liil

          '

ii i i iliil ! i , , , , I,,1 o

           .. , ,  i1.,1
-. i 5 9.217ia2.18  '

odd AC ( filloiMlc . i 6 ti/lM4lS ' fio il /rd C iliiI

   *

i i . i i liil * ii i i i I i i l_ c i i , , i liil - ii i , iI,il i i i i i liiI  : ii i i ili,i a i I 8d10:2i10 2 a hidif /ihd e i lii1 . i ( fillbifiIlP 0## ArrB ^ f f,!2.fM3

   -
   . . . . i Iii1    *

ii i , iIiiI

   '        (

iliil i i i i i liil ii i i o mn w rn,'t n

   , _i i i  i Ii,I    o i, , ,  ,1,,I 131 1 u .. .. = ,,  . 1, 1. i .  . n ,, i. - ,. ,, , ,,  ,.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ NaC #oawles U S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMIS5 ION PomwueAi umsm ?cnn %,, ... a,., ne ws, .,

 *  '
** -
 .
  *
  *

INSPECTOR'S REPORT j N'

.

Of fice of Inspection and Enf orcement

          / ,g,4
~ ~ ' ~

mawy , J . r teCl% Sit bi%DO8 ",I " '** D0c al1 No is e,.. On LiCIN$t Wa t %Inf ASMC D A'l m 14 ypj'd'+- No sea o -

     - " ' ' ' " " '

LLu r M i t A gre e e 3 3 4 .1 r i *

     " " * * "

_ u O De Li f t C a .eletaCl D 1 , 14 1% 1 PleioD os i%ve n f +G A v eu% Anat C fio% i%$ettfoo% eta *0avt0e' 08%ANi/ AfiUN UX)t 08 miteiuN My Co%;V,'.T ING ACitvif T ($er #(WL' 09 A' Wayw,. a,wr, fAOW 70 f- siig agat ostati stas t O'at a ,,,,,,,y,,,,,,,,,, p p,, , MO DAv vA WO DA, vm - att:Dl%f 5%$PECf 0R N LNN EI I'"A_ V I '.N '" M14 0 13

[)

J II- olf

 ,b ,4
  /l/ 1L5

    ' - "= o ANa A~a A'sai n Av 3J j- 33
             -

l F

6- - . 3% pt GON A, g(?'ON I ' "I O ' A C ' ' * ' ' ' C U S U V C I I U ' < * * * '" 8*'

   '

Q,- SAftfy QB . MGVf Vi'.it 40 - PL ANT SIC _ 14 - 1%Quis' 1 - %#C f 0#U 691 03 IN Clot N T OF SPIC' At 11 -6%vt%f via 16 - 1%, t s t,Ga tia% g 4 - 8tGIONAt Of f tCi tt film os - .N8 0er t vs %f as visDon i;. SMPvt%f inPOmf 0% - MGut A uoit o.- waf ACCf 13.sveont 35 37 3 A5 Fist Op'A,t h'. . A T ON I ALAu5 ,O t a, %,.upt s t%sgacivi%' C0%s t al%q q miront cos? AiN ,4 ggt,gn on atPOmf f a A%%v 't46Ca's

 ' ~ ' " * * " '

08 v& A'eCNS AND 8'l L C iNF OR Y A f CN 0 0 C D Di v. A 'iCN$ p'}[ niaC sGay ut Riega'lt%' 1 / t - Cttan On elG 70MG 808 I - VIOLAflON d/ tt f f t e issut0 AC f o% 3 - DtviAf oN A e C D Ale C D A e C D 90 DAv va 40 CA' lvn

    ' ~

4 - VOL AfiO4 4 DE VlAf SON , , t til t _ vtg h l l l l 39 4) d' al 4) 44 49 iC 5% oaom.i%.on a.m% o- _ . . o . . a . ., % A owua uo.l. omi ..a ,Ou m, gt owsa vo.. . ,%i, y

              ..o a .. a . ou m,
'
   ,,[, y 9e   r g:  e,h5 i :rgiy
-

i 8:  : J 6 g;a

   $ jn  e 45 a:  : '
         ;  - q'  5-r  a, ,

t 8: j e!gv:

    >       . p .
*

j _

   ;
           .
        .       ~
 'I     ~(, f: I1   I, fs
        -

r h s qirs  :,' s !: riirs 3 le La: Ere

             .
          ,
: 1 5 > e u A a.: < re :, 2 36   2 s, e  -

4 - . a i llilldhld '

   "

eir il- /i trv 0 i liil mi fli/ loi7hlp ' v.p i3 /imo C i liiI ii i , , IiiI a i i i i i liil ii i s i liil < i i i n i liil

   "
   ,, i i  i 1.il     i i i i  i liiI e i l fillh G lS  '

dion/ /ith0 (' i lii1 i I lilldi78lF ' oit iJ li ano C i liiI

          -
   '

ii , , i liil i i i . i liil

   <

i, i , i l,il < _

           >>  i i  i liil o

i, , , , I,,1 " i i , , i l..I i f fillbildl& ' Abi t/ ltw t' , Iii1 - i 5 tillDJid !O ' u no Iioio c- i I,iI

   '

is i i i lii! * i i i i i liil ii i , i liil i i , , i liil o ii , , i liil , i i i i 1 il

. i l Eil 16 Mlf>  '

einil ,I,mb ( , li,I - n Jfill0Ji'll6 ' ens ti ao e FhiHa%4L i l i i_L

   -        *
   ,, i ,  i liil     i i , ,
   <

ii i i i liil y ( i i i i i Iiil mMi',9=,'#A f s, n i i i i i lii1 - fl #ff - 6 om ,y /io no c i i u_L 1. i,

            -
  ,. ,, ,, ,. ,. ,. ,. . ,,  ,. . , , . .,   ,, ,,  ,. ,. ,. ,o ,,   ,.

. }}