IR 05000237/1976010
| ML17252B144 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Dresden, Quad Cities  |
| Issue date: | 05/27/1976 |
| From: | Hind J NRC/RGN-III |
| To: | Brian Lee Commonwealth Edison Co |
| References | |
| IR 1976009, IR 1976010, IR 1976012, IR 1976014 | |
| Download: ML17252B144 (11) | |
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:J / > ---* A UNITED STATES A N.LEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
- ,
- .~
REGION Ill 799 ROOSEVELT ROAD --- - ----- ---- --------- ------ -GL:EN ELl.:VN;-ILt:INOIS '60137 Commonwealth Edison Company AlTNi Mr. Byron Lee, J Vice President P.O. Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 60690 Gentlemen: Docket No.~7 Docket N Dock.et No. 50- 54 . Dock.et No. 50-265 This refers to the inspection conducted* on April 29 and * May 13, 1976, by Mr. c. c. Peck of this office and to the discussion of his findings with Messrs. Larson, Butterfield, _Massiu, Kuhel and other members of your staff at the conclusion of the inspection. Your activities pursuant to Title 10, Code of Federal Regulations, Part 70, "Special Nuclear Material as they pertain to Licenses No. DPR-19, No. DPR-25, No. DPR-29 and No. DPR-30 were the subject of the inspectio *
.,:* No items of noncompliance with NRC requirements were. identified during the course of this 1.napectio,, * The inspection consisted of an examination of the plutonium production and uranium fission and transmutation quantities that.Commonwealth Edison.has reported semi-annually on forms MRC-742, Material Status Report for the Dresden 2 and 3 and Quad-{:ities 1 and 2 stations. During a previous * inspection (No. 050-237/75-24 and 050-249/75~21), quantities reported were found to differ significantly from the* amounts that our inspectors considered to be reasonable based on thermal energy generated and fuel exposure for. . some of the. six-months perio The reasons. for such differences were satisfactorily explained to us during this inspection and we have no further questions at this* time. To eliminate the possibility of future discrepancies, it vaa agreed at the conclusion of. the inspection that * future Material Status Reports for_ Commonwealth Edison facilities wou1d show actual in-core plutonium production and uranium fission and transmutation totals on: the.* reverse side of the NRC-742 form~ whenever such totals differ from.** *. quantities recorded on the front * o~. the form..
... *'. . ~-. . ~. '*. (o()~ 1> . ~. ,** ~.,.-.. ~ .. ~--~-~--~-~~--.__,..,..,,.___,....__* -~
y ... e '.. *..
- /
- e Commonwealth Edison Company
- 2 - MAY 2 *7 1976 - ---------- - -::" - --- --- - - - - Areas examined during this inspection concern a subject matter which is exempt from disclosure according to Section 2.790 .of the NRC's "Rules of Practice." Part 2, Title lC, Code of Federal Regulation Consequently, our report of this inspection will not* be placed in the Public Document Roo We will be glad to d1.scuss any questions you have. concerning .t.his,inspectio *-..:*-
Sincerely yours, .*.*, . -~ *" ~, .... .,: :*. ,_..
- * J. A~. Hind, Chief
- .. * :, *. Safeguards Branch *
- I*
Enclosure: ........ :.** : *~ IE Inspection n.eports ,..,..,..,.. *',..* ....... No. 050-237/76-10,
- <
- '.............. :,*.**c
. _,._,.. No. 050-249/76-09, ... . "...,' "" '.*.. * . *'No*. "<>so-2'54l76-l4, .:'.)/.::><>*L:: {<'.~~:'.>: :~ ;.:,--:: and No. 050-265/76-12
.. .....
- *
(Part 2~ 790(d). Information).*. *: *:_:, > ;'.<: '*.'. ?~- > .. *: *. ;. bee w/encl:
- * *
Central Files * .. '.. Regions I, II; and V
- . *,,.:>. IE Mail and File Unit.
bee w/o encl:**** PDR Local PDR *
- _:;*
.... :;:: .. '.. *. ..... :...' ~.. '. ' ,.
- ... '
..
- .
- ~~
'
- '
... ~ \\,....
- .. ' *'
.,...,..... ' ' ~ I. *
- ..
- .*.:
.
- * c *
..,*, *... .... : ; : :.~ *:
- '*...,
. *. :,.. :',' *~;.. :~. .... *: : ..... :.....
- .: *:_,,,
- ,I*".
. ',.: I
- ".: :.*.-' *.. ~; >~ * :. * *: ~: *
~--. ~..- ' ' * * .. *.. .r;-:*:: -:.*. *-:*:... * .. :... .........
- .
... ..
- ......
. .. .. :... ~. ~f;'"!'.":".,... *
- '**~_*: ; *-.- *"'. **_.. * ****.. *:....
~- ... ..:. .... .... ~. . :<***-. '
- .. *.'
. --:
- -.-......
-**
- I,"
- <.tr-~-.- *""*.S.<*.:.~.
,: .... -._.. ..,..,,. *...* ~**-"'*;**-... ' . ,,~*- ~.. :: <.... ... . ' ~ "*".:. . **':..-*.
- -... *.*
..~. " ~- ~ :**:
- ';***.
_:**...,.. '
.* : r'
- *.* ' * * ' '~ *
. *. ~,*.
- ... :
.,*.
- .
.. ...
- ".. :.. *.
'... . ~
*
- -*--*-----.**-----..,*-***-,,_,_: ___ *_:. ________.. _____,r------*~***-... O*O'*-*----~-----... -*M-*,.;...~-----*--*--*****-*-*------------~...
""'?::1:***:U<"';.;. . *.' '* ','-..
.. .';:. UNITED sAs NUCLEi\\R REGULi\\TORY COMMissr9 . OFFICE OF INSPECTION i\\ND ENFORCEMENT
REGION III
---
~---- ---- --- --- - --- ----- -- --- --
.* ___ .* - --... . ,.l .. IE Inspection IE Inspection IE Inspection IE Inspection Licensee: - - -
~--- -
- -- ----- Report Report Report Report N N N N /76-10 050-249/76-09 050-254/76-14 050-265/76..:.12 Commonwealth Edison Company P. O. Box 767 Chicago, Illinois 60690 Dresden Nuclear Power Station Units 2 and 3 Morris, Illinois License No. DPR-19 License No. DPR-25 Category: C
- Quad-Cities Nuclear Power Station.*License No. DPR-29 Units 1 and 2 License No. DPR-30 Cordova, Illinois Category:
C .. Type of Licensee:. BWR, 800 MWe _Type of Inspection:. Materials Safeguards, Announced Dates of Inspection: April 29 and May 13, 1976 7>J. tUr4. Principal Inspector: ~l)t C. C. Peck * *
- s-fz~ /1~
(Date) Accompanying Inspectors: * Norie *
- Other Accompanying Personnel:
None .. . - . . . Reviewed By: ~.1 (f(,~.
Safeguards Branch '*.
- S-F3-76~285.*. * * **
. Copy.--1L of J~. copie *~ __ Pages *
Attachme*nt: **
- . Findings (Part 2. 790(d). Information).*
.*_.. ',.*,.,
- THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT TO BE
- ' :. REPRODUCED WITHOUT SPECIFIC APPROVAL.. OF IE: III*
,:. .. .. ...
- ., '.-*.-*:
.. *'*._:* .,;
- .. *. '..
..... *:*. .. ' ,*,.. * .., _.... _.. : . ***[* ....
J" Part 2.790(d) lnforrnat1ori e SUMMARY OF FINDINGS Inspection conducted April 29 and May 13, 1976 (Dresden Units 2, 76-10 and 3, 76-09) (Quad-Cities Units 1, 76-14 and 2, 76-12): The inspection consisted of an examination of uranium depletion and plutonium production quantities that have been reported on Forms NRC-742 by the licensee for the Dresden 2 and 3 and Quad-Cities l and 2 station Apparent discrepancies between reported quantities and NRC-calculated quantities were resolve No items of noncompliance were identifie Enforcement Items No items of noncompliance were identified during the inspectio Licensee Action on Previously Identified Enforcement Items Not applicabl Other Significant Items Systems and Components. * .N.on Facility Items (Plans and Procedures) None * .. * Managerial Items Non Noncompliance Identified and Corrected.. by Licensee Non Deviations Non Status of Previously Reported Unresolved Items Not.applicabl..***.
- . ; ~...
. :~-..
- - 2
'. **... -*.. ' ~.... .:_t*, Part 2.?~0(d) Information
PO.rt 2. 7:JO (cl) infor!l13. ti on e e ~ Management Interview At the conclusion of the meeting it was agreed that the licensee would report actual in-core uranium burnup and plutonium production --- -- --- ---data on t-he--l'everse--of *the-NRG-742*-, Materials-Status Report--forms--* whenever these quantities differed from data reported on the face
- -.e of the for The licensee representatives stated that these differences should tend to be less significant since many of the reasons for past differences have been eliminate Present at the discussion were:
L. D. Butterfield, Supervisor, Nuclear Fuel Services .P.*.* c.. Kuhel, Group Leader, Nuclear -Fuel -Services C. O *. Larson, Comptroller's Staff H. L. Massiu, Group Leader, Nuclear Fuel Services Joan White, Comptroller's Staff C. C. Peck, NRC
- .. "*'* >>:*:***--.
..
- ' *:.. *,,...
'*"
- .. *.:..
~. :. - 3 ~
- "
,... Pa.rt 2 ~ 7JO ('I) 1 :. L r*..r:*~ t. t,* '**. .. -:-:- .. *
Part 2~ 7 JO (:l} Ini'c;~rr.o.tion e e REPORT DETAILS Licensee Personnel Supplying Information L. D. Butterfield J. P. Hill P. C. Kuhel C. 0. Larson H. L. Massiu Joan White Scope of Inspection The inspection was a meeting for the purpose of resolvin*g some apparent discrepancies between uranium and uranium-235 fission and transmutation totals and plutonium production totals reported by the licensee, and corresponding totals manually calculated by NRC inspector These data are.reported semi-annually on Form NRC/ERDA-742 in.accordance with Section 70. 53 of 10 CFR Part 70.. A comparison of NRC-calculated and licensee reported data for all reporting periods since December 1972 for Dresden 2 and 3 (seven periods) and since June 1974 for Quad-Cities 1 and 2 (four
- periods) disclosed in general that the reported quantities for the two periods in 1975 appeared incorrec The manual calculations used by the inspectors cannot be expected to be as accurate generally as the licensee's computerized data, since it is not *
- '*posBible "'to :corrsrder ~-11--significant variables.in a manual metho However~ the manual method normally agrees within 8% with
- .accurate computer data..Since differences were much larger than 8%, the inspection was made to learn the cause of the inconsistencie CFR Part 70, Section 70.53 On-line process computers are progranuned.*to print out fuel inventories for the Dresden 2 and 3 and Quad-Cities 1 and 2 reactor For each of the 725 fuel assemblies.in each of the
. reactors, the computer will supply the current inventory of each uranium and plutonium isotope. Facility totals are also provided for the isotope The process computers were first used to generate data for use in completing the NRC-742 forms in July 197 Until that time an off-line computer program supplied by GE was used to provide the data for these forms., . - 4.*-...
- .:I
. *- r*.. ~-.....
- .*\\.
........ ~*.~=-1...-*;_..
The* li.censee explained that the change to*use of the on-line computer was responsible for most of the discrepancies between the depletion and production quantities reported and actual in-core depletion and productio Perturbations have also been caused by refu~lings,
~--- ---re-10cat1-ons--0£f-uei in -the--Core: and_ ~O~P~t-er --r~uOdi~g- ~-~th_o_d*~-.- --
--- -~ '*.. . '* **- The licensee stated that an effort was made to report ending inventory figures as accurately as possible on the 742 form The differences between ending inventory totals and beginning inventory, excluding changes caused by receipts and shipments, therefore represent uranium depletion or plutonium productio Discrepancies in the beginning and ending inventories caused by computer program changes, rounding, refueling, etc show up as apparent depletion* and proau*c-tion. *rhere "is 'no other space on the '74.2 form to indicate such discrepancie Although these perturbations have been relatively small and insignificant as percentages of inventory totals (less than 0.1%), they can represent more than 10% of depletion or production for a six-month perio It was stated that the computer programs for Dresden 2 and 3 and Quad-Cities 1 and 2 were currently being modified to improve their inventory accurac Presumably this will also mean that reported uranium depletion and plutonium production figures will also be more accurat In conclusion it was agreed that the licensee would in the future report actual in-core uranium depletion and plutonium production quantities on the reverse side of the NRC-742 form whenever these data differed from quantities reported on the front.of the for Attachments 1-4 show comparat.ive licensee-NRC depletion production calculations for the four reactor For those instances in which the 742-reported data were questioned, the licensee's calculations of actual *in-core depletion are shoW1 Attachments: Attachments 1 through 4 _.,**, '*,....
- .-;
.. ~ ;. ' '... -~ ' \\.. ---.. - < *,. ~: :..
- ,,*-:*-...
5.- ~".. .,... ~.:. . ....... '~.** : ': :. -.*. .,
.
- ----*-*--*---~----- *-* ____ ____,_____:_, __....:~.~.-.J, e.l'e.rt ~.1~0 ( dJ Information e
. . e ~,;... Quad-Cities 1 --- ~---- -- - -- - -- ~-- -- -- -- - - - - --- *-- - - - - ------ - ----- - ----- - - -- Reported Actual NRC NRC-742 Depl/Prod Calculated % Difference Period 1-6/74 u . 233,222 232,209 - U-235 122,000 121,917 - Pu 59,691 56,,859 - /74 u 424,500 405, 718 -:- U-235 190,746 201,126 + Pu 86,120 86,631 + /75 u 293,090 368,875 375,135 +l. 7 U-235 186,037 175,419 188,614 +7. 5 Pu 53,240 80,624 82,383 + /75 e u 424,500 430,500 427,645 . -0. 7 .U-235 190,74,006 207,920 + Pu . 86, 120 83, 130. 85,833 + Overall u 1,457,097 1,440,707 - U-235 681,171 719,577 + Pu 309,56, 706 + I -,*. *"" Attachment 1
- J.. *.
. _.......- . ....- Part 2. 790 (d) Information *
Part 2, 790 fdJ Inlorrn8.Hon e e e
- -
Qund-Cities 2
Repor-ted -- -
- --Actual-----
- -*- -- *NRc--* - ----- - - - - --- ---- -*------- --------- ----- NRC-742 Depl/Prod Calculated % Difference .Period 1-.6/74 u 447,630 467' 158 + U-235 234,600 249,853 + Pu 115,726 119,595 +.3. 3 7-12/74 u 400,710 404,213 + U-235 194,612 . 209,373 + Pu 91,839 95,743 + /75 u 80, 113 159,312 161, 79 +I. 6 U-235 73,615 83,350 86,999 + Pu 14,248 41,590 41,946 + /75 u 455,529 347,750 345,886 - e U-235 192,942 175,52,959 + Pu . 93,973 84,305 81,.693. - Overall u 1,355,402 . 1 379 055.. -:**-. ' . ',*.. . +l. 7 .U-235 688,08, 184* + Pu 333,460 338, 977 + *..
- Attachment 2
- -.. *..
. ;~ . ... *,...
- *Part 2, 790 (d) Inform'.l.tion
- .-..
- .
- .~
e Part 2.790(d) Information Dresden 2 _______________________ Rep_or.ted __ '--- ___ ActuaL ___________ NRC -- ----------- ----- ------- - ---- ------- Period 7/72-6/73 u U-235 Pu 7-12/73 u U-235 Pu 1-6/74 u U-23 Pu 7-12/74 u e U-235 .. Pu .1-6/75 u U-235 Pu 7-12/75 u U-235 Pu Overall u U-235 . Pu . - II::-*. NRC-742 Depl/Prod Calculated % Difference 950,050 572,244 347,956 436,868 234,340 . 114,008 446,090 220,836 80,752 214,595 98,347 .,,45,7_19 . 78,226 52,086 17 '908 - 475,717 241,571 115~45,375 41,815' 21,030. 2,603,695 . 1,409, 153 724,916 964,327 605,926 332,183 468,967 255,193 114, 294 418,051 214,395 85, 372 ... 218, 460 112, 913 . 46;*828 83,368 46,696 22,418 479,25 : 253,860 110,596 '2,632,425 *. 1,488, 983.... 711,691 - . *.*'. .
- .'.
Attachment 3 .. *.:.: -~.,. .. _.....,,.
- ,.. _
Part 2. 790 (d) Information _,, ___ ;, +l. 5 +.5 +7. 3 + +o.o * -.9 + + '+1 +2.*4 + +IL + + +. 2.. + + ' -:-.***. .. _.:,*. ...
. *,. ~ '..... Attachment 4 '.o'*. 'Part 2. 790 (d). Inforru:ition }}