IR 05000219/1988008

Mgt Meeting Rept 50-219/88-08 on 880308.Major Areas Discussed:Licensee Activities Re NRC Bulletins 79-02 & 79-14.Licensee Presentation Encl

ML20153D855
Person / Time
Site:	Oyster Creek
Issue date:	04/29/1988
From:	Chaudhary S, Strosnider J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION I)
To:
Shared Package
ML20153D829	List: IR 05000219/1988008 ML20153D826
References
50-219-88-08-MM, 50-219-88-8-MM, IEB-79-02, IEB-79-14, IEB-79-2, NUDOCS 8805090307
Download: ML20153D855 (14)

Text

. . .

,

.

U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 1

REGION I

Meeting Report N /88-08 Docket N License No.

'

OPR-16 Licensee

GPU Nuclear Corporation Oyster Creek Nuclear Generating Station P. O. Box 388 Forked River, NJ 08731 Facility Name: Oyster _ Creek Generatiiig Sta+. ion Meeting At: NRC Region I Office, King of Prussia, PA Meeting Conducted: March 8, 1988 Inspector: -

K- h 19 I

. K. Chaudhary, Serfior Reactor Engineer ~ date Approud by: K b b A-

. R. Strosnider( Chief, MPS, EB, DRS

//UN

' date P

Meeting Summary: The subject of the meeting was licensee activities related to NRC Bulletins 79-02 and 79-1 o307 880503 PDR ADOCK 05000219 Q DCD

_

-

- s

. .

'

M:r ,

,

DETAILS 1.0 Meeting Attendees GPU - Nuclear Corporation D. K. Croneberger, Director, Engineering Services M. W. Laggart, Manager, BWR Licensing Y. Nagai, BWR Licensing A. P. Rochino, Manager, Engineering Mechanics J. Rogers, Senior Licensing Engineer R. Zak, Senior Licensing Engineer U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission H. Ashar, Senior Structural Engineer, NRR L. H. Bettenhausen, Chief, Projects Branch 1, RI S. K. Chaudhary, Senior Reactor Engineer, RI C. J. Cowgill, Chief, Reactor Projects Section 1A, RI A. W. Dromerick, Licensing Project Manager, NRR

'J. P. Durr, Chief. Engineering Branch, RI S. Hou, Senior Mechanical Engineer, NRR Kamal Manoly, Technical Assistant, DEST, N99 J. E. Richardson, Acting Deputy Diretor, DRS, RI J. R. Strosnider, Chief, Materials & Processes Section, RI 2.0 Purpose and Scope of the Meeting The meeting was convened at the request of the licensee to discuss the stat.us of the licensee's actions / plans and sc'iedules for work pursuant to IE Bulle. tins 79-02 and 79-1 The licensee presented to the NRC staff the status of the bulletin followup efforts, and commitments the licensee had made in 1985 in response to the NRC inspection finding The NRC staff reviewed the projected schedule, and discussed the technical bases of licensee's evaluations of pipe support reanalysis and modifications efforts. The NRC staff informed the licensee that detailed technical review of the program and schedule for adequacy would be performed in later NRC inspection A summary of the licensee's presentation is attached with this report as Attachment _

.

..

IEBULLETIN79-02/14 REVIEW

GPUNUCLEARl0YSTERCREEKPLANT March19888,MJ +

7 - s>

Ma#q/t u s e -os

'

INTRODUCTION 0 CEOLOGYOfIEB79-02/14 0 STATUSOfCOMMITHENTS STATUSOfFIELDACTIVITIES ,

o SUPPORTH00lflCAT10N 0 BASEPLATEINSPECTION FLOORRESPONSESPECTRA o H0TIVATION I

o SSIMETW000 LOGY 0 STATUSlRESULTS o INTERACTIONSWITHNRR

l

_

'

.-

.

RESUMPTIONOfTEBULLETIN79-14l02 EVALUATIONFOR0.C.IN1985 0 IEINSPECTION85-14CONDUCTEDSYREGIONI,MAY14-17,1985 00 INADEQUATE DOCUMENTATION Of ORIGINAL 1979/80 EFFO 00 PROCECURESlINSTRUCTIONS RELATED TO ORIGINAL 1979/80 Eff0RTWERENOTCONTROLLEDINACCORDANCEWITH ORIGINALQAPLAN o SEVERALINTERACTIONSWITHREGIONIIN1985-1986 REGARDINGSCOPE,STATUSANDSCHEDULEOfREEVALUATION 00 PIPINGANALYSISANDPIPESUPPORTCRITERIACONCURRED WITHREGIONI o GPUNCOMMITMENTTOREGIONI 00 COMPLETEINSEECTIONS,REAWALYSIS, DESIGN l VERIFICATIONSANDM00lflCATIONSBYENDOf12R l

'

<

A i

'

/ -.

I

,

-

'  :

'

'

. 79-14 SUPPORT UPGRADE 3 i STATUS AS OF MARCH 1.1988 l f /

SATSFED DESIGN W/O MUOf KX10N are .

l i

-

' '

,

,

69.33:

,. s.

l '

_%' O ". *

MOD 9TD DUW.'G ,

, .

,

z~ '

,s " ".

,- 1986 & 1987

l

~

. . 7.2 :.

~ '

l' <

r,

,l l , _- .

'N  ? DLCNATED CR CK AS-6 BASED  :

7D BC AfDTfD \ -,.N:27 N A N R.CC N 4 6 6 IN 1988 'N Y YO

\

l l

l yy & l'

4.1. .

, 16.S$' -- .:.: ',~~

~ ~ ~ *

.i EXFTCTED RED'.C!]CN DLE TO l .

'

.

A%WD SPECivA REANA!NSS 20 '

~ OfE?ift I EoSN uErddl 5/ T disE'

..- .-_ . ... .- _

- - _ - . - _ _  % T

- - - - - - - - - - --- -- _ -- ---- --- _ _ - - .

..

\ '-

79-02 ANCHORAGE INSPECTIONS

. STATUS AS OF MARCH 1,1988

!

I iis ' - , , f i , /, > '

i

,

DOCLAENTADON ACCEPTABW W/O ADD {DONAL NSPECTION 392

,

, 56.3 % {

> ,,/

-

fl!!I,i ,1f9II'l!!il!!

.

t

,

y-T}i QQ;'gp

.s y ; : ~;

.

2 .

_.t.j!. --- -- --

-_-_. .I

-

...

ggg g F& :' =Hq ' /'

,

pggg

' *

s y/

i -

g g 70 ge-W

,

N gr -D SN g / . . - - - .

' ,

-

y DiSPOSIDONED IN  :

16.4 % ' Ol 91 .

$

'

13.1 % .l

..

.

.

.

REASONSFORGENERATING NEWFMRRESPONSESPECTRA FOR *

CONfLICTINGSEISMICCRITERIAONSEVERALPROJECTS-NEEDFORUNIFICATION

"

UNAMPLIFIEDGROUNDRESPONSESPECTRAFORPIPINGANALYSE$lPIPE SUPPORTEVALUATION

"

SEPAMPLIflE0FMRRESPONSESPECTRAFORBLOCKWALLS(IE8 80-ll)lES$fBUILDINGDESIGN/SPENTFUELP00LRACKM005,SEPSEISMIC EVALUATIONS,ET "

. UR$l8LUME1986AMPLIFIEDSPECTRAFORRECIRCPIPEANALYSES

'

SAVINGSINMAN-REMEXPOSUREFORMODIflCATION/INSPECTIONSINSIDEDRY

'

REDUCTION 0FOVERALLCONSTRUCTIONCOST

'

TAKE ADVANTAGE Of EXISTING "STATE Of THE ART" SEI5MIC HETW000 LO COMPUTATIONALTECHNIQUES l

l 4314H/0306H/6

- . - -

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _____ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - - _ _ - _ _ - _ - _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ .

- -

- ~

' ___

.

.

,

,

'

i .

-

!

l j INPUT

f TIME HISTORY I

.

BUILDING l

MATHEMATICAL > '

'

MODELS l v ~

i

! RESULTS

'

m

'

SSI COUPLED &

'

SSI m FRS AT

'

! MODEL ANALYSIS DIFi ERENT

ELEVATIONS

!

!

.

i SOIL FINITE 3 I

ELEMENT MODEL

!

i

l Overall Approach to Develop N:;7: Spectra i

!

L

_

J i

URS Corporation

_

MAKING TECIINOl OGY WORK *

i uns nri on44 43

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

. .

.

.

r ,

s w e SSI MODEL i  !

?  ?

Asza Seene Aasa Somo'v*

Coa'9 We Free Feep Assa Soma. .

g ,

Sese or 1=.c.,.

s

... a j d J

i

! ,,.4 m  ; ,.

m , , - ,

! .

.

: =. }

8 . . . .. . . . . . ..t:y . . . ca ., .  :

!.............e> '

i 4 8 l  !

--

s** "I., ... _....!

!  ; _

! i l j j "n

!  ! 8

8 I

N..mmm, I

'

M M' M i

seu h e Base %ea Sam. henae l i *

.!

• .

I (  ! Acz.1;es m ,1, Asse See: .e Base W ee j Bus assee g

s I 3

!........

4.................D.................p /

, . .q. . .cy s' .M

, , . . . .,,_i--.+_,...

l l

Schematic Representation of Soil-Structure inMraction Analysis Using Finite Element Model

.

,

l

.

l i L  ;

i

'

URS Corporation MAKING TECHNOLOGY WORK "

_ - ._

,, e >

l l

t U AS SF1004414

. . _ . - - - .. _m , . . . _ . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . . _ _ ~ . _ _ . _ . _ . . . . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ , _ . . _ . ._ ,. - . , , . . _ - . - . . . -

,

t

-

,

F

,

El.156* 9*, 7 Number of Nodes = 287 Reador Wq Number of Soll Elements = 137 t, Number of Beam Elements =43 O

El.107 91 i C rywen

,Mi Reactor El. 93' 5' , ,

'NWP r Shield Wall l El. 82' 9' , . X qi 4 , 4>

"

q i l

-

EMrgy Transmitting a> ,,

Boundaries Sirmlating Schematic of Semi infinite Soi! Layers

Mg q, Upper Tier Steel q

' '

di Schematic of

,f, - .. 'p O Lower Tier Steet

, , ;,

4>

'

>

l dY g

_

/ y-# :

Vis:cus Dashpots Simu'ating 3 D Effects (Typ.)

.

l V i

@ D D @ @ Y D D D1 - Vis:cus Dashpets

'

9 @ 10' = 90* m SirMaM; Visco4fastic

"

Hatfspa:e l Superflush SSI Model, l Oyster Creek Reactor Building

_

URS Corporation

'

, MAKING TECHNOLOGY WORK *

l l uns sri oon ts

,

'

. ,

. . .

AMPLIFIE0FLOORSPECTRAREANALYSIS STATUS l

'

GENERATEDS0llSTRUCTUREINTERACTIONMODEL

'

GENERATEDFLOORRESPONSESPECTRA-SSE&OBE

'

10CFR50.59SAFETYEVALUATIONJUSTIFYINGUSEFOROYSTERCREEKINPROGRESS

EANALYlED ALL AFFECTED PIPING MODELS MD GENERATED SUPPORT REACT

REANALYZEDALLAFFECTEDSUPPORTS(FIRSTFASS)FOROBElSSEALLOWABLES RESULTS

'

PIPINGSTRESSLEVELREDUCEDSOMEWWAT

'

SEISMICREACTIONLOADSGENERALLYDECREASED

'

REACTIONLOADSFROMPIPINGATTACHEDTOTWETORUSANDTHEUPPERELEVATIO OFTHEREACTORVESSELWAVEINCREASEDWWICHRESUl.TEDINAFEWADDITIONA UPGRADES

'

APPR0X.20 FEWER (NET)UPGRADESAREREQUIRED

THEREDUCTION0FWORKISNOTASGREATASGPUNHADANTICIPATED

THEANALYSISHASABETTERTECHNICALBASIS 4314H/0306H/7

-

[

. 1

-

. 1

,

INTERACTIONSWITHNRC(NRR) l ONNEWSEISMICMETHODOLOGYFOR GENERATINGFLOORRESPONSESPECTRA o MEETINGSONJULY7,1987ANDSEPTEMBER3,1987 00 GPUNPRESENTEDTECHNICALDETAILSOFNEWMETHODOLOGY, I.E., DETAILSOFSUPERFLUSHCOMPUTERCODE MATHEMATICAllFINITEELEMENTMODELSOFBUILDINGS ANDS 0ILS 00 GPUNPROPOSEDUTILIlING0.165GZPAGROUNDRESPONSE SPECTRAAPPROVE0BYNRCFORUSEIN0.C.SYSTERATIC EVALUATIONPROGRAM(SEP)

0 NRCLETTER0FOCTOBER27,1987T0GPUN 00 ACCEPTED AB0VE %0 POSED GRCUND RESPONSE SPECTRA SUBJECTT0lHf;EECON0!I!ONS $$1ANALYSISWITHCOMPATIBLEINPUTTIME HISTORIESPERAPPLICABLESRPCRITERIA RESPONSESTOADDITIONALINF0REQUESTBYNRCBE SATISFACTORY AUDIT RESULTS (N0VEMBER 17/18,1987) ARE ACCEPTABLE

% .- -- - - -

. -

INTERACTIONSWITHNRL(NRR)-(CONTINUED)

AUDITOfGPUN/URSBLUME, NOVEMBER 17/18,1987

"

ADDITIONALINf0lACTIONITEMSWEREIDENTIFIEDBYNRCTOSUPPORT FINALAPPROVAL

"

WRCPERSONNELANDTHEIRCONSULTANT(BNL)WEREIMPRESSEDWITH ANALYSESlRESULTS

"

AfTERCONSULTATIONWITHRESTOfNRRSTAff,ADDITIONALCONDITIONS AND LIMITATIONS HAVE BEEN IMPOSED ON SSITHESE EFFOR ARE STATED IN DECEMBER 16, 1987 LETTER. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION (7 ITEMS)

RE@ IRED BY NRR staff WERE IDENTIFIED BY THIS LETTE STATUS Of INf0lACTION ITEMS RE@lRED BY NRR

"

RESPONSES T0 6 Of 7 ITEMS FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION HAVE BE SUBHITTEDTONRRONFEBRUARY26,198 "

SEVENTHITEMTOBESUBMITTEDINMARCH1988.

4314H/0306H/4

-

.

'

INTERACTIONSWINRC(NRR)-(CONTINUED)

MEETINGONDECEMBER21,1987

"

NRCHASGIVENGPUNTHREEOPTIONS OPTIONlA USE0.165gSEPGROUNDRESPONSESPECTRAANDEXISTINGCONSERHIVE SSIMETH0C0 LOGY OPTION 1B USE0.165gSEPGROUNDRESPONSESPECTRAANDNEWSEISHICMETH0001.0GY, BUTLIMITMAX.REDUCTIONINBASEMATTO251 OPTION 2 GENERATESITESPECIFICGROUNDH0 TION,USENEWSEISMICMETHODOLOGY, WITHN0l.IMITATIONFORREDUCTIONATBASEMAT

"

PRESENTANDFUTURECONCERNS8YNRCPERTAININGTOOPTION2HUSTBE RES0t.VEDSUCCES$ FULLY

"

. ACCEPTING CRITERIA FOR OPil0N 2 NOT GEAR AND flNAl.IZED (N REVISIONINPROCES$).

.

~

!

!

4314H/0306H/5

. - -. . - - - _ -