ML19346A227

Responses to B Stamiris Discovery Requests Re Bldg Const,Per ASLB 810508 Order.Affidavits & Certificate of Svc Encl. Related Correspondence

ML19346A227
Person / Time
Site:	Midland
Issue date:	05/27/1981
From:	Boos A, Swanberg N CONSUMERS ENERGY CO. (FORMERLY CONSUMERS POWER CO.)
To:	Stamiris B AFFILIATION NOT ASSIGNED
References
ISSUANCES-OL, ISSUANCES-OM, NUDOCS 8106050430
Download: ML19346A227 (7)

Text

.

. 6 YlI15 . ESPONDENCE

/ 4 je DOCM '[ UNITED STATES OF AMERICA I* USNFC -

JUN 0- ' -. r -

i. ..'i..,.e 1

M*-lj Nif0 LEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

". s. !aetet 4*BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

i. '

, > of Docket Nos. 50-329-0M O' e 50-330-0M T CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY -

50-329-OL

.50-330-OL (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2)

RESPONSES TO STAMIRIS' DISCOVERY REQUESTS PURSUANT TO BOARD ORDER OF MAY 8, 1981 .

Pursuant to the Order of the ASI.S dated May 8,1981, Consumers Power Company hereby provides the following responses to interrogatories of Bar Stamiris: . D/ 'A Questions 5(b) - 5(e) (January 26, 1981 Recuest)

[9 fi n 63\ "92h -

C 01 ic5 J -

b 5(b) On what basis was the decision to remove and replace the~ fauMy'$Mu,,w" c :ost U fill under the administration building made? ' 9. , .d .

a,N 4

The basis for the decision was the status of building const tQQ \

in this area at the time the problem was discovered. No construction

above the grade beam and footings had been completed. The most . . -.

(

economical approach was to remcve and replace the grade beam and the supporting fill. -

l l

5(c) Who made this 5(b) decision?

The decision was made by the Bechtel' Project Superintendent. (Joel Newgen) 5(d) When was this (5b) decision made?

The decision was made in September, 1977.

5(e) Describe and explain any alternative corrective actions ever considered and rejected for the Administration Building, if such considerations were made. -

05o3 No alternative corrective actions were considered. I 8106050VJb g I

Question 13 (April 17. 1981 Request Re sponse During the period of December 6,1979 through April 30, 1980, concrete work on the Diesel Generator Building included placement of the following:

b" removable roof plugs for bays-2, 3 and 4, mud mats and base slabs for the stairtovers and not h entries, stairs and slabs for the north entryways and the parapet wall for the west stairtover.

Dates for the concrete pours were as follows:

December 6,1979 - removable roof plug bay 2 December 10, 1979 - removable roof plug bays 3 and 4 January 30, 1980 - mud mats for stairtowers February 13, 1980 - base slabs for stairtovers February 13, 1980 - mud mats, north entries bays 2 and 3 February 26, 1980 - stairs and slabs for all north entryways -

February 26,1980 - parapet wall for west stairtower ,

i i

No work was performed by way of excavation or sealing of cracks during , ,, _ ___

i this period.

l The " grade slabs" mentioned (in Applicant's Response dated March 30, 1981) refer to the conertee slabs at elevation 634'-6" in all four bays of the building. Concrete ' work on these slabs includes mud mats, structural slabs, and underlying ductbanks. The curbs referenced are the pads for motor control centers in all four bays.

The NRC was advised of Applicant's intent to resume construction on the diesel generator building in MCAR 24, Interim Report #7, p. 14, attached to a letter from Stephen Howell to James ".appler dated September 5,1979, v, r-w- . ,- , -%., -p , ,-n----.7,-..-,,,wm,yv, -+,.g-w--ww,.-,- .-,%._,.- ,--.7y, , - , . , - . .w..,,,-,m.7 ,,m-+-.-,e,.-w.,w,-.- m -et.,. , ...mm,.,- , - ..

and in MCAR 24 Interim Report #8, p. 3, attached to a letter from Howell to Keppler dated November 2,.1979. In addition, the NRC had a full time inspector assigned to the Midland site during the time period in question. .5 No work related directly or indirectly to soils or soil settlement was i

performed during the time peric4 in question.

-e e W 6e ses O

p-w-- ,s--,- .--w, .--w,--e..,-,-- ,,.. .---- e -,,--,-.ve.. m. y e----~...-.--,----e

~- --. . y ,,. ,,y- , ,---, v, e .e,, .--w..__ y. -

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION In the Maccer of Docket Nos. 50-329-Oh 50-330-0M M.

CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY 50-329-OL 50-330-OL (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2

' CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of Responses to Stamiris' Discovery Requests Pursuant to Board Order of May 8, 1981, with attached affidavics, were i

served upon the following persons by depositing copies thereof in the United Stated Mail, first class postag;e on this 27th day of May,1981. -

Frank J. Kalley, Esq. Michael Miller, Esq. -

Attorney General of the Isham, Lincuin & Beale State of Michigan one First National Plaza Stewarr E. Freanas, Esq. Suite 4200 Assistant Attorney General Chicago, niinois _60603 i Gregory T. Taylor, Esq. @ ~

l Assistant Attorney General;. g Mr. Steve Gadler l 720 Law Building 2120 Carter Avenue Lansing, Michigan 489 C0CKETED St. Paul, Minnesota $5108 usNC .

~3 Myron M. Cherry, Esq. ik 1 N ' - D. F. Judd, Sr. Projec: Manager

. One I3M Plaza 'g $@gN g g gy '

Babcock & Wilcox Suite 4501 8 d'f,; ,,3 3:r,2:e P. O. Box 1260 Chicago, Illinois 606 ,, Y;-e Lynchburg, Virginia 24505 c &

Mr. Wendell E. Marshall y to Atomic Safety & Licensing Appeal 3 card RFD 10 U. S. Nuclear Regula.ory Commission Midland, Michigan 48640 Washington, D. C. 20555 Charles 3echhoafer, Esq. Mr. C. R. Stephaus, Chief Atomic Saf ety & Licensing Scard Par el Docketing & Service Section l "U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm. Office of the Secretary U. S. Nuclear Rsgulatory Ccamission l Dr. Frederick P. Ccvan Washington, D. C. 20555 6152 N. Verde Trail Apt. B-125 3cca Raton, Florida 33433 l

Lester Kornbli-3 , Jr.

Atomic Safetf cm Licensing Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washing:on, D.' C. 20535

.5 Ralph S. Decker, Esq. ._

Route 4, Box 1900 canhridge, Maryland 21613 Ms. Mary Sinclair 5711 Summaarset Street .

Midland, Michigan 48640 W4114== D. Paton, Esq.

CouN el for the NRC Staff U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Cossaission "as* 4 ton, D. C. 20555 Atomic Safsty & Licensing Board Panel U. S. Nuciaar Regulatory Consaission Washington, D. C. 20555 3arbara Stamiris 5795 North River Road Route 3 Preeland, Michigan 48623 >

gg . -

- James E. Brunner l Consumers Power Cecipany 212 West Michigan Avenue --

Jackson, Michigan 49201 l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l l

l l

i

,,a-.,. . ,~ ...e,-, . , . < , .,-n., , . , . ,

l

. >. l UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of DOCKET NOS. 50-329-0M CONSUMERS POWER CCMPANY ) 50-330-0M

, ) 50-329-0L

(Midland, Units 1 and 2) ) 50-329-0L

)

)

AFFIDAVIT OF NEAL SWANBERG .

Neal Svanberg, being duly sworn, deposes and says that he is employed by Becatel Associates Professional Corporation, as an Assistant Project Engineer; that he is responsible for providing additional answers ,

to Barbra Stamiris interrogatory to Consumers Power Company Number 13; and that to the best of his knowledge and belief the above information and the answers to the above interrogatories are true and correct.

i . ... _.

Neal Swanberg Subscribed and sworn to before me this .) ( day of "/ > e ,1981

/

, .d. d , i_ _4 Notary Public, Washtenaw County, Michigan 1 .

My Commission Expires: */'a.x ../- 30 NJh Ezve.d!A.TROSS N0tM.! ?'.T3*.!0, WA.m,,v co,,ng.,

C C0Y, C S:05 ?.12* m 507,30,ggeg

UNITED STATE OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD

~

In the Matter of ) ., .

DOCKET NOS. 50-329-0M ~

CDNSUMERS POWER COMPANY ) 50-330-0M

) 50-329-OL

) 50-329-OL

)

(Midland, Units 1 and 2) .)

)

County of Washtenaw)

)ss State of Michigan )

AFFIDAVIT OF ALAN BOOS Alan Boos, being duly swcrn, deposes and says that he is an Assistant Project Manager, Midland Project, Bechtel Power Corporation; that he ,

is prir.arily responsible for providing the answers to Barbara Stamiris' Interrogatories So, c, d, and e to Consumers Power Company; and that to the best of his knowledge and belief the above information and the answer to the above interrogatory is true and correct. ,

2 -

V Alan Boos Subscribed and sworn. to before me this JB day of Mea . ,1981.

/

&_ h A'W Notary Public, Washtenaw County, Michigan My Commission Expires: h h_,, u J d h jf[ k

~

Es. .*.T 1755033 30 n ?.! P';3:.:0, h .e 1N 00.,r r MI 00M C33 03 II?I3.IS :;07.30,1982

.. . . . . -, - . . - . . . .-._., . - - -- , ,. ,.-_ - .. . - . _ . - - - . . . - . . - _ - . . , . - - . . . . - - ,