Corrections to Pb Herr May 1979 Testimony in Support of Contention 12.Corrections Relate to Max Risk to Population & Reflect Population Data Analysis Performed After Preparation of Testimony.Certificate of Svc EnclML19208C327 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
05000471 |
---|
Issue date: |
08/22/1979 |
---|
From: |
Burt L MASSACHUSETTS, COMMONWEALTH OF |
---|
To: |
|
---|
References |
---|
NUDOCS 7909260068 |
Download: ML19208C327 (4) |
|
|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20039B5361981-12-16016 December 1981 Response to ASLB 811210 Order.Lists Preconst Activities Taken at Proposed Site.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20058M0481981-11-16016 November 1981 Order Granting Partial Initial Decision Vacated on Ground of Mootness ML20011A6091981-10-23023 October 1981 Motion for ASLB Order Allowing Withdrawal of Application & Terminating Adjudicatory Proceeding Before Aslb. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20010H2851981-09-14014 September 1981 Detailed Statement of Commonwealth of Ma TMI-related Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010H2401981-09-14014 September 1981 Confirms That ASLB Need Not Rule on Motion for Protective Order Re Commonwealth of Ma 810814 Notice of Deposition. Applicant Production of Documents Obviates Need for Deposition.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010H2431981-09-14014 September 1981 Motion to Compel Answers to First Set of Interrogatories Directed to Util Re TMI Issues.Certificate of Svc Encl. Related Correspondence ML20010H2831981-09-14014 September 1981 Conditional Notice of Withdrawal of Listed Portions of 810821 Emergency Planning Contentions.Withdrawal Conditional on Incorporation of Revised Evaucation Study in Psar.W/ Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20005B8851981-09-0909 September 1981 Errata Sheet to Commonwealth of Ma 810824 Request for Clarification/Motions for Extension of Time for Filing Direct Testimony on Emergency Planning & Ruling Re Rebuttal Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010G5081981-09-0808 September 1981 Response to Commonwealth of Ma First Set of Document Requests Re TMI Issues.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005B9081981-09-0202 September 1981 Suppl to Commonwealth of Ma 810824 Motion to Extend Time for Filing Direct Testimony on Emergency Planning.Addl Listed Events,Which Occurred Since Motion Filed,Lend Support to Motion.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005B9251981-09-0101 September 1981 Response to NRC First Set of Interrogatories Directed to Commonwealth of Ma.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20005B9331981-08-28028 August 1981 Supplemental Response to First Set of Interrogatories Re Emergency Planning in Compliance W/Aslb 810820 Ruling on Discovery.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20005B9301981-08-28028 August 1981 Response to First Set of Interrogatories Re TMI Issues, App B to NUREG-0718.Related Correspondence ML20010C9041981-08-17017 August 1981 Responses to Applicants' Interrogatories Re Emergency Planning & TMI-2 Related Issues.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010D1631981-08-17017 August 1981 Request for Prehearing Conference to Be Held on 810901 & for Rescheduling of Argument on Exceptions to Partial Initial Decision.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20010D1721981-08-14014 August 1981 Response to Commonwealth of Ma Second Set of Interrogatories Re Emergency Planning.Protective Order Re Production & Identification of Repts Prepared by Hmm Associates Should Be Granted.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010C8401981-08-14014 August 1981 Notice of 810904 Depositions of Rh Cunningham,Rj Merlino & Util Employee W/Described Knowledge.Existence,Methodology & Results of Studies Re 10 & 30-mile Evacuation Radius to Be Addressed.W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20010C8451981-08-14014 August 1981 Notice of 810902 Deposition of Persons Designated by NRC to Have Knowledge of Methodology & Results of Analysis of Accident Consequences & Feasibility of Protective Actions. W/Certificate of Svc.Related Correspondence ML20010C8521981-08-14014 August 1981 Motion for Order to Compel Production of Documents Per Commonwealth of Ma 810701 First Set of Requests.Util Response Inconsistent W/Proper Purpose & Scope of Discovery. Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010C5951981-08-14014 August 1981 Request for Production of Documents Directed to NRC Re TMI-2.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010C5801981-08-14014 August 1981 Interrogatories Directed to NRC Re Emergency Planning & TMI-2 Related Issues.Related Correspondence ML20010C4411981-08-12012 August 1981 Motion Requesting That Scheduled Aslab 810901 Oral Argument & ASLB 810901 Prehearing Conference Not Be Held on Same Day. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20010C2911981-08-10010 August 1981 Answer in Opposition to Applicant 810804 Motion for Protective Order.Applicant Arguments Are Absurd & Indicative of Lack of Concern for Public Safety.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20010C2981981-08-10010 August 1981 Motion to Reconsider ASLB 810803 Denial of State of Il 810715 Motion to Modify Prehearing Conference Order.Stated Grounds for Denial Are Inaccurate.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20010B2031981-08-0505 August 1981 Second Set of Requests for Production of Documents Directed to NRC Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010B3071981-08-0505 August 1981 Second Set of Interrogatories Directed to NRC Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010A8951981-08-0404 August 1981 Motion for Protective Order & Answer to Commonwealth of Ma Motion to Compel.Motion Should Be Denied.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010A8841981-08-0404 August 1981 Motion to Amend ASLB 810702 Prehearing Conference Order, Changing Commencement Date of Hearing on Emergency Planning Issues from 811009 to 13.Applicant Counsel Has Prior Engagement.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20010A8861981-08-0404 August 1981 Second Set of Interrogatories Directed to Util Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20010A8881981-08-0404 August 1981 Second Set of Requests for Production of Documents Directed to Util Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl. Related Correspondence ML20010A8811981-08-0404 August 1981 Response to Commonwealth of Ma Request for Production of Documents (First Set).Objects to Certain Requests as Overly Broad & Burdensome.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20009F8361981-07-27027 July 1981 Interrogatories Directed to Commonwealth of Ma Re Emergency Planning & TMI-related Issues.Certificate of Svc Encl. Related Correspondence ML20009F8511981-07-24024 July 1981 Application for Subpoena Directed to Argonne National Computer Ctr to Produce Any Software or Document Containing or Describing Mod or Improvement to Crac Code Since Development.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20009F8481981-07-24024 July 1981 Answer Opposing NRC 810710 & 15 Motions for Protective Order.Nrc Misperceived & Mischaracterized Nature of Questions.Commonwealth of Ma Is Requesting NRC Position on Issues,Not Info on Issues ML20009F8451981-07-24024 July 1981 Motion to Compel Answers to Commonwealth of Ma First Set of Interrogatories Directed to Util Re Emergency Planning. Interrogatories Are Relevant to Contentions.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005B9541981-07-20020 July 1981 Response to Commonwealth of Ma First Set of Interrogatories Re Emergency Planning.Prof Qualifications & Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20009D0721981-07-15015 July 1981 Motion to Modify Prehearing Conference Order.Order Should Reflect Commonwealth Objection to Proceed W/Conference W/O Court Reporter,Request for 2-month Discovery Period & Request to Change Date to 810831.W/Certificate of Svc ML20005B4011981-07-0101 July 1981 First Set of Requests for Documents Directed to NRC Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20005B4001981-07-0101 July 1981 First Set of Interrogatories Directed to Applicant Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20005B3981981-07-0101 July 1981 First Set of Interrogatories Directed to NRC Re Emergency Planning.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20005B3791981-07-0101 July 1981 First Set of Requests for Production of Documents Re Emergency Planning Directed to Util.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence ML20005A4071981-06-17017 June 1981 Answer of a & M Cleeton Supporting Applicant Motion for Order Scheduling Further Proceedings Re Emergency Planning. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20005A4361981-06-17017 June 1981 Brief in Opposition to Exceptions Taken by Intervenors Ma Wildlife Federation,Commonwealth of Ma & AR & MW Cleeton Re ASLB 810202 Partial Initial decision,LBP-81-3.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20126M3831981-06-0909 June 1981 Answer Supporting Applicant Motion for Order Scheduling Proceedings on Emergency Planning,W/Suggested Revisions to Proposed Schedule.First Prehearing Conference & Opening of Discovery Would Be on 810622.W/Certificate of Svc ML20004E7901981-06-0404 June 1981 Motion for Order Scheduling Further Proceedings on Emergency Planning as Listed.First Prehearing Conference & Opening of Discovery Should Be on 810622,w/discovery Closing on 810722.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20004B6071981-05-21021 May 1981 Brief Supporting Exceptions to ASLB Partial Initial Decision Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law on All Matters Except Emergency Planning & TMI-2 Related Issues.Constitutionality of Regulation Should Be Decided.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20004B6051981-05-21021 May 1981 Motion for Leave to File Brief in Support of Exceptions Out of time.Two-day Delay Was Caused by Sudden Illness of Secretary.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20004B6941981-05-19019 May 1981 Exceptions to ASLB Partial Initial Decision.Aslb Erred in Considering Benefits Vs Costs Before Evidentiary Hearings on Emergency Planning & TMI-2 Issues.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20004B6481981-05-19019 May 1981 Brief in Support of Exceptions 1,2 & 6 to ASLB 810202 Partial Initial Decisions.Decision Should Be Reversed & Matter Remanded for Further Considerations of Class 9 Accidents.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20003D2731981-03-12012 March 1981 Joint Motion for Consolidation of Date for Filing Briefs & Extension Until 810519 to File Briefs.Good Cause for Commonwealth of Ma Is Necessity for Thorough Review,Counsel Illness & Litigation Obligations.Certificate of Svc Encl 1981-09-09
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20136B4401979-08-27027 August 1979 Transcript of 790827 Hearing in Plymouth,Ma. Pp 11,353-11,490 ML19208C3271979-08-22022 August 1979 Corrections to Pb Herr May 1979 Testimony in Support of Contention 12.Corrections Relate to Max Risk to Population & Reflect Population Data Analysis Performed After Preparation of Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML19225B2281979-06-29029 June 1979 Revised Supplemental Testimony on Need for Facilty.Penalist: Bh Weiner,Pa Legrow,Dv Bourcier,Aw Barstow,Fc Turner, N Godley,& D Hanna.Commonwealth of Ma Contention 6, Cleeton Contention H,& Ford Contention M.Documentation Encl ML20136B3581979-06-29029 June 1979 Testimony on Behalf of Ma Governor'S Ofc of Energy Resources Re Need for Facility ML20136B3521979-06-29029 June 1979 Testimony on Behalf of Ma Governor'S Ofc of Energy Resources Re Need for Facility ML19259C4591979-05-21021 May 1979 Boston Edison Co Supplemental Testimony Re Need for Facility.Testimony Provided by Bh Weiner,Pa Legrow,Dv Bourcier,Aw Barstow,Fc Turner,N Godley & D Hanna.Supporting Documentation Encl ML19261E2841979-05-14014 May 1979 Testimony of Pb Herr Re Population Density & Other Site Characteristics in Support of State of Ma Contention 12. Alternative of Locating Facility at More Suitable Site Not Considered by Applicant.Resume & Certificate of Svc Encl ML19270H2641979-05-11011 May 1979 Direct Testimony on Financial Qualifications of Intervenor State of Ma Contention 5.Delineates RM Kelmon Role in License Application & General Financial Duties.Elaborates on Tj May Financial Responsibilities ML19270H2601979-05-11011 May 1979 Direct Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re Alternative Sites.Elaborates on Util Siting Study for Long Range Generating Capacity Expansion ML19269E5041979-05-0909 May 1979 Testimony on Behalf of State of Ma Re Ability of Util to Finance Share of Facility.Financial Analysis,Transcript of Util Board of Directors Meeting,Addl Testimony & Certificate of Svc Encl 1979-08-27
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20136B4401979-08-27027 August 1979 Transcript of 790827 Hearing in Plymouth,Ma. Pp 11,353-11,490 ML19208C3271979-08-22022 August 1979 Corrections to Pb Herr May 1979 Testimony in Support of Contention 12.Corrections Relate to Max Risk to Population & Reflect Population Data Analysis Performed After Preparation of Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML19225B2281979-06-29029 June 1979 Revised Supplemental Testimony on Need for Facilty.Penalist: Bh Weiner,Pa Legrow,Dv Bourcier,Aw Barstow,Fc Turner, N Godley,& D Hanna.Commonwealth of Ma Contention 6, Cleeton Contention H,& Ford Contention M.Documentation Encl ML20136B3581979-06-29029 June 1979 Testimony on Behalf of Ma Governor'S Ofc of Energy Resources Re Need for Facility ML20136B3521979-06-29029 June 1979 Testimony on Behalf of Ma Governor'S Ofc of Energy Resources Re Need for Facility ML19259C4591979-05-21021 May 1979 Boston Edison Co Supplemental Testimony Re Need for Facility.Testimony Provided by Bh Weiner,Pa Legrow,Dv Bourcier,Aw Barstow,Fc Turner,N Godley & D Hanna.Supporting Documentation Encl ML19261E2841979-05-14014 May 1979 Testimony of Pb Herr Re Population Density & Other Site Characteristics in Support of State of Ma Contention 12. Alternative of Locating Facility at More Suitable Site Not Considered by Applicant.Resume & Certificate of Svc Encl ML19270H2641979-05-11011 May 1979 Direct Testimony on Financial Qualifications of Intervenor State of Ma Contention 5.Delineates RM Kelmon Role in License Application & General Financial Duties.Elaborates on Tj May Financial Responsibilities ML19270H2601979-05-11011 May 1979 Direct Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re Alternative Sites.Elaborates on Util Siting Study for Long Range Generating Capacity Expansion ML19269E5041979-05-0909 May 1979 Testimony on Behalf of State of Ma Re Ability of Util to Finance Share of Facility.Financial Analysis,Transcript of Util Board of Directors Meeting,Addl Testimony & Certificate of Svc Encl 1979-08-27
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20136B4401979-08-27027 August 1979 Transcript of 790827 Hearing in Plymouth,Ma. Pp 11,353-11,490 ML19208C3271979-08-22022 August 1979 Corrections to Pb Herr May 1979 Testimony in Support of Contention 12.Corrections Relate to Max Risk to Population & Reflect Population Data Analysis Performed After Preparation of Testimony.Certificate of Svc Encl ML19225B2281979-06-29029 June 1979 Revised Supplemental Testimony on Need for Facilty.Penalist: Bh Weiner,Pa Legrow,Dv Bourcier,Aw Barstow,Fc Turner, N Godley,& D Hanna.Commonwealth of Ma Contention 6, Cleeton Contention H,& Ford Contention M.Documentation Encl ML20136B3581979-06-29029 June 1979 Testimony on Behalf of Ma Governor'S Ofc of Energy Resources Re Need for Facility ML20136B3521979-06-29029 June 1979 Testimony on Behalf of Ma Governor'S Ofc of Energy Resources Re Need for Facility ML19259C4591979-05-21021 May 1979 Boston Edison Co Supplemental Testimony Re Need for Facility.Testimony Provided by Bh Weiner,Pa Legrow,Dv Bourcier,Aw Barstow,Fc Turner,N Godley & D Hanna.Supporting Documentation Encl ML19261E2841979-05-14014 May 1979 Testimony of Pb Herr Re Population Density & Other Site Characteristics in Support of State of Ma Contention 12. Alternative of Locating Facility at More Suitable Site Not Considered by Applicant.Resume & Certificate of Svc Encl ML19270H2641979-05-11011 May 1979 Direct Testimony on Financial Qualifications of Intervenor State of Ma Contention 5.Delineates RM Kelmon Role in License Application & General Financial Duties.Elaborates on Tj May Financial Responsibilities ML19270H2601979-05-11011 May 1979 Direct Testimony on Behalf of Applicant Re Alternative Sites.Elaborates on Util Siting Study for Long Range Generating Capacity Expansion ML19269E5041979-05-0909 May 1979 Testimony on Behalf of State of Ma Re Ability of Util to Finance Share of Facility.Financial Analysis,Transcript of Util Board of Directors Meeting,Addl Testimony & Certificate of Svc Encl 1979-08-27
[Table view] |
Text
.
'
,. NRC PUBLIC DOCUMENT ROOM UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD 4
%
$~ s -
.
p
.k QC' 0:.
)
,N is
n, ,
,, &h.
In the Matter of: )
%^2
'
Yp '.# [f C
. / k
) s: , .
BOSTON EDISON COMPANY et al_.
~
(Pilgrim Nuclear Generating ) Docket No. 50-471 m i' Station, Unit 2) )
)
)
CORRECTIONS TO TESTIMONY OF PHILLIP B. HERR.
The following corrections should be made to the Testimony of Phillip B.-Herr submitted by Intervenor Common-wealth of Massachusetts in support of its'. Contention 12.
- 1. Page 8, line 7, delete the first and second sentences of the paragraph following "III.
MAXIMUM RISK TO POPULATION", and substitute:
"When in the site selection process a decision-maker is assessing the comparative risk resulting from a hypothetical major accident, a question of critical concern is what the worst consequences might be at each alternative site. In order to rationally evaluate alter-native sites, a decision-maker must be able to assess the most severe consequences which are reasonably likely following an accident at each site, measured by the max-imum, not average, number of people who might be exposed to risk."
- 2. Page 9, line 17: delete the last sentence in the first full paragraph, beginning with "If the objective" and substitute:
"If the objective of the decision-maker were to minimize maximum potential population at risk, or to avoid exceeding an acceptable threshold of population at risk, Site A is a far superior selection."
r
,A, (3 09:36099$ ,
_ _ _ . _ -
_~ __
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ ._ _
__ _
'
.
_2_
- 3. ,Page 17, line 5: delete the word " annual", and substitute " annular."
,
- 4. Page 20, line 18: delete the last sentence of the second "
paragraph, beginning with "A few natives may
, . . . , and substitute:
"A few natives may thread their way to Glen Charlie Road in Wareham, Head of the Bay Road in Bourne, or other by passing routes, but their numbers cannot be large."
- 5. Page 22, foctnote 11: delete " Table B" in tite second line from the bottom, and substitute " Table C".
The following corrections reflect further analysis of population data performed by Professor Herr subsequent to prepara-tion of his alternative sites testimony in May 1979.
- 1. Page 11, line 16: at the end of the third sentence appearing in the paragraph under "A. Temporal Anal-ysis", insert an asterisk (*) after the number "4,300. " and add reference to the following footnote:
- Analysis based upon the ' Pilgrim Station Environ-mental Report' (ER) as amended through May 20, 1974, suggests that in Zact peak 1990 population within five miles may be nearly 63,000 persons.
- 2. Page 12, line 7: insert an asterisk (*) after the word " summertime", and add reference to the following footnote:
- Analysis of the Environmental Report indicates a 1990 total of nearly 180,000 persons at peak summer periods.
- 3. Page 22, footnote 11: add to the end of footnote 11 the fc11owing sentence:
- Analysis of the Environmental deport indicates a 1990 peak seasonal total in excess of 50,000 persons.
Respectfully submitted, LAURIE BURT Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Division Commonwealth of Massachusetts August 22, 1979 One Ashburton Plac'e, Boston, MA 02108
. _ _ . . _ .
.
.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
,
BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD D
)
)
In the Matter of: )
)
BOSTON EDISON COMPANY et al. ) Docket No. 50-471
)
(Pilgrim Nuclear Generating )
Station, Unit 2) )
)
)
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.
I, LAURIE BURT, hereby certify that the attached
" Corrections to Testimony of Phillip B. Herr" submitted by the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, was served on the following by depositing copies in the U.S. mail, first class postage prepaid, or by other method so indicated, this 22nd day of August 1979:
(notifiedb ANDREW C. GOODHOPE, Esq. BARRY H. SMITH, ESQ. (phone Chairman, Atomic Safety and MARCIA E. MULKEY, ESQ. (8/22/75 Licensing Board Office of the Executive U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Legal Director Washington, D.C. 20555 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n
~
Washington, D.C. 20555 DR. A. DIXON CALLIHAN Union Carbide Corporation ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING P. O. Box Y BOARD PANEL Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37830 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, D.C. 20555 DR. RICHARD F. COLE Atomic Safety and Licensing Board WILLIAM S. ABBOTT, ESQ.
U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 50 Congress Street, Suite 925 Washingten, D.C. 20555 Boston, MA 02109 ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING OFFICE OF THE SECRETARY APPEAL BOARD Docketing and Service Section U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Comm'n Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555
.
1015 163
. .. -. . - - ..- -.
.
-
,
MR. DANIEL F. FORD MR. AND MRS. ALAN R. CLEETON 1208 Massachusetts Avenue 22 Mackintosh Street Cambridge, MA 02138 Franklin, MA 02038 -
HENRY HERRMA$'N, ESQ. DALE G. STOODLEY, ESQ.
- 151 Tremont Street Boston Edison Company Boston, MA 02111 800 Boylston Street Boston, MA 02199 CHIEF LIBRARIAN Plymouth Public Linrary GEORGE H. LEWALD, ESQ. (Hand-del'd)
North Street Ropes and Gray Plymouth, MA 02360 225 Franklin Street Boston, MA 02110 EDWARD L. SELGRADE, Deputy Director Governor's Mass. Office of Energy Resources 73 Tremont St.
Boston, MA 02108 CluAll LAURIE BURT Assistant Attorney General Environmental Protection Division Commonwealth of Massachusetts One Ashburton Place, 19th Floor Boston, MA 02108 (617) 727-2265
.
e
-
1015 164
- __ _
- ._ . .- -