ML20071F192

Forwards 810602 Rept Re Feedwater Pump Trip Compiled by F Witkowsky & J Daugherty.Handwritten Notes on Various Subjs Encl

ML20071F192
Person / Time
Site:	Beaver Valley, 05000000
Issue date:	06/09/1981
From:	Lacey W DUQUESNE LIGHT CO.
To:	Werling J DUQUESNE LIGHT CO.
Shared Package
ML20071F054	List: ML20071F077 ML20071F086 ML20071F192
References
FOIA-82-530 NUDOCS 8303110061
Download: ML20071F192 (31)

Text

{{#Wiki_filter:. _, Q (1, f Y.I DIWCLSNT. LIGHT COMPANY ( l f, + K J a /,2 # L ,- --

 }          9,  ,e                                                                Le:4ver Va))ey hiwer St at ion                                                     '

I. i June 9, 1933 BVPS:WSL:18 June 2,1983 Auto-Stop of The 1A Main Feedwater Pump i . Mr. J. A. Werling: Please find attached a report on the June 2, 1981 Teedwater Pump [FW-P-1A] trip. This report was compiled by Frank Witkowsky of the Techn'ical Advisory Group and Jim Daugherty, Nuclear Shift Operating Toreman. In addition to the information contained in the report, I would like to offer the fo13cwing: . r After the restart of [FW-P-1A), an ' alarm was received that indicated

                    " Abnormal Steam Generator Feed PPlA Lube Oil Pump Trouble".                                                                                      In the subsequent check-out of the main feed pump, three valves on the pressure switch manifold were found to be in what was felt, at the time, the clesed position. Since the alarm came in after the pump was restarted, it is more likely that the switch isolation valves were throttled. practically closed to reduce hydraulic

surges. The pressure would have bled down during the short period of time the feed pump was shutdown.

5.~' W. S. Lacey Attachment ( WSL:ses a cc: J. J. Carey i l J. D. Sieber T. D. Jones

h. P. Wi))iams l Onsite Safety Co:.mittee members l T. P. Witkows;ky J. . ?. . :'ac;her y -

j l Centra] Ti]e (2), i 8303110061 830131 ! PDR FOIA SHCLLY82-530 PDR

    -- -.i,.,        -.,.,v  - . - - . -     ..-y,,,.w   ..__m,,,v-- . , - . --      y--32,.,w,,,,%.,.   ,~wv.,-- .,-,.-,,.,~,7_..,   y.~--~ir     is-re--wom-w+~~--r--*--see--=-~       -s-,+h-'e    --e-=-

c' DI .n;; *,:;E LIGiir COMPA::Y s Ee.tver valley Power Station June 8, 1981 Rcoort On The Auto-stoo Of the 1A Main Feedwater Pumo The 1A Main Feedwater Pump tripped at 1427 hours on June 2, 19S1. The Sequence of Etents recorder indicated the lAl motor stopped approximately 34 milli-seconds before the IA2 motor, implying that the 1A1 motor tripped on elettrical protection. The NCO manually re-started the 1A1 motor after U e discharge valve closed. Then,. the 1A2 motor automatically started in 1.5 - seconds. Within minutes, the NSOF went to the motor breaker switchgear cabinets and found the 131 breaker cabinet for the IA2 motor. phase A timed overcurrent relay (31 'JS101A) had tripped. DLCo construction personnel were also working in the breaker ccmpartment. Work consisted of pulling-cable and making / preparing a terminal ends for DCP 299. The NSOF reset relay (51-VB101A) aikd informed construction personnel of the incident. He did not remember which flag had dropped. There had been home confusion as to which motor had tripped first - the lAl or the 1A2. The Secuence of Events recorder indicated that lAl auto-stopped by indicated time secuence but the timed overcurrent COM-5 relcy (51 '!B101A) on the 1A2 motor A phase had been found tripped. A check of the logics indicates no motor preference in tripping sequence. This implies that either motor, tripped on electrical protection, will auto-stop the other motor. The Computer Engineer has cade a preliminary check of the lAl and 1A2 motor alarm addresses and has found nothing outstanding. The Computer Engineer will input false input signals at each motor (at the earliest opportunity that the breaker cubicles can be worked in) to verify that the computer leads are not reversed. 4 Since the feedwater p' ump motors did not trip out on their manual re-start, it is reasonable to assume that no electrical abnormal motor conditions exist. Both motors started and have been running for days at full power demand since ] the incident . j j It should be noted that the COM-5 type relay can, while monitoring motor i running current, be tripped by a sudden jar. I Contrary to the Sequence of Events recorder print-out on which motor tripped i first, no indicated trip was found for the lAl motor. The lAl motor's breaker cabinet (lA) was found closed and no one was working at or near it. However, the solid state ground relay 50-VA101 has been found in the targeted position at least twice since the auto-stop incident. These ground relays are of ten found targeted and may be censidered unreliable indication. i, In sumary, although not conclusive - but very probably, the 1A Main Feed Pump had been unintentionally and accidentally tripped by construction personnel who were working in the 1A2 motor breaker cabinet while they were pulling cable i or working inside and very close to the targeted relay 51-VS101A. i

• ,, u

                                                                   ./                      r y / $gg,S Wh                            f
                                                                //    I' r.t u k P. Uitkowsky    [

Shift Technical Advisor

                                                          ;$                           Sj3-r/
                                                          &                   E6 fm A =d's) B6 &

Ac'/a/ / i796 & e x l L,)L C,c ~l. Awe ,w

            ~)2naJ                                         u                -
                                                                              'J;;auff)
            #'*!'jEEt a _ap_! ?

A d p3 1 " p!  ?

                                                                                              !M
 . ^^$w &g_ M m_af_                                  _
                                  -L                      x              '         '
                                                                         . & _ \J                  ._
      ---L                           ,h                                am                                _

r .

g k hmmmm

                                                      ^
   ~ ~ ' ~ ~

o q__ M-M_ , { _,( i ydtM-_a n A _ /, u ManexefsAbr_1nJ_ sw- _A, - d%_Aarn_

                          )            //
                                                   -f              ,

a {G b w A_, Mm c2. . - -

                                                                                 ^

Z? . _~ j

                   -s_w   r v__a n                 wa                              _

_Mj _dk GY<.__.

                    -__     w x                     res                            . -

mus wA l_ M g w / y ' , _

                                                                                                                                                               'l

^ b sea g ggy-4, - aau, & u r a [ f,  ;

                  . 1
                                         -%s 27?& L F 56 Ps 2t                                          7f Vr                          _.                      .
                    '=Jt/
                    ~

W 792 n 72 Ns - - -

                        % M Y b             . _ . _ _   _   _                             A_

692

                                                                             .../_ _ __              - _ _ _                   ...-       _ . . - -
                                                                                                             ?_W W,W]

s- sus A,L~Ampi

                                               /rcosr
                         ~M__ 1~&

wuxwanms-ausiyaa k awk x __

_ _ y i-py %Q w , , , _[ ' -

                                                                                        $_.                   bMs                                            .

(um L W Myeqs__. _

l

                                                                                                                                 -.m--

ssn K X_w_ QAs a~ .

                                                                                                                            =

cm%,m=cary ug, ad mas ( , __ _ _s t x 4 L__ e _ ga7 C~7j_ [ ^ MlAL _ Nnd f./JV.-- &? ')V - -

                                > SA                           -+:

9 h dM Fs k y/d w24'f*4 w

                                ,    d/dX L2 y 23f}d, n                  D,8,N mm, w%=wh
                      ---Ww-e                                  m.-+_-me   wm-.=%%    -
                                           -N-emmmen.%
                                                 =-

Wwww

                                                                                        - m- e m mm-e-wmo w

Iw

I y;a Fb"

                                                                        ; tu es wie                     ao                        n-<<

su pm pi/ //c c - - t r 4 - hl//p g c r ur >~ n l61 h futy y

                             /            'C yo/ - s)uv Vg/u              y/ k         bf       f]f Y VL ase    /~/             i u </ ~ L nhe               /, ni-, uL s,                  -
           ,,,fd'sc/c tu>

3 com f

 ? Im I L, t pv cn nc4 //ci-m-o{t c) -fu ll cr<<q si n /r b 6 -n/t' af wue n /' rg $nudd e M 5,~ c m TG- 7 il 9e /ss / lfe << 0 0I[ fa ] 4 ic 7)nllOpo b

to - a 'h m oa fy 9m V ln 40 if- l0}o n T^ &cIn Y b cf m 1' ' t did , +- to a'ap shq 4/ n %, , wn y ecovkf v} n s )rj,a h;, Y 40 // [dahW ""h pn Wm> v .14 p, p va/r'e / % ~ lu vdut pep h> Jt ge ckuQ [ la c /c td ,,_2.,n + -  % 4 2 - + b w A 1 e O O ( c&J > - As y _pt cf<, ,19 ,, Ad./ py v.1/ve yen w - op ~ / w c/< W ne fil/ E< .c_ duo m a n i 0M 54.f V y't/ / /MO i. 1 J 1 I i ! t e l r E k # ra d/A ~ e- w,7% L A7"LL ' 6/Y-/qS~4. 6& 3 %~// . . ( - _6p) 7 / s, x 6n_ -_ . ~ A grs4a r ~"; gL j ynj %- a a Am zgr vs r  ; n, 7

y gQ 4

b /_ . c2h _ e y _s __f - _ &,_a_cr/+ W _&_ _ - F _&nLw- _n _ . T M2];;&T~WL-- N-= w ++-h- *w-+ **-me.e _ - . _ * - - - . - - - _ _ ,, ._ m .% w -- _. o. e _ i y L n +,4 w & - _w - L &a I r W d . l/ / w_fm_W-_- ._ . Z12cM__ l ~& _u s fff scun' /f _2N 4 \ ws _ . ww _ sa _- Qua___ _5 - 4 y , '. -w _ ( 7 E- ] - , n- /__. . _. ~ - r~ w _ W ku d y - ge, + - - +e- ***-=e-e + - . m% .m__ T L gtfindn @ 7n yJ A,x A cJ o1 M 3 63% ' - 1. P he ~ ~ ~ ~ i %M M . A 4 . pf#gg;h /94 ^ Mi K NWP&n .G-C%Lri . f  ;- L_fA%-_, WW. . _ 111/h Yagg

JunX2yy2[m;:n;; n s _xy _ _ _ _.

- -- ==i ,w -e - - em . . . , ,e_. ..-e . m . m - e_ M - 3/uHolf y,i Y q fy//e n. t' $5 j 4., Ay 3,f /. 3 cy ' d-l oonbt r e mn ti~ gbw 4 ,C// s h '( h,cc, , (v 7he r, c4eck /op 7L- c l ie c h, s zt u~ t 9 79v.c v / 29 ,1 /e 4 /2 0 &c, hi e-f>a % m Fu l uo n ' es sJ, u c( J,/>4 hy Ce c c/p - y fc m u> r~ h c4~ ebckd Jbn ey W 4 9 sc 7b h /h.7 F e ec/ pa),,0 5m A 6/m e v4-i clain-d i 9 fot/< ' l/N y a, n e rdwl/ f loc L< d W o( f4, 6/ue,. fv>ta-94 hen v f 2 6 ve/ve wa > <, aa L. / f, w> t # p-;. e&n f t,,lvo ve n ,,p - as r gyrql xl Jkrh k bl /0 kin b [iU c " /fr, ~ 4 6<<ta ->nce// ~ 4< t Sv, 4 /) /oh, fV! kt' V f (A/ / ve ro u fi a t l~ /'1 h*1X N fuem (o - ? cc h , lyn a,!"Yl{R,yGT'Na crem <r l l 1 ( fJu n qu<R /1 gik t h- 0 l/f f f c b>< fo c2 f vehe fueutz +er fgh,., ladec l ~ L1p b <tl rdiG /ick -a -% l tur H fin / b q cc 's m - ( 9 few /V. 0 , p nu 1 , pin y - OT T G w et ,i""I l h>t Fib V5 +4 G ~ e,4 4: Jefe ~/<8' r v., e, a n 7>< as-d . ( n~ U uo to 4 /re: w g kh t l i l L I ~~ 6 -B - f/ 9 $p ./ #.s___p_.,A .'. Jm- -w76 w s, _ S, - , y _ h , _ ,/ y h__ - - 7[ J ' s D r __]A) & 3_ %c //_ w he f 2/ i [ f # P i r wpr 4}C pM J Ms ,y  ? a- w art n 2 -7 s _ ~' ~f_ & , n V ~ _ _c u : _ Ac M L_ __ V__ W %w$:w/y .%t 2 W t A, Lmb. l_si ~LC23 A ~ - W M[q m, ~uJL as _ _i _ - - . . . - . . t / ke_ct . .. - / - syxx, _ _ w3yM_ , _ v __ . s - / s u C - - --- - _E M _[ p )---- _ ._ zaMgm ;_  ::

MDi;]3]M;, __ ey ..  :

nz:m:Ezr;1___

1E n

-e mw- p =a h * - -+.-- e - + ----..e. ese e -_ --e-.- , , _ w _w -w- +,--me. - w .6- + + --<exami=>e. - - ==- e ew * - e - e - . m. - - , _a--my-,. e- - . mm - . ** _ .g --e _ m - -en-* w W m muuu* w W -+w .--& - - -=ee ,_ , ,_ -.__ _e._ . . . _ . . _ . . _ _ . ) [)g v /c fi~ m S &rh w ~ S ff o ps,,,y t (dathJ u /// f e k t h wnc ce f /e,,-[ &nt< -lac u - 9 - u r+/uf vg fu( friil% 1% I? 'hak )im e // n u m , ,,~ a hl/if2 pl,, 5 x orm n - , p' 1i S 45y ;u i t s)# y < -, eny + " r~-, ' T a" Ws

• a l"s' *xW , o,~n 1

l i i u Y wpg ~ b//3/8/ fYN /, sk x. w/ tskaM __-}< !Lsdeat@4 ~Mzr __ _ M'76 =L_ =r - 7X 2 Rn ) J_A- 3X //Ea ,_ -[g=.s;4 9n a g h -- n a T ~L L / g y I }i ~ < rk 6_ 2kta_ 3 Jh d%A - n __ m , Q _- ~rd . _ E M % 1 kL M man __ -

: O r / p 2M" '_' :

w _r dy 4 wua w_ A dD ~ r pg ty Ayw h-Y && Gx- mv , As=W M.- (M-. -% .,mm- . w- e-w.- M M_ M, _ - __ - - ._. \/ - . _s # 2 L _- _ - . . - __ , [ . bvb h . _ sex - = - W , C /40 (! _ M W _ __ __ _ _ / texigji x A, S 2 yi A, - - n - * * - - - - * - - - - .. -- m -,. - - - .-- w m, e- , e _ , . . , - %_, m. _m _ _ _ _ , . ,e co-e e e-- - -- m _ j = w- .=m.e .w a.. _ -m.- . ,

~1 , 5% 4n FM 743 %h i fo g 19 5 h // ss f* chumw] -

on or /Vi //vf Sv/clig 4 cky ($s nilsa , c m 7bn u ~ 3 yve b wet 6 fv p evny t po 7%m yvap aSb / /M & n a /j b J'O om -l M clt GlI by) C (lw d "c" pa b y % *> h 7l% l v k 5 % ~< < ]G //yY f #} + 7) V b1 Iv Fl a yigpd tr ~ d % kl, f y( < 179' f I < Cem /J/< Vy < sii l oOEa b < k Sn+ b w/e onced w ye ' Mwgar dma,f fa wLJ 4;wd /~ n ss .,, ,4, n, w s. < [f *y /' /uy vp < - d-A) F < w a is s < {piv #Ntv cf) f(l C h(c u n l#Y"IL' l 4~ /g L /c lye l 9u pp - d 4,& l<p - e f bw dh t.A 4 Of b i bn)y $? u z , t t/w%' a 7 __saa azo 7 - 1 1 ~~~ .r h__.._ u 2tzd3y __ il t w/d dug . f -_ W~ z % _ ox _ _ _ _ . _ h ;z 587 nanna " m <WW, ' ~ u_ x"y' M nun r kcz6 G A-_sz w Y a _ g _ g ; 4 _p _ __ _ gJ u rnpuum & M T_ - '3 e

• uhgfgM

~ ~ , r r d E4B A J / y 5 a sc A. wa>L M' ra p, an .A +wuA A%V, ?Yli }1M w-a /xc c 3 .w <( T - Ahfh _ W 6 /146K .. .3L-Beaf. ,a)) fe W. . ~ -> Li}d/du. " S ~ W./ p/ W -ss-J e_ d drL E .K f - u h_~se  % s_ _dJJ m 4. a r n & , rw e . . nA w W om. iM,au &) ' W, - G . 2% p y~ygaxx4 i \ s i rt -__ _ - __f.___.. .w I Y.-_-.----.------ - _ &W p a-,_ . ~a#2pc W N E3 ej r COL.e ' ' L_& n %ar

L- & _

6 g&-. ^ 2_ g w af _ !Mm a, - TA  % ;4:AA 6=L L yLLR*f a upp eK1 1 1 El sz-  %[um _ A u a- t I _ _-- __g..____ - _ _ . _ _ _ ' l I 9 , a  % esTank & - 7wkOf fL-- ^ . . n n . . _ Y -_ _ _ - _ n osa-w ++ u.*=s= w *e . esp.-pwa weg -w- yew-me e p- w*emm-mi ' eme- e w - -e-m - M eb--- .- emb - p-w._.-.+e - m e e hag-wh e- am... mem_ mw--+--e m ,.mwes, m----- me .l. .e amamme- *_ea- - meum --N - - w .-g. , emme- m es.mgow- - --..=m-' ew - - - , ww q. e. .hwe m e m e -6 w h' W e-e- m w-- e-- e *=esmen - e.m- - ar- m w em- -w- -e w+e m_ .egimm .a w ..ege e 46

m. _ __ ~ . - _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . . _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _

mye,_ a . ,,- e. . e ega.,. sm .,e-e a-e,s. mw - en em- 'S- 4'Im y,. sw-- wm+-. emper e-emi -. .. . + . e4 . - em a , ,p.mn. , , , ,, -. -_ - --.---~.-_e_ -.- - - - - - - - . ,---e.- - - - -+- -- m- ---. , l j - _ - -._ - - _ .. . .. . . . . - . - - - - -. -- i g. "'t p,,;l6pcweIWj!2'l""* yn o' 4 fG //p / W * / / ra u r />lr e r/ / 9 80 $ Ih hkY hutfft 0 ed.n + /Am j /. .pAdss .1/hb ev /A , (A, if/n q / - i "2 14- y p~ct hs - Ar/ vng w/ ,4~.cs at ;u, u< /-> wn< $'jotkscl visuall / v a k n/ g 7' va ka hk 40 b <+ cl0 b fifr e os m lu 4 f" hp /s f fi// "c jfrewm/$ d '> 9 ( frl A'7} / 05' p/n m 91df52uh // p to yA uo ms' w&A /o# cl?/ u .1' /; / c&ai6 ue/ss ;C-6,, m o, y e fe Q ve h Wh if a re c ha ve/<e slen le n w q /d or b m J /,1 4&d 6 ., + ,+ 6,dD ? - 1 oc Lf bua i n/y pu ,, laAe Gn f@ 5A <3 l c len e L'L .cf (W~) g (& a l gyr j un ~m(As sQ **"9 pid esn h, e// g a,t aa 9~~n; $ 7 /fne <- I f ;/lll { l l 6,bs/r/ 3K ~ ~ QL L 77p u t k L ,)t J J - - ymww; AML . _ 3 . __ _ l 1 b 02o - . J LL TkMEg&~ ubMM -LAB , 2C 7 4 y,f ~ _. - . . -- . w g& M - i ._ _- ____ .. _ - . I AL _ -. -_ /_ . - - - f/ xg._ _ . lAl { w mJ_ s s_=gxa . _ . --y * - * * . - -. - w% ..-.-w.+ **w1 * * "*h -- 4 e e... em -

• e.*-= m we.ee .em%..., .- m w- ,

we, O ~.. ~~. z -{s - --. S _ . ._._ a - &s t 2 6 z] um, JLCaR _ L Ep-pBf 1 F M M A M i:E _ _ MXL2lkaTMEW cf a _ w r Exf, 22_2 / 3 e-- e.ume.-

m. s an-,,

.-w,-- --mw.-,.. w ---- wawww -= w mm*.----=a-----w.w=.%= = - -.,,-.-ve.-g4-mm.-e- ..aw. -. .--,e- -.= e%-ww- + w a -m-m -a----- -ens,we . - , - =+ . - . - .- --- sme.-we w +w.. h.* e*-- s-am-- - --.+-m- ~w.m - -wwe=mem-w m -e-we---+m.- - - --.-m. - - . * - - - , .% -e m -e-e.--,= . - ---mm-.==%.,sm----s ---.--- .-.,-o---- ew.e-  % - - - - - =um.--m---.--,e ,. .-. e-- .--e- -----w -- .ee  %.--.e.

w. m .m we h

'~ - - ~ - ~ gJVr/ 7;me,, ea e _ _ __ _ _ j- ___..._____.i \ i m

. p l Y -- _.

._--.M.~ ty /w/_ ( ( w a d Q / _ _ o-1Cy n ryyy_ h_ C__ _/ ng - L45T DI ~ D f  ?~ll # &m, m - ~ h_ _L 07/ - ~ ~ ' ~ lokf lT & h __ f/Arzr ;- W__b _ - ilh aMa_z o_on ][ 1 _ L_L gg M_, 1 n :w Dy ns _c;se AAatap yg 7 q: rJ A Ak . d M% LL _ _p mw7]_- . L a/ss, ._$ - ..,w  %, =,.m. m- m- w e. -m>, a w e em. -.---a- . _ - ~ . z cy 9 Q_ laI b ; "O d"t f u- _. - . _ _ _ _ _ _ __ e- _ _. -e. --,_e _ . 2 - . _n_m e _J_. __ - . - __ __ --wW es e emune we - +- h h m - w e - we

2. 2 , _ x_ 3 , VX9 --

e +e- - a_. w-- +4-- - yw w-- .we- ---pe= ==.e-.. m.wswe-- .w m _ ' + pee W N o-WW= -- _ W*- e g.e w-Se e-- -we . - + - - - ew *-"- N*- he -.m-_m-,y-e* eww- + - - - - -Mw *"N* --.=--wa- __ e- h-I___...______ -_ 6 p . , . _ , - . - - - ~ ~ - - _ . . EEli l M Ti l A rz_ , - /z 4_,_ -Mn RBc W_L.

l. T a

_aan wmaq1w - w y e. ep/ e _ 11__ = G iiiff 9 1 - - MW TY ~ , M_- .Fm V / / , - -= Xgm-th w ' ' ' __ h _ _ _ u_ _A/R C N __ M J A & i_- __J_ A ,sa;W ' db b ec_ a,/ &" J k i .__ _ _ . _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ _ __ 2' f pCA~ Q Y< O =c% y2L a ^ xa: axa' inu WM i > 2 3 e-E s m. w mM flA kW . s . e e. q4 ~& --  % ,p, -MN -Wny _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - - ~ .__2h_M ~__ M -_ I WJ_ ,A yk .__ 1 w_ w ,n l 1 + _ L_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ l}}