ML13259A201

2013 Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Initial License Examination Administrative Files

ML13259A201
Person / Time
Site:	Davis Besse
Issue date:	06/18/2013
From:	Bielby M NRC/RGN-III/DRS/OLB
To:
Shared Package
ML11354a427	List: L-13-225, 2013 Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station Initial License Examination Administrative Files ML13259A201
References
L-13-225
Download: ML13259A201 (8)

Text

2013 DAVIS-BESSE NUCLEAR POWER STATION INITIAL LICENSE EXAMINATION ADMINISTRATIVE FILES

1. Pre-Examination I acknowledge that I have acquired specialized knowledge about the NRC licensing examinations scheduled for the week(s} of _Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 __as of the date of my signature. I agree that I will not knowingly divulge any information about these examinations to any persons who have not been authorized by the NRC chief examiner. I understand that I am not to instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants scheduled to be administered these licensing examinations from this date until completion of examination administration, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC (e.g., acting as a simulator booth operator or communicator is acceptable if the individual does not select the training content or provide direct or indirect feedback}.

Furthermore, I am aware of the physical security measures and requirements (as documented in the facility licensee's procedures} and understand that violation of the conditions of this agreement may result in cancellation of the examinations and/or an enforcement action against me or the facility licensee. I will immediately report to facility management or the NRC chief examiner any indications or suggestions that examination security may have been compromised.

2. Post-Examination To the best of my knowledge, I did not divulge to any unauthorized persons any information concerning the NRC licensing examinations administered during the week(s}

of_ Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013From the date that I entered into this security agreement until the completion of examination administration, I did not instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants who were administered these licensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC.

PRINTED NAME JOB TITLE I RESPONSIBILITY SIGNATURE (1} SIGNATURE (2} DATE NOTE 1.]1tt.4-f ~M.~Mc,Cl .'{flA!tr\ Wofe~ ~

2. i;t.Wd.l. ~ l.elll> ~ w..:~...

3. tJ!.""tK.. L. l<te; E,~t.A"""" v...>r, '\.t';"(___

i'U~~r;Q

~~ ~IA.Lifi>(T"U*

~~ ~;\*dt ~ic;.V ~

6. -RILlA- 7J-/ lf/ll{ 5I!?. 5Jf{lv4et£ W&.

1. Bov-.~ &<..a *rott 51 A* tflJfow8te- £A<

a. DM0> c;:fiT2lJiq f'?C S 5rsr~ I£Jfrc.

9. MA.kt Doyle.. ~0 rltA.l,*Jator

~ ~::tl!:r.~ /.o ;~M~O:~It'Jifr(Zn_ ~~~

'S RD \/ AL D Pr~c7'2 ~ l{ ~ 15 ~.lit

~fl.o v.._J;Q..,,.DI" ll"-'-lt') (, ll'l ',.,.

14. -"---~----=-- Sf( o v~ l l-et"'f,;"" ~-z~*-n _1_~ f'v\.. ~-t11J

~,--~--~n<V~*L..*.....,.._..L.,-'799-----7":'7'1--'- '6/-4}3  ;:;:;:)~~ cJ;;)!?

15. !iJDrJ.Aco Fox flo VA LttPATo YL \.,.,..;:::'- -t:,r';-rF r= ~ ~: ~

7 /  ;

t-~"- ~r~""';~ N NOTES:

• ,.r-'Nr tul\1 NUREG-1021, Revision 9 Supplement 1 fAje.. \ at q ....,.... .her -telecc"\ .1 r *"

llf.JI' {tt:J1 ~-, FENOC Facsimile

1. Pre-Examination Q " \ ~ i t\ A I acknowledge that I have acquired specialized knowledge about the NRC licensing examinations scheduled for the week(s) of Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 as of the date of my signature. I agree that I will not knowingly divulge any information about these examinations to any persons who have not been authorized by the NRC chief examiner. I understand that I am not to instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants scheduled to be administered these licensing examinations from this date until completion of examination administration, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC (e.g., acting as a simulator booth operator or communicator is acceptable if the individual does not select the training content or provide direct or indirect feedback). Furthermore, I am aware of the physical security measures and requirements (as documented in the facility licensee's procedures) and understand that violation of the conditions of this agreement may result in cancellation of the examinations and/or an enforcement action against me or the facility licensee. I will immediately report to facility management or the NRC chief examiner any indications or suggestions that examination security may have been compromised.

2. Post-Examination To the best of my knowledge, I did not divulge to any unauthorized persons any information concerning the NRC licensing examinations administered during the week(s) of Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 From the date that I entered into this security agreement until the completion of examination administration, I did not instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants who were administered these licensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC.

PRINTED NAME JOB TITLE I RESPONSIBILITY DATE SIGNATURE (2) DATE NOTE

1. DA-v\0 W 1TJ Ou u~ sQ.o W(..o.t-T;~..I 5~ ~/,~~~ ----;~~*-*-,S~'~>~'l-

2. t/J¥~UI Cfrv~}

3. ~ono.Jd fu..-k r:<ea.~.:t~r 0f~o~ Vaitdr.f""..... * -~l

~ /) A

4. L<A~T~\ '<~.+tyqz \lo. \

>>(,...... i>hf"o(2p .> R. () v" (.~""'

AfACfon. O£E!JA10Jt

"("~~ov~

13. v--..v'-"1 * "t.VV ~IV!.... ' ~ '-(<<let-v't~ r-I

14. /l,.,oTI../'1 .JO#V~ON -£5 c,o/L T o6/3lr3

15. ~.>refH:17 .S~.t-am ~ {??r CeJ.3)13 7-~,

NOTES:

NUREG-1021, Revision 9 Supplement 1 PA~e. 2 ~+ tf FENOC Facsimile

ES-201 Examination Security Agreement Form ES-201-3

1. Pre-Examination O~tGtl\b.l-I acknowfeqge that I have acquired specialized knowledge about the NRC licensing examinations scheduled for the week(s) of Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 as of the date of my signature. I agree that I will not knowingly divulge any information about these examinations to any persons who have not been authorized by the NRC chief examiner. I understand that I am not to instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants scheduled to be administered these licensing examinations from this date until completion of examination administration, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC (e.g., acting as a simulator booth operator or communicator is acceptable if the individual does not select the training content or provide direct or indirect feedback). Furthermore, I am aware of the physical security measures and requirements (as documented in the facility licensee's procedures} and understand that violation of the conditions of this agreement may result in cancellation of the examinations and/or an enforcement action against me or the facility licensee. I will immediately report to facility management or the NRC chief examiner any indications or suggestions that examination security may have been compromised.

2. Post-Examination To the best of my knowledge, I did not divulge to any unauthorized persons any information concerning the NRC licensing examinations administered during the week(s) of Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 From the date that I entered into this security agreement until the completion of examination administration, I did not instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants who were administered these licensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC.

PRINTED NAME JOB TITLE I RESPONSIBILITY SIGNATURE (1) DATE SIGNATURE~~:I DATE

, #NOTE

1. RA'~ ~ttflc;S Pi f'MM DtNt:wlik<=el Le-A a ~ 4 fo!"t/t$

2. AoJ~ MAll Tu-1 £9e<t2XT 3.J0a-uJ 'B,-.y,~"Q4 e:,co.c2-1 1~ ~tr:-

~

4. TlM- Pwba~J.f <; ~ocz.:;- zt

&1Jit?:r £~g~ ~ ii~'

5. /]11-fVIEt... C.AIYIIIC.-1/0 £$CO~!

4--~~

9. _ _ _ __

10. _ _ _ __

11. _ _ _ __

12. _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

13. _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - - -

14. _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - - -

15. _ _ _ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

NOTES:

NUREG-1021,R-~o9S ,,._,. 1 ~~Jl_,

Gl 3 Q '/"" LJ.

~ Af~ 'E't-- k~~ ~\\~ c.~~~

"'**"'- 1 ~ -r:<--f ewv'l

~;)J .K*

fir.) T S1~t'\c..T~I'-<._ LAJ~ ~FE~g~ymilewi't""~

r"e.>'Y\G.~"'~~A~ s.~Ac..Tv..J-1$' ori~~~l At-~1::. oJAr d A{/1(!/::;:;i~ r.toV\J n..&{: ~v M; Sit:>.~ ~ $.~ ~ L/- d ~I

ES-201 Examination Security Aareement Form ES-201-3

1. Pre-Examination 0 r:d'J\cu\

I acknowledge that I have acquired specialized knowledge about the NRC licensing examinations scheduled for the week(s) of Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 as of the date of my signature. I agree that I will not knowingly divulge any information about these examinations to any persons who have not been authorized by the NRC chief examiner. I understand that I am not to instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants scheduled to be administered these licensing examinations from this date until completion of examination administration, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC (e.g., acting as a simulator booth operator or communicator is acceptable if the individual does not select the training content or provide direct or indirect feedback). Furthermore, I am aware of the physical security measures and requirements (as documented in the facility licensee's procedures) and understand that violation of the conditions of this agreement may result in cancellation of the examinations and/or an enforcement action against me or the facility licensee. I will immediately report to facility management or the NRC chief examiner any indications or suggestions that examination security may have been compromised.

2. Post-Examination To the best of my knowledge, I did not divulge to any unauthorized persons any information concerning the NRC licensing examinations administered during the week(s) of Davis Besse NPS 6/3/2013 through 6/14/2013 From the date that I entered into this security agreement until the completion of examination administration, I did not instruct, evaluate, or provide performance feedback to those applicants who were administered these licensing examinations, except as specifically noted below and authorized by the NRC.

PRINTED NAME JOB TITLE I RESPONSIBILITY SIGNATURE (1) DATE SIGNATURE (2) DATE NOTE

1. RA'i ~ll..fl.~5 PY ft-A/cl\ il:.wwlti-\t~1 Le-Aa -A71J'~

I 4/n/p.

I I

_.fi!~

.. f {/ 0dn

2. _ _ _ _ _ __

3. _ _ _ _ _ __

4. _ _ _ _ _ __

5. _ _ _ _ _ __

6. _ _ _ _ _ __

7. _ _ _ _ _ __

8. _ _ _ _ _ __

9. _ _ _ _ _ __

10. _ _ _ _ _ __

11. _ _ _ _ _ __

12. _ _ _ _ _ __

13. _ _ _ _ _ __

14. _ _ _ _ _ __

15. _ _ _ _ _ __

NOTES:

NUREG-1021, Revision 9 Supplement 1

'{ 6 f 'f FENOC Facsimile

ES-403 Written Examination Grading Form ES-403-1 Quality Checklist

• Facility: Davis- Besse Date of Exam: 06/10/13 Exam Level: RO [&] SRO [&]

Initials Item Description

1. Clean answer sheets copied before grading

2. Answer key changes and question deletions justified and documented

3. Applicants' scores checked for addition errors (reviewers spot check> 25% of examinations)

4. Grading for all borderline cases (80 +/-2% overall and 70 or 80, as applicable, +/-4% on the SRO-only) reviewed in detail

5. All other failing examinations checked to ensure that grades are justified Performance on missed questions checked for training deficiencies and wording problems; evaluate validity of questions missed by half or more of the applicants Printed Name/Signature Date

a. Grader

b. Facility Reviewer(*)

c. NRC Chief Examiner(*)

d. NRC Supervisor(*)

(*) The facility reviewer's signature is not applicable for examinations graded by the NRC; two independent NRC reviews are required .

5501 North State Route 2 RrstEnergy Nuclear Operating Company Oak Harbor, Ohio 43449 Raymond A. Ueb 419-321-7676 Vice President, Nuclear Fax: 419-321-7582

-OPERATOR LICENSE EXAMINATION MATERIAL-

-WHEN SEPARATED FROM ENCLOSURE, HANDLE THIS DOCUMENT AS UNRESTRICTED -

June 18, 2013 10 CFR 55 L-13-225 Mr. Michael Bielby Chief Examiner, Region Ill U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 2443 Warrenville Road, Suite 210 Lisle, IL 60532-4352

Subject:

Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 Docket Number 50-346, License Number NPF-3 Submittal of Post Examination Materials in Support of Recently Completed Initial License Operator Examinations Enclosed are the post examination materials for the initial licensed operator examinations that were administered during the week of June 10, 2013.

The enclosed items are being submitted to the NRC for review and approval in accordance with 10 CFR 55.40, "Written Examinations and Operating Tests-Implementation" and NUREG 1021, Operator Licensing Examination Standards for Power Reactors (Revision 9, Supplement 1).

After the Written Examination was completed, the Applicants participated in a review session to determine if enhancements to the questions were necessary. Results of this review indicate several questions should be evaluated for enhancements (Questions 1, 15, 17, 35, 39, 41, 42, 43, 47, 49, 53, 60, 73, 77, and 85) prior to reuse. These questions are being tracked by Notification 600840344.

Post-exam analysis indicates three potential generic training program weaknesses (Questions missed by 50 percent or more of the Applicants; Questions 2, 57, & 96).

Investigations of these potential generic weaknesses are being tracked by the Corrective Action Program (CR 2013-09027).

JUN 2:0 2013

-OPERATOR LICENSE EXAMINATION MATERIAL-

-WHEN SEPARATED FROM ENCLOSURE, HANDLE THIS DOCUMENT AS UNRESTRICTED-Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 L-13-225 Page 2 of 2 All individuals signed onto Form ES-201-3, Examination Security Agreement, have not yet completed the post-examination signature. When Form ES-201-3, Examination Security Agreement, has been completed, it will be forwarded to you, thus completing the necessary documentation for the Davis-Besse Nuclear Power Station, Unit 1 Initial Licensing Examination.

There are no regulatory commitments included in the submittal. If there are any questions or if additional information is required, please contact Mr. Daniel T. Hartnett, Superintendent- Nuclear Operations Training, at (419) 249-2396.

Sincerely,

d~c?d/

~aym~ A. Lieb vaw Enclosure A: Form ES-403-1, Written Examination Grading Quality Checklist Enclosure B: The ORIGINAL Applicant answer sheets, a graded copy and two clean copies of each Applicant's answer sheets Enclosure C: All questions asked by the Applicants during the administration of the examination and the Proctor's responses to those questions.

Enclosure D: The Written Examination Seating Chart Enclosure E: Copies of all Condition Reports generated for this exam Enclosure F: Examination Statistics cc: Regional Administrator, NRC Region Ill (w/o Enclosure)

Chief, Operations Branch, NRC Region Ill (w/o Enclosure)

DB-1 NRC/NRR Senior Project Manager (w/o Enclosure)

DB-1 Senior Resident Inspector (w/o Enclosure)

USNRC Document Control Desk (w/o Enclosure)

Utility Radiological Safety Board (w/o Enclosure)