ML111040153: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML111040153
| number = ML111040153
| issue date = 04/13/2011
| issue date = 04/13/2011
| title = Licensee Slides from 4/13/11 Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc., to Discuss Proposed National Fire Protection Programs Standards 805 License Amendment Submittal for Arkansas Nuclear One, Units 1 & 2(TAC ME6018 and ME6019)
| title = Licensee Slides from 4/13/11 Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc., to Discuss Proposed National Fire Protection Programs Standards 805 License Amendment Submittal for Arkansas Nuclear One, Units 1 & 2
| author name =  
| author name =  
| author affiliation = Entergy Operations, Inc
| author affiliation = Entergy Operations, Inc
Line 18: Line 18:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:NFPA 805NFPA 805 LICENSE AMENDMENT REQUESTS LICENSE AMENDMENT REQUESTS 1 Pre-Application M eeting with NRC Staff April 13, 2011Arkansas Nuclear One (ANO) 1&2Palisades (PLP)Waterford 3 (WF3)
{{#Wiki_filter:NFPA 805 LICENSE AMENDMENT REQUESTS Pre-Application Meeting with NRC Staff April 13, 2011 Arkansas Nuclear One (ANO) 1&2 Palisades (PLP)
Agenda Agenda*Introductions*Fleet Project Management Approach
Waterford 3 (WF3) 1
*LAR Submittal Forecast
 
*805 PRA Peer Review Status
Agenda
*6850 Alternative Treatments
* Introductions
*Site S p ecific U p dates pp-ANO-1 & 2-PLP
* Fleet Project Management Approach
-WF3*Summary 2 2Dial-In: 800-369-3325 with Participant passcode: 56518 followed by #  
* LAR Submittal Forecast
* 805 PRA Peer Review Status
* 6850 Alternative Treatments
* Site Specific p       Updates p
    - ANO-1 & 2
    - PLP
    - WF3
* Summary Dial-In: 800-369-3325 with Participant passcode: 56518 followed by #
2


===Introductions===
===Introductions===
Introductions*Corporate Team-Licensing -Dave Mannai, Bryan Ford-Engineering Manager -Luis Terrazas
* Corporate Team
-Fleet Project Management -Andy Thomas, Doug Kibler-Corporate PRA -Deepak Rao
    -   Licensing - Dave Mannai, Bryan Ford
-NFPA 805 Technical Lead -Jessica Walker*Site Teams-ANO*Engineering Director -Jaime McCoy*Licensing -David Bice
    -   Engineering Manager - Luis Terrazas
*Fire Protection/PRA -Jessica Walker-PLP*Engineering Manager -Jim Miksa
    -   Fleet Project Management - Andy Thomas, Doug Kibler
*Licensing -James Kuemin
    -   Corporate PRA - Deepak Rao
*Fire Protection -Tom Swiecicki-WF3*Engineering Manager -Rex Putnam  
    -   NFPA 805 Technical Lead - Jessica Walker
*Licensing -David Ferris
* Site Teams
*Fire Protection -Dennis Kunas 3 3 Fleet Project Management Approach Fleet Project Management Approach*Integrated Fleet (corporate and site) Project Team*Bi-Monthly Executive Stakeholder Briefs
    -   ANO
*Weekly Fleet Project Team Meetings
* Engineering Director - Jaime McCoy
*Active Project Risk Management Program
* Licensing - David Bice
*Dedicated Fleet and Site Schedulers 4 4 LAR Submittal Forecast LAR Submittal Forecast *ANO 1&2, PLP, and WF3 -June 29, 2011*Submittals will meet acceptance criteria (LIC-109)
* Fire Protection/PRA - Jessica Walker
*Challenges 5 5 805 PRA Peer Review Status805 PRA Peer Review Status*Conduct Internal Events Peer Review-Complete*Closure / disposition of Internal Events Peer Review -F&Os will be resolved prior to LAR Submittal*Conduct Fire PRA Peer Review-Complete (Palisades Draft Report)Closre/dispositionofFirePRAPeerReie
    -   PLP
*Clos u re / disposition of Fire PRA Peer Re v ie w -F&Os will be resolved prior to LAR Submittal 6
* Engineering Manager - Jim Miksa
6850 Alternative Treatments 6850 Alternative TreatmentsTreatmentANO-1ANO-2PLPWF3Transient combustible HRR. Use a lower HRR for a postulated transient fire. Instead of using the HRR for  
* Licensing - James Kuemin
'transients' as shown in NUREG/CR-6850, Table E-1, Case 8, the HRR for Case 7 is used. The basis for this is described in the ERIN Fire Factors report submitted to the EPRI/NEI Review Group.
* Fire Protection - Tom Swiecicki
XXXXTransient Combustible Ignition Frequency -Use of a weighting factor applied to transient fires to reflect the reduced probability of a fire impacting critical targets based on procedural controls and the reduced likelihood of transient type fire conditions existing in close proximity to targets of concern (submitted to methodology review committee).
    -   WF3
XXXXTreatment of Ventilated Panels for Non-Suppression Probability.
* Engineering Manager - Rex Putnam
XXCredit for reduction of zone of influence for panels with limited ventilation, used to support Multi-Compartment Analysis.XXHot Short Probability Reduction for Outside of a Panel Configuration (ANO-2 only)
* Licensing - David Ferris
X 7 ANO ANO--1& 2 1& 2 --Current Status Current StatusMilestone ANO-1 Status ANO-2 StatusTable B-1 Fundamental FP ElementsIn ProgressIn ProgressInternal Events PRACOMPLETECOMPLETEFiPRA IP IPMajor Project Milestones 8 8 Fire PRA I n Progress I n ProgressTable B-2 -NSCA MethodologyIn ProgressCOMPLETETable B-3 -NSCA Fire Area ComplianceIn ProgressIn ProgressFire Risk EvaluationsIn ProgressIn ProgressTable F-1 -Non-Power OperationsIn ProgressIn ProgressTable G-1 -Radioactive ReleaseCOMPLETECOMPLETE ANO ANO--1&2 1&2 --Challenges Challenges*Challenges*Gaps
* Fire Protection - Dennis Kunas 3
*Technical Issues 9 9 ANO ANO--1&2 1&2 --Items for Approval Items for Approval*3.3.5.2 Metal conduits and cable trays-ANO uses PVC in underground and embedded applications*3.5.16 Firewater dedicated for Fire Protection use -ANO uses the fire water system for other functions 10 10 ANO ANO--1&2 1&2 --Modification Overview Modification Overview*Independent AFW pump/piping/valves/controls*Primary Control Station
 
*Electrical cable re-route/fire wrap
Fleet Project Management Approach
*RCP trip circuit backup power supply
* Integrated Fleet (corporate and site) Project Team
*Detection system upgrade  
* Bi-Monthly Executive Stakeholder Briefs
*Modifications for Table B-1 Issues 11 11*NFPA 10 fire extinguisher type and location changes*NFPA 15 update non-UL listed modules
* Weekly Fleet Project Team Meetings
*NFPA 30 room ventilation changes
* Active Project Risk Management Program
*NFPA 50A hydrogen relief valves & bottle relocation
* Dedicated Fleet and Site Schedulers 4
*NFPA 805 fire barriers/seals/doors/dampers upgrade PLP PLP --Current Status Current StatusMilestoneStatusTable B-1 Fundamental FP ElementsIn ProgressInternal Events PRACOMPLETEMajor Project Milestones 12 12Fire PRAIn ProgressTable B-2 -NSCA MethodologyCOMPLETETable B-3 -NSCA Fire Area ComplianceIn ProgressFire Risk EvaluationsIn ProgressTable F-1 -Non-Power OperationsIn ProgressTable G-1 -Radioactive ReleaseCOMPLETE PLP PLP --Challenges Challenges*Challenges*Gaps
 
*Technical Issues 13 13 PLP PLP --Items for ApprovalItems for Approval*3.5.16 Firewater dedicated for Fire Protection use -PLP uses the fire water system for other functions*3.11.4. Through Penetration Fire StopsUnsealed conduits 5 feet or longer 14 14 PLP PLP --Modification Overview Modification Overview*Independent AFW pump / piping / valves / controls*Electrical cable re-route / fire wrap
LAR Submittal Forecast
*Independent breakers for 2400 VAC Safeguards & Startup Transformers*Primary Coolant Pump breaker trip pushbuttons
* ANO 1&2, PLP, and WF3 - June 29, 2011
*Detection system upgrade2400VACbktlf 15 15*2400 VAC b rea ker con t ro l power f uses *Bypass switches for AFW & ECCS systems WF3 WF3 --Current Status Current StatusMilestoneStatusTable B-1 Fundamental FP ElementsIn ProgressInternal Events PRACOMPLETEMajor Project Milestones 16 16Fire PRAIn ProgressTable B-2 -NSCA MethodologyIn ProgressTable B-3 -NSCA Fire Area ComplianceIn ProgressFire Risk EvaluationsIn ProgressTable F-1 -Non-Power OperationsIn ProgressTable G-1 -Radioactive ReleaseIn Progress WF3 WF3 --Challenges Challenges*Challenges*Gaps
* Submittals will meet acceptance criteria (LIC-109)
*Technical Issues 17 17 WF3 WF3 --Items for ApprovalItems for Approval*None 18 18 WF3 WF3 --Modification Overview Modification Overview*Electrical circuit modifications*Suppression system upgrades
* Challenges 5
*Detection system upgrade 19 19 Summary Summary*All Entergy sites plan to meet June 29, 2011*Action Items
 
*Closing Remarks 20 20}}
805 PRA Peer Review Status
* Conduct Internal Events Peer Review
    - Complete
* Closure / disposition of Internal Events Peer Review
    - F&Os will be resolved prior to LAR Submittal
* Conduct Fire PRA Peer Review
    - Complete (Palisades Draft Report)
* Closure Clos re / disposition of Fire PRA Peer Review Re ie
    - F&Os will be resolved prior to LAR Submittal 6
 
6850 Alternative Treatments Treatment                            ANO-1 ANO-2 PLP WF3 Transient combustible HRR. Use a lower HRR for a postulated transient fire. Instead of using the HRR for transients as shown in NUREG/CR-6850, Table E-1, Case 8, the HRR for Case 7 is used. The basis for this is         X    X    X  X described in the ERIN Fire Factors report submitted to the EPRI/NEI Review Group.
Transient Combustible Ignition Frequency - Use of a weighting factor applied to transient fires to reflect the reduced probability of a fire impacting critical targets based on procedural controls and the reduced likelihood     X    X    X  X of transient type fire conditions existing in close proximity to targets of concern (submitted to methodology review committee).
Treatment of Ventilated Panels for Non-Suppression Probability.                                                 X    X Credit for reduction of zone of influence for panels with limited ventilation, used to support Multi-Compartment       X    X Analysis.
Hot Short Probability Reduction for Outside of a Panel Configuration (ANO-2 only)                                         X 7
 
ANO--1& 2 - Current Status ANO Major Project Milestones ANO-1       ANO-2 Milestone Status      Status Table B-1 Fundamental FP Elements      In Progress In Progress Internal Events PRA                    COMPLETE    COMPLETE Fi PRA Fire                                   I Progress In P        I Progress In P Table B NSCA Methodology            In Progress COMPLETE Table B NSCA Fire Area Compliance  In Progress In Progress Fire Risk Evaluations                  In Progress In Progress Table F Non-Power Operations        In Progress In Progress Table G Radioactive Release        COMPLETE    COMPLETE 8
 
ANO--1&2 - Challenges ANO
* Challenges
* Gaps
* Technical Issues 9
 
ANO--1&2 - Items for Approval ANO
* 3.3.5.2 Metal conduits and cable trays
      - ANO uses PVC in underground and embedded applications
* 3.5.16 Firewater dedicated for Fire Protection use
      - ANO uses the fire water system for other functions 10
 
ANO--1&2 - Modification Overview ANO
* Independent AFW pump/piping/valves/controls
* Primary Control Station
* Electrical cable re-route/fire wrap
* RCP trip circuit backup power supply
* Detection system upgrade
* Modifications for Table B-1 Issues
* NFPA 10 fire extinguisher type and location changes
* NFPA 15 update non-UL listed modules
* NFPA 30 room ventilation changes
* NFPA 50A hydrogen relief valves & bottle relocation
* NFPA 805 fire barriers/seals/doors/dampers upgrade 11
 
PLP - Current Status Major Project Milestones Milestone                  Status Table B-1 Fundamental FP Elements        In Progress Internal Events PRA                      COMPLETE Fire PRA                                  In Progress Table B NSCA Methodology              COMPLETE Table B NSCA Fire Area Compliance    In Progress Fire Risk Evaluations                    In Progress Table F Non-Power Operations          In Progress Table G Radioactive Release          COMPLETE 12
 
PLP - Challenges
* Challenges
* Gaps
* Technical Issues 13
 
PLP - Items for Approval
* 3.5.16 Firewater dedicated for Fire Protection use
      - PLP uses the fire water system for other functions
* 3.11.4. Through Penetration Fire Stops Unsealed conduits 5 feet or longer 14
 
PLP - Modification Overview
* Independent AFW pump / piping / valves / controls
* Electrical cable re-route / fire wrap
* Independent breakers for 2400 VAC Safeguards & Startup Transformers
* Primary Coolant Pump breaker trip pushbuttons
* Detection system upgrade
* 2400 VAC b breaker k control t l power ffuses
* Bypass switches for AFW & ECCS systems 15
 
WF3 - Current Status Major Project Milestones Milestone                  Status Table B-1 Fundamental FP Elements        In Progress Internal Events PRA                      COMPLETE Fire PRA                                In Progress Table B NSCA Methodology            In Progress Table B NSCA Fire Area Compliance    In Progress Fire Risk Evaluations                    In Progress Table F Non-Power Operations        In Progress Table G Radioactive Release          In Progress 16
 
WF3 - Challenges
* Challenges
* Gaps
* Technical Issues 17
 
WF3 - Items for Approval
* None 18
 
WF3 - Modification Overview
* Electrical circuit modifications
* Suppression system upgrades
* Detection system upgrade 19
 
Summary
* All Entergy sites plan to meet June 29, 2011
* Action Items
* Closing Remarks 20}}

Latest revision as of 05:59, 21 March 2020

Licensee Slides from 4/13/11 Meeting with Entergy Operations, Inc., to Discuss Proposed National Fire Protection Programs Standards 805 License Amendment Submittal for Arkansas Nuclear One, Units 1 & 2
ML111040153
Person / Time
Site: Palisades, Arkansas Nuclear, Waterford  Entergy icon.png
Issue date: 04/13/2011
From:
Entergy Operations
To:
Plant Licensing Branch IV
Kalyanam N, NRR/DLPM, 415-1480
References
TAC ME6018, TAC ME6019
Download: ML111040153 (20)


Text

NFPA 805 LICENSE AMENDMENT REQUESTS Pre-Application Meeting with NRC Staff April 13, 2011 Arkansas Nuclear One (ANO) 1&2 Palisades (PLP)

Waterford 3 (WF3) 1

Agenda

  • Introductions
  • Fleet Project Management Approach
  • LAR Submittal Forecast
  • 805 PRA Peer Review Status
  • 6850 Alternative Treatments
  • Site Specific p Updates p

- ANO-1 & 2

- PLP

- WF3

  • Summary Dial-In: 800-369-3325 with Participant passcode: 56518 followed by #

2

Introductions

  • Corporate Team

- Licensing - Dave Mannai, Bryan Ford

- Engineering Manager - Luis Terrazas

- Fleet Project Management - Andy Thomas, Doug Kibler

- Corporate PRA - Deepak Rao

- NFPA 805 Technical Lead - Jessica Walker

  • Site Teams

- ANO

  • Engineering Director - Jaime McCoy
  • Fire Protection/PRA - Jessica Walker

- PLP

  • Engineering Manager - Jim Miksa
  • Licensing - James Kuemin
  • Fire Protection - Tom Swiecicki

- WF3

  • Engineering Manager - Rex Putnam
  • Licensing - David Ferris
  • Fire Protection - Dennis Kunas 3

Fleet Project Management Approach

  • Integrated Fleet (corporate and site) Project Team
  • Bi-Monthly Executive Stakeholder Briefs
  • Weekly Fleet Project Team Meetings
  • Active Project Risk Management Program
  • Dedicated Fleet and Site Schedulers 4

LAR Submittal Forecast

  • ANO 1&2, PLP, and WF3 - June 29, 2011
  • Submittals will meet acceptance criteria (LIC-109)
  • Challenges 5

805 PRA Peer Review Status

  • Conduct Internal Events Peer Review

- Complete

  • Closure / disposition of Internal Events Peer Review

- F&Os will be resolved prior to LAR Submittal

  • Conduct Fire PRA Peer Review

- Complete (Palisades Draft Report)

  • Closure Clos re / disposition of Fire PRA Peer Review Re ie

- F&Os will be resolved prior to LAR Submittal 6

6850 Alternative Treatments Treatment ANO-1 ANO-2 PLP WF3 Transient combustible HRR. Use a lower HRR for a postulated transient fire. Instead of using the HRR for transients as shown in NUREG/CR-6850, Table E-1, Case 8, the HRR for Case 7 is used. The basis for this is X X X X described in the ERIN Fire Factors report submitted to the EPRI/NEI Review Group.

Transient Combustible Ignition Frequency - Use of a weighting factor applied to transient fires to reflect the reduced probability of a fire impacting critical targets based on procedural controls and the reduced likelihood X X X X of transient type fire conditions existing in close proximity to targets of concern (submitted to methodology review committee).

Treatment of Ventilated Panels for Non-Suppression Probability. X X Credit for reduction of zone of influence for panels with limited ventilation, used to support Multi-Compartment X X Analysis.

Hot Short Probability Reduction for Outside of a Panel Configuration (ANO-2 only) X 7

ANO--1& 2 - Current Status ANO Major Project Milestones ANO-1 ANO-2 Milestone Status Status Table B-1 Fundamental FP Elements In Progress In Progress Internal Events PRA COMPLETE COMPLETE Fi PRA Fire I Progress In P I Progress In P Table B NSCA Methodology In Progress COMPLETE Table B NSCA Fire Area Compliance In Progress In Progress Fire Risk Evaluations In Progress In Progress Table F Non-Power Operations In Progress In Progress Table G Radioactive Release COMPLETE COMPLETE 8

ANO--1&2 - Challenges ANO

  • Challenges
  • Gaps
  • Technical Issues 9

ANO--1&2 - Items for Approval ANO

  • 3.3.5.2 Metal conduits and cable trays

- ANO uses PVC in underground and embedded applications

  • 3.5.16 Firewater dedicated for Fire Protection use

- ANO uses the fire water system for other functions 10

ANO--1&2 - Modification Overview ANO

  • Independent AFW pump/piping/valves/controls
  • Primary Control Station
  • Electrical cable re-route/fire wrap
  • RCP trip circuit backup power supply
  • Detection system upgrade
  • Modifications for Table B-1 Issues
  • NFPA 10 fire extinguisher type and location changes
  • NFPA 15 update non-UL listed modules

PLP - Current Status Major Project Milestones Milestone Status Table B-1 Fundamental FP Elements In Progress Internal Events PRA COMPLETE Fire PRA In Progress Table B NSCA Methodology COMPLETE Table B NSCA Fire Area Compliance In Progress Fire Risk Evaluations In Progress Table F Non-Power Operations In Progress Table G Radioactive Release COMPLETE 12

PLP - Challenges

  • Challenges
  • Gaps
  • Technical Issues 13

PLP - Items for Approval

  • 3.5.16 Firewater dedicated for Fire Protection use

- PLP uses the fire water system for other functions

  • 3.11.4. Through Penetration Fire Stops Unsealed conduits 5 feet or longer 14

PLP - Modification Overview

  • Independent AFW pump / piping / valves / controls
  • Electrical cable re-route / fire wrap
  • Independent breakers for 2400 VAC Safeguards & Startup Transformers
  • Primary Coolant Pump breaker trip pushbuttons
  • Detection system upgrade
  • 2400 VAC b breaker k control t l power ffuses
  • Bypass switches for AFW & ECCS systems 15

WF3 - Current Status Major Project Milestones Milestone Status Table B-1 Fundamental FP Elements In Progress Internal Events PRA COMPLETE Fire PRA In Progress Table B NSCA Methodology In Progress Table B NSCA Fire Area Compliance In Progress Fire Risk Evaluations In Progress Table F Non-Power Operations In Progress Table G Radioactive Release In Progress 16

WF3 - Challenges

  • Challenges
  • Gaps
  • Technical Issues 17

WF3 - Items for Approval

  • None 18

WF3 - Modification Overview

  • Electrical circuit modifications
  • Suppression system upgrades
  • Detection system upgrade 19

Summary

  • All Entergy sites plan to meet June 29, 2011
  • Action Items
  • Closing Remarks 20