ML15314A105

2015 Clinton Power Station Initial License Examination Submittal Comments

ML15314A105
Person / Time
Site:	Clinton
Issue date:	11/10/2015
From:	Division of Reactor Safety III
To:
Zoia, C D
Shared Package
ML15124A054	List: ML15313A055 ML15313A061 ML15313A062 ML15313A063 ML15313A064 ML15313A066 ML15313A201 ML15314A105
References
Download: ML15314A105 (3)

Text

ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station Date Received: 2/13115 ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3116/15 Operating Test 2015-301 I Item# I UnSat/Editorial I Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Qperatina Test JPM417 Editorial Chanoe estimated comoletion time from 15 minutes to 35 minutes. Chanoed as requested .

JPM418 Editorial

• Add action to simulator setup instructions to turn the synch scope on, verify Changed as requested.

clockwise rotation and adjust DG speed if necessary, and then turn the synch

. scope back off.

Step 8.2.12.6 - add comment that JPM can be terminated when VARS are within ranae (500- 0 KVAR\ and aenerator load is beina raised.

JPM429 Editorial

• General note - add steps for evaluator to annotate performance of the A and Changed as requested.

B FCVs.

• Step 8.4.2.2. - add cue "If examinee requests to use "double detent,

authorize use.

• Add a comment to step 8.4.2.2. to discuss the amount of FCV movement that is reauired to meet the th reshold of a minor reactivitv manaoement event.

JPM247 Editorial

• Typo on page 7 - step 4.1 - standard third bullet - remove the word "is" in Changed as requested.

front of MIA.

• Step 5.8 - add to the cue - If the operator sends an EO to the RCIC Room, cue him/her that there are no abnormalities in the room and that the RCIC Turbine is rotatina slowlv.

JPM501 Editorial

• Move Simulator Setup action #2 to after action to just before action 7 (Freeze Changed as requested.

the simulator)

• Add remaining TCVs (2, 3, 4) to JPM.

• Add cues that the plant is stable.

• Delete instructor stationed @ P678 - NRC will orovide P678 cue .

JPM531 Editorial

• Add the first 3 steps (FC031A, 19A & 21A) to the initial conditions. Changed as requested.

• Add 8.3.2.3 to the initial conditions .

JPM534 Editorial

.* Put a copy of 9000.01 in examinee binders Put a copy of the blank data sheet in the examlnee binders

• Chanae Estimated Comoletion Time from 1Oto 20 minutes.

Changed as requested .

Incorporated all 6 changes as requested .

JPM537 Editorial

• Remove second sentence from INITIAL CONDITIONS (leaving ONLY, "The plant is in Mode 1")

• Remove the following words from the INITIATING CUE, "for MSIVs 1621-F022A and 1B21-F022B".

• Fix typo - 8.1 .1.3 should be 8.1.2.3 .

• Add the following_ to the cue for step 8.1 .1.3 - When examinee reoorts that -*- ----- -..-****-

- 1B2f.F022B closed fully after the test pushbutton was released, acknowledge the report and state, "Take appropriate action for the valve closure".

• On the marked up copy of CPS 9031.10, delete the N/A'ed steps .

• Step 8.2.5.2 - Standard - Change to read, "No action required. Permission received in the steo 8.2.5.1 Time Comoression cue"

ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Clinton.Power Station Date Received: 2/13115 ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3/16/15 Operating Test 2015-301 Item# UnSat/Editorial Chief Examiner Comment Facilit Action/Res onse JPM423 Editorial . Step 8.3. 1.1 #1 on page 8 - change the standard to read "Examinee enters Changed as requested .

"Open and/or On" in the Original Condition field of CPS 3512.01F002".

• Step 8.3.1 .1 #2 on page 8- change the standard to read "Examinee enters "Not Ooen and/or Off" in the Original Condition field of CPS 3512.01F002".

JPM532 Editorial Add 'Today's date is 11/27/14" to the initial conditions block. Changed as requested .

JPM Stec 3 Cue -Add "if requested, provide RWP (Attachment 1)

JPM535 Unsat

• Change the first sentence of the initial conditions block to read, "The plant was Changed as requested .

operating at rated thermal power with no out of service equipment."

• Delete the 200 sentence in the Initial Conditions block (NO LCOs are in effect.)

• Change the first bulleted item in the Initiating cue block to read, Technical Specification actions are required to be entered, and if the event is reportable, the reportability requirements. Delete the second bulleted line.

• JPM step 1 standard - Add ITS 3.6.1.3 A.1 and A.2 to the list.

• Terminating Cues - Change the terminating cue to read, "Examinee has evaluated ITS and determined reponlng requirements for inoperablllty of the High Pressure Core Sorav (HPCSl Svstem".

JPM536 Editorial Steo 4 Standard - add Channel 3 to the end of the first bulleted line. Chanaed as requested.

JPM538 Editorial Step 1 Standard - soecilv reauirements for ITS 3.6.1 .3 Action A.1 and A.2 Chanaed as requested.

JPM244 Editorial

• Step 8.5.8.3 Standard - change the standard to read, "Simulates placing th e Changed as requested.

. Main Control Switch in MANUAL 1 and/or Manual 2.

Step 8.2.2 Cue - Add a cue that flow noise can be heard if requested by the examinee.

JPM451 Editorial

• Add alarms that are expected to be In to the initial conditions block. Changed as requested.

• Step 8.4.6. 1 - Add a cue that describes what alarms are in and if they are expected to reset when steo 8.4.6.1 is performed.

• .~ <Cil-*

.... ... *.~..r::

"~**"* ..

• .~.*:~~,M:~~ ~

Scenario 1 Editorial Event 4 TDRFP 'A' High Bearing Temperature - the MDRFP. is started per section Added CPS 3103.01 section 8.1.6 to the ATC actions 8.1.3 MDRFP Startup and section 8.1.6 Transition from a TORFP to a MDRFP but block.

the scenario quide onlv references section 6.1.3.

cenano 1 *---eai!Orlal -cFC'ommen! - sFiOUTd we cna

riae lo soeea i.JDCfiTeT6 lransler lo l'VJ[J~ NO reas16ie way lo ao llils=lefl as 1s.

Scenario 1 Editorial Alter computer points CW-BA027, 28, and 29 to simulator lesson plan for event #7 Added computer points to the simulator lesson plan to to add realism. cause them to ramp up - 30°F over 1Ominutes.

Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #4 - add EO cue (ii directed to raise cooling Added EO cue #6 to event 4 water flow\ - "Flow Is hiah in the band".

ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station Date Received: 2/13/15 ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3/16/1 5 Operating Test 2015-301 Item# I UnSat/Editorial I Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #4 - add EO cue (if directed to check Added EO cue #7 to event 4 TDRFP bearina bubbler flow) - "Bubbler flow is normal."

Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #8 - add cue from field concerning local gas Added EO cue #3 to event 8.

boundary inspections.

Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #4 - add EO cue to report no abnormalities if Added EO cue #8 to event 4.

requested to check TDAFP 'A' room conditions on the camera.

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 7/8- the actions required to perform "Terminate and prevent LPCS and Added actions required to Terminate and Prevent LPCS LPCI injection" are not detailed in the scenario guide. and LPCI injection to the BOP Actions for Event 7/8 in the Scenario 2 sim auide.

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 7/8 - the crew may "Anticipate Blowdown" but those actions are not listed in Added "Anticipate Slowdown" to the ATC and SAO the scenario guide. actions block for events 7/8. Modified the PC-7.1 critical task listing in the scenario outline to indicate that a blowdown is not required if containment pressure can be lowered below EOP*6 Figure N after anticipating blowdown.

Scenario 2 Editorial The critical tasks listing on page 4 of the scenario guide needs to be revised to Revised critical task listing PC-7.1 to state, 'W ithin 10 reflect that EOP-6 does not require a blowdown on high Containment Pressure minutes of exceeding Figure N and containment unless contain.ment pressure cannot be low~red below Fig. N. pressure continuing to rise, the SAO will enter EOP*3 Emergency RPV Depressurization. If the crew Anticipates Slowdown using bypass valves, and in doing so Containment Pressure can be reduced I maintained below Fig. N, then this critical task is considered to be met. IPAA\

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 6 - the actions to terminate HPCS injection are reversed from those Swapped actions to shut 1E22-F004 and Stop the HPCS contained on the hard card. oumo in the BOP actions block of event #6.

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 4 - need to add rising trend to the CAD temperature reported from the area Added trend information to event 4 EO cue 1a.

operator.

Scenario 3 Editorial Event 6 - Validation crew swapped the running SPE blowers; those actions are not Added open bullet action to the Event 6 BOP actions listed in the Annlicant's Actions or Behavior block of the scenario auide. block.

Scenario 3 Editorial Event 8 - Validation c rew entered ITS 3.4.5 RA B.1 but the ITS reference is not Added ITS 3.4.5 to the SRO Actions block for event 8.

listed in the scenario auide.

Scenario 3 Editorial The ITS 3.1.5 pressure limit value for accumulator pressure is <: 1520 psig. In the Changed all instances of 1540 psig to 1510 psig.

scenario guide for Event #7, the accumulator pressure is reported to be 1540 psig.

Chanae the reported pressure to 1510 psig.

Scenario 3 Editorial Event B - Add SRO action to direct RR Loop emergency isolation Added to ATC & SRO actions for event #8.

Scenario 1, Editorial Add MCA Baseline data to PPG 10 in the simulator setup instructions. Added to the Simulator Operator Initial Setup 2, and 3 instructions.

ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station Date Received: 2/13115 ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3116/15 Operating Test 2015-301 I Item# I UnSat/Editorial I Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Qperatina Test JPM417 Editorial Chanoe estimated comoletion time from 15 minutes to 35 minutes. Chanoed as requested .

JPM418 Editorial

• Add action to simulator setup instructions to turn the synch scope on, verify Changed as requested.

clockwise rotation and adjust DG speed if necessary, and then turn the synch

. scope back off.

Step 8.2.12.6 - add comment that JPM can be terminated when VARS are within ranae (500- 0 KVAR\ and aenerator load is beina raised.

JPM429 Editorial

• General note - add steps for evaluator to annotate performance of the A and Changed as requested.

B FCVs.

• Step 8.4.2.2. - add cue "If examinee requests to use "double detent,

authorize use.

• Add a comment to step 8.4.2.2. to discuss the amount of FCV movement that is reauired to meet the th reshold of a minor reactivitv manaoement event.

JPM247 Editorial

• Typo on page 7 - step 4.1 - standard third bullet - remove the word "is" in Changed as requested.

front of MIA.

• Step 5.8 - add to the cue - If the operator sends an EO to the RCIC Room, cue him/her that there are no abnormalities in the room and that the RCIC Turbine is rotatina slowlv.

JPM501 Editorial

• Move Simulator Setup action #2 to after action to just before action 7 (Freeze Changed as requested.

the simulator)

• Add remaining TCVs (2, 3, 4) to JPM.

• Add cues that the plant is stable.

• Delete instructor stationed @ P678 - NRC will orovide P678 cue .

JPM531 Editorial

• Add the first 3 steps (FC031A, 19A & 21A) to the initial conditions. Changed as requested.

• Add 8.3.2.3 to the initial conditions .

JPM534 Editorial

.* Put a copy of 9000.01 in examinee binders Put a copy of the blank data sheet in the examlnee binders

• Chanae Estimated Comoletion Time from 1Oto 20 minutes.

Changed as requested .

Incorporated all 6 changes as requested .

JPM537 Editorial

• Remove second sentence from INITIAL CONDITIONS (leaving ONLY, "The plant is in Mode 1")

• Remove the following words from the INITIATING CUE, "for MSIVs 1621-F022A and 1B21-F022B".

• Fix typo - 8.1 .1.3 should be 8.1.2.3 .

• Add the following_ to the cue for step 8.1 .1.3 - When examinee reoorts that -*- ----- -..-****-

- 1B2f.F022B closed fully after the test pushbutton was released, acknowledge the report and state, "Take appropriate action for the valve closure".

• On the marked up copy of CPS 9031.10, delete the N/A'ed steps .

• Step 8.2.5.2 - Standard - Change to read, "No action required. Permission received in the steo 8.2.5.1 Time Comoression cue"

ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Clinton.Power Station Date Received: 2/13115 ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3/16/15 Operating Test 2015-301 Item# UnSat/Editorial Chief Examiner Comment Facilit Action/Res onse JPM423 Editorial . Step 8.3. 1.1 #1 on page 8 - change the standard to read "Examinee enters Changed as requested .

"Open and/or On" in the Original Condition field of CPS 3512.01F002".

• Step 8.3.1 .1 #2 on page 8- change the standard to read "Examinee enters "Not Ooen and/or Off" in the Original Condition field of CPS 3512.01F002".

JPM532 Editorial Add 'Today's date is 11/27/14" to the initial conditions block. Changed as requested .

JPM Stec 3 Cue -Add "if requested, provide RWP (Attachment 1)

JPM535 Unsat

• Change the first sentence of the initial conditions block to read, "The plant was Changed as requested .

operating at rated thermal power with no out of service equipment."

• Delete the 200 sentence in the Initial Conditions block (NO LCOs are in effect.)

• Change the first bulleted item in the Initiating cue block to read, Technical Specification actions are required to be entered, and if the event is reportable, the reportability requirements. Delete the second bulleted line.

• JPM step 1 standard - Add ITS 3.6.1.3 A.1 and A.2 to the list.

• Terminating Cues - Change the terminating cue to read, "Examinee has evaluated ITS and determined reponlng requirements for inoperablllty of the High Pressure Core Sorav (HPCSl Svstem".

JPM536 Editorial Steo 4 Standard - add Channel 3 to the end of the first bulleted line. Chanaed as requested.

JPM538 Editorial Step 1 Standard - soecilv reauirements for ITS 3.6.1 .3 Action A.1 and A.2 Chanaed as requested.

JPM244 Editorial

• Step 8.5.8.3 Standard - change the standard to read, "Simulates placing th e Changed as requested.

. Main Control Switch in MANUAL 1 and/or Manual 2.

Step 8.2.2 Cue - Add a cue that flow noise can be heard if requested by the examinee.

JPM451 Editorial

• Add alarms that are expected to be In to the initial conditions block. Changed as requested.

• Step 8.4.6. 1 - Add a cue that describes what alarms are in and if they are expected to reset when steo 8.4.6.1 is performed.

• .~ <Cil-*

.... ... *.~..r::

"~**"* ..

• .~.*:~~,M:~~ ~

Scenario 1 Editorial Event 4 TDRFP 'A' High Bearing Temperature - the MDRFP. is started per section Added CPS 3103.01 section 8.1.6 to the ATC actions 8.1.3 MDRFP Startup and section 8.1.6 Transition from a TORFP to a MDRFP but block.

the scenario quide onlv references section 6.1.3.

cenano 1 *---eai!Orlal -cFC'ommen! - sFiOUTd we cna

riae lo soeea i.JDCfiTeT6 lransler lo l'VJ[J~ NO reas16ie way lo ao llils=lefl as 1s.

Scenario 1 Editorial Alter computer points CW-BA027, 28, and 29 to simulator lesson plan for event #7 Added computer points to the simulator lesson plan to to add realism. cause them to ramp up - 30°F over 1Ominutes.

Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #4 - add EO cue (ii directed to raise cooling Added EO cue #6 to event 4 water flow\ - "Flow Is hiah in the band".

ILT 14-1 NRC Exam Submittal Comments Clinton Power Station Date Received: 2/13/15 ILT Class 14-1 Exam Date 3/16/1 5 Operating Test 2015-301 Item# I UnSat/Editorial I Chief Examiner Comment Facility Action/Response Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #4 - add EO cue (if directed to check Added EO cue #7 to event 4 TDRFP bearina bubbler flow) - "Bubbler flow is normal."

Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #8 - add cue from field concerning local gas Added EO cue #3 to event 8.

boundary inspections.

Scenario 1 Editorial Event Triggers and Role Play - Event #4 - add EO cue to report no abnormalities if Added EO cue #8 to event 4.

requested to check TDAFP 'A' room conditions on the camera.

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 7/8- the actions required to perform "Terminate and prevent LPCS and Added actions required to Terminate and Prevent LPCS LPCI injection" are not detailed in the scenario guide. and LPCI injection to the BOP Actions for Event 7/8 in the Scenario 2 sim auide.

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 7/8 - the crew may "Anticipate Blowdown" but those actions are not listed in Added "Anticipate Slowdown" to the ATC and SAO the scenario guide. actions block for events 7/8. Modified the PC-7.1 critical task listing in the scenario outline to indicate that a blowdown is not required if containment pressure can be lowered below EOP*6 Figure N after anticipating blowdown.

Scenario 2 Editorial The critical tasks listing on page 4 of the scenario guide needs to be revised to Revised critical task listing PC-7.1 to state, 'W ithin 10 reflect that EOP-6 does not require a blowdown on high Containment Pressure minutes of exceeding Figure N and containment unless contain.ment pressure cannot be low~red below Fig. N. pressure continuing to rise, the SAO will enter EOP*3 Emergency RPV Depressurization. If the crew Anticipates Slowdown using bypass valves, and in doing so Containment Pressure can be reduced I maintained below Fig. N, then this critical task is considered to be met. IPAA\

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 6 - the actions to terminate HPCS injection are reversed from those Swapped actions to shut 1E22-F004 and Stop the HPCS contained on the hard card. oumo in the BOP actions block of event #6.

Scenario 2 Editorial Event 4 - need to add rising trend to the CAD temperature reported from the area Added trend information to event 4 EO cue 1a.

operator.

Scenario 3 Editorial Event 6 - Validation crew swapped the running SPE blowers; those actions are not Added open bullet action to the Event 6 BOP actions listed in the Annlicant's Actions or Behavior block of the scenario auide. block.

Scenario 3 Editorial Event 8 - Validation c rew entered ITS 3.4.5 RA B.1 but the ITS reference is not Added ITS 3.4.5 to the SRO Actions block for event 8.

listed in the scenario auide.

Scenario 3 Editorial The ITS 3.1.5 pressure limit value for accumulator pressure is <: 1520 psig. In the Changed all instances of 1540 psig to 1510 psig.

scenario guide for Event #7, the accumulator pressure is reported to be 1540 psig.

Chanae the reported pressure to 1510 psig.

Scenario 3 Editorial Event B - Add SRO action to direct RR Loop emergency isolation Added to ATC & SRO actions for event #8.

Scenario 1, Editorial Add MCA Baseline data to PPG 10 in the simulator setup instructions. Added to the Simulator Operator Initial Setup 2, and 3 instructions.

• - .. . - .. -. *-