ML19344A181: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Line 24: Line 24:
;~ ~                                            ~
;~ ~                                            ~
                                                                                               ,-      //      og g                    g
                                                                                               ,-      //      og g                    g
,
     -(}                              .
     -(}                              .
UNITED STATES '0F AMERICA                                Ot      Ug 121977 > q-
UNITED STATES '0F AMERICA                                Ot      Ug 121977 > q-NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION                                  -                                    -
                                                                                                                                          -
NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION                                  -                                    -
q
q
   ~
   ~
                                                                                                               %t} **
                                                                                                               %t} **
Before the' Atomic' Safety and Licensing Board-
Before the' Atomic' Safety and Licensing Board-q, Na i
                                        -
i In the Matter of                                  )
q, Na i
i
'
In the Matter of                                  )
                                                               )
                                                               )
j'        CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY                          -)        Docket Nos. 50-329
j'        CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY                          -)        Docket Nos. 50-329
Line 43: Line 36:
1
1
;      .
;      .
A
A 1                                              MOTION TO INTRODUCE                                                                              ,
* 1                                              MOTION TO INTRODUCE                                                                              ,
j    ,                                    . ADDITIONAL EXHIBITS                                                                        .
j    ,                                    . ADDITIONAL EXHIBITS                                                                        .
:
.                          Intervenors other than Dow Chemical Company offer the following Exhibits in evidence:
.                          Intervenors other than Dow Chemical Company offer
.
the following Exhibits in evidence:
::                        la    Midland Intervenors' Group Exhibit 60A (Exhibit                                                            '
::                        la    Midland Intervenors' Group Exhibit 60A (Exhibit                                                            '
.
i' volume prepared by Dow as an attachment to Dow's Memorandum                                                                            '
i'
                                                                                                                                                  ,
volume prepared by Dow as an attachment to Dow's Memorandum                                                                            '
;
;
;          Concerning Hearing Preparation, containing Exhibits A-2) .
;          Concerning Hearing Preparation, containing Exhibits A-2) .
.
l          This is the companion volume to Midland Intervenors' Exhibit                                                                          :
l          This is the companion volume to Midland Intervenors' Exhibit                                                                          :
.
60; through oversight,.it was not included in our offer of',                                              '
60; through oversight,.it was not included in our offer of',                                              '
i-        Exhibit ~60.          All parties have copies of the volume, and we
i-        Exhibit ~60.          All parties have copies of the volume, and we offer it simply to' ensure'that it will be a formal part of
.
offer it simply to' ensure'that it will be a formal part of
  ;        the record .
  ;        the record .
i' 2.'    Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 78'(Pages 6, 7, i          and 18 -of- Dow's notes' of. a February 24, 1976 Dow-Consumers
i' 2.'    Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 78'(Pages 6, 7, i          and 18 -of- Dow's notes' of. a February 24, 1976 Dow-Consumers
;          meeting) '.      This document is attached-tc the Board's June.15,
;          meeting) '.      This document is attached-tc the Board's June.15, 11977: Memorandum concerning antitrust matters, of which all
,
           .partie's have copies. -Again, we offer it to ensure that it will; be . a formal 3 part -of theirecord.                                                                                    .
11977: Memorandum concerning antitrust matters, of which all
           .partie's have copies. -Again, we offer it to ensure that it
!                  -    -
will; be . a formal 3 part -of theirecord.                                                                                    .
'
                                                                                                                                                   \
                                                                                                                                                   \
1 40 08'O80 T / 7
1 40 08'O80 T / 7
                              -
                  ..                      .-          ..        - .        . - - - - - . -                                              - - . ,


            . . _ _ . _ _                      __                              .      -
          -                  .
i,  .,
i,  .,
T            ,
T            ,
Line 87: Line 60:
                             !!idland Daily News) .      This Exhibit, which postdates the hear-
                             !!idland Daily News) .      This Exhibit, which postdates the hear-
)                            ings. and thus could not be offered through a Consumers witness, i
)                            ings. and thus could not be offered through a Consumers witness, i
is offered to show Consumers' public admission that the cost
is offered to show Consumers' public admission that the cost of repairing the Unit 2 liner plate bulge may exceed $800,000.
,
See Tr. 3273 and. Rules 801(d)(2) and 902(6) of the Federal Rule's of Evidence. Copies of this Exhibit are attached to this Motion.                                            .
of repairing the Unit 2 liner plate bulge may exceed $800,000.
See Tr. 3273 and. Rules 801(d)(2) and 902(6) of the Federal Rule's of Evidence. Copies of this Exhibit are attached to
        ,
this Motion.                                            .
: 4. Midland Intervenors ' Exhibit 80 (Consumers '
: 4. Midland Intervenors ' Exhibit 80 (Consumers '
June 15, 1977 Interim Report concerning the Unit No. 2 liner i
June 15, 1977 Interim Report concerning the Unit No. 2 liner i
plate bulge)      This - Exhibit, which postdates the hearings, is a report filed with the Commission by Consumers; it shows that
plate bulge)      This - Exhibit, which postdates the hearings, is a report filed with the Commission by Consumers; it shows that Consumers -has not yet fully evaluated the liner plate daniage or its safety implications.        See Rules 801(d)(2) and 803(6) of the Federal Rules of Evidence. Copies of this Exhibit are attached to this Motion.                      ~
                                                                                                  '
Consumers -has not yet fully evaluated the liner plate daniage or its safety implications.        See Rules 801(d)(2) and 803(6)
,
'
of the Federal Rules of Evidence. Copies of this Exhibit are
'
attached to this Motion.                      ~
: 5. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 81-(Consumers'
: 5. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 81-(Consumers'
   .                        Document No.. 110-012, . a compilation by Consumers of the rela-    ,
   .                        Document No.. 110-012, . a compilation by Consumers of the rela-    ,
d tionship.between residential electricity bills and personal income) . This Exhibit was produced by Consumers and made
d tionship.between residential electricity bills and personal income) . This Exhibit was produced by Consumers and made
'
                           . available to all parties. . It is offered in order to ensure that.it.'is formally part of the record, and relates to demand
                           . available to all parties. . It is offered in order to ensure
'
that.it.'is formally part of the record, and relates to demand
                           ; forecasting. See Timm Testimony, p. 47.
                           ; forecasting. See Timm Testimony, p. 47.
.
4 e
4 e
                            .
                                                                -
                                                                                  .
e                                    .
e                                    .


_
L.      .
L.      .
                                                                  .
       ~      "
       ~      "
...      s                        '
...      s                        '
                                    .
: 6. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 82 (the June 17, 1977 Staff Safety Evaluation concerning Palisades) . This Exhibit, which postdates the hearings, is a "public record" within the-meanit:g of Rule 803(8).of the Federal Rules of            -
: 6. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 82 (the June 17, 1977 Staff Safety Evaluation concerning Palisades) . This Exhibit, which postdates the hearings, is a "public record" within the-meanit:g of Rule 803(8).of the Federal Rules of            -
Evidence.. It is offered to show that the Staff regards any Palisades steam generator.. tube corrosion as " effectively minimized" by recent actions., and that the Staff has agreed
Evidence.. It is offered to show that the Staff regards any Palisades steam generator.. tube corrosion as " effectively minimized" by recent actions., and that the Staff has agreed to 2 5-month deferral of further steam tube ~ inspection.
>
to 2 5-month deferral of further steam tube ~ inspection.
    -
                                        ..
                                                                                "
As indicated, these Exhibits either postdate the hearings, or consist of documents available to the parties but for one reason or another not formally offered.
As indicated, these Exhibits either postdate the hearings, or consist of documents available to the parties but for one reason or another not formally offered.
                                                                                      -
                              -
                                                                            -
            .
                                                                                            ,
                                                                                        -
                                                              .
                                                                          . .
                    ..                                                      .
                        .
One of the Attorneys for Intervenors other than Dow Chemical Company,
One of the Attorneys for Intervenors other than Dow Chemical Company,
                                                                        '
        .
                                      .
                                                                                    .
             'Myron M_. Cherry-Peter A. Flynn One IBM Plaza                                                              '
             'Myron M_. Cherry-Peter A. Flynn One IBM Plaza                                                              '
Suite 4501 Chicago,-Illinois    60611                                                    l
Suite 4501 Chicago,-Illinois    60611                                                    l
             .(312) .565-1177                                                        .l
             .(312) .565-1177                                                        .l l
                                              '
H i
l H
                                                                                  .
i
                                             ~
                                             ~
l}}
l}}

Revision as of 07:41, 31 January 2020

Motion to Introduce Addl Exhibits Re Dow Chemical Co Memorandum on Hearing Preparation & Notes from Dow-CPC 760224 Meeting
ML19344A181
Person / Time
Site: Midland
Issue date: 06/30/1977
From: Cherry M, Flynn P
CHERRY, M.M./CHERRY, FLYNN & KANTER
To:
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel
Shared Package
ML19344A177 List:
References
NUDOCS 8008060515
Download: ML19344A181 (3)
v • d • e


Text

. - _. . .- .- .. - - _ - _ _ - _ _ .

{ '-

h N j-9

~

g

~ ~ ~

,- // og g g

-(} .

UNITED STATES '0F AMERICA Ot Ug 121977 > q-NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION - -

q

~

%t} **

Before the' Atomic' Safety and Licensing Board-q, Na i

i In the Matter of )

)

j' CONSUMERS POWER COMPANY -) Docket Nos. 50-329

) 50-330 l (Midland Plant, Units 1 and 2) -)-  :

1

.

A 1 MOTION TO INTRODUCE ,

j , . ADDITIONAL EXHIBITS .

. Intervenors other than Dow Chemical Company offer the following Exhibits in evidence:

la Midland Intervenors' Group Exhibit 60A (Exhibit '

i' volume prepared by Dow as an attachment to Dow's Memorandum '

Concerning Hearing Preparation, containing Exhibits A-2) .

l This is the companion volume to Midland Intervenors' Exhibit  :

60; through oversight,.it was not included in our offer of', '

i- Exhibit ~60. All parties have copies of the volume, and we offer it simply to' ensure'that it will be a formal part of

the record .

i' 2.' Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 78'(Pages 6, 7, i and 18 -of- Dow's notes' of. a February 24, 1976 Dow-Consumers

meeting) '. This document is attached-tc the Board's June.15, 11977
Memorandum concerning antitrust matters, of which all

.partie's have copies. -Again, we offer it to ensure that it will; be . a formal 3 part -of theirecord. .

\

1 40 08'O80 T / 7

i, .,

T ,

a ]- .

e I

~3. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 79 (an artic"2 l concerning QA-QC matters which appeared in tae May 27, 1977

!!idland Daily News) . This Exhibit, which postdates the hear-

) ings. and thus could not be offered through a Consumers witness, i

is offered to show Consumers' public admission that the cost of repairing the Unit 2 liner plate bulge may exceed $800,000.

See Tr. 3273 and. Rules 801(d)(2) and 902(6) of the Federal Rule's of Evidence. Copies of this Exhibit are attached to this Motion. .

4. Midland Intervenors ' Exhibit 80 (Consumers '

June 15, 1977 Interim Report concerning the Unit No. 2 liner i

plate bulge) This - Exhibit, which postdates the hearings, is a report filed with the Commission by Consumers; it shows that Consumers -has not yet fully evaluated the liner plate daniage or its safety implications. See Rules 801(d)(2) and 803(6) of the Federal Rules of Evidence. Copies of this Exhibit are attached to this Motion. ~

5. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 81-(Consumers'

. Document No.. 110-012, . a compilation by Consumers of the rela- ,

d tionship.between residential electricity bills and personal income) . This Exhibit was produced by Consumers and made

. available to all parties. . It is offered in order to ensure that.it.'is formally part of the record, and relates to demand

forecasting. See Timm Testimony, p. 47.

4 e

e .

L. .

~ "

... s '

6. Midland Intervenors' Exhibit 82 (the June 17, 1977 Staff Safety Evaluation concerning Palisades) . This Exhibit, which postdates the hearings, is a "public record" within the-meanit:g of Rule 803(8).of the Federal Rules of -

Evidence.. It is offered to show that the Staff regards any Palisades steam generator.. tube corrosion as " effectively minimized" by recent actions., and that the Staff has agreed to 2 5-month deferral of further steam tube ~ inspection.

As indicated, these Exhibits either postdate the hearings, or consist of documents available to the parties but for one reason or another not formally offered.

One of the Attorneys for Intervenors other than Dow Chemical Company,

'Myron M_. Cherry-Peter A. Flynn One IBM Plaza '

Suite 4501 Chicago,-Illinois 60611 l

.(312) .565-1177 .l l

H i

~

l

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML19344A181&oldid=2349977"