ML091490364: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
| number = ML091490364
| number = ML091490364
| issue date = 05/06/2009
| issue date = 05/06/2009
| title = Memorandum from T. O'Hara of Usnrc to J. Richmond of Usnrc, Regarding License Renewal Inspection Activities, Feeder for Oyster Creek Generating Station, Inspection Report No. 05000219/2008007
| title = Memorandum from T. O'Hara of USNRC to J. Richmond of USNRC, Regarding License Renewal Inspection Activities, Feeder for Oyster Creek Generating Station, Inspection Report No. 05000219/2008007
| author name = O'Hara T L
| author name = O'Hara T
| author affiliation = NRC/RGN-I/DRS/PSB2
| author affiliation = NRC/RGN-I/DRS/PSB2
| addressee name = Richmond J E
| addressee name = Richmond J
| addressee affiliation = NRC/RGN-I/DRS
| addressee affiliation = NRC/RGN-I/DRS
| docket = 05000219
| docket = 05000219
Line 14: Line 14:
| page count = 9
| page count = 9
}}
}}
See also: [[followed by::IR 05000219/2008007]]
See also: [[see also::IR 05000219/2008007]]


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:MEMORANDUM  
{{#Wiki_filter:MEMORANDUM TO:             John Richmond, Inspection Team Leader
TO: John Richmond, Inspection  
                          Division of Reactor Safety
Team Leader Division of Reactor Safety THRU: John R. White, Chief Plant Support Branch 2 Division of Reactor Safety FROM: Timothy L. O'Hara, Reactor Inspector Plant Support Branch 2 Division of Reactor Safety SUBJECT: LICENSE RENEWAL INSPECTION  
THRU:                     John R. White, Chief
ACTIVITIES, FEEDER FOR OYSTER CREEK GENERATING  
                          Plant Support Branch 2
STATION, INSPECTION  
                          Division of Reactor Safety
REPORT NO. 05000219/2008007
FROM:                     Timothy L. O'Hara, Reactor Inspector
The enclosed feeder contains input for the subject report resulting  
                          Plant Support Branch 2
from inspection  
                          Division of Reactor Safety
of License Renewal Commitments  
SUBJECT:                   LICENSE RENEWAL INSPECTION ACTIVITIES, FEEDER
during the period October 13, 2008 to November 14, 2008, at the Oyster Creek Generating  
                          FOR OYSTER CREEK GENERATING STATION,
Station. The inspection  
                          INSPECTION REPORT NO. 05000219/2008007
was conducted  
The enclosed feeder contains input for the subject report resulting from inspection of
in accordance  
License Renewal Commitments during the period October 13, 2008 to November 14,
with Inspection  
2008, at the Oyster Creek Generating Station. The inspection was conducted in
Procedure  
accordance with Inspection Procedure 71003, License Renewal Commitments.
71003, License Renewal Commitments.
Cover Letter Input
Cover Letter Input No input.Enclosure:
No input.
Feeder for Oyster Creek Generating  
Enclosure:   Feeder for Oyster Creek Generating Station, Inspection Report
Station, Inspection  
              No. 05000219/2008007
Report No. 05000219/2008007
                                                                                c"f
c" f  
 
2 cc w/Enclosure: (VIA E-MAIL)John Richmond, DRS T. O'Hara, DRS DRS File SUNSI Review Complete: (Reviewer's  
                                                  2
Initials)DOCUMENT NAME: G:\DRS\PLANT  
          cc w/Enclosure: (VIA E-MAIL)
SUPPORT BRANCH 2\O'HARA\HOPECREEK-ISI-FEEDER(1-17-
          John Richmond, DRS
          T. O'Hara, DRS
          DRS File
SUNSI Review Complete:                       (Reviewer's Initials)
DOCUMENT NAME: G:\DRS\PLANT SUPPORT BRANCH 2\O'HARA\HOPECREEK-ISI-FEEDER(1-17-
08)REV4(TLO).DOC
08)REV4(TLO).DOC
After declaring  
After declaring this document "An Official Agency Record" it will not be released to the Public.
this document "An Official Agency Record" it will not be released to the Public.To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure "E"= Copy with attachment/enclosure "N" = No copy OFFICE RI/DRS 11111'S NAME TOHara/ J. White DATE 01/ /09 01/ /09 OFFICE ICI I I I11 NAME  
To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure "E"
= Copy with attachment/enclosure "N" = No copy
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS IR 05000219/2008007;  
OFFICE         RI/DRS                                                                   11111'S
10/13/2008  
NAME           TOHara/           J. White
-11/14/08;  
DATE           01/ /09           01/ /09
Oyster Creek Generating  
OFFICE                       ICI                         I I                         I11
Station;License Renewal Commitments  
NAME
Inspection;  
 
IP 71003 A. NRC-Identified  
 
and Self-Revealing  
                                SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
Findings No findings of significance.
IR 05000219/2008007; 10/13/2008 - 11/14/08; Oyster Creek Generating Station;
ii  
License Renewal Commitments Inspection; IP 71003
2 Report Details REPORT DETAILS OTHER ACTIVITIES (OA)40A2 License Renewal Follow-up (IP 71003)2. Detailed Reviews and Observations
A.     NRC-Identified and Self-Revealing Findings
2.7 Drywell Shell External Coatings Inspection (inside sand bed bays)a. Scope of Inspection
      No findings of significance.
The inspectors  
                                          ii
reviewed the licensee's  
 
visual inspection (VT) procedures, interviewed  
                                          2
nondestructive  
                                    Report Details
examination (NDE) supervisors  
                                  REPORT DETAILS
and observed field collection, recording  
OTHER ACTIVITIES (OA)
and reporting  
40A2 License Renewal Follow-up (IP 71003)
of inspection  
2.   Detailed Reviews and Observations
data which was completed  
2.7 Drywell Shell External Coatings Inspection (inside sand bed bays)
in accordance  
  a. Scope of Inspection
with the approved procedures.  
    The inspectors reviewed the licensee's visual inspection (VT) procedures,
The inspectors  
    interviewed nondestructive examination (NDE) supervisors and observed field
also reviewed a sample of the visual testing (VT) qualifications  
    collection, recording and reporting of inspection data which was completed in
of the data collection  
    accordance with the approved procedures. The inspectors also reviewed a
technicians.
    sample of the visual testing (VT) qualifications of the data collection technicians.
The inspectors  
    The inspectors reviewed a sample of the VT inspection data sheets for the sand
reviewed a sample of the VT inspection  
    bed areas from the exterior of the drywell for the inspections conducted in
data sheets for the sand bed areas from the exterior of the drywell for the inspections  
    October and November 2008. The inspectors verified that the licensee
conducted  
    completed the inspections, identified condition(s) in the exterior coating which
in October and November 2008. The inspectors  
    required repair, completed the coating repairs in accordance with engineering
verified that the licensee completed  
    procedures, and conducted appropriate re-inspection of repaired areas.
the inspections, identified  
  b. Observations
condition(s)  
    The inspector conducted a general observation (not a qualified VT inspection) of
in the exterior coating which required repair, completed  
    the repaired area and the general condition in Bay 11. The inspectors verified
the coating repairs in accordance  
    that the licensee's inspection data reports appeared to accurately describe the
with engineering
    conditions observed by the inspectors in Bay 11.
procedures, and conducted  
    The inspector also conducted a general observation (not a qualified VT
appropriate  
    inspection) of the general condition in Bay 9. The inspectors verified that the
re-inspection  
    licensee's inspection data reports appeared to accurately describe the conditions
of repaired areas.b. Observations
    observed by the inspectors in Bay 9.
The inspector  
    The inspector conducted a general observation (not a qualified VT inspection) of
conducted  
    the general condition in Bay 5. The inspectors verified that the licensee's
a general observation (not a qualified  
    inspection data reports appeared to accurately describe the conditions observed
VT inspection)  
    by the inspectors in Bay 5.
of the repaired area and the general condition  
 
in Bay 11. The inspectors  
                                          A-3
verified that the licensee's  
                                    ATTACHMENT
inspection  
                          SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION
data reports appeared to accurately  
                              KEY POINTS OF CONTACT
describe the conditions  
Licensee Personnel
observed by the inspectors  
P. Tamburro,
in Bay 11.The inspector  
J. Kandasamy, Manager Regulatory Affairs
also conducted  
C. Hawkins, NDE Level III Technician
a general observation (not a qualified  
VT inspection)  
of the general condition  
in Bay 9. The inspectors  
verified that the licensee's  
inspection  
data reports appeared to accurately  
describe the conditions
observed by the inspectors  
in Bay 9.The inspector  
conducted  
a general observation (not a qualified  
VT inspection)  
of the general condition  
in Bay 5. The inspectors  
verified that the licensee's
inspection  
data reports appeared to accurately  
describe the conditions  
observed by the inspectors  
in Bay 5.  
A-3 ATTACHMENT
SUPPLEMENTAL  
INFORMATION
KEY POINTS OF CONTACT Licensee Personnel P. Tamburro, J. Kandasamy, Manager Regulatory  
Affairs C. Hawkins, NDE Level III Technician
M. McDermott, NDE Supervisor
M. McDermott, NDE Supervisor
NRC Personnel S. Pindale, Acting Senior Resident Inspector, Oyster Creek J. Kulp, Resident Inspector, Oyster Creek LIST OF ITEMS OPENED, CLOSED, AND DISCUSSED Opened/Closed
NRC Personnel
None.Opened 05000219/2008007-01  
S. Pindale, Acting Senior Resident Inspector, Oyster Creek
URI xxx Closed None.3  
J. Kulp, Resident Inspector, Oyster Creek
A-4 LIST OF DOCUMENTS  
                LIST OF ITEMS OPENED, CLOSED, AND DISCUSSED
REVIEWED License renewal Program Documents Drawings Plant Procedures  
Opened/Closed
& Specification
None.
Specification  
Opened
SP 1302-32-035, 2/24/93; Inspection  
05000219/2008007-01       URI         xxx
and Minor Repair of Coating on Concrete & Drywell Shell Surfaces In The Sand Bed Region ER-AA-335-018, Revision 5; Detailed, General, VT-1, VT-1C, VT-3 and VT-3C Visual Examination  
Closed
of ASME Class MC and CC Containment  
None.
Surfaces and Components
                                          3
ER-AA-335-004, Revision 2; Manual Ultrasonic  
 
Measurement  
                                          A-4
of Material Thickness And Interfering  
                          LIST OF DOCUMENTS REVIEWED
Conditions
License renewal Program Documents
VT Inspection  
Drawings
Data Sheets 1 R22-LRA-084, Bay 19, 11/8/08 1 R22-LRA-083, Bay 15, 11/8/08 1 R22-LRA-082, Bay 7, 11/8/08 1R22-LRA-091, Bay 19, 11/8/08 1 R22-LRA-026, Bay 1, 10/30/08 1R22-LRA-052, Bay 3, 10/31/08 1R22-LRA-027, Bay 5, 10/29/08 1R22-LRA-054, Bay 7, 10/31/08 1 R22-LRA-028, Bay 9, 10/29/08 1 R22-LRA-046, Bay 11, 10/31/08 1 R22-LRA-035, Bay 13, 10/30/08 1R22-LRA-048, Bay 15, 10/31/08 1 R22-LRA-029, Bay 17, 10/30/08 1R22-LRA-050, Bay 19, 10/31/08 Incident Reports (IRs)00939194 00836395 00838523 00838509 00839848 Maintenance  
Plant Procedures & Specification
Requests(AR)  
Specification SP 1302-32-035, 2/24/93; Inspection and Minor Repair of Coating on
& Work Orders(WO)
      Concrete & Drywell Shell Surfaces In The Sand Bed Region
4  
ER-AA-335-018, Revision 5; Detailed, General, VT-1, VT-1C, VT-3 and VT-3C Visual
A-5 WO R2088180-07, VT Inspection  
      Examination of ASME Class MC and CC Containment Surfaces and
of Exterior Drywell Shell In Sand Bed 1, Bay 1 AR00839192
      Components
ER-AA-335-004, Revision 2; Manual Ultrasonic Measurement of Material Thickness
      And Interfering Conditions
VT Inspection Data Sheets
1R22-LRA-084, Bay 19, 11/8/08
1R22-LRA-083, Bay 15, 11/8/08
1R22-LRA-082, Bay 7, 11/8/08
1R22-LRA-091, Bay 19, 11/8/08
1 R22-LRA-026, Bay 1, 10/30/08
1R22-LRA-052, Bay 3, 10/31/08
1R22-LRA-027, Bay 5, 10/29/08
1R22-LRA-054, Bay 7, 10/31/08
1R22-LRA-028, Bay 9, 10/29/08
1R22-LRA-046, Bay 11, 10/31/08
1R22-LRA-035, Bay 13, 10/30/08
1R22-LRA-048, Bay 15, 10/31/08
1R22-LRA-029, Bay 17, 10/30/08
1R22-LRA-050, Bay 19, 10/31/08
Incident Reports (IRs)
00939194
00836395
00838523
00838509
00839848
Maintenance Requests(AR) & Work Orders(WO)
                                          4
 
                                      A-5
WO R2088180-07, VT Inspection of Exterior Drywell Shell In Sand Bed 1, Bay 1
AR00839192
AR00839185
AR00839185
AR00839188
AR00839188
Line 187: Line 194:
AR00839194
AR00839194
AR00839204
AR00839204
AR0083921  
AR0083921 1
1 AR00839214
AR00839214
5  
                                        5
A-6 NDE Certification  
 
Records NDE Certification  
                                          A-6
#1421 for M.Kent Waddell dated 10/29/08 NDE Certification  
NDE Certification Records
#0977 for Richard L. Alger dated 10/29/08 Miscellaneous  
NDE Certification #1421 for M.Kent Waddell dated 10/29/08
Documents LIST OF ACRONYMS EPRI Electric Power Research Institute NDE Non-destructive  
NDE Certification #0977 for Richard L. Alger dated 10/29/08
Examination
Miscellaneous Documents
NEI Nuclear Energy Institute SSC Systems, Structures, and Components
                                  LIST OF ACRONYMS
SDP Significance  
EPRI         Electric Power Research Institute
Determination  
NDE         Non-destructive Examination
Process TR Technical  
NEI         Nuclear Energy Institute
Report UFSAR Updated Final Safety Analysis Report SGTR Steam Generator  
SSC         Systems, Structures, and Components
Tube Rupture ISLOCA Interfacing  
SDP         Significance Determination Process
System Loss of Coolant Accident LOCA Loss of Coolant Accident NDE Non Destructive  
TR           Technical Report
Examination
UFSAR         Updated Final Safety Analysis Report
ASME American Society of Mechanical  
SGTR         Steam Generator Tube Rupture
Engineers VT Visual Testing PT Penetrant  
ISLOCA       Interfacing System Loss of Coolant Accident
Testing UT Ultrasonic  
LOCA         Loss of Coolant Accident
Testing RT Radiographic  
NDE           Non Destructive Examination
Testing ISI In Service Inspection
ASME         American Society of Mechanical Engineers
LPCI Low Pressure Coolant Injection IGSCC Inter Granular Stress Corrosion  
VT           Visual Testing
Cracking BWRVIP Boiling Water Reactor Vessel Internals  
PT           Penetrant Testing
Project NCV Non Cited Violation DMW Dissimilar  
UT           Ultrasonic Testing
metal weld EPRI Electric Power Research Institute 6
RT           Radiographic Testing
ISI           In Service Inspection
LPCI         Low Pressure Coolant Injection
IGSCC         Inter Granular Stress Corrosion Cracking
BWRVIP       Boiling Water Reactor Vessel Internals Project
NCV           Non Cited Violation
DMW           Dissimilar metal weld
EPRI         Electric Power Research Institute
                                            6
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 05:16, 14 November 2019

Memorandum from T. O'Hara of USNRC to J. Richmond of USNRC, Regarding License Renewal Inspection Activities, Feeder for Oyster Creek Generating Station, Inspection Report No. 05000219/2008007
ML091490364
Person / Time
Site: Oyster Creek
Issue date: 05/06/2009
From: O'Hara T
NRC/RGN-I/DRS/PSB2
To: Richmond J
Division of Reactor Safety I
References
FOIA/PA-2009-0070, IR-08-007
Download: ML091490364 (9)
v • d • e


See also: IR 05000219/2008007

Text

MEMORANDUM TO: John Richmond, Inspection Team Leader

Division of Reactor Safety

THRU: John R. White, Chief

Plant Support Branch 2

Division of Reactor Safety

FROM: Timothy L. O'Hara, Reactor Inspector

Plant Support Branch 2

Division of Reactor Safety

SUBJECT: LICENSE RENEWAL INSPECTION ACTIVITIES, FEEDER

FOR OYSTER CREEK GENERATING STATION,

INSPECTION REPORT NO. 05000219/2008007

The enclosed feeder contains input for the subject report resulting from inspection of

License Renewal Commitments during the period October 13, 2008 to November 14,

2008, at the Oyster Creek Generating Station. The inspection was conducted in

accordance with Inspection Procedure 71003, License Renewal Commitments.

Cover Letter Input

No input.

Enclosure: Feeder for Oyster Creek Generating Station, Inspection Report

No. 05000219/2008007

c"f

2

cc w/Enclosure: (VIA E-MAIL)

John Richmond, DRS

T. O'Hara, DRS

DRS File

SUNSI Review Complete: (Reviewer's Initials)

DOCUMENT NAME: G:\DRS\PLANT SUPPORT BRANCH 2\O'HARA\HOPECREEK-ISI-FEEDER(1-17-

08)REV4(TLO).DOC

After declaring this document "An Official Agency Record" it will not be released to the Public.

To receive a copy of this document, indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment/enclosure "E"

= Copy with attachment/enclosure "N" = No copy

OFFICE RI/DRS 11111'S

NAME TOHara/ J. White

DATE 01/ /09 01/ /09

OFFICE ICI I I I11

NAME

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

IR 05000219/2008007; 10/13/2008 - 11/14/08; Oyster Creek Generating Station;

License Renewal Commitments Inspection; IP 71003

A. NRC-Identified and Self-Revealing Findings

No findings of significance.

ii

2

Report Details

REPORT DETAILS

OTHER ACTIVITIES (OA)

40A2 License Renewal Follow-up (IP 71003)

2. Detailed Reviews and Observations

2.7 Drywell Shell External Coatings Inspection (inside sand bed bays)

a. Scope of Inspection

The inspectors reviewed the licensee's visual inspection (VT) procedures,

interviewed nondestructive examination (NDE) supervisors and observed field

collection, recording and reporting of inspection data which was completed in

accordance with the approved procedures. The inspectors also reviewed a

sample of the visual testing (VT) qualifications of the data collection technicians.

The inspectors reviewed a sample of the VT inspection data sheets for the sand

bed areas from the exterior of the drywell for the inspections conducted in

October and November 2008. The inspectors verified that the licensee

completed the inspections, identified condition(s) in the exterior coating which

required repair, completed the coating repairs in accordance with engineering

procedures, and conducted appropriate re-inspection of repaired areas.

b. Observations

The inspector conducted a general observation (not a qualified VT inspection) of

the repaired area and the general condition in Bay 11. The inspectors verified

that the licensee's inspection data reports appeared to accurately describe the

conditions observed by the inspectors in Bay 11.

The inspector also conducted a general observation (not a qualified VT

inspection) of the general condition in Bay 9. The inspectors verified that the

licensee's inspection data reports appeared to accurately describe the conditions

observed by the inspectors in Bay 9.

The inspector conducted a general observation (not a qualified VT inspection) of

the general condition in Bay 5. The inspectors verified that the licensee's

inspection data reports appeared to accurately describe the conditions observed

by the inspectors in Bay 5.

A-3

ATTACHMENT

SUPPLEMENTAL INFORMATION

KEY POINTS OF CONTACT

Licensee Personnel

P. Tamburro,

J. Kandasamy, Manager Regulatory Affairs

C. Hawkins, NDE Level III Technician

M. McDermott, NDE Supervisor

NRC Personnel

S. Pindale, Acting Senior Resident Inspector, Oyster Creek

J. Kulp, Resident Inspector, Oyster Creek

LIST OF ITEMS OPENED, CLOSED, AND DISCUSSED

Opened/Closed

None.

Opened

05000219/2008007-01 URI xxx

Closed

None.

3

A-4

LIST OF DOCUMENTS REVIEWED

License renewal Program Documents

Drawings

Plant Procedures & Specification

Specification SP 1302-32-035, 2/24/93; Inspection and Minor Repair of Coating on

Concrete & Drywell Shell Surfaces In The Sand Bed Region

ER-AA-335-018, Revision 5; Detailed, General, VT-1, VT-1C, VT-3 and VT-3C Visual

Examination of ASME Class MC and CC Containment Surfaces and

Components

ER-AA-335-004, Revision 2; Manual Ultrasonic Measurement of Material Thickness

And Interfering Conditions

VT Inspection Data Sheets

1R22-LRA-084, Bay 19, 11/8/08

1R22-LRA-083, Bay 15, 11/8/08

1R22-LRA-082, Bay 7, 11/8/08

1R22-LRA-091, Bay 19, 11/8/08

1 R22-LRA-026, Bay 1, 10/30/08

1R22-LRA-052, Bay 3, 10/31/08

1R22-LRA-027, Bay 5, 10/29/08

1R22-LRA-054, Bay 7, 10/31/08

1R22-LRA-028, Bay 9, 10/29/08

1R22-LRA-046, Bay 11, 10/31/08

1R22-LRA-035, Bay 13, 10/30/08

1R22-LRA-048, Bay 15, 10/31/08

1R22-LRA-029, Bay 17, 10/30/08

1R22-LRA-050, Bay 19, 10/31/08

Incident Reports (IRs)

00939194

00836395

00838523

00838509

00839848

Maintenance Requests(AR) & Work Orders(WO)

4

A-5

WO R2088180-07, VT Inspection of Exterior Drywell Shell In Sand Bed 1, Bay 1

AR00839192

AR00839185839185AR00839188

AR00839214839214AR00838509

AR00839211839211AR00841957

AR00843380843380AR00842325

AR00842357842357AR00837647

AR00837628837628AR00837554

AR00836367836367AR00836362

AR00837188837188AR00836802

AR00838148838148AR00837765

AR00836994836994AR00838402

AR00842360842360AR00842359

AR00842357842357AR00842355

AR00842333842333AR00842323

AR00841543841543AR00839053

AR00838509838509AR00838833

AR00839028839028AR00839033

AR00839182839182AR00839185

AR00839188839188AR00839192

AR00839194839194AR00839204

AR00839210839211

AR00839214

5

A-6

NDE Certification Records

NDE Certification #1421 for M.Kent Waddell dated 10/29/08

NDE Certification #0977 for Richard L. Alger dated 10/29/08

Miscellaneous Documents

LIST OF ACRONYMS

EPRI Electric Power Research Institute

NDE Non-destructive Examination

NEI Nuclear Energy Institute

SSC Systems, Structures, and Components

SDP Significance Determination Process

TR Technical Report

UFSAR Updated Final Safety Analysis Report

SGTR Steam Generator Tube Rupture

ISLOCA Interfacing System Loss of Coolant Accident

LOCA Loss of Coolant Accident

NDE Non Destructive Examination

ASME American Society of Mechanical Engineers

VT Visual Testing

PT Penetrant Testing

UT Ultrasonic Testing

RT Radiographic Testing

ISI In Service Inspection

LPCI Low Pressure Coolant Injection

IGSCC Inter Granular Stress Corrosion Cracking

BWRVIP Boiling Water Reactor Vessel Internals Project

NCV Non Cited Violation

DMW Dissimilar metal weld

EPRI Electric Power Research Institute

6

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML091490364&oldid=2145107"