ML20235A227
| ML20235A227 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Framatome ANP Richland |
| Issue date: | 04/20/1976 |
| From: | Brock B, Norderhaug L NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V) |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20234F575 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-86-410 IE-V-119, NUDOCS 8707080362 | |
| Download: ML20235A227 (3) | |
Text
..
s Y, s.. *
-t. ' p M;Y?g;3, % y., y v.
W e
- ,a
% fw r
1 a
$gh b ;hh Wh 1
1 w.m r:
- v,W,v,+ p c
~
+
&, s afgeJ.x.v.,., vy,q. fE&N7kNQk:h=n Q" %W.yyi:%
v wux.
4 :
. a,
,p,~,
. w.x.
3
&g.nnWls.h&:
- M" g
Qj i
hV hg%P%:Q.v(e; c
+,
uj w 'v+
~
a JJ" k w
+-
') b;@5 (Q
i
'd&l W 4 p&) g k a w h @W, myn n,
4.f '
.. @ % m m..
I w
W W 4w.
3
~
WM. mpy @M M +% @.
m.t ' e April 20,1976 F J#w t
ow
, ,3 : U W i%Msyr
'e
{
Qikkhs
$j $ N 5 h Mi M % $
U p%. h M p p ff % W NWhMf.syi&WWA%,e f &&WW$i'5MQQQ: "" '&y. A+/@&gL' R
v l& 5&hf y;iO&^f IE-V-119
&w 2 Nwa$+$
r-i a Memo to Files
..c
'"N W
- r
- b., m p/ d 4 a
1 k.k
,y>
.y-u
- a., x.4e%r m
-o 4
om
.dA;.3 TRIP REPORT: TASK FORCE OBSERVATION - EXXON NUCLEAR COMPANY e'4WiJr$p'.
e g.
w 9
'. V ?
h
-,t..e, %o @4 MARCH 25-26, 1976 c.r 3
.%e
,M W W;, W'F;N w m M :.
v%.
R A,-
i 7,
! 4.,
em,., w p..e. ;. g-n,
. f.,
p 3
.a:w. m,n@y o:b
' W. 4 f
ik l i, Entrance Interview - 9:00 a.m., March 25,1976, p...
s c,
uw- :..p
~ ":
in T V tWW n;! n:
.mL
'.." %, 4 w,., l
. T. -
y gt;,
- z...
M*W ~
e fM Exxon Attendees
- NRC Attendees
.e
..y
.y y
..g
- q.. ys.y;wy
' m. Russ Rentschler g' (g.pg
,n
'Qu.
Leo Hanson
. ::@[r Roy Nilsen E Frank Pagano W.
M %g,')
l
['
I M
i i....
L[, Y Ri L
Buddy Burste
' Barry Minnelli o
W"B2 4
M ?
4.
Rip Collings
' Don Thurman s
i Don Joy
~.
Y i W j~
John Jaech T.
- t. ;.
f' Len Mercer
, Buddy Brock
,4 N
Dick Schneider LeRoy Norderhaug
% d i, u;d Tony Kraft 14 4;,
+
(
4];~'
gy;(mic '
Scope S
r ge l k M J.'
After a round of introductions, Russ Rentschler described the purpose w
, [lh+,.3 Rh M N P 'of the meeting as follows:
I a.,
w, g ia m
.x
'., eA E, y T, f.
'LI.. Material control and security assessment.
m
,m
,+>. 2.,.s.. m.<
s
... ~.
. 2.
Not an inspection, although group findings and observations
, n. 9 1
may be explored at a later date during formal IE inspection.
QS g.,
,7
~
- s..
"+
3.
Assessment of adequacy of licensce systens to meet current
, Un
~
regulatory reyoirements.
..u.
.w J.
4.
Observations and findings related to upgrading as may in
. "P the future be necessary as a result of GESMD or public comments on 10 CFR 73.55.
~
9.>3._
870700(G62 870701 3 W' Copy 3. d
._,3..._.. m;m PDR FOIA SKINNER 86-410 PDR
)...pc::c
".a'~.,,~.
- "~
IE:V W.-
rs.nc.v
" ^L
- M NORDERHAUG:jz
., '1, s
M s
m mm mmm.a
.u n:t
'y 7.
,y..
&yyq:uhw W:n
- m.,
- q
+
u' w
m.},k
. 'y. ;>,,
( #.'
U-a.my- - -
. s wd. y g 4w W.m n'yy,yAg-a m.; 3. n.,.s., m,,
s
<?
p.
,n s
.c M qf%2 &!,w.
n p;s. s vat;.,n :,. e,.sd h j ',e'. b,/f*M:r k,y, A..
. ~<
t:
If r E 9dif +=
C*;
h fN k b S. j;,h t.
t u
.'o
.~
n:
a x v..
5 v
wm 4 # # $w =.
r~ u;i'7 W
n re 4 m,
u
. e,
- u m
'.g. ~. ~
.,w,..g :t m
w.
,.&. a &w,v 7
s v
6:r% &m;s
,% Q i $l %g ; f. 3],;.rin)(,
j' & -
{*1
~c KY*
fp' f: pkh D
Y lgm., QaQ Y'
Q-i;f TQ h,'
- g. m, ;,
- /
%.e
,~ _
$y a m.,,yl?sk..:pQ[
9 t
,c'
.mn J WM #n:.;,,vw.rNW D -
.,u af.6 L y#g:. s....m..
p P.S ?
. April 20, 1976 W:
o:-
w :q o.n ;f g( g m :yM.QM,N[T$pp Y*;Z[+n'g.N, u.. -
' 4. ) ;( 'r,;h5 ^ h,hidhi"
,7 I
' h,.
" f M.. s[ }t *.,. d, y ;,
Ahw m.w.,. s y 5 y,.;..
we Md I
- r. : n
/:j
, M M,:
-Wy g
. v.. A%.qW.,
w@
st,
M C '," p. w., c %y.. p v. u.
W,. f m
4 wmgx
.m.p+.e;ng % g-t
. WiumRw.u e
w :w' "%w#" Sr IE-V-119 ' r 4 ' N pa y
p g
a UWW
.7 Memo to Files
' 7 7. ~, *
'b.C
, A ;m p.,,r,.%.
4
. wg -
n.
4 4
r,;mp~ g,.
i WQ.
.,u p OTRIP REPORT: TASK FORCE OBSERVATION - EXXON NUCLEAR COMPANY
.y WJ W@pAm -
sten, @4g,g.
m A N N
MARCH 25-26, 1976 4e.
M 4c;e;yM.a,,n, v.
,u,%
4.;
m.
4 A g; 6
n.3.;,x q%,M e n p
Fh,.w%..
4.e. m;~ r Entrance Interview - 9:00 a.m., March 25, 1976 i 4
> !: e m y _a m s o
s 4
u,.
P.c 74 63 AW.9M' Exxon Attendees NRC Attendees 1, ;'9? W#@ ' % -
c p,(
-. e u s.,
n..
9.
m
..l.;r.yf 7.
g,
. j j%<s.;. E. '
,. a ;
7
-c o
- i i.
d Russ Rentschler
?'n * *
- p i Leo Hanson e*
- v*
1%
- il Roy Nilsen Frank Pa ano WPC,<.
.c a e Buddy Burste
,Barry Minnelli
~
i X.
v W} g #
sh.,,. '
Y, Rip Collings Don Thurman Si
", i l
John Jaech Don Joy f
. Buddy Brock 7'
4 Len Mercer
?
Dick Schneider LeRoy Norderhaug
?. h' Tony Kraft te t,.
p1.. rF Scope
.o%:%_._ y,
~
"1 p
. M.
.g
- .c.>
d.i M:J.
After a round of introductions, Russ Rentschler described the purpose
$h4
-of the meeting as follows:
, Q +}, ;a y$ ev&m
" L. ya c
9,
e-y.j M.
.i j 1.
Material control and security assessment.
a s
'E., c,
w, v.
'c 2.
Not an inspection, although group findings and observations L.
.may be explored at a later date during formal IE inspection.
W F. c.
O k
3.
Assessment of adequacy of licensee systens to meet current regulatory rmirements, wg 4.
Observations end findings related to upgrading as may in the future be necessary as a result of GES@ or public comments on 10 CFR 73.55.
- v..x,..
.,'.Y EAN -
w 8707000362 B70701 Cor.y...,3. d..J.~..... cc i :
)...po-
'~~
IE:V ra.'..e.v
. a.,,
NORDERHAUG:jz y
c.
_,, xne.t
o
.c-
. *d Ap@h i-s a;a. m,
y.. %* -
, $,,.R $ $.N b
~
i[Nh.he.h2
< w-Q v -
)
.Q jj p '. V *
)
e
)
5%R d:aN
~
!&f&py.N Nrno to Files 9 April 20,1976 Wips.;-
' rf
',gg Q3-o 9y g
, w y.,..sg
)
hfdhkhjh *'C'
,8 #: Basis % %
j,, T > + p '
l 4V? ?
W %
?
2%
, ]& M $: A
~
?
l C
f.g,,. m:
c x;.,
n j
6L.,$a; TThe basis a ainst which judgments are raade will be the hypothetical "f,$m, QEf.
c
.g G
- 1) one trusted employee normally having access to SNM; Tn p,M. and (2)f' the facility interior,three armed individu
{
.Q 0;~threatsof e
MW t
- 1 edge o g.p gW7;. qpeDif, d6 g
i nw
, 3. 4 #
. n.3,g F,w '<,,, 4 ~ +... q,;a
.s,,4 e
px; A; Sy s
s!: if W,, ' Question to be Answered ~ ~9 % * *' P., q p O g,,a 3y g %p4
'W s k "Sf#
vrt!N '
3 k y_h?@ D M "PMMCould an adversary (group) succ i
x: %::
~
g i-32 2
T
$hkacts over a period of a year? art 73" materials in a single 9
- zg
),
3g<
j <j/
kas%ph.,h f i Exit Meeting - 1:00 p.m., March 26, 1976 ) M.X -
@' UMY$ @N N
Ry
, wgMy;ppp@7$ ~
x c QQ
$p ' 7 '" After a day and one-half and one night of observations, inter and discussions, the following findings were presented at an exit h,,
4.-
o r
2, K*'
briefing attended by those who had attended the entrance int rtiew ]1 6 fq'~9{..
j.
and also including Walt Hampson, Don Cornell and Marv Schnet le
'r Ws is W
- all of Exxon.
.n 3s
. v.
T ' gy
,,w T
Findings and Recommendations o,
.o
.6 J. Written commitment needed between Exxon and LLEA (Richland m-AJ Police Department).
E 4
5-
- . Sufficient handguns should be available to arm each member hd4 p.9. d.of the security force on duty,
[I y
y, o y ' w; ' +
m w%e M P.M.A shotgun or scattergun should be available.
O Q
e m.w.0.
g:g y
.7 g J.@ P
. Single guard response to alarm will not be sufficient in about N.
f..'
-'O
~
4 six months when new requirements are expected.
W W
W N '97 l
~
ye s II "s
, r.
.,~.
n x..
- c f, 9:,'8'~
.Too much activity in primary central alarm station (PCAS).
q w
VC> -
GDoor between " interrogation" corridor end PCAS it. riccFed too
~ '
much of the time.
g-y
. Communication checks with LLEA should be each shift which, while
' a 'n net.
'4 @
currently not allowed, may change when LLEA has its own radio k e..
. Roof of production area is of sufficient. penetration resistance
'[
f assuming motion detector sensitive to entry from roof. Assumption should be checked.
j r_
4 a.
c r % ;;Tp: n D:3:,
Q.j;5 xf.ma w:sO 4GsbyMT @g
,y
.y 4"
~
.q : Q,cy +/g ' r.4 g
^
fgirpg l
~ A b ^- l ?
,w GdW
.v...
n-
%,.r. %,f).;$ "!y f f ?.
- UV ) /Un 1r i?
I
.vt.m, fm...w; :,
w
+,m,
e w'
- m. s.
w 3m....- y
, W hn % k,~~i'flA, f g %o F
t DU 8
,h,..ixx. ~.h.h k:N
~
o
~% Y^
Yh.n2gp:hhhN
.v i
l N @ N N N to File
' di
> "-3--
April 20,$ k M f M !U 1
d[$ 4 w?nu.4 v.- N-J.itdFr@ N '
%ft y:n
! P%
- r" Mynp.,,iu."
q:pppwn.s.va k
A n'bt I detector at SNM doorway monitor should be provided tkhhhk
!f@- t.
k.
yMQiik..ct shields smuggled in or fabricated within protected a LN % M W cete y;@O.g@%w;%e. Local annunciation n..
./s.>
2 e w
@M N NM82. 7,.
.A w
$:e M.aiams. 42..
MKiins.M;m ko M *m;m':F M% p%C # W
~
' t i:Q Q 5$ P i $ ;j k
$@f3%g'Mh[jBadge pass-through in PCAS.should be eliminat dd%
U t hfi W n W ' >'
NM2nd W A" i&
y
,,o nyp.-n:,q.;,,, p,jd A
i d h ld be upgraded to meet UL-752.
' " d W40.dYyq
}m &.. W W.. !d. b...PC S w n ows s ou
. W
. ~ ~
W '.dipU Mee I4 o,M 4 % An SNM search with a radiation detector is needed in any area
,'Et'* 9# where an alarm has been triggered to assure that secreted SNM MJGOn :
?
1
? Q
+ " W N is detected.
C M'7M.v.
,w n wrq n
o o;,.,,y,3.-*, :y H.Q.') -H,
},p}Q}P j'y
+
~ w:k's r9,,{':Qg N
e J.
. ?
y; jw-c -
- 4 g.;j
,,q.-
r,4..? t, L <
, ] y) l"
$n//
h,i <
1.,
- Q' L(J -
y
~j>,hw 1
9 4
,s F
e n.
e a.
C' }
- 8. Brock
~L. Norderhaug o-Chemist Chemist R-(.
?
~
,.0 me. e
.h-6
}..
. ~...
t.edd"e$a&'
jl
- nt 3.y. -.p
'%e W
4.*~._
,.e l-
.t.
k.
?
- trl,
- ef '
is,
e.? y s
?$. '
- 0$.
f~
}:@.w~w-
,lp " *
.w.
. e.
~...
q;] p
- *'s r
'.A ls.i ' $ a t,
, i
(
.iTi[
I
~.'[..'l., + h',,
i
- t y el, 6.
,y.'a s'
),
, ay 1. J ~ *" {j r.
,.8 Y
I
, $', g[
6
- g
,,.i 4
' ab l:
-, j :;
> t :;
t,',E. *
'bg,,
s wr
- 4
,.'? ;
s -
,.i p.&
's'*'L,.
f1f
.s g
,; *y w
e + es e-
'u wr-
- i ME e.
,dg W
a I
3:.
i.
u, w. :~;&
j -.
~
?
' <%. s,a. m,,.3.;2.
. n., a..
a.,-
-+.
g,.
'I 6'
b,h,* j '
h 4
y s
,,