ML20235A227
| ML20235A227 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Framatome ANP Richland |
| Issue date: | 04/20/1976 |
| From: | Brock B, Norderhaug L NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V) |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20234F575 | List:
|
| References | |
| FOIA-86-410 IE-V-119, NUDOCS 8707080362 | |
| Download: ML20235A227 (3) | |
Text
. . -__-_ _ _ _ _
, :- s
-t Y, s . . *
. ' p 'M;Y?g;3 , %W v.
e , :,a y., y
- 1 a r
% fw b ;hh Wh 1 w.m
$gh 1
wux r:
~ + , c
. w.x. - v ,W,v,+ p .
v -
3
, 4 : .a, ,p ,~ ,
g Qj '%.; <
- M" %
w i
&,hg%P%:Q.v(e; hV sa JJ"afgeJ k '
.x.v.-
c
, vy,q.
+, Q" %W.yyi:
fE&N7kNQk:h=n
-. &g.nnWls.h&:
+- uj w 'v+
~
i (Q ')wb;@5 4 .f W 'd&l mynW 4 p&) g k a . W 4w w . :.
3 n,
' h @W,
.. @ % m m..
~ . .,
April 20,1976 F J#w m.t ' e I
'e { ow " t -
U WM. mpy @M M +% @.,3 : U W i%Msyr .
Qikkhs R $j $ N 5 h Mi M % $
NWhMf.syi&WWA%,e -
v p% . h M p p ff % W
'&y.y;iO&^f A+/@&gL' l&&w5&hf a ;r:f &&WW$i'5MQQQ: ""
r-i a b ., m p/om d4 Memo to Files - -o..c -
'"N 4
,y>
W IE-V-119
.y-u ,
- a. , x.4e%r 1 2 Nwa$+$ m
- g. w 9 e.dA;.3 k.k TRIP REPORT: TASK FORCE OBSERVATION - EXXON NUCLEAR COMPANY e'4WiJr$p' .
R MARCH 25-26, 1976 M :.
'. V ? .%e h c.r A,- -,t..e, %o @4! 4 .,
v%. ,Mem, W W;, ., wW'F;N p..e. w;. mg-i .
3 n, . f., , , ,. ,
p 7,
' W. m 4 ,n@y 3 ik l i , Entrance Interview - 9:00 a.m., March 25,1976 , p. ..
.a:w. s fo:b uw- :. .p c,
n: ~ ":
n;!
.mL - '
in. T. -
T V tWW y gt; , z. ..
- e. .y fM Exxon Attendees
.e* NRC Attendees ' .." % M*W , , 4 w,., ~ l
.y y q.. ys .,.y;wy
..g . ,
,n g' 'Qu.
(g.pg W. .
Leo Hanson ,
' m. Russ Rentschler '
['
I . ::@[r M Roy Nilsen E Frank Pagano MRi%gL ,')
l L[ , Y ' Barry Minnelli '
i i. . . . - Buddy Burste ,
o M ? : s 4. ., Rip Collings ' Don Thurman " 4 i W Y j~ ,
John Jaech
- Don Joy '
~.
W"B2 i
,4 T. Len Mercer , Buddy Brock
- t. ; . f' LeRoy Norderhaug N Dick Schneider d Tony Kraft '
% 14 i, 4;,u;d
+ 4];~' .-
(
S ge gy;(mic ' >
Scope r
%, , , w .
l k M J .' After a round of introductions, Russ Rentschler described the purpose -
I Rh M N P 'of the meeting as follows: a.,
, , [lh+, .3 w, g ia m .
. . .x y,+>.T,2. f.
'LI. . Material control and security assessment. ,m
,, ' ., eA E, m .
,.s.. m; .< s
, n. 9
...~.
1
> . 2. Not an inspection, although group findings and observations g.,
~
,7 ,
may be explored at a later date during formal IE inspection. QS .. --
- s. .
"+ '
, Un
~ 3. Assessment of adequacy of licensce systens to meet current regulatory reyoirements. ..
.w
- u. J.
- 4. Observations and findings related to upgrading as may in the future be necessary as a result of GESMD or public . "P comments on 10 CFR 73.55. ~
9.>3._ .
870700(G62 870701 3 W' -
PDR SKINNER 86-410 FOIA PDR Copy 3.d ._,3..._.. m;m
)...pc::c
- "~
IE:V rs.nc.v ".a'~.,,~. " _
W.-
NORDERHAUG:jz
" ^L
- M -
.,- '1, . .. s m mm mmm.a M .
. s , . _
.u n:t **'
7 . ,y.. 'y
- q w&yyq
- uhw W:n u'
,. , m. , +
m .} ,k . 'y . ;>, , s
( #.' <
a.my- - -
U- ,
, . s wd. y g 4w W p.
,n.m
<? n'yy,yAg- ..
,, am s
.; 3. n.,.s.,
.c C*;
m,,
5 v h fN k b S. j;,h t.
wm:, . e,.sd h j ',e'. b,/f*M:r
. ~< t:
a If r E 9dif +=
x v. . .'o .~ Mn: qf%2 &!,w.
t u
. e, n p;s W . s vat;.,n n m w.
, -, r~ u;i'7 k,y,
' .g . ~. ~
v A .. ,
- u 4re#m4# m,7$w =su .
, .,w,. .g :t '
~c
- .. D 6:r%
KY* &m;s fp' f: pkh
, j'.&. &a -&w,v {*1
- g . m, ; ,
,% Q i $l %g ; f. 3],;.rin)( ,
,~ _
%.e Q-i;f TQ h,'
- /
Y lgm., QaQ
$y ,c' 9
Y' a m.,,yl?sk. .:pQ[ u J.mn t ,
WM #n:.;,,vw .rNW D -
W:af.6 L y#g: .ps..P.S ..m ..? . ' . April 20, 1976 o:-
y,7 ;, we
- r. : n Ahw y ,.;..
m.w .,. s y 5
/:j w I:q o.n $
g ;f g( g m
' h, .
%; :yM.QM,N[T$pp
' 4. ) ;( 'r,;h5 ^ h,hidhi" Y*;Z[+n'g ", M f M. M . s[ Md
.N, u
}t-Wy *..., -. d,( I w@ . v.. A%.qW.,
st ,
m 4
ea pC '," p . w ., c %y.. p v.guW,.
. WiumRw.u f ,
wmgx .m.p+.e ;ng % pa g- yt w :w' "%w#" Sr IE-V-119 ' r 4 ' .N wgUWW M .
' 7 7 . ~, *
.7 Memo to Files
'b.C .y r,;mp~
. ,u p g, . ,, . .
4 , 4
- n. i .
, A ;m p.,,r 4
A OTRIP REPORT: TASK FORCE OBSERVATION - EXXON NUCLEAR COMPANY WQW@pAm WJ . %.-
M sten, N @4g,g. N MARCH 25-26, 1976 m.
4e. 6p 4 % A g; 4.; 4c;e;yM.a,,n, %
%, v. ,u,% , ,,,,, e n m Fh m,s .w%..
7 4 4.e.
u,. .'m;~s r Entrance Interview - 9:00 a.m., March 25, 1976 i
": P.c 4 n.3.;,x
> !: e m y _a q% o ,M 4 63 ,
A '
c p,( >
W.9M' Exxon Attendees %
NRC Attendees 1, ;'9? - . W#@ e u s., '%-
n.. 9. o m ..l.;r.yf ,
,. a; g, 7 -c
. : i 7.
e* Russ Rentschler i . d
- ?'n * * .
- p i
- il Leo Hanson Roy Nilsen Frank Pa ano *v* . j j%<s 1% .; . E. '
~ ..
Buddy Burste ,Barry Minnelli -
WPC,< .
i X. .c a e ,
vSiW} g #
- sh . , , . ' Y, Rip Collings Don Thurman ;
John Jaech Don Joy <
l
", i f 4 :. ,
Len Mercer <
. Buddy Brock LeRoy Norderhaug 7'
? Dick Schneider
?. h' Tony Kraft , , . ,
t, . te ~
p p1 .. rF ._ y Scope "1 ,
.g .o%:%_
- .c .>
. M.
d.i M:J. After a round of introductions, Russ Rentschler described the purpose , ,
y$ $h4 -of the meeting as follows: -
, Q +}, ;a y.j ev&m 9, e- ,
c
- 1. Material control and security assessment. -
a " L.s ya M. w,
.i j . . .<
'c v. 'E., c ,
Not an inspection, although group findings and observations
- 2. ,
L. .may be explored at a later date during formal IE inspection. W;,F.. c..
O k 3. Assessment of adequacy of licensee systens to meet current w
regulatory rmirements, g
- 4. Observations end findings related to upgrading as may in '
the future be necessary as a result of GES@ or public comments on 10 CFR 73.55. v. .x,. .
. ,'.Y 8707000362 B70701 w EAN - .-
PDR FDIA Cor.y . ..,3 . d ..J.~..... cc i :
SKINNER 86-410 PDR
)...po-
"' '~~
IE:V ra.'. .e .v .
. a ., , * ; .-
NORDERHAUG:jz y
_ ,, xne.t
- , c.
o
.c- . *d, _
Ap@ha;a. m ,
i- .
. , . . s
) %' .Q jj p '. V * ~
) e y .. %* -
< w-Q v -
) 5%R i[Nh.he.h2
$,,.R $ $.N b d:aN ' ~
!&f&py.N
$ Nrno to Files 9 o
April 20,1976 Wips.;-
g , w y., . .sg .
. 9y ' ,gg Q3- )
?
' rf 4V? ? W %
hfdhkhjh ,8 *'C' 2%M $: A
~
? l
- Basis % % j ,, T > + p ' l , ]&
C f.g , , . m: c -
x;., c
, n .
.g j
TThe basis a ainst which judgments are raade will be the hypothetical "f ,$mG , QEf .
e 6L.,$a; 0;~threatsof 1) one trusted employee normally having access to SNM; Tn -
.Q MW
{
g i p ,M. t
- 1 edge and o (2)f' the facility interior,three g.p gW7; . qpeDif, - armed individu d6 s
nw 3. 4 #
. n.3,g F ,w '<,,, 4 ~ +.. . q,;a .s,,4 e Sy px; A;
'W s g
3 s!: if W,, ' Question to be Answered ~ ~9i k% "Sf#
~ ' -
- *'3yP., g %p4 x: %:: q p O g vrt!N
, ,a '
2 k y_h?@ D M "PMMCould an adversary (group) i-32 Tsucc j <j/ $hkacts over a period of a year?
, ; zg art 73" ), 3g< materials in a single a 9
N kas%ph. ,h f i Exit Meeting - 1:00 p.m., March 26, 1976 @' UMY$ ) M .X -@N Ry ; .
x c QQ
$ , wgMy;ppp@7$ ~
h,, $p ' 7
$ '" After and a day discussions, and the one-half following and findings wereone night presented of at observations, an exit r o 4.- inter 2, briefing attended by those who had attended the entrance int rtiew K*'
fq'~9{..
- j. 'r and also including Walt Hampson, Don Cornell and Marv Schnet le ]1 6 is W :all of Exxon. ,
.n - , ,
Ws T ' gy ,,w ,, , ,
3s '
. v. ,
T Findings and Recommendations ,
o ,
.o , .6 .
- J. Written commitment needed between Exxon and LLEA (Richland ".
m- AJ Police Department). E 4
% & 5- :. Sufficient handguns should be available to arm each member <
[Ihd4 p.9 .md.of the security force on duty, .
y y, w%e M P .M.A shotgun or scattergun should be available.
, oOy ' w; ' +
Q ,.
e m .w .0 . ; g:g y
.7 g J.@ P . Single guard response to alarm will not be sufficient in about N.
W
~
4 six months when new requirements are expected. W f . ye.' s -'O W"s N '97 l II
, r.
.,~ .
- c
' ~
n x ..
f, q 9:,'8'~
.Too much activity in primary central alarm station (PCAS).
- w ,
~'
VC> - '
GDoor between " interrogation" corridor end PCAS it. riccFed too
- much of the time. '
y - .
g-
' . Communication checks with LLEA should be each shift which, while #
.; currently not allowed, may change when LLEA has its own radio '4 @
' a 'n , net. -
k e. .
. Roof of production area is of sufficient. penetration resistance '[
f assuming motion detector sensitive to entry from roof. Assumption should be checked. j
_ l r_ 4 c a.
rxf.ma
% ;;Tp: n D:3:, , . , Q.j;5
^
.q : Q,cy +/g ' r.4
.y ~
4"
w:sO 4GsbyMT @g g
,y
~ A b ^- l ? : ,w GdW fgirpg l
.v n- ... .
fm . . ;mw.w;. s:, . .
+ ,m ,
% f,.r. F e w' % ,f).;$ "!y f f ?. - UV ) /Un 1r i?
DU I .vt.m, w 3m... .- y .
8g %o t
.v . .-
,W o hn % k,~~i'flA,~ -
,h,. .ixx. ~.h.h k:N .
i
~% Y^
. Yh.n2gp:hhhN 1
' di > "-3-- -
April 20,$ k M f M !U l N 4@
d[$ %ft w?nu.4 N Mynp.,,iu."
N y:n N to File ! P%
- r" v.- N-J.itdFr@ N '
q:pppwn.s.va
! k A n'bt I detector at SNM doorway monitor should be provided tkhhhk
!' f@- t. LN % yMQiik..ct M W cete .: shields smuggled
, n .. in or fabricated
./s.> 2e - within w protected ar '
- k. @M N NM82. 7,.
y;@O.g@%w;%e.
$:e dd% U t hfi W n W ' >'
M.aiams. 42. . ~
Local annunciation MKiins.M;m ko M *m;m':F M% p%C # W NM2nd W A" i&
.A w k
s
' t i:Q Q 5$ Peliminat i $ ;j
$@f3%g'Mh[jBadge <
y pass-through . , ..
in PCAS.should
. ,,o be nyp .-n:,q.; , , , p,jd A i d h ld be upgraded to meet UL-752. ' " d W40.dYyq I4 -
.W W '.dipU Mee :,
1 }m &.. 4 %W W.. !d. b...PC S w n ows s ou
. ~ ~
o- ,M ?
An SNM search with a radiation detector is needed in any area
? Q
,'Et'* 9# where an alarm has been triggered to assure that secreted SNM MJGOn :
+" W n N
wrq e J.
nN is detected. :
o
,' ,wM'7M.v. ,',
C '.
o; ,. , ,y ,3.-* , :y H .Q.') -H,
- 4
.? },p}Q}P~ w:k's -
j'y r9,,{':Qg
. c -
y; jw-
, ,q .- r,4..? t, , ] y)
+ * ' ' ' '
, L< g.;j
- h,i < 1.,
, l" *
. ;Q' ~j> ,hw
$n//1 L(J 9- 4 F
y
e n.
e
,s >-
a.'
C' "' '
~L. Norderhaug
} o-
. 8. Brock Chemist Chemist ,
. . R- ~
(. ?
,.0 me. e 6
% .h-'
}. .
.~...
jl t.edd"e$a&' -
3.y. .p- *nt >
- W
'%e 4.*~._ , .e l- - .. ..
k.
?
- trl, - ef ' is , e.? y s .
.t .
f~ ?$. '
- 0$ . ,
.w.
~ ...
q;] p }:@.w~ .' w- ,
. e.
- *'s r '.A ** ( , i ,lp " *
.iTi[ ls.i ' $ a t , ' I
.'[. .)'l.,..., + h',,
i
~,y.'a
@ s' *t , ay 1.
y el , 6.
- J ~ *" {j r .
,.8 -
, ,.i 4 Y I
, , $' , g[ 6
- g
' ab l:
> t :;
.' -, j :;
t,',E .
- wr '
'bg,, .
s
- 4-
,.'? ;
s-
, .i
-%-, p .&
's'*'L,. f1f
.s g ,; *y w e + es e-
'u wr- :i ME
- e. ,dg
- W -
a >
<-, I
- i. u, 3:. l j - .
~
w . :~;& '
?
- ;.. .. ,. .*n. ., a.. '
<%. s ,a. m,,.3.;2.
. g,. . a.,- ,
-+. .
4 ,
y s 'I 6' b,h,* j ' ' * .
h .