ML20128K579
| ML20128K579 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Davis Besse  |
| Issue date: | 07/01/1985 |
| From: | Jordan E NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
| To: | Taylor J NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE) |
| References | |
| NUDOCS 8507110063 | |
| Download: ML20128K579 (39) | |
Text
r MEMORANDUM FOR: James M. Taylor, Director Office of Inspection and Enforcement FROM: Edward L. Jordan, Director Division of Emergency Preparedness and Engineering Response Office of Inspection and Enforcement
SUBJECT:
DAVIS-BESSE INCIDENT - JUNE 9, 1985 The attached transcription of NRC Operations Center recordings of conver-sations of the Headquarters Operations Officer with Davis-Besse Personnel, Region III staff and the Emergency officer is provided for your information.
By copy of this memo, with attachment, the transcript is also being provided to the Public Document Room.
Edward L. Jordan, Directcr Division of Emergency Preparedness and Engineering Response Office of Inspection and Enforcement cc: w/ attachment W. J. Dircks, EDO H. R. Denton, NRR J. G. Keppler, RIII C. J. Heltemes, AE00 ACRS PDR DISTRIBUTION
'"': DCS ,: ,
l DEPER R/F l IRB R/F
' CERossie RHVollmer ELJordan SASchwartz KEPerkins RFPriebe MHHawkins J
I IR hER:IE IR PER:IE IRB:y R:IE DD:DEPER:IE MH (ins: amw RF be KEPdiQ@ns SASchwartz
}// 85 f/ /85 ~fl\/85 }/ /85 I 0:DEPER:IE j ELJordan
i i
i s .
This is a transcript of the telephone conversations of the Headquarters Opera-tions Officer concerning the Davis Besse incident that took place on June 9, 1985. These conversations took place between the hours of 0211 through 0851.
Although every effort has been made to accurately transcribe the original taped conversations, this may not be a verbation text due to low volume, interfer-ence, or unintelligible recordings.
02:11:30 A = Headquarters Operations Officer B = Licensee (A) NRC. a deleted).
(B) This is (name deleted) at Davis Besse in Ohio.
(A) Yes.
(B) We just recently had a trip. We had a main feed pump trip; we had a com-plete aux feed pump trip. We've got the aux feed pumps back now and the plant appears to be stable.
(A) Yeah, what was the cause of the reactor trip?
(B) It's undetermined right now, but the MSIV's both closed and as far,as I know that's... that's what we know as far as the initiating event, at the moment. The shift supervisor might know more; I don't.
(A) Okay, I'll need to know what vould be the cause of the reactor trip once you determine it.
(B) Okay.
06/13/85 1 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT a
(A) Do you have a time for the reactor trip?
(B) Hang on just a second. .. 0133.
(A) Okay; so you said that your main feedwater pumps tripped?
(B) The main feedwater pumps tripped; the aux feedwater pumps either failed to initiate or tripped. At any rate, they weren't running when I came in.
(A) Okay, have you determined what the cause of that problem was?
(B) What's that?
(A) Have you determined what the cause of the aux feedwater pump trip is?
(B) No, we haven't.
(A) Okay, is that still under investigation?
(B) That's still under investigation. They seem to be, seem to be controlling okay right now though, manually, so.....
(A) .0kay. And what was the cause of the main feedwater pumps tripping? Do you know?
(B) That we don't know. We had been having trouble with them before and we have a whole lot of the instrumentation attached there. It will be hours before we get to investigating that, so... We also don't have, we broke condenser vacuum because of drop in steam header pressure while we were trying to get back off the aux feed pump.
(A) Anything else unusual or not understood?
(B) Not anything that I can really think of right now. I gotta get your name
- now.
06/13/85 2 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
(A) My name is (name deleted).
(B) What was it?
(A) (Name deleted). That's spelled (name deleted)...
(B) (Name deleted)...
(A) ...(name deleted)...
(B) ...I didn't...
(A) Okay, that's (name deleted). (Name deleted).
(B) All right. (Name deleted)... I just can't hear you real well. (Name deleted)...
(A) ...(name deleted). (Name deleted). (Name deleted).
(B) Okay.
(A) Okay, what was the power prior to the trip?
(B) What was the power at the time of the trip?
(A) Right.
(B) I believe about 90%.
(A) 90%. And you're in Mode 3 right now?
(B) Ah...
(A) Hot shutdown?
06/13/85 3 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
(B) Yeah, I believe so.
(A) Okay. And you're calling this under a notification of 50.72?
(B) I don't know what the notification number would be.
(A) Yeah, I'll need to know that. I need why you're calling this in.
(B) Uh, that's uh, that I don't know. You're talking about CFR numbers?
(A) I need to know why you're notifying me. Are you declaring an unusual Event?
(B) Yeah. We do have an unusual event.
(A) Okay, that is very important, I need to know that. Okay, what time did you declare this an Unusual Event?
(B) What's that? (Note: He appears to be talking to control room personnel).
(A) What time did you declare this--
(B) Hold that. We haven't declared an Unusual Event. We are just in the pro-cess of evaluating it.
(A) Okay, so you are not, did not declare an unusual event.
(B) Yeah.
(A) Okay, so you're saying the plant is stable right now?
(B) The plant appears to be stable right now. I'll get back to you as soon as I find a little more on this.
(A) Okay. Thanks a lot.
06/13/85 4 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
) .
(B) Uh-huh.
(A) Goodbye.
(A) Wait, hold it for a minute there! You called the resident inspector on this?
(B) Uh, I don't know about that yet. I can, I'll inquire and if we haven't I'll make sure he's notified.
(A) Okay, good enough. Thank you.
(B) Uh-huh.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
02:15:37 06/13/85 5 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
4 f
The next telephone conversation occurs at 02:17:00 and is a notification by the
- Operations Officer to the Regional Duty Officer. This conversation is inter-rupted at 0218 by a call back from the Licensee A = Headquarters Operations Officer B = Licensee C = Regional Duty Officer (C) Hello.
(A) (Name deleted), this is (name deleted), Headquarters.
(C) Yes.
(A) Davis Besse took a reactor trip at 0133.
(C) Okay, let me get to the other phone so I can take this information down, okay?
(A) Okay.
[There is a pause on the tape here]
I (C) That okay?
(A) Okay. They took a reactor trip, the cause is still unknown.
J
- (C) Okay.
j (A) Okay. The main feedwater pump tripped on them, cause unknown. The aux feedwater pump tripped on them, cause unknown.
(C) The aux feedwater?
i (A) Yes, e
a 06/13/85 6 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
1' o
(C) That's interesting.
(A) It is. Could you hold on for a minute please?
(C) Sure can.
(A) They're calling me back.
, (C) All right.
[ CONVERSATION is interrupted]
I 02:18:29 (A) NRC, (name deleted).
(B) Yes, (Name deleted), this is (name deleted) again.
(A) Yes, (name deleted).
(B) Uh, the initiating event was a main feed pump one trip.
(A) Okay.
(B) And exactly whr' happened after that I still can't tell you too good.
We're just working on figuring everything else out.
(A) Okay. And so, could you give me a call back once you have determined the cause of the feedwater pump trip? And also we're interested in the aux feedwater pump trips also.
1 (B) Yeah, like I said. I'm not sure whether that was a trip or a failure to initiate, but at any rate they wanted to--it didn't come on by itself, so.....
06/13/85 7 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
(A) Okay, so if you, once you determine that information you could pass it on to me we would appreciate it.
(B) Yeah, do you want to hold the line or anything?
(A) Oh, no, that's not necessary but, and also I need to know your event classification.
(B) I know, I've been trying to get them to declare but we haven't yet, so...
(A) Okay. Keep me in touch, please.
(B) Okay.
(A) Okay, thanks.
(B) Bye.
[END OF CONVERSATION, CONTINUATION OF ORIGINAL CONVERSATION WITH THE REGIONAL DUTY OFFICER]
02:19:25 (A) Hello?
(C) Hello, (name deleted)?
(A) Okay, the cause of the reactor trip appears to be the main feedwater pump No. 1 tripped.
(C) Did they just call you back?
(A) Yes, they did. Evidently the person who was talking to me is real disori-ented. In fact, they know very little about this event it seemed like.
However, the plant is stable. Okay, for the aux feedwater pump they're 06/13/85 8 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
not sure whether the pump initiated, and tripped, or it failed to initi-ate. But in any case the aux feedwater pumps, they are operating right now, and they're operating normally.
(C) So they tripped and then they restarted them evidently.
(A) Well, this person appears did not know the information.
(C) Did they trip? Do we know that for sure?
(A) No, we don't.
(C) Okay. I'll just put down ' tripped?' for right now then.
(A) Right and once that guy gets back to me, apparently they're scurring i around to see what's going on with this, but I will have a good nice talk to him once he calls me back again. Make sure we get all these questions cleared up.
(C) Okay.
! (A) Evidently this person must have been the operator, STA, or something talk-ing to me; you know the other people are busy.
- (C) Okay, so the cause was a feedwater problem, then.
(A) Right.
(C) Okay, say that their main steamline isoletion valve closed on 'em...
(A) Okay.
(C) Other than that, that's about all I know about at this point. The reactor was tripped from 90% power, now it's in Hot Shutdown; stable.
i s
06/13/85 9 OAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
--. - -.- - . - .- . - . - - _ . . - . - - - - - - _ . - -_..-.-.1. . . -
4 (A) Gl:ay. How about giving me some times?
(C) Okay, ti:e reactor tripped at 0133.
(A) That Central?
(C) Let's ree. That'll be Eastern.
(A; (C) And they called me up at 0211...
(A) Okay.
(C) And at this time the individual said he wasn't sure whether the resident inspector was notified but was going to make sure he will be notified.
(A) Okay.
(C) And also the individual will get back to me with their event classifica-tion. He is not familiar with the 50.72.
(A) I'm not surprised.
(C) Okay.
(A) I'll give you a call back once I get the rest of the information from them.
(C) Okay. Very good. Anything else?
(A) That's it.
(C) Okay. Thank's a lot.
06/13/85 10 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
O (A) All right.
(C) Bye.
[END 0F CONVERSATION]
02:21:57 06/13/85 11 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
O The next conversation occurs at 02:26:24 and is the plant calling the Opera-tions Officer to declare an Unusual Event.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer B = Licensee (A) NRC; (name deleted).
(B) Yeah, (name deleted) this is (name deleted) again.
(A) Yes, (name deleted).
(B) We do have an Unusual Event at least now. At 0225.
(A) Okay, 0225. Okay, and repeat, is the plant stable?
(B) What's.that?
(A) Plant stable right now?
(B) Yes, we're stable right now.
(A).0kay. What's the reason why you declared an Unusual Event?
(B) Basically, I guess, we would have declared earlier on an Alert based on loss of--a Site Area Emergency based on the loss of all feedwater, but since it was quickly restored before we could--within a few minutes before we could get into the emergency plan, we're not really in any obvious sec-tion of the emergency plan, but since we're uncertain as to what the cause '
of the loss of initiation or the lack of initiation of aux feedwater was, and since the main feedpumps are tripped still, the Shift Supervisor's a little uneasy about things and that's why he wants some emergency plan activation.
(A) Right. Okay, it sounds good. So you'll keep me posted?
06/13/85 12 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
9 O
(B) Uh-huh.
(A) Okay. Thanks a lot.
(B) Yeah.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
02:27:39 l
l 06/13/85 13 0 AVIS BESSE INCIDENT
The next conversation occurs at 0233 and is the Headquarters Operations Officer notifying the Regional Duty Officer of the notification of Unusual Event.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer C = Regional Duty Officer (A) Hello.
(C) Okay. (Name deleted), this is (name deleted) again.
(A) Yes.
(C) Okay, I just got a call back from Davis Besse and they have declared an Unusual Event.
(A) Okay.
(C) Okay, due to the questionable operation of the aux feedwater pump.
(A) Okay.
(C) Okay. Other than that the plant is still stable, and they're still inves-tigating the cause of the... either the pump tripped or failed to start.
(A) Either it tripped or it failed to start.
(C) Right.
(A) Okay, very good.
(C) Okay, I'll keep you posted.
(A) Okay, thanks.
06/13/85 14 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
4 (C) Okay, bye.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
02:33:50 1
06/13/85 15 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
The next conversation occurs at 02:39:40 and is the Operations Officer notify-ing the Emergency Officer.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer D = Emergency Officer (D) Hello.
(A) Yes, (name deleted). This is (name deleted), Headquarters.
(D) Yes.
(A) Okay, Davis Besse declared an Unusual Event due to a reactor trip and a
. bunch of weird things happened after the reactor tripped. The reactor trip was caused by a main feedwater pump tripping, which then isolated the main steam isolation valve. The problem arises when the aux feedwater pump failed to--either failed to start or---
(D) Whoa, whoa, whoa, hold on. The main feed pump tripped and that isolated the main steam isolation valve?
(A) Pardon me?
(D) The feedwater pump tripped and you said that automatically isolated the main steam isolation--
(A) Hey, I didn't say 'automatica11y'. That's what they told me. I still--
that's one question I gotta ask them. Probably it...it's usually designed to isolate with less than 600 lbs of steam pressure.
(D) Right, it's a safety valve.
(A) And so, if you trip a pump.
06/13/85 16 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
(D) If you trip a pump the pressure goes up. Alright, go ahead. What else?
(A) Anyway, the problem arose when the aux feedwater pump either failed to start or it immediately tripped off after starting. But it had to be ini-tially manually initiated. Okay. And that occurred for about 5 minutes and they started their pumps up. And so the plant is stable, everything is normal right now. The aux feedwater pump is still operating as normal but the cause of the problem on the aux feed pump is still undetermined at this time.
(D) And so the plant is stable.
(A) Uh, yes.
(D) Okay. And does the Region III Duty Officer know?
(A) Uh, yes he does.
(D) Okay, fine. - Okay, thanks for calling, (name deleted).
(A) Okay, good enough.
(D) Bye.
(END OF CONVERSATION]
02:41:20 06/13/85 17 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
4 The next conversation occurs at 02:53:38 and is a call from RIII Staff to the Operations Officer for an update. (Region III) is very difficult to understand on the tape.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer E = Region III Staff (A) NRC, (name deleted).
(E) Yes. Hi, (Name deleted) from RIII. I just got a call from my resident at Davis Besse...
(A) Yes.
(E) That they've had a trip.
(A) Right.
(E) And, that he was going to go out and see what the devil was going on. He didn't get any details, but they'd gotten themselves in a tight fix.
(A).Yes.
(B) What did the licensee tell you?
(A) Okay, now who's this speaking, please?
(E) This is (name deleted). I'm a section chief...
(A) Okay, (name deleted). They called me up on a reactor trip.
(E) Right.
06/13/85 18 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
l (A) Let me get my sheet out. Okay, the cause of the trip, which they told me ,
i on the second phone call, was due to main feedwater pump No. 1 tripping.
j (E) Right, and they had the problem with the auxiliary feed pumps.
j (A) Right. And they also had a main steam isolation valve isolation. The biggest problem was the aux feedwater pump had to be manually started be- -
cause it either failed, or failed to start, or tripped. And that cause is f still under investigation.
)
,i j (E) Did they declare it an Unusual Event?
t j (A) Yes, they did. This was after I questioned the fact that the person who l was talking to me knew very little information, and it took a third phone i call in order to declare an Unusual Event. I asked him what the event classification was, and he said at that time he didn't know, t
i n
1 02:55:00 I i !
(E) I was just looking in our NRC book and it says that one of the initiating j conditions for notification of an Unusual Event would be loss of engi- l
! neered safety feature or fire protection system function requiring shut- '
I down by technical specification. I would say that any danger of losing j
] auxiliary feedwater would automatically qualify as an Unusual Event. i 1 i l !
l (A) Right. But in their emergency plan the loss of the aux feedwater system i i is declared a site area emergency. !
(E) Oh? But did they say they declared a site area emergency? !
i r
\
l (A) No, they didn't. Okay, within a couple minutes they started the pumps, I and by that time they weren't even in their emergency plan.
] ,
I (E) is the plant stable?
I l
1
! 06/13/85 19 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
{
i i I
l
(A) Yes. The plant is stable and the aux feedwater system was operating prop-erly within, I think, five minutes, they mentioned, after the reactor trip.
(E) Well, anyway I thought I'd call to let you know that (name deleted) and (name deleted) both probably be there within a half hour to forty five minutes.
(A) That's probably a good idea because the person I talked to knew very lit-tle information, and they seemed pretty disoriented when I talked to him on the phone.
(E) Right, I think, did you tell the Region III Duty Officer.....
(A) Yes, I did.
(E) When did you call him? At Home?
(A) Pardon me?
(E) When did you call him? We need to follow up. I'd like to suggest you call him back when I hang up.
(A) Okay. I called him about 15 minutes ago.
(E) Oh, woke him up to take the call?
(A) Right.
(E) Okay, thanks very much.
06/13/85 20 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
(A) Okay. Thanks for the info.
(E) Okay. Bye.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
02:57:02 L
i a
06/13/85 21 0 AVIS DESSE INCIDENT
1 The next conversation occurs at 03:06:16 and is a call from the plant to the Operations Officer reporting an update on their status.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer B = Licensee (A) NRC, (name deleted).
(B) Yes sir. This is (name deleted), shift supervisor at Davis Besse.
(A) Yes, (name deleted).
(B) Can you give me your name again, please?
(A) My name is (name deleted).
(B) Okay. Uh, it's the same one we talked to earlier. Do you have any ques-tions for me?
(A) I sure do.
(B).Okay.
(A) What was the cause of the isolation of your main steam isolation valves?
(B) I do not know.
(A) It's still under investigation?
(0) There were...we had no conditions at the timo that would have caused those to close.
(A) Okay. Have you determined the cause of your main or aux feedwater from tripping?
l 06/13/05 22 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
(B) The main feed pump?
(A) Yes.
(B) Are you talking about the initial feedpump trip?
(A) Yes.
(B) No.
(A) Okay.
(B) I do not know what the cause of that.
(A) Okay, and have you determined the cause of the aux feedwater pump for not
! starting or tripping after start?
(B) No, not really.
i (A) Okay.
(B) It's still under investigation but we do have good control now.
i (A) Okay.
J (B) No problem that way. We are stable on the secondary side and we're stable on the primary side. :
(A) Okay, then I guess that's all I needed to know. However, when you have i determined the cause of your main steam isolation valves and your aux feedwater, and your main feedwater from tripping, could you give me a call 1 l back, please?
(B) We certainly will, sir, i
1 06/13/85 23 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT 1
(A) Okay. I also got word from Region III that both your resident inspectors are on their way.
(B) Okay. I did call one of them myself and talk to him.
(A) You should expect them within 20 minutes or so.
(B) Okay, sir.
(A) Okay. Thanks for the call.
(B) Thank you.
(A) Thanks, bye.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
03:07:53 06/13/85 24 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
The next conversation occurs at 0511 when the Operations Officer calls the plant for the routine morning status report. j A = Headquarters Operations Officer B = Licensee 2
(B) Hello, Davis Besse.
(A) Ye,, good morning, your status.
(B) Okay. Right now we have the startup feed pump running and it's supplying feedwater to both steam generators. We have both aux pumps, feedwater !
pumps available but not pumping water. Right now we're in the process of reestablishing vacuum in the condenser and normal post-trip lineup.
(A) Okay. ,
Any new news on all the trips?
(B) All what trips?
(A) Oh, the cause of the main feedwater...
i (B) Oh, okay. No, there's no... we've got some chart recorders that have data on them. We're analyzing it. The food pump did trip and appeara to be on a... well, we've got indication that it may have been on overspeed. l (A) Okay.
(B) We have no... we do understand we had a what we call a steam and feedwater rupture control system trip concurrent with the food pump trip. And that l was what isolated... did the isolation and secured the other main feed i
- pump.
(A) Oh, okay.
i 06/13/85 25 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
l .
(B) And then both aux feedwater pumps started but tripped due to problems with their trip throttle valve.
(A) O kay. So you're telling me the trip throttled this valve?
i (B) We originally thought it was overspeed because that's the only thing that really trips them but we're, we're thinking, we're hasing problems with the trip throttle valve. And once they were ...the t-ip throttle valves were reset they've been running. We've had one system that has not, one auxiliary feedwater system that we've declared it aperable, although it's :
available; we just don't have the proper control.
(A) Okay. You still in your Unusual Event?
(B) Ce're still on the unusual event. We could get out of it, but we'd like (
to stay in it until we get vacuum restored and get off of our safety j systems.
(A) Okay. It sounds pretty good.
(B) Okay.
f (A) Thanks for the info. ;
l l !
(B) All right. Thank you.
l (END OF CONVERSATION) l 05:13:38 l l
l ,
I l
i !
l !
06/13/85 26 0 AVIS DESSE INCL 0ENT ,
The next two conversations occur at 07:49:32 and 0753, respectively. One to the Region III duty officer and the second one te the emergency officer for an update.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer C = Region III Duty Officer D = Emergency Officer (C) Hello.
(A) Hey, (name deleted). This is (name deleted), Headquarters.
(C) Okay. Let me get down to my other phone.
(A) Okay.
[ PAUSE, WHILE PHONES ARE SWITCHED]
(C) Okay.
(A) Okay. I called back Davis Besse during the morning status calls, and they cleared some information for me. Okay, the aux feedwater pumps apparently had problems with the trip throttle valve.
(C) Say that again?
(A) The aux feedwater pump...
(C) Okay, aux feedwater pump...
(A) Right. Apparently had some problems with the trip throttle valve.
(C) Okay. Problems with trip throttle valves.
06/13/85 21 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
(A) Right. And they suspect that to be the problem of why it tripped off. But i
they're still investigating.
(C) Okay.
(A) Okay, the MSIV closure, OK, is still a mystery. But, apparently it was actuated by the feed steam leak isolation system.
(C) Say that again, now? '
t (A) Okay, the cause of the main steam isolation closure was a result of the I
signal from the feedwater main steam leak isolation system.
(C) You're breaking up a little bit, I'm sorry. Try again.
. i (A) Okay. The reason why the main steam isolation valve closed was due to t appare.nt signal from the feedwater steam main steam isolation signal.
(C) Okay. ,
(A) But it's still a mystery why it actually actuated. I (C) Okay. !
(
(A) Okay, that resulted in a tripping of the other main feedwater pump. So i therefore they lost all main feedwater. Remember that the whole event !
initiated from the tripping of the No. I main feedwater pump... f I
(C) Okay. (
(A) ...cause still unknown. At the same time the main steam isolation valve l closed on 'em. !
(C) All right. !
1 I
06/13/85 28 DAVIS DESSL INCIDENT l 1
]
(A) It is still under Unusual Event when I talked to them a couple hours ago; they will remain so until they regain condenser vacuum.
(C) Okay. ,
(A) Let me see. Other than that, that's about all I have for the Davis Besse event.
(C) Okay. The supervisor told me, after we talked, he and I talked, and he sent both the resident and senior resident to the site. As soon as they get out there and get this thing sorted out, he told me after he got a complete update a little later on this morning, probably around 8:00 o' clock our time, he's going to call me and give me a complete rundown. i (A) Okay, sounds good.
(C) Okay?
(A) Okay, thanks.
(C) Bye, j 1
(END OF FIRST CONVERSATION]
t 07:53:05 1 1
t 07:53:53 (D) Hollo? i This is (namo deleto), Headquarters?
(A) Hollo, (namo doloto)?
(0) Yes.
l l
j 06/13/05 29 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
(A) Okay, let me give you an update on these two unusual events. Quad Cities terminated around midnight.
(D) Okay.
(A) No problems. At Davis Besse, they're still in an Unusual Event and will remain so until they restore condenser vacuum.
(D) Okay. They're still working on aux feed.
(A) Right. And they suspect--
(D) I didn't realize they had lost condenser vacuum. Oh, but they had the main steam lines isolated.
(A) Right. And the cause of that's still unknown. But it happened at the same time when they lost the No. I main feedwater pump that started the whole show.
(D) Okay, so they're still cooling with aux feed.
(A) Right.
(D) Are they dumping to.....?
(A) Hold on, (name deleted), no they're not coolin0 with aux feed. They so-cured aux feed; they restored feedwater pump. The start up feedwater pump.
(0) Okay, but then they still have to dump the main condenser or--
(A) Yeah, yeah, they're dumping that in the atmosphere, of course.
(D) lhey're dumping in the atmosphere.
06/13/85 30 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
l o
(A) Right.
(D) All this time. Wow!
(A) So, other than that, they suspect the problem was the trip throttle valve <
for the aux feedwater.
2 (D) ..is why they had trouble starting them?
i (A) Right. They thought it was overspeed but that's the only thing that can l trip these things, but they're looking at it a little closely, and they j think that it could be a problem with the trip throttle valve. But when they reset it, everything was fine.
(D) Okay. Why? What was the problem with the condenser vacuum that they j didn't get the main steam isolation valve open?
I i
I (A) It takes some time to punip these things out. This was about an hour and a half ago during morning status, about 2 hours2.314815e-5 days <br />5.555556e-4 hours <br />3.306878e-6 weeks <br />7.61e-7 months <br /> ago, when I talked to them.
i (D) Oh, okay.
(A) So, other than that overything is normal. ,
i 1
(D) Okay, and you say Quad cities has ended their event?
i,
! (A) Yeah.
- (D) Okay, thank you.
)
(A) Okay, good enough, t
I
! (0) Bye.
I (A) Dyo, !
I i
I j 06/13/85 31 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT ,
[END OF CONVERSATION]
07:56:00 I
T 06/13/85 32 DAVIS U[550 INCIDENT
9 The following call occurred at 08:45:20 with the plant calling the Headquarters Operations Officer to notify him that they had terminated the Unusual Event.
A = Headquarters Operations Officer B = Licensee (A) NRC, (name deleted).
(B) Yeah, this is (name deleted), the shift supervisor at Davis Besse.
(A) Yes.
(B) I'm calling to inform you that we have downgraded out of the Unusual Event. We are no longer in our emergency plan.
(A) Okay. .What time did you terminate the Unusual Event?
(B) 0840.
(A) Okay. Now what is the plant's condition right now?
(B) We're in stable, normal, post-trip condition.
(A) Okay, is that Hot Shutdown?
(8) Hot Shutdown, Mode 3. No, Hot Standby, I'm sorry. Hot Standby, Mode 3.
(A) What are your plans of action right now?
(B) They are going to remain in Hot Standby and investigate the cause of the various problems that occurred during the transient.
(A) Okay. You had mentioned a couple hours a00 that you have one train of your aux feedwater system inoperable?
06/13/8B 33 0 AVIS DESSE INCIDENT
O (B) Yes, that is true.
(A) Okay. Are you in any LC0 Action Statement?
i (B) Yes, we're in an Action Statement for that. A 72-hour action statement.
l (A) Okay, 72 hours8.333333e-4 days <br />0.02 hours <br />1.190476e-4 weeks <br />2.7396e-5 months <br /> to Cold Shutdown? ,
(B) To Hot Shutdown.
i (A) Okay, anything else?
(B) No. That's all.
(A) Okay, your name please?
(B) (Name deleted). (Name deleted). I'll need your name, too. ,
(A) Okay. My name is (name deleted). That's spelled (name deleted).
(B) Okay. Thank you.
(A),Okay. Thanks for the call. s (B) Thank you.
(A) Bye. j i
08:47:06 ;
i 08:48:15 ,
l (A) Hello, this is (name deleted). I I
i I
06/13/85 34 0 AVIS DESSE INCIDENT i
(B) Hey, (name deleted), this is (name deleted) again. I forgot to ask you what is the cause of the aux feedwater system being out of service?
(A) The turbine governor is malfunctioned. It would not control turbine speed correctly.
(B) Okay. Thanks a lot.
(A) You're welcome. Thank you.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
06/13/85 35 DAVIS DESSE INCIDENT
These last two calls were made by the Headquarters Operations Officer to the Region III Duty Officer (08:49:47) and Emergency Officer (08:51:40).
A = Headquarters Operations Officer C = Region III Duty Officer D = Emergency Officer (C) Hello.
(A) (Name deleted)?
(C) Yes.
- (A) This is (name deleted), Headquarters.
(C) Okay.
(A) Davis Besse terminated Unusual Event at 0840.
(C) Okay.
(A) 0kay, they're stable in Hot Standby, Mode 3. Their plans are to stay in Mode 3 while they're investigating the reasons for the various I malfunctions.
(C) Okay.
(A) Okay, they're currently in a 72-hour-to-Hot-Shutdown LCO action statement because they had to take one of the trains of the aux feedwater system inoperable due to a turbine governor malfunction.
(C) Okay, they determined that that was the cause of the problem?
(A) Well, for one of the problems.
06/13/85 3G DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
(C) One of the problems, okay.
(A) Okay, so that's about it.
(C) Okay.
(A) Okay?
(C) Very good. Thanks.
[END OF CONVERSATION]
08:51:40 (D) Hello.
(A) Yes, (name deleted), this is (name deleted), Headquarters?
(D) Yeah.
(A) Davis Besse terminated Urusual Event at 8:40.
(D) Okay.
(A) Okay?
l (D) All right.
(A) Thank you.
(D) Bye l
l l
[END OF CONVERSATION]
06/13/85 37 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
?
o' 08:52:00 This concludes the initial conversations taped during the Davis Besse incident on June 9, 1985.
06/13/85 38 DAVIS BESSE INCIDENT
>