ML20126B233
Text
-. _ =
/
!\\l l V ~ /T I <) /
I3 11,MMMiidA.
4..
.. w n ja
.r 4!$:'Ihoi$as Regional MSf2'+. tor I
2 x
- r. m
.w
, :v
~
5 Lo' r,. 5.v6. 4.~
of Reactor Profcts,
'Utill to discuss a series of allegations
- Brantz s; m v a
made by the e During the disedssion the alleger suggested an NRC.
staffimpropile as i
fg '# 't. '
- w.,# w ?. %
u
'Ibe NRC is the "Non Regulatory Commission" and is in general i
" aligned" with the utility.
The Durr report (Region I Inspection Report 50-336/89-13) "Did not attach appropriate j
severity levels to my concerns, I.evel IV's and V's."
Furthermore, the individual expressed a general disgust with the ability of the agency to resolve his concerns.
An allegation panel met on September 12,1990, and determined those actions that will be taken by the NRC in followup to the technical and other concerns made at the August 30 meeting. Basy! on that followup, we will address technical concerns resolution directly to bd we are addressing the alleged NRC staff impropriety to you.
~
This memorandum does not request any action, but is forwarded to you for information and what further action you deem necessary. If you have any questions, please call me or Charles W. (Bill) Hehl of my staff.
C".;l Si:ned By*
Ti,w..cs T. Martin.
l Thomas T. Martin l
Regional Administrator 1
RI:DRP RI:DRP RI:DRP RI:DRA J.S. Stewart E.Wenzinger C.Hehl W.Kane 10/02/90 10/02/90 10/02/90 10/03/90
- SEE PREVIOUS CONCURRENCE SHEET OFFICIg@pSIlhCOEY was deleted in accordante wit {th g of Woma Act, exegon F01 A -
9212220018 920608 PDR FDIA
~l OUILD91-162 PDR
/
N APPEN0lX 4.0
')
~'
SAMPLE RECORD OF ALLEGATION PANEL DECISIONS O h l!sl va 1
PANEL ATTENDEES:
SITE:
t lie l I ALLEGATION NO.:M-9 C-A-i 3 7 Chairman -
9f(1/90 (Mtg.d'234S)
Branch Chief -
F C 'O OATE:
h Section Chief (AOC) - IJu 4J,e _
PRIORITY:
High Medium No(Unknown)
Others her - M SAFETY SIGNIFICANCE: Yes S J, h - G 6 M,nid $4au/, (/e/e<<n)
CONCURRENCE TO CLOSE00T: 00 BC SC
/I h d o/ ( Je/u.-l CONFIDENTIALITY GRANTED: Yes i
(See Allegation Receipt Report)
IS THEIR A 00L FIN 0!NG:
Yes No Yes No 15 CHILLING EFFECT LETTER WARRANTEO:
Yes No HAS CHILLING EFFECT LETTER BEEN SENT:
Yes No HAS LICENSEE RESPONDED TO CHILLING EFFECT LETTER:
ACTION:
UocNe\\G ftAI f l'mrun5 M
1) er #
- 2) -
3) 4)
5)
NOTES: _
A4-1 1]{[0
[
/} L.
7V * //
'W I
Ce 4.1 tb g,, e
- {9 70 meeol
~
Nfony{v2J ba/oe- /my([.
~ T!0 ll CE*if f Af8f /
v'
__1 SM ).
f e
eu0.me. L ufd,-,
c2, Posm.A b % r1 be- ' lo k I.<eu ee,
,. mp- ) 3 7
no c%
3.
hmJL 6 h ropa e no 1 7 - u -90 me-o f A.
RcP at
- ak ww m i as-a 5
As
- t)Rss.~sps/ex
+
) 7-1,-9c n,e-. 1 7/odoIkenge,T\\ ort,iper,5c_
b-C
[tpredat4 t
(DRs5 m c-~J l
i h c,-vo,,s.,,. m 4
7-br reprF/;e.gf7c:A seed 4) n-M h I c.
7.a S a+ b b 6s d teytJ-)cmcun p
- b. Reg.a y pat kaw A.at7, AM<
a.l\\epmp,,caus,.g/;,c, c, MEph i-TanJ e,wm A k
9,, a, a w p -
Ec#sy et, wb d
g.sols{<nelee,5Aamp5'.3 3
iJ A a &,_ama.
1
&&T l
L
~
' RECEIPT REPORT Date A 3"% "A " O/I 7 A11egation No.
,r (leave blank) t Address:
City / State / Zip:
D-Yes No Yes No
- shgationpanel l
Yes No
,at'need to be sent Yes No ityagfeinentbeensigned?
Yes No tirifyhy it was granted is attached?
Yes No e-e f;
~iitW*'/Y1;//shne 2-ooctet No.: ed3ac 9
(Allegation Sumary (brief description of concern (s): 3 ftMM o mfNM/
'wwk ( P 1 UMLJ), belo;f& nnk 455 Skae 1
Orh irdcbch ftn
[* To.76n.9 (1) Tkni, J9l4 (3) RLP (J6rscahw CM W S.
i i
(a) ALgff
( & (g,g m ut, j& j,ppug,,h k (L)Afg( l$3,eg
^
Number of Concerns:
b b-e_ w e d -~
Employee Receiving Allegation:
7 (first two initials and last name)
Type of Regulated Activity (a) 4 Reactor (d)
Safeguards (b) _ Vendor (e) _ Other:
(c),,_ Materials (Specify) l Haterials License No. (if applicable):
Functional Area (s): '/ (a) Operations (e) Emergency Preparedness (b) Construction (f Onsite Health and Safety l
_(c) Sa"eguards (g Offsite Health and Safety l
(d) Transportation
_(h Other:
l (NRC Region I Form 207 Information in
-s Revised 10/B9) in accordance with eted e
Act, ex,emPlions IInformation FOIA M l~[(,%.,p
.~.
]
k of S Page Detailed Description of Allegation:
I G' Allen naA,0 3 mtwos dvd fMiA< s% edi 4e
@. Ad.Al d - (M - W.d 1-.
~I~ b..u M 4 calee.o Je m ee #
me. Ali issue art s,rn k /i d<A.A 4. <rmum 4, ck n~J/
W ed 4 /a d.- e4 m. cjosnd cw uns $ h cN '4b s we c u m rh k a u me<:
rf.2, g mme.
saf n 4, A.,culesu 4 d-tL4 A1,l4/l cAend ke w Mek bcw <dt % oh w,l,a 4(ceds ds.m
)
i I
48
/
Mi t i-1 cwb.a. de ddA-Hbl-l.m iavans,'lh 1
t 5/n ho -mem, - Alle,o h.u w/ vdoLb <>As lb.w NRC on *.ucsm All 'le cw k 4h RcP mML ws.b3,'A c4 i
c>ll E.t cc< up.k.
He 1 su red /ha Mtvlren,IvG._
AC T3 /,\\ \\eAw de Gb L.,ek A lanah sbh ibtJ w
t o s.wk 4
[
i Vf21/9c' -
(.C N[eJ na m'es rduU - /f kI'/ '-//,i/ w-cuLl
'%<sd d
<=f<he n -so I Li kW 04 Llk dLl1 rot e mi,%, cm - cad dub', ms,i cm,hhlAe (nede' unchJ u hob.ved k+ A s wda ed OCd.,Q '. 'cl<ef md,r,fneA}3 M4cs h.su s d th mee, M\\ed 6 %dQ'DmeM hh ceO' m s M I Al ft ( o m - ed d/./~3 < -,u O '" is e n Reuce "l%co",eH'l '-ti, uta'),K' th ' fJ./ 4.4 bw rva,4 2;) b4 avled, aawm $ seas,'/, /enA -fo ism-Idd U M o.~ul l/e sk'dc, one,J </ls, a a4 URc
<c~.o m bi s rev,t ttn Ye'Sbilhti a % d /e d a c # l " E k
/
/.
NRC Region I Form 207 (Revised 10/89) 2.
l.
..e..: ~..,.
, * ~. -
J. ' '..,j.' C.,1. Y. rb :[;.{g,ft ~) 'R'.
s-
~
..,3 ' ', a c.
.... ~0,h'..bi(l ?;$ G i I A?.u,:l -f.,
E.'.i h Y :.'..,,"50'
' ~ ' ' '
b * * '. ~
i g.
my ' S_ -
-r 1
<.. <.. ~, c...-+ a.........
JCLWR 2.TMM M,... ' :-
. w: ;....,..~:
T.*'^
.f e
p,9, 3 op z Deta11 A
' of [
ab j
\\
(
1
'D.
9(*
A,
.sn wman.<.:
a, ' ' c
- 1,* g ^ + ",.
e
.eI$
~
s e
~n n.
(
l'
..t.
s g
5g
- ,y
.2 w> kt du,w 1av1 (A] hen GmordT he dud'h rbkh n.,
19!El'7FL A Nc;eirN bee'.,4 /
/.3/ '2 mev/s o.s i
1enwh y
(% A brl<0 a cLwd cf acreJ
/ dis Ae c,o chbu:WE
+ m c m n /a u <.1 : a s L I'ecb, a % & ; m (Sb lb hoankh E.
5-r
}.lloned tend /ck e.-colt /L,%a d us %
nc na c o sn!w 'i: sri r u n u '
-lonu hewithe kr ms/ l 0 L# SEc3 Le lene,m ef 4 d
LM clnh " ell <tJV'ev Ac u m e c,c;-s k "ldisa
\\
A&;,L" -k Wil u cwddobud tNui
/
-d4-$h h..s4. %I4 reed 4 saue 6,/s,c T owel4 na:,de cub d h;\\ re m,h 4 mvid. ~IL/c) L 'D Qere<ee m neh 8 reb Al<st fak I wwlkca,<.,
Ln nemst.
L\\ le sefu d c %,, d A x c]a A m t cd b NRC Region I Form 207 fC (Revised 10/89) g v/5, o
.. - _. _ _,,,., _.