ML20107A054
Text
T e
1
(
i UNITED STATES k
ATOMIC ENERGY COMMISSION
~
W ASHINGTON, D.C. - 20545 NOV 5 1973 Robert J. Schemel, Chief, ORB #1, L MEETING WITH JERSEY CENTRAL POWER & LIGHT COMPANY Date, Time & Place:
( November 13, 1973
- .=...
Rm. 100 Woodmont Bldg.
Regulations Attendees:
T. V. Wambach, ORB #1 F. Liederbach, QAB S. Cummins, QAB R. Glasscock, RO:I Other Attendees:
N. Trikouros, GPU D. Gaines, JP.C&.L--...
Purpose of Meeting:
To review draft QA Plan for Operations - \\
for Oyster Creek -
~ ~.,
,o T. V. Wambach Operating Reactors Branch #1 Directorate of Licensing cc: Docket File Attorney, OGC AEC PDR R0 (3)
Local PDR Principal Staff Participants L Reading Receptionist 1
RP Reading ACRS (3) i E. G. Case A. Giambusso l
R. S. Boyd RP Assistant Directors D. J. Skovholt T. J. Carter RP Branch Chiefs J. M. Hendrie TR Assistant Directors TR Branch Chiefs R. F. Fraley, ACRS T. V. Wambach R. Bevan
/
9604120115 960213 PDR FOIA DEKOK95-258 PDR a
..Q x
~
/
(,
ii :Jd
.~'.y s
.erser Central Power & Ught. Company }(d..#,(- ;i, MAOl$0N AVENUC AT PUNCH EOWL ROAD
- t.tOHRISTOWN,N.J.07560
- 20M3H111 Se.hs A v. san
'OC.,N Pj puntsi: Uldes Corporatica
_ Gwe d v.e. n lf-l "H".., '.
Hovember 5, J 73 50 -219 I
(.
T ( }.'l M. l'$} d lh h f Y h.)j N' N,
- ~
"1.'
//
n x
f(J' l-J b
Hr. Donald J. Skovholt, Ar.r.ir.t. ant, Ilirect.or for Operating lleactors E
NOV9 1973 > ~5~
~
Directorate of 1.icensintJ its. ncmc rum linited State:, Atomic Energy Counission g
cews Washington, D. C. 20646 s"u s"a
- 8 7
e
Dear fir. Skovholt:
%j 4
1
(
By letter date:! October 26,193; you r.' quested revisad c.ur n representing thr limits for the averaqr p' inn,,r linn, r heat pneratur rne for GE l'ype I and il fuel nr.seblies in :.he Oy::W Creek reactor.
Th:n 2 r0Yl$0d curyc5 dre to pre?ct t the results of c: dited i;eatt:p calet.icti;cs j
follo.;ir.; a por.tulated 1.03. at expen:en:.: grcntnr ti;cr; 1rs,000 IrdO/T.
By lutti:r datu:1 Cr:r..Ber 31,1;'"'3,.v: u rittpies t$ul sinf l Ar cal :n-la tions and curvus darintig: t imi tim; ryn,!. tint,s <n,. u.n yno:: ryg III.:
fuel in the Oyster Cree'< rence;r. Thest calc';!d-icas were to be nons un(ter $l.ec i fled r;c,ndi t ier.s.
Further, < v; b i tivi t / 1n.tlysi', e.ts raou.:5 e.c In Mtpk.6Pt of our Septr-$c P 7.1973. F. n:Icst for Chinq"o to the Oyster Creek inchnical $necificiitions.
Attach.m:nt i pee..ent;s the ;ey: ed lir:i ~: inn curve'. for Types :.
ii. and ITI-T fuel.
The-liai r.ing cur.,
for Typ Ili (n.31 ir, also st.-
for coqmleceu y,.
Ther: ct,evn wern r;u.crat<.r.' u. irip tne ces,d ; t lon<.
r.pocified in yaor tuo lettect,.
At t?.t.le:er.t il goAen ts um rc.u:lte. rr p r.m tric study por fora. d t.c reasure tha r.r.m itivir.y 3r 99 p.-J c. lad t g +ratura te CliM W 18,tW sptAy iva!,,(r.in,ffr ce t(n,Ls,;.
-, tea t j 72 g r pey, j.j:
rted q m chine c.; to.cht..., in cuenc:9 tic :.
in short, this s tati shc..r, tM t urai e the w:it cw: cw.r,.3 iun, rc.. :.i.lon of the anniier.h h spray lu al tran::Ter coaNide ns tt, a c.ie a
,+c; et 0:e. icIict pcssive errJ.; Ming, ths.31t.ulate! p:0 cid. : :erature i:, incrcu.:.i y
i
..(
by only 6Vr.
gi i
e
~
e H J;if 2 " T Q,a:v._ + mE L, ~b ftT,p d;~~~_W :; % u.1 i-
.. p:-c.-
.m.m=vs w/.w?. -mW v
mr e. :
- ~ u.s.*~Q _,_ f_t-:q :: :., *_.y%.T L*L% t?,,,._9:M ".~2; ~
,-i.
m-
.,t m-
\\
Hr, Donald ti. Skovholt
' ~
.i;.
Page II Hovember 5, 1973
, ),' -~
a.
In view of the power dorate effect at Oyster Crock as a result of the August 24, 1973 Af.C order to change the Oyster Creek Technical Specifications, it is requested that a timely review be performed and approval be granted in this matter.
Very truly ' ours, y
- V6)!l.2i'!!,.D vIvan R. Finfr,ockv Jr.
Vice President i
pk At tachmen ts e
1 e
- e 4
o O
e 1
(
I
9 h.mlth.. @*w. e.,.m. w * $ r.
,I
.,... c
. i
- h....
l..
.. ".. p.... *
- b..[
in
- i
........ l........ l u..-..
9.g,
f.,.g.
. y... a..
s.p..
....g..
1
.e t#e.\\.gg.
.a
.se.,
...y.
- a..... e..s..a.,..
.,.e..*
s.,~
......,..,,i,.,e..i..
..g w.
- e..,
m
...g
.o.
.. l e,,e...
..a,
..c H-
- c..
. 1 1,
1..
- 9. -
.4
..g..
,,.,....e
,.,l.e..
.t I...
i At,t,RC[
.g...
,. ~ g..
.%g
........,g...
.t..,".
. f.....s
-.l.,,
g i.f. *..,.1,,
>...S...
.e..
s
- e.... 1 ~.........
.e.
..g y..
. l,,,.
.g
.~'
- ~.=
- 7
~~':..
. i n.,.,. - ~.- q :
..,...............g~_,
1,,
,, l l
..4.a.
g 4 p,.,,
.,. i
..,.6.,,
,.....,.q..4.
......i.....t,
". ~.
.~
.. - i.1
- t. s
(.t l
...l...
,i
....l...
. it
.i. t. h f r....,,
e.
. s....
t '.
Til
...,.5
...y
- i...
4
.I.el...
..Ii...
.8..,..
. ~..
u.
~.
,.....,,...- -.r.."...-
. H < P...
... f
.f
...... ~...
.s...i.
.l..
4~
..r y.
. t -l -
.......I
,.,3
,;,,,
- n".
.g
.6..
..,..L.........
a}(,.
.,~7.. [,*a !
...c.
..t.......
.. (
s
-t
.....o s
F..
r.
.i
..l.
- o., '
p 9-N.
, g,
- m 3;p u.
,, T..r?"+ l..
m r_-
.".L.4
..g--
c.,.,-
..j
...,,.s, r
'. q
., g :
.u.
...J
. cf..,.....f R
,..r.,
.g, ' p. s =,
m
- ...g f
... f. (...
........,...... ~.. ~.
- e
,f,
.t.
t,;
..w.......
3..
- t..
j...
.... s..t a. i....
i.
i.
I
... g
..k.
..g.
m,
.t.. t,,..
e.J..............
9.. r..
..i.
i q e..
....l
.t.,,
,e
..,4,.,..,.
,...L......
....e
.,.2n.g,.
- 6..
. l.3 g,
i
.i,q r.
g
~... p.
o.
-~
... ~..
i..
,.i.. t.,....
....s...
e.
,s.
...l...
..,.t:..
- t.
..r
. w.y ).
q..t
......,..,....a.
i
. t.
u.
g
.3
.t.....
,ej..
i
,,..... t.l.
g
- t...t.s.,
,(,.
,.l.
..i,..
4 4
....q.
.. L.
...,T..,..t.,.,.
. ~.
..a, a..-
r.,.
.[.
i
. (
..A,....
..o
- s.
m
...t..
s
.,.j
.g p
p
....6
..s,.
,5 y,
...w
.6..
.,v.- p..,.
..i..
...6n yy y
.I
....[t,
.......6........
, e.
~.
1 r
......l...,t.,;....
..,[
W
) &%
.p.b..
a, s
=.
f4 e Os
...J..,......
l d., '.,.
g dl
..l..(
e.........
M.'.,.
. f " J.*..
J.".
d)
- i. l.
. o. s.,
..,..8 o.. ).
.l.
...j....._. _..
. 18
.s
.l...
.,..I...
.t...
...t.
t....
oo
.J.-
y.....
,u.~..,.
7 i.
....9....
J, w
. s.... f... q.....;......
...t.
da F p...-ml
..).... -.3...
..e.
.. m m. p..
g
-e if p.
ej
~
.q'
$ 'g.
,4 h j
f.pp..
g g.
t.
.s.
i
..r.
....... -.t v.
g
.,.,.,.......\\,.
.....,.-.t....-..
..t a
.a
... L..... ~.
.i
..s,.
."..r-
,....e r4 ;I
.f t6 o
.. p.
..g.s
_. 1...
,4 0,,,,,,.f...,.-
l3 e
..g-a o g.)
.?,
.. ~ -.
,q
,s
,g.
...(.
e l..,
- ).
U 4t
. ' ' ~ ~. ~ * * *'**f'.
...l.
.D.
. ).
..l..
j..
.....i
.~'(**
~.....'
y 1
n..
u
..-w.-
v.
,..~....~...,.,. -
.i.....
t.
o.
~ t c.
.. ~..
.:4..
. ;[. :.
.9.
] * 'it T-y N.
U...
... +.
q;
- e
..}.
r
.. r 3
- 4.; a..s t............
\\
g'. #
- ag.
g g,
p
- b.
e
%J f* J ru
...I,'***
...d.'.*.."."(**.".g#.'*.**..
g, 3
t 6'
pg.
s?
Tj
..f
,...,s......
..I.
6, i
(A 4
..{... t.L s
,..l.>{
, o
{ gg
,.. g y
- a..
- j v.
p~
..y.f 48
......t'......
},
. d45...
t.
8 b"
.3 a"
. =. =.. =.....~e.~..
t.
- ~.
i]
~.
..,,.s.......
l.. ~ =..[..v
..g.....
}....
- +.
- o J.., ?...
i...
..a
.t v.
?
a g
o
,1
- .h.
.~.p..
i
.4',.g4-g,,,-
..{.
'.a.
..v4
..+a.
> -. =.
8
~
",J, y)r i
.g g,a '....
i
..e.....
eig'
.. t
.n.
...\\..
...l.
,, l s
.. s
- 6..
.., ~.
., ( I.
,,6,
.g.
.a-.
1
+...
.,fg.....
j)3 a
=.-
, =.
.+.
.u- ~...
.g t,r.
...r......
.........m4;...
i...,
.t -
a,
.'l.(. ;
. ),..
+.
- f..r 3
i.,.-(
'..~.,.4..,
l..
3 4..
.6
.s e. i.
.... L
...n,.
~.
3, ;g
.r g:
.t..
i
- a. k. a.
. (.. q.., '.
.g.'..
..n...
....e e.g L
.. r.,
ii..
1 L.1
=
=
ors-.
4.
f.
.i i. 1'.s..
g,.
- t..
- e l'.I..* r et t
.1.
,.......4 l
. M...
a...
....9......(..
l.
].
.g
..e.g...
,...4
.. g.. 4.'...,.
a.,
- 6..
-... ".,{
,l.
.g.!..
,8
. y..;.,*
.i.i i-ie i.
q.
of
.l..
,.,. g g
... i.ey.. 1.I... '
.. ;.". 7 * ' * * * * * " ' * ".. "
M'
. N.l.
.,t I U. f. *.,.
...l...
t.....
+
r
.... t...
g.i
.I
.e.
.e.
..t.
..a.
a..
.e..
e f/
)
i, i
g..~ *
- (I
.u..
6.
.dl'JiW/ 3.ll'.1 {,Q..'.s....'
if)M 1
[....!..l.
- t....,......
1 3
.. a....!.......
- t..
- ...i.
a....,
, a
,4 i.
- i...
. o.
a.
..i..
i r..
.., +..
.g....i.
.=.
e
.i.
i
-....i...
.l' p'
t,.
.t g
...s.n
.. g
.)
.,g.
.g
...1..............i...,
g
,..l" l..
- f..
)
l l.
n........
v.
.a......J..,
~
1
.y.
',9 i-
.g,..,
n..
7
- n-(
su.
..v
.i..:
~
.i p
m,..-
,i TAnLE 1 l'
SMd C0JFICIEtlT Al%LY3IS 1
~
l'A1'LHun = 10.9h lol/f t.
- j..
'E
- i Dirt.rr COR. Wet
'. PEAK _ CLAD TEMP
--.ce) v.lY Tim (se.e.) '. Tim.} ace) ho(cco)
Rn NU* Temp ( #
tff" a
- 960 204-elcA 100%
jo
- .6 50/,
36 - m
.36 7 15o 9.
2173 10 4 i.o w$
50 - w -
50
.;150 9
2170 1M 1
j 5 50',
75 - co 75_
/
150
- 9 2166 100%
l00 50%
100 - ca 100 150
- 9 2165 1(X$
~
25 S0%
125 - ca 325
.,.150
.9 1266 WIe s
g
.k ;
,5m 90$
150'-en 150 150
- '1h 0171 lf<d r.
I75 SON 17,5 -Vo
- l'75
.175,
'15 klf9 lW
!CO 50$
200 -co 200
-200
' ' 15 2200 AM i ?9, 50'$
22'. - os
.225 204
- l'S
- !1(A UNI'
)
{'o 50.?
00 -o2 290 3%
45 219'3 AM j
75
$0$
379 -co 375
>2%
15.
9.198 100fs
- 00
'io/.
500 - co
.500
, 2oli
-M.
2156 10 0 i
s.
- l!O Of 800 - c.o 20/)
'n.).., -.,..,....,1.9...
f>&Oh I'MI 2 Ci ctno +,,. wy crc .liAD:nt, in N/hr-f t - F:
^ b l's. > 8.'e n ?.1 sI., $
Ot'cAq, in - 1,73 t
h of1: Pro.r; ? = 0 7U Group'I; i 0.875 li ctv: cw.u;r 3
.9,0
- Oranp h u.0,0 k ICLL '..:
) J.*n t c Ct. 8.'..- c.'h ori. f ttj r4* t t te.9 t, 1.
ey/
i e
n g
a e 7-w -
---=====--me-~
~- --
y w - -, -
- M, ur -E
N L $ 55 W 2QB H t-s wrM v11.c w.v.es.=
.-xw Mi2 V I$5?NS-e e
.7, s
3-1.
. (
vA 3
y* ^
. o AvtM:mcorr'TT Requested Perrectric ts'turly - Nu.on 'lype III-E Fuel C..
Paramtrin studies were perforhedIto illustrate the senedtivity of the pe@. clatt ternpomtore to the assur.:cd duert spncer capture rod 9
vetthy; tima and to assured variations in the spray heat trtatutor.
1 000001010n1.4 occuringt at lthat i,3.rno. Tho nons.rmeil npacot captw c rod.
vettinc timo was varied from the title of' rated, spray to the in<uviouuly
- t caletd.ated connervative Ynn:nnouchi quench titto.
Por cach cc.se thf;.
opray coefficient,n for rod 6roupo 3 und 1+ vero htJ.wei at the tu;;;vart{
{
npacor espt.tcre rosi wel.t.ing timo. The resul'ta 01' these'calede,Llons
, are te,1ven in Tablo.L, In add.tt,lon, au w further.,rN.ut:re of the sent.Mivi:y of FOT to the acauhW( f) pray huub ' transfer conf fleiunts,, the speh,) herd transfer C0017.'101 cuts for rod croura 3 nnd l were na<n.wt to e.>r) t$ se..
i concurrently with an accurced ornnor copt.ure rul nchtig tim ar 203 secondn.
%e reaults of thio nonumr> tion is uhoun on the 3not.1-(7:n or Tabin 1.
As the arndynia indicaLee, the peak c19..1 tmperature it.:
relaMycly inceratlLive to t,he the nr unmmcet alssi' capture ruJ udt.Qps even when Ui in c.ecuretytnics1 by w ry earinosyative 3.2m.wn1.chtr.;'an lu the nyrny hont trannfer coctrJulent.u.
b 2
4 WW -
,--W'"'""'.',
~ '"' "
,y,
- w
_r,,,-
m w.
. - ~.
-. ~....
i
&,! 3... c jej - t1
...p.
n
- e. ;y,....s. p..m.... _,..re p.pp. x vg q i :m.. t grup t ;i.e,
- 1.,. 'fr M1-en u..
D...
.,s,,,,
si,
r '- '
u
...a.
- di... p*
t' I e '
y..s ' C r A - M.s:
- q. -
.e t.c. g
., MU E ",
- ~~ u%
.' ' st.,
.f.q:/*tv e 'J".;.'.. '.i,..
tic 4Iio t ui s's W W.
- v '. *--. r y:,.s.. a. \\...w, 4..,..,.......,.... _.
e.
t g
.s.
... o.
,..~ -..
3,., r,,.,.
..,y, v.,.. u..:
". >,v n.r.%.,,
.i ;
i 1
- w....i
i r,... s : - m. -on..
.a.
n u..
.m
.q
. y,t 1
- 7..
..x-g -
p
.s as -
- p~~.-:ep.
....., ~..
-a
, v : :.-~ -- :. - =..w=- - -
7 l
1 2
3 1
4 5
{'
- 1 1
2 2
2 2
g i
s
,s 13 8
9
'I O 11 l
.n 3
3 3
3
['
u.
s' g
e I~~,
1 g
l'3h
.1. 5 16 1
l u
u n.
/
. I' l
}
/*"%
N.
. /'%
f\\
N,'['N Q
j y '
' ao A
{
i n
~?
'~=
. I.
M*[. s r=*'*.e a* s,
.e p.-
2
.< w.>.
23 2
u o co m.
u-l s.
w./
,,._ /
t t
\\
8
,k
- ** g
'*6.,
a f
8 'l 4
l i
s..
i
,. s e
,,,.r.-*
t
, l 2
[
y
(,
%.s.,.
8 s....-
l
.....m..
.-....,,e.
i M-h h4 3.h,$ 98.
l
. ~
e t
8.ai.
i
.Fj (101'O.,.,1, I
.I i
4 retu */. ;/ st.::. r. In:;,p ;.1;' a,eg.)p; gy,3<fgn I
- 9
-,,.r
--)
n n
y w
.,,,__.,-,.-__.,y
-_._:_2=
u &.
,,, a.
..J.1 u%s.es
=a w.--
'