ML18230A495
| ML18230A495 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 03/21/1979 |
| From: | Trowbridge G Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| Download: ML18230A495 (20) | |
Text
March 21, 1979 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD In the Mat'ter of )
)
CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-400
) 50-401 (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power ) '0-402 Plant, Unit's 1, '2, 3 and 4) ) 50-403 APPLICANT'S RESPONSE TO POSTCARD REQUEST OF KUDZU ALLIANCE AND WELLS EDDLEMAN In ALAB-526, 9 NRC (February 13, 1979), this Appeal Board affirmed the January 10, 1979 Order of the Licensing Board denying a series of petitions by the Kudzu Alliance and Mr. Wells Eddleman for "general intervention" status in the captioned proceeding and specifically for intervention in the remanded proceeding on management capability.
On March 13, 1979, a postcard communication to this Appeal Board from Mr. Eddleman Wps docketed. The communication states: "In light of the ASLB's apparent willingness now to reverse it,s initial ruling on Kudzu Alliance's and my intervention in the Safe Mgt hearings, we ask the Appeal Board to return that issue .to .the ASLB for a ruling." This cryptic comment may be misleading.
0 The Licensing Board did not reverse or indicate "willingness" to reverse its initial ruling on the intervention of Mr. Eddleman and the Kudzu Alliance.
At the remanded proceeding held in Raleigh, North Carolina on February 27 through March 2 and March 6 through March 8, 1979, Mr. Eddleman-was permitted to make an oral limited appearance statement. Tr. 2381-2403; 2531-2535. Further, the Licensing Board permitted Mr. Eddleman to sit at counsel table with the Intervenors and the counsel from the North Carolina Attorney General's office to participate in the hearing as an advisor to those attorneys. Tr. 2405, 2406.
In granting Mr. Eddleman the right to participate in the remanded hearing in this limited manner, the Board did not, find that either Mr. Eddleman or the Kudzu Alliance now could make the showing required by the rules for intervention in a proceeding. In fact, the Board indicated that it could not allow Mr. Eddleman to participate as a fu'll intervenor because it had no "right to suspend 5 2.714, the Intervention Rules." Tr. 2405. A copy of the transcript whereby the Board granted Mr. Eddleman this right of limited participation is attached hereto.
Mr. Eddleman has brought no new information to the attention of the Appeal Board that would warrant reconsideration of its decision in ALAB-526,or,remand to the Licensing Board on the question of intervention. Absent review by the Commission (for which neither Mr. Eddleman nor the Kudzu Alliance petitioned
~ i within the required fifteen days after service of decision),
the Order of the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board, as affirmed by the Appeal Board, is final. 10 C.F.R. 5 2.786.
Respectfully submitted, SHAW g ITTMANg OTTS TROWBRI DGE By G orge F. Trowbrzd e J hn H. O'eill, Jr.
Dated: March 21, 1979
'sl i!xV)
.">>QQ8 'an) baS iHl'P ~
GS -8'.I 0 lai 1-
~18 atlas Pone q O~V .CQ 'i": R A If r~i,o 0'=" "c'ii'"x' '.
6137 I 55g i >3.s DealingsTG cion ' ag 88~ i'lii.4 a' OP. h"'s 3.llZG "nCGS an& COilclUS3.OI5S O;it 't I58 158R " ng z l3llt .iGV8 '
'SS
',as 4~i,onst-acean. ~. -:. 158 3n¹ezs"-an¹s -;1na~ s 'nappenin'
'+Be
++ie~e~o78 i1a ~ i c O CT .n. Va¹ 'qa>> Illwrvep COHLilission'S in<Given'on .'2 GSI a
~
BOR '5as a g:.GR i Ga'.
w rs v v'i Di3i i" ng R Pa O~ ir'Z~" C. ~ ~
" - 5RVG Pa~i.e L n R heazing ) p Ven 3 jl,=v ¹. S i.a'5CLing I GVG i+ Hieing petitio"5 i - oL583. i'e illva3.3.¹ ~ ~ P. iv RPDGaz's <<'5a' conc=ib~t icn ",.o .'".3'll record an he mac.e.
aces noh g've "'558 Bear¹ =~gh-~ "o s"spena Sec~=on 2 7='." p . 5 58 in'.ezvGI5'~~on,Q3.8s ( Qlkich a" 10518 Qa "i "8 'o appea~ a v>3.ing g-anting inde=.veniion. ==.Q rze a":-.Gear rave this case a decision h-z <<=he "=oa=a an¹ i 'le ap,.ier 5 QORZC'aaGLa~~-5
~~y no~ oe an Zn'-8"veno=.
vs% n'?'Fxj ~na;.18 nave a Qi i.e.."en'P C'4Qsl:ance
~ ~
I' 'l06 XllDQV 4(,7>11@ t1<lg -O J, )- -> ( Oyer rr <
<c aa<< I'7> ~4
<isa'4a I'I 'h<rI<l D< ':a .'
7=. << ~ O.<N 0 Wi
~
' i.DP. ".
<<LIP. - S.c' 4)4 Q Pi(il;-'> ". i'~ '7QU '. VG.' iV.'~ "<.l YTL'C> QQGP PZH!
CH~ P.'LQ3 8>l:2'H: ?~.~ ~"a.= 1-;<Z) S>'~ a~< .1=-.'e-QG~iA<XE'. p cLVQ i i1 QU ~
<L1 i <<OS<<<c>i < O <<(BVS i >1 ~
l C'<1 t.lQSP 8 "vQ ~24~'J S '70< i<i%'Ca MV2.9G i QKa'. <<1" 6 V <1 PC<.'~ VC~' <. 'rR 7 6 4<r e r< il<.".<<<~" 1'rB a2.
T C<QI 5'I'Iv",0 <'>>.>ar 7aiOcl <rO " 'l <r '8 v CQUDG) << 'rQ '
~'7" i..
~ ~
'1&
~
U:1 ! S "--1'.Q'g '<ix '<
Qll 'AX" "..
<=0<" 'i JOG 7,;r. '.
)li(-6'kl~ IJl<:i< S VQc1 I J Da BI10 J I-'Qv CO < r>>O<" 6 \'+1 <
MS CQ"Qe::.i;~r QaCQ=i:W. 'OS"~ aS ~.='ou S; Z S;-:Ojeci= O O>1 QW a~~. Q PD<4 g *~ <<0; <<<r'A'1%'<t w ' 'I IJ ~
$'<QQ G < P ~v SRl=<<SZ<=.;Q4 =g' 0 VCclg l41P.. =-DD. 2RP.: X m:1oi; s.xr v~. <<.-"z-'"='c". a" 3.
4ar) 0 ~+$ -. j c Q-arl b)7t 77 CF~"=DZihiI GH:.T".-I: 'Zh"-'= evans . X .Ce'.ll -7QV. ~'O S'i:
QG~)TD ) ~jOQ "7 ll $ 3.'< CIGAR'E r Zf. Z '.l vo'<x GQ "s q xi.e yclx .< 1 Qc! Pc11
~
4.~
(Rl 'g \ <<>> j I<
4 v\ ~ kA ar v Ia
~ i c~+i> C~ Wg ~
Q iLRligll 83: i )
CHAZP~h>H S:ilT.PH: F)63.... g
'PQQ'C 'r'K" CQIi 8 ~ Z II!
SU1.G +;lR': i 56~:G LG ~O Q . QQ.l67A HQ:iBVG ) ~<QQ AiQS ~ c=,.iW)QZGC:c~' i" i~.g i ~8 PC i ."iV." i='- GS
~JQSC~~~QRV "Ci.'" "D ".Zlg ~ 'l'X"SOIi;8 Ci!1C~S i.XQV C.S 0 I'731-ICs 6- P '
.-.=-Opi=- ' n.='-S ZOOS a-c="- V.'.'Il'.n~ ".O COZply V=: h 4 }q~ j Oem'
- ii=.ect;i Ons . L~ LC Z 'l~ 31 ri ~gQI3 QDSPZVGQ i 3c'4 ~
NR. EDD",MLKM:
CSB.Z'PJ20 S&3.:KH: $ T":": '"h"-.':. < a a.'n8, '-Iles, Q38~iYIBP r r% Z8 g 02 Rlg l-O
~
~V..4'= POU CGA).+VSP &:9 4QQ COXQP1 "v Xg.'hl c:" I Q2 'C 6 0:GGX'S Q 7'8 'G'"ll 8 c.Q 'SP Ci. CQ P =CQX V~n.
51K w, i~s~~7, YQi. 'i;O!X,.>%~~2.'1 RG,Zc= ~,EBS ..CQ"l(0".C7 g Z'Lgxa'~Z l"H)JP<~h~g 8'f ~~< g ~gS fQ> "QS 4QQg QgcSO~)P i CQllg'i3C Q
>~l~.S hea ingt rOOni
- "1R. PDDZL';i%'l
C QIIUQXYViG3~P
+Sf Q jg~fiih>i)
e
~
~W ~
2- 68 riO'J t J j t'I,>ah.r 'v' '.'
a,
~ .
s4 tf,%3jrjju IC 'y'~.">7 v Z J'O t it YPG Q~ /TwQ QZK 't. $8 .V3.C';'K t."1' g:.CCGGu fCj:
VQU. l1P VG 1".G: G37GC COP ~ GS 0 t.. ~.'! G - t.:.jt.Oil~/ ) 11PV."~ <: ) '>>'U .
L;Pie ia .>iL'(~I ~ -.Q - ' t. l7'G .Q v - a~ ~ i)itt C'82K '~iMf S "4TTH: 'fcTQti'l Q ~nt. r) "t GGS~
JiG,' ~wS g CO~3.'.GS O 'CQG 'CGSt Mf!Q~tV' O't PC C.G.".:nan'?
ZDDFLiL"7: ? ~ RG:LS lBS DtG. 'G SCAG QP.
"<RVc:e3 BO ' 'C tlG's X~$
Qz ~ Pig'tTg t v f~ ~ C 'Bc Q lt-'S .'tlRCG Gl GS t S O>>
E= 't D )G DB.SV BD+ Z VG +ODQ:t"..C" SUCl1 ."GCUGS 26 jMS. h1RC.
ill'DCQ OL; ~j10 l=GS ~:..tlQDV ~
~ 'I '
+~t 'tQ Skt t G GAG YGSt "Fi1Oj1V~ "2 'G"l ~'7OQLQ Dipl(G "- 'alG S t p>>.:
Ql(1 CQG jlQp j CcN t I
~
)gQll t Q lL(1 Q6 'f t.G Q'~1GQ Q~jgo 0 Q G t O Q+t SQ
'bG ZP."-'tl~EG ~ ~ S OY'i'" CQQV.
Q trl'TPgg gi gjV~t TP.;GV 318Vt~ ~2Y3't CP i.=C '...'Pr" 4~2VG 7 1 QGPQV C",OQG g ~ ~ ~ t P CP t Q>> jl ~
GS.. C t y QQQ PC 5 'i lj,l". - "tGQ QQGC'L 0 vs c. t '4 GV <'1 3.3 lltZRG .; SG Pt.3. ~G~LBlS cj v t1-;;PG G
'QG~~AGl: ~
l~~C t'~: jjlQ' ~+CQGLjtl:.. I >gQU illtj ~ Ct": .
~~@ "wlG
~7~) j tp~f +Q ~ Qf'" jjlQ COQtp /'Q t l1'C "Y'~vie=~ ~
~ ~
63
0
..DO) in as r'Ã p:.:". L.e "oil'Ziun.'.Oa-won s S sa. aoZ'7
.i Q'c ~10u mc~.~1 Ilprrob ' anQ reCLK , ne i.iilen ver X ask =or .-:.-',- 0= iZ Z +0 g~i= ' as XC ~0 me ab i:le CnQ Of. ci16 iles a.ngi giga DR .L" 'S " ..Z Qon i 'cIl" ni i -'Lear~a one,~ ner 0 lio-
+~+e r 40 ne j C.=ne' 'as go'g i 0 aces'cc n-"-s ~i. pe neara i'"2'. ~'-': Ti a.i".' f'ne ".1laC11 m i S" ~ a CHiCDZK') G~GTH". Pe elm Q DR. L'DS: Z missed ~he nod,. Z'm sc=-ry.
CH>XEI~A SM:T'-I: t'~=. L'~del>>~~.
tcianQA.Qg (iQ'.QFieiPi <=0 -"i>. >> Z2'ZeLQaa~ o )
'DR. ~ZDS". 'lJr. Ecaelnan, ile a wo Gay Oxle KsL ng up 'j'ou~ c..( ~~e Boar@. >aS a'.SouSSed '~l 'S sU.gesi etR the O>>e aCO "renal:'~ til~S irxorma""V.On ."0 you. Via.>he hi+e Ci =. rman s get.~ing noarse.
Qi u .Ger i le U." "ng 0': t'le OHKJ.SS1 n esi.BJD" S.l-s re~rang, as;re Q~scuss d se~rera'. ~~~a.es .~lCi in za. ~
gus i ClLSOusse6 Qe. Ore ~pour L .Ka;CeQ aggePZRnCQ S'"r-" emender ~70u L'w ' One 41)I:4C 'Cre,la.S a Cl S 4 On Z 1 C Prclie 4Q a~oia'
0
- "ec'g ' '6: c'Lat '
V<'. 'W "III<<ihI ~
'I C' I 'i' WLC' '- 4 '."' ' 'ei or Qo c I~rle << (>>. ' "e 'J.>>. E" .6 f Ci".. 1 ' '".s AD 4.<<c~ ~ oi; aLas <<eeiha adecr (late . -= cl i c~cn ' van'" 1?OL, =6 mis interpre)c o>3r sta '-
'i~pe srho'ge.~. '" s ';.earinIg ao'j: to: '" 1) ale cnah reIvie (? or "he Staf x
' review of tale ." =: cense app 1 ication.
FiR. ZDDE~(EL~1: LTe1 ", eC nie see 3
- ( Uano.erstanaa
~?6Q cor ec c 1 v 4
~
o'Q Q,"st~,':!.<c',.'s ".CI3cj' al <ever ?I I Gar3 ilg
)0 :ile BoarQ s i 3. ' has to .ilaKe ":vclcianent as co ':z..ether the Staf f s ev." c':" o a " icense apQ ".ca I33 cn has -'eh
< Rc(eQvave ~
'l 2 and -C "aat Clh at ' -" . iS Sue in c 'les Lrle -'".ng ev ~
iL "c 'loL~gh xt
~ ~
s
<<o4 the '~TPhC s 0 'Der ~ >a cozrac i?
DR . ~ ~ DS: Ne3. 1, i.' not an issue in l=".is imari ng with espect Co the entire app ica " on; hu '- it s
't 6 .an issue ' a sense 3.r. Chi s hearing vith respIsct :o the j7 4I 4
Par. Oz "hae or3.g" na 1 hearing tha ~'-e 'e rec.o ng
't S Y&. EDD" ~ L&l: So tP at ?oL~ cov. 'l 0; e BBp 1 e,>>
aise the a=: s ion o f -(shy, i &at revie:? was mace for 3OI3 inson cr 3m~~ s-in.cl:, ti:ey have a 1 1 .~iles e prob 1 en;s nol)?
20 the cal3abi 1 it";ras cc- roc= 1 ~)'va 1 ..at =" at -'":.at po 't ~
LEEDS ~
ry>>a ha-ie gy'~i Qv C'-3 on O-,i 3l ( II)B Gv '(P'L C LL<< " nazi Ih aa>r (rwoh 0 ( I 8 6
.23 ~ 4 >
IlglhI h )~ 5h.V ~ < h p
~ ~g a lI 'I'h ~ ) N vc 3 ~ ai>>> )
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING APPEAL BOARD In the Matter of )
)
CAROLINA POWER 6 LIGHT COMPANY ) Docket Nos. 50-400
) 50-401 (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power ) 50-402 Plant, Units 1, 2, 3 and 4) ) 50-403 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that copies of "Applicant's Response to Postcard Request of Kudzu Alliance and Wells Eddleman,"
dated March 21, 1979, were served upon those persons on the attached Service List. by deposit in the United States mail, postage prepaid, this 21st day of March, 1979.
John H. 0 Nexll, Dated: March 21, 1979
UNXTED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSXON THE -ATOMIC 'SAFETY AND LICENSXNG 'APPEAL "BOARD In the Matter of )
)
CAROLINA POWER 6 LIGHT COMPANY Docket Nos. 50-400
) 50-401 (Shearon Harris Nuclear Power ) 50-402 Plant, Units 1, 2, 3 and 4) ) 50-403 SERVI CE LIST
~Alan .-S.,-Rosenthal, '.Esq,. .-"Charles A.i:Barth, Esq.
Chairman Office of the Executive Legal Atomic Safety and Licensing Director Appeal Board U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, .D.C. 20555 Thomas S. Erwin, Esq.
Dr. John H. Buck P. O. Box 928 Atomic Safety and Licensing 115-West Morgan Street Appeal Board Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Dennis P. Myers, Esq.
Associate Attorney General Michael C. Farrax, Esq. State of North Carolina Atomic Safety and Licensing P. O. Box 629 Appeal Board Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D. C ..20555 -Mr, kfel ls,<Eddleman Route 1 Box 183 Ivan W. Smith, Esq. Durham, North Carolina 27705 Chairman Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Kudzu Alliance U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission .Box 3036 Washington, D.C. 20555 Chapel Hill, North Carolina 27514 Mr. Glenn O. Bright Docketing and Service Section Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Office of the S cretary U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, D.C. 20555 Washington, D.C. 20555 Dr. J. V. Leeds, Jr.
10807 Atwell Drive Houston, Texas 77096
l
)l Oi '/
.I