ML092190886

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Meeting Slides, Nrc/Nei Public Meeting TR Process
ML092190886
Person / Time
Site: Nuclear Energy Institute, Boiling Water Reactor Owners Group, PROJ0704, PROJ0669, PROJ0700, PROJ0710, PROJ0694
Issue date: 08/25/2009
From:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
Mensah T
References
TAC MD4832
Download: ML092190886 (3)


Text

NRC/NEI Public Meeting Topical Report (TR) Process July 30, 2009 Topics

  • Pilot license amendment requests in conjunction with TR reviews

" Development of a 50.59-like process for screening/evaluating changes to approved TRs

  • TR Metrics compared to LAR metrics
  • Lessons Learned From TR Reviews on LIC-500 30July2009/NEI 1

Pilot license amendment requests in conjunction with TR reviews Would improve quality of Topical Report and the NRC review and would improve future LAR submittals Perceived problem with different LAR and TR review cycle NRC metrics Proposed solution is to not include pilot LAR in standard LAR metric Would like to see this addressed in revision 5 of LIC-500.

30July2009/NEI 3

Development of a 50.59-like process for screening/evaluating changes to approved TRs.

" Problem Statement Methodology for determining whether NRC approval of a revision is required does not exist.

Difficult for the licensee to reference a revision that is not approved.

" Proposed Solution Will develop industry method and present at future meeting 30July2009/NEI 4

2

TR Metrics compared to LAR metrics

" What changes do NRC envision in TR metrics?

We believe TR metrics should be consistent with LAR metrics

" Potential additional metrics?

(How will we know we have made improvement?)

NRC?

Industry (potential)

  • Limitations and Conditions
  • Requests for Additional Information
  • Review Cost
  • Rejections and withdrawals 30July2009/NEI 5

Lessons Learned From TR Reviews on LIC-500 BAW-1 0192 Rev. 0, "BWNT LOCA - BWNT Loss of Coolant Accident Evaluation Model for Once-Through Steam Generator Plants" 11 months to acceptance letter PSAT 4025CF.QA.04 Rev. 1, "StarFIRE Model Report" 7 months to acceptance letter At RAI due date NRC determined additional branch review required 3 months later need for outside contractor 2nd acceptance letter received two months later Staff expects to meet draft SE original date 30July2009/NEI 6

3