Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-149,consisting of 850308 Incomplete Insp Rept 50-456/85-06 & 50-457/85-06 on 850204- 0301 & Notice of Violation.Violations Noted:Failure to Ensure Insp Personnel Have Acceptable Level of CapabilityML20214D677 |
Person / Time |
---|
Site: |
Braidwood ![Constellation icon.png](/w/images/b/be/Constellation_icon.png) |
---|
Issue date: |
10/03/1986 |
---|
From: |
Forney W NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III) |
---|
To: |
|
---|
References |
---|
OL-I-ROREM-149, NUDOCS 8705210427 |
Download: ML20214D677 (5) |
|
|
---|
Category:EXHIBITS (DOCKETING AND SERVICES BRANCH INFORMATION
MONTHYEARML20214F1991987-04-22022 April 1987 Applicant Exhibit A-188,consisting of Admitting Exhibit.Util Re General Ofc Records Audit,Lk Comstock Engineering Co,Inc 830110 Memo Re Audit Responses & 821101 General Insp Rept Re Torque Wrench Test Record Encl ML20214F1611986-12-0505 December 1986 Applicant Exhibit A-187,consisting of Forwarding marked-up 860312 Deposition of ML Goedecke in Chicago,Il Re Welding at Plant,Per Board 861204 Ruling.Supporting Documentation Including Related Insp Repts Encl ML20214D8431986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-248,consisting of 840123 Memo Listing Methods for Alleviation of Present Number of Open Insp Correction Repts.Qa Surveillance Rept 3244 Encl ML20214E1371986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-261,consisting of 840508 Memo Discussing Insp of Outstanding QC-US Rept Items for safety- Related Items,Per Author Procedures.Areas Deficient for QC Dept Listed ML20214E0771986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-254,consisting of 840418 Memo Discussing Considerations to Be Taken Into Account Prior to Cross Training,Per 840416 Meeting ML20214E1081986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-258,consisting of 840502 Memo Requesting Assurance in Writing That All Necessary Insps Complete Re Closed safety-related Reworks 014,015 & 018,per Plant Procedure 4.3.24 ML20214C3901986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-233,consisting of 830406 Memo Requesting That saftey-related Cable Pull Cards Be Forwarded to QC Dept for Compliance W/Plant Procedures 4.3.8 & 4.8.8. Basis for Request Discussed ML20214C4441986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-236,consisting of 830719 Memo Advising That Qualified joint-disciplined,certified Inspector Should Inspect Welding When Inspecting Configurations.Reason Stated ML20214F6111986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-274,consisting of 840709 Memo Summarizing Major Concerns Expressed by QC Dept at 840630 Meeting.Overall Mgt Meeting Scheduled for 840718.Response in Memo Form Required by 840712 ML20214F6001986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-273,consisting of 840630 Memo Re QC Inspectors Directing Craft Personnel During in-processing Type Insps.Inspectors Should Not Direct Craft at Any Time ML20214F5861986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-272,consisting of Summary of 840627 Staff Meeting Re Insp of Conduit Straps,Raceway Status,Insp Quantity Vs Quality,Level III Welding Inspectors Assignments & Remodeling Plans ML20214E0941986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-256,consisting of 840501 Memo Discussing Actions Required in Response to T Paserba Memo. Schedule Should Be Established for cross-training of Welding Inspectors,Indicating Progress on Daily Basis ML20214E1071986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-257,consisting of 840502 Memo Advising That Coupons/Samples Being Fabricated W/Acceptable & Rejectable Items on Each for Enhancement of Weld Insp Training Program ML20214F5521986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-271,consisting of 840627 Memo Requesting Attendance of Listed Individuals at 840628 Meeting of Facility Const Assessment Program,Per 840627 Telcon W/C Mennecke.Handwritten Notes Encl ML20214D8241986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-247,consisting of 840112 Memo Providing Plan of Action for Completion of Phase II & Backlog Insps,By 840501 for Welding & Configurations. Personnel Assignments Discussed.Schedules Encl ML20214F5371986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-270,consisting of 840623 Memo Re Falling Behind on Reworks & Daily Insps.Turn Around Time for Rework Review Is 1 Day.Rework Status Update Encl ML20214D9711986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-251,consisting of Undated Reinsp Program Status Rept ML20214E1511986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-263,consisting of 840512 Memo Submitting Guidelines for Completion of New Daily Insp Status Repts.Sample Rept Encl ML20214D6561986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-243,consisting of 831019 Memo Discussing Vendor Welded Hangers Not Conforming to Present Welding Procedures.Concurrence Re Whether or Not Hangers Need Repairing or Acceptable Requested ML20214D6731986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-244,consisting of 831024 Handwritten Speed Ltr Instructing Continued Installation of Pan Hangers in Unit 2 Wing Walls & Insp of Lk Comstock Welds Only.Another Insp Company Analyzing All Mfg Welds ML20214C5211986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-240,consisting of 831003 Memo Forwarding Trend Analysis Rept,Per Util Request.Rept Consists of Review of Lk Comstock Insp Correction Repts from Spet 1982 - Aug 1983 ML20214F4661986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-269,consisting of 840616 Memo Re Improving Inspectors Productivity,Per Conversations of Last Supervisor Meeting.Plan for Improving Insp Output Should Be Submitted by 840618 ML20214D6341986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-242,consisting of 831011 Memo Authorizing RM Saklak Signature Authority for Items Including Review of Insp Correction Repts/Notification of Change Repts & Welder Qualification Forms for 831013-19 ML20214D7611986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-246,consisting of 831108 Memo to All QC Inspectors Reiterating Previous Instructions That QC Checklists & Insp Correction Repts/Nonconformance Repts Used in Field During Insp ML20214C4821986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-238,consisting of 830923 Memo Re 830922 Welding & Configuration Meeting.Instructions Resulting from Meeting Discussed ML20214D6231986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-241,consisting of 831005 Memo to Training File Summarizing Requirements for Proper Documentation & Use of Checklists Re Insps,Established During 830929 Training Class ML20214C4321986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-235,consisting of 830707 Memo Questioning Why Engineering Requesting That Lk Comstock Engineering QC Prepare Ncrs for nonsafety-related Items When Author Not Chartered to Inspect nonsafety-related Items ML20214C5081986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-239,consisting of 830827 Daily Insp Status Rept W/Handwritten Instructions for Completing Repts ML20214C4611986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-237,consisting of 830805 Memo Requesting Inspectors to Conduct Weld Rod Insp Prior to Leaving Areas Under Insp,Due to Util Surveillance on Weld Rod Control ML20214F8361986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-277,consisting of 840806 Memo Requesting Nonconformance Rept for DCRs Mentioned in Encl J Poe Memo (C84-07-06) & RM Saklak Reply.Request Received One Day After Due Date & Involves Reinspection ML20214E1261986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-260,consisting of 840505 Memo Proposing Estimated Completion Date of Jan 1985 for Review of Avos.Proposal Based on Use of Two QC Inspectors Devoting Efforts Solely to Avo ML20214D8751986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-249,consisting of 840124 Memo Forwarding Electrical Bulk Quantity Curves for Period Ending Dec 1984.Curves Include New Fuel Load,Eccs,Ihf & Unit II Cold Hydro Dates & Reflect New Estimates for Unit 1 ML20214D9211986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-250,consisting of 840125 Memo Discussing Activities Which Should Be Undertaken in Response to Util Surveillance 3244 Re Timeliness of Closeout of Insp Correction Repts ML20214E0831986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-255,consisting of Minutes of 840426 Meeting Conducted as Result of 840424 Meeting W/Util Re QC Insp.Personnel Instruction Logs Encl ML20214E0721986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-253,consisting of 840227 Memo Listing Individuals & Respective Insp Disciplines for Which Qualification by Stated Dates Required ML20214C4151986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-234,consisting of 830516 Memo Re Weld Insp non-reported Backlog Chart Condition.Backlog of Weld Insps Discussed ML20214E0411986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-252,consisting of 840209 Memo Requesting That Present Insp Correction Repts (ICR) & Nonconformance Repts Be Closed by 870220.Response to Listed Requirements Requested by 840218 ML20214F8921986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-280,consisting of 840801 Memo Listing Revised Counts for Backlog Insp for Welding & Configuration,Junction Box & Equipment & Riser Project ML20214F8821986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-279,consisting of 840730 Memo Suggesting 100% Reinspection on All Cable Pan Riser Hangers ML20214F8751986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-285,consisting of Forwarding QA Investigation AR007388-7396 Re Pace of Facility Const Assessment Program.Related Documentation Encl ML20214F8581986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-278,consisting of 840723 Memo Forwarding Status Rept for Wk of 840713-19.RM Saklak 840726 Memo Responding to 840721 Memo Re Welding/Configuration & K Worthington 840723 Memo on Root Causes of Backlog Encl ML20214F8391986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-284,consisting of 841023 Memo Re Concerns Addressed in Through Paint Weld Insps.Requests Response by 841026.Related Info Encl ML20214E1131986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-259,consisting of 840505 Memo Requesting Matrix Indicating All Special Projects Involving QC Dept & Manpower (by Name) for Each by 12:00 Pm 840507,per 840503 Meeting W/D Cosaro ML20214F8331986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-283,consisting of Re Steady Increase in Number of Insps Not Completed in Current Group.Table of Facility Qc,Number of Insps Incomplete, Organization Chart & Other Related Info Encl ML20214F8221986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-282,consisting of 840822 Staff Meeting Summary & Minutes,Weekly Mgt Rept for Week of 840813 & Update of Current Insp Group.Related Viewgraphs Also Encl ML20214F8021986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-281,consisting of 840801 Memo Recommending Inclusion of New Welding & Configuration Count Compiled by K Worthington Into Backlog Status Rept to Be Issued 840803.Addl Insps Will Not Be Complete Until 840905 ML20214F8011986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-276,consisting of 840730 Memo Requesting Completion Date for Qualification/Training in Remaining Areas,Per Lk Comstock Procedure 4.1.2 ML20214F7911986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-275,consisting of 840721 Memo Forwarding Status Summary Rept for Wk of 840113 - 840719, Weekly Insp Status for 840712-18 & Backlog Completion Schedule for Wk of 840713-19 ML20214E1871986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-268,consisting of 840613 Memo Requesting Written Clarification Indicating Individual Responsible for Beam Stiffner Installation,Per Encl 840529 Speed Ltr ML20214E1741986-12-0404 December 1986 Intervenor Exhibit I-ROREM-266,consisting of 830419 Memo Advising That Requirements for Reporting Clearance Problems Re Installation of Piping,Conduit,Cable Tray & Other Components Described in Encl Eliminated.W/O Stated Encl 1987-04-22
[Table view] Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20207E0051999-03-0202 March 1999 Transcript of 990302 Public Meeting with Commonwealth Edison in Rockville,Md.Pp 1-104.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20236H9381998-06-30030 June 1998 Transcript of 980630 Meeting W/Commonwealth Edison in Rockville,Md.Pp 1-123.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20198P3001997-11-0404 November 1997 Transcript of 971104 Public Meeting W/Ceco in Rockville,Md Re Measures Established by Ceco to Track Plant Performance & to Gain Understanding of CAs Put Into Place to Improve Safety.Pp 1-105.W/Certificate & Viewgraphs ML20149H0301997-06-19019 June 1997 Comment Opposing Proposed Generic Communications Re Control Rod Insertion Problems ML20059C2351993-12-17017 December 1993 Comment Supporting Petition for Rulemaking PRM-21-2 Re Commercial Grade Item Dedication ML20204G3081988-10-19019 October 1988 Order Imposing Civil Monetary Penalty in Amount of $50,000, Per 880506 Notice of Violation from Insp on 880301-17 ML20154K0301988-05-20020 May 1988 Transcript of 880520 Dicussion/Possible Vote in Rockville,Md Re Full Power OL for Facility.Pp 1-70.Related Info Encl ML20148G2161988-03-25025 March 1988 Decision.* Affirms Concluding Partial Initial Decision, LBP-87-14,25 NRC 461.Served on 880325 ML20149D8231988-02-0101 February 1988 Notice of Withdrawal.* Withdraws Appearance as Atty for Util in Proceeding,Effective 880201.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236A8341987-10-21021 October 1987 Transcript of 871021 Proceedings in Bethesda,Md.Pp 1-100 ML20235K8741987-09-30030 September 1987 Notice of Oral Argument.* Oral Argument on Pending Appeal of Intervenors Bridget Little Rorem from Board 870519 Concluding Partial Initial Decision in Proceeding Will Be Heard on 871021.Served on 871002 ML20235H7121987-09-25025 September 1987 Memorandum & Order.* Intervenor Appeal from ASLB Rejection of late-filed Contention Dismissed & LBP-87-19 & LBP-87-22 Vacated on Grounds of Mootness Due to Util Withdrawing Amend Application.Served on 870928 ML20237L7461987-09-0303 September 1987 Order.* Oral Argument on Pending Appeal of Intervenors Bl Rorem Et Al from Licensing Board 870519 Concluding Partial Initial Decision in OL Proceeding Will Be Heard on 871021 in NRC Public Hearing Room.Served on 870903 ML20237L7721987-09-0101 September 1987 Reconstitution of Aslab.* Notice That Aslab Has Been Reconstituted for OL Proceeding.Board Will Consist of as Rosenthal,Wr Johnson & Ha Wilber.Served on 870902 ML20237L6931987-08-28028 August 1987 Decision.* Review of Licensing Board 870513 & 0706 Partial Initial Decisions Revealed No Error Necessitating Corrective Action.Result Reached by Licensing Board Re Decision LBP-87-13 Affirmed.Served on 870831 ML20237K0361987-08-11011 August 1987 NRC Staff Brief in Support of LBP-87-14.* Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236P1101987-07-31031 July 1987 Brief of Comm Ed.* Brief Filed Re Appeal by Bridget Little Rorem,Et Al from ASLB 870519 Concluding Partial Initial Decision.Appeal Shoud Be Denied & Decision Affirmed. Certificate of Svc Encl ML20236N9791987-07-31031 July 1987 NRC Staff Response to Aslab Order of 870721.* NRC Supports Deferral of Briefing of Intervenors Appeal Until Applicant Affirmation Re Withdrawal of License Amend Application Received.Bc Hunsader Encl.W/Certificate of Svc ML20236N8851987-07-31031 July 1987 Response to Intervenors Request for Deferral of Further Appellate Proceedings.* Forwards Util to NRC Withdrawing License Amend Applications Re Ownership.Pending Appeal Should Be Dismissed.Certificate of Svc Encl ML20235Y8711987-07-23023 July 1987 Appeal from Licensing Board Denial of Motion to Reopen Record.* Intervenors Rorem Appeal from Decision of Licensing Board of 870706 Denying Rorem Motion to Reopen Record for Purpose of Admitting Late Contention.W/Certificate of Svc ML20235Y9081987-07-21021 July 1987 Order.* Date for Filing Briefs Re Intervenor Appeal of Board 870706 Memorandum & Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration & Motion to Admit late-filed Contention Postponed Until Further Order by Board.Served on 870722 ML20234D0521987-07-0202 July 1987 Motion to Reopen Record to Admit late-filed Contention on Financial Qualifications.* Record Should Be Reopened Since Rule Barring case-by-case Financial Qualification Adjudication Not Applicable ML20235D6761987-07-0202 July 1987 Order.* Intervenors 870623 Motion That ASLB Reconsider 870610 Memorandum & Order Denying 870506 Motion to Reopen Record & 870701 Motion to Admit late-filed Contention Denied.Motion in Alternative Dismissed.Served on 870707 ML20234D0961987-07-0101 July 1987 Affidavit of DW Cassel.* Affidavit Re Intervenors Rorem,Et Al Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Late Filed Contention on Financial Qualification.Related Info Encl.W/Certificate of Svc & Svc List ML20216J8821987-07-0101 July 1987 Motion in Alternative Before Appeal Board.* Intervenors Hold That Jurisdiction Over 870701 Motion to Reopen Record to Admit Late Filed Contention on Financial Qualifications Remains W/Aslb.W/Svc List & Certificate of Svc ML20234D0361987-07-0101 July 1987 Opening Brief of intervenors-appellants Bridget Little Rorem,Et Al.* Board Majority Committed Errors of Fact & Law That Compel Reversal of 870519 Concluding Partial Initial Decision.Certificate of Svc Encl CLI-87-07, Order CLI-87-07.* ASLB Concluding Partial Initial Decision, Resolving All Contested Issues & Authorizing NRR to Issue Ol,Reviewed by Commission & Effective Immediately.Separate Views of Commissioner Asselstine Encl.Served on 8707011987-06-30030 June 1987 Order CLI-87-07.* ASLB Concluding Partial Initial Decision, Resolving All Contested Issues & Authorizing NRR to Issue Ol,Reviewed by Commission & Effective Immediately.Separate Views of Commissioner Asselstine Encl.Served on 870701 ML20235A7271987-06-30030 June 1987 Transcript of 870630 Discussion/Possible Vote in Washington, DC Re Full Power OL for Facility.Pp 1-70.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20216D1941987-06-22022 June 1987 Order.* Amend to 861107 Protective Order Which Resolved Dispute Between ASLB & Commission Ofc of Investigation Over Disclosure of Certain Investigatory Matls.Certificate of Svc Encl.Served on 870623 ML20215J8891987-06-19019 June 1987 Applicant Texas Utils Electric Co Petition for Directed Certification of Licensing Board Order of 870312.* Brief Supports Granting Petition to Vacate ASLB 870312 Order. Supporting Documentation & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20215D9241987-06-15015 June 1987 Memorandum on Licensing Board Jurisdiction.* Jurisdiction Over Intervenors 870506 Motion Retained Until Further Action of Licensing Board Due to Util 870528 Filing of Application for Amend to Ol.Served on 870616 ML20214W9601987-06-12012 June 1987 Transcript of 870612 Telcon in Washington,Dc.Pp 18,585- 18,596 ML20214W5031987-06-10010 June 1987 Memorandum & Order (Denying Intervenors Motion to Admit late-filed Contentions on Financial Qualifications).* Rorem, Et Al 870506 Motion Re Financial Qualifications of New co- Licensees Denied for Want of Jurisdiction.Served on 870611 ML20214W5491987-06-0909 June 1987 Notice of Reconstitution of Board.* Iw Smith,Chairman & Rf Cole & AD Callihan,Members.Served on 870610 ML20214W4911987-06-0909 June 1987 Order.* ASLB 870513 Partial Initial Decision Addressing Emergency Planning Issues Will Be Reviewed Sua Sponte & Will Not Be Deemed Final Until Further Order.No Appeal from Decision Received ML20214P0811987-06-0101 June 1987 Notice of Appeal.* Intervenor Bl Rorem,By Attys & in Accordance w/10CFR2.762,appeal ASLB 870519 Concluding Partial Initial Decision Re Plant Which Served on Parties on 870521.Notice of Appearance & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20214N0521987-05-28028 May 1987 Affidavit of Mj Wallace.* Affidavit of Mj Wallace Re Startup & Initial Criticality of Unit 1.W/Certificate of Svc ML20214N0471987-05-28028 May 1987 Affidavit of Jc Bukovski.* Affidavit of Jc Bukovski Re Delay in Startup,Testing & Commercial Operation of Unit 1 ML20214N0421987-05-28028 May 1987 Commonwealth Edison Co Comments to Commission on Immediate Effectiveness Issues.* Forwards Affidavits of Mj Wallace & Jc Bukovski.Requests Opportunity to Be Heard If Commission Contemplates Such Stay ML20214N4321987-05-26026 May 1987 NRC Staff Response to Motion to Admit late-filed Contention on Financial Qualifications.* Board Must Deny Motion to Admit late-filed Contention & Deny Request to Certify Question of Waiver to Commission.W/Certificate of Svc ML20214N3901987-05-22022 May 1987 Amend to Concluding Partial Initial Decision.* Amends 870519 Concluding Initial Decision to Delete Limited Authorization Granted NRR to Issue License for Low Power Testing,Due to Issuance of LBP-87-13 on 870513.Served on 870526 ML20214N0631987-05-19019 May 1987 Errata Correction.* Requests Pen & Ink Corrections to Minority Decision Pages Forwarded as Corrected Pages to Errata .Pages 73,74 & 75 Should Be Numbered as Pages 72,73 & 74,respectively.Served on 870529 ML20214N0851987-05-19019 May 1987 Errata.* Forwards Corrected Pages to Minority Opinion, Matters of Dissent.Served on 870528 ML20214G5141987-05-19019 May 1987 Response to Intervenor Motion Seeking to Reopen Record for Admission of New Contention.* Intervenor Filed Motion, Motion to Admit Late Filed Contention on Financial Qualifications. Affidavit & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20214N3431987-05-19019 May 1987 Errata to Concluding Partial Initial Decision (Ol).* Minor Editoral Corrections Listed.Served on 870528 ML20214G5921987-05-19019 May 1987 Concluding Partial Initial Decision (Ol).* Due to Violation Re Discouragement to Document Any Major Deficiency That Could Result in Lengthy Delay in Production,Civil Penalty Should Be Imposed on Comstock & Util.Served on 870521 ML20214G8701987-05-18018 May 1987 Notice of Reconstitution of Aslab.Gj Edles Chairman & WR Johnson & CN Kohl Members.Served on 870520 ML20213F9971987-05-13013 May 1987 Partial Initial Decision on Emergency Planning Issues.* ASLB Resolves All Outstanding Issues Re Offsite Emergency Favorably to Applicant Subj to Certain Info Being Included in Next Emergency Info Booklet.Served on 870514 ML20215K9991987-05-0606 May 1987 Motion to Admit late-filed Contention on Financial Qualifications.* Contention Based on Util 870406 Filing Re New Ownership & Financing for Facility.Affidavit & Certificate of Svc Encl ML20214F1991987-04-22022 April 1987 Applicant Exhibit A-188,consisting of Admitting Exhibit.Util Re General Ofc Records Audit,Lk Comstock Engineering Co,Inc 830110 Memo Re Audit Responses & 821101 General Insp Rept Re Torque Wrench Test Record Encl 1999-03-02
[Table view] |
Text
.__ - - _ - _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - . __ . - - _ _ _ _ _
r.A n s u i 6 a .s 6 U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION
$f[
REGION III '
'87 AFR 22 P7 :24 ,
Report No. 50-456/85-006(DRP); 50-457/85-006(DRP) . $,p. -
Docket Nos. 50-456; 50-457 Licenses No.'CPPR-132; CPPR-133
.
Licensee: . Commonwealth Edison Company Post office Box 767 Chicago, IL 60690 Facility Name:- Braidwood Nuclear Power Station, Units 1 and 2 Inspection At: Braidwood Site, Braidwood, Illinois Inspection Conducted: February 4 through March 1, 1985 Inspector: R. N. Gardner r LM _
Approved By: , e /
,
Date Inspection Summary Inspection on February 4 throush March 1.1985 (Report Nos. 50-456/85-006(DRP);
50-457/85-006(DRP))
Aress Inspected: Special, announced safety inspection of the Braidwood Con-struction Assessment Program (BCAP) in regards to licensee action on previously
, identified items, Construction Sample Reinspection (CSR) Documentation Review Checklists, invalidated BCAP discrepancies, CSR reinspection activities, and RSCAP,setivities. The inspection consisted,of 144 inspector-hours onsite by one NRC inspecto .
Results: Of the five areas inspected, no items of noncompliance were identified in three areas; two items of noncompliance were identified in the remaining areas (failure to ensure that inspection personnel have acceptable level of capability - Paragraph 3; and failure to take proper corrective action - Paragraphs 3 and 4).
I NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMW15110N l Docket No. W N MSI Official Exh. N l
"'
$O0$k$5000$56 *
PDR s att soinnE0 Acc'icsnt R;ClinD
- ntervenor RtJEC: 9 I
- -
Cont's 01fr Cantactor CAff / ~ '
I [EXill8IT @ um/s/1 ';v oin, witam 'F M
!
'
Ed '8*mes l$serties 312 232-0262 ,,
/
- , _, . ._
. . , . . ., - , . , . - .
. - - . . - - - - . __ . - _ . _ _ _ _ _ -
'
-
_
Ex. 12.f-2, .
Appendix NOTICE OF VIOLATION
.
,
Co m nwealth Edison Company Docket No. 50-456 Docket No. 50-457 As a result of the inspection conducted on February 4 through March 1,1985, and in accordance with the General Policy and Procedures for NRC Enforcement Actions, (10 CFR Part 2, Appendix C), the following violations were identified: CFR, Appendix B, Criterion II, states, in part, that "The quality
-
assurance program shall provide control over activities affecting the -
quality of the identified structures, systems , and components. . . . The program shall provide for indoctrination and training of personnel performing activities affecting quality as necessary to assure that suitable proficiency is achieved and maintained."
Commonwealth Edison Company Quality Assurance Masual, Quality Requirement No. 2.0, Section 2.3, states, in part, that " Qualifications and certi-
,
fications will be... established to meet the applicable requirements of i
. . . ANSI Standard N45.2.6. . . Contractor personnel engaged in inspection. . .
will be required to be trained, qualified, and certified to perform their specific activity in accordance with the above requirement ANSI M45.2.6-1978, Paragraph 4, states, in part, that " Personnel who are assigned the responsibility and the authority to perform functions covered by this standard shall have, as a miniassa, the level of capa-
, bility shown in Table 1. Table 1 requires a 1,evel II capability for personnel evaluating the acceptability of inspection and ====4aation
results. According to Table 1. Ievel I inspectors are authorised to act
) as data takers but they are not authorized to determine the acceptability i gt of construction activitie '
AfiY p Contrary t.o the above, the licensee's electrical contractor utilized Level I Quality Control (QC) inspectors for inspection and acceptance
- of electrical welds. This practice involved 14 different Level I
,
inspectors over a four year time period.
I j This is a Severity Level IV violation (Supplement II).
] CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion XVI, states, is part, that " Measures
!
shall be established to assure that conditions adverse to quality, such
} as...nonconformances are promptly identified and corrected."
l
Commonwealth Edison Company Quality Assurance Manual, Quality Requirement l
No.16, Section 16.1, states, in part, that "A corrective action system will be used to assure that such items as. ..nonconformancies. ..which are adverse to quality. . .are promptly identified and corrected."
!
!
,
$
a
'l
. _ _ _ _ _ __
. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . - - _ _ _ _ . . _ . _ . . . . _ _ _ . _ . _ _ . _ . . . . _ . . _ . _ ,
._
.
s Ex.12.F-2, Appendix 2 l Contrary to the above, the following instances of failure to take proper
- corrective actions were identified: Although the Braidwood Construction Assessment Program (RCAP)
had identified that Level I QC inspectors had inspected and accepted construction activitie's, in violation of the require- I ments delineated in ANSI N45.2.6, this nonconformisg condition l was not documented as a BCAP observatio gf-phila ) j l Thirty-seven BCAP observations, which dealt with the lack of i QC verified " red-lined" record copy drawings, were. invalidated I by the RCAP taskforce even though the documented basis for the invalidation of the observations did not support the l invalidation gf.ol, Of b) l This is a Severity Level IV violation (Supplement II). l l
Pursuant to the provisions of 10 CHL 2.201, you are required to submit to this l office within thirty days of the date of this Notice a written statement or ;
explanation in reply, including for each iten of noncompliance: (1) ,
corrective action taken and the results achieved; (2) corrective action to be taken to avoid further noncompliance; and (3) the date when full compliance will be achieved. Consideration may be given to extending your response time for good cause show .
March 8, 1985 ME/l)a_
R. 7. Warnick, Chief
Dated Projects Branch .
t
@'
. - - --- . , , . - _ . _ . , , , . _y ,,_m__, ,._,.,,__,_----.,,e .,-,~,,_,-._--m-m,
.
. ._ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ . _ _ . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _
. . s
. -
Ex.12.F-2, Level I inspectors is questionable. Previous inadequacies in the training program for Level I electrical weld inspectors, as documented -
in NRC Inspection Report Nos. 456/84-07 and 457/84-07, increases the concern rega'rding the acceptability of welds inspected and accepted solely by Level I QC inspector This failure to establish and implement a program which assures that QC
, inspection personnel, who are performing activities affecting quality, i are trained and certified to the level required to adequately perform
! those activities is an item of noncompliance to 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, i Criterion II '(50-456/85-006-02; 50-457/85-006-C2) .
. Review of Invalidated BCAP Discrepancies
- The inspector reviewed 37 BCAP observations which documented deficiencies identified during Construction Sample Reinspection (CSR) documentation reviews. The population for which the documentation reviews were per-formed was small bore piping configuratio The observations dealt with the lack of QC verified " red-lined" record copy drawings required by Phillips Getschow Co. (PGCo) procedures. While the observations were validated by CSR engineers, they were subsequently invalidated by Sargent and Lundy (S&L). The inspector was informed by Evaluation Research Corporation (ERC) personnel that IRC observation number 007 had been initiated by ERC to document the Independent Expert Overview Group (IEOG)
position that the S&L invalidations were unacceptable. The ERC obser-vation correctly concluded that in developing the "As Constructed" drawing, QC was required by procedure to verify the accuracy of the verification drawing and that at issue in the BCAP observations was the lack of the signature or initials of the certified inspector who performed the verification. Since the inspector who performed the verification was not known, the acceptability of that inspector's level of certification could not be determined, and therefore rendering the status of the inspection indeterminat The inspector subsequently reviewed the BCAP written response to the
- ERC observation. This response stated that tS QC -signature on the verification drawing was not required as the 5 inspector who performed the field verification marked up the verification drawing copy as necessary and signed the "Stop Work Order" to signify completion of the
'
QC verification. The BCAP response further stated that the BCAP Small Bore Pipe Configuration Document Review Checklist would be revised to
'
reflect the QC signed "Stop Work Order" form as an acceptable alternative to the QC signed or initialed " Red-line" drawi:3 (This revision was i subsequently issued on February 1, 1985.) Finally, the DCAP response stated that observations describing the lack of a QC signature on the
" red-line" drawing previously processed as valid would be reprocessed as
.
invalid observations. ERC concurred in the respons In reviewing this matter the inspector, accompanied by the Senior Resident Inspector, discussed the PGCo implementation of procedures QCP-40, Revision 3 and QCP-21, Revision 6 with PGCo engineering and QC personnel. As a result of these discussions the inspectors determined
!
!
- 4
,1 a
_, _ _ - , _ - _ . - _ _ . . _ - . _ , _ . . _ . - . . - - _ - - .. . _ _ . . . _ . . _ . . _ _ , - . _ . _ , . _ . . ~ . , , _ . . , _ _
- _ _ _ . - _ - . - - _ . - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - -
, . 3
-
. .- -
Ex.12.F-2,- . .
that the QC inspector who signed the "Stop Work Order" was not the QC
'
inspector who p u formed the field verification but was a QC inspector who I worked in the QC office. h e the QC signed "Stop Work Order" is not an
-
acceptable alternative to a QC signed or initiated " red-lined" drawing.
,
h invalidated observations do identify a valid nonconforming condition
'
regarding the Small Bore Piping Configuration documentation in that there
'
was no record of the QC inspector who actually performed the field verification. Therefore, the acceptability of that inspector's level of certification remains indeterminat ,
'
.
The invalidation of the 37 BCAP observations is not acceptable, is ,
'
considered to be improper corrective action, and is a further example l of noncompliance to 10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion XVI '
l (50-456/85-00,6-01(B); 50-457/85-006-01(B)). 1
1
' CSR Reinspection Activities ,
! On February 19, 1985, the inspector witnessed the overinspection of a 4" conduit. The overinspection was performed by BCAP QA inspectors. The conduit had previously been reinspected by the BCAP taskforce. The CSR reinspection package number was
> CSR-I-E-CMD-054 while the conduit number was C2A5194. During the overinspection the inspector determined that the reinspection performed by the BCAP taskforce accurately documented the
, acceptability of the conduit, On February 20, 1985, the inspector, accompanied by the Resident
- Inspector, inspected tw conduits which had previously been
'
reinspected by the BCAP taskforce. h CSR reinspection package numbers were CSR-I-E-CMD-004 and CSR-I-E-CMD-044 while the conduit numbers were C2A0217 and C0A760 .
The inspectors concluded that the BCAP reinspections were performed in an acceptable manner.
f On February 26, 1985, the inspector witnessed the overinspections I
of three cable pans. N overinspections were performed by ERC inspectors. N cable pans had previously been reinspected by
- the BCAP taskforce. The CSR reinspection package numbers were CSR-I-E-CBP-054, CSR-I-E-CBP-056, and CSR-I-E-CBP-057 while the cable paa numbers were 11678J, 216161, and 1905A. During the
- overinspections the inspector determined that the reinspections i
performed by the BCAP taskforce accurately documented the acceptability of the cable pan On February 27, 1985, the inspector witnessed the overinspection of a large bore pipe support which had previously been reinspected by the BCAP taskfor e. N overinspection was performed by BCAP QA inspectors. N CSR reinspection package number was CSR-I-M-002-052 while the pipe support number was M-ICV 07065R. During the overinspection, the BCAP QA inspectors identified that the 1/2" offset dimension for the support to beam attactment was out of i
_ __ _ _ _ . _ . - - __ . . _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ .- _ - _ ~ ... _ - _ _