IR 05000295/1993004

Enforcement Conference Repts 50-295/93-04 & 50-304/93-04 on 930127.Major Areas Discussed:Root Causes & Contributing Factors for Violation & Corrective Actions Taken or Planned by Licensee Re Insp Conducted on 921027-930108

ML20128F796
Person / Time
Site:	Zion  File:ZionSolutions icon.png
Issue date:	02/03/1993
From:	Farber M NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION III)
To:
Shared Package
ML20128F784	List: IR 05000295/1993004 ML20128F779
References
50-295-93-04, 50-295-93-4, 50-304-93-04, 50-304-93-4, NUDOCS 9302120036
Download: ML20128F796 (3)

Text

., ..; .

-U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

..

REGION 111 Reports No. 50-295/93004(ORP); 50-SO4/93004(DRP)

Docket Nos. 50-295; 50-304 Licenses No. DPR-39; OPR-48 Licensee: Commonwealth Edison Company 1 Opus West III 1400 Opus Place - Suite 300 1 Downers Grove, IL 60515 Meeting Conducted: January 27, 1993 Meeting At: Region III Office, Glen Ellyn, Illinois Type of Meeting: Enforcement Conference l l

'

Inspection Conducted: October 27, 1992 through January 8, 1993 Inspector: D. E.~ Jones  ;

Approved By: MW ~

7-

'

M. J. Farpyr, Chief / date Reactor Projects Section lA Meetina Summary Enforcement Conference on January 27. 1993 (Recorts No. 50-295/93004(DRP): 50-304/93004(DRP).

-Areas Discussed: A review of a Severity Level: IV Violation, the root causes and contributing factors for the violation, and corrective actions:taken or-planned by the licensee. In addition, the following personnel error events ~at '

Zion were addressed: foreign object damage to the 1A AFW pump, Unit 2 AFW support damage, ILRT valve. lineup errors, and inadvertent steam dump _-

isolation. The violation was for failure to independently- verify the position ?

f of Unit 1,1B motor driven auxiliary feedwater (AFW) pump discharge isolation valve (1FWOO38) to be- fully open -Juring the valve realignment on October 2,-

1992.

,

l

!=

9302120036 930205 PDR ADDCK 05000295

. PDR

'

.

'

.

DETAILS Persons Present at Conference-Commonwealth Edison Company (CECO)

M. Wallace, Vice President, Chief Nuc. Lear Operating Officer R. Tuetken, Site Vice President, Zion Station T. Joyce, Station Manager W. Kurth, Superintendent, Production J. Zura, Nuclear Station Operator T. Printz, Operating Engineer D. Giernoth, Shift Engineer E. Broccolo, Services Director M. Jackson, Regulatory Performance Administrator R. Ward, Regulatory Performance Manager S. Kaplan Regulatory Assurance Supervisor K. Dickerson, Regulatory Assurance M. Mason, Regulatory Assurance S. Stimac, License Administrator S. Reece-Koenig, Nuclear Licensing R. Budowle, Quality Verification W. Stone, Performance Improvement Director P. Barnes, Compliance Supervisor U. S. Nuclear Requlatory Commission H. Miller, Acting Deputy Regional Administrator, Region III (RIII)

W. Forney, Deputy Director, DRP, RIII M. Farber, Chief, Section lA, DRP, RIII D. Jones, Reactor Engineer, DRP, RIII R. DeFayette, Director, EICS, Rill

• J. Smith, Senior Resident Inspector, Zion, RIII

• C. Shiraki, Licensing Project Manager, Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation

• Denotes those who participated via telephone Enforcement Conferencg An enforcement conference was held in the NRC Region III Office on January 27, 1993. This conference was conducted as a result of findings of the inspection conducted October 27, 1992 through January 8, 1993, in which a Severity Level IV Violation of HRC Regulations was identifie Inspectinn findings and violation are documented in Inspection Report No. 50-295/92031 (DRP), transmitted to the licensee by letter dated January 19, 1993. A copy of the licensee's slide presentation is attached to this repor l

.- _-

__ . _- _ - _ _ _ _

<

. . . l l

The purpose of this conference was to (1) discuss the violation, root _ l causes, contributing factors,-and the_ licensee's corrective actions; and !

(2) discuss recent personnel error events at Zion, which included the !

following: foreign object damage to the 1A AFW pump, Unit 2 AFW support ;

damage, ILRT valve lineup errors, and inadvertent steam dump isolatio l During the enforcement conference, the licensee acknowledged the ,

Severity Level IV Violation as stated in the inspection repor The l

'

licensee's presentation thoroughly covered the AFW pump discharge isolation valve IFWOO38 event investigation-including a synopsis of the event, investigation results, safety significance, and corrective actions. In addition, the licensee discussion of recent personnel error events also included causes and corrective actions. Personnel error reduction was also a topic of discussion which included implementation of the root cause process, personnel error event trend identification, corrective actions and results achieved, and 1993 initiative A lessons learned discussion concluded the licensee's presentatio Attachment: As stated

.

.-.