ML20199H091

From kanterella
Revision as of 07:24, 10 December 2024 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Partially Withheld Memo Re Telephone Call Expected by J Zudans on 850220.Author Monitored Telephone Until Listed Time.Call Not Received.Partially Deleted Handwritten Notes Re Meeting W/Technical Review Team & Related Info Encl
ML20199H091
Person / Time
Site: 05000000, Comanche Peak
Issue date: 02/22/1985
From: Kline M
NRC
To:
NRC
Shared Package
ML17198A302 List: ... further results
References
FOIA-85-299, FOIA-85-59, FOIA-86-A-18 NUDOCS 8607030109
Download: ML20199H091 (16)


Text

____________

g/f,* **c,70,,

w UNITED STATES NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION s,,'7:

y r.

g W ASHINGTO N, D. C. 20555 h

.y

%,,.....f FEB 2 21935 l

Note to Files Aramised to call John Zudans collect on (301) 492-7903 at 1700

' nours ebruary 20, 1985.

I monitored this phone until 1800 hours0.0208 days <br />0.5 hours <br />0.00298 weeks <br />6.849e-4 months <br /> EST -

and ever called.

M.E. Kline 8607030109 860623 PDR FOIA GARDE 86-A-18 PDR

<=otA-25-5?

i

, <, =.

i' ' ' ', : h ' "

i a p a7

,;.. v..

.a.

. u..

am..

a m.

.a a

m.

a,ma xm-m man,m mmeg m eu m. mmo + oye yn,.am.amm mgar,wl.p..a4mmamEg.eQg mpg.ggmbgm m. mgHg ggm mMag a

4 g

adpgg Mepg 4H A,a m.

/

7r W

r-um JQW f

l g.

w',\\

il d,6 S PM %

U%w s (),.

i

_dds T

Ct5 L/zs A ktsA o

-see i

1 i

ItW 1

ad ej-

\\

Or es h

+ce N.

w-i

\\

O

(,/dd AM i

i 1

[*

gr.

m

___p____.-..___-

j' :

'2 0 - 8 f ft $

zac-5 G 9 g,, 2 s-a. m.

g" W

f-P h -Fb A M

@%c7w 4: /s p m.

l L -m J.

corbit$hs l

W bhm

'7M-f/so 20,

!l Ba-W N'Y, m go

~ ~ + -

sp-, w t

$Am.tA AsAw -N/2c 'e oa f'" 'to 50's

%f' d

'f Y.T

~

A d

l l

9.e

' i'

  • 4 de J*

<a

his' Gistil.}S 3 -2. e -8 5 4.'1.=rwt. b

~.

Ob h

(/a c/c ~'l?)

V b

.$lAs/li f

t'.5 os m.omu 4 s

&lt, <>,

r,r.-c, S-

/h.dwan. - - ),.,sibyadf., 44weA

+

&Ahm wx Awc,J /ssc<cs a J s m sses- >..e c. ~ <p. i cc ~ ay 5

!ccsl Sz'veyes a n d e n /ec k s S t

&nacle,-ed' S.

0-AcNs as 2 anf.3 a'ay /l ads' a e/.skises sc.c.t c,,,/s. c 7 0.>uad iwn O'-As/fs ere.ccresr:.:d au.A rfre.1s es xce e.Jc. eor.l h

,l

'l Bed /diny /ca.ls cn s cyyser me>~4ew &,arye9 <~fy /

k S M :crr ca. d) we-a.:f.eJ,<g,c...y ase1 p.i c c.4..a.

v A.i)

, c:,. ua.

h

($.

.d.. Lsl

[gab ~

f S

./Le N

  • L g4lll fC -

L.f. s [Q

(*

jpfh*$h

?

2 Q

e.

i?,

[.';2'-ut',"ry:

a tiax :iy & u s'c l?

hn :u G.,c,,,,;tteJ (e,;,ti e,,.pgs.: jk, gi:rl S y", er C ['9 7 "'

L.:1%.a A

~

L'.*'a y ' bib liE'"

V jy', /Q 'd.i :ht f J'et'net sea. J d4 %(rud. *eiua+yaiea?a~~%

e.

-)

/g u. J.:,, c.:i i

9 9 13 ( nct-de,ucn 6 e.)

., C.
1. J !.r Le

. gofne

.>1

(s.

NCE?"0 e

(b' STR BILIT!

h 3/03 (A f d.

(3) 6oX FRA146 57R,/SNvSS (b) 'v' boa.T STR/5NvBB h

(4 b' &A.T Q) ST,WT M/4L(7i42)

@) c u e p O.):,w m c w narir.il

(**) STR F!tAne5 Gh+1G HGA. STT3T'SP1LL'$'c 'il-21: A65) f1XEs (E) Bid}GhE'15 7D.sToP s7fJT'.501% PR!?1' TD Pull'Cl'S (b) CLIP AtxLE To !!OLD U Bc)fs (6c.k FT-)

(6) LU.S,5 (GTCP,%'lhL '80Ylior07H=TtU:551 h

(=0 f, bub!ESTRDy~ Tot 80R F2 (

(e)

BUMPe?.s ra REPMicE sTRUTmk (0.5(+)Hs 70 'O' GAP (~THL9lin. CMT)

(0 QtNGHi!JG 'u Be.CT5

@. LonD3 o!/ SPT* NOT AG2ED F:f (4 S M/6

/f6E.DWAR6 (b) swiF]s' 4. 0 P ST12U13 $ SNUBBERS (0-) FRic17oN C6".)

@ 0 L o/1D A fo R..s N O BBi'J 4 :'7RU T3 I

h.

(6) hCTUAL S E*C7ib?] PI:.oP(!Yt.b 30(CC-

.6 Fct K'..y!)

(5) HMGil(G 3vfPotJ5 cfF R LCli-80!,13

~

'p) f}--SH.9-hs. D t.STR?5CM of t twi?! KidH IN BM

<Q)(S; sWE

.i.T. itGT*.

An Y Dik'3er.

  • 1,&+-t4i'T4tiliGi1 0T Yi TJK.: ;L.121!.T!!!!'IH'

~i

(@0-(.U-lll&RP2I' YDP51.9ti4!:G'u:bh ifIC4 HSPD W.A.M (8) DIFF 46 0.1<t/P oF Sil'Ji%.'D(I'A% PtKT nr 8 v.J.,.C.)

(b) cross SAI1-(W7 7vs6@ FCC 'U'T102. (CC-CcX'-066) [g'IS<@vb (9) 1%V6lE A XthL RESTg(Sih!.sNVBhEP 5)1. no :'t<T REi. TO 37 FF.

(9) rgensat.er e.yCnse) cono Ren;srassonor/

h ElC,4HONDS f~

~rn (8) EXCESS b (ALTER.5 571FF SPT~)

l h~f (b) Be7JblNG IN BoiX

@)

(G) St% doiblT~ NOT f,GCP.PT' FOR.. DYNAlltCS (d) sdang. tenus por essen eri PROPet Disr! Bas W '

(e) HEHo 4 FR.4/NG ACTTCd NOT. Qibit)

6) :!)co(LREc7 Proc.W.ip Te>C CodPLlHS Tops / Sit 70 tA' ST

?, -

~' f$k..

Me

d l

lochL GFFECT5 Nor Goristp.,,NAtT rseeycy' Mac.114)

Q) Ifo"$ DIRPt4 FAIAURE CC.cR- ?o9 yppy. op c>jjp> g

& 71lBE' WALL EXS.'d.h Fhil. vee.* CC-Itc.-038 CP 2*HtcSITE

@) FAlt-wcx t?

cc-ors-o 37 5 33c.

UBCCi(' h g)SX.%! l4;.FMI 7;&& % M ep, y 5

@) FRIL PiJGlW

  • h'

[E 7'.)IYICNAL FA!).vCE Sl'T*l0K atL. friL ad-ts?-N2 A!.wnoL'&L. /)P.t9i S

(& C AL(L. of P.t G!b '!D 16CAtti n.';;Mf' 3P]' 5? PL54 f~oRHa (t) (w95EO $,. <Gc' GRD.nv6 R.'e!.b.S lblT!C /01- ),1 iNTbRJ) eR)?C.tt)lG, (h) 2AJ f>>k. pal >3 IN1(ik; Win} V!iE-(i) QA)L :P K)hPP:NG HDDE' NOTT.Y!l.5/D- /WE'd I:att!. Qt},

t

(.i) PUAIQ!) r 3 SME&R NcY ALUllhyS' 15 ED ( $ h cNgth (h.) SiktT 70893.NI BhSG'P UO PNUI **UI% 0Y Sild WAU-5

&'U'B01Ths2$$ tony (a) cru sas z wAY lehDS (b) u)l1H 2Why' Uhb5 5M'GTICN NEED ID BE AGCCONT6b FCf.'.

(Q) w s 71+ z. tu n Y "

n e' B.'NDIN%

'I

?) CINCHED DeluN 'O' B6.LTS (5) J.oA.D E'Aast.'.DS MF3 L.o5 AunW.

(p~

(b) P'M L TriR0 ON 7 'E355 NOT vhi.Q.(_l.',0, !!'/ATT}

@)inwss h: dhnDS CN PIPE 55FEQ11/N. UCAL CTi 35 $ S72 4D euTPcT

' && ?i'. HRP.D!CiyPE SMUT?.!*iM'IT-CJ.21MP ETc.

(b) STRUCT - 1:' M.T e' sn:..'cr

, 80%. BHS, vf Erc, a

(C.) K.!cK / ' ADS 4NO!'/.WL.37Rt/TS (1) CIMC.H5b uP 'U' ikLT SF WCT5

(@ SW. Pf'AlfG 0:.>HSTRh!ilTS (y) A NO.fMkS hrcKid'^ '7.'!hTML GHCl47h (3) EPfECT.'i 0F TRONMibHS ll'nD CK.NC

& Bupi> luc, J.onu.s ou spr neusens

~.

QT) wRLL Tc te ALLY / WAU.. TD PLletEUM ETC D*Ls (Sko$"

(6) SG1sHIC.

, G5TRAINT

@)(H) fcn%L STIFF NE55 sn mvess

~

l',5 GEUGillC.

op. l.ssgy. cyl5pjc.

ty h.vNIXiiiS/EE tUEU%

v,

.t....

.......-.a g......

@n) Ok!)Cl<. PR.o PM!ir;ou G.

(& WGLDS 7!FA'r VICA, BGry} p5q i.p.5-

.s y aj 5 C.I~ TO c R4 Cl< (1e w1THovr yo; EXfH NG::M2.:!7 AIG AlttM ours/pE <3 s.S ncy gys t

0 AI6N L3h-b3 GA f ift: 4:,1/6 2 o; yy,;.

.g p J -

. >.) g t 4 g%. g,.'+,

,.g g G D B C T:\\ u n a-Pl.Mi!WM F&R iyir g.

05 CC LU pSE 2H&:l< ~O r WR6 whu Dy2 ;,2, ccp(p g figg. yo

'J9 A Pf6/D!^ XL.

(5) THiS Wh6 PSIIriEb ::'T' //; t,5.yc, et.;,.,,,g,y,,g_.y,.y in (BJ GAA.C..

GO GSMS HhS FeJMD~78?c. sk GA:.cs bvE NoT-S1791D

hkOIJG, (0IHAVE.t@uA!b l-IC S T* Of: A PPl.

OALq s.p g ; y ac9eg g iN THERE 1%hfl. - th).. P. - Het-t Rc=s,T g pump 3

/

DifrPH, 70.tStsNFM.

ET'2 J

j ' ] 7 j f _..

l 1

f O

e 9

T^j l

gf t

i

%l

\\

Now why don't we say what this is ref erring to.

Can you first tell me, DENISE let's look at what newspaper this is.

I This is an article writter by Bruce Milar, it's publishec on -

Alright.

l i

f. CHECK Fcrt Werth Star Telegram.

l Tuesday merr.ing, Februarv 7.10JS DENISE Fort Worth Star Telegram.

s.

r

, And it reads as follows, "A group opposing the licensing of Ceman:ne Peat I

nuclear powe'r plant, Monday, criticized a proposal by plant owners te a n three outside consultants for an evaluation of pipe supports at the pla-Juanita Eiiis, president of the Dallas based Citizens Associatier for Scanc.

I stic she opposed selection of engineering consultant., Ecasco

Energy, Servi:ss, Inc.', cf New York, and CYGNA Energy Services Comcany c' San Sne saic both have a stake in the licensing of Coman:ne Pea-Francis:c.

te review quality.cor.t-ci at tne ciant.

as:

Ebasco is uncer certract uti'.ity officiais hired CYGNA for a SE00,000 technical evaluatier of CASE witnesses, Jack Doyle and Mark Walsh, say that u.-

design standards.

is not an independent assessment anc lacks sufficiert CYGNA repert l

Walsh and Doyle are former engineers at Comanche Pea.

engineering data.

Well I.cen't know acything about Walsh and Doyle, and I don't know an.s ini about anything else, but I do know a little something about pipe supoc :

~

And it bethered me, then I get to thinking, well what if they de them

  • w

& $c ? %d D I

} %

ff hs %!

~,

-. g: K.;

M,,,

fI

7 a,,-

y

~

q ~~Ya

.y.

1 swin.+

I l

l N

c m p' Q c C D t d,.

e s^ov

...5

.f i

r~

e e

to47W4J (NlMyJ $Mn covft 4M MM3 4

+

~

fS/M AffLtH) JCd 74/e& ce 4 WHs0, Ao A fa/ pay fy.r,7 rse fax poM&J M N s

w,

.i. ~- n.,,.

Thaw seyahse /*&

.,. ~ ~_

ff w,, n&-:h==u,y.,,s

/ kb

}/d /Y17 f/3/

&d l~

WeMM -

1 l

I i

l..

l DklY

8 e e o

~

Aeis tik k w

Mw~

A+c ps

~;&.y

e. uyi kie,9e f pea-i f4wlc'.C f'kr{ cit l1**~S - 4fpltc4lvt (c% b.Sgtabc,J co.~h:o veaf s,'#

clalejtykv

  1. 'flcO/7 l

DCv4sek b

OM

- lGVc:<zyplJ l(

  • c'L'V*4s % & h h v l

4 4

4 1

l

}

I, I

I v

l l

' t, a

t sa

a.

1 s

  • ._b.

k

/

g 5

h f

)

x

[

y) 1 A

\\n 5

=1

)

hm h.D

.g e

gy

~ '

h..

ok.

)

N-

.. g f-

.t'

};

13

.s k,

O,

\\

.i

, ~

Q y

- _R

.b... 5c.m,.1;..

4 s

7. y.; -,..

A.

.V

.N. :s-2.: ';%

k' ?

b,- E ht w ;p. S$is i y;:e.

.,'a.,.., u.~ L. '

  • a,.

'N

}

^

=V.'

k

...-.~..;.

9 g

J m..-

w n.r -

3..., ;,

.p.y 3_

. g; -;p-..

3:.6

-Q

,.,h,.,y: '.?..jfb..p, g y.. I l

.. :.,.!,y : ~,. -

. g.

j y

R-

, 5.

g

- -....m...

. g.

1 4

...: z.Q.

4. -i.i. ~ o. -

\\.

2, Q

u

' P; v

q'*.3 I

.n Y.

?.5%

nuu uuu e-L L :.

g a=

}'

su-u O

H

~***

ooa L-O i

EEE b

'O

...f-E. E. G

-~

f w

..: (

en. em 8-Q&

3 e

h e t

's

. g.

F E.

i

/

.e s

I

\\

3 e

st

}. '

~

~'e-

  1. e W.,-

',f.l ' '. ^

  • MS:

. C. ~. : i,-

c'

  • 'it? p j W,D :.. ;'il # s k ? L 5 %. A.:a'd s.1 '.: ;____.:1, : :...

.:..U.h d :.

Adisa:S, r.a

-i

t-:?.:.

2 246 69-98-V10d i

~

3g S<4r

- te he t

y a:

4 f

e g.

(4 e j$

4:

h,

.w C

A N

n ct

.c

+A t

.c

.a.

h.

9

't e

E cs n

M

.g 4I

- 4 3g 1

im

'{

R

)

t m0

(

.T gw$!

l k

4 DF

{h 54 p

1

,g iN LMa $ 1 s t Y

/

!E s

g& I k h k $ h I,S k

Kk E

9 4

  • e 6 4M EL R..$e
  • iw t 11 !! %

. ill p t 1 t i {a p l i'

  • 1 jH EI R j/ g *{-t* Dj'-

t

D q-4 i

cu

,a l-

,u

. a s s,i g =

t

-l 9

g s

' e 3 4 3 b8h vt hI k 4 4 Ebb 3

4 ma a-c

09 l

l-l l

1

$1 l$' j. l4 1

I

'[

lwN l

l l

ln l

l l

3 i

o. o l

.l l

~

~

l 1

aE

\\

_ EE ll r

l p.3 t

(.

2

.n yu y

v t

4

'e

,1 x

)

A n

s

,g t

Ji 'gsk7 f k

,o,

? t },'t t

.~

~

s!3 6 s

It n Qf t y

y.

t,.

E 40$j1 ia k

8) db.

b)

I

'Q c

a 8

l T2 6,

., - T2 % $4%'

i $ k i

[.

ll--l~(:__

~

~

~

x ;_ - __

y ll n

L sh h

h I

> +

1

~

i u,lw l

(

1 1

3 l19 f

l l

glc l

l.

I.

s al, I

l l.

=

Ele I

l'7 l

eq l

1

$m g4 2

e f

y--I e*

s g

h 3

Ls 4

j

,(

1

-t 9

e a\\

g a

O.

ky

{s

}D 3i w

, k

.\\ N k

qd DI g

'w 1

i eat N

e

$ g" 4 e3

+

d-4.h 4

4 g

r g

2 I

5glE la 4ft E l

l

~

a 4

hw Ie l

p Mwi=3, cza iah awxwz

. :s -

.: n -.,

--3m-

__ n. ~ _..

-.m,

]g bcle Pd TNM hy-A-6</

Di wM s C_rncardmg

-178C I-N R C.

'Ska.g.ufw Ge pv V tJo.

As 2 3- 007, by H

B rooks 6trif 6,

cGerut 9 t <r r.5, Suse.c+: ca.u. p a ca m a c a-+ cs. ~

pm%

e.g. C w e.; m P_e d s fe _

eee:fi SWh..

A & c A a d.-

ResJs o.f h u;%.

W R -I-l9 95 i

(2 pges To m

( Ex. 6 ca 7 m),

4 O

e S

e

/

6 l

F0lA-85-59 t.:

=.

aw u Ja4

=

aw-

e

.: raw-mm

--