ML20214C529
| ML20214C529 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Harris  |
| Issue date: | 02/12/1986 |
| From: | Eddleman W EDDLEMAN, W. |
| To: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| References | |
| CON-#186-132 82-468-01-OL, 82-468-1-OL, OL, NUDOCS 8602210169 | |
| Download: ML20214C529 (8) | |
Text
.
PlMEDCORPMW UNITED STATES OF AMERICA DCCKETED USNRC j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 12Fegagf71 21g 1 BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD OFFICE C. 5 - -
Glenn O. Bright DOCMEig /ct Dr. James H. Carpenter James L. Kelley, Chairman In the Matter of CAROLINA POWER AND LIGHT CO. et al. )
(Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant, )
Unit 1) ) ASLBP No. 82-h68-01
)
OL Wells Eddleman's Requests for Subpoenas on Contention 57-C-3 (Night-time Notification)
Pursuant to the Board's Order of 1-24-86 and 10 CFR 2.720(a),
and other applicable rules, Wells Eddleman hereby moves that the Board Chairperson issue subpoenas for the following persons:
Jesse Riley, 854 Henley Place, Charlotte NC 28207 (7.0h-375-h3h2);
Dr. M. Reada Bassiouni, ATI, 22 Union Wharf, Boston MA OP109, (617-367-016h); Bob Black, CP&L, Box 1551 Raleigh NC P7602, as my witnesses, and for Eugene J. McKinney of Southern Bell Marketing, 800-532-6786 (w),
70h-365-0571 (h) as a Board witness on telenhone alerting systems.
Mr. McKinney is knowledgeable about available telephone dialing systems as well as those under development. I understand his managemen t is not in favor of his testifying voluntarily for n'nyono, but being subpoenaed as a Board witness is the best alternative.
Note that, first, his testimony is relevant since the contention calls for the use of telephona alerting systems and no testimony has been presented on that issue. Also, per the VC Summer test, the Board in its order of 1-16-86 found the record deficient (item 6) concerning mechanisms such as the telephone alerting system caTled for by the E WJ 1.SC> S
o .
l l
l contention. The Board allowed the PEMA staff, NRC Staff and Anplicants
, o proyide testimony or the telephone alerting system (it's mentioned in FEMA-43), but none have indicat'ed they will. Thus, the e !s no ;
alternative (since Intervenor cannot get voluntary testimony) to the Board's calling Mr. McKinney as its witness on telenhone alerting systens
, Dr. Bassiouni and Mr. Black were the principal affiants in summary disposition on 57-C-3 Both have extensive knowledge relevant to this contention, and Dr. Bassiouni has wide experience with about 4/5 of the nuclear utilities in the US concerning alerting systems including tone alert radios, telephone, and other systems as well as sirens. Dr.
Bassiouni is well qualified to answer the Board's questions 1,3,h,5 and 6 (or questions arising under those items in the 1-16-86 order), and he has stated he has knowledge concerning item 2 (the Gernaa siren . study which he brought to the attention of the Board and narties). Mr. Black, as CP&L's senior emergency n1anning person, knows the CP&L alerting system, alternatives considered for expanding / augmenting it (item 6) and can assist in calculation of numbers of households. In addition he nay have both opinions and information Applicants have withheld from the equivalent situation to testimony (a reliable source showed this was trde when Dr. Bassiouni j
was not called on Contention 57-C-3 originally). Mr. Black should be familiar with both the alerting system and calculations concerning it, as well as telephone dialing systems, tone alert radios, etc.
Mr. Riley, as an intervenor's representative in the Catawba _ NRC proceeding (50-413/h14 OL) dealt with telephone alertin6 . systems and has knowledge concerning the effectiveness of alerting systems (Item
- 1) and knowledge of siren alerting systems and telephone alerting as a backup / supplement (Item 6) and has extensive experience in calculation which may be useful in dealing with items 2 thru 5 of
the Board's 1-16-86 Order.
Having shown the relevance of the above-named witnesses' testimony, and the apnropriateness of calling Mr McKinng as a -
Board witness, Wells Eddleman hereby reouests that the subpoena,s, duces tecum (attached to Board, Applicants, Staff and NRC DociNiiing and Service conies only) be executed by the Board Presiding Officer in order that the information and knowledge of these nersons, which is inportant, and in the cases of Dr. Bass!ouni and others vital, to the resolution of the issues in this proceeding including especially the 6 items reopened by the Board 1-16-86, most particularly item 6 and reliable information on items 1-5 It is expected that Dr. Bassiouni's knowledge of tone-alert radio systems tried (and in some cases scranped) by other utilities will be nost particularly relevant in light of Applicants' new plan to provide tone-alert radios within 5 miles of the Harris nuclear plant.
Respectfully,
/ -
Q,1g Wells Eddleman 2-12-86 Intervenor, for himself Attachments, as stated P.S. Mr. Riley indicates he is most readily available to testify the morning of 4 March. I have indicated h March on all subpcenas but will be flexible with the witnesses schedules, of course.iWL
~ .
@ UNITED STATES OF AMERICA PED NUCLIAR REGULATORY C0!C'.ISSION tter of CAROLISA POWER k LIGHT CO. Et al. )) Docket 50-h00 InDu Shen ry' Harris Nuclear Power Plant. Unit 1-0.L.
CEltrIFICATEOF SERVICE I here y ce ify that copies of k (6*G#J h fytdr
~
YNbMb00k%3_S 0d Ato 3'D-C ~? [Wini!-% IU W .}
day of Feb.wt, 1981,bydepositin l HA een served this the US Mail, first-class postage prepaid, upon all parties whose names are listed below, except those whose nanes are parked with an asterisk, for whom service was accor:plished by Judges James Kelley, Glenn Bright and Janas Carpenter (1 copy each)
Atomic Safety and Licensing Board & their Law Clerk, sane US Nuclear Regulatory Comission address Washington DC 20555 Al Cole, Karen Long or Thomas.A. Baxter or Jo Anne Sanford George F. Trowbridge (attorney for Applicants) -
Fq tttorney General's Shaw, Pittman, Potts & Trowbridge -
Office 1600 M St. NW -
M L622 Washington, DC 20036 .RaI61cn !r 27602 Office of the Executive Legal Directer . s Spence . Arry Attn Docke ts 50-400/h010.L.
USERC fiftd ggti FEMA 500 C St.
Hoom 840 Sw washington DC 20555 Washington DC 20740 Dan Read Docketing and Service Section (3x) C);AMGEMLP 3ox 2151 Attn Docke ts 50-h00/hC1 0.L. .
Office of the Secretary Waleigh, NC 276062 USNRC Dr. Linda W. Little Washington DC 20555 (F Plan Only) Governor's Waste Mst. Bd.
Steve Rochlis 513 Albenarle B3 dg.
John Runkle FEFA, Suite 700 325 H. sam 8but" St.
1371 Peachtree St. NE Ra1.ngn, NO 27611 Granville Rd ,
Chapel Hill Ne 2751h / Atlanta GA 30309 Bradley W. Jones Robert Gruber USNRC Region II
'Travi s Payne Exec. Director 101 Marietta St.
Edelstein & Payne Public Staff At3anta GA 30303 Blex 12601 Box 991 Raleigh NC 27605 Raleigh NC 27602 Richard Wilson, M.D. Certified by w
- 729 Hunter St.
Apex NC 27502
1 Enitch Biates of America NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION O
In the matter of.
Carolina Power & Light Co. g al.
SHEA'10N HARRIS NUCLEAR POWER PLANT, > DOCKET NO.50-h00 OL UNIT 1 TO Dr. M Reada Bassiouni ATI .
22 Union Wharf Boston, MA 02109 (617)-367-0164 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear ...at...the.. dawn. town..Eoliday... Inn in th e ci ty o f .Ra.1eigh., ...NC............ ... ...... ... ....... . ..... .. ...... . ............. ....... ... ...... ........ .
on th e.......h.t,h...... day o f.. M,p,pp,h,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,3 9,f,6 ......a t... .... $.*.3.0..... 0'clo ck A . M.
t o testify o n behalf o f ...We.l.l. 8.. 3.d,d,l e,ma,n,,, ,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, , ,,,,,,,,, ,,
in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) or object (s) described:
- ' ic.
all documents relating to matters raised in Board itens 1, 2,3,h,5 or 6 (including tone alert radios and telenhone alerting systems) of the Licensing Board 's 1-16-86 Memorandum and 0* der reopening the record on Contention 57-C-3, and all relevant l
information and documents concerning the Harris plant alerting 07 stem. BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY ATIDRNEY FOR "-~~" " " " " * " " " * " " "
Wells Eddleman. nro se AnA pn% m- nn-ham NC'27701-3131 RLEPHONE 919-688-0076 i
/
l l 10 C.F.R. 2.720 (t) presiding offscer or.11 he is un.aiiabre. the On motion made prompsty, and in any esent Commission may (1) qunt or modify the sub-l at or before she time specified be the ashpoena poena if it is unreasonable or requires evidence for complianet by the person to dom the sub- not relennt to any matter in issue, or (2) con-poenn is directed. and on notice to the party at dation denial of the morton on just and reasonable l uhoar hastance she subpoena sees issued, the terms
Enitch 9tates of America NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION O
In the matter of:
Carolina Pow & Light Co., et al.
SHEARON HARRIS NUCLEAR P0'4ER PLANT >. DOCKET NO.50-h00 OL Unit 1 TO Bob Black, CP&L .
Box 1551 Raleigh NC 27602 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear ....a.t...tho... downtown.4Iol.i. day-Inn in the ci ty o f ....P.al e.ig h r .: NC....... ... ..... .... ........................... ... ... ...--. . ..~ ...~.. . ...
on the.....h....@...... day o f......'.. ...M,a,rc,h,,, ,, ,, t 9,,$,6......a t.... ....... 0.13.0.. 0' clock A . M.
to testify on behalf of .....We11.s..-Ed.dlema-n-.- .. - -. ~~~~....~.- - .- --
in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) or object (s) describedt
, . , . a. -
All documents relating to matters raised in any of Board items 1, 2,3,14,5 or 6 (pages 8-11 of Board's 1-16-86 Memorandum & OM er in this docket reopening the record on Eddleman Content' on 57-C-3) and any other documents you possess relevant to telechone ale = ting systems, tone alert radios uronosed to be used by CP&L in the Harris EPZ, and all other vge66YR 6P fMPO6AR f SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY .
AT'IVRNEY FOR .. ... 19- .
w112 m , m r; ,n se N P o -h - " N " hem NC 27701-3131 TELEPHONE OIO bbb OO7b
/
10 Cf.R. 2.110 (f) ensiding ofpcer or, if he is unvanabre. the On motion made prompsty, and in any ewnt Commission may (1) quash or modify the sub-at or before she time specified in the ashpoena poena if it is unreasonable or requires evidence for comptinnee by the per,on to whom the sub- not niennt to any matter be issue. or (2) con-poena is directet, and on notice to the party at dition denial of the motion on just and reasonable mAcar bnstance she subpoena uns Loued, the termL
k Enitch Biates of America NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION O
In the matter of:
CAROLINA POWER & LIGHT CO. et al.
Shearon Harris Nuclear Power Plant, TO Eugene J McKinney Southern Bell Marketing Charlotte NC (800) 532-6786 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear .at...the...Dc.wr Bown..Holi.dair... Inn in th e ci ty o f . . 3.4.1#16h.,...E..... .. .. .. . . .. ........ ......... . .... . . . ....... ..... .. .... . . . . ..... . ..
on the......4....D.... day of.. ..N.ay,ch,,,, ,,,, ,, ,,19,,8,6.. ..a t.. 8.O.9... .... .. 0' clock A M.
to testify on behalf of ......the...Lic.en. sing..iloa.nd...in...this...nroces. ding,.. ....
in the above entitled action and bring with you the document (s) or object (s) described in the attached schedule. (comnrising the Board 's Memorandum and Order of 1-19-86: please bring all information relevant to the items mentioned, particularly telephone alerting systems and devices now available or under develBpment).
BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND 1.ICENSING BOARD BY ATIDRNEY FOR . . . . . . .. .. .. .. 1 9 _ .
Vol l a t;'adinmon 7-n oo, AnA unwvan 4t.
Durher "" 2??01-3131 ntzrnout 919-688-0076 (Licensing Board 301-192-7C00) 4
/
10 C.F.R. 2.720 (I) presidins offscer or, if he is unve.ilable. the On motion made prompsty, and in any ewnt Commission may (1) quash or modify the sub-at or before the time specified in the arbpoena poena if it is unreasonable or requires evidence for complianet by the person to whom the asb- not relevant to any matter in issue, or (2) con-poena is directed and on notice to the party at dition denial of the motion on just and reasonable sahoar hnstance the subperna was tsaned, the terms.
A .
Enitch Biates af America NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION C
In the matter of:
Carolina Power & Light Co. et al.
O.
I Shearon Harris Nuclear Plant, Unit 1 50-400 0.L.
I l
l TO Jesse L. Riley 854 Henley Place Charlotte NC 28207 .
l 70h-375-4342 YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear ..A.t...the...HoJ, ids.y... Inn.. Downtown j
m th e ca t y o f. .... . ... ..g.g. . . . .g.g. . .g . .. . . . .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . .. . .. . . . .. . . . . . . . . . ..
on the.....h.th....... day of... March..... . ........1936... . ..a t... . 8.:.30........ 0' clock a .M.
to testify on behalf of ....... . . . .Wel.
Eddlema
- l. .s ..............n..........................
in the above entitled action a.nd bring with you the document (s) or object (s) described :
BY ORDER OF THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD BY Mr $ddleman, pro se " " " * " ' " " " ' " "
60(- Parker St. Durhan NC 27701-3131 71ELEPHONE 919-688-0076 ,
.- l 10 C.F.R. 2.720 (t) presising ofpcer or, if he is unmitable. the On motion made prompsty, and in any ewnt Commission may y) qunah or modify the sub-at or before she time specified in the anbpoena poena if it is unreasonable or requires evidence for compliance by the person to whom the sub- not relesent to any matter in issue, or (29 con-poena is directed. and on notice to the party at dition denial of the morton on just and reamnable sukone bastance she subpoena sus tanned. the terms
_ _ _ _ - _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ - _ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ -