|
---|
Category:LEGAL TRANSCRIPTS & ORDERS & PLEADINGS
MONTHYEARML20196G4021999-06-18018 June 1999 Comment on FRN Re Rev of NRC Enforcement Policy NUREG-1600, Rev 1 & Amend of 10CFR55.49.Concurs with Need to Provide Examples That May Be Used as Guidance in Determining Appropriate Severity Level for Violations as Listed ML20206H1881999-05-0606 May 1999 Exemption from Requirements of 10CFR50,App K Re ECCS Evaluation Models. Commission Grants Licensee Exemption ML20206H2221999-05-0404 May 1999 Exemption from Requirements of 10CFR50.60 That Would Allow STP Nuclear Operating Co to Apply ASME Code Case N-514 for Determining Plant Cold Overpressurization Mitigation Sys Pressure Setpoint.Commission Grants Exemption ML20206M5111999-04-30030 April 1999 Comment Supporting Draft RG DG-1083 Re Content of UFSAR IAW 10CFR50.71(e). Recommends That Listed Approach Be Adopted for Changes to Documents Incorporated by Ref CY-99-007, Comment Supporting Proposed Changes to Improve Insp & Assessment Processes for Overseeing Commercial Nuclear Industry That Were Published in Fr on 990122 & in SECY-99-0071999-02-22022 February 1999 Comment Supporting Proposed Changes to Improve Insp & Assessment Processes for Overseeing Commercial Nuclear Industry That Were Published in Fr on 990122 & in SECY-99-007 TXX-9825, Comment Endorsing NEI Comments on Proposed Rulemaking to 10CFR50.65, Requirements for Monitoring Effectiveness at Npps1998-12-14014 December 1998 Comment Endorsing NEI Comments on Proposed Rulemaking to 10CFR50.65, Requirements for Monitoring Effectiveness at Npps ML20195C7541998-11-0505 November 1998 Order Approving Application Re Proposed Corporate Merger of Central & South West Corp & American Electric Power Co,Inc.Commission Approves Application Re Merger Agreement Between Csw & Aep ML20155H5511998-11-0202 November 1998 Exemption from Certain Requirements of 10CFR50.71(e)(4) Re Submission of Revs to UFSAR ML20154C4101998-09-30030 September 1998 Comment Re Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Reporting Requirements for Nuclear Power Reactors.Comanche Peak Electric Station Endorses NEI Comment Ltr & Agrees with NEI Recommendations & Rationale ML20248K5051998-06-0909 June 1998 Confirmatory Order Modifying License (Effective Immediately).Answer for Request for Hearing Shall Not Stay Immediate Effectiveness of Order ML20216E1051998-04-0707 April 1998 Comment Supporting Draft RG DG-1029 Titled Guidelines for Evaluating Electromagnetic & Radio-Frequency Interference in Safety-related Instrumentation & Control Sys NOC-AE-000109, Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Rev to 10CFR50.55a, Industry Codes & Standards.South Texas Project Fully Endorses Comments to Be Provided by NEI1998-03-30030 March 1998 Comment on Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Rev to 10CFR50.55a, Industry Codes & Standards.South Texas Project Fully Endorses Comments to Be Provided by NEI ML20217H3611998-03-26026 March 1998 Comment Opposing Draft GL 97-XX, Lab Testing of Nuclear Grade Charcoal, Issued on 980225.Advises That There Will Be Addl Implementation Costs ML20198Q4851998-01-16016 January 1998 Comment Opposing PRM 50-63A by P Crane That Requests NRC Amend Regulations Re Emergency Planning to Require Consideration of Sheltering,Evacuation & Prophylactic Use of Potassium Iodide for General Public ML20211A4871997-09-12012 September 1997 Changes Submittal Date of Response to NRC RAI Re Proposed CPSES risk-informed Inservice Testing Program & Comments on NRC Draft PRA Documents ML20149L0311997-07-21021 July 1997 Comment on Draft Guides DG-1048,DG-1049 & DG-1050.Error Identified in Last Line of DG-1050,item 1.3 of Section Value/Impact Statement.Rev 30 Should Be Rev 11 ML20140A4871997-05-27027 May 1997 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule Re Safety Conscious Work Environ.Util Agrees W/Nuclear Energy Inst Comment Ltr ML20137U3531997-04-0808 April 1997 Order Approving Application Re Formation of Operating Company & Transfer of Operating Authority ML20133G5411996-12-0505 December 1996 Transcript of 961205 Meeting in Arlington,Tx Re Comanche Peak Thermo-Lag Fire Barriers. Pp 1-111 ML20135B7881996-11-29029 November 1996 Order Approving Corporate Restructuring of TU to Facilitate Acquistion of Enserch Corp ML20128M8011996-10-0303 October 1996 Comment Opposing Proposed NRC Generic Communication, Primary Water Stress Corrosion Cracking of Control Rod Drive Mechanism & Other Vessel Head Penetrations ML20116B8871996-07-19019 July 1996 Transcript of 960719 Predecisional Enforcement Conference Re Apparent Violations of NRC Requirements at Plant ML20097D7321996-02-0909 February 1996 Comment Opposing Petition for Rulemaking PRM-50-63 Re CPSES Request for Amend to Its Regulations Dealing W/Emergency Planning to Include Requirement That Emergency Planning Protective Actions for General Public Include Listed Info ML20094Q6421995-11-28028 November 1995 Comment Supporting Petition for RM PRM-50-62 Re Amend to Regulation Re QAPs Permitting NPP Licensees to Change Quality Program Described in SAR W/O NRC Prior Approval If Changes Do Not Potentially Degrade Safety or Change TSs ML20094H4801995-11-0808 November 1995 Comment Supporting Nuclear Energy Inst Comments on Proposed Rules 10CFR60,72,73 & 75 Re Safeguards for Spent Nuclear Fuel or high-level Radwaste TXX-9522, Comment Opposing Proposed GL on Testing of safety-related Logic Circuits.Believes That Complete Technical Review of All Surveillance Procedures Would Be Expensive & Unnecessary Expenditure of Licensee Resources1995-08-26026 August 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed GL on Testing of safety-related Logic Circuits.Believes That Complete Technical Review of All Surveillance Procedures Would Be Expensive & Unnecessary Expenditure of Licensee Resources ML20091M6441995-08-25025 August 1995 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule Re Review of Revised NRC SALP Program.Believes That NRC Should Reconsider Need for Ipap or SALP in Light of Redundancy ML20086M7921995-07-0707 July 1995 Comment Supporting Proposed GL Process for Changes to Security Plan Without Prior NRC Approval ML20084A0181995-05-19019 May 1995 Comment Suporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Containment Leakage Testing.Supports NEI Comments ML20077M7311994-12-30030 December 1994 Comments Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR50 Re Shutdown & Low Power Operations for Nuclear Power Reactors ML20077L8711994-12-22022 December 1994 Comment Supporting Proposed Rule 10CFR50,55 & 73 Re Reduction of Reporting Requirements Imposed on NRC Licensees ML20073B6951994-09-19019 September 1994 Affidavit of Cl Terry Authorizing Signing & Filing W/Nrc OL Amend Request 94-016 ML20073B6731994-09-19019 September 1994 Affidavit of Cl Terry Re License Amend Request 94-015 ML20072P5441994-07-13013 July 1994 Testimony of Rl Stright Re Results of Liberty Consulting Groups Independent Review of Prudence of Mgt of STP ML20092C3911993-11-15015 November 1993 Partially Deleted Response of Rl Balcom to Demand for Info ML20092C4031993-11-15015 November 1993 Partially Deleted Response of Hl&P to Demand for Info ML20058E0561993-11-10010 November 1993 Comment on Proposed Rule Re Staff Meetings Open to Public. Believes That NRC Has Done Well in Commitment to Provide Public W/Fullest Practical Access to Its Activities ML20056G3351993-08-27027 August 1993 Comment Opposing Proposed Rule 10CFR2 Re Review of 10CFR2.206 Process ML20045D8321993-06-11011 June 1993 Comment Supporting Proposed Rules 10CFR50 & 54, FSAR Update Submittals. ML20044F3271993-05-21021 May 1993 Comments on Draft NRC Insp Procedure 38703, Commercial Grade Procurement Insp, Fr Vol 58,Number 52.NRC Should Use EPRI Definitions for Critical Characteristics ML20044D3311993-05-0404 May 1993 Comment Supporting Proposed Generic Communication Re Mod of TS Administrative Control Requirements for Emergency & Security Plans ML20056C0831993-03-19019 March 1993 Texas Utils Electric Co Response to Petitioners Motion to Stay Issuance of Full Power License.* Licensee Urges NRC to Reject Petitioners Motion & to Deny Petitioners Appeal of 921215 Order.Motion Should Be Denied.W/Certificate of Svc ML20056C1881993-03-17017 March 1993 Order.* Directs Util to Respond to Motion by COB 930319 & NRC to Respond by COB 930322.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 930317 ML20128F6221993-02-0303 February 1993 Transcript of 930203 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote Public Meeting in Rockville,Md.Pp 1-2.Related Info Encl ML20128D9651993-02-0303 February 1993 Memorandum & Order.* Stay Request Filed by Petitioners Denied.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 930203 ML20128D4651993-02-0202 February 1993 Texas Utils Electric Co Response to Emergency Motion to Stay Issuance of low-power Ol.* Petitioner Request Should Be Denied Based on Failure to Meet Heavy Burden Imposed on Party.W/Certificate of Svc ML20128D3391993-02-0202 February 1993 Emergency Motion to Stay Issuance of low-power Ol.* Petitioners Specific Requests Listed.W/Certificate of Svc ML20128D6321993-01-29029 January 1993 Memorandum & Order.* Denies Citizens for Fair Util Regulation for Fr Notice Hearing on Proposed Issuance of OL for Facility.W/Certificate of Svc.Served on 930129 ML20128D3461993-01-29029 January 1993 NRC Staff Notification of Issuance of OL for Facility.* Low Power License May Be Issued by 930201.W/Certificate of Svc ML20128D6111993-01-26026 January 1993 Joint Affidavit of I Barnes & Ft Grubelich Re Borg-Warner Check Valves.* Discusses Issues Re Borg-Warner Check Valves Raised by Cfur & Adequacy of Actions Taken by TU Electric 1999-06-18
[Table view] Category:TRANSCRIPTS
MONTHYEARML20133G5411996-12-0505 December 1996 Transcript of 961205 Meeting in Arlington,Tx Re Comanche Peak Thermo-Lag Fire Barriers. Pp 1-111 ML20116B8871996-07-19019 July 1996 Transcript of 960719 Predecisional Enforcement Conference Re Apparent Violations of NRC Requirements at Plant ML20072P5441994-07-13013 July 1994 Testimony of Rl Stright Re Results of Liberty Consulting Groups Independent Review of Prudence of Mgt of STP ML20128F6221993-02-0303 February 1993 Transcript of 930203 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote Public Meeting in Rockville,Md.Pp 1-2.Related Info Encl ML20066B5631989-10-27027 October 1989 Transcript of 891027 Investigative Interview of Bp Garde in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-91 ML20066B5351989-10-23023 October 1989 Transcript of 891023 Investigative Interview of Tl Austin in Houston,Tx.Pp 1-45.Related Info Encl ML20244C9131989-03-28028 March 1989 Transcript of 890328 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Discussion/ Possible Vote on Full Power Ol.Pp 1-65.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20055G7801988-11-10010 November 1988 Investigative Interview of La Yandell on 881110 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-13.Related Info Encl ML20055G7151988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of J Kelly on 881109 in Arlington, Tx.Pp 1-35.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20055G7831988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of R Caldwell on 881109 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-27.Related Info Encl ML20055G7881988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of AB Earnest on 881109 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-90.Related Info Encl ML20151B3591988-07-13013 July 1988 Transcript of 880713 Hearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 25.187-25,295 ML20154R3061988-06-0101 June 1988 Transcript of 880601 Prehearing Conference in Dallas,Tx. Pp 25,157-25,186 ML20148K0271988-03-21021 March 1988 Transcript of 880321 Discussion/Possible Vote on Full Power License for South Texas Nuclear Project,Unit 1 (Public Meeting) in Washington,Dc.Viewgraphs Encl.Pp 1-73 ML20151B5821988-02-25025 February 1988 Transcript of 880225-26 Public Meetings W/Case & J Doyle ML20238C3921987-12-0909 December 1987 Transcript of 871209 Public Meeting in Dallas,Tx Re Status of Corrective Action Programs at Facility.Pp 1-60 ML20236J3981987-11-0303 November 1987 Transcript of 871103 Prehearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 25,139- 25,156 ML20245D1231987-11-0202 November 1987 Transcript of 871102 Special Prehearing Conference in Dallas,Tx.Pp 24,963-25,138 ML20149E5451987-10-16016 October 1987 Transcript of T Tyler 871016 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-51 ML20149E5411987-10-16016 October 1987 Transcript of Jf Streeter 871016 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-95 ML20149E5231987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of Wg Counsil 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-86 ML20149E5301987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of JW Beck 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-56 ML20149E5061987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of J Hansel 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility,Vol Ii.Pp 1-54 ML20149E4191987-10-14014 October 1987 Transcript of J Hansel 871014 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility,Vol I.Pp 1-125 ML20238A6921987-09-0303 September 1987 Partially Withheld Rept of Interview W/R Spangler Re Allegations Concerning QA Audit Group ML20238A7201987-09-0303 September 1987 Partially Withheld Rept of Interview W/Gs Keeley Re Clarification of Info Contained in 831019 Rept Prepared by R Spangler Re Alleged Intimidation of QA Audit Group by Util QC Site Manager.Related Info Encl ML20235H8341987-08-0505 August 1987 Transcript of 870805 Deposition of Bp Garde in Bethesda,Md Re Plant.Pp 128-224 ML20237G2781987-07-30030 July 1987 Vol II of Transcript of 870730 Public Meeting W/Util.Pp 2- 87.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237G2721987-07-29029 July 1987 Vol I of Transcript of 870729 Public Meeting W/Util.Pp 2- 129.Supporting Matl Encl ML20235H8031987-07-27027 July 1987 Transcript of 870727 Deposition of Bp Garde in Bethesda,Md Re Plant.Pp 1-127.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20235T7021987-07-20020 July 1987 Transcript of 870720 Telcon in Washington,Dc.Pp 24,892- 24,962 ML20237L0731987-04-0909 April 1987 Partially Deleted Transcript of Unnamed Region IV Official 870409 Interview Re Region IV Mgt Handling of Two Insp Repts of Plant ML20214J9581987-04-0707 April 1987 Transcript of 870407 Meeting in Dallas,Tx.Pp 1-85 ML20209E5821987-04-0202 April 1987 Transcript of 870402 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Comanche Peak Response Team Program.Pp 1-101.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20212Q7331987-01-29029 January 1987 Transcript of 870129 Hearing in Bethesda,Md.Pp 1-82 ML20097J5141987-01-22022 January 1987 Partially Deleted,Transcript of 870122 Sworn Statement in Bay City,Tx.Pp 1-101 ML20155F8161987-01-0707 January 1987 Transcript of 870107 Nrc/Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Mgt Meeting in Glen Rose,Tx.Viewgraphs Encl. Pp 1-100 ML20215E0031986-12-15015 December 1986 Transcript of 861215 Prehearing Conference in Bethesda,Md Re Facility.Pp 24,676-24,826 ML20097J4821986-11-0606 November 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of 861106 Sworn Statement in Lake Jackson,Tx.Pp 1-63 ML20210B3271986-09-10010 September 1986 Transcript of 860910 Hearing in Chicago,Il.Pp 12,338-12,563 ML20214L0401986-08-19019 August 1986 Transcript of 860819 Hearing in Dallas,Tx Re Comanche Peak. Pp 24,600-24,675 ML20214L0301986-08-18018 August 1986 Transcript of 860818 Hearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 24,423-24,600. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L3691986-07-25025 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of I Barnes 860725 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Insps at Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-75.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L7051986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of Le Ellershaw 860724 Investigative Interview in Glen Rose,Tx Re NRC Insps of Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-16 ML20238A3271986-07-24024 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of W Warren 860724 Sworn Statement in Glen Rose,Tx Re Activities Involving Phillips at Plant ML20237L4311986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of C Hale 860724 Investigative Interview in Glen Rose,Tx Re NRC Insps at Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-84 ML20237L3581986-07-23023 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of J Gagliardo 860723 Sworn Statement in Arlington,Tx Re Activities of Senior Resident Inspector for Const at Plant.Pp 1-31 ML20238A8021986-07-23023 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of T Westerman 860723 Sworn Statement in Arlington,Tx Re Insp Repts 85-14 & 85-11 & Draft 2-A in Phillips Matrix.Pp 514-707.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L5541986-07-22022 July 1986 Marked-up Transcript of E Johnson 860722 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Mgt at Plant.Pp 1-138.Partially Deleted Addendum Encl ML20238B8101986-07-22022 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of B Taylor 870722 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Region IV Insp Program at Plant.Pp 1-31.Supporting Documentation Encl 1996-07-19
[Table view] Category:DEPOSITIONS
MONTHYEARML20133G5411996-12-0505 December 1996 Transcript of 961205 Meeting in Arlington,Tx Re Comanche Peak Thermo-Lag Fire Barriers. Pp 1-111 ML20116B8871996-07-19019 July 1996 Transcript of 960719 Predecisional Enforcement Conference Re Apparent Violations of NRC Requirements at Plant ML20072P5441994-07-13013 July 1994 Testimony of Rl Stright Re Results of Liberty Consulting Groups Independent Review of Prudence of Mgt of STP ML20128F6221993-02-0303 February 1993 Transcript of 930203 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote Public Meeting in Rockville,Md.Pp 1-2.Related Info Encl ML20066B5631989-10-27027 October 1989 Transcript of 891027 Investigative Interview of Bp Garde in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-91 ML20066B5351989-10-23023 October 1989 Transcript of 891023 Investigative Interview of Tl Austin in Houston,Tx.Pp 1-45.Related Info Encl ML20244C9131989-03-28028 March 1989 Transcript of 890328 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Discussion/ Possible Vote on Full Power Ol.Pp 1-65.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20055G7801988-11-10010 November 1988 Investigative Interview of La Yandell on 881110 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-13.Related Info Encl ML20055G7151988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of J Kelly on 881109 in Arlington, Tx.Pp 1-35.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20055G7831988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of R Caldwell on 881109 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-27.Related Info Encl ML20055G7881988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of AB Earnest on 881109 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-90.Related Info Encl ML20151B3591988-07-13013 July 1988 Transcript of 880713 Hearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 25.187-25,295 ML20154R3061988-06-0101 June 1988 Transcript of 880601 Prehearing Conference in Dallas,Tx. Pp 25,157-25,186 ML20148K0271988-03-21021 March 1988 Transcript of 880321 Discussion/Possible Vote on Full Power License for South Texas Nuclear Project,Unit 1 (Public Meeting) in Washington,Dc.Viewgraphs Encl.Pp 1-73 ML20151B5821988-02-25025 February 1988 Transcript of 880225-26 Public Meetings W/Case & J Doyle ML20238C3921987-12-0909 December 1987 Transcript of 871209 Public Meeting in Dallas,Tx Re Status of Corrective Action Programs at Facility.Pp 1-60 ML20236J3981987-11-0303 November 1987 Transcript of 871103 Prehearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 25,139- 25,156 ML20245D1231987-11-0202 November 1987 Transcript of 871102 Special Prehearing Conference in Dallas,Tx.Pp 24,963-25,138 ML20149E5451987-10-16016 October 1987 Transcript of T Tyler 871016 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-51 ML20149E5411987-10-16016 October 1987 Transcript of Jf Streeter 871016 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-95 ML20149E5231987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of Wg Counsil 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-86 ML20149E5301987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of JW Beck 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-56 ML20149E5061987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of J Hansel 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility,Vol Ii.Pp 1-54 ML20149E4191987-10-14014 October 1987 Transcript of J Hansel 871014 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility,Vol I.Pp 1-125 ML20238A6921987-09-0303 September 1987 Partially Withheld Rept of Interview W/R Spangler Re Allegations Concerning QA Audit Group ML20238A7201987-09-0303 September 1987 Partially Withheld Rept of Interview W/Gs Keeley Re Clarification of Info Contained in 831019 Rept Prepared by R Spangler Re Alleged Intimidation of QA Audit Group by Util QC Site Manager.Related Info Encl ML20235H8341987-08-0505 August 1987 Transcript of 870805 Deposition of Bp Garde in Bethesda,Md Re Plant.Pp 128-224 ML20237G2781987-07-30030 July 1987 Vol II of Transcript of 870730 Public Meeting W/Util.Pp 2- 87.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237G2721987-07-29029 July 1987 Vol I of Transcript of 870729 Public Meeting W/Util.Pp 2- 129.Supporting Matl Encl ML20235H8031987-07-27027 July 1987 Transcript of 870727 Deposition of Bp Garde in Bethesda,Md Re Plant.Pp 1-127.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20235T7021987-07-20020 July 1987 Transcript of 870720 Telcon in Washington,Dc.Pp 24,892- 24,962 ML20237L0731987-04-0909 April 1987 Partially Deleted Transcript of Unnamed Region IV Official 870409 Interview Re Region IV Mgt Handling of Two Insp Repts of Plant ML20214J9581987-04-0707 April 1987 Transcript of 870407 Meeting in Dallas,Tx.Pp 1-85 ML20209E5821987-04-0202 April 1987 Transcript of 870402 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Comanche Peak Response Team Program.Pp 1-101.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20212Q7331987-01-29029 January 1987 Transcript of 870129 Hearing in Bethesda,Md.Pp 1-82 ML20097J5141987-01-22022 January 1987 Partially Deleted,Transcript of 870122 Sworn Statement in Bay City,Tx.Pp 1-101 ML20155F8161987-01-0707 January 1987 Transcript of 870107 Nrc/Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Mgt Meeting in Glen Rose,Tx.Viewgraphs Encl. Pp 1-100 ML20215E0031986-12-15015 December 1986 Transcript of 861215 Prehearing Conference in Bethesda,Md Re Facility.Pp 24,676-24,826 ML20097J4821986-11-0606 November 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of 861106 Sworn Statement in Lake Jackson,Tx.Pp 1-63 ML20210B3271986-09-10010 September 1986 Transcript of 860910 Hearing in Chicago,Il.Pp 12,338-12,563 ML20214L0401986-08-19019 August 1986 Transcript of 860819 Hearing in Dallas,Tx Re Comanche Peak. Pp 24,600-24,675 ML20214L0301986-08-18018 August 1986 Transcript of 860818 Hearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 24,423-24,600. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L3691986-07-25025 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of I Barnes 860725 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Insps at Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-75.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L7051986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of Le Ellershaw 860724 Investigative Interview in Glen Rose,Tx Re NRC Insps of Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-16 ML20238A3271986-07-24024 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of W Warren 860724 Sworn Statement in Glen Rose,Tx Re Activities Involving Phillips at Plant ML20237L4311986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of C Hale 860724 Investigative Interview in Glen Rose,Tx Re NRC Insps at Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-84 ML20237L3581986-07-23023 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of J Gagliardo 860723 Sworn Statement in Arlington,Tx Re Activities of Senior Resident Inspector for Const at Plant.Pp 1-31 ML20238A8021986-07-23023 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of T Westerman 860723 Sworn Statement in Arlington,Tx Re Insp Repts 85-14 & 85-11 & Draft 2-A in Phillips Matrix.Pp 514-707.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L5541986-07-22022 July 1986 Marked-up Transcript of E Johnson 860722 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Mgt at Plant.Pp 1-138.Partially Deleted Addendum Encl ML20238B8101986-07-22022 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of B Taylor 870722 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Region IV Insp Program at Plant.Pp 1-31.Supporting Documentation Encl 1996-07-19
[Table view] Category:NARRATIVE TESTIMONY
MONTHYEARML20133G5411996-12-0505 December 1996 Transcript of 961205 Meeting in Arlington,Tx Re Comanche Peak Thermo-Lag Fire Barriers. Pp 1-111 ML20116B8871996-07-19019 July 1996 Transcript of 960719 Predecisional Enforcement Conference Re Apparent Violations of NRC Requirements at Plant ML20072P5441994-07-13013 July 1994 Testimony of Rl Stright Re Results of Liberty Consulting Groups Independent Review of Prudence of Mgt of STP ML20128F6221993-02-0303 February 1993 Transcript of 930203 Affirmation/Discussion & Vote Public Meeting in Rockville,Md.Pp 1-2.Related Info Encl ML20066B5631989-10-27027 October 1989 Transcript of 891027 Investigative Interview of Bp Garde in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-91 ML20066B5351989-10-23023 October 1989 Transcript of 891023 Investigative Interview of Tl Austin in Houston,Tx.Pp 1-45.Related Info Encl ML20244C9131989-03-28028 March 1989 Transcript of 890328 Meeting in Rockville,Md Re Discussion/ Possible Vote on Full Power Ol.Pp 1-65.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20055G7801988-11-10010 November 1988 Investigative Interview of La Yandell on 881110 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-13.Related Info Encl ML20055G7151988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of J Kelly on 881109 in Arlington, Tx.Pp 1-35.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20055G7831988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of R Caldwell on 881109 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-27.Related Info Encl ML20055G7881988-11-0909 November 1988 Investigative Interview of AB Earnest on 881109 in Arlington,Tx.Pp 1-90.Related Info Encl ML20151B3591988-07-13013 July 1988 Transcript of 880713 Hearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 25.187-25,295 ML20154R3061988-06-0101 June 1988 Transcript of 880601 Prehearing Conference in Dallas,Tx. Pp 25,157-25,186 ML20148K0271988-03-21021 March 1988 Transcript of 880321 Discussion/Possible Vote on Full Power License for South Texas Nuclear Project,Unit 1 (Public Meeting) in Washington,Dc.Viewgraphs Encl.Pp 1-73 ML20151B5821988-02-25025 February 1988 Transcript of 880225-26 Public Meetings W/Case & J Doyle ML20238C3921987-12-0909 December 1987 Transcript of 871209 Public Meeting in Dallas,Tx Re Status of Corrective Action Programs at Facility.Pp 1-60 ML20236J3981987-11-0303 November 1987 Transcript of 871103 Prehearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 25,139- 25,156 ML20245D1231987-11-0202 November 1987 Transcript of 871102 Special Prehearing Conference in Dallas,Tx.Pp 24,963-25,138 ML20149E5451987-10-16016 October 1987 Transcript of T Tyler 871016 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-51 ML20149E5411987-10-16016 October 1987 Transcript of Jf Streeter 871016 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-95 ML20149E5231987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of Wg Counsil 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-86 ML20149E5301987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of JW Beck 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility.Pp 1-56 ML20149E5061987-10-15015 October 1987 Transcript of J Hansel 871015 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility,Vol Ii.Pp 1-54 ML20149E4191987-10-14014 October 1987 Transcript of J Hansel 871014 Deposition in Dallas,Tx Re Facility,Vol I.Pp 1-125 ML20238A6921987-09-0303 September 1987 Partially Withheld Rept of Interview W/R Spangler Re Allegations Concerning QA Audit Group ML20238A7201987-09-0303 September 1987 Partially Withheld Rept of Interview W/Gs Keeley Re Clarification of Info Contained in 831019 Rept Prepared by R Spangler Re Alleged Intimidation of QA Audit Group by Util QC Site Manager.Related Info Encl ML20235H8341987-08-0505 August 1987 Transcript of 870805 Deposition of Bp Garde in Bethesda,Md Re Plant.Pp 128-224 ML20237G2781987-07-30030 July 1987 Vol II of Transcript of 870730 Public Meeting W/Util.Pp 2- 87.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237G2721987-07-29029 July 1987 Vol I of Transcript of 870729 Public Meeting W/Util.Pp 2- 129.Supporting Matl Encl ML20235H8031987-07-27027 July 1987 Transcript of 870727 Deposition of Bp Garde in Bethesda,Md Re Plant.Pp 1-127.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20235T7021987-07-20020 July 1987 Transcript of 870720 Telcon in Washington,Dc.Pp 24,892- 24,962 ML20237L0731987-04-0909 April 1987 Partially Deleted Transcript of Unnamed Region IV Official 870409 Interview Re Region IV Mgt Handling of Two Insp Repts of Plant ML20214J9581987-04-0707 April 1987 Transcript of 870407 Meeting in Dallas,Tx.Pp 1-85 ML20209E5821987-04-0202 April 1987 Transcript of 870402 Meeting in Bethesda,Md Re Comanche Peak Response Team Program.Pp 1-101.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20212Q7331987-01-29029 January 1987 Transcript of 870129 Hearing in Bethesda,Md.Pp 1-82 ML20097J5141987-01-22022 January 1987 Partially Deleted,Transcript of 870122 Sworn Statement in Bay City,Tx.Pp 1-101 ML20155F8161987-01-0707 January 1987 Transcript of 870107 Nrc/Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station Mgt Meeting in Glen Rose,Tx.Viewgraphs Encl. Pp 1-100 ML20215E0031986-12-15015 December 1986 Transcript of 861215 Prehearing Conference in Bethesda,Md Re Facility.Pp 24,676-24,826 ML20097J4821986-11-0606 November 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of 861106 Sworn Statement in Lake Jackson,Tx.Pp 1-63 ML20210B3271986-09-10010 September 1986 Transcript of 860910 Hearing in Chicago,Il.Pp 12,338-12,563 ML20214L0401986-08-19019 August 1986 Transcript of 860819 Hearing in Dallas,Tx Re Comanche Peak. Pp 24,600-24,675 ML20214L0301986-08-18018 August 1986 Transcript of 860818 Hearing in Dallas,Tx.Pp 24,423-24,600. Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L3691986-07-25025 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of I Barnes 860725 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Insps at Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-75.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L7051986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of Le Ellershaw 860724 Investigative Interview in Glen Rose,Tx Re NRC Insps of Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-16 ML20238A3271986-07-24024 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of W Warren 860724 Sworn Statement in Glen Rose,Tx Re Activities Involving Phillips at Plant ML20237L4311986-07-24024 July 1986 Transcript of C Hale 860724 Investigative Interview in Glen Rose,Tx Re NRC Insps at Plant & Region IV Regulation of Facility.Pp 1-84 ML20237L3581986-07-23023 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of J Gagliardo 860723 Sworn Statement in Arlington,Tx Re Activities of Senior Resident Inspector for Const at Plant.Pp 1-31 ML20238A8021986-07-23023 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of T Westerman 860723 Sworn Statement in Arlington,Tx Re Insp Repts 85-14 & 85-11 & Draft 2-A in Phillips Matrix.Pp 514-707.Supporting Documentation Encl ML20237L5541986-07-22022 July 1986 Marked-up Transcript of E Johnson 860722 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Mgt at Plant.Pp 1-138.Partially Deleted Addendum Encl ML20238B8101986-07-22022 July 1986 Partially Deleted Transcript of B Taylor 870722 Investigative Interview in Arlington,Tx Re Region IV Insp Program at Plant.Pp 1-31.Supporting Documentation Encl 1996-07-19
[Table view] |
Text
_ . _ . _ . . _ . . . .
_. . ___ . . _ _ . . . . . _ _ _
_.
. _ . _ . _ . .
CAROLINA POWER AND LICHT COMPANY PREPARED T IM n F bBR i ROSS, JR.
{
1 Q PLEASE STATE YOUR UAME AND ADDRESS.
2 3 A My name is Robert M. Gross, Jr. My business address is 1000 Crescent 4 Avenue, N. E., Atlanta, Georgia 30309.
5 6 Q UHAT IS YOUR EDUCATIONAL BACKGROUND?
- 7 8 A I graduated from Georgia Institute of Technology in 1965, receiving 9
the degree of Bachelor of Industrial Engineering. I also attended 10 Georgia State University and in 1971 received the degree of Master of Business Administration, najoring in finance.
11 12
( 13 Q PLEASE STATE YOUR PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE.
14 15 A I have been ecployed by Southern Engineering Company of Georgia for 16 approximately nine years. During this time I have been involved in 17 the preparation of cost of service studies of Class.A and B investor-18 owned utilities, rural electric cooperatives and nunicipal electric 19 systens and have participated in wholesale and retail electric rate 20 e nsulting assignments in 23 states. I an a registered professional 21 engineer in the State of Georgia.
22 23 Q HAVE YOU EVER TESTIFIED 15 OTHER COMMISSION PROCEEDINGS?
24 f ( , 25 A 26 Yes, I have testified as a rate expert and cost of service witness before the State Cor=issions of Kentucky, Indiana, Mighigan, Vermont 27 and Virginia. I have also testified before the Federal Power Cornission 28 in proceedings involving the Mississinpi Power Connany, FPC Docket No.
29 E-7685; Appalachian Power Company, FPC Docket No. E-7775; Duke Power 30 Company, FPC Docket No. E-7994; Gulf States Utilities Company, FPC 31 Docket No. E-8911; Appalachian Power Company, FPC Docket No. E-9101; 32 Virginia Electric & Power Conpany, FPC Docket No. E-9147; Arizona _
Public Service Company, FPC Docket No. E-8624; Public Service Cornany 33 f Indiana. Inc., FPC Docket Nos. ER76-149 and E-9537; and Georgia Power 34 ,
_Conpany, FPC Docket Nos. E-9091, E-9521 and E-9522.
35 36
( 37 Q KHAT WAS YOUR ASSIGNMENT IN THIS PROCEEDING?
38 39 A My assignnent was to determine whether the nethods employed by Carolina 40 Power and Light (CP&L) to establish the proposed wholesale rate structure
'
41 were just, reasonable and consistent with sound ratemaking procedures.
42 43 Q UHAT DATA HAVE YOU R1'V EWED IN PREPARING YOUR TESTIMONY AND EXHIBITS?
44 45 A I have reviewed tho: iortions of the Company's filing which relate to 46 its wholesale rate c . ..gn including the testimony and exhibits of CP&L's 47 witnesses and other '. formation CP&L supplied in response to the FPC 48 Staff and various in irvenors request for data.
49 WOULD YOU PLEASE SUM IARIZE THE COOPERATIVE INTERVENORS POSITION WITH SO Q
(- REGARD TO THE PROPC',ED WHOLESALE RATE STRUCTURE FILED BY CP&L IN THIS PROCEEDING?
l l .
'
"I 909260 /6/f .
. __- , ,_ _
-. . . - - . . . . .
. . . . - . . - . .
. . - . .
.
' *
. ,
,
.
( l A I believe there are basically two deficiencies in the Company's proposed 2 wholesale rate structure.
3 4 First of all the cost of service studies for the wholesale class as 5
reflected in the filings of Company, Staff, and Intervenors show that 6 there is a substantial difference in the cost of providing service
( 7 to wholesale delivery points at transmission voltages as compared to g wholesale delivery points receiving service at distribution voltages.
9 I believe that the wholesale rate structure should be redesigned to 10 accomodate a difference in pricing for service to transmission and distribution voltages.
11 12 13 Secondly, the Company's 95% summer-based billing demand ratchet con-( tained in the proposed wholesale rate "RS-ll", is entirely inconsistant, 14 as a rate device, with the_nethods employed by Staff and Intervenors 15 to establish demand cost responsibility on CP&L's system. Furthermore, 16 17 th Company provides no evidence linking its own filed cost of service studies with the level (95%) of the proposed ratchet provision. Finally, 18 CP&L has overstated the demand charge in the proposed wholesale rate "RS-ll" yg 20 by applying the 957. ratchet to erroneous wholesale billing data which pro-duces an understatement in the amount of test year billing quantities.
21 22 I IIAND YOU COOPERATIVE INTERVENORS' EXIIIBIT NO. (RMG-1) AND ASIC YOU 23 Q 24 TO IDENTIFY IT.
t
(' 25 This Exhibit is entitled " Wholesale Delivery Point Statistics for 197 5 26 A and 12 Months Ending December 31, 1976."
27 28 WILL YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN TIIIS EXIIIBIT.
29 Q 30 This Exhibit shows the delivery voltage at wholesale delivery points A
31 served by CP6L. In addition it provides other statistical and load 32 data which will be utilized later in ny testimony.
33 Column (b) of this Exhibit shows the delivery voltage for wholesale 3 delivery p ints. The voltages range from 4.2 kV up to 230 kV. It is 36 obvious from this information that there is a considerable range in l the type of facilities associated with CP&L's service to who'lesale delivery points.
40 4y Q IFTilEREAWAYOFMEASURINGTIIECOSTOFSERVICEDIhFERENTIALBETWEEN TIIESE VARIOUS SERVICE VOLTAGE LEVELS?
42 '
43 44 A Yes. Generally the method used by all parties in this case to allocate 45 transmission and distribution costs results in two distinct groupings of~
46 wholesale loads. The first group consists of those wholesale delivery 47 points which are served directly off CP&L's Power Supply Systen. CP&L 48 has defined its Power Supply System to include all transmission lines t 49 (66 kV and above) and all transmission substations with a low voltage
(, 50 side of 66 kV and above. The remaining wholesale delivery points have
.
m
^
__ . _
. .
r __
.
- ,
,
,
(
l delivery voltages at distribution levels (33 kV and below). Whereas 2 the first group of wholesale loads requires only Power Supply Trans-3 mission support, the second group requires certain distribution line 4
and substation investment in addition to the cor: mon Power Supply Transmission facilities. There is obviously a significant unit cost 5
6 differential between providing service to delivery points at the Power Supply Transmission level (66 kV and above) as compared to service 7
at distribution voltages.
8 9
10 From a ratemaking standpoint I believe that it would be preferable to 11 design a. wholesale rate that would accomodate the difference in pricing 12 necessary to reflect the average cost of service difference between 13 transmission and distribution service.
14 I HAND YOU COOPERATIVE INTERVENORS' EXHIBIT E0. (PJ1G-2) AND ASK YOU 15 Q 16 TO IDESTIFY IT. .
.
17 18 A This Exhibit is entitled "Statenent 'F', as Revised".
19 20 Q WOULD YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN '.HIS EXHIBITi 21 22 A Yes, this Exhibit reflects the adjustments to the Company's filed 23 Statement "P" required to show (1) the Lepact of Cooperative Intervenor 24 cost of service adjustments on unit costs and (2) the development of demand charges associated with service to wholesale loads served at
( 25 26 transmission voltages and those served at distribution voltages. The 27 difference in unit costs between transmission service and distribution 28 service is $0.30/kW per month. This analysis is quite similar'.to the 29 simil r to the Company's calculations contained in Statement "P" for 30 f r Period II except that rather than averaging all the demand related costs regardless of delivery point voltage level as does 31 the Company, I have recognized the difference in costs between 32 service to distribution voltages as opposed to loads served to 33 transmissi n v ltages.
34 35 36 Q W0m YOU EME MWN WHY THE WHOWAI.E RATE SHOM DMERNME AS 37 BETWEEN TRANSMISSION AED DISTRIBUTION SERVICE LEVELS?
38 39 40 A There are a number of reasons that I believe this rate differential is 41 necessary.
42 43 The rate is applied by delivery point. There are currently 130 wholesale 44 delivery points with varying service voltages. I have distinguished 45 broadly between transmission and distribution voltage levels to provide 46 a nore accurate recovery of CP&L's cost of serving certain types of delivery 47 Points. This is important for two reasons. First of all there are 45 48 different wholesale customers served by CP&L. Some wholesale customers 49 are served entirely at transmission v'oltages, some wholesale customers are 50 served entirely at distribution voltages and some wholesale customers have
(
..
. . , . - . . - .
..
.
'
.
.
- 1 delivery points at both transmission and distribution voltage levels.
2 Providing for a difference in rate level between transmissicn and 3 distribution service levels results in a more equitable recovery of 4 cost from each wholesale customer. Obviously it is not proper to 5 recover distribution related cost from a wholesale customer who pur-6 chases the entire requirement at a transmission level.
7 8 Secondly, as indicated in the Company's tariff, CP&L presently 9 requires the wholesale customers to build to the existing power supply 10 transmission system of CP&L when new wholesale sources of delivery 11 are required. Presently and in the future new delivery points will be 12 at transmission voltages, primarily at 115 and 230 kV, With this general 13 trend it would not be proper for CP&L to apply a wholesale ' rate to such
'
14 n w p ints of delivery that contains a component of distribution cost 15 when the wholesale customer is providing the necessary distribution 16 facilities. -
17 18 Q YOU HAVE PREVIOUSLY STATED THAT YOU DISAGREE WITH CP&L'S PROPOSED 95%
19 SUOIER-BASE BILLING DEMAND RATCHET. WOULD YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN WHY?
20 21 A I agree with Staff Witness Gallagher that it is not consistent from a 22 ratemaking standpoint to adopt a very severe seasonal billing demand 23 ratchet when system demand related costs are allocated based upon an 24 average of the demands imposed upon the system throughout the year.
,
' (' 25 26 CP&L includes in its proposed "RS-11" Wholesale Rate Schedule a 95% '
27 summer-base billing demand ratchet. This ratchet provision imposes a 23 monthly minimum billing demand based upon 95% of the highest non-coincident ~
29 demand experienced during the preceding months of June through September.
30 This ratchet, of couse, causes individual wholesale customers' power bills 31 to be greatly influenced by the level of demands experienced during the 32 Period of June through September. It makes littic sense on one hand to allocate demand related costs on the basis of an average of 12 monthly 33 34 demands as proposed by Staff and Intervenors and then turn around and 35 bill the wholesale customer predominately on the basis of that customer's 36 maximum demand established during a four month period.
i 37 38 Q ASSUMING FOR TIIE MOMENT THE APPLICABILITY OF CP&L'S POWER SUPPLY DEMAND 39 ALLOCATION METHODOLOGY, WGULD YOU THEN AGREE WITH THE INCLUSION OF A 40 SUMMER-BASE BILLING DEMAND RATCHET IN CPhL'S PROPOSED UHOLESALE RATE 7 41 42 A Yes, I believe the billing demand ratchet must be consistent with the method 43 used to allocate power supply costs. If power supply costs'are allocated 44 on the basis of the 4 summer months CP's then it would be consistant to 45 use a summer based billing demand ratchet, as CP&L has done in this case.
46 However, even assuming the applicability of CP&L's allocation methodology 47 which Staff and Intervenors certainly oppose, I do'believe that the 1cvel of CP&L's summer based ratchet is too high.
43 49 50
(
.
t
, . ~ . - . . - -
.
.
.
! .
( I SHOW YOU A DOCUMENT MAPJ*.ED COOPERATIVE It4TERVENOES' EXHIBIT NO.
l Q 2 (RMG-3) AfiD ASE YOU TO IDENTIFY IT.
3 4
A This Exhibit. is entitled " Metered Non-coincident Pholesale Peak Demand 5
Summati n For June Through September 1975".
6 Q WAS THIS EXHIBIT PREPARED UNDER YCUR SUPERVISION?
7 A Yes.
1 Q PLEASE DISCUSS THIS EXIIIBIT.
12 A Using the nost recent data available, I have selected for each wholesale 13 delivery point the actual naximum 15 minute integrated demand established 14 during the period of June through September 1975. For each wholesale 15 customer I show how such seasonal non-coincident delivery point demands 16 are incurred during the four nonth season. These delivery point demands 17 represent the amounts that would be used when applying the proposed summer-18 based ratchet. '1he arithmetical summation of these maximum seasonal demand 19 equals 1,250,495 kW for the wholesale class.
20 21 The purpose of che ratchet is to insure that should the wholesale customer r quir ap ci ty in the sucmcr peak season (by CP6L's definition), then 3
the customer would be held accountable for 95% of such capacity on a 3 billing basis for the remainder of the year. I believe that given the 25
( 26 necessity of such a ratchet, the level of the ratchet should reflect the diversity of wholesale loads during the summer season. The purpose of 27 the exhibit is to measure such diversity.
28 29 30 The seasonal diversity is measured by dividing the wholesale load coin-31 i cat with the four summer monthly system CP's, taken, from Statement "M"'
32 Peri d I f 1,072,767 kW, by the above figure of 1,250,495 kW. Tliis Calculation results in computed coincidence of 86%. I believe this computation shows that the summer based ratchet should be set'at a level of approximately 857. rather than 957.. Setting the ratchet at 957; would in my opinion place an unreasonable burden on certain wholesale customers.
37 38 Q PHY Do YOU BELIEVE TIIAT A WHOLESALE CUSTOMER COULD BE UNFAIRLY BURDEhTD 39 EY ESTABLISHING A RATCIIET AT A LEVEL THAT WAS HIGHER TIIAN TIIE LEVEL OF 40 RATCHET DERIVED FROM A STUDY OF THE SUI:MER SEASON DIVERSITY?
'
41 42 A Our studies show that many wholesale delivery points establish peak demands 43 (NCP's) at times other than when CP&L monthly system peak demand is occurring.
44 In other words nany delivery point demands are a function of tobacco drying 45 and farming requirements and are not significantly related to air condi-46 tioning requirements or industrial loads which cause the company's system 47 to peak. The Company's load characteristic of course is heavily air con-48 ditioning related whereas a sizable portion of the wholesale Cooperative 49 load is related to farning operations. The natural diversity of the 50 wholesale class summer peak loads should be recognized in the determination k of the ratchet level.
.
4 4.+e * *-a# --e= emm. en - e., e =enn.,e em e - e g
--. . .
- .
..
,
.
(
1 It the diversity is not used to establish the ratchet,.then certain d
2 wholesale custorers who traditionally peak during the summer at times j not coincident with CP&L would be treated for billing purposes as if 3
4 their peak demands were coincident with the CPLL's system peak demands.
5 This would unfairly penali::e particularly many wholesale Cooperative g Customers.
7 C g Q I BELIEVE THE FINAL ASPECT OF YOUR TESTIMONY CONCERES THE COMPANY'S CALCULATION OF REVENUES UNDER THE PROPOSED RATE FOR PERIOD II. WOULD 9
10 YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN HOW THE COMPANY ERRED IN ITS CALCULATIONS.
11 12 A Yes. Since the proposed rate contains a 95% su==er-base billing demand 13 ratchet, in calculating revenues for calendar year 1976 (Period II),
L the wholesale billing , determinants were affected by peak wholesale 74 loads (NCP's) incurred during the period June through September 1975.
15 The maximum wholesale non-coincident load established during the period 16 June through September 1975 established a ninimum billing demand for the 17 period of January through at least June 1976 which in many cases exceeded g
the metered monthly demand. Enen compiling data to calculate test year 9 - revenues, CP&L used actual demands for June, July, and August, 1975 but t
20 used estimates for September, 1975 demands. Although the actual Septem.
21 ber, 1975 demands were available to the Company at the time it filed 22 its case, it elected to use an estimate. _In most cases the actual 23 September, 1975 demand is significantly higher than the estimated 24 demand and also sets the 1975 su=mer peak demand.
25
( 6 Q I HAND YOU COOPERATIVE INTERVENORS' EXHIBIT NO. (RMC-1) AND ASK YOU 27 TO IDENTIFY IT.
~
28 29 30 A This Exhibit has been identified earlier as "Knolesale Delivery Points f,, Statistics for 1975 and 12 Months Ending December 31, 1976."
32 33 Q ?OULD YOU PLEASE EXPLAIN THE REMAINING DATA ON THIS EXHIBIT THAT HAS NOT 34 BIEN PREVIOUSLY COVERED IN YOUR TESTIMONY.
35 36 A Yes This gxhibit shows the difference between the Company's estimated 37 September 1975 demandsused to calculate test year revenues and the actual L
38 SCPtember 1975 demands which were incorporated in ,other areas of the Company's 39 filing. Since the actual September wholesale demands significantly exceed the estimated wholesale demands, the level of 1976 revenues, as shown by the 40 41 Company in Statement M, Period II are significantly understated thereby.
42 producing also an understatement in the rate of return being earned under 43 the proposed rate.
44 45 Using actual September 1975 whoicsale demands, I show that wholesale 46 billing units for Period II would be increased by 189,010 kilowatts. This increase in billing kilowatts would have reduced the proposed demand charge 47 43 as shown on Statement "P", Period II from $4.90 per kilowatt to $4.83 per kilowatt. In summary the Company erred in its derivation of the proposed 49 "RS-ll" rate by overstating the demand charge by 7C per kilowatt.
'
50
(
. s.
.
t
. r . ..t .. .. .. a .y . ..--w-....~n. ..........n..
,
-- - - - , . , , ,, . , , - , - , , .y
_ _ _ _
. .. - . . . ._. -. . . . . . .
- . . . .
-
.
, - .
,
1 Q DOES T1UsT C0:3LUDE YOUP, TESIDIONY?
2 3 A Yes.
4 5
6 7
8 9
10 11 12 13 14
-
13 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
( 25 26
-
27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 -
35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
.
_ _ ._. . . . . _ . . . _ _
. _-