ML19144A371
| ML19144A371 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 06/13/2019 |
| From: | Leslie Perkins NRC/NRR/DLP/PLPB |
| To: | Dennis Morey NRC/NRR/DLP/PLPB |
| Perkins L, NRR/DLP, 415-2375 | |
| References | |
| BL-12-001 | |
| Download: ML19144A371 (4) | |
Text
June 13, 2019 MEMORANDUM TO: Dennis C. Morey, Chief Licensing Processes Branch Division of Licensing Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation FROM: Leslie Perkins, Project Manager /RA/
Licensing Processes Branch Division of Licensing Projects Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
SUBJECT:
SUMMARY
OF MAY 7, 2019, PUBLIC MEETING BETWEEN THE U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION AND NUCLEAR ENERGY INSTITUTE AND INDUSTRY REPRESENTATIVES TO DISCUSS INDUSTRYS PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE OPEN PHASE CONDITION VOLUNTARY INDUSTRY INITIATIVE (NRC BULLETIN 2012-01)
On May 7, 2019, a Category 2 public meeting was held between the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) and representatives of the Nuclear Energy Institute (NEI) and the nuclear power plant industry. The purpose of the meeting was for NEI and NRC staff to discuss proposed changes to the Open Phase Condition (OPC) Voluntary Industry Initiative (VII) that will provide an option for licensees to use a risk evaluation in support of not engaging the OPC automatic trip function. NEI provided their plans going forward which included: presenting the revised OPC Initiative to Nuclear Strategic Issues Advisory Committee for approval by May 17, 2019, issuing Revision 3 of the VII and NEI-19-02 Guidance for Assessing Open Phase Condition Implementation Using Risk Insights by the end of May 2019, and identifying at least two plants using the alternative approach for initial inspections. NEI estimated that licensees will make decisions on whether to implement the risk option by August 2019 and NEI will provide that information to the NRC for NEI-affiliated licensees. A question was asked whether the NRC could close out the bulletin earlier for plants that choose to operate with the automatic function enabled. The staff committed to consider this question and to provide its plans for closing out the bulletin for individual plants.
The staff questioned the events referenced for OPC frequency calculations included in NEI 19-
- 02. Specifically, the staff questioned why the following events were not included in NEI 19-02:
Monticello (LER 87-014); Nine Mile Unit 1 (LER 0023); Comanche Peak Unit 1 (LER 92-016-00); and Wolf Creek (2019 -identified in licensees corrective action document).
As a result of the discussion at the public meeting, the industry team evaluated the above events and provided additional information by email dated May 30, 2019. The team agreed with the staff that the first three events should be included in the list of events reviewed by plants when developing plant-specific OPC event frequencies as described in NEI 19-02. In regards to the Wolf Creek event, follow-up with the utility indicated this to be a degraded (partially broken)
D. Morey insulator on a transformer that had not failed, nor has it caused an OPC or loss of offsite power.
This type of degraded condition is not typically counted as a full failure in PRA frequency analyses because it did not cause a loss of function or a plant trip and thus was not included in the NEI 19-02 list of events.
NEI included the first 3 events and the additional reactor years (2750 compared to 929.2) associated with plant operation during those years. This change resulted in a frequency calculation that is lower than the conservative OPC frequency used in the pilot results calculations. Thus, the pilot results remain bounded with the inclusion of the additional operating experience. NEI 19-02 Section 3.2 was revised to include a table of events containing three of the additional events discussed during the public meeting. Notations were also provided to indicate the events used in the NRC risk study OPC frequency calculation in ML17234A631 -
Preliminary Estimate on the Impact of Open Phase Condition, May 2017.
NRC staff will have additional discussions internally to determine the schedule and path forward for the closure of Bulletin 2012-01. The industrys slide presentation, NEI draft technical report, and the draft OPC Initiative, Revision 3 can be found in ADAMS at Accession Nos.
ML19127A355, ML19122A321, and ML19122A333 respectively.
Enclosures:
As stated Meeting Participants NEI Slide Presentation NEI Draft Technical Report Draft Open Phase Condition Initiative, Revision 3 Meeting Notice CONTACT: Leslie Perkins, DLP/PLPB (301) 415-2375
ML19144A371 Mtg. Summary; ML19127A355 NEI Slide Presentation; ML19122A321 Draft Technical Report; ML19122A333 Draft OPC Initiative, Rev 3; ML19114A550 Mtg. Notice; ML19144A373 Package *concurred via email NRR-106 OFFICE NRR/DLP/PLPB PM* NRR/DE/EEOB* NRR/DLP/PLPB/BC* NRR/DLP/PLPB/PM NAME LPerkins DWilliams DMorey LPerkins DATE 6/10/2019 6/10/2019 6/13 /2019 6/10/2019
Meeting Participants Names Organization Eric Benner NRC Mike Franovich NRC Roy Mathew NRC Donna Williams NRC Hari Kodali NRC Adakou Foli NRC Patrick Castleman NRC Michelle Kichline NRC Leslie Perkins NRC Khoi Nguyen NRC Vijay Goel NRC Eric Bowman NRC Duc Nguyen NRC Stephen Campbell NRC Khoi Nguyen NRC Ismael Garcia NRC David Decker NRC Kayla Gamin NRC Michael G. Wiwel PSEG Nuclear Frances Pimentel NEI Greg Krueger NEI Stephen Geier NEI Maggie Staiger NEI Robert M. Carritte MPR Associates Chris Peckat AEP Nikki DeRosia AEP Greg Hill AEP Matt Johnson Jensen Hughes Richard Anoba Jensen Hughes Stephen Naron Exelon Kazimierz Leja Exelon Hank Morehouse Exelon Mohamed Mustafa Entergy Gregory Norris Entergy Ayodele Ishola-Salawu NextEra Joey Clark Certrec Corporation Phil Lashleyd First Energy Corporation Mark Rice Energy-Northwest Shawn Simon INPO Wayne Johnson EPRI Gary Miller Dominion Energy Jordon Vaughan Duke Energy Bryan Carroll Duke Energy Enclosure
Names Organization Tamatha Womack TVA Brad Dolan TVA Preston Cooper TVA Jana Bergman Curtiss-Wright Mathew Dickerson Cooper Nuclear Station Kari Osborne Southern Nuclear Bill Freebain Platts Joniel Cha Platts Mark Sharp Stars Alliance Gordon Clefton DOE INL