ML17334B072

Conformance to Item 2.1 (Part 2) of Generic Ltr 83-28 Reactor Trip Sys Vendor Interface,Cook Units 1 & 2 & Haddam Neck.

ML17334B072
Person / Time
Site:	Haddam Neck, Cook, 05000000
Issue date:	03/31/1987
From:	FARMER F G EG&G IDAHO, INC.
To:	NRC
Shared Package
ML17334B073	List: ML17334B072
References
CON-FIN-D-6001, CON-FIN-D-6002 EGG-NTA-7614, GL-83-28, TAC-52827, TAC-52828, TAC-52843, NUDOCS 8704060174
Download: ML17334B072 (12)

Text

EGG-NTA-7614 CONFORMANCE TOITEN2.1(PART2)OFGENERICLETTER83-28REACTORTRIPSYSTEMVENDORINTERFACE COOK-1AND-2HADOAHNECKF.G.FarmerPublished arch)987IdahoNationalEng1neer)ng Laboratory EG&GIdaho,Inc.IdahoFalls,Idaho83415PreParedrorthe.NuclearRegulatory Conm1ss1on Washington, O.C.20555UnderDOEContractNo.DE-AC07-76ID01570 FINNos.D6001and06002 ASSTRACTTh1sEG56Idaho,Inc.reportprov1desarev1ewofthesubm1ttals forthreeoftheWestinghouse (W)nuclearplantsforconformance toGenericLetter83-28,Item2.l(Part2).Thereportincludesthefollow1ng Westinghouse plants,andisinpart1alfulf1llment ofthefollowing TACNos.:PlantDocketNumberETACNumberCook-1Cook-2HaddamHeck50-31550-31650-21352827528285284311 FOREWORDThisreport1sprov1dedaspartoftheprogramforevaluat1ng licensee/applicant conformance toGenericLetter83-28,"Required Act1onsBasedonGenericImpl1cations ofSalemATMSEvents."Thiswork1sconducted fortheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Comnission, Off1ceofNuclearReactorRegulation, D1vis1onofPWRL1censing-A byEG5GIdaho,Inc.TheU.S.NuclearRegulatory Comm1ssion fundedtheworkundertheauthorization, BLR20-19-19-ll-3, FINNos.D600landD6002.111 CONTENTSABSTRACT.............................

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~FOREblORD

-.........................

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~l.INTRODUCTION 2.REVIEWREQUIREMENTS

.............................................

3.GROUPREVIEWRESULTS.....................

4.REVIEWRESULTSFORCOOK-lAND-24.lEvaluat1on

..............................

~...........

4~2Conclus1on

..........................................

~~~w5REVIEWRESULTSFORHADDAHNECK5.1Evaluat1on

...........................................

5~2Conclus1on6.GROUPCONCLUSION

...................

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~6EFERENCES

.............................................

R CONFORMANCE TOITEM2.lPART2OFGENERICLETTER83-28REACTORTRIPSySTEMVENDORINTERFACE COOK-1AND-2HADDAMNECKl.INTRODUCTION OnDuly8,1983,Gener1cLetter83-28was1ssuedbyD.G.Eisenhut, lDirectoroftheDivis1onofL1cens1ng, Off1ceofNuclearReactorRegulat1on, toalllicensees ofoperat1ng

reactors, applicants foroperat1ng

11censes, andholdersofconstruct1on permits.Thisletter1ncludedrequiredact1onsbasedongener1cimplications oftheSalemATMSevents.Theserequirements havebeenpubl1shed 1nVolume2ofNUREG-1000,

.2"Gener1cImpl1cat1ons ofATWSEventsattheSalemNuclearPowerPlant.'his reportdocuments theEG&GIdaho,Inc.reviewofthesubm1ttals ofthreeoftheblestinghouse plants,Cook-land-2andHaddamNeck,forconformance toItem2.1(Part2)ofGenericLetter83-28.Thesubm1ttals fromthelicensees utilizedintheseevaluat1ons arereferenced 1nSection7ofthisreport.

2.REVIEWREgUIREHENTS Item2.1(Part2)(ReactorTripSystem-VendorInterface) requireslicensees andapplicants toestabl1sh, 1mplement andma1nta1nacontinu1ng programtoensurethatvendor1nformat1on onReactorTr1pSystem(RTS)components 1scomplete, currentandcontrolled throughout the11feoftheplant,andappropriately referenced or1ncorporated inplantinstructions andprocedures.

Thevendor1nterface program1sto1ncludeperlod1ccemunications w1thvendorstoassurethatallapplicable information hasbeenreceived, aswellasasystemofposit1vefeedbackwithvendorsformailingsconta1ning techn1cal 1nformation, e.g.,licensee/applicant acknowledgement forreceiptoftechnical information.

Thatpartofthevendorinterface programwhichensuresthatvendorinformation onRTScomponents, onceacqu1red, isappropriately controlled, referenced and1ncorporated inplant1nstruct1ons andprocedures, w111beevaluated aspartoftherev1ewofItem2.2oftheGenericLetter.BecausetheNuclearSteamSystemSupplier(NSSS)1sord1narily alsothesuppl1eroftheent1reRTS,theNSSS1salsotheprincipal sourceof1nformation onthecomponents oftheRTS.Th1srev1ewofthe11censeeandappl1cant submittals w1ll:Il.Confirmthatthelicensee/appl1cant has1dentified an1nterface withe1thertheNSSSorw1ththevendorsofeachofthecomponents oftheReactorTr1pSystem.2.Conf1rmthatthe1nterface 1dentified by11censees/applicants 1ncludesper1od1cco@munication withtheNSSSorwiththevendorsofeachofthecomponents oftheReactorTr1pSystem.3.Conf1rmthattheinterface 1dent1fied byl1censees/appl1cants 1ncludes'systemofpositivefeedbacktoconf1rmreceiptoftransm1ttals oftechnical 1nformation.

3.GROUPREVIEWRESULTSTherelevantsubm1ttals fromeachofthe1ncludedreactorplantswererev1ewedtodeterm1ne compl1ance w1thItem2.1(Part2).F1rst,thesubm1ttals fromeachplantwererev1ewedtoestabl1sh thatItem2.1(Part2)wasspec1f1cally addressed.

Second,thesubm1ttals wereevaluated todeterm1ne theextenttowh1cheachoftheplantscompl1esw1ththestaffgu1del1nes forItem2.1(Part2).

4.REVIEWRESULTSFORD.C.COOK-lAND-24.1Evaluat1onIndianaandMichiganElectricCompany,the11censeeforD.C.Cook,providedtheirresponses toItem2.l(Part2)oftheGener1cLetteronarch30,1984,Apr1l10,1985,andDecember31,1986.Inthoseresponses, the11censeedescribes theD.C.Cookinterface programestabl1shed fortheRTS.The1nterface programfortheRTSdescr1bed 1ncludesannualcontactwitheachRTS.component vendorandasystemofpos1t1vefeedbackw1ththecomponent vendors.4.2Conclusion Wef1ndtheprogramdescribed 1nthel1censee's submittal forthe1nterface programfortheRTSmeetsthestaffpos1tiononItem2.1(Part2)oftheGenericLetterand1s,therefore, acceptable.

5.REVIEI4RESULTSFORHADOAHHECK5.lEvaluat1onConnect1cut YankeeAtom1cPowerCompany,the11censeeforHaddamNeck,providedthe1rresponses toItem2.l(Part2)oftheGener1cLetteronNovember8,1983,andHarch5,1987.Inthoseresponses, thelicenseeconf1rmsthattheNSSSforHaddamNeck1sWestinghouse andthattheReactorTripSystem(RTS)forHaddamNeck1sincludedasapartofthewestinghouse interface programestabl1shed fortheHaddamNeckNSSS.TheWestinghouse 1nterface programfortheNSSSincludesbothper1odiccomnunication betweenWestinghouse andlicensees/appl1cants andposit1vefeedbackfromlicensees/appl1cants 1ntheformofsignedrece1ptsfortechnical informat1on transm1ttedbyWestinghouse.

5.2ConclusionMefindthe11censee's conf1rming statement thatHaddamNeckisapart1cipant intheWestinghouse 1nterface programfortheRPSmeetsthestaffpos1tiononItem2.1(Part2)oftheGener1cLetterandis,therefore, acceptable.

vV 6.GROUPCONCLUSiON Meconcludethatthe11censee/appl1cant responses forthe11stedWest1nghouse plantsforItem4.5.2ofGener1cLetter83-28areacceptable.

7.REFERENCES 1.NRCLetter,D.G.E1senhuttoall11censees ofOperating

Reactors, Applicants forOperating License,andHoldersofConstruct1on Perm1ts,"Requ1red Act1onsBasedonGenericImpl1cat1ons ofSalemATMSEvents(GenericLetter83-28),"July8,1983.2.GenericIm11cat1ons ofATblSEventsattheSalemNuclearPowerPlantNUREG-l000, Volumel,Apr111983';Volume2,July1983.3.IndianaandmichiganElectr1cCompanylettertoNRC,H.P.Alex1chtoD.G.E1senhut,

D1rector, Divis1onofLicensing, "Required ActionsBasedonGener1cImplications ofSalemATLASEvents{GenericLetter83-28),"Narch30,1984.4.IndianaandMichiganElectricCompanylettertoNRC,H.P.Alex1chtoH.R.Denton,Director, DivisionofLicens1ng, "Additional Information Requested inResponsetoGenericLetter83-28,"Apr1110,1985.5.Ind1anaandmichiganlettertoNRC,H.P.Alex1chtoOfficeofNuclearReactorRegulation,

'GenericLetter83-28,Items2.land2.2,Pertain1ng toVendorInformat1on ControlSystem(VICS),"December31,1986.6.Northeast Ut111ties lettertoNRC,N.G.Couns11toDarrelG.Eisenhut,

D1rector, D1v1s1onofL1censing, November8,1983.7.Northeast Ut1l1ties'letter toNRC,E.J.NroczkatoDocumentControlDesk,"GenericLetter83-28,Item2.1.2,"arch5,1987.