ML18079A831

Request Submitted by Util for Denial of Intervenors Coleman 790625 Request for Reconsideration of Dismissal of Coleman Contention 7.NRC Must Remand Matter to Aslb. Certificate of Svc Encl

ML18079A831
Person / Time
Site:	Salem
Issue date:	07/06/1979
From:	Wetterhahn M CONNER, MOORE & CORBER
To:
Shared Package
ML18079A830	List: ML18079A829 ML18079A831
References
NUDOCS 7908220144
Download: ML18079A831 (6)

Text

UNITED STATES OF A~IBRICA NUCLErlR REGULriTORY C0~1.MISSI0~1 Before the Atomic Safetv and Licensing Board In tl:e i:.1a t ter o £ PUBLIC SERVICE ELECTRIC AND GriS Docket ~jo. 50-272 CO.MP.'LNY, et al. (Proposed Issuance of

.~endment to Facility (Salem Nuclear Generating Operating License Station, Unit 1) No. DPR-70)

!..ICE~ISEE Is J..NSWER TO II INTERVE~WRS COLZZ*L~'i"S I :*10TIC:-1 FOR RECONSIDERZ:..TION OF DISMISSAL OF COLE~,L~)JS'

[CONTENTION] NO. S:2VEN" On June 25, 1979, the Public Advocate of New Jersey, representing Mr. and Mrs. rilfred C. Coleman, Jr. in the captioned proceeding, moved for reconsideraticn of dis~issal of the Colemans' Contention 7 by this Ato~ic Safety and

___!_/

Licensing Board ("Board") . As grounds for reconsideraticn, the Public Advocate cites a decision of the c. S. Court of Appeals for the District of Col u.i-;illia Circuit, :*linnesota v.

,.~,

--c *,*o ~

~* ;:::.

-, "

Q. - _', 2 o'° 9 , 78-2032, (D.C. Cir. May 23, 2.979).

discussed below, Licensee, Public Service Electric and Gas Company, et - i opposes  ::-.otio:::. reconsideration.

~'

It is undisputed th2t ~~= Court c= ~??eals 0ist=ict o= Col~~bia Circuit has remanded the two cases pendi::g before it to the Kuclear ?.eg'.J.la tory C:Jrrtl:lis s i.o::::

( "~;?..c" or "Corrl:rnis s icr. n) fer further ac-=ion regarding a

__l1I The Board's ~-!c.~- 2~, l978 OrC.e~ ?c:..:c~.*li::g S~ecia.:.. ?.:-e-hearing Conference denied the Cole~a~s 1

?reposed Contentio::: 7.

ru H 1D ct Ill I-'*

A I.~.- .... Ill ~J .. rt Ul

'-. (D 1-*

r::(D I-'* 'd I-..,vJ' .."'ro

... p, I-' rl* Ii r 1* fll  ::i

!.J.. tJ- <D  !:J () I-'* *o 0 ~J* CD

r-Jth<ll*J H H n ~o n I-'* !J  :::i CL <D Ill fll 1-i CD Pl 10 f-J UI :-s p,  :::i* Ii 0 !JI l/l () Ill (J) ti Ill Ul

'0 1-*'* r11 I*'* fll () 1-* rt* (D r:: rt rl* 1-i 0 CDOCl>UI I I.o. f-J n m 'CJ I~

= <D I-'* I-'* er CD ~:l Ill r1* ~J 111 I-' CD 8 l*i ~:; (D ~J fll Pl

() ()

I*-* rl* UI rt* ro m ru 0 lu"-.1 ?i1 0 Ul I.........."" :::i0 ro b" l/l :.<:; I**'- rl*  :::i 0* ~J (l rt f-J Iii I-' rt I-'

1-'- Ill Ill Iv lQ I-'* Ill w fD I] 0 :_J" () I-'* 0 0 CD 1*11 rt* 1~ r1* rop_,,n!.J Cl> n,  :.J.. *-j er CD 0 0 () 1-i 0 :J* (I) 0-* (D *Q  ::r Ii 1-h CD s ru r: w ;J Ul tJ' I-'* I fD (D rl* H ()  ::i ti Ul (I)

J rt* I-' Ill f-J Ii ~j 'D n* I*'* rt  ::.i* n* I-'* Ul I-'* I-'* (J) 0* ;Y (D :J I-'* 11* I*'* *£1 r.. m  :-:i  :.).. ..... Ii 1-'* (/) ct* ~

w Fl r1* 0 :.Y ClJ ID Ul f-'* ()  !.J (J) CD 1-i 0 (D <D ID t*h tJ"

...... 8*~ (I) r:: ,q 1-'- fll

1 UI :J 0  ::.s I-'* n 1Q I-'* o  ::J rt* rr th Ul 0 Ill ()  ::.J 0 r:: Pl rr o*  ::J INO

'0 IU ru o rt ~] CD 1--' 0 '-... CD r1* 0 rt* r:: :1~ ()1-:: ~ UI Ul (/) Pl !J' m 1*1i :J* [11 t*~ I*-* fl* I-' I-'* rr 0 l*i Pl I-' ;J OJ ~ ro Ill I-'* 8 0... (J)

.i r**

rll r1* CD 0 Ill Ill 0 n* Pl Ul 0  ::J *1* ~I ~j p, () I~ I-*'*  ::.s CD  :::i  ;:.I 1 h rl* CD fli (1, I-'* H u* Ill 0 p,  ;:: 0 N r1*  ;:i n. r1* ru rt* <:  :::i *-~

0 fll  ::i* rt*

rt 0 1*~ r1* ru 1-** (D [II  :.:i rt CD

J' 1*11 (IJ w  :.1 **:i ,._J. Ul en tJ' p, m n* I-'*

(D Ii rl* Ul 111 rt* IA  ::i*

tJ 0 -~  :.:i 11* [II Ill CJi rt* CD 1---' Iw CD Ul

( ) ')' '"j ni ti I-'* <D '-...Ii rr Pl 0 io 0, Ii Ill f-J 0 Ul rt*  :..3 t*h ~i Ul I-' W m u1 rt ct* ()  !:j r1*  !:J 0 l*h t*j OJ IJ* Ill ;J r1* o .... 0 0 r::()

rop, r::

~) CJJ  ::1 Ill 0 Ii 'O rt* Ii rt* (])

fll (/) 0* :J Pi rt*  :-J Ill I*~

,_ . 0 ~-y ([l f-J

.S c~ CL Ul I l c: l[l (l> fJJ  :.:i* 0 p. :1 UI CD 1-'* CD 1.J. r: ~:s er lll Ul rr n* ~ llJ 0 Ul Cll D* fl, (]J rr 0 ru (j) Ill r1* r::: b' rt* rt ll' ro IJ* 0  ::i I_, r1* ~* ty CD 0 t;* L:~ l- 1

• I--* r1* I-' 'd  ::.s rt* J"':~ l_J* ~1* <D 1--' ti t~ :J (lJ 0 ::1* ([) rr CD I-'* (I) ru IJ* 11* Ill Ii f\J rt* Ii ~ *< <: n n* *Q m :-r CJ, ": rr  :*y :J ti pi= rt* fll () (Jl l*h (IJ l*J* ([J (II (]) I-'* rl* 1~ 1u ~3  :~ 1-i Ii en 11* I-'* rt* I-'" 1~ i';" ~; I*'* (0 n rn 1u  ::J () l*h n () CD IJl 0 n.

0 CJ 0 I*'

.... 0 (II I-'* ()  :;,::  ::1 r1" r:::

f.: r I ~; r1* ~-1 r.: n  :::i Ul I~  ! t* rt* ::I" E1 () I-'* Ill fll IJ* rt*

r1* n  :.i* 0 f(" l*'- ;s fll CD  !:1 ~-i fll  !.J.

() !U (J) Ill 0 (Jl I-' I i.-:: iJ r1* CD tr

() : 1 :i ([) (ll 0 I-' 0 Ii ro Ih I I-'* 1*11 ([l  ::Cl II>

0 I ....

-J n

- 3 -

consider any aspect of the remanded question on its own initiati?e. Because of the remand's generic nature, it ~ay very welJ. be that the Cor:i.Inission decides net to ha'1e this illatter considered in individual adjudicatory proceedings instead, elects to have i .:..

-'- considered in an ongoing or new generic proceeding. The c. c.:..rcui t 6/

clearly leaves such an alternative open to the Commission.

In such an event, no further consideration ~y this 3oard ~av be necessary.

_]_/

\'iith regard to the ":nani£est injustice" alleged ':Jy the Public Advocate, such assertions are spec~lative at l:lest. In any event, anv claim of injury and request redress must be directed to t:"1e Co.mnission, net to this Licensing 3oar*:::. To ~epeat, it is quite possi~le t~at intervenors will be required to ?Ursue this =atter through present proceeding.

6/ ~*1innesota v. ~'-JRC, slio op. at ll, """:::;;. _S_e_-=_- _a_l_s_o_ ~.rer~c:::--_:.

Yankee ~uclear Power Ccrp. v. ~RDC, ~35 G.S. 519,

~~____,_,....,._-=____,........,........,........,...,_.........,_,..___.........,........,~........,_,.._,..........,........,~

n.13 (1978); Cnion of Concerned Scientists~. A~c,* ~99

?.2d 1069 (D.C. Cir. 1974); ~ader v. ~a~, 363 F.S~pp.

946 (D.C.C. 1973).

_]_/ Cols!:',a::1s' :::irie:: ==-~ ..:;.

Under these circumstances, the mo~ion for reconsidera-tion should be denied.

Respectfully submitted, CONNER, MOORE & CORBER Mark J. Wetterhah~

Counsel for ~~e Licensee July 6, 1979

UNITED STATES OF -~E:EEC.;

1:-iUCLEAR REGUL.;:,_TORY cm~*lISSION Before the Atomic Safety and Licensing Board In the ;;.1atter of PUBLIC SERVICE ELECTRIC fil-iD GAS Docket ~o. 50-272 CO.MPA:::.iY, et al. (Proposed Issuance 0£ Amendment to Facility (Salem Nuclear Generating Operating License Station, Unit 1) No. DPR-70)

I hereby certi£y that copies of ~icensee 1 s Ans*..;er to 11

'Intervenors Colemans' Motion for Reconsideration of Dismissal of Colema::is' [Contention] ~l'o. Seven 11 and 11 Licensee 1 s ~-nswer to ~*lotion by In tervenors, Coleman, to Compel Suppleru.e!'lta tio::i of .?-.nswers to Interrogatories by Licensee, 11 both dated July 6, 1979, in the captioned matter, have been served upon the fol-lowing by deposit in the United States mail this 6th dav of Jllly, 1979:

Gary L. Milhollin, Esq. Chairman, Atomic Safety an~

Chairman, Atomic Safety Licensing Board Pa~el and Licensing Board U.S. Nuclear Regulatory 1815 Jefferson Street Commission Madison, Wisconsin 53711 Washington, D.C. 20555

~=* Frederick J. Shon Barry Smith, 2sq.

Member, Atomic Safety a~d Office of t~e 2xec~tive Licensing 3oard Panel Legal Directer C.S. N~clear Reg~lat.ory U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Com.mission Cc~uissior:..

Washingtcn, D.C. 20555 \*lashi:::gtcn, D. C.

Dr. James c. L~-nb, III Z..ls:nbe.:-, Atomic S2.::ety and Deputy Attor~ey General Licensi~g Board ?a:::el Depa!:"t.uent of Lar,.,..~ and 313 Woodhaven Road  :?ublic Saf et.y Chapel Hill, N.C. 27514 Environraental Protection Section Chairman, Atomic Safety and 36 West State Street Licensing Appeal Board Panel Trenton, ~.J. 08625 C.S. Nuclear Reg~latory Co::i..-nission

\~7a.sn~.z:gton, D. c. 20555

Richard ?ryling, Jr., Esq. Carl Valore, Jr., Esq.

Assistant General Solicitor Valore, McAllister, Aron Public Service Electric & Wes tr:1ore lar:d

& Gas Company ~ainland Pro~essional Plaza 80 Park ?lace P. O. Box l/5 Newark, N. J. 07101 Northfield, N. ~. CS225 Keith Onsdorf=, Esq. Office of t2e Sec~2tary Assistant Deputy Public Advocate Docketing and Service Section Department of the Public Advocate U.S. ~uclear ~egulatory Division of Public Interest Cormniss ion Advocacy Washington, Q. C. 20555 Post Office Box 141 Trenton, N. J. 08601 June D. ~acArtor, Esq.

Deputy Attorney General Sandra T. ~yres, Esq. Tatnall Building, P. O. 3ox 1401 Departnent of the Public _;.dvocate Dover, Delaware 19901 520 East State Street Trenton, N. J.. 08625 Mr. Alfred C. Coleman, Jr.

Mrs. Eleanor G. Coleman 35 11 :{ 11 Drive Pennsville, ~ew Jersey 08070