ML21334A356: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(StriderTol Bot change)
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:}}
{{#Wiki_filter:Fire Protection Team Inspection December 2, 2021
  ©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute
 
Overview Attributes of the Fire Protection Team Inspection (FPTI) are redundant to attributes of other NRC inspections.
Low numbers of FPTI findings indicates strong industry performance.
Proposal:
* Incorporate unique FPTI inspection criteria to Comprehensive Engineering Team Inspection (CETI) and credit other Inspection Procedures (IPs), as applicable
                                                              ©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 2
 
Focus Areas SECY-99-140 provided initial stated benefits for Fire Protection Inspections.
* All initial benefits have been realized.
Initial inspections identified additional focus areas to be addressed (e.g., fire barrier ratings, multiple spurious operations, etc.).
* IP revisions and/or Temporary Instructions proven effective at enforcing resolution of emergent items.
* Emergent items have been resolved.
Current FPTI focuses on Design Basis, Operating Experience, and Modifications
                                                              ©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 3
 
Duplicate Comparable Inspection Criteria FPTI Criteria                            Comparable Criteria IP 71111.21M, Section 02.02, Design Review 03.01, SSC Credited for Fire Prevention, IP 71111.21M, Section 02.04, Detection, Suppression, or Post-Fire Maintenance Area Review SSD Review IP 71111.21M, Section 02.06, Review of Operating Experience Issues 03.02, Fire Protection Program          IP 71111.05 Section 03.01, Fire Area Administrative Controls                  Walkdown and Inspection Sample IP 71111.21M, Section 02.03, 03.03, Fire Protection Program          Modification Review Changes/Modifications IP 71111.18, Plant Modifications
                                                                          ©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 4
 
Inspection Results                                          Inspections Results Finding(s)        No Finding(s) 16 Quantity of FPTI with no (0) findings  14 12 exceeds those with findings            10 8
Total FPTI findings have decreased      6 4
since 2013.                              2 0
Zero (0) FPTI findings greater than        2012  2013  2014    2015  2016  2017    2018    2019    2020 green.                                                      Inspection Findings Findings per inspection is dropping    2.00                                                                  35 significantly (2020 < 0.5 findings per 1.50 30 25 inspection)                                                                                                  20 Strong industry performance and 1.00 15 effective resolution of issues        0.50                                                                  10 5
identified during inspections.        0.00                                                                  0 2012 2013  2014  2015  2016  2017    2018    2019  2020 Green        None        Findings per Inspection
                                                                              &#xa9;2021 Nuclear Energy Institute  5
 
Recommended Path Forward Proposal
* Incorporate unique IP 71111-21N.05 criteria into the CETI and credit other existing IP criteria.
* Utilize Temporary Instructions for emergent issues, as necessary.
NRC IP Owner, Fire Protection technical staff and NEI plan on scheduling a public meeting to engage further.
                                                        &#xa9;2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 6}}

Latest revision as of 10:33, 18 January 2022

Fire Protection-ROP Public Meeting-120221
ML21334A356
Person / Time
Site: Nuclear Energy Institute
Issue date: 11/29/2021
From:
Nuclear Energy Institute
To:
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Govan T
References
Download: ML21334A356 (6)
v • d • e


Text

Fire Protection Team Inspection December 2, 2021

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute

Overview Attributes of the Fire Protection Team Inspection (FPTI) are redundant to attributes of other NRC inspections.

Low numbers of FPTI findings indicates strong industry performance.

Proposal:

  • Incorporate unique FPTI inspection criteria to Comprehensive Engineering Team Inspection (CETI) and credit other Inspection Procedures (IPs), as applicable

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 2

Focus Areas SECY-99-140 provided initial stated benefits for Fire Protection Inspections.

  • All initial benefits have been realized.

Initial inspections identified additional focus areas to be addressed (e.g., fire barrier ratings, multiple spurious operations, etc.).

  • IP revisions and/or Temporary Instructions proven effective at enforcing resolution of emergent items.
  • Emergent items have been resolved.

Current FPTI focuses on Design Basis, Operating Experience, and Modifications

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 3

Duplicate Comparable Inspection Criteria FPTI Criteria Comparable Criteria IP 71111.21M, Section 02.02, Design Review 03.01, SSC Credited for Fire Prevention, IP 71111.21M, Section 02.04, Detection, Suppression, or Post-Fire Maintenance Area Review SSD Review IP 71111.21M, Section 02.06, Review of Operating Experience Issues 03.02, Fire Protection Program IP 71111.05 Section 03.01, Fire Area Administrative Controls Walkdown and Inspection Sample IP 71111.21M, Section 02.03, 03.03, Fire Protection Program Modification Review Changes/Modifications IP 71111.18, Plant Modifications

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 4

Inspection Results Inspections Results Finding(s) No Finding(s) 16 Quantity of FPTI with no (0) findings 14 12 exceeds those with findings 10 8

Total FPTI findings have decreased 6 4

since 2013. 2 0

Zero (0) FPTI findings greater than 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 green. Inspection Findings Findings per inspection is dropping 2.00 35 significantly (2020 < 0.5 findings per 1.50 30 25 inspection) 20 Strong industry performance and 1.00 15 effective resolution of issues 0.50 10 5

identified during inspections. 0.00 0 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Green None Findings per Inspection

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 5

Recommended Path Forward Proposal

  • Incorporate unique IP 71111-21N.05 criteria into the CETI and credit other existing IP criteria.
  • Utilize Temporary Instructions for emergent issues, as necessary.

NRC IP Owner, Fire Protection technical staff and NEI plan on scheduling a public meeting to engage further.

©2021 Nuclear Energy Institute 6

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML21334A356&oldid=3402925"