ML19345A806: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
Line 18: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:.
{{#Wiki_filter:.
,
,
INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM UNIT 2 SALEM GENERATING STATION INTRODUCTION:
INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM UNIT 2 SALEM GENERATING STATION INTRODUCTION:
Commencing with the date of Commercial Operation, and for the duration of first 120 month inspection interval, the Inservice Inspection Program for Class 1, 2 and 3 components and systems is based on Section XI of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 1974 Edition and Addenda through Summer 1975. Section XI requirements are augmented by cer-tain special requirements as defined in the Salem Unit No. 2 Technical Specifications, Sections 4.4.5.0, 4.4.10.1 and 4.4.10.2 for examination of steam generator tubing, reactor coolant pump flywheels and steam generator channel head cladding.
Commencing with the date of Commercial Operation, and for the duration of first 120 month inspection interval, the Inservice Inspection Program for Class 1, 2 and 3 components and systems is based on Section XI of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 1974 Edition and Addenda through Summer 1975. Section XI requirements are augmented by cer-tain special requirements as defined in the Salem Unit No. 2 Technical Specifications, Sections 4.4.5.0, 4.4.10.1 and 4.4.10.2 for examination of steam generator tubing, reactor coolant pump flywheels and steam generator channel head cladding.
Line 29: Line 27:
RFB:az LP4 la 8011e5023T
RFB:az LP4 la 8011e5023T


_ ._                          _                            .    ._    -      _ ._.                  _
                -
,
    *
          .
ATTACHMENT 1 ITEM 3 FOR WHICH RELIEF IS REQUESTED
ATTACHMENT 1 ITEM 3 FOR WHICH RELIEF IS REQUESTED
                          .
: 1.    . Bolts in Category B-G-1, except as-many as four bolts in each of four reactor coolant pumps, will be examined
: 1.    . Bolts in Category B-G-1, except as-many as four bolts in each of four reactor coolant pumps, will be examined
'                                ultrasonically in place during the inspection interval.        Those bolts which are inaccessible due to
'                                ultrasonically in place during the inspection interval.        Those bolts which are inaccessible due to interference from structural members and piping will be examined at or near the end of the inspection interval                            All when the pumps are disassembled for maintenance.
.
:
interference from structural members and piping will be examined at or near the end of the inspection interval                            All when the pumps are disassembled for maintenance.
bolts in Category B-G-2 will be e xamined visually during the inspection interval. If visual examination i
bolts in Category B-G-2 will be e xamined visually during the inspection interval. If visual examination i
reveals indications of distress, the bolts will be removed for surface and/or volumetric examination.
reveals indications of distress, the bolts will be removed for surface and/or volumetric examination.
: 2.      Ultrasonic indications will be recorded at 50% of 3
: 2.      Ultrasonic indications will be recorded at 50% of 3
reference level (DAC) unless suspected by the examiner
reference level (DAC) unless suspected by the examiner to be other than geometric in origin, in which case
!
!
to be other than geometric in origin, in which case
;                                they will be recorded and investigated by a Level                                  II or Level III Examiner if in excess of 20% of DAC. All indications above 100% DAC will be resolved as to their shape and identity by a Level II or Level III Examiner.
;                                they will be recorded and investigated by a Level                                  II or Level III Examiner if in excess of 20% of DAC. All indications above 100% DAC will be resolved as to their shape and identity by a Level II or Level III Examiner.
<
l Justification for departure from a 20% reference level evaluation criterion for all UT examinations is explained in detail in Attachment lA, prepared by i
l Justification for departure from a 20% reference level evaluation criterion for all UT examinations is
                                                                                                                                                      ,
explained in detail in Attachment lA, prepared by i
Southwes" Research Institute as agents for PSE&G.
Southwes" Research Institute as agents for PSE&G.
: 3.      Ultrasonic examination of ferritic piping will be per-formed in accordcnce with Article 5 of Secti'n V of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code with the exception                                                              ;
: 3.      Ultrasonic examination of ferritic piping will be per-formed in accordcnce with Article 5 of Secti'n V of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code with the exception                                                              ;
that all indications will be recorded and evaluated as indicated in paragraph 2 above.
that all indications will be recorded and evaluated as indicated in paragraph 2 above.
,
i-                      4.      Inaccessibililty for examination was identified during
i-                      4.      Inaccessibililty for examination was identified during
'                                  the Preservice Inspection and has been described in the
'                                  the Preservice Inspection and has been described in the
Line 63: Line 45:
'                                  bility have been extracted from these tables and compiled into an abbreviated table which has been included as Attachment 1B for convenient reference.
'                                  bility have been extracted from these tables and compiled into an abbreviated table which has been included as Attachment 1B for convenient reference.
Comments in these tables are necessarily brief.
Comments in these tables are necessarily brief.
4
4 I
                                                                                                                                                    .
!
,
I
:
'
P8023/05 01                                Page 1 of 2
P8023/05 01                                Page 1 of 2
         . _ . ,  _s., .    --      . , . .  . _ . . . , _ . _      , . . .___      . . , , _ , , , . .      . ,,. .- . _ ., -, ,_, ,,, - .
         . _ . ,  _s., .    --      . , . .  . _ . . . , _ . _      , . . .___      . . , , _ , , , . .      . ,,. .- . _ ., -, ,_, ,,, - .


            -      .              .-      -                    - -      .. . .
      .
  . ,
d ATTACHMENT l-(CONT'D)
d ATTACHMENT l-(CONT'D)
:
Information in greater detail has been provided in the          >
Information in greater detail has been provided in the          >
way of additional comments, also included as part of Attachment IC. Consideration of alternate methods are
way of additional comments, also included as part of Attachment IC. Consideration of alternate methods are discussed and in some cases sketches are attached for greater clarity.
          -
discussed and in some cases sketches are attached for greater clarity.
                                                                              '
: 5. Welds having limited ultrasonic examinations are treated in the same manner and are' included  in the            -
: 5. Welds having limited ultrasonic examinations are treated in the same manner and are' included  in the            -
tables and comments mentioned above. No distinction is 1
tables and comments mentioned above. No distinction is 1
Line 88: Line 57:
i              inspectability except in the nature of the comment.            ;
i              inspectability except in the nature of the comment.            ;
Detailed radiographic procedures for augmented or alternative examinations will be prepared at such time as the need arises in order to take advantage of the possibility of more advanced technology at that time.          I
Detailed radiographic procedures for augmented or alternative examinations will be prepared at such time as the need arises in order to take advantage of the possibility of more advanced technology at that time.          I
: 6. The holding time after pressurization and prior to commencement of visual examinations during pressure tests required by IWA 5000 of Section XI will be 10 minutes when insulation is removed. This procedure is presently specified in recently approved editions of Section XI and is considered acceptable practice for an
: 6. The holding time after pressurization and prior to commencement of visual examinations during pressure tests required by IWA 5000 of Section XI will be 10 minutes when insulation is removed. This procedure is presently specified in recently approved editions of Section XI and is considered acceptable practice for an exposed pressure boundary. The longer holding time required by the 1974 Edition of Section XI ecesents unnecessary exposure to radiation in an operating plant.
.
                                                                               't RFB: pac 7-16-80 P8023/05 01/02            Page 2 of 2 i
'
exposed pressure boundary. The longer holding time
'
required by the 1974 Edition of Section XI ecesents unnecessary exposure to radiation in an operating plant.
,
                                                                               't RFB: pac 7-16-80 P8023/05 01/02            Page 2 of 2
                                                                                !
i
!
I i
I i
                                                                                !
l I
l I


_ . .          .                                                                          .                                  . = -      .
_ . .          .                                                                          .                                  . = -      .
          .                                                                                                                                          ,
      .
ATTACHMENT 1A
ATTACHMENT 1A


==Title:==
==Title:==
Comments Concerning the 20 Percent Versus 100 Percent Evaluation Level for Ultrasonic Examination of Nuclear Power Plant Piping
Comments Concerning the 20 Percent Versus 100 Percent Evaluation Level for Ultrasonic Examination of Nuclear Power Plant Piping Introduction I.            The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has asked several plant owners for detailed information to justify two things.
                  .
Introduction
                                                                                                                                        '
I.            The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has asked several plant owners for detailed information to justify two things.
A. That a 20% reference level evaluation criterion is impractical and B. That a 100% reference level evaluation criterion will provide a level of safety comparable to the Section V code requirements (of evaluation at 20%).
A. That a 20% reference level evaluation criterion is impractical and B. That a 100% reference level evaluation criterion will provide a level of safety comparable to the Section V code requirements (of evaluation at 20%).
D,iscussion II.            Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) presents the following considerations on these two closely related questions, taking them in order:
D,iscussion II.            Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) presents the following considerations on these two closely related questions, taking them in order:
Line 121: Line 74:
i                                          thickness differences (12-1/2% of thickness) as well as allowable weld l' _.
i                                          thickness differences (12-1/2% of thickness) as well as allowable weld l' _.
                                           'dropthrough and other conditions such as counterbore taper, crown, etc. These conditions can provide an extremely large
                                           'dropthrough and other conditions such as counterbore taper, crown, etc. These conditions can provide an extremely large
,                                          number of geometric reflectors (with or without mode conversion) which produce ultrasonic examination (UT) indications greater than 2C% of the UT reference level (DAC) (see attached graph). Weld
,                                          number of geometric reflectors (with or without mode conversion) which produce ultrasonic examination (UT) indications greater than 2C% of the UT reference level (DAC) (see attached graph). Weld metal in stainless steel piping contains, in addition, reflectors due to metallurgical grain structure which can l
,
'
metal in stainless steel piping contains, in addition, reflectors due to metallurgical grain structure which can l
l also produce indications greater than 20%
l also produce indications greater than 20%
i
i Attachment lA                                Page 1 of 9 P8035/05 1 I
'
Attachment lA                                Page 1 of 9
,
P8035/05 1 I
_      ..  . _ ,          _  __ , , . .    , , . . . _ . _ - , . , _ . . _ . , . - _ . , _ . - _ . , _ _ , . - _ _ ~      . . ,
_      ..  . _ ,          _  __ , , . .    , , . . . _ . _ - , . , _ . . _ . , . - _ . , _ . - _ . , _ _ , . - _ _ ~      . . ,


      ._      _  _ _ _                                                    _    _          _ _ .              - _ _
        .
  .
DAC.      It appears that the incidence of geometric reflectors increases exponentially as the amplitude is reduced.
DAC.      It appears that the incidence of geometric reflectors increases exponentially as the amplitude is reduced.
'
             .              2. Two stress-corrosion cracks are known to have been missed by SWRI normal examination techniques.                        However, they were not missed because of lack of
             .              2. Two stress-corrosion cracks are known to
'                                detectability; indications of 141% and 159% DAC were obtained from these stress-corrosion cracks in'the HAZ. They were'not identified because of thr2 large i
                                          -
have been missed by SWRI normal examination techniques.                        However, they
,
'
were not missed because of lack of
'                                detectability; indications of 141% and
'
159% DAC were obtained from these stress-corrosion cracks in'the HAZ. They were'not identified because of thr2 large i
4 number of equally high amplitude geometric indications from the adjacent i                                root area-which, in effect, masked the test-data to preclude identifying these cracks.          Reducing the recording level to i
4 number of equally high amplitude geometric indications from the adjacent i                                root area-which, in effect, masked the test-data to preclude identifying these cracks.          Reducing the recording level to i
20% will cause this problem to exist on a much larger scale in that the tremendous increase in ' recorded indication data will
20% will cause this problem to exist on a much larger scale in that the tremendous increase in ' recorded indication data will obscure real flaw indications.              .
.
!
'
obscure real flaw indications.              .
: 3. During the performance of inservice inspections, significant radiation
: 3. During the performance of inservice inspections, significant radiation
                                 . exposure is being experienced by all the inservice examination personnel.                                          In SwRI's experience the examination staff receives essentially all of the legally allowed radiation exposure when recording 50% DAC data.                To evaluate and record 20%
                                 . exposure is being experienced by all the inservice examination personnel.                                          In SwRI's experience the examination staff receives essentially all of the legally allowed radiation exposure when recording 50% DAC data.                To evaluate and record 20%
data would require that the personnel spend several times as much time in a radiation area to obtain additional ultrasonic data which is not practically decipherable and would require a proportional increase in radiation 4
data would require that the personnel spend several times as much time in a radiation area to obtain additional ultrasonic data which is not practically decipherable and would require a proportional increase in radiation 4
exposure to the available examination personnel.            Therefore, these personnel would not be available for the performance of ultrasonic examinations of as many lines or at as many sites.
exposure to the available examination personnel.            Therefore, these personnel would not be available for the performance of ultrasonic examinations of as many lines or at as many sites.
Necessarily, this would force the industry to reduce the sampling rate of examinations because of the
Necessarily, this would force the industry to reduce the sampling rate of examinations because of the inavailability of trained personnel.                                                      The Attachment lA                          Page 2 of 9
,
inavailability of trained personnel.                                                      The Attachment lA                          Page 2 of 9
.            P8035/05 2
.            P8035/05 2
:
_ _      .    .    . - _    . . , , -    . - -  ~ - - - - .      ._. -        - - _ . _ . - . - . . - . _ . _ . - - - , , -
_ _      .    .    . - _    . . , , -    . - -  ~ - - - - .      ._. -        - - _ . _ . - . - . . - . _ . _ . - - - , , -


  .
reduction of sample size would have a detrimental effect on the monitoring of plant integrity through inservice inspection and would eliminate the non-mandatory examinations presently
reduction of sample size would have a detrimental effect on the monitoring of plant integrity through inservice inspection and would eliminate the non-mandatory examinations presently
     -                performed by the utilities in the interest of promptly examining known or suspected problem areas.
     -                performed by the utilities in the interest of promptly examining known or suspected problem areas.
Line 170: Line 97:
recording criteria to the utility, a small sample of a randomly selected weld was examined.      Because of radiation levels, the demonstration was limited to one hour. In that hour, 15 separate indications were recorded with the 60-degree examination in 5/8-inch of weld length while 10 indications were recorded with the 45-degree examination in 1-7/8 inches of weld length. Only maximum amplitude positions were recorded and most indications of 20% DAC and greater were recorded.      It is recognized that this was a very small sample , but it is believed to be typical of 4" bypass line welds. The three-man crew successfully completed the examinations recording at the 50% level within the one-day of examination time available on the unit.
recording criteria to the utility, a small sample of a randomly selected weld was examined.      Because of radiation levels, the demonstration was limited to one hour. In that hour, 15 separate indications were recorded with the 60-degree examination in 5/8-inch of weld length while 10 indications were recorded with the 45-degree examination in 1-7/8 inches of weld length. Only maximum amplitude positions were recorded and most indications of 20% DAC and greater were recorded.      It is recognized that this was a very small sample , but it is believed to be typical of 4" bypass line welds. The three-man crew successfully completed the examinations recording at the 50% level within the one-day of examination time available on the unit.
Evaluation time would have been increased proportionately with dubious conclusions due to the sheer volume of data. The welds were judged to be f ree of cracks based on the 50% DAC recording and 100%
Evaluation time would have been increased proportionately with dubious conclusions due to the sheer volume of data. The welds were judged to be f ree of cracks based on the 50% DAC recording and 100%
evaluation criteria and several months of successful operation without leaking
evaluation criteria and several months of successful operation without leaking Attachment lA              Page 3 of 9 P8035/05 3 i
,
Attachment lA              Page 3 of 9
,
P8035/05 3 i
!
1
1
_.
                                        -      ,-..          .-- . - . . ,


9
9 confir. sed that these examinations, like those performed at several other sites, were effective.
.
confir. sed that these examinations, like those performed at several other sites, were effective.
B.      Evaluation at 100% and greater provides
B.      Evaluation at 100% and greater provides
     -                  equivalent safety _  _
     -                  equivalent safety _  _
Line 191: Line 109:
(b)    All indications 100% of DAC or greater shall be investigated by a Level II or Level III operator to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location of the reflectors.
(b)    All indications 100% of DAC or greater shall be investigated by a Level II or Level III operator to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location of the reflectors.
(c)    Any indication 20% of DAC or greater and suspected by the operator to be other than geometric in nature, including all 20% or greater indications originating in the base metal, shall be recorded and investigated by a Leval II or Level III examiner to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location.of the reflector.
(c)    Any indication 20% of DAC or greater and suspected by the operator to be other than geometric in nature, including all 20% or greater indications originating in the base metal, shall be recorded and investigated by a Leval II or Level III examiner to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location.of the reflector.
                                                    -                -_
           *It must be noted that the 100% evaluation criteria was (and is) the Code requirement for utilities commited to the 1971 Edition of Section XI (S71 Addenda). The inconsistency arose when the 1974 Edition of Section XI incorporated Section V by reference. In the. Summer of 1976 Edition (IWA-2232) the ASME has reconfirmed its previous position by clearly requiring evaluation of only indications of 100% DAC or greater.
           *It must be noted that the 100% evaluation criteria was (and is) the Code requirement for utilities commited to the 1971 Edition of Section XI (S71 Addenda). The inconsistency arose when the 1974 Edition of Section XI incorporated Section V by reference. In the. Summer of 1976 Edition (IWA-2232) the ASME has reconfirmed its previous position by clearly requiring evaluation of only indications of 100% DAC or greater.
Attachment lA                      Page 4 of 9 P8035/05 4
Attachment lA                      Page 4 of 9 P8035/05 4
                . . , _        _          _- .-      ._.  ,  . - -    , _ . _ .--


_-  - ___.                                                                . _ _
    .
  .
(d)          Any indications investigated and
(d)          Any indications investigated and
'                                    found to be other than geometric in nature shall be reported to the owner for evaluation and
'                                    found to be other than geometric in nature shall be reported to the owner for evaluation and disposition.
      .
disposition.
SwRI's long-standing requirement to record 50% DAC information reflects the necessity to record a sublevel of data below that point at which we feel a concern. The prime reason for recording this information is to allow for the known variation in reproducibility of i                      test data.          We have shown data reproducibility to be a factor caused by many thing including operator experience, training, procedure, equipment
SwRI's long-standing requirement to record 50% DAC information reflects the necessity to record a sublevel of data below that point at which we feel a concern. The prime reason for recording this information is to allow for the known variation in reproducibility of i                      test data.          We have shown data reproducibility to be a factor caused by many thing including operator experience, training, procedure, equipment
;                      variations, environmental encumberances,
;                      variations, environmental encumberances,
Line 208: Line 119:
                         -intent of any editior. of the Code and to provide greater safety.at less cost in time, dollars, and radiation exposure to personnel than simply requiring the recording / evaluation of all 20% DAC data.
                         -intent of any editior. of the Code and to provide greater safety.at less cost in time, dollars, and radiation exposure to personnel than simply requiring the recording / evaluation of all 20% DAC data.
: 2. The adequacy of this practice is supported by the follosing:
: 2. The adequacy of this practice is supported by the follosing:
(a)        Except f or a very limited number of applications of the 20% evaluation level criteria of Paragraph IX-3470
(a)        Except f or a very limited number of applications of the 20% evaluation level criteria of Paragraph IX-3470 of the 1971 issue of Section III, the 100% reference level evaluation                      ,
'
criteria of Paragraph IS-213.5 of the Summer 1971 Addenda to Section XI was in effect until ' the adoption in late 1976 of the 1974 Edition of Section XI. The 100% recording criteria was endorsed by the Section V Subcommittee for Nondestructive Examination in a Attachment lA                      Page 5 of 9 P8035/05 5
of the 1971 issue of Section III, the 100% reference level evaluation                      ,
criteria of Paragraph IS-213.5 of the Summer 1971 Addenda to Section XI was in effect until ' the adoption in late 1976 of the 1974 Edition of Section XI. The 100% recording criteria was endorsed by the Section V Subcommittee for Nondestructive Examination in a
:
'
            .
Attachment lA                      Page 5 of 9 P8035/05 5
                                                                                                ,
                              . -- ,      -  ,# .--,                --
                                                                         - ,---, - -      v---.
                                                                         - ,---, - -      v---.


_ _  _ _ _              -    _          .        _ _ _ _
                               .v Code Inquiry of 1973, and appeared in Paragraph T-544 of the 1974 Edition of Section v. There is no question of the overall success of the inservice examination program
                               .v
    .
Code Inquiry of 1973, and appeared
.
in Paragraph T-544 of the 1974 Edition of Section v. There is no question of the overall success of the inservice examination program
         -                    during.these many years, and the I
         -                    during.these many years, and the I
      -
100% evaluation criteria was reconfirmed by ASME in' Paragraph IWA-2232 of the Summer 1976 Addenda to the Section XI code.                                                            .
100% evaluation criteria was reconfirmed by ASME in' Paragraph IWA-2232 of the Summer 1976 Addenda to the Section XI code.                                                            .
(b) As a result of the different failure mode of austenitic piping (noted in Paragraph (d) below) SwRI had developed modified approaches in procedure to maintain assurance of maximum crack detection
(b) As a result of the different failure mode of austenitic piping (noted in Paragraph (d) below) SwRI had developed modified approaches in procedure to maintain assurance of maximum crack detection sensitivity.              Search unit size, frequency and beam angle, as well as procedure, are optimized to take advantage of the known parameters of the type of f ailure to be detected and investigated in different situations.
'
sensitivity.              Search unit size, frequency and beam angle, as well
<
as procedure, are optimized to take advantage of the known parameters of the type of f ailure to be detected and investigated in different situations.
(c) While it has been demonstrated that j-                            significantly deep through-wall stress-corrosion cracking may give l
(c) While it has been demonstrated that j-                            significantly deep through-wall stress-corrosion cracking may give l
only a low amplitude response, it a
only a low amplitude response, it a
Line 239: Line 132:
  ;
  ;
multiple plants that the 100%
multiple plants that the 100%
:
evaluation criteria, augmented by 4                            operator investigation at the 20%
evaluation criteria, augmented by 4                            operator investigation at the 20%
level, can be applied with satisfactory results:
level, can be applied with satisfactory results:
i                            (1)        No component or pipe examined by SwRI has experienced leaking by way of a stress-corrosion crack between the periodic a ;aminations.
i                            (1)        No component or pipe examined by SwRI has experienced leaking by way of a stress-corrosion crack between the periodic a ;aminations.
.,
(2)        At least 48 piping cracks have been found and repaired
(2)        At least 48 piping cracks
  )~                                        in the early stages of propagation.
'
have been found and repaired
  )~                                        in the early stages of
.
propagation.
Attachment lA            Page 6 of 9 P8035/05 6
Attachment lA            Page 6 of 9 P8035/05 6
                                                                                                                !
          -
               +        -            - - -    - _,            , _ _ _ _ _ _  .,  __,_. . . _ , - _ . _ . , ,I
               +        -            - - -    - _,            , _ _ _ _ _ _  .,  __,_. . . _ , - _ . _ . , ,I


(d)  Much experience has shown that the typical mode of f ailure in stainless steel piping is not in the weld metal, per se, but is
(d)  Much experience has shown that the typical mode of f ailure in stainless steel piping is not in the weld metal, per se, but is
                         " stress-corrosion cracking" in the
                         " stress-corrosion cracking" in the adjacent heat-affected zone (HAZ) and base metal. A trained UT operator can distinguish the dif ference between the usual weld-metal geometric indications and the somewhat similar indictions due to stress-corrosion cracking by noting their location in the base metal of HAZ. This is true even when their amplitude is in the 20%
'
adjacent heat-affected zone (HAZ) and base metal. A trained UT operator can distinguish the dif ference between the usual weld-metal geometric indications and the somewhat similar indictions due to stress-corrosion cracking by noting their location in the base metal of HAZ. This is true even when their amplitude is in the 20%
to 50% range and even though indications in this range originating in the weld metal cannot be identified.
to 50% range and even though indications in this range originating in the weld metal cannot be identified.
(e)  A prime example of the adequacy of the total SwRI examination technique is th a t Recirculation Bypass lines have been ultrasonically examined in accordance with RO Bulletin 74-10 in six nuclear power plants.
(e)  A prime example of the adequacy of the total SwRI examination technique is th a t Recirculation Bypass lines have been ultrasonically examined in accordance with RO Bulletin 74-10 in six nuclear power plants.
Line 264: Line 147:
Summary and Conclusions III. For the reasons enumerated above, SwRI recommends to its clients that, in the interests ot maintaising maximum nuclear power plant integrity and safety at minimum cost in time and personnel radiation exposure, and efforc to institute a blanket 20% DAC recording / evaluation criteria be i
Summary and Conclusions III. For the reasons enumerated above, SwRI recommends to its clients that, in the interests ot maintaising maximum nuclear power plant integrity and safety at minimum cost in time and personnel radiation exposure, and efforc to institute a blanket 20% DAC recording / evaluation criteria be i
I l
I l
l
l l
                                                            ,
Attachment lA                Page 7 of 9 P8035/05 7                                                  l l
l Attachment lA                Page 7 of 9 P8035/05 7                                                  l l


                                                                          .                _        _
    .
  .
,i                                                                                                    !
,i                                                                                                    !
4 resisted. Instead, SwRI recommends a commitment to the SwRI recording / evaluation practice which was set out in Paragraph B.1 above and is reinterated below:
4 resisted. Instead, SwRI recommends a commitment to the SwRI recording / evaluation practice which was set out in Paragraph B.1 above and is reinterated below:
      *
(a)  All indications 50% of DAC or greater shall be recorded.
(a)  All indications 50% of DAC or greater shall be recorded.
(b)  All indications 100% of DAC or greater shall be investigated by a Level II or l
(b)  All indications 100% of DAC or greater shall be investigated by a Level II or l
Line 280: Line 158:
(d)  Any 171.ications investigated and found to be o'ber than geometric in nature shall be reported to the owner for evaluation and disposition.
(d)  Any 171.ications investigated and found to be o'ber than geometric in nature shall be reported to the owner for evaluation and disposition.
Attachment lA                  Page 8 of 9 P8035/05.8 i
Attachment lA                  Page 8 of 9 P8035/05.8 i
                                                                                                      !
1 l
1 l
         --                ,    , . ,              .  , . , ~ . _ . - -  , . - - _ _ _ . . - . .
         --                ,    , . ,              .  , . , ~ . _ . - -  , . - - _ _ _ . . - . .


_- .        _.  .
_
                                                                                                                                  .
4500-                      __
4500-                      __
43o0- Baco on A                                    TY Pl CAL ULTR.A50M t C 4'co : 9avey on                                        EX AM i M A.Tl O W R.ESULTL S'co-      bvn IL                                    FO R.      c.LA55      l  PJ PI NG 3700; gggg,gggg, O
43o0- Baco on A                                    TY Pl CAL ULTR.A50M t C 4'co : 9avey on                                        EX AM i M A.Tl O W R.ESULTL S'co-      bvn IL                                    FO R.      c.LA55      l  PJ PI NG 3700; gggg,gggg, O
Line 297: Line 171:
m                              i90o. 12AdqE THA;J
m                              i90o. 12AdqE THA;J
     )                              1 loo - Tilli lofAL                    ___
     )                              1 loo - Tilli lofAL                    ___
                                                                      -
7}                            e600; ta u m gg e R. O F        _    _
7}                            e600; ta u m gg e R. O F        _    _
33 O      T opl CATIOtl$    -
33 O      T opl CATIOtl$    -
1100
1100 s3OO-                                      _ _
                                                          '                          -
s3OO-                                      _ _
10 0 -
10 0 -
500
500 300 ~                                                              _
__
300 ~                                                              _
soo                                                                  '  '  '
soo                                                                  '  '  '
                                                                                                                  .-
o*'2'*          l 4D*    60  do  goo      IZD  16 0    200 1S0  380 450' boo' 650 750  1000 PER. CENT OF DAC 1
o*'2'*          l 4D*    60  do  goo      IZD  16 0    200 1S0  380 450' boo' 650 750  1000 PER. CENT OF DAC 1
2
2
* 14 0 R EColz DE D D ATA AVAIL A t$L E FOR l'A H,u L Ar t O N .                  _      o _ , , ,
* 14 0 R EColz DE D D ATA AVAIL A t$L E FOR l'A H,u L Ar t O N .                  _      o _ , , ,
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ - - _ _


  -                  -
,.
ATTACHMENT 1C DETAILED EXPLANATION OF EXCEPTIONS TO THE ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL CODE
ATTACHMENT 1C DETAILED EXPLANATION OF EXCEPTIONS TO THE ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL CODE
       -                          SECTION XI FOR THE SALEM UNIT NO. 2 INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM Item Bl.2    Category B-B Closure Head Peel Segmen*-To-Disc Circumferential Weld l
       -                          SECTION XI FOR THE SALEM UNIT NO. 2 INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM Item Bl.2    Category B-B Closure Head Peel Segmen*-To-Disc Circumferential Weld l
Line 329: Line 194:
                                     ,  , . . , . -      .- ,_ .--~, , .. ,. . . . , , _ , _ - -
                                     ,  , . . , . -      .- ,_ .--~, , .. ,. . . . , , _ , _ - -


                .-.                -          -                                . .
        .
    .-
  .
                                         ' ATTACHMENT-lC (CONT'D) 4 I t e m B'. . Category B-D~
                                         ' ATTACHMENT-lC (CONT'D) 4 I t e m B'. . Category B-D~
Reactor Vessel Inlet Nozzle to Shell Welds Vo.ametric examination will not be performed when the Core Barrel is in' place due to inaccessibility. The examinations will be performed when the core barrel is removed during the inspection interval. These welds are identified.as 27.5-RCN-1210, 27.5-RCN-1220,
Reactor Vessel Inlet Nozzle to Shell Welds Vo.ametric examination will not be performed when the Core Barrel is in' place due to inaccessibility. The examinations will be performed when the core barrel is removed during the inspection interval. These welds are identified.as 27.5-RCN-1210, 27.5-RCN-1220, 27.5-RCN-1230, and 27.5-RCN-1240 in the examination l                  plan.
,
27.5-RCN-1230, and 27.5-RCN-1240 in the examination l                  plan.
As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-15-77 attached, the Core Barrel covers the weld area when it is in place.
As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-15-77 attached, the Core Barrel covers the weld area when it is in place.
Since all weld examinations are performed from the inside surface using a mechanized inspection device, these welds are inaccessible at this time. Examina-tions cannot be performed from the outside surface due to the area being covered by insulation on the shell of the weld and the configuration of the weld joint on the nozzle side'of the weld. The insulation on the shell portion of the- reactor vessel is not designed for removability and to remove-it would. require the cutting away of the insulation support rings f rom the vessel.
Since all weld examinations are performed from the inside surface using a mechanized inspection device, these welds are inaccessible at this time. Examina-tions cannot be performed from the outside surface due to the area being covered by insulation on the shell of the weld and the configuration of the weld joint on the nozzle side'of the weld. The insulation on the shell portion of the- reactor vessel is not designed for removability and to remove-it would. require the cutting away of the insulation support rings f rom the vessel.
T Since the Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval, and ASME Code Case N-73 (1647) allows these examinations to be
T Since the Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval, and ASME Code Case N-73 (1647) allows these examinations to be deferred toithe end of each inspection interval, i t is PSE&G's position that the intent of the Code is being complied with.
'
deferred toithe end of each inspection interval, i t is PSE&G's position that the intent of the Code is being complied with.
T Reactor Vessel Outlet Nozzle to Shell Welds Volumetric examination will be performed with the Core Barrel in place except for the . examination of the
T Reactor Vessel Outlet Nozzle to Shell Welds Volumetric examination will be performed with the Core Barrel in place except for the . examination of the
                     . Reactor Vessel base metal due to inaccessibility. The
                     . Reactor Vessel base metal due to inaccessibility. The base metal will be examined when the Core                    Barrel is removed during the inspection interval. These welds are identified as 29-RCN-1210, 29-RCN-1220, i                    29-RCN-1230, and 29-RCN-1240 in the examination plan.                                1
:
base metal will be examined when the Core                    Barrel is removed during the inspection interval. These welds are identified as 29-RCN-1210, 29-RCN-1220, i                    29-RCN-1230, and 29-RCN-1240 in the examination plan.                                1
,
}
}
!
l l
l
P802304 02                          Page 2 of 5
!
l P802304 02                          Page 2 of 5
,
                                   ,  -          .,m.. -
                                   ,  -          .,m.. -
                                                           ,-w me., ..e.-m,---. -
                                                           ,-w me., ..e.-m,---. -
                                                                                     .-.m.  ,,-e~,.v - v,
                                                                                     .-.m.  ,,-e~,.v - v,


                            .  .                                                            .
i l
i l
        .
  ..
  .
ATTACHMENT 1C (CONT'D)
ATTACHMENT 1C (CONT'D)
,
          .
As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-16-77 attached, the Core Barrel covers    the reactor vessel 'ase metal when it is in place. Since all weld examin. ions are per-formed from the inside surface using a: automated inspection device, these welds are inaccessible at this time. Examination cannot be performed from the out-sidesurface due to the area being covered by insulation which would require the. cutting away of the insulation support rings to remove.
As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-16-77 attached, the Core Barrel covers    the reactor vessel 'ase metal when it is in place. Since all weld examin. ions are per-formed from the inside surface using a: automated inspection device, these welds are inaccessible at this time. Examination cannot be performed from the out-sidesurface due to the area being covered by insulation which would require the. cutting away of the insulation support rings to remove.
Since the Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval, and ASME Code Case N-73 (1647) allows these examinations to be deferred to the end of each inspection interval, it is PSE&G's position that the intent of the Code is being complied with.
Since the Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval, and ASME Code Case N-73 (1647) allows these examinations to be deferred to the end of each inspection interval, it is PSE&G's position that the intent of the Code is being complied with.
Item Bl.14      Category B-I-l Reactor Vessel Cladding Visual examination will not be performed on the Reactor vessel Shell Cladding when the Core Barrel is in place due to inaccessibility. The patches of cladding to be examined are identified as 2-RPV-Patch-1, 2-RPV-Patch-2, 2-RPV-Patch- 3, 2-RPV-Patch-4, 2-RPV-Patch-5, and2-RPV-Patch-6 in the examination plan.
Item Bl.14      Category B-I-l Reactor Vessel Cladding Visual examination will not be performed on the Reactor vessel Shell Cladding when the Core Barrel is in place due to inaccessibility. The patches of cladding to be examined are identified as 2-RPV-Patch-1, 2-RPV-Patch-2, 2-RPV-Patch- 3, 2-RPV-Patch-4, 2-RPV-Patch-5, and2-RPV-Patch-6 in the examination plan.
Since this examination can only be performed from the inside surface of the reactor vessel shell, the exami-nation can only be performed when the Core Barrel is removed. The Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval.
Since this examination can only be performed from the inside surface of the reactor vessel shell, the exami-nation can only be performed when the Core Barrel is removed. The Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval.
Item B4.5    Category 3-J Reactor Coolant Loop Piping Longitudinal Welds Volumetric examinations will not be performed on the longitudinal welds in the Reactor Coolant piping elbows.- Surface examinations will be performed as well as a visual examination for leaks required by Section
Item B4.5    Category 3-J Reactor Coolant Loop Piping Longitudinal Welds Volumetric examinations will not be performed on the longitudinal welds in the Reactor Coolant piping elbows.- Surface examinations will be performed as well as a visual examination for leaks required by Section i
                          -
1 P802304 03                  Page 3 of 5
      .
i 1
                                                                                              '
P802304 03                  Page 3 of 5
_ , - _ _ . _    _    _  .-- , . _ . _ , -
          -._ _        _                  _


          -                      . _ _
  .
1
1
                                           ' ATTACHMENT IC (CONT'D)
                                           ' ATTACHMENT IC (CONT'D)
Line 391: Line 228:
Item B5.6 Category B-L-1 Reactor Coolant Pump Casing Welds A visual examination for leaks will be performed.
Item B5.6 Category B-L-1 Reactor Coolant Pump Casing Welds A visual examination for leaks will be performed.
The Reactor Coolant Pump casings are made of cast stainless steel which cannot be penetrated by ultra-sonic examination techniques.          Also, acceptable radio-graphs cannot be obtained due to fogging of the film i
The Reactor Coolant Pump casings are made of cast stainless steel which cannot be penetrated by ultra-sonic examination techniques.          Also, acceptable radio-graphs cannot be obtained due to fogging of the film i
!
4 P802304 04                        Page 4 of 5 l
4 P802304 04                        Page 4 of 5 l
     - , .        -            ,-      -      ,,      ,- ,  - . , .  -      . ~ . , -. -
     - , .        -            ,-      -      ,,      ,- ,  - . , .  -      . ~ . , -. -


                                                            .
ATTACH"ENT 1C ( CO"~ ~ .,
ATTACH"ENT 1C ( CO"~ ~ .,
caused by long exposure time coupled with background
caused by long exposure time coupled with background radiation from the pump casing. Radiography will be considered as new techniques are developed to examine these welds in the future.
'
RFB: pac 7-16-80 P802304 05              Page 5 of 5
radiation from the pump casing. Radiography will be considered as new techniques are developed to examine these welds in the future.
RFB: pac 7-16-80
                                                .
P802304 05              Page 5 of 5


      .                  . - .          ..    -                                  -                .                    . .  .          .      _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - _ _ _ - -
k 4
k 4
      '.
                                                                                                                                                                              ,
4 I
4 I
Attachment 2 ISI          Boundary  Diagrams Sy.s tems
Attachment 2 ISI          Boundary  Diagrams Sy.s tems
Line 413: Line 241:
: 2.    -Steam Generator Feed & Condensate                                        249826 - A - 1777
: 2.    -Steam Generator Feed & Condensate                                        249826 - A - 1777
: 3.      MainLReheat and' Turbine By-Pass Steam                                  249827 - A - 1777 1
: 3.      MainLReheat and' Turbine By-Pass Steam                                  249827 - A - 1777 1
'
: 4.      Chilled Water                                                            241828 - A - 1568
: 4.      Chilled Water                                                            241828 - A - 1568
'
: 5.    - Fire Protection                                                        241829 - A - 1568 Y
: 5.    - Fire Protection                                                        241829 - A - 1568 Y
: 6.      Steam Generator Drains & Blowdown                                        249830 - A - 1777 7.-    Chemical &. Volume Cvntrol - Operation                                  249831 - A - 1777
: 6.      Steam Generator Drains & Blowdown                                        249830 - A - 1777 7.-    Chemical &. Volume Cvntrol - Operation                                  249831 - A - 1777
: 8.      Chemical & Volume Control -                                              2 4 9 8 3 2 - A -- 1777 i
: 8.      Chemical & Volume Control -                                              2 4 9 8 3 2 - A -- 1777 i
Boric Acid Recovery J                        9.      Chemical & Volume Control -                                              249833 - A - 1777
Boric Acid Recovery J                        9.      Chemical & Volume Control -                                              249833 - A - 1777 Primary Water Recovery
                      '
Primary Water Recovery
: 10.      Component Cooling                                                        249834 - A - 1777 d
: 10.      Component Cooling                                                        249834 - A - 1777 d
'
: 11.      Residual Heat Removal                                                    249835 - A - 1777
: 11.      Residual Heat Removal                                                    249835 - A - 1777
  >                      12.      Spent Fuel Cooling                                                        249836 - A - 1777
  >                      12.      Spent Fuel Cooling                                                        249836 - A - 1777
Line 431: Line 254:
: 16.      Waste Disposal-Liquid                                                    24-9840 - A - 1777
: 16.      Waste Disposal-Liquid                                                    24-9840 - A - 1777
.,                      17.      Service Water                                                            249841 - A - 1777
.,                      17.      Service Water                                                            249841 - A - 1777
,
: 18.      Sa mpling                                                                  249842 - A - 1777
: 18.      Sa mpling                                                                  249842 - A - 1777
: 19.      Demineralized Water - Restricted Areas                                    241843 - A - 1568 20,      Waste Disposal Solid                                                      241844 - A - 1568 a
: 19.      Demineralized Water - Restricted Areas                                    241843 - A - 1568 20,      Waste Disposal Solid                                                      241844 - A - 1568 a
  ;
  ;
NM:az 1                        LB1 1-B
NM:az 1                        LB1 1-B i
:
i
  ..- _ . ., _ - - ,                  _      _  -_  . ,    . . . , , , - . _ , , - _ , _ . - . _ , . , . _ _ _ _ .            , , , . , _ _ _ . . , - . - . ,


                                                                                        . .                    .
TMM 1
TMM 1
       ,                                        CIASS A (DMPCNDf!S, PARTS AND E8TODS OF EXAMINATION
       ,                                        CIASS A (DMPCNDf!S, PARTS AND E8TODS OF EXAMINATION Examination Category                                                                                            Method d
  .
Examination Category                                                                                            Method d
IMm          Table
IMm          Table
     ' No.          Fa3-2500                    Cb @onents and Parts to be Examined t
     ' No.          Fa3-2500                    Cb @onents and Parts to be Examined t
Ikactor Vetsel Volum tric B-A Longitudinal and circumferential shell welds in mre region Bl.1                                                                                                      Volumtric Bl .2 '    B-B            Iontitudinal    and circumferential welds in shell (other than those of Category B-A and B-C) and meridional and circun:ferential
Ikactor Vetsel Volum tric B-A Longitudinal and circumferential shell welds in mre region Bl.1                                                                                                      Volumtric Bl .2 '    B-B            Iontitudinal    and circumferential welds in shell (other than those of Category B-A and B-C) and meridional and circun:ferential seam welds in bottom head and closure Volunetric Vessel-to-flange and head-to-flange circunferential welds 81.3        B<                                                                                            Volumetric Prinary nozzle-to-vessel welds and nozzle inside radiused secticr Bl.6        B-D Visual (IWA-5000)
                            -
seam welds in bottom head and closure Volunetric Vessel-to-flange and head-to-flange circunferential welds 81.3        B<                                                                                            Volumetric Prinary nozzle-to-vessel welds and nozzle inside radiused secticr Bl.6        B-D Visual (IWA-5000)
Vessel penetrations, including entrol rod drive and instrumntation Bl.5        B-E penetrations.
Vessel penetrations, including entrol rod drive and instrumntation Bl.5        B-E penetrations.
Voluretric and Surface Bl.6        B-F            tbzzle-to-safe end welds Voluretric B+1              Closure studs, in place Bl.7                                                                                                      Volaretric and Surface B+1              Closure studs with nuts, when removed 81.8                                                                                                      Volumetric B+1              I.igamnts between threaded stud holes Bl.9                                                                                                      Visual Closure washers, bushings
Voluretric and Surface Bl.6        B-F            tbzzle-to-safe end welds Voluretric B+1              Closure studs, in place Bl.7                                                                                                      Volaretric and Surface B+1              Closure studs with nuts, when removed 81.8                                                                                                      Volumetric B+1              I.igamnts between threaded stud holes Bl.9                                                                                                      Visual Closure washers, bushings
  ,        Bl.10      B-G-1                                                                                                _
  ,        Bl.10      B-G-1                                                                                                _
B1.11      B+2              tb ccrponents within this category
B1.11      B+2              tb ccrponents within this category Bl.12      B-H            No corponents within this category
_
Bl.12      B-H            No corponents within this category
: 1) Visual and Surface Closure Head claddin;                                                                          Or Bl.13    B-I-l
: 1) Visual and Surface Closure Head claddin;                                                                          Or Bl.13    B-I-l
: 2) Volumetric 4
: 2) Volumetric 4
Visual Vessel Cladding Bl.14      B-I-l Visual 91.15      B-N-I            Vessel Interior Visual S-N-2 Interior attach ents aM core su; mort structures 91.16                                                                                                      Visual Bl.17    B-N-3            Core-support structures Volu-etrtC N              Control rod drive housings Bl.19                                                                                                      Visual (IWA-5000)
Visual Vessel Cladding Bl.14      B-I-l Visual 91.15      B-N-I            Vessel Interior Visual S-N-2 Interior attach ents aM core su; mort structures 91.16                                                                                                      Visual Bl.17    B-N-3            Core-support structures Volu-etrtC N              Control rod drive housings Bl.19                                                                                                      Visual (IWA-5000)
B-P              Exerpted conponents 81.19 Pressurtzer Voluretric B2.1        B-B              Iongitudinal and circumf erential welds 4
B-P              Exerpted conponents 81.19 Pressurtzer Voluretric B2.1        B-B              Iongitudinal and circumf erential welds 4
Volu etric B2.2        B-D            Nozzle-to-vessel radiused section Visual (IWA-5000) 62.3        B-E            teater penetrations Volumetric and Surface B2.4        B-F            Nozzle-to-safe and welds
Volu etric B2.2        B-D            Nozzle-to-vessel radiused section Visual (IWA-5000) 62.3        B-E            teater penetrations Volumetric and Surface B2.4        B-F            Nozzle-to-safe and welds B2.5      B+1              No cc:'ponents within this category B2.6      B+1              No mnpanents within this catecpry I            B2."      B+1              tu mnponents within this category B2.S        B-H            No corponents within this category Visual B-1-2            Vessel claMing Bl.9                                                                                                          Visual (IWA-5000)
_
B2.5      B+1              No cc:'ponents within this category
                                                                                                                                    -
B2.6      B+1              No mnpanents within this catecpry
_
I            B2."      B+1              tu mnponents within this category
_
B2.S        B-H            No corponents within this category Visual B-1-2            Vessel claMing Bl.9                                                                                                          Visual (IWA-5000)
B2.10      B-P              Exerpted wrponents Visual B2.11      B+2              Pressare-retaining tolting P6235/s4 1/2
B2.10      B-P              Exerpted wrponents Visual B2.11      B+2              Pressare-retaining tolting P6235/s4 1/2
                -            _ ._                          ,                    - . _    -
                                                                                                        . . _ _      _ _ _ , __. -      - . _ , _ .


                                .            . ,    . - . . _ _.                                                                    . _
TABIE 1 CCNTDCED Examination Cate9oU ttv          Tcle                                                                                                          Method                        l
* TABIE 1 CCNTDCED
      ..
,
* Examination Cate9oU ttv          Tcle                                                                                                          Method                        l
          ''
           ..      .IWB-2500                    CoTonents and Parts to be Examined Steam Cenerators .
           ..      .IWB-2500                    CoTonents and Parts to be Examined Steam Cenerators .
Nolumtric Iongitudinal and circumferential welds, including tube sheet-to-head
Nolumtric Iongitudinal and circumferential welds, including tube sheet-to-head
                     ~
                     ~
53.1        B-B or shell welds on the primary side Volumetric
53.1        B-B or shell welds on the primary side Volumetric
  <
         '33.2        B-D        tbzzle-tMead welds and nozzle inside radiused section on the
         '33.2        B-D        tbzzle-tMead welds and nozzle inside radiused section on the
                               -      primry side Volum tric and Surface Bi.)        B-F        No2zle-to-safe end welds
                               -      primry side Volum tric and Surface Bi.)        B-F        No2zle-to-safe end welds
                                                                                                                                            -
;        B).4      B-G-1          No awponents within this category 31.5    B-O- 1          No conponents within this category 31.6    B+1            No conponents within this category                                                                                              7 51.7    B-G-1            No corponents within tnis ev.egory Vessel Cladding                                                                            Visual 33.6      B-I-2 Visual (IWA-5000) 33.9-        B-P          Exe pted copnts Pressure-retaining boltirv3                                                              Visual l        83.10    B G-2 Eddy Current 4.4.5.0*      Tuoing
;        B).4      B-G-1          No awponents within this category
                                                                                                                                            -
* 31.5    B-O- 1          No conponents within this category
                                                                                                                                            -
31.6    B+1            No conponents within this category                                                                                              7
                                                                                                                                            --
51.7    B-G-1            No corponents within tnis ev.egory Vessel Cladding                                                                            Visual 33.6      B-I-2 Visual (IWA-5000) 33.9-        B-P          Exe pted copnts Pressure-retaining boltirv3                                                              Visual l        83.10    B G-2 Eddy Current 4.4.5.0*      Tuoing
;
;
Vessel Clack 31ng (Steam Genenstor #24)                                                  Volumetric 4.4.10.2*
Vessel Clack 31ng (Steam Genenstor #24)                                                  Volumetric 4.4.10.2*
Piping Pressure Boundary Safe-erd to piping welds and safe-end in branch piping welds                              Volum tric and Surface
Piping Pressure Boundary Safe-erd to piping welds and safe-end in branch piping welds                              Volum tric and Surface
;          B4.1        B-F
;          B4.1        B-F 34.;      B-G-1          fu corponents within this category B4.3      IH'r-1        No ccTorents within this category 34.4      B-G-1          No corponents within this category Circrf erential and longitudinal pipe welds                                                Voluretric 34.5        B-J Branch pipe connection welds exceeding six in. dia eter                                    Volunetric B4;6        B-1
,
                                                                                                                                              -
34.;      B-G-1          fu corponents within this category
                                                                                                                                              -
B4.3      IH'r-1        No ccTorents within this category
                                                                                                                                              -
34.4      B-G-1          No corponents within this category Circrf erential and longitudinal pipe welds                                                Voluretric 34.5        B-J Branch pipe connection welds exceeding six in. dia eter                                    Volunetric B4;6        B-1
?
?
Branch pipe connection welds six in diareter and smiler                                    Surface B4.-        B-J S>cr,et welds                                                                              Surface 34.:        B-J Integrally welded supports                                                                Volunetric 34.,      B-r-1 Support corponents Visual
Branch pipe connection welds six in diareter and smiler                                    Surface B4.-        B-J S>cr,et welds                                                                              Surface 34.:        B-J Integrally welded supports                                                                Volunetric 34.,      B-r-1 Support corponents Visual
   ,          B4.10      B-F-2 Exe pted corponents                                                                        Visual-(IWA-5000)
   ,          B4.10      B-F-2 Exe pted corponents                                                                        Visual-(IWA-5000)
B4.11      B-P Pressure-retaining bolting                                                                  Visual B4.12      B+2 Reactor (bolant Pu@s
B4.11      B-P Pressure-retaining bolting                                                                  Visual B4.12      B+2 Reactor (bolant Pu@s Pressare-retaining bolts and studs, in place                                                Voluretric S5.'      B+1 Pressure-retaining bolts and studs, when removed                                            Voluretric and Surface I            B5.2-    B-G-1 Pressure-retaining bolting                                                                  Visual B5.;      3+1 Integrally-welded supports                                                                  Volu.-etric 35.4      3-r-1.
,
Pressare-retaining bolts and studs, in place                                                Voluretric S5.'      B+1 Pressure-retaining bolts and studs, when removed                                            Voluretric and Surface I            B5.2-    B-G-1 Pressure-retaining bolting                                                                  Visual B5.;      3+1 Integrally-welded supports                                                                  Volu.-etric 35.4      3-r-1.
i                                            Unit 2
i                                            Unit 2
                                         *Salet Technical Spectficaticns i
                                         *Salet Technical Spectficaticns i
Line 516: Line 296:
                             .p-  .-    -w                  - - - , m ,, . , - - . - , - ~  e. - . . - . . . - - - , - .-.  --.---..-,--.-,-...,--,m y , y r,.
                             .p-  .-    -w                  - - - , m ,, . , - - . - , - ~  e. - . . - . . . - - - , - .-.  --.---..-,--.-,-...,--,m y , y r,.


                              . . . . .  . .. - .                        .                                                                                        .  .-            -          -
_
i-
i-
                .-
* TABIE 1 CDfrINUED
* TABIE 1 CDfrINUED
    .-
      -
'
    ,
                   . Exa:raratton Cate'PC/                                                                                                                                                    Method-Itet ~            'Tasle                                      Conponents and Parts to be Examined
                   . Exa:raratton Cate'PC/                                                                                                                                                    Method-Itet ~            'Tasle                                      Conponents and Parts to be Examined
' = m.                    rn3-2500
' = m.                    rn3-2500 Visual B5.5'        B-K-2                    Support corponents Volunetric
                                                                          -
.
Visual B5.5'        B-K-2                    Support corponents
                    ..
Volunetric
,'- B5.6              B 'el.
,'- B5.6              B 'el.
Punp casing welds Visual
Punp casing welds Visual
'
       . B5.7          B *.e-2          .        Parp casing Visual (IWA-5000) 85.9            B-P'                ' Exenpted cx2nponents B5.9          B-G-2                    . No components within this cate7xf volunetric and Surface                    ,
       . B5.7          B *.e-2          .        Parp casing Visual (IWA-5000) 85.9            B-P'                ' Exenpted cx2nponents
                                                                                                                                                                                          -
B5.9          B-G-2                    . No components within this cate7xf volunetric and Surface                    ,
4.4.10.l*                Purp Flywheel f
4.4.10.l*                Purp Flywheel f
Valves
Valves B6.1          B ~,-1                    tb coqxnents within this categorf B6.2          B-G-1                      te mnponents within this categorf B6.3        ~-B-G-1                      No corponents within this categorf l                                                                                                                                                                                          .
_
B6.4            B-K-1                    te corponents within this categorf Visual                                  i e6.5            B-K-2                      Support corponents Visual B6.7            B-K-2                    Valve tx231es Visual (IWA-5000) 1 B6.3              B-P                    Exe pted conponents Visual B-G-2                    Pressure-retatnang bolting B6.9 Unit 2
B6.1          B ~,-1                    tb coqxnents within this categorf
,                                                                                                                                                                                          .
B6.2          B-G-1                      te mnponents within this categorf
_
B6.3        ~-B-G-1                      No corponents within this categorf l                                                                                                                                                                                          .
'
B6.4            B-K-1                    te corponents within this categorf Visual                                  i e6.5            B-K-2                      Support corponents
,
Visual B6.7            B-K-2                    Valve tx231es Visual (IWA-5000) 1 B6.3              B-P                    Exe pted conponents
,
Visual
* B-G-2                    Pressure-retatnang bolting B6.9 Unit 2
,
* Salem Technical Specification 4
* Salem Technical Specification 4
I 1
I 1
4 s
4 s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                      "
d 1
d 1
,
W 4
W 4
I 4
I 4
,.
1 PS025'0C 5/6 l-1 i
1
>
!
PS025'0C 5/6 l-1 i
;
;
             ,m.        .              - .                  , - - . . , _ - , - . . _ _ _ . _ . . _ . . - . - . . . _ , , . , . . _ . . - , . - . , ~ , , - . , , .
             ,m.        .              - .                  , - - . . , _ - , - . . _ _ _ . _ . . _ . . - . - . . . _ , , . , . . _ . . - , . - . , ~ , , - . , , .
                                                                    .
                                                                                                                                                                       ,    -_=____,,,_e-,    . . . . , , , . . . . .
                                                                                                                                                                       ,    -_=____,,,_e-,    . . . . , , , . . . . .


                                  -                              -    .
          .
              .
DBIE 3 t
DBIE 3 t
* CIASS a COMKNEN25, PAIUS, AND ME'IH006 OF CXAMDiATZCN
* CIASS a COMKNEN25, PAIUS, AND ME'IH006 OF CXAMDiATZCN Exan nation
  .
Exan nation
   .            Category-Ite-        Tsole                                                                                                            Method
   .            Category-Ite-        Tsole                                                                                                            Method
: u.          rad-2520                                      Conponents and Parts to be Examined Pressure Vessels '
: u.          rad-2520                                      Conponents and Parts to be Examined Pressure Vessels '
Volumetric
Volumetric
!    C1.1        C-A                  Circrferential butt welds Volumetric 01.2        C-9                  tbzzle-tWessel welds Surface 0;.3        C-C
!    C1.1        C-A                  Circrferential butt welds Volumetric 01.2        C-9                  tbzzle-tWessel welds Surface 0;.3        C-C Integrally-welded supports Visual and ei'her C1.4        C-D                  Pressare-retatning bolting                                                                surface or volretric I                                                                              Piping Volmetric l    C2.1    C-F,C-G                Circumferential butt welds Volunetric 02.1    C-F,C-G                Iongitudinal weld joints in fittings q
                                '
Integrally-welded supports Visual and ei'her C1.4        C-D                  Pressare-retatning bolting                                                                surface or volretric I                                                                              Piping Volmetric l    C2.1    C-F,C-G                Circumferential butt welds Volunetric 02.1    C-F,C-G                Iongitudinal weld joints in fittings q
Volu:tetric                  ;
Volu:tetric                  ;
C2.3    C-F,& G                Branch pipe-t g ipe weld joints Visual and either C2.4                C-D          Pressare-retaining bolting                                                                surf ace or volu:netric Surface C2.5      C-E-1                  Integrally-welded supports 1
C2.3    C-F,& G                Branch pipe-t g ipe weld joints Visual and either C2.4                C-D          Pressare-retaining bolting                                                                surf ace or volu:netric Surface C2.5      C-E-1                  Integrally-welded supports 1
Visual
Visual
       ~2.6      C-E- 2                Sapport co ponents l
       ~2.6      C-E- 2                Sapport co ponents l
I Purps Volunetric
I Purps Volunetric 23.1      C-F,0-G                Pa p casing welds Visual and either 03.2                C-D        Pressare-retaintry bolting                                                                surface or volunetric Surface 03..          -E-1                Integrally-welded sappo 3 Visual C1.4      0-E-2                  Suoport corponents
"
                                                                                   ' 1ves 04.1      C-F.C-C                No corponents w. thin this category Pressure-retaining bolting                                                                Visual and either 04.2                C-D                                                                                                  surf ace or volumetric Surface 04.1      C-E-1                  Integrally-welded supports Visual C4.4      C-E-2                  Sup; ort ccrponents 1 Class 2 Ccrponents (subject to the exe@ tion criteri". of IW.1220)                        Visual
23.1      C-F,0-G                Pa p casing welds Visual and either
,
03.2                C-D        Pressare-retaintry bolting                                                                surface or volunetric Surface
'
03..          -E-1                Integrally-welded sappo 3 Visual C1.4      0-E-2                  Suoport corponents
                                                                                   ' 1ves
                                                                                  -
                                                                                                                                              -
04.1      C-F.C-C                No corponents w. thin this category Pressure-retaining bolting                                                                Visual and either 04.2                C-D                                                                                                  surf ace or volumetric Surface 04.1      C-E-1                  Integrally-welded supports Visual C4.4      C-E-2                  Sup; ort ccrponents 1 Class 2 Ccrponents (subject to the exe@ tion criteri". of IW.1220)                        Visual
                                           - marging Safety In]ection Pa.ps 21, 22 and 23
                                           - marging Safety In]ection Pa.ps 21, 22 and 23
                                           - No. 2 Reactor Coolant Filter 1
                                           - No. 2 Reactor Coolant Filter 1
Line 615: Line 344:
                                           - Nfueling Water Storage Tank Heating Rectrc. Parp
                                           - Nfueling Water Storage Tank Heating Rectrc. Parp
                                           - Cantatn ent Tray Pupnps 21 and 22
                                           - Cantatn ent Tray Pupnps 21 and 22
                                             - Stearn Generators 21, 22, 23 and 24 (Shell Sidel
                                             - Stearn Generators 21, 22, 23 and 24 (Shell Sidel l
                                                                                                                                                              ,
l h , . '. 4 ~ ,
l l
h , . '. 4 ~ ,
                 .., . _ . - .-    _          , . _ - . . _ . .        - - , -            . - . _ _ _ . . _ . . ,,, . . ~ __    _ . _ , . . . . , . . , ,
                 .., . _ . - .-    _          , . _ - . . _ . .        - - , -            . - . _ _ _ . . _ . . ,,, . . ~ __    _ . _ , . . . . , . . , ,


             .              .          -                                .      -                . ~
             .              .          -                                .      -                . ~
          '
                                                                      .
    *
      .
   -o  -
   -o  -
!
TABLE 3 CLASS 3 COMPONENTS Examination In Accordance With IWD-2400 (Visual) i Reactor Coolant System Pressurizer Relief Tank Chilled Water System
TABLE 3 CLASS 3 COMPONENTS
,
              .
Examination In Accordance With IWD-2400 (Visual) i Reactor Coolant System Pressurizer Relief Tank Chilled Water System
: 1.      Chillers #21, 22 and 23
: 1.      Chillers #21, 22 and 23
: 2.      Chilled Water Strainers
: 2.      Chilled Water Strainers
Line 657: Line 376:
: 7.      No. 2 Ion Exchange Filter l
: 7.      No. 2 Ion Exchange Filter l
: 8.      Evaporator Feed Ion Exchangers 21, 22, 23 and 241
: 8.      Evaporator Feed Ion Exchangers 21, 22, 23 and 241
: 9.      Gas Stripper and Boric Acid Evaporator Package &l2
: 9.      Gas Stripper and Boric Acid Evaporator Package &l2 I
!
Footnotes,      1, 2 and 3 - See Page 4 I              P8035/ 04 9
I Footnotes,      1, 2 and 3 - See Page 4 I              P8035/ 04 9
                            .          _ . _ _ _ . . _ - , _ .        - - - . _ . _ , _ _ _ _    . _ _ _ _ . . _ .._ _ . _ _


                .
d 7
d
          .
        -
        .
7
    .:
i    ,.
i    ,.
TABLE 3 (CONTINUED)
TABLE 3 (CONTINUED)
* Chemical Volume & Control - Primary Water Recovery
Chemical Volume & Control - Primary Water Recovery
                  -
: 1. Monitor Tanks 21 and 22 1                                    l
: 1. Monitor Tanks 21 and 22 1                                    l
: 2. No. 2PrimaryWaterStorageJank
: 2. No. 2PrimaryWaterStorageJank
Line 691: Line 401:
;
;
: 7. No. 2 Reagent Tank j                        8. Laundry and Hot Shower Tank 21 and 22
: 7. No. 2 Reagent Tank j                        8. Laundry and Hot Shower Tank 21 and 22
'
: 9. No. 2 Chemical Drain Tank
: 9. No. 2 Chemical Drain Tank
: 10. Reactor Coolant Drain Pumps
: 10. Reactor Coolant Drain Pumps
Line 701: Line 410:
: 16. Waste Disposal Filter
: 16. Waste Disposal Filter
: 17. No. 2 Waste Evapora' tor
: 17. No. 2 Waste Evapora' tor
,
'                  Footnotes 1, 2 and 3 - See Page 4 P8035/04 10                          Page.2
'                  Footnotes 1, 2 and 3 - See Page 4 P8035/04 10                          Page.2
:
             - .            - - . . -      . . ~ - - --        . . . . . - . . -- . . - . . - ,- - - . - - . - , .
             - .            - - . . -      . . ~ - - --        . . . . . - . . -- . . - . . - ,- - - . - - . - , .


      .
e TABLE 3 (CONTINUED)
    '
                                                                                                          ,
e
  , .
TABLE 3 (CONTINUED)
Sampling
Sampling
: 1. Volume Control Tank Sample vessel l
: 1. Volume Control Tank Sample vessel l
          -
: 2. Boron Sample Tank l
: 2. Boron Sample Tank l
                           ' Pressurizer Steam Sample Vessel l
                           ' Pressurizer Steam Sample Vessel l 3.
,
3.
l
l
: 4. Pressurizer Liquid Sampie Vesgel
: 4. Pressurizer Liquid Sampie Vesgel
Line 746: Line 445:
: 1. Service Water Pumps 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 and 26
: 1. Service Water Pumps 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 and 26
: 2. Service Water Pump Strainers 21, 2 2,          23, 24, 25 and 261
: 2. Service Water Pump Strainers 21, 2 2,          23, 24, 25 and 261
: 3. Service Water Intake Sump Pumps
: 3. Service Water Intake Sump Pumps Footnotes 1,.2 and 3 - See Page 4                                                            i
,
Footnotes 1,.2 and 3 - See Page 4                                                            i
                                                                                                          !
"
             -P8035/04 11                            Page 3                                              j
             -P8035/04 11                            Page 3                                              j
__            _ , ..___ _ . .
      ,
_
_    _                              -.          _ _ _
                                                                            . - - _  . __  . _ . . . _ _


                  . _ . .          . _                    .,.-                                _ . _ .  .              _ . . .                                      ,
              '
    >
      ,
!*      .
Footnote #1    Designed to.1968 Edition ASME Section III Class C - Classified Nuclear Class 3-in accordance with NRC Regulatory Guide 1.26.
Footnote #1    Designed to.1968 Edition ASME Section III Class C - Classified Nuclear Class 3-in accordance with NRC Regulatory Guide 1.26.
Footnote #2    Designed to 1968 Edition ASME Section VIII -
Footnote #2    Designed to 1968 Edition ASME Section VIII -
Classified Nuclear Class 3-in accordance with
Classified Nuclear Class 3-in accordance with
                                               ~
                                               ~
                           '              the 1970 Winter Addenda of ASME Section III,
                           '              the 1970 Winter Addenda of ASME Section III, and NRC Regulatory Guide 1.26.
,
Footnote- # 3 - Designed to' the 1968 ASME Pump and Valve Code-1                                          Classified Nuclear Class 3 in accordance with NRC P99ulatory Guide 1.26.
and NRC Regulatory Guide 1.26.
I l
Footnote- # 3 - Designed to' the 1968 ASME Pump and Valve Code-1                                          Classified Nuclear Class 3 in accordance with
t 1
'
l i
NRC P99ulatory Guide 1.26.
-
,
I
I
,
l t
1 l
i I
)
)
.
F P8035/04 12                                                  Page 4 i
!
.
F
'
P8035/04 12                                                  Page 4 i
t t
t t
       .-__._._..._2                            - - - . _ , - _ , . . . . _ . . . . . _ _ _ _ .        . _ - - . . _ ,        , , _ _ , . _ , . . _ _ . . _ . . - - _ , _ . -}}
       .-__._._..._2                            - - - . _ , - _ , . . . . _ . . . . . _ _ _ _ .        . _ - - . . _ ,        , , _ _ , . _ , . . _ _ . . _ . . - - _ , _ . -}}

Revision as of 05:12, 31 January 2020

Inservice Insp Program
ML19345A806
Person / Time
Site: Salem PSEG icon.png
Issue date: 10/29/1980
From:
Public Service Enterprise Group
To:
Shared Package
ML18085A270 List:
References
NUDOCS 8011250238
Download: ML19345A806 (26)


Text

.

INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM UNIT 2 SALEM GENERATING STATION INTRODUCTION:

Commencing with the date of Commercial Operation, and for the duration of first 120 month inspection interval, the Inservice Inspection Program for Class 1, 2 and 3 components and systems is based on Section XI of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, 1974 Edition and Addenda through Summer 1975.Section XI requirements are augmented by cer-tain special requirements as defined in the Salem Unit No. 2 Technical Specifications, Sections 4.4.5.0, 4.4.10.1 and 4.4.10.2 for examination of steam generator tubing, reactor coolant pump flywheels and steam generator channel head cladding.

Repairs in the pressure retaining bcundary of systems and components falling within the scope of this program will be made in accordance with Division 1 of Section XI, or, if such repairs are not specified in Division 1, repairs will be made in accordance with the provisions of the Code appli-cab 1C to the construction of the component.

SCOPE:

Class 1, 2, and 3 components and the methods of examination for each component are listed in Tables 1, 2 and 3 respec-tively. Examination boundaries are defined on modified system piping diagrams entitled "ISI Boundary Diagrams" in Attachment 2. The schedule for examination of specific components is described in the long term inservice examination plan.

REQUEST FOR RELIEF:

Relief is requested from certain requirements of Section XI that hav3 been determined to be impractical because of accessiblity and design limitations established prior to issuance of the 1974 edition of the Code, and for other con-siderations. These requirements and the affected components are itemized in Attachment 1. In some cases, alternate means of testing are described. It is the position of PSE&G that the relief will not compromise the integrity of safety related components.

RFB:az LP4 la 8011e5023T

ATTACHMENT 1 ITEM 3 FOR WHICH RELIEF IS REQUESTED

1. . Bolts in Category B-G-1, except as-many as four bolts in each of four reactor coolant pumps, will be examined

' ultrasonically in place during the inspection interval. Those bolts which are inaccessible due to interference from structural members and piping will be examined at or near the end of the inspection interval All when the pumps are disassembled for maintenance.

bolts in Category B-G-2 will be e xamined visually during the inspection interval. If visual examination i

reveals indications of distress, the bolts will be removed for surface and/or volumetric examination.

2. Ultrasonic indications will be recorded at 50% of 3

reference level (DAC) unless suspected by the examiner to be other than geometric in origin, in which case

they will be recorded and investigated by a Level II or Level III Examiner if in excess of 20% of DAC. All indications above 100% DAC will be resolved as to their shape and identity by a Level II or Level III Examiner.

l Justification for departure from a 20% reference level evaluation criterion for all UT examinations is explained in detail in Attachment lA, prepared by i

Southwes" Research Institute as agents for PSE&G.

3. Ultrasonic examination of ferritic piping will be per-formed in accordcnce with Article 5 of Secti'n V of the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code with the exception  ;

that all indications will be recorded and evaluated as indicated in paragraph 2 above.

i- 4. Inaccessibililty for examination was identified during

' the Preservice Inspection and has been described in the

! Remarks column of Tables 1 and 2 of the SalemThose No. 2 Preoperational Baseline Examination Report.

items which could not be examined due to inaccessi-

' bility have been extracted from these tables and compiled into an abbreviated table which has been included as Attachment 1B for convenient reference.

Comments in these tables are necessarily brief.

4 I

P8023/05 01 Page 1 of 2

. _ . , _s., . -- . , . . . _ . . . , _ . _ , . . .___ . . , , _ , , , . . . ,,. .- . _ ., -, ,_, ,,, - .

d ATTACHMENT l-(CONT'D)

Information in greater detail has been provided in the >

way of additional comments, also included as part of Attachment IC. Consideration of alternate methods are discussed and in some cases sketches are attached for greater clarity.

5. Welds having limited ultrasonic examinations are treated in the same manner and are' included in the -

tables and comments mentioned above. No distinction is 1

made between items having no accessibility and limited ,

i inspectability except in the nature of the comment.  ;

Detailed radiographic procedures for augmented or alternative examinations will be prepared at such time as the need arises in order to take advantage of the possibility of more advanced technology at that time. I

6. The holding time after pressurization and prior to commencement of visual examinations during pressure tests required by IWA 5000 of Section XI will be 10 minutes when insulation is removed. This procedure is presently specified in recently approved editions of Section XI and is considered acceptable practice for an exposed pressure boundary. The longer holding time required by the 1974 Edition of Section XI ecesents unnecessary exposure to radiation in an operating plant.

't RFB: pac 7-16-80 P8023/05 01/02 Page 2 of 2 i

I i

l I

_ . . . . . = - .

ATTACHMENT 1A

Title:

Comments Concerning the 20 Percent Versus 100 Percent Evaluation Level for Ultrasonic Examination of Nuclear Power Plant Piping Introduction I. The Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) has asked several plant owners for detailed information to justify two things.

A. That a 20% reference level evaluation criterion is impractical and B. That a 100% reference level evaluation criterion will provide a level of safety comparable to the Section V code requirements (of evaluation at 20%).

D,iscussion II. Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) presents the following considerations on these two closely related questions, taking them in order:

A. The impracticality of recording / evaluation at 4

the 20% reference level.,

l 1. The welded joints in nuclear piping f requently contain code-allowable wall '

i thickness differences (12-1/2% of thickness) as well as allowable weld l' _.

'dropthrough and other conditions such as counterbore taper, crown, etc. These conditions can provide an extremely large

, number of geometric reflectors (with or without mode conversion) which produce ultrasonic examination (UT) indications greater than 2C% of the UT reference level (DAC) (see attached graph). Weld metal in stainless steel piping contains, in addition, reflectors due to metallurgical grain structure which can l

l also produce indications greater than 20%

i Attachment lA Page 1 of 9 P8035/05 1 I

_ .. . _ , _ __ , , . . , , . . . _ . _ - , . , _ . . _ . , . - _ . , _ . - _ . , _ _ , . - _ _ ~ . . ,

DAC. It appears that the incidence of geometric reflectors increases exponentially as the amplitude is reduced.

. 2. Two stress-corrosion cracks are known to have been missed by SWRI normal examination techniques. However, they were not missed because of lack of

' detectability; indications of 141% and 159% DAC were obtained from these stress-corrosion cracks in'the HAZ. They were'not identified because of thr2 large i

4 number of equally high amplitude geometric indications from the adjacent i root area-which, in effect, masked the test-data to preclude identifying these cracks. Reducing the recording level to i

20% will cause this problem to exist on a much larger scale in that the tremendous increase in ' recorded indication data will obscure real flaw indications. .

3. During the performance of inservice inspections, significant radiation

. exposure is being experienced by all the inservice examination personnel. In SwRI's experience the examination staff receives essentially all of the legally allowed radiation exposure when recording 50% DAC data. To evaluate and record 20%

data would require that the personnel spend several times as much time in a radiation area to obtain additional ultrasonic data which is not practically decipherable and would require a proportional increase in radiation 4

exposure to the available examination personnel. Therefore, these personnel would not be available for the performance of ultrasonic examinations of as many lines or at as many sites.

Necessarily, this would force the industry to reduce the sampling rate of examinations because of the inavailability of trained personnel. The Attachment lA Page 2 of 9

. P8035/05 2

_ _ . . . - _ . . , , - . - - ~ - - - - . ._. - - - _ . _ . - . - . . - . _ . _ . - - - , , -

reduction of sample size would have a detrimental effect on the monitoring of plant integrity through inservice inspection and would eliminate the non-mandatory examinations presently

- performed by the utilities in the interest of promptly examining known or suspected problem areas.

4. A typical example of the impracticality of the 20% level recording / evaluation practice involved the examination of the 4" Recirculation Bypass lines in a nuclear power plant. The job required both 45-degree and 60-degree angle-beam examinations on one or both side of 20 pipe welds having a total of 450 inches of weld examination length. To demonstrate the impact of the 20%

recording criteria to the utility, a small sample of a randomly selected weld was examined. Because of radiation levels, the demonstration was limited to one hour. In that hour, 15 separate indications were recorded with the 60-degree examination in 5/8-inch of weld length while 10 indications were recorded with the 45-degree examination in 1-7/8 inches of weld length. Only maximum amplitude positions were recorded and most indications of 20% DAC and greater were recorded. It is recognized that this was a very small sample , but it is believed to be typical of 4" bypass line welds. The three-man crew successfully completed the examinations recording at the 50% level within the one-day of examination time available on the unit.

Evaluation time would have been increased proportionately with dubious conclusions due to the sheer volume of data. The welds were judged to be f ree of cracks based on the 50% DAC recording and 100%

evaluation criteria and several months of successful operation without leaking Attachment lA Page 3 of 9 P8035/05 3 i

1

9 confir. sed that these examinations, like those performed at several other sites, were effective.

B. Evaluation at 100% and greater provides

- equivalent safety _ _

l. Equivalent safety, comparable to code
  • requirements, is assured by the recording / evaluation criteria developed, refined, and qualified by SwRI through many years of research and experience.

This criteria is embodied in current SwRI practice, which requires that:

(a) All indications 50% of DAC or greater shall be recorded.

(b) All indications 100% of DAC or greater shall be investigated by a Level II or Level III operator to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location of the reflectors.

(c) Any indication 20% of DAC or greater and suspected by the operator to be other than geometric in nature, including all 20% or greater indications originating in the base metal, shall be recorded and investigated by a Leval II or Level III examiner to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location.of the reflector.

  • It must be noted that the 100% evaluation criteria was (and is) the Code requirement for utilities commited to the 1971 Edition of Section XI (S71 Addenda). The inconsistency arose when the 1974 Edition of Section XI incorporated Section V by reference. In the. Summer of 1976 Edition (IWA-2232) the ASME has reconfirmed its previous position by clearly requiring evaluation of only indications of 100% DAC or greater.

Attachment lA Page 4 of 9 P8035/05 4

(d) Any indications investigated and

' found to be other than geometric in nature shall be reported to the owner for evaluation and disposition.

SwRI's long-standing requirement to record 50% DAC information reflects the necessity to record a sublevel of data below that point at which we feel a concern. The prime reason for recording this information is to allow for the known variation in reproducibility of i test data. We have shown data reproducibility to be a factor caused by many thing including operator experience, training, procedure, equipment

variations, environmental encumberances,

' test piece conditions, calibration standards, etc. These facators are i routine and will continue to occur during the application of examinations of this nature on piping. This practice is belived to be more conservative than the

-intent of any editior. of the Code and to provide greater safety.at less cost in time, dollars, and radiation exposure to personnel than simply requiring the recording / evaluation of all 20% DAC data.

2. The adequacy of this practice is supported by the follosing:

(a) Except f or a very limited number of applications of the 20% evaluation level criteria of Paragraph IX-3470 of the 1971 issue of Section III, the 100% reference level evaluation ,

criteria of Paragraph IS-213.5 of the Summer 1971 Addenda to Section XI was in effect until ' the adoption in late 1976 of the 1974 Edition of Section XI. The 100% recording criteria was endorsed by the Section V Subcommittee for Nondestructive Examination in a Attachment lA Page 5 of 9 P8035/05 5

- ,---, - - v---.

.v Code Inquiry of 1973, and appeared in Paragraph T-544 of the 1974 Edition of Section v. There is no question of the overall success of the inservice examination program

- during.these many years, and the I

100% evaluation criteria was reconfirmed by ASME in' Paragraph IWA-2232 of the Summer 1976 Addenda to the Section XI code. .

(b) As a result of the different failure mode of austenitic piping (noted in Paragraph (d) below) SwRI had developed modified approaches in procedure to maintain assurance of maximum crack detection sensitivity. Search unit size, frequency and beam angle, as well as procedure, are optimized to take advantage of the known parameters of the type of f ailure to be detected and investigated in different situations.

(c) While it has been demonstrated that j- significantly deep through-wall stress-corrosion cracking may give l

only a low amplitude response, it a

has been demonstrated by SwRI on

multiple plants that the 100%

evaluation criteria, augmented by 4 operator investigation at the 20%

level, can be applied with satisfactory results:

i (1) No component or pipe examined by SwRI has experienced leaking by way of a stress-corrosion crack between the periodic a ;aminations.

(2) At least 48 piping cracks have been found and repaired

)~ in the early stages of propagation.

Attachment lA Page 6 of 9 P8035/05 6

+ - - - - - _, , _ _ _ _ _ _ ., __,_. . . _ , - _ . _ . , ,I

(d) Much experience has shown that the typical mode of f ailure in stainless steel piping is not in the weld metal, per se, but is

" stress-corrosion cracking" in the adjacent heat-affected zone (HAZ) and base metal. A trained UT operator can distinguish the dif ference between the usual weld-metal geometric indications and the somewhat similar indictions due to stress-corrosion cracking by noting their location in the base metal of HAZ. This is true even when their amplitude is in the 20%

to 50% range and even though indications in this range originating in the weld metal cannot be identified.

(e) A prime example of the adequacy of the total SwRI examination technique is th a t Recirculation Bypass lines have been ultrasonically examined in accordance with RO Bulletin 74-10 in six nuclear power plants.

Thirteen cracks were found in four plants and the findings were confirmed by other methods, including excavation, in all cases. As noted above, no component or pipe examined by SwRI has experienced leaking by way of stress-corrosion cracking between periodic examinations.

Summary and Conclusions III. For the reasons enumerated above, SwRI recommends to its clients that, in the interests ot maintaising maximum nuclear power plant integrity and safety at minimum cost in time and personnel radiation exposure, and efforc to institute a blanket 20% DAC recording / evaluation criteria be i

I l

l l

Attachment lA Page 7 of 9 P8035/05 7 l l

,i  !

4 resisted. Instead, SwRI recommends a commitment to the SwRI recording / evaluation practice which was set out in Paragraph B.1 above and is reinterated below:

(a) All indications 50% of DAC or greater shall be recorded.

(b) All indications 100% of DAC or greater shall be investigated by a Level II or l

Level III operator to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location of the reflectors.

(c) Any indication 20% of DAC or greater suspected by the operator to be other than geometric in nature, including all 20% or greater indications originating in the base metal, shall be recorded and investigated by a Level II or. Level III examiner to the extent necessary to determine the shape, identity, and location of the reflector.

(d) Any 171.ications investigated and found to be o'ber than geometric in nature shall be reported to the owner for evaluation and disposition.

Attachment lA Page 8 of 9 P8035/05.8 i

1 l

-- , , . , . , . , ~ . _ . - - , . - - _ _ _ . . - . .

4500- __

43o0- Baco on A TY Pl CAL ULTR.A50M t C 4'co : 9avey on EX AM i M A.Tl O W R.ESULTL S'co- bvn IL FO R. c.LA55 l PJ PI NG 3700; gggg,gggg, O

3500- c it, 30 Tages

~

g 3300-

<f 3 goo _ AS MANV U

6 2')oo - IN DicAT8045 2700-W I L t. BE to 2500 -

O FoveJD IM lilE 23M cl un p: 20*/o To 60'7.

m i90o. 12AdqE THA;J

) 1 loo - Tilli lofAL ___

7} e600; ta u m gg e R. O F _ _

33 O T opl CATIOtl$ -

1100 s3OO- _ _

10 0 -

500 300 ~ _

soo ' ' '

o*'2'* l 4D* 60 do goo IZD 16 0 200 1S0 380 450' boo' 650 750 1000 PER. CENT OF DAC 1

2

  • 14 0 R EColz DE D D ATA AVAIL A t$L E FOR l'A H,u L Ar t O N . _ o _ , , ,

ATTACHMENT 1C DETAILED EXPLANATION OF EXCEPTIONS TO THE ASME BOILER AND PRESSURE VESSEL CODE

- SECTION XI FOR THE SALEM UNIT NO. 2 INSERVICE INSPECTION PROGRAM Item Bl.2 Category B-B Closure Head Peel Segmen*-To-Disc Circumferential Weld l

Volumetric examination will not be performed on this weld due to inaccessibility. A visual examination for leaks will be performed during pressure tests required by Section XI. This weld is identified as 2-RPVCH-6446 B in the examination plan.

As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-9-77 attached, this weld is located within the area covered by the Control Rod Drive Penetrations. This location prevents access to the weld for any type of volumetric or surface examination from either the inside or outside surface of the closure head. To gain access would required re-moving and re-installing numerous Control Rod Drive penetration tubes.

Bottom Head Peel Segment-To-Disc Circumferential Weld Volumetric examination will not be performed on this weld due to inaccessibility. A visual examination for leaks will be performed during pressure tests required by Section XI. Tnis weld is identified as 2-RPV-3443 in the examination plan.

As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-9-77 attached, this '

weld is located within the area covered by the instrumentation tube penetrations. This location prevents access to the weld for any type of volumetric or surf ace examination f rom either the inside or out-side surface of the bottom head. To gain access would

~

require removing and re-installing numerous instrumen-tation tubes.

i i

P802304 01 Page 1 of 5 i

, , . . , . - .- ,_ .--~, , .. ,. . . . , , _ , _ - -

' ATTACHMENT-lC (CONT'D) 4 I t e m B'. . Category B-D~

Reactor Vessel Inlet Nozzle to Shell Welds Vo.ametric examination will not be performed when the Core Barrel is in' place due to inaccessibility. The examinations will be performed when the core barrel is removed during the inspection interval. These welds are identified.as 27.5-RCN-1210, 27.5-RCN-1220, 27.5-RCN-1230, and 27.5-RCN-1240 in the examination l plan.

As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-15-77 attached, the Core Barrel covers the weld area when it is in place.

Since all weld examinations are performed from the inside surface using a mechanized inspection device, these welds are inaccessible at this time. Examina-tions cannot be performed from the outside surface due to the area being covered by insulation on the shell of the weld and the configuration of the weld joint on the nozzle side'of the weld. The insulation on the shell portion of the- reactor vessel is not designed for removability and to remove-it would. require the cutting away of the insulation support rings f rom the vessel.

T Since the Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval, and ASME Code Case N-73 (1647) allows these examinations to be deferred toithe end of each inspection interval, i t is PSE&G's position that the intent of the Code is being complied with.

T Reactor Vessel Outlet Nozzle to Shell Welds Volumetric examination will be performed with the Core Barrel in place except for the . examination of the

. Reactor Vessel base metal due to inaccessibility. The base metal will be examined when the Core Barrel is removed during the inspection interval. These welds are identified as 29-RCN-1210, 29-RCN-1220, i 29-RCN-1230, and 29-RCN-1240 in the examination plan. 1

}

l l

P802304 02 Page 2 of 5

, - .,m.. -

,-w me., ..e.-m,---. -

.-.m. ,,-e~,.v - v,

i l

ATTACHMENT 1C (CONT'D)

As indicated in PSE&G Sketch No. 8-16-77 attached, the Core Barrel covers the reactor vessel 'ase metal when it is in place. Since all weld examin. ions are per-formed from the inside surface using a: automated inspection device, these welds are inaccessible at this time. Examination cannot be performed from the out-sidesurface due to the area being covered by insulation which would require the. cutting away of the insulation support rings to remove.

Since the Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval, and ASME Code Case N-73 (1647) allows these examinations to be deferred to the end of each inspection interval, it is PSE&G's position that the intent of the Code is being complied with.

Item Bl.14 Category B-I-l Reactor Vessel Cladding Visual examination will not be performed on the Reactor vessel Shell Cladding when the Core Barrel is in place due to inaccessibility. The patches of cladding to be examined are identified as 2-RPV-Patch-1, 2-RPV-Patch-2, 2-RPV-Patch- 3, 2-RPV-Patch-4, 2-RPV-Patch-5, and2-RPV-Patch-6 in the examination plan.

Since this examination can only be performed from the inside surface of the reactor vessel shell, the exami-nation can only be performed when the Core Barrel is removed. The Core Barrel is scheduled to be removed at or near the end of the inspection interval.

Item B4.5 Category 3-J Reactor Coolant Loop Piping Longitudinal Welds Volumetric examinations will not be performed on the longitudinal welds in the Reactor Coolant piping elbows.- Surface examinations will be performed as well as a visual examination for leaks required by Section i

1 P802304 03 Page 3 of 5

1

' ATTACHMENT IC (CONT'D)

- XI. These welds are identified in the examination plan as the LU-1, LU-0, LD-1, and LD-0 welds'on lines 31-RC-1240,31-RC-1230, 31-RC-1220, 31-RC-1210, 29-RC-1240, 29-RC-1230, 29-RC-1220, and 29-RC-1210.

The Reactor Coolant loop elbows are made of cast stain-less steel which cannot be penetrated by ultrasonic examination ' anniques. Also,. acceptable radiographs

' cannot be obtained by present techniques due to fogging of the film caused. by long exposure time coupled with background radiation from the reactor coolant piping.

Radiography will be considered as new techniques are developed that would make it possible to examine these welds in the future.

Reactor Coolant Loop' Piping Circumferential Welds volumetric examination on.eight reactor coolant loop piping wilds will oe limited during inservice These welds are inspection due to restricted access.

identified as 31-RC-1210-5 and 6, 31-RC-1220-5 and 6, 31-RC-1230-5 and 6, and 31-RC-1240-5 and 6 in the examination plan.

Due to anti-whip restraints that were installed after the preservice examination was completed, portions of these circumferential welds are inaccessible for inservice examination.

Item B5.6 Category B-L-1 Reactor Coolant Pump Casing Welds A visual examination for leaks will be performed.

The Reactor Coolant Pump casings are made of cast stainless steel which cannot be penetrated by ultra-sonic examination techniques. Also, acceptable radio-graphs cannot be obtained due to fogging of the film i

4 P802304 04 Page 4 of 5 l

- , . - ,- - ,, ,- , - . , . - . ~ . , -. -

ATTACH"ENT 1C ( CO"~ ~ .,

caused by long exposure time coupled with background radiation from the pump casing. Radiography will be considered as new techniques are developed to examine these welds in the future.

RFB: pac 7-16-80 P802304 05 Page 5 of 5

k 4

4 I

Attachment 2 ISI Boundary Diagrams Sy.s tems

1. Reactor Coolant 249825 - A - 1777 1
2. -Steam Generator Feed & Condensate 249826 - A - 1777
3. MainLReheat and' Turbine By-Pass Steam 249827 - A - 1777 1
4. Chilled Water 241828 - A - 1568
5. - Fire Protection 241829 - A - 1568 Y
6. Steam Generator Drains & Blowdown 249830 - A - 1777 7.- Chemical &. Volume Cvntrol - Operation 249831 - A - 1777
8. Chemical & Volume Control - 2 4 9 8 3 2 - A -- 1777 i

Boric Acid Recovery J 9. Chemical & Volume Control - 249833 - A - 1777 Primary Water Recovery

10. Component Cooling 249834 - A - 1777 d
11. Residual Heat Removal 249835 - A - 1777

> 12. Spent Fuel Cooling 249836 - A - 1777

13. Safety. Injection 249837 - A - 1777
14. Containme's Spray 249838 - A - 1777
15. Auxiliary Feed Water 249839 - A - 1777
16. Waste Disposal-Liquid 24-9840 - A - 1777

., 17. Service Water 249841 - A - 1777

18. Sa mpling 249842 - A - 1777
19. Demineralized Water - Restricted Areas 241843 - A - 1568 20, Waste Disposal Solid 241844 - A - 1568 a

NM:az 1 LB1 1-B i

TMM 1

, CIASS A (DMPCNDf!S, PARTS AND E8TODS OF EXAMINATION Examination Category Method d

IMm Table

' No. Fa3-2500 Cb @onents and Parts to be Examined t

Ikactor Vetsel Volum tric B-A Longitudinal and circumferential shell welds in mre region Bl.1 Volumtric Bl .2 ' B-B Iontitudinal and circumferential welds in shell (other than those of Category B-A and B-C) and meridional and circun:ferential seam welds in bottom head and closure Volunetric Vessel-to-flange and head-to-flange circunferential welds 81.3 B< Volumetric Prinary nozzle-to-vessel welds and nozzle inside radiused secticr Bl.6 B-D Visual (IWA-5000)

Vessel penetrations, including entrol rod drive and instrumntation Bl.5 B-E penetrations.

Voluretric and Surface Bl.6 B-F tbzzle-to-safe end welds Voluretric B+1 Closure studs, in place Bl.7 Volaretric and Surface B+1 Closure studs with nuts, when removed 81.8 Volumetric B+1 I.igamnts between threaded stud holes Bl.9 Visual Closure washers, bushings

, Bl.10 B-G-1 _

B1.11 B+2 tb ccrponents within this category Bl.12 B-H No corponents within this category

1) Visual and Surface Closure Head claddin; Or Bl.13 B-I-l
2) Volumetric 4

Visual Vessel Cladding Bl.14 B-I-l Visual 91.15 B-N-I Vessel Interior Visual S-N-2 Interior attach ents aM core su; mort structures 91.16 Visual Bl.17 B-N-3 Core-support structures Volu-etrtC N Control rod drive housings Bl.19 Visual (IWA-5000)

B-P Exerpted conponents 81.19 Pressurtzer Voluretric B2.1 B-B Iongitudinal and circumf erential welds 4

Volu etric B2.2 B-D Nozzle-to-vessel radiused section Visual (IWA-5000) 62.3 B-E teater penetrations Volumetric and Surface B2.4 B-F Nozzle-to-safe and welds B2.5 B+1 No cc:'ponents within this category B2.6 B+1 No mnpanents within this catecpry I B2." B+1 tu mnponents within this category B2.S B-H No corponents within this category Visual B-1-2 Vessel claMing Bl.9 Visual (IWA-5000)

B2.10 B-P Exerpted wrponents Visual B2.11 B+2 Pressare-retaining tolting P6235/s4 1/2

TABIE 1 CCNTDCED Examination Cate9oU ttv Tcle Method l

.. .IWB-2500 CoTonents and Parts to be Examined Steam Cenerators .

Nolumtric Iongitudinal and circumferential welds, including tube sheet-to-head

~

53.1 B-B or shell welds on the primary side Volumetric

'33.2 B-D tbzzle-tMead welds and nozzle inside radiused section on the

- primry side Volum tric and Surface Bi.) B-F No2zle-to-safe end welds

B).4 B-G-1 No awponents within this category 31.5 B-O- 1 No conponents within this category 31.6 B+1 No conponents within this category 7 51.7 B-G-1 No corponents within tnis ev.egory Vessel Cladding Visual 33.6 B-I-2 Visual (IWA-5000) 33.9- B-P Exe pted copnts Pressure-retaining boltirv3 Visual l 83.10 B G-2 Eddy Current 4.4.5.0* Tuoing

Vessel Clack 31ng (Steam Genenstor #24) Volumetric 4.4.10.2*

Piping Pressure Boundary Safe-erd to piping welds and safe-end in branch piping welds Volum tric and Surface

B4.1 B-F 34.; B-G-1 fu corponents within this category B4.3 IH'r-1 No ccTorents within this category 34.4 B-G-1 No corponents within this category Circrf erential and longitudinal pipe welds Voluretric 34.5 B-J Branch pipe connection welds exceeding six in. dia eter Volunetric B4;6 B-1

?

Branch pipe connection welds six in diareter and smiler Surface B4.- B-J S>cr,et welds Surface 34.: B-J Integrally welded supports Volunetric 34., B-r-1 Support corponents Visual

, B4.10 B-F-2 Exe pted corponents Visual-(IWA-5000)

B4.11 B-P Pressure-retaining bolting Visual B4.12 B+2 Reactor (bolant Pu@s Pressare-retaining bolts and studs, in place Voluretric S5.' B+1 Pressure-retaining bolts and studs, when removed Voluretric and Surface I B5.2- B-G-1 Pressure-retaining bolting Visual B5.; 3+1 Integrally-welded supports Volu.-etric 35.4 3-r-1.

i Unit 2

  • Salet Technical Spectficaticns i

l k hkwa 54 3'4 5

.p- .- -w - - - , m ,, . , - - . - , - ~ e. - . . - . . . - - - , - .-. --.---..-,--.-,-...,--,m y , y r,.

i-

  • TABIE 1 CDfrINUED

. Exa:raratton Cate'PC/ Method-Itet ~ 'Tasle Conponents and Parts to be Examined

' = m. rn3-2500 Visual B5.5' B-K-2 Support corponents Volunetric

,'- B5.6 B 'el.

Punp casing welds Visual

. B5.7 B *.e-2 . Parp casing Visual (IWA-5000) 85.9 B-P' ' Exenpted cx2nponents B5.9 B-G-2 . No components within this cate7xf volunetric and Surface ,

4.4.10.l* Purp Flywheel f

Valves B6.1 B ~,-1 tb coqxnents within this categorf B6.2 B-G-1 te mnponents within this categorf B6.3 ~-B-G-1 No corponents within this categorf l .

B6.4 B-K-1 te corponents within this categorf Visual i e6.5 B-K-2 Support corponents Visual B6.7 B-K-2 Valve tx231es Visual (IWA-5000) 1 B6.3 B-P Exe pted conponents Visual B-G-2 Pressure-retatnang bolting B6.9 Unit 2

  • Salem Technical Specification 4

I 1

4 s

d 1

W 4

I 4

1 PS025'0C 5/6 l-1 i

,m. . - . , - - . . , _ - , - . . _ _ _ . _ . . _ . . - . - . . . _ , , . , . . _ . . - , . - . , ~ , , - . , , .

, -_=____,,,_e-, . . . . , , , . . . . .

DBIE 3 t

  • CIASS a COMKNEN25, PAIUS, AND ME'IH006 OF CXAMDiATZCN Exan nation

. Category-Ite- Tsole Method

u. rad-2520 Conponents and Parts to be Examined Pressure Vessels '

Volumetric

! C1.1 C-A Circrferential butt welds Volumetric 01.2 C-9 tbzzle-tWessel welds Surface 0;.3 C-C Integrally-welded supports Visual and ei'her C1.4 C-D Pressare-retatning bolting surface or volretric I Piping Volmetric l C2.1 C-F,C-G Circumferential butt welds Volunetric 02.1 C-F,C-G Iongitudinal weld joints in fittings q

Volu:tetric  ;

C2.3 C-F,& G Branch pipe-t g ipe weld joints Visual and either C2.4 C-D Pressare-retaining bolting surf ace or volu:netric Surface C2.5 C-E-1 Integrally-welded supports 1

Visual

~2.6 C-E- 2 Sapport co ponents l

I Purps Volunetric 23.1 C-F,0-G Pa p casing welds Visual and either 03.2 C-D Pressare-retaintry bolting surface or volunetric Surface 03.. -E-1 Integrally-welded sappo 3 Visual C1.4 0-E-2 Suoport corponents

' 1ves 04.1 C-F.C-C No corponents w. thin this category Pressure-retaining bolting Visual and either 04.2 C-D surf ace or volumetric Surface 04.1 C-E-1 Integrally-welded supports Visual C4.4 C-E-2 Sup; ort ccrponents 1 Class 2 Ccrponents (subject to the exe@ tion criteri". of IW.1220) Visual

- marging Safety In]ection Pa.ps 21, 22 and 23

- No. 2 Reactor Coolant Filter 1

- No. 2 Excess Letdsn Heat Exchanger (Tube Stdel j

- No. 2 kgenerative Meet Exchanger

- No. 2 Letdcwn Heat Erchayr Ware Side)

Accumlators 21, 22, 23 and 24 l

Boron In]ection Tank l Refueling Water Tank '

Safety In]ection Purps 21 and 22

- RHR Heat Exchangers 21 and 22

- RHR Pa@ s 21 and 22

- cencal Volune and control Tank

- Head Tanks 21, 22, 23 ard 24

- Ref aeling Water Storage Tank Heat Exchanger

- Nfueling Water Storage Tank Heating Rectrc. Parp

- Cantatn ent Tray Pupnps 21 and 22

- Stearn Generators 21, 22, 23 and 24 (Shell Sidel l

l h , . '. 4 ~ ,

.., . _ . - .- _ , . _ - . . _ . . - - , - . - . _ _ _ . . _ . . ,,, . . ~ __ _ . _ , . . . . , . . , ,

. . - . - . ~

-o -

TABLE 3 CLASS 3 COMPONENTS Examination In Accordance With IWD-2400 (Visual) i Reactor Coolant System Pressurizer Relief Tank Chilled Water System

1. Chillers #21, 22 and 23
2. Chilled Water Strainers
3. No. 2 Expansion Tank i 4. Chilled Water Pumps Chemical Volume & Control - Ooerations
1. Resin Fill Tank 2
2. No. 2 Chemical Addition Tank 2
3. No. 2 Boric Acid Batching Tank 2
4. Boric Acid' Tanks 21 and 222 ,
5. Boric Acid Transfer Pumps 3

-6. Boric Acid Filterl

7. Seal Water Filterl
8. Seal Water Injection Filter 21 and 22 1
9. No. 2 Excess Letdown Heet Exchanger (Shel
10. Nc. 2LetdownHeatExchanjer(ShellSide)gSide)2
11. No. 2 Seal Water Heat Exchanger l
12. - Mixed Bed Demineralizers 21 and 22 1
13. Deborating Demineralizerg 21 and 22
14. Cation Bed Demineralizer
15. Boric Acid Blender 2 Chemical Volume & Control-Boric Acid Recoverv
1. Hold-up Tanks 21, 22 and 23 1
2. No. 2 Concentrates Holding Tank 2
3. No. 2 Hold-Up Tank Recirc. Pump 3
4. Gas Stripper Feed Pumps 21 and 22 3
5. Concentrates Holding Tank Transf er Pump 21 and 223 No. 2 Concentrates Filterl
7. No. 2 Ion Exchange Filter l
8. Evaporator Feed Ion Exchangers 21, 22, 23 and 241
9. Gas Stripper and Boric Acid Evaporator Package &l2 I

Footnotes, 1, 2 and 3 - See Page 4 I P8035/ 04 9

d 7

i ,.

TABLE 3 (CONTINUED)

Chemical Volume & Control - Primary Water Recovery

1. Monitor Tanks 21 and 22 1 l
2. No. 2PrimaryWaterStorageJank
3. Monitor Tank Pumps 21 and 22
4. Prinary Water Make-Up Pumps
5. Prin'.ry Water Storage Tank Heating Recirc. . Pu mp
6. No. 2 Distillate Filterl l 7. No. 2 Primary Water Storage Tank Heat Exchanger1 2
8. Evaporator Distillate Demineralizers 21 and 22 Containment' Spray

! 1. Spray Additive Tank l Auxiliary Feedwater

1. Auxiliary Feed Storage Tank l
2. Auxiliary Feed Pump 21 and 22 3
3. No. 2 Auxiliary Feedwater Storage Tank Heating-Water Circulator Pump
4. No. 2 Feedwater Storage Tank Heat Exchanger 2 Waste Disposal Liquid
1. Waste Monitor Tanks
2. No. 2 Reactor Coolant Drain Tank 3.. No. 2 Spent Resin Storage Tank l 4. Waste Monitor - Holdup Tank
5. Waste Holdup Tank 21 and 22-
6. Auxiliary Building Sump Tank
7. No. 2 Reagent Tank j 8. Laundry and Hot Shower Tank 21 and 22
9. No. 2 Chemical Drain Tank
10. Reactor Coolant Drain Pumps
11. Waste Monitor Tank Pumps
12. Waste Monitor Holdup Tank Pumps
13. Waste Evaporator Feed Pumps
14. No. 2 Laundry Pump i 15. No. 2 Chemical Drain Tank Pump
16. Waste Disposal Filter
17. No. 2 Waste Evapora' tor

' Footnotes 1, 2 and 3 - See Page 4 P8035/04 10 Page.2

- . - - . . - . . ~ - - -- . . . . . - . . -- . . - . . - ,- - - . - - . - , .

e TABLE 3 (CONTINUED)

Sampling

1. Volume Control Tank Sample vessel l
2. Boron Sample Tank l

' Pressurizer Steam Sample Vessel l 3.

l

4. Pressurizer Liquid Sampie Vesgel
5. Reactor Coolant Sample Vessel
6. Steam Generator Sample Heat Exchanger 21, 22, 23 and 241 l
7. Steam Generator Main Steam Sample Heat Exchanger l
8. Pressurizer Steam Sample Heat Exchanger l
9. Pressurizer Liquid Sample Heat Exchanger
10. Reactor Coolant Sample Heat Exchanger Waste 'sisposal Solid
1. No. 1 Seal Water Tank
2. Evaporator Bottoms Hold-up Tank
3. Evaporator Bottoms Trans. Pumps 1 and 2
4. Evaporator Bottoms Metering P.'mps 1 and 2
5. Resin Slurry Metering & Trans. Pumps 1 and 2
6. Waste Removal Pumps 1 and 2 Component Cooling
1. Component Cooling Surge Tank 2
2. Component Cooling Pumps 21, 22 and2 23
3. Component Cooling Heat Exchangers Spent Fuel Cooling a
1. Spent Fuel Pit Pumps 21 and 22
2. 9 pent Fuel Pit Skimmer Pump
3. Refueling Water Purification Pump
4. Spent Fuel Pit Skimmer l Filter
5. Spent Fuel Pit Filter
6. Refueling Water Purification Filter l

! 7. Spent Fuel Pit Heat Exchanger l

8. No. 2 Spent Fuel Pit Demineralizer l Service Water I
1. Service Water Pumps 21, 22, 23, 24, 25 and 26
2. Service Water Pump Strainers 21, 2 2, 23, 24, 25 and 261
3. Service Water Intake Sump Pumps Footnotes 1,.2 and 3 - See Page 4 i

-P8035/04 11 Page 3 j

Footnote #1 Designed to.1968 Edition ASME Section III Class C - Classified Nuclear Class 3-in accordance with NRC Regulatory Guide 1.26.

Footnote #2 Designed to 1968 Edition ASME Section VIII -

Classified Nuclear Class 3-in accordance with

~

' the 1970 Winter Addenda of ASME Section III, and NRC Regulatory Guide 1.26.

Footnote- # 3 - Designed to' the 1968 ASME Pump and Valve Code-1 Classified Nuclear Class 3 in accordance with NRC P99ulatory Guide 1.26.

I l

t 1

l i

I

)

F P8035/04 12 Page 4 i

t t

.-__._._..._2 - - - . _ , - _ , . . . . _ . . . . . _ _ _ _ . . _ - - . . _ , , , _ _ , . _ , . . _ _ . . _ . . - - _ , _ . -