ML070320457: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 16: Line 16:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:[John Hickman -RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports .Pag 1]From: "Alice Carson" <acarsonl967@comcast.net>.
{{#Wiki_filter:[John Hickman   - RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports     .Pag 1]
To: "'John Hickman"'  
From:               "Alice Carson" <acarsonl967@comcast.net>.
<JBH@nrc.gov>, <thy@nrc.gov>
To:                 "'John Hickman"' <JBH@nrc.gov>, <thy@nrc.gov>
Date: 12/27/2006 11:10:57 AM  
Date:               12/27/2006 11:10:57 AM


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports John/Tom, It was just brought to my attention that there was a typographical error in Section 5.1.4 of the FSSR for OOL-14. The report, and the quote from the report included in the response provided to you earlier this morning, erroneously reference OOL-14-04, instead of OOL-14-01.
RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports John/Tom, It was just brought to my attention that there was a typographical error in Section 5.1.4 of the FSSR for OOL-14. The report, and the quote from the report included in the response provided to you earlier this morning, erroneously reference OOL-14-04, instead of OOL-14-01. The attached response has been revised to acknowledge this error.
The attached response has been revised to acknowledge this error.Alice Carson----- Original Message -----From: Alice Carson [mailto:acarsonl967@comcast.net]
Alice Carson
Sent: Wednesday, December 27, 2006 10:47 AM To: 'John Hickman';  
              ----- Original Message -----
'thy@nrc.gov' Cc: 'Greg Babineau';  
From: Alice Carson [mailto:acarsonl967@comcast.net]
'Marty Erickson';  
Sent: Wednesday, December 27, 2006 10:47 AM To: 'John Hickman'; 'thy@nrc.gov' Cc: 'Greg Babineau'; 'Marty Erickson'; 'Joe Bourassa'; 'Gerard P. Van Noordennen'
'Joe Bourassa';  
'Gerard P. Van Noordennen'


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports John/Tom, Attached are responses to the questions/comments on OOL-12 and OOL-14, which were previously provided to Yankee via email on 12/20/06.
RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports John/Tom, Attached are responses to the questions/comments on OOL-12 and OOL-14, which were previously provided to Yankee via email on 12/20/06. If you have any questions, please give me a call.
If you have any questions, please give me a call.Alice Carson OOL-12 Observations/Comments:
Alice Carson OOL-12 Observations/Comments:
FSS Report Appendix A -Final Status Survey Planning Worksheets  
FSS Report Appendix A - Final Status Survey Planning Worksheets - indicates that after a boundary modification, two bias samples that had been taken were considered to be outside the survey unit. This information is different from the information in Section 5.4 - Survey Results - which indicates that two samples (OOL-12-021 & OOL-12-022) were taken as bias samples & are not listed in the results table. This situation could confuse some readers.
-indicates that after a boundary modification, two bias samples that had been taken were considered to be outside the survey unit. This information is different from the information in Section 5.4 -Survey Results -which indicates that two samples (OOL-12-021  
Please clarify OOL-14 Observations/comments:
& OOL-12-022) were taken as bias samples & are not listed in the results table. This situation could confuse some readers.Please clarify OOL-14 Observations/comments:
No information on gamma survey/scan results were provided in Section 5.4 -
No information on gamma survey/scan results were provided in Section 5.4 -Survey Results or in Section 6.0 -Conclusions.
Survey Results or in Section 6.0 - Conclusions. OOL-1 4-01 is a class 3 soil area, and the Yankee Rowe LTP, Rev. 1, specifies judgmental gamma surveys/scans. It appears that some judgmental surveys were made, but the results are not given. Please address.
OOL-1 4-01 is a class 3 soil area, and the Yankee Rowe LTP, Rev. 1, specifies judgmental gamma surveys/scans.
CC:                 "'Greg Babineau'" <Babineau @yankeerowe.com>, "'Marty Erickson"'
It appears that some judgmental surveys were made, but the results are not given. Please address.CC: "'Greg Babineau'" <Babineau  
              <erickson @yankeerowe.com>, "'Joe Bourassa-' <Bourassa@CYAPCO.com>, "'Gerard P. Van Noordennen'" WVanNoordennen @CYAPCO.com>
@yankeerowe.com>, "'Marty Erickson"'
 
<erickson  
IFC -Xt-6jn-p&#xfd;T-W)76MO-1.TM 0-
@yankeerowe.com>, "'Joe Bourassa-'  
[~\temp\GWYoOYt1~TMP                                                                                       Pane i~t Mail Envelope Properties     (45929B02.B15 :14 : 47893)
<Bourassa@CYAPCO.com>, "'Gerard P. Van Noordennen'" WVanNoordennen  
@ CYAPCO.com>
IFC -Xt-6 jn-p&#xfd;T-W)76MO  
-1. TM 0-[~\temp\GWYoOYt1~TMP Pane i~t Mail Envelope Properties (45929B02.B15
:14 : 47893)


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
Status Survey Reports Creation Date From: RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final 12/27/2006 11:10:23 AM'Alice Carson" <acarson 1967 @comcast.net>
RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports Creation Date          12/27/2006 11:10:23 AM From:                  'Alice Carson" <acarson 1967 @comcast.net>
Created By: acarson 1967@comcast.net Recipients nrc.gov OWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 JBH (John Hickman)nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDOO1 THY (Thomas Youngblood)
Created By:           acarson 1967@comcast.net Recipients nrc.gov OWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 JBH (John Hickman) nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDOO1 THY (Thomas Youngblood)
CYAPCO.com VanNoordennen CC ('Gerard P. Van Noordennen')
CYAPCO.com VanNoordennen CC ('Gerard P. Van Noordennen')
Bourassa CC ('Joe Bourassa')
Bourassa CC ('Joe Bourassa')
yankeerowe.com erickson CC ('Marty Erickson')
yankeerowe.com erickson CC ('Marty Erickson')
Babineau CC ('Greg Babineau')
Babineau CC ('Greg Babineau')
Post Office OWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 Route nrc.gov nrc.gov CYAPCO.com yankeerowe.com Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 1773 12/27/2006 11:10:23 AM Responses to 12-20 questions on OOL-12_andOOL-14.pdf 7955 Mime.822 15679 Options Expiration Date: Priority: ReplyRequested:
Post Office                                                             Route OWGWPO04.HQGWDO01                                                     nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01                                                     nrc.gov CYAPCO.com yankeerowe.com Files                           Size               Date & Time MESSAGE                         1773               12/27/2006 11:10:23 AM Responses to 12-20 questions on OOL-12_andOOL-14.pdf                   7955 Mime.822                       15679 Options Expiration Date:               None Priority:                       Standard ReplyRequested:                 No Return Notification:           None Concealed  
Return Notification:
Concealed  


==Subject:==
==Subject:==
None Standard No None No Icmp\GW}dO-OOI.T-M-P Page2_Security:
No
Standard Junk Mail Handling Evaluation Results Message is eligible for Junk Mail handling This message was not classified as Junk Mail Junk Mail settings when this message was delivered Junk Mail handling disabled by User Junk Mail handling disabled by Administrator Junk List is not enabled Junk Mail using personal address books is not enabled Block List is not enabled NRC Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports (Email from Hickman to Carson dated 12/20/2006)
 
Icmp\GW}dO-OOI.T-M-P                                               Page2_
Security:                       Standard Junk Mail Handling Evaluation Results Message is eligible for Junk Mail handling This message was not classified as Junk Mail Junk Mail settings when this message was delivered Junk Mail handling disabled by User Junk Mail handling disabled by Administrator Junk List is not enabled Junk Mail using personal address books is not enabled Block List is not enabled
 
NRC Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports (Email from Hickman to Carson dated 12/20/2006)
OOL-12 Observations/Comments:
OOL-12 Observations/Comments:
NRC Comment: FSS Report Appendix A -Final Status Survey Planning Worksheets  
NRC Comment: FSS Report Appendix A - Final Status Survey Planning Worksheets -
-indicates that after a boundary modification, two bias samples that had been taken were considered to be outside the survey unit. This information is different from the information in Section 5.4 -Survey Results -which indicates that two samples (OOL- 12-021 & OOL-12-022) were taken as bias samples & are not listed in the results table. This situation could confuse some readers. Please clarify Yankee Response:
indicates that after a boundary modification, two bias samples that had been taken were considered to be outside the survey unit. This information is different from the information in Section 5.4 - Survey Results - which indicates that two samples (OOL 021 & OOL-12-022) were taken as bias samples & are not listed in the results table. This situation could confuse some readers. Please clarify Yankee Response: Two (2) samples, OOL-12-021 and OOL-12-022, were originallytaken as biasedsamplesfor the subject survey unit; however, they subsequentlyfell outside the survey unit, after a survey unit boundary modification and, therefore, were omittedfrom the table. The last sentence of the first paragraphin Section 5.4 should read: "Samples OOL-12-021 and OOL-12-022 were originallycollected as biasedsamples for OOL-12; however, after a boundary modification of the Unit, the samples were found to lie outside of the survey unit, and therefore they are omittedfrom inclusion in OOL-12."
Two (2) samples, OOL-12-021 and OOL-12-022, were originally taken as biased samples for the subject survey unit; however, they subsequently fell outside the survey unit, after a survey unit boundary modification and, therefore, were omittedfrom the table. The last sentence of the first paragraph in Section 5.4 should read: "Samples OOL-12-021 and OOL-12-022 were originally collected as biased samples for OOL-12;however, after a boundary modification of the Unit, the samples were found to lie outside of the survey unit, and therefore they are omitted from inclusion in OOL-12." OOL-14 Observations/Comments:
OOL-14 Observations/Comments:
NRC Comment: No information on gamma survey/scan results were provided in Section 5.4 -Survey Results or in Section 6.0 -Conclusions.
NRC Comment: No information on gamma survey/scan results were provided in Section 5.4 -Survey Results or in Section 6.0 - Conclusions. OOL-14-01 is a class 3 soil area, and the Yankee Rowe LTP, Rev. 1, specifies judgmental gamma surveys/scans. It appears that some judgmental surveys were made, but the results are not given. Please address.
OOL-14-01 is a class 3 soil area, and the Yankee Rowe LTP, Rev. 1, specifies judgmental gamma surveys/scans.
Yankee Response: Judgmentalscans were performed in the Survey Unit. The results are addressedin Section 5.1.4: "OOL-14-O1 was scanned approximately 10% with a SPA-3.
It appears that some judgmental surveys were made, but the results are not given. Please address.Yankee Response:
No activity greaterthan background or DCGLw, attributableto plant radionuclides,was present in OOL-14-[01]. " In subsequent reports Yankee addressedresults of the SPA-3 scans in Section 5.4 of the report.}}
Judgmental scans were performed in the Survey Unit. The results are addressed in Section 5.1.4: "OOL-14-O1 was scanned approximately 10% with a SPA-3.No activity greater than background or DCGLw, attributable to plant radionuclides, was present in OOL-14-[01]. " In subsequent reports Yankee addressed results of the SPA-3 scans in Section 5.4 of the report.}}

Latest revision as of 09:55, 23 November 2019

Licensee Response, Dated 12/27/2006, to NRC Comments on Yankee Final Status Survey Reports, OOL-12 and OOL-14
ML070320457
Person / Time
Site: Yankee Rowe
Issue date: 12/27/2006
From: Carson A
- No Known Affiliation
To: John Hickman, Youngblood T
NRC/FSME/DWMEP/DURLD/RDB
References
OOL-12, OOL-14
Download: ML070320457 (4)


Text

[John Hickman - RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports .Pag 1]

From: "Alice Carson" <acarsonl967@comcast.net>.

To: "'John Hickman"' <JBH@nrc.gov>, <thy@nrc.gov>

Date: 12/27/2006 11:10:57 AM

Subject:

RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports John/Tom, It was just brought to my attention that there was a typographical error in Section 5.1.4 of the FSSR for OOL-14. The report, and the quote from the report included in the response provided to you earlier this morning, erroneously reference OOL-14-04, instead of OOL-14-01. The attached response has been revised to acknowledge this error.

Alice Carson


Original Message -----

From: Alice Carson [1]

Sent: Wednesday, December 27, 2006 10:47 AM To: 'John Hickman'; 'thy@nrc.gov' Cc: 'Greg Babineau'; 'Marty Erickson'; 'Joe Bourassa'; 'Gerard P. Van Noordennen'

Subject:

RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports John/Tom, Attached are responses to the questions/comments on OOL-12 and OOL-14, which were previously provided to Yankee via email on 12/20/06. If you have any questions, please give me a call.

Alice Carson OOL-12 Observations/Comments:

FSS Report Appendix A - Final Status Survey Planning Worksheets - indicates that after a boundary modification, two bias samples that had been taken were considered to be outside the survey unit. This information is different from the information in Section 5.4 - Survey Results - which indicates that two samples (OOL-12-021 & OOL-12-022) were taken as bias samples & are not listed in the results table. This situation could confuse some readers.

Please clarify OOL-14 Observations/comments:

No information on gamma survey/scan results were provided in Section 5.4 -

Survey Results or in Section 6.0 - Conclusions. OOL-1 4-01 is a class 3 soil area, and the Yankee Rowe LTP, Rev. 1, specifies judgmental gamma surveys/scans. It appears that some judgmental surveys were made, but the results are not given. Please address.

CC: "'Greg Babineau'" <Babineau @yankeerowe.com>, "'Marty Erickson"'

<erickson @yankeerowe.com>, "'Joe Bourassa-' <Bourassa@CYAPCO.com>, "'Gerard P. Van Noordennen'" WVanNoordennen @CYAPCO.com>

IFC -Xt-6jn-pýT-W)76MO-1.TM 0-

[~\temp\GWYoOYt1~TMP Pane i~t Mail Envelope Properties (45929B02.B15 :14 : 47893)

Subject:

RE: Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports Creation Date 12/27/2006 11:10:23 AM From: 'Alice Carson" <acarson 1967 @comcast.net>

Created By: acarson 1967@comcast.net Recipients nrc.gov OWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 JBH (John Hickman) nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDOO1 THY (Thomas Youngblood)

CYAPCO.com VanNoordennen CC ('Gerard P. Van Noordennen')

Bourassa CC ('Joe Bourassa')

yankeerowe.com erickson CC ('Marty Erickson')

Babineau CC ('Greg Babineau')

Post Office Route OWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 nrc.gov TWGWPO04.HQGWDO01 nrc.gov CYAPCO.com yankeerowe.com Files Size Date & Time MESSAGE 1773 12/27/2006 11:10:23 AM Responses to 12-20 questions on OOL-12_andOOL-14.pdf 7955 Mime.822 15679 Options Expiration Date: None Priority: Standard ReplyRequested: No Return Notification: None Concealed

Subject:

No

Icmp\GW}dO-OOI.T-M-P Page2_

Security: Standard Junk Mail Handling Evaluation Results Message is eligible for Junk Mail handling This message was not classified as Junk Mail Junk Mail settings when this message was delivered Junk Mail handling disabled by User Junk Mail handling disabled by Administrator Junk List is not enabled Junk Mail using personal address books is not enabled Block List is not enabled

NRC Summary Comments on Yankee Rowe OOL-12 & OOL-14 Final Status Survey Reports (Email from Hickman to Carson dated 12/20/2006)

OOL-12 Observations/Comments:

NRC Comment: FSS Report Appendix A - Final Status Survey Planning Worksheets -

indicates that after a boundary modification, two bias samples that had been taken were considered to be outside the survey unit. This information is different from the information in Section 5.4 - Survey Results - which indicates that two samples (OOL 021 & OOL-12-022) were taken as bias samples & are not listed in the results table. This situation could confuse some readers. Please clarify Yankee Response: Two (2) samples, OOL-12-021 and OOL-12-022, were originallytaken as biasedsamplesfor the subject survey unit; however, they subsequentlyfell outside the survey unit, after a survey unit boundary modification and, therefore, were omittedfrom the table. The last sentence of the first paragraphin Section 5.4 should read: "Samples OOL-12-021 and OOL-12-022 were originallycollected as biasedsamples for OOL-12; however, after a boundary modification of the Unit, the samples were found to lie outside of the survey unit, and therefore they are omittedfrom inclusion in OOL-12."

OOL-14 Observations/Comments:

NRC Comment: No information on gamma survey/scan results were provided in Section 5.4 -Survey Results or in Section 6.0 - Conclusions. OOL-14-01 is a class 3 soil area, and the Yankee Rowe LTP, Rev. 1, specifies judgmental gamma surveys/scans. It appears that some judgmental surveys were made, but the results are not given. Please address.

Yankee Response: Judgmentalscans were performed in the Survey Unit. The results are addressedin Section 5.1.4: "OOL-14-O1 was scanned approximately 10% with a SPA-3.

No activity greaterthan background or DCGLw, attributableto plant radionuclides,was present in OOL-14-[01]. " In subsequent reports Yankee addressedresults of the SPA-3 scans in Section 5.4 of the report.