ML18079A829

Request Submitted by Util for Denial of Intervenors Coleman 790626 Request That ASLB Compel Licensee to Suppl Responses to Interrogatories 1,3 & 6.Questions Have No Relation to Grid Strap Problem

ML18079A829
Person / Time
Site:	Salem
Issue date:	07/06/1979
From:	Wetterhahn M CONNER, MOORE & CORBER
To:
Shared Package
ML18079A830	List: ML18079A829 ML18079A831
References
NUDOCS 7908220113
Download: ML18079A829 (4)

Text

,_

\

.*' -~**' ' ....

.,.;:{:-~-;::-- ',..

UNITED STATES OF AI*!ERICA NUCLEAP. REGULATORY CO~L!1ISSIO:::J  :*.:*

_7/t/11 .

Before the Atomic sa=e~y and Licensing Boar~

In the Matter of PUBLIC SERVICE :C:L.ECTRIC _;,:,\ID G.~_s Docket :Jo. 50-2 72 C0i-1PANY, et al. (Proposed Issuance of

..'\..mendment to ?acili t.:'

(Salem ~uclear Generating Operating License Station, Gnit 1) :Jo. DPR-70)

LICENSEE Is A1-1SWER TO ~10TION BY I);TERVE::WRS I COLE~*LZ:..i*~ I

':'O COMPEL S\JPPLE.ME~JTATION O? .~JSWERS ?O INTERROG.:i.TORIES BY LIC3NSE:C:

On June )~

- - I 1979, t.he Public Advocate of New Jersey, counsel for t.he iEtervenors, ~Ir. and :*lrs . .:;.lfred C. CoJ...e.san, Jr., i11 captioned proceeding, ~oved the Atooic Safety and Licensing Board pursuant to 10 C.F.R. §2.740(c) to com-pel sup?lenen~ation of responses to cer~ain i~ter~osator~es previously promulgated to t.he Licensee, Public Service et al. As discussed below, sL..:ch ~Lotior. . shoulc be *:::.eniea. -

As identifiec by the Colenans, t~e interrcga~ories fer which su;?le~entatic~ is recuested are ~8S. ~, 3 a~d 6, presumably of the Colernans' ) i

- - I 1978. These in~errogatories read as follows:

Interrogatory l

1. ~t ?* 2 of the Safety A~alysis, ~~e licensee describe~ the alternatives wh~ch

....lere consi:ie:::-eC. and "det.el:'~i:1ed to be i...:n-sa t.isfac-t:or~:-11 for a *v-c...=:...et~- o~ ~e2so::s.

2 Please describe the changes, if any, which have taken place in the status of spent fuel reprocessing ar.d the availa-bility of the facilities of the General Electric Company and Nuclear Fuel Ser-vices. available insofar as they relate to awa.y from reactor (".?.FR") alternati?es.

For example, have the facilities applied for expansion of spent fuel storage?

Will these facilities be available for reprocessing or AFR storage? If so, when? If not, why not?

l(a). Please explain the basis for the statement (bottom of p. 2) that "storage in the existing racks is possible, but only for a short period of tim2. 11 How long? What factors and assu..."nptions underly the time of availability, (e.g.,

fuel burnup, capacity factor of the unit, tra~sshipment, etc.)?

l(b). Has ~~e licensee consi~ered ~~e alternative in the intervenors' contention 9 (D), "ordering the ge::1eration of spent fuel to be stopped or restricted", (e.g.,

operation of the unit with existing racks until an offsite APR alternative is availa-ble.) If so, llease describe in full. If not, why not?

Interros_:-a'c.ory 3

?lease provide a full U?date of t~e licensee's

?lans for discharse of spent fuel, the first ba~ch of which is ~lanned for discharse in Ja~uary, 1979 (9. 3).

°i'iha t increase would occur in radiation levels in the storase water of t~e s9ent fuel pool in the event that ~he licensee's a~plication is granted? (see p. I) 6 (a) . What increase in radioactive materials a~d i~ radiation levels would occur in the coolan~ ~ater filters? What increase would occur in t~e screens, traps, drains and ?ipes?

?lease provide all relevant calcula'c.ions and

~~e ~asis ttere=c~e.

() ~-] lh I-'- Ul rt- OJ <.(~ rt o* lh Pl ~-J* 0 tJ l{j  :::i* 0 ti ~J ti 0 l1-*

,, I-' rt* 0 CD Ill I-'* ID I-'* tj

.i m (D p, Ii (D Ul I-'  :-j 1-1  :!:;

lJ' ID 0..-< t*j Ul -t(J p, CD tii Ill lU j_), Ul 8 1--' (/) (D <, (/} Ii (]l r.: Ul ti t-3

() r: m Ill 0 CD () I-'- <D 0 Ul tr Ill 11- I-'* ti p_,  ::r Ill rt () n en I-'- ~j 0 lQ 1--'  ::::s 11 {/) CD (]) CD n rt* l(~ *" 1--'* p, 11 ~..:: I 1* rt* p1 rt* CD ti r-t Ill ..:4 0.. Ill <!

p, I-'" (D 11* I-'- (D n 1--'* rt (\) () '0  ::.i I-'- t_-l fl" 0 Ii , ... 0 :J (J 1-1 Ill ::::s Ul :::l rt* tr I-'* m () 0 0 t*j *o Ul 0 (D rt I-'* 0 I-'* Ul '< 0.*-0 0\

(D  ::i:J 0 () ~

0 0 :J Ul 0 ::.i ~ 0 (D l*j 0'0 Ill :::i* ru t*h (D I-'*  ::::s ti Ill ~ 1-h ::::s rt CD ~

11  :=1 rt* Ul  :-J Ul ID 0 p, CD CJ) Pl ti I-'* 0.. Ii  :.s ti CD () 0 Ill 0 tJ' Ul ..-. l)l ~J* rt* n 'Cl 1--' :-j CD 1--'* :::i* CJ) () I'-> CD <! rt* 0 CD 0 rt  ::::s p_, ti Ii ti rt OJ~

~ (/I ~* (/I Ul IU i:.: w :-J 0 1--' ill Ill ({) 0 Ul 0 Ul lj Ul CD 0 N 1:: I-'* 0 I-'* ri' 1--' t-h I-'* CD Pl

• !)'Cl ~- p, 1-1i~ rt* ~J Ill ;:I r..: ::::s CD (\)  :-j t:1 ~j () CD CD Pl CD CD (/I Ill l(l

<, rt l'l 'd () I*-' Cll () 0 Ii ~*

1 lcJ ID 1-'~l'Cll'U  ::: rt* (\) H ([l ~J* CD r1* Ii (j t-h tr tJ' rt* 0 Ill n* I-'*  ::r  :::i* CD ~ CD Ill *o (fl (IJ ID x Clt ::-1 .. ~1* Ul <D 0 ti :.].. . . ._ !::1 rt 1--' :-V Ill ~1 CD t11 I-'* 0 CD ~ Ul Ill p, () I-' I-' rt 1--'

~'j ~:l lj 'lJ 1*1 I-'* CD :1 t--'* rt* 0 ~" PJ I ..~

..::. ~J (D 1...::: t'j  ::.i ~ tJ' ti Ill p, ID <D

(() (j) Ill CD {fl () (/I () rt* Ul :.1* rt r: 1~- (/} ~1* J_J* 'd ()  :.J 0 {/I I-'- 1--' Ii lQ () '0 Ill = Ill

J  :::i Ii 0 ~1 .. (1) 1--* Ill Ii t('l I-'* Cl> ~-'- ~j rt- Ill CD ~ Ill r:J rt  ::.i*  ::::s 1--'* CD CD 0 Ill tJ* (/I rt- {/I r1- rt 1~- rt* ~l ({) (l [II 0 Ii [II I'-> fll {/I  :::i* 1~- rt- () Ul p, ;:J n CD CD ~J (1)

I'* rt- ~ :*.r -- ~ ,.

1-J* ~~' :_J~ (D Ill Ul 1-1 Ill  :*1 CD .... rt '* n 'd CD 'd *n I-'* p, CD

!U () :.Y Ill *. 1. jlJ 1-.....~ 0 0 t-h Ill rt rt* CD o*  ::1* -<, OJ !J ll  ::.i ti :v 1.:; Ill IU ...,. :::i* ,n rt* ,.... Ul Ill 0 <D Ul --- ~j 8 , ,__. 1*1 <D ~ 1--' tr Ii p,  ::::s ~ () *-< ~y ...... ni' ~

{/I 1--* rl pi Pt Cll I..::~ 1-** t-h (D I-'* "-.CD 1~- <!  !:I CD CD 0 <! {/I <D rt- CD::::StJtd r:: I h ~1 1-1 (/}

r1* 1/1 : l <! l j Ii tJ' liJ p, 1-i :--1'1--'*~o ::1 Ul ,Q :J (D rt rt- ~ 0 CD I-' ..... 0 rt- o 1--'

J" IJ' 0 CD I"* 01 lj p, {/I 1~- ([l ::::s ~J ti p, r; Ill H CD n* ....<. Pl () (/J *v O t-h Ul 0 i::: IU w (ll m {/I :J {/I 0 0 rt* 1--' rt* n 0 Cl ::) . ti ~ I-" p, 1--' (ll <D ('I' Pl  ::::s pi  ::i 1~-

m :1 Ul 1(1 <[~ IU ~:;* ~* ( ,. <. 0 Cll Ill Ill !J

'" ti CD 0 1-1 m 0 n- rt* rt t1 r 1- n* :--J

'<J  ::i () (ll 1*. PJ  ::i 1-1 CD Ul ti rt* p, CD ,f~ 1--' t-h  !::I H CD 0 Ill ~J' CD ~1*

(ll

()

1() (I) pi fl {/l  !";l.l rt* ~~ Ii ~..* 1-'*'0 (/I i::: Ill 0 n.J I-'-  !:I CD CD 0 rt*

11 ,... :1 n. 0 rt- ([) ()  ::1' rt* (ll  :-J 0 Ii 1*1 Ill I-" ti Pl rt CD 0 rt* p_, Ii t*h :::i*

CI ;:J p1 :J" 0 l\1 Ii rt* I-'" CD ::,J' () 0 ~j I*'* Ul rt* ;J rt*  :::> ~ {/I  ::::s  :::i* *(1 CD 'D m 1-'-'tl 'U IU ..-~ ~. 1 *t 1--'* (j) l)J 0 Ii  ::1 Ill rt* ~: 0 ru .. ~ (D (D rl* (D (D CD {/I 0 0 Ill 0 0 Ul 111 {/I l*-1 ID !J {/I I-"  :,..... ~lJ .. 'd 0 CD ~:l CD (D rt-(\J UJ 1--' 11 rt* C.1 Ill p, < I-' ti 1-'Hl*l

J "* r1* '(jO 1-1 p, n 1u I'* ~J p, *n :1 ;J(() df:: Ill rt* :s i:: <D ' n.

n. ci 0 *il fll rt 0 Ul n. :j* ro :_l * ~:l Cl> r ,. rD  : )' L-' 1:;  :--J m I-'* 11 = l-1 p, 0 rt*

liJ CD () :J  ::: ~i ct* ([) {[) :J pi l.n *'-!  ::1  :::i Ill 1~- ~j pi  !:l l\l ID r:: Ul Cll 0*

tl' u* ru I h D* I"* I"* p, Ill rt* rt* "cJ (D 0 rt* () CD ~j

g. rt 1---' l\l Ul l*j r'" El 1---; 1-"'0 0 :J :1 :J I--'* Ii  ::i* 0  ::::s  :-J (D rt* {/I CD CD {ll {J) I-'* 0 ID (ll 'cJ 1*11 ('I' l t ~Cl rt* cJ [IJ OJ CD ::.i rt* 1*1 :J N :_.,... .-*

<, 11 11 1--.:: Ul :j :-J :j I:-' e 0 I-'  :*r* ~l* r i* ~J' (j) I [II Ill (D I*" {/I lJ I (D CD Ii CD r: 0 lfj n*

I*) I" 1--" ('), Cll ell  :.J* m (JJ rn rt (/l (l m Ii 1--* () Ill l'h I (j

1 {) ,... I*--'* ([i p, {/I 1--' <Q u

n. I*'* Cl CD 1*1 I*'* Pl H Ill

(\) ru D* {II I" Ii (I) () 0  :--J 1-* ru Ill Ul !:J rt* !J 0 rt*

1-1 {ll (J' (J n. ID :J  ::s Ul l.D tJ Ii rt* ~ ~ . ,< I

.J ... 0 CD {/I n Ul (I) ~-1 Ill CD I*-' 0 <D

() r: I-* .:--~ :J *cJ Ill I-" I-'* CD 1-] l.D lO <! lO Ii l*h (J , ... ((> fl' 0 Ul :J .._,.< () ID CD --1 I*-'*

-;* ( 1* f ( I*"*  ::J (]) ID Ul r*t Ill OJ ell 11* '*-: IU 11* Ul 11* p, 0 rt* I---' Ul

!J' Pt tJ' I '*' ([)  : )' , I) ru 0 Ul

([)  :~)* t- I (/I

{/l w 0 ID er 11* ..

(LI

(\) ID p1 H I ID :J* rt* ct*  ::i.J

I I\ :1 I I' I'- (D  ::r ~f Ii

() (LI  ! ~I rt ro 1u CD

{J) rt*

4 have no relation to the crid~

strap -

- Droblem. -"--side from a gener::i.l reference to §2. 740 (e), the :?ublic _J,.dvocate fails to assert in what way a prior response was incorrect when

~ade or that a knowing concealment exists. In an absence of such a showing and considering the infor:aation relateC.

to the Licensing Board and oarties on June 25, 1979, it is clear that these interrogatories need not be su?pla~ented.

Therefore, the Public Advocate's ~otion s~ould be denied.

Respectfully subraitted, COi:~rJErt, ~-100RE ~ COR:SER Mark J. Wetterhahn Counsel =or Licensee Jul}t* 6, 1979