ML23102A052

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Meeting Slide: Information Meeting with Federally-Recognize Tribes Regarding the Proposed Rule Renewing Nuclear Power Plant Operating Licenses Environmental Review
ML23102A052
Person / Time
Issue date: 04/12/2023
From:
Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards
To:
References
Download: ML23102A052 (27)
v • d • e


Text

Informational Meeting with Federally-Recognized Tribes Regarding Proposed Rule - Renewing Nuclear Power Plant Operating Licenses -

Environmental Review Subsequent License Environmental Directorate Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission April 12, 2023

Logistics

  • Will open floor to questions after the presentation
  • Chat feature in MS Teams is available for use 2

Purpose of the Meeting

  • To inform Federally recognized Tribes of NRC regulatory activities
  • Summarize the NRCs process for the review and update of NUREG-1437, Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Plants (LR GEIS)
  • Discuss how you can provide comments
  • Answer questions regarding the proposed rule package 3

Agenda

  • Background
  • Purpose of the LR GEIS
  • LR GEIS Update Process and Methodology

- Updates to Table B-1, Summary of Findings on NEPA Issues for License Renewal of Nuclear Power Plants

  • Rulemaking Schedule
  • How to Submit Comments
  • Question and Answer Session 4

Background

  • Scoping initiated in August 2020, 7 years after the last revision cycle (2013)
  • Staff Requirements Memorandum (SRM)-

SECY-21-0066 directed the staff to develop a new rulemaking plan

Background (cont.)

  • SRM-SECY-22-0024 issued in April 2022 directed the staff to:

- Initiate a rulemaking that aligns with Commission Order CLI-22-03 and recent decisions in CLI-22-02 and CLI-22-04

- Remove the word initial from 10 CFR 51.53(c)(3)

- Revise the LR GEIS, Table B-1, and associated guidance to fully support subsequent license renewal (SLR)

- Account for changes to applicable laws and regulations, new data, and lessons learned

- Complete the rulemaking within 24 months 6

Purpose of the LR GEIS

  • Summarizes findings from a detailed inquiry into the environmental impacts of license renewal and continued plant operations during the renewal term
  • Identifies and evaluates generic impacts (same or similar) at all power plants, or a subset of power plants
  • Identifies plant-specific impacts that need to be addressed in supplements to the LR GEIS 7

LR GEIS

  • Findings from the LR GEIS are codified in Table B-1 of Appendix B to Subpart A of 10 CFR Part 51 year review and update, if necessary
  • Categorization of impact issues

- Category 1: impacts same or similar at all nuclear power plants or a subset of nuclear power plants

- Category 2: requires nuclear plant-specific analysis 8

Process to Update GEIS

  • Review and update the 2013 LR GEIS to validate the findings for initial license renewal (LR) and expand the analyses to cover SLR reviews
  • Consider the need to modify, add to, or delete any of the 78 environmental issues in the 2013 LR GEIS
  • Ensure that the LR GEIS and plant-specific environmental reviews meet the hard look standard under NEPA 9

Process to Update GEIS (cont.)

  • General analytical approach:

- Describe the nuclear power plant activity or aspect of plant operations or refurbishment that could affect the resource

- Identify the resource that is affected

- Evaluate past license renewal reviews and other available information

- Assess the nature and magnitude of effect on an affected resource from initial LR or SLR

- Characterize the significance of effects

- Determine whether the results apply to all plants or a subset of plantsthat is, whether the environmental issue is Category 1 (generic) or Category 2 (plant-specific)

- Consider additional mitigation measures 10

Updates to Table B-1

  • In the draft revised LR GEIS, the staff proposes a total of 80 environmental issues that may be associated with continued operation and refurbishment during the renewal term

- 59 environmental issues are Category 1

- 20 environmental issues are Category 2

- 1 environmental issue is uncategorized

  • No environmental issues were eliminated, but certain issues were consolidated, and one issue was subdivided into three separate issues
  • One new Category 1 issue and two new Category 2 issues were added 11

Consolidated Category 2 Issue

  • Groundwater quality degradation (cooling Groundwater ponds at inland quality sites) (Cat. 2) degradation
  • Groundwater quality (plants with degradation (cooling cooling ponds in salt ponds) marshes) (Cat. 1) (Cat. 2) 12

Consolidated Category 2 Issue Impingement

  • Impingement and mortality and entrainment of aquatic entrainment of organisms (plants with once-through cooling systems or aquatic cooling ponds) (Cat. 2) organisms
  • Impingement component of (plants with Losses from predation, parasitism, and disease once-through among organisms exposed to cooling systems sublethal stresses (Cat. 1) or cooling ponds) (Cat. 2) 13

Consolidated Category 1 Issue

  • Impingement and Impingement entrainment of aquatic mortality and organisms (plants with entrainment cooling towers) (Cat. 1) of aquatic
  • Impingement component of organisms Losses from predation, (plants with parasitism, and disease cooling among organisms exposed to towers) sublethal stresses (Cat. 1) (Cat. 1) 14

Consolidated Category 1 Issue

  • Infrequently reported thermal impacts (all plants) (Cat. 1)
  • Effects of cooling water discharge on Infrequently dissolved oxygen, gas reported supersaturation, and eutrophication effects of (Cat. 1) thermal
  • Thermal effluent component of effluents Losses from predation, parasitism, (Cat. 1) and disease among organisms exposed to sublethal stresses (Cat. 1) 15

Subdivided Category 2 Issue

  • Endangered Species Act: federally listed Threatened, species and critical habitats under U.S. Fish endangered, and Wildlife jurisdiction (Cat. 2) and protected
  • Endangered Species Act: federally listed species, species and critical habitats under National critical Marine Fisheries Service jurisdiction (Cat. 2) habitat and essential fish habitat
  • Magnuson-Stevens Act: essential fish (Cat. 2) habitat (Cat. 2) 16

New Issues

  • National Marine Sanctuaries Act: sanctuary resources (Cat. 2)
  • Greenhouse gas impacts on climate change (Cat. 1)
  • Climate change impacts on environmental resources (Cat. 2) 17

Issue Category Change Severe Severe accidents accidents (Cat. 2) (Cat. 1) 18

Summary of Proposed Amendments

  • Codifies the revised Category 1 (generic) conclusions of the draft revised LR GEIS in Table B-1 in Appendix B to Subpart A of 10 CFR 51

- Conclusions have been expanded to specifically account for SLR (one term), initial LR and other new information since the 2013 LR GEIS

  • Revises Table B-1 to account for lessons learned, knowledge gained, and experience from environmental reviews performed since development of the LR GEIS, Revision 1 (2013)
  • Updates 10 CFR 51.53 and Table B-1 to reflect new scientific data, and changes in environmental regulations and impact methodology regarding the assessment of potential environmental impacts of nuclear power plants
  • Makes conforming changes to § 51.53(c)(3) and § 51.95(c) 19

Rulemaking and LR GEIS Schedule Proposed Rule to the Proposed Rule Published Public Comment Period Commission March 3, 2023 Ends December 6, 2022 (88 FR 13329) May 2, 2023 Final Rule to the Final Rule Publication Commission April 25, 2024 (est.)

November 30, 2023 (est.)

Docket ID: NRC-2018-0296 20

All Supporting Documents

  • All Supporting Follow the links below or go directly to:

https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/operating/licensing/renewal/sled.html Documents for the Proposed Rule: Federal Register Notice Regarding Renewing Nuclear Proposed Power RuleLicenses - Environmental Review Plant Operating ML22357A007 Draft NUREG-1437, Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License ML23010A078 Renewal of Nuclear Power Plants, Volume 1 & 2, Revision 2 ML23010A086 Draft NUREG-1555, Supplement 1, Revision 2, Standard Review Plans for Environmental Reviews for Nuclear Power Plants, Supplement 1: Operating ML22165A070 License Renewal Draft Regulatory Guide DG-4027, Preparation of Environmental Reports for Nuclear Power Plant License Renewal Applications (also referenced as ML22165A072 RG 4.2, Supplement 1)

Draft Regulatory Analysis for the 10 CFR Part 51, Generic Environmental ML23010A074 Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Power Plants 21 21

Submitting Comments

- Please note that comments will not be edited to remove identifying information

  • By Email: Rulemaking.Comments@nrc.gov

- If you do not receive an automatic email reply confirming receipt, contact us at 301-415-1677 22

How to Submit Comments (cont.)

  • By Mail:

Secretary ATTN: Rulemaking and Adjudications Staff Mail Stop: TWFN-7-A60M U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Washington, DC 20555-0001

  • Comment period ends May 2, 2023 23

Specific Request for Comment

  • The proposed rule would extend the applicability of the LR GEIS to one term of SLR.

The NRC is seeking comment on whether the proposed rule should be expanded beyond two license renewal terms.

  • Please provide the rationale for your response.

24

Points of Contact

- Phone: (800) 368-5642, ext. 1519

- Email: Yanely.Malave-Velez@nrc.gov

- Phone: (800) 368-5642, ext. 3835

- Email: Jennifer.Davis@nrc.gov

- Phone: (800) 368-5642, ext. 6944

- Email: Kevin.Folk@nrc.gov 25

Discussion

  • Raise your hand

- MS Teams: Raise my hand button

- On the phone: press *5

  • Youll still need to unmute

- MS Teams: Unmute button

- On the phone: press *6 26

References

  • STC Letters

- STC-20-059 - Notice of Review and Update of LR GEIS

- STC-21-045 - Issuance of Scoping Summary Report

- STC-23-012 - Issuance of Proposed Rule Package

- STC-23-015 - Notification of Public Meetings

- STC-23-018 - Notice of Informational Meeting with Federally recognized Tribes

  • NETWG Meetings

- NRC Overview Presentation, August 2021

- NRC Status Briefing, October 2022

- NETWG Presentation, February 2023 27

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML23102A052&oldid=3531362"