ML20237L656

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Handwritten Memo Re Mgt Analysis Corp Rept on Util QA Program.Nrc Should Review Contractor Repts to Determine Significance of Findings,Observations & Reportability Under 10CFR21 & 50.55(e)
ML20237L656
Person / Time
Site: Comanche Peak  Luminant icon.png
Issue date: 07/31/1985
From: Phillip H
NRC
To: Westerman T
NRC
Shared Package
ML20237F760 List: ... further results
References
NUDOCS 8708200293
Download: ML20237L656 (5)
v • d • e


Text

{{#Wiki_filter:-_-- ___ - _ _

  1. % d os.: Co qq g i 6% ~ a s.1 g r,-

Joh 5i, is gg b o < % 6 L '. 'T. t 4 < .s M -r m c Ps t- s Grosp Le Fyo - i-l. s. P,4 . c.c , e , scwiw i b .' 6 % f L , g de v l ceses c.>% b A o f%  ! Sw 6 p eA  : M .Y b po v-t J o n. 

                                                                              /ka k,l , carfc<a %

terc s U P,l'. 0 <r G G- Pv, gy m t 1 1 bme6 M A.d D T * >c o. 5 U f < (I b'</ t h s {ec.?( a n C>< gorah. o f4: a k hv y d 19N n a % :, , q <e % wt Lw4 4 (4 6 C Ps ss c e .s k d 6 di G k e g k 9gblo -<  ;. 0 , 13 N . Du v,4 3 +w , iag< d6 7 4-1.4s l-e s > u.Gl.i,a< igle im46 o( g o c F A p~f s o d! , l 3 teqv:a + 4s A , s e.a.<~{.' c a l % , a > k< e0 % al\ <*p<h a_u f f , w h.ck wow (4 3 k u %f v < u. bis , w a 64 a , , A ksa roy luly veu<wed L sL 4u .s 

       &             q\< em4 ua      Aa (de gu. 9 ,1 %.ef qs + ls +9                                a s s- vma          po ym .

L o u.d t 9at,y tW , u s k-od d k.w.4 . A c (.u de d ss $no. ws to m 4 0+ 6% v or p ', yAp%~D4:c. ew .' ypd: sL ip% w k L st ,L e . m ns on otw pv o g n s+ ch as vn c3 x mb e (~ $ u; km < .( u s gem i, sl t i 4.',., &h 0% qve cg m ussv e del y <d. 4 l b . v e p .e s.t3 ta a-v <. daecd<d So 1 .e u , 04 i t i f le-B703200293 870019 PDR ADOCK 05000445 G PDR . L_____--____----______ 

 ,M
   ~
2. ,

i MM^A A b V0u O Su f DV vi J 6V

a. e d i t ev o 3v~

wko L 4. 6% k s44 4 l h poi kt ef Ga la c{. A ll>i o-f a.tl e x6 v n~l l weds us a > f r os. d .e 4 cc w ok + g4 % d e -on s%. ' l N-{ f lJ > wguJve.w.m4 hud Le m e), il ped 3 l -a.,_ 6 Cy, L 6 bce , o it c. c+T, Pu -Im?o 

      ?vy aA ,%y e. k . we n V> {< d k4 n~
                          ,                                                             we v r ce-pre.

h % siv e ves.us of N aA progv e . As c. a e Yesv.If c~ v i b i ct.S c o w v4a c.3 S u, 4 d th to It c. ed l r4- 3 A ; v4 - n b.e w fh Aggi. e u( -fa( e i lo {equlw f e u . 'ew [L-a b Nu. s & ad.e p a. ef m QA proy ~ v;o . TL g tJed u; s du w erv e 0+ tks (& n Q w eii vn p e {.n y h e- ( d tM Qkb ea.fL v i9N d v4a ive d N vaLa b s lea l q 24 AMc v , gevi u,a .s 

     ,,wd           m r-c bru. q        es , i s v s .

On M, t 9 Fi Y<rc.s()N(,'Iie.r' lt $Ad v]ve a. 7/vc h sa < d cr I s L-r w kr ik a. d v a's e d +% D rL c W rf b y e. M M aj<4v,ogi 4 { ova.QA (MIK ) haL bJ a f stL, I u a ., of, U W A  % p in m q < vn .  %: , r,p A w ~ ., vt4 f wta b. N ailn d 4o 6 U (C 16 s f.e I h f Co n s uli o-nk s &>. v s 'n k N c.6 0 v-c0 m> 

  %pc.16                  of      bL A g h co,d 3           tfeoibusi mp6b an *e-f                                             1 a p p.                     q 7 4                       s par, m u y a-du L d           su ok          ce pods .

b c~ 4vesa% wM p d W. Leob

3 1 Gvi f 0L /m3f c4 4 k. gew (sLd  % l (' 2 L1 ye. u s f s 4 v< Wh c k cenb c4w m a , 3 ,el lew c. ,p u b LL f.c..mq w b d %,n soi Nc< c q uo.m u. 4 cJ %.6 IF ( s k k.,/a ef oA po y4 6-M> of  % c2 n p s gr ~ Gu akuk L, u&4e to , gens',12 4. Al % b k "5 5 f " N ve a.< s 4 w w.s Pw tu yl. c k V, veo.ws l l 4 sLmta b.m also v e m t. y g u cow Oy cw kl of% n or u s wue also u vr w s.lG un,  % wm 1 d:< e cd e d ev 

    &lu d             %             sh           I cm        ~w s k -d n     towq &W                              Lo %

ififfu&gt:~nno,w,y<kdN 9 L . u s u wuen ~ ;~ , s u.si tu wi u < 4 s kow ld k b ti b d e k ~ . '- < % s, y ..C e l a ; o (D ((me ud9, 

   /oleb w wa os u a x d tk re 9

g4 ca.s sw ..4 WI y u 6 l 1 

                                                                                 )

1 1

July 8, 1985 . UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of ) Dochet Nos. 50-445-1 

                                 )               50-446-1 TEXAS UTILITIES ELECTRIC          )               50-445-2 and COMPANY, ET AL.                )               50-446-2'
                                 )

(Comanche Peak Steam Electric ) (Application for Station, Units 1 and 2) ) Operating Licenses) APPLICANTS' RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO CASE'S MOTION FOR IMMEDIATE HEARINGS, EVIDENTIARY DEPOSITIONS, AND/OR DISCOVERY REGARDING THE MAC REPORT I. INTRODUCTION By pleading dated June 24, 19851 Citizens Association for Sound Energy (" CASE") has moved this Board, in the alternative (in descending order of preference) for (1) immediate evidentiary hearings, (2) immediate sequestered, evidentiary depositions of a large number of ind.ividuals, with costs to be funded by the Applicants, and/or (3) an immediate first round of comprehensive discovery regarding "the MAC Report." The MAC Report, dated May 1978, has been the subject of letters 1/ " Board Notification and CASE's Motions: For Discovery l l ~ Regarding the MAC Report and Issues Raised by the MAC Report and/or for Hearings and/or P.videntiary l Depositions," June 24, 1985 (hereafter " Motion"). I

F III. CONCLUSION For all the reasons discussed above, CASE's Motion should be denied in its entirety. CASE has not demonstrated facts and circumstances surrounding this matter which would justify the extraordinary relief of hearings prior to specification of I l I relevant issues, prior to discovery in conformance with the j i Commission's Rules of Practice, and prior to preparation and j l submittal of prefiled testimony. Similarly, CASE's discovery l requests ate premature and inconsistent with the basic procedural scheme of the Commission's Rules of Practice. CASE has to date not specified any issues related to the MAC Report or demonstrated safety significance in light of the current posture of this proceeding. Consistent with Applicants' recently filed Management Plan, Applicants request that any future discovery on this matter be preceded by specification of issues together with a showing of current safety significance. Once any such issues are admitted into the proceeding for purposes of discovery (following responses by the Applicants and the Staff), the Applicants also request 

   .}}
Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20237L656&oldid=3111471"