ML20205M674
| ML20205M674 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | McGuire, Mcguire  |
| Issue date: | 04/13/1999 |
| From: | Rinaldi F NRC (Affiliation Not Assigned) |
| To: | Barron H DUKE POWER CO. |
| References | |
| TAC-M98964, TAC-M98965, TAC-MA5017, TAC-MA5018, NUDOCS 9904160007 | |
| Download: ML20205M674 (6) | |
Text
,
Q J7 R Rig f(A y".
4 UNITED STATES l
' j NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION WASHINGTON, D.C. 2055'H)o01
\\..... j't April 13, 1999 Mr. H. B. Barron Vice President, McGuire Site Duke Energy Corporation 12700 Hagers Ferry Road Huntersvitie, NC 28078-8985
SUBJECT:
LICENSING BASES RECORD CHANGE - MCGUIRE NUCLEAR STATION, UNITS 1 AND 2 (TAC NOS. M98964, M98965, MA5017, AND MA5018)
Dear Mr. Barron:
On March 18,1998, a telephone conference was conducted to discuss the subject licensing bases record change regarding Duke Energy Corporation's (DEC) license amendment request dated May 27,1997, and the staff's approval in the form of Technical Specification (TS)
Amendments 184 and 166, dated September 30,1998. Your letter of March 18,1999, documented the discussions and provided the formal request for action on the proposed correction. Another letter dated March 23,1999, provided additionalinformation that was missing from the March 18,1999, letter. The correction would change the designation for TS Surveillance Requirement (SR) 3.3.5.2 from " administrative" to "more restrictive". This correction is currently required for Unit 2. which is undergoing a refueling outage, but it applies to both units.
The TS (Table 3.3-3 Functional Unit 9) applicable before the implementation of TS Amendments 184 and 166 required operability of the Loss of Power Diesel Generator Start Instrumentation only in Modes 1,2,3, and 4, with a suNeillance frequency of at least once per 18 months. TS Amendments 184 and 166 revised the applicability to also include "when associated DG [ diesel generator)is required to be OPERABLE by LCO [ limited condition of operation) 3.8.2." In
{
accordance with TS 3.8.2, the associated DG is required to be available in Modes 5, and 6, and 1
during movement of irradiated fuel assemblies. The change, the inclusion of Modes 5 and 6 and during movement of irradiated fuel, results in a "more restrictive" SR and effectively reduced the scheduled interval for performance of the surveillance by approximately 28 days. This results from the fact that the time period continues through an outage.
Tne staff agrees that this surveillance should have been considered as a *more restrictive" char,9e and not as an " administrative" change. Enclosed please find the respective revised f
pages to our Safety Evaluation of September 30,1998. The first page consists of Table A -
j Administrative Changes Section 3.3 Instrumentation, showing the deletion of Change 3.3 A.52.
The second page is Table M - More Restrictive Changes Section 3.3 Instrumentation, which includes Change 3.3 M.30. The deleted Change 3.3 A.52 and the :nserted Change 3.3 M.30 contain the same requirement. Also, the license conditions at the end of Appendix D remain in effect. Further, the first surveillance interval begins upon completion of the first surveillance l
9904160007 990413 F
7?
ADOCK0500g9 c_
____u_.
/ tl g ' )
DR 4
'JJuad Q
H. B. Barron April 13, 1999 performed after implementation of Amendment 184 for Unit 1, and Amendment 166 for Unit 2.
This change is considered a correction of record and does not involve any change to the McGuire Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2 TS.
If you have cny questions, please contact me at (301) 415-1447.
Sincerely, Original signed by:
Frank Rinaldi, Project Manager, Section 1 Project Directorate il Division of Licensing Project Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation l
Docket Nos. 50-369 and 50-370 I
l
Enclosure:
As stated cc w/ encl: See next page Distribution:
Docket File ~h FRinaldi PUBLIC OGC PD 11-2 R/F GHill(4)
JZwolinski/SBlack ACRS HBerkow COgle, Ril CHawes To receive a copy of this document, Indicate in the box: "C" = Copy without attachment / enclosure "E" = Copy with attachment / enclosure "N' = No copy *See previous concurrence OFFICE PM:PDil-2 r
LA:PDil-2 l
TSB*
l BC:TSB*
EELB*
l NAME FRinaldi:cn W CHawes CA1H CSchulten WBeckner OChopra DATE 4 / 6 /99 4 / 6 /99 4/5/99 4/5/99 4/6/99 OFFICE BC:EELB*
l SC:PDll-1,
N PDil:D y
l NAME JCalvo REmch 8M HBerkswd/V DATE 4/6/99 4-//,2,/99
//
/
/
/
/
t OFFICIAL RECORD COPY l
l
c
]
H. B. Barron 1 performed after implementation of Amendment 184 for Unit 1, and Amendment 166 for Unit 2.
This change is considered a correction of record and does not involve any change to the McGuire Nuclear Station, Units 1 and 2 TS.
if you have any questions, please contact me at (301) 415-1447.
Sincerely, WC L~t
^
Frank Rinaldi, Project Manager, Section 1 PrQJect Directorate 11 Division of Licensing Project Management Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation Docket Nos. 50-369 and 50-370
Enclosure:
As stated o; w/ encl: See next page
r
~
McGuire Nuclear Station cc:
Ms. Lisa F. Vaughn Ms. Karen E. Long Legal Department (PBOSE)
Assistant Attorney General Duke Energy Corporation North Carolina Department of 422 South Church Street Justice Charlotte, North Carolina 28201-1006 P. O. Box 629 Raleigh, North Carolina 27602 County Manager of Mecklenburg County L. A. Keller 720 East Fourth Street Manager - Nuclear Regulatory Charlotte, North Carolina 28202 Licensing Duke Energy Corporation Michael T. Cash 526 South Church Street Regulatory Compliance Manager Charlotte, North Carolina 28201-1006 Duke Energy Corporation McGuire Nuclear Site Elaine Wathen, Lead REP Planner 12700 Hagers Ferry Road Division of Emergency Management Huntersville, North Carolina 28078 116 West Jones Street Raleigh, North Carolina 27603-1335 J. Michael McGarry, Ill, Esquire Winston and Strawn Mr. Richard M. Fry, Director 1400 L Street, NW.
Division of Radiation Protection Washington, DC 20005 North Carolina Department of Environment, Health and Natural Senior Resident inspector Resources c/o U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 3825 Barrett Drive 12700 Hagers Ferry Road Raleigh, North Carolina 27609-7721 Huntersville, North Carolina 28078 Mr. T. Richard Puryear Dr. John M. Barry Owners Group (NCEMC)
Mecklenberg County Duke Energy Corporation Department of Environmental 4800 Concord Road Protection York, South Carolina 29745 700 N. Tryon Street Charlotte, North Carolina 28202 Mr. Steven P. Shaver Senior Sales Engineer Westinshouse Electric Company 5929 Carnegie Blvd.
Suite 500 Charlotte, North Carolina 28209
T 0
1 N
9 E
3 1
e M
c 3
r 3
SE n
le u
b le s
T R io CI tc a
b o
U A
T a
l T
c Q
6 1
5 5
n E
3 4
3 3
2 E
R 3
6 3
3 3
3 3
3 3
3 TN E
M ER IU 1
1 Q
3 4
E 3
3 R
3 3
S 7
le e
4 T
5 I
6 b
lb a
3 a
3 5
T 3
T 3
s s
s t
o n
O n
oi n
,t d ls a asSo d aN h ia t
i r
C h nTi eml T t P af oI t
ler a n
tet o o eL t
c eitcthA ot oO t
e nisM toui a
d bf ole t
L c"
id e
m a
o hA Nt wg lnb" a
snt leTb r
t ee mTP S
b ht in i
ut p
ta(P d
hS T n n
e gn it x
lol E
u s
r GN t
got inios mt n i
a e
TO s
e nh o
"n I L yt c e i a e. t NO b "s e
c x nt e
L b io e e ficin n
otin s E" p
e h h r
l ue c
AI l
e r
T oo ai lapjh a
t CT d t m
dt d t
t HA t
r yn nr e
h et eof n eBo tnio n
h r
a co ot At enf eoi gma s
E N ir s
u c
f onRl mot Cq qee inu o o ent ia dI n tnaEe ut V E u
i am r
v
.te t
l ni n
t I
M evtato sa P
r i s is r
it r
sy o o en d eOan cr t
T x nl si o AU eie itipne et sh inif r
f r ci t
c t
d nol c R R r r ele ei ot ah r
bine mpb st h i d
eit T T pi n ht t r
nd p
at l
r o i
ms n e tesa S S eno oph r i h or eNmt o e r
t I
N mC t f p h
ow c o ain se ct d h u yt S NI E
hd e wsp e
e i
t qio sat I
t a
yh e
Cet M 3 G
r Aiv t
f t
d n bT n n r e a
n aC 3
N o",a eee ot r
e b mf m op e r
d i
al D
i e 0t inmo e st s sauor t
sh r
AN A
t nais nt mr o a
t n
s AT C
te5i b em s
O H
ioc n mSi e n t
i ua f
I ne in mi vif r
i d
t io uT nbi co r
o ue eccc EC F
cpd e a ne lo I Mmis At te ot m cqr r
g uh sd a nupn c n" LE O
ehaA erd eFSio eignt e ein r
t f
h CS en n et l
t lb nt h vm BS Y
d r
neo uoi c
a b na e t
T wa i
A R
ySI d g secr aost n amle t
T f
i T pi yo e
A iT snn amind s e lna F as x
i cI n r ui h uh n e t
so M
e a
r todo r
s o
n ior eot ywla M
s n
iet let c pt i
s e e r
n r n b nTi io t
oh s e tene n
d di o
a t
U r ies c
f ta ed eo ai vt n
aiog t
S h ve Mtam T eo oa eof e r
i St n e
f cr a a on nnt mhf pn mT r t h
ep dtnh tsmi r
t t
ta ein s
gme er ne u
epd e e c e
d sn r
s ot m o
nnn olid tsf r
s "s eSa emi io t
a eeo u
ei r
c y ytcNr I
o a
nr T n nhT l e uh mec d
eb w H toc Sr t
y t
a ss i
n n ).
it i s o Ot w e ehI nt n Iem gs a
r n n i n r
s ht wcmh ua n ro I
qh oCo ont ",n o n uTf E)"n e
e L p d iof w
d ul f
Po n9 ts tuit os o tu csh r 2 F o
.e S Ot r
i r
e a
Mo n
h d n md f
T a
h oe nt L t o
d.
eAf Snoiu S
nmt t
s C( n i6ot mP d n
ot Th r e s
i r
tcSpe eeouc e e eca cnS t
T e eSe toeio o
yof w m.
n A
b l
e h
m s
l i t u n o
MCse r
u mtapt iT e
ml cf t
or o t
r u
m n
a f
i qC e
er peo u
eN o "s opt i a
Arehiu enr i r st t
aalpm R
sl ly a
nf nt S
r i a Rpr Pp t
en ooin g q See me d e nr spor Sek no r s S Cnre d
Ss s i
r t st e a
r T
T i a n e o
am e
i e
T T
r Rd n s
oo Naio u
Cit Cs oCe i
wp",h Cumhag pot u lc C
q n
LS r
tcn e o r
r t
t u
e e
eedCa e
t egt o
h no hllaf 1 o
o Rnf h h eGs N
3 h
c r
r h
h eA N
Tfum h
n r
T f
1 " aoc T
t Di Tt ficc re i
i fi u
NE cc G
i ee c
)
OG C
pp M
7 8
0 0
t ss I
(
SN 4
4 4
5 S
d 6
ae SA 4
A A
A A
A b i a
r n
UH A
wu CC 3
3 3
3 3
ISF 3
3 3
3 3
3 tag a
b a c w
3 CM t
DO a
) )
CM a
(
(
C
- i
)
T N
E n
n M
o o
E i
t t
i c
c R
I A
A e
U 3.
0 3
1 1
r 1
3 Q
3 u
E 3
3 3
3 3
s 3
R 3
3) 3 4
o C
4 S
le le(
e le te l
T bb b a tb b
te b
c a
n C
a6 a1 a
a b
T1 T2 T
T a
E T
T T
N E
M P
E n
C R
io 1
I i
n 1
t U
d io 3
5 1
Q n
tc 3
3 o
1 E
C A
3 3
3 R
e e
2 8
l 3
l 5
S b
b T
3 3
a R
a 3
I 3
3 T
S T
3 e
e b
c s
n a
le n
w r
la n
n l
o n
E ate io to S
nd i
i7 h
4 a e -
a n
vP u
dn t
h c a
o r
ne G
s t
ce ui M
ue c
ah NN h
f t
sh A
a n
- 3. w AO mf aT ig eo c
t e
wr w
, d HI e
T sh S) gr f
e 2n t
C A yt E4 n na n
t n
. a*
1 iM an
.n ET St Veo r
a o
e a
4 s
w VN l
h Fdi f
f ed o t
ti g om o
dnd T E ot Boc nn I
r e
AMA oli oi o
M
.u ne oat t
CM n
r n
o r
S Mo i u i
s
.S I U oi f (
3h u
o nT t
R R Cq i
t c
d q i
e2 t
wI nb d e d
fo1 TS ee le T
d*
i
,s r r n og e u a
r S
dis w
aS e
E uo nd in e sc N
c e
t RI st aud cS h
e eA per E
s h h n n
hF sd u t
en E3 G
cSo AC t
S o o t
ye r o p
R y
a mS R3 N
Pt let t
i s
s bh b E h
ON A
c y.
b o e of d T t
nC t
o d m ni MO H
nAl aHr P
e.
e o A
e e
r o le r
r s n St e no ee ivo isr ab",
TI C
mTi it a
ic f
p hb a2 s
et vt MC F
nI d od e ml i
t i
t r c eu nr E
O ae e n eh 8
h m ict oue e n p
ee r
r E
nin nn r u en mp3 t
S Y
nt a
f L
o o
m r
n eF e i u
O B
R hi api n e e
r n
a wk wo sb C Ct e 5" mh A
A t
r t
ie h
L M
lewl o
scs i
n o T
t u
c b
oe st i t y
b f
e lo s2 nl T ne r
nb e
t c
t M
bd a t t t
aer nnd c a o r
o e e set mt ic ej a oe U
r ce ea n
t i
l e ap mlpM lec1 eI ng mi Stab S
r pl o r
o ey Gtnra op n e ein nn i7 r t in ei i h nim u
L ie De e r
uf d
mp r
ut e aoo qP n qa P
o ns e qt b ht e
o eS Or e r
u ei e a'o f
aar r
r h Cd r
ele et t
e".
h tsb wla a
L t
t t f
a c
n h ue o sd oisb c
u 5
e r
ot c
ino e
va nt c n1 h
t Pd ie r
r la eA t
i t
od t
t cfis ee e l
lan lio oOe r
nh e uci b
p eb n r
v i
l r
i f Li e eb d e e ms o vaa vc et u
yeq a
mn epr u
r c eom t
wd ulis r n ih e r s s
N e
u u b
lit o
i Spe sF e is s
r e
r ri nt e na laou Sac Sr l
nr ph ar uis wiw i q Tt e T o i
i ci n
uG o
qpy t
en s ota ot t
f p q i
a e pt n Rnp Rt ped t
Tt r r i a
d ne n
es s
a d
t r
Sne Sem Sels Smk Se o te rS T i t St r
T do me T me T ec TT T d a a
Cep Cui Cu n Ci lo Cc Cea e
r r
n ur i
so c
r u r
ec p et et a e qe eg ei u
h sq h a h s v s u
T lps T ine nh h
h o_h t
e n e s N
Ti c T
t i
TL l
a r
r e
cc r
i i
f i
u NE
)
f oo G
)
)
OG C
C C
0 e e c
8 9
p p M
I
(
(
(
SN 5
6 7
2 2
_3 s s SA 2
2 2
M M
_M ae u
t UH M
M M
wu b :
u.
r CC 3
3
_3 aG a
S F 3
3 3
3 3
I
_3 tac h
DO 3
3 3
s CM u
)
)
CM(
ni
(
_