ML20198D445

Partially Withheld Assessment of Allegation AQ-131 to Allegation Category Qa/Qc 5A, Repair,Rework & Maint, Re Electrical Boxes Shipped to Facility in Damaged Condition or Repaired by Unauthorized Personnel

ML20198D445
Person / Time
Site:	Comanche Peak
Issue date:	06/07/1985
From:	Livermore H, Watson V NRC, NRC - COMANCHE PEAK PROJECT (TECHNICAL REVIEW TEAM)
To:
Shared Package
ML20198C597	List: IA-85-517, Partially Withheld Assessment of Allegation AQE-41 to Allegation Category Qa/Qc 6, QC Insp Re Worn Gauges Used to Calibr Lighting Restraint Cable Tools Resulting in Incorrect Installation & Issuance of Nonconformance Rept ML20198C594 ML20198C616 ML20198C640 ML20198C704 ML20198C711 ML20198C794 ML20198C831 ML20198C859 ML20198C871 ML20198C883 ML20198C897 ML20198C933 ML20198C974 ML20198D040 ML20198D103 ML20198D141 ML20198D170 ML20198D231 ML20198D267 ML20198D290 ML20198D314 ML20198D348 ML20198D373 ML20198D377 ML20198D391 ML20198D411 ML20198D419 ML20198D424 ML20198D427 ML20198D432 ML20198D437 ML20198D445 ML20198D450 ML20198D460 ML20198D471 ML20198D479 ML20198D487 ML20198D492 ML20198D507 ML20198D510 ML20198D523 ML20198D529 ML20198D534 ML20198D545 ML20198D554 ML20198D559 ML20198D565 ML20198D576 ML20198D585 ... further results
References
FOIA-85-59, FOIA-85-89 NUDOCS 8605230275
Download: ML20198D445 (2)

Text

. _ __

I

1. Allegation Category: QA/QC 5A, Repair, Rework, and Maintenance

2. Allegation Number: AQ-131

3. Characterization: It is alleged that electrical boxes were shipped to Comanche Peak Steam Electric Station (CPSES) in a damaged condition or were damaged and then repaired by unauthorized personnel.

4. Assessment of Safety Significance: The NRC Technical Review Team (TRT) reviewed the testimony of the allecer and the invoices associated with  !

this allegation. The electrical equipment was sold by RLS Industries, Inc. to Tyson Building Co. This company was fulfilling the conditions of Subcontract CP-0712, which was issued for construction of four nonsafety-related buildings at CPSES (an administration building annex, two combustible-material storage buildings, and the operations support center).

The TRT learned that the electrical boxes in question were located in the floor of the administration building annex. Tyson Building Co. was under contract to build the administration annex and, therefore, was responsible for completing this work.

The repair work involved filling in the floor around the boxes and replacing the floor tile. The TRT determined by observation that the electrical boxes, which distribute 120-volt power to the telephone lines throughout the center of the building, have never been damaged.

5. Conclusion and Staff Positions: Based on the evidence reviewed, the TRT concludes that this allegation cannot be substantiated. The electrical boxes were not damaged, as alleged, and only the floor around the boxes and the tile covering the boxes were repaired. In addition, this electri-cal equipment is nonsafety-related and is installed in a nonsafety-related area.

The TRT was unable to contact this alleger to discuss its findings and conclusions.

7. Attachments: None.

( (

Reference Documents:

1. NRC' allegation review case number 4-84-A-49, April 3, 1984.

2. Texas Utilities Service Inc., Subcontract #CP-0712.

~

"s50523055 B60512~~ 7

-PDR -FOIA. I

_9ARDE85-99_.. . P DR . . . , . . _) 0-143

8. This statement prepared by: f/Acww Y. h, 6/6/f5 V. Watson, TRT Date' Technical Reviewer Reviewed by: 1A24M t -

H. Livermore, Date Group Leader Approved by:

Vincent Noonan, Date Project Director 0-144