ML20136D670

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Cost Analysis Group (Cag) Comments on Regulatory Impact Analysis of Proposed Revs to 10CFR73.71, 'Reporting of Safeguards Events.'
ML20136D670
Person / Time
Issue date: 03/25/1985
From:
NRC OFFICE OF RESOURCE MANAGEMENT (ORM)
To:
Shared Package
ML20136C160 List:
References
FOIA-85-361 NUDOCS 8511210343
Download: ML20136D670 (2)


Text

- . . . . ~ . . . . -

'J. .

(

THE COST ANALYSIS GROUP'S (CAG) COMMENTS ON THE REGULATORY IMPACT ANALYSIS OF THE PROPOSED REVISIONS T0 t

10 CFR 73 71 -- REPORTING 0F SAFEGUARDS EVENTS ared by:

COST ANALYSIS GROUP

,,0FFICE OF RESOURCE MANAGEMENT l Nuclear Regulatory mission

.1 j

PT O,

agginggggaestoaa DELLE 5-361 PDR

  • A o* , ,

THE COST ANALYSIS GROUP'S (CAG) COMMENTS' ON TFE REGULATORY IMPACT ANALYSIS OF THE PROPOSED REVISIONS TO 10 CFR 73.71 -- REPORTING OF SAFEGUARDS EVEN This report is a review of the cost analysis portion of NMSS's value impact analysis of the Proposed Revisions to 10 CFR 73.71 -- Reporting of Safeguards Events.

The report Group's (CAG) is provided under the direction of the Cost Analysis Charter.

J The value impact analysis clearly.shows cost reductions to both the NRC and industry resulting from the proposed revisions. Our review concludes that no major changes are required. There are, however, some reccmmendations we offer which'may be of use, even to future value impact analyses.

First, there exist two handbooks which should be followed when preparing a value impact analysis. One is "A Handbook for Value-Impact Assessment,"

NUREG/CR-3568, and the other is "A Handbook for Cost Estimating," NUREG/CR-t 3971. Second, the analysis assumes there exist 48 sites. According to i

j " Licensed Operating Reactors," NUREG-0020, Vol. 8, No.12, December 1984, j there are presently 85 operating power reactors on 56 sites. We understand that your analysis of total industry cost is dependent upon the total number of industry reports made to the NRC, not the number of sites, hence this j

modification will have no change on your " bottom-11ne" estimate. Fourth, in confirming your calculations, we were unable to replicate one estimate. On

'{

Page 3, under Loc Entries, you report the Industry cost / year to be $17.4K. We

- calculate the value to be $18K, but this has no significant impact on your results. Last, while paperwork cost burden is adequately addressed in the cost analysis, a specific statement should be. included under 2. Statutory Considerations.

e a

h e

9