ML20134H601
| ML20134H601 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 09/06/1990 |
| From: | Claxton G, Williamson E NRC OFFICE OF INVESTIGATIONS (OI) |
| To: | |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20134F836 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-96-475 NUDOCS 9702110380 | |
| Download: ML20134H601 (9) | |
Text
_ . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ _ _ . - ~ _ _ _ _ . _ . . _ _ _ _ _ _ _
a REPORT OF INTERVIEW WITH b WILLIAM M. STOKLEY l
On June 27, 1990, ST0KLEY, President, Stokley Enterprises, Inc., was intervieweo at his place of business, 880 Avenue J, Norfolk, Virginia, by Nuclear Regulatory Commission Investigators Gary H. Claxton and E. L. Williamson.
ST0KLEY was interviewed to determine his knowledge of and involvement in the shipment of 22 Potter and Brumfield, Inc. (P&B), motor-driven relays (MDRs) that were sent to the Carolina Power and Light (CP&L) Shearon Harris Nuclear Plant (SHNP). Upon receipt at SHNP, these relays were suspected of being previously used. Subsequent inspection and electrical testing revealed that the relays had been cosmetically changed to appear new and they did not meet the minimum testing requirements to perform their intended function.
STOKLEY said.he has been the owner and president of his own company since 1085. He said prior to establishing Stokley Enterprises, he worked for Bay Marine, Inc., Norfolk, Virginia, as a buyer and seller of military surplus materials. He said he had worked for the Newport News Shipbuilding Company, Newport News, Virginia, for 3 years as an electrician. He said he worked 1 year for KWAT Enterprises. Norfolk, Virginia, an electrical supply firm, as a buyer / sales representative for 1 year and was the part owner of B&D Electrics, Norfolk, Virginia, for 5 years. He said B&D was a manufacturer of electrical components. He said he attended Old Dominion University for 1 year. He explained that most of his working life he had been associated with buying and selling surplus electrical components. !
ST0KLEY said he buys surplus material from all over the country and he was not !
sure where the 22 MDRs in question had actually come from. He said he had the I relays in stock in his warehouse when Peter TOLBERT, President Spectronics, i Inc., Mobile, Alabama, called him to inquire about purchasing some relays. He !
said that he does a lot of business with Spectronics adding that Spectronics {
was the P&B authorized distributor for the southeastern United States. He I said when he was asked by TOLBERT to send the relays to SHNP, he did not know it was a nuclear power plant. He said if he had known that fact, he would not have sent the relays because he did not deal with components that would be used in a nuclear application. He said because Spectronics wanted the relays as soon as possible, he drop-shipped them via United Parcel Service (UPS) directly to SHNP and billed Spectronics.
He said the relays shipped to SHNP were not new relays but "new surplus." He .
I explained that "new surplus" are components that have not been previously l used, but are not factory new. He said that if a customer asks for new l components, he will attempt to get new parts, but, he added, he advises the l customer that what they are getting is surplus material. He said everyone he ,
deals with knows that he primarily handles surplus materials and that is why !
they call him.
He said all of the relays he sends out are subjected to continuity checks to determine if the contacts will open and close. He said no electrical testing .
instrumentation is used and no elaborate testing is performed. He said he l EXHlBIT_ 9
'!" PAGE_ l 0F_ 'I PAGE(S) 9702110390 V70204 PDR F07A ,f , , - L'> [l/l'/
LAMBERTf6-475 PDR / (
a *~ .
does some minor refurbishing of relays as well as other electcical components which he s' ells. He explained that when these components come frca surplus, they might be dirty and oxidized, so he or his employees will cosmetically I clean up the various components. He said the clean-up usually includes cleaning the exterior with solvent, putting new paint on the hold-down nuts, cleaning and replacing contacts if necessary, and subjecting the relays to i electrical continuity testing. He said nothing internally is altered, and only cosmetic improvements are made. He said the manufacturer's labels /name plates are never changed or altered in any way.
I ST0KLEY stated if the component did not meet his standards, i.e., the contacts would not open, he would throw the part away or cannibalize the unit and use parts from it for another unit. He said since he deals primarily in surplus, most of his purchases come from the Navy and the Navy is also one of his larger customers. He said most of the parts he deals with, including relays, motor controls, switches, and circuit breakers, are sold back to the Navy to be used on ships. He said that even though his inventory is maintained in his head, he does maintain records, identifying what each customer purchases. He said all of his customers know that he deals in surplus, and wFen ordering, they do not specify what application the part will be used for.
STOKLEY stated that in early June 1990, he received a call from TOLBERT inquiring where he (ST0KLEY) had gotten the relays which had been sent to SHNP. ST0KLEY said he told TOLBERT he had gotten them from surplus. STOKLEY said TOLBERT related that someone from SHNP had chiled P&B complaining about the relays. He said SHNP had tested the relays and they did not meet their acceptance standards and SHNP personnel inouired as to where he had gotten the components. TOLBERT also told him (STOKLEY) that these 22 relays would l probably be coming back to him for credit. ST0KLEY said he has since had other conversations with TOLBERT but not about these specific relays.
ST0KLEY said he sent the MDRs to SHNP on May 30, 1990, and he provided the invoice, purchase order, and UPS documentation for the shipment. He said, in the past, he has sold P&B relays to Spectronics and has also purchased new relays from Spectronics for sale to other customers.
ST0KLEY did not provide any additional information at this time. The substantive portion of the interview was concluded and ST0KLEY gave verbal approval for the Office of Investigations to review his records and observe his storage and work areas. l
< INVESTIGATOR'S NOTE: During the interview ST0KLEY was extremely nervous i and appeared to be evasive in his responses. Because he appeared to be less than honest and forthright during the interview, it was decided to limit the interview and concentrate on reviewing the records that he had voluntarily made available to prevent possible destruction of records pertinent to this interview.
I i
Case No. 2-90-014 2 i
1
n This Report of Interview was prepared on July 26, 1990.
adw-E. L. Williamson, Sr. Investigator Office of Investigations Field Office, Region II '
/)
V .l/ r. , )
Ah L Gary H. Claxten, Investfgato'r Office of Investigations Field Office, Region II Reviewed by: e Date: // f/4/ro V / ' ,
a i
1 i
Case No. 2-90-014 3
72cuc' tM. z/,.<'mgm
)~ PLACEa DATE/ TIME: b/au Ef n19C /:$/o,,,
s' I, Nff/ t s , M./uk2Ze . do hereby make the following voluntary 4
statement to d4e 8/r/2Eri who has identified himself to me as an Investigator with the United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission. I do.hereby make this voluntary statement without any threats having been made against me or any promises extended to me.
//bt dfM orwhc, Du19 s) <t/ hk&.a, diUT1 n' us Jar, so de L c h e 7 ,,, & b L ,.
O s 'insr/c<'s cwinx fo /As 1l&f L ka ~
di J xassiis/
Si'ss2:1s,:ur <:
sinc ts / Mins tia, 2dt/2A FNsuh /&L .adA1 D .jstads/ns & . B u Z/2 M %
Ntdb- od' s
~ t/di M .-l<f.t s.2 - 2231/> A JNtOAI A il 274s-u" sxs. c1 tt<-, M 'ctj ./dus{_
211dd)21d Xe del Y/ d'J'A . dit2TtAA<E/$ O2K 2/d/- J1' 24! Aldt//a
) A b b Y' fnM? /m4b' /-M' & NodAw Artss ktwit /fE16. f A2$I,4%W $/b'nh 9/<tNCtd 4A >,
C v fA.AtA'<% /k!l ti/1 Ab+A'At, t ' Y <2 d A , j)2/ m 2A nt/ m I
. ' /Y b hs AAsid'd, hat 77) 4/C4 dtb4 W .keAb-
.h / rts 1itcA k/M J / /t4-3 A. WaterM JfL22AvYsX Y J dou &dru, s i u r' ' n d oi 'f'o ~AAss' a stu h d k d- f b /: l db//4AftY. Y NC AW Y f}Xl 2 f?dt'NDxtr. 6t bAnuh) (E4titt/
YndnjfAws. yf &
Af1*W l
hYdf AM4241/Aj's 0 4du/
n u k m st .4 M s af kod A 'A ,otn 1sbwNs,
&CNits. :$) Y' '790L/,oAl Nt"<M &
}su Ix svtcv ns&s Jax ihesJ A ' A le d Of<
i! Ad/td $$, f4$ Ak'2f 'dNd &M i hfitV1IMhCftd '
d A17/suva- 25LfVor itOb&r/>WA,1 & < Adds;6e
- ),, s ie d e & n s h ei- s '
esAG Wdd Ar V
uX:/udstw' "
/dwin .n w w s do s A e e d n 2 tobm d> %
O b n' Yd / rt W J r1 &- /d&te- OdLWl?CJAd
(
/241 c: Ai -/,nrfW ,
r/ no 22dain4 .3+So a % ~ d m /'
A Y /2/t / NM 'dA'tAAfLA C.eh$1 JAfW /22# R d'd A b ~
'd dra 2 : # L i<1 afd Addi2/ da 244so A m 5L/JJ)'1 Y b,l.DA-/
be hJ .thfLe //// .
1
- it '!
Pa
' EXbe 8IT 1 i. of 5 J /
7p 9o_g;,
6gx PAGE / OF [ PAGE(S)
N sa 21dddst2'Ud' A>P JJdw 'zkm cse ?DCA/dda
.n< xn'dt41d 2 cws.1 JR. xse da<<1' //tess 2W,'
-t9 EJA u x u di Add J!"imAl %/2,b cw J s ea.
.56f '),erdh Ar jZir:Le- daajo sexXs' sur' C </xf dir' cid!?t L%-,1 di s<n e'a AArt/d C~ O<fdir J x A ' d a B 2 Vr/ xdsw ci schwicues sda y AJ A ua 1/ 2:b . -wu 4e'>t GA w ika, e% L k o2e'!4 oresAs1 ktosadsu ded' cAumia 1.4 sJJZ/is
% n / O ft dru fs 14 da/L, Y)5&sjdL A
) &dN e- D2 twsrsu/ nDo m s asA5s Aes sc' '
jeiA' daim YJs 1sr2
- /d.i. e<<w1E '
,T l Ar$bdf A 4in;;2- JA?s Af On MON & 01475C s )
s J" sari w'A, ondtXn-b sesw1/a &-
2n an L M Akb xdsO% 1/ st d &sA x s yll.m J 1 A h u jt s 6 2 . zs , k',, a u ici % ~
/ sos ,
sss chsn /rttA' $ */ 2&, Afds r ez fo 2 9)sss -
ds 2m Aleys/1 % A&isa xsm _J
}[htw v A& cBr' onha sd Any sm 1 clad ens J 2a sj >191L % &m' .< ark '%o 1 ff M Y b'r /MDL EdY AJrtztW /Ansirbs #dV>-/
x M A f d 4s srxAsn crA> dbrdA A>AsMM
(, /M, Ldhsiais '0)A wroh/ AndssA lVxs//J- AM/n i Y fls >>n f>> A N N N>es AAAnaves_ b'w ks -o%rd e ,s 6' ,, 6 1 ass a L A Ami-,-
om-, adt)7J/nf e s.-re n .s D x -> A ff A M A <., '
Jrt$YwZs' sws in A ts,7- A At241 s' / p 44 ' Arab w
/suWtJ Asiv'.d> erit Aome 23' 4 A*Adkc 'lbf fb
/h fo d? s-,eso J42zrn (d ts L bME/usW
.a ints cF s,,,-w %1 ma, As An> was .
M. A s d 2 d J c o n d ei s, y u n dl A . &'touArd-s!wf s1,was. J m.-d/s+' .rh' a na DA <r-o -
0l(111 Af 25/9 /s '+ 1 Yb o'/t dYk Hu 1 J na d Xo >dA :/r M Ansrb A i <2
($,/$.!!/r/a r, shN!/ -hdd A$$r d241'hJ JA ? UAtl55 l U &&dej W &' '
'Am , -rsm dEcomd-s N' N0/n57s "if
,a;;2c>ttts b ers y 42A uiAs^ C Yek M^Y5 i)fA Kt/
s r
Y& hi r-I A$Kbx dA > A4'AYY n LfA1 Statement Continuation- Page ( .7) of ( 6) .
9
.--~_,.J w..w% e .4. g. +-- -;a- r'a A ~6a.-, - - .
4..iw _su. .Ja-.a+,mi a.4 .d 4.rs3.- *J4.4da.J - - - -
..*....._*w.w,.4.-.., :5 n .,;.w,,m._A A a.h.. .a.6_a...-.ageu-Am.aas e
O A d m , a 1 A k e & & f L s/ /. R J ,i A % k w e s d d e d ZA: }/wL osd At aufAs sodd/ j<>& h d' dsat v A' s ? / . n J.i Ao n / h a s w i b /.1 Q 8M AV84 /ace1& Xssa Acteudb Ms ,Q.fo3 bea 7' 4jfsw nm W e sea-ax m%z o Aeof s' '
-<uao aiAls/sA a m , Qttd t" A s A s h ~
2 ,r d -
cal + -ts'u ..wisfjffx A A '/dlufo, ~
V We.eAd' J d Ht. ds#d A &
J . n o 2 1. s -c m1 /o2Yis
? Ltd' .6tmad4/s' #)nA2 <o-Ass'.
4As 2sak zo <<s Du 4:2dezzA'W . J-n.s , &
l mDM su Aizzms' <d mwh as'A
&Krs/ s visd % si - <W mArd As/
MTu:<L.s Alt ookhzT, ddsene //s K k s"at
.2Wm A /nz/ AFM 2 xWCAd' JJu 26 hs.K h ZbAMW /MDA- IW %&&' 2d2/M x ,>zi Ar Nt/
. s. ~ ~ n a a . - m !'"
JJ W M MS mA (desk /a) K n -A w 1
A sVsb d 6 mi' sns2.4 A ia .-ets u - .-
AWMAlis . t/ 4tAtw .risto-- hwAAu 4?x2u/d . 6t su'1'on 2xs1 Ana.-u2' s4
- i<s-s' & n h s1 fonss' soc e- ' af a cd' W 2 u -Se k beam i1ci / - V V
%) .dneJ Dn8n A ssa 1A, JM N de o xus:.1// a>n zw / Pr .da lEs E d &24 1u . JJ-ja -rree krs m Cr da E iStsj sj f & <? a " M e w
/HM174$.brs'<y' fdf} AW' 58) m d'A4ftsr x'stA19/m
-Btano7Eo \.S A /s s e r m n L #A M M sN
. hida Mrs/urs as .ksin - m A'1' o i k dA
.&tt ut7's d /A , cr t h <v' ns o "J 2x s a siq' mM . 't!ss Osou, %u J nm su27 'aurro re a n A-sts/puul Ar7sb k < Atx-e&a~/ .. 6 /1 rsta l WAt! Enstff D ars 'sratr <o Vnt7 w m 2' 22' %)x470
w~z Jun 4' esas zu, 1AbeL a 6s t2'c d c' A/LA %0 et'o d fW t>/re k dao <&2- J a'u/ A Assb~
m m s/uhL <<
"in v as s 2e e swww " ~
Statenent Continuation - Page (.3) of - i f
i l
/ /* EbldW Ef"* Yb (l41sf,/hs.4,69/
?'uAS) lo/ 2/ooL joAAs d /' u ; / s Asehw 7/u m%J , J hr:/ AsmmAen xjAr/ a2/
Y / 0 Ydf/ f/57 AD/<Ttxs Ast MA Au>&s Pac >rs s, w'.nW J m n,,ns d<A A)-ds m A/S W Wef? / 9 2 D L .'s t / ,1 d ese 9 M // f Q 'l1 h W 41
'N*. ~~ Y<1 & Yda //}D A & ,
.Asi Wns, 'dM's .J/o 414e Jn
\
J &>;rs A1/ Wodhe, . J "dM mat Awe n-sm enaxq A>ild (Z-wAi d dos 2som a/x'vd .26 mM s.
w0 houszd 'sd M Adsr.: Ar4cf x n : 1 1
-+tsidA2dA 4YdAf &&n mutoNs Asocu dsts/ m~an najred ACLP Atsa, nes aAdof Jhu 'r%, -
W (2f//
- bAl W) Aff./ $W NY& W s, L %w/w AAttn/ // W Als reirs &b 1/114.t.Y.
J dos /f s is Ades 1sm>' -ceE2 ids 4s
/w sms o Assf 2%f 2/s A 22 mm N rR1 V
Jnfo c m%&n sn /dul.
L M e rte, N!,* A200/xs- Ga<Ms M $s f N4 YW JG&dM%::1,t"- $1_ Den ,t;ot*A 2 M~ d3s) l dem u9 io n r k To eAss l 2Asm nJ. dJn i EAeons td -23 .& siottWoo siufI As/<3 DL noy >&<,i--
3 ' m a ',?s M ' Assa' a 6tsb h%Asm MM nad' eA d /.Zrti enstWnfo . / 1
/
/
\O '
N
/
. Tf1 n Q N / !
~~
N/ TnoV'
/K
/ \
- / .
l
/ W 9N %
/
N .
l / N l N l
Statement Continuation- Pace (y) of (()
t
, T ' i. r- -
. . Q;. ,, p ..
^
W ' \ /
\ . L. /
.K - /:
.; , . A /
N /
N / .
l x / .
.- N /
. .. N / -
. ~. c x /
N / -
a.n . N / -
N/ '
[N 9.4 - / N
- 'v . /r N
~ sa:- / \
- . e:, . / N -
> '/ \ \
/ \
/ N K
.;< v'. pg4. . /
- g.'- @'.Wjo 6.< n -
N
\.
dh 4M6TC \
OCff. 4p; .
s
- .[.
7 61 have read the foregoing statement consisting of __ h handwritten / typed i
'pages. I have made and initialed any necessary corrtictions and have signed my name in ink in the margin of each p,ag . swear that the foregoi ta ement is
. true.and correct. Signed on (m- - O at b .ebt .
Ns 11 ; h h o.
k k
- SIGNATURE: b 0
NAME
. ; Subscribed and sworn to before me this a80 1 day of C o w ,
l99h4963-st 710^ /'/L Ibuhco I INVESTIGATOR: # O Ee I [fi/ M
- a - .
WITNESS: [ Y // / d [ a e o I KAMElnTLE StatementContinuation-Page([of([
c .
l .
i i
l I
, _ , . _ ~ _
MEMORANDUM OF ::ALL Previous editions usable 70 l
l l b YOU WERE CALLED BY- YOU WERE VISITED BY-d 1
OF (Organuation) i I
l l b _ EASE PHONE > FTS .OVON i
- WILL CALL AGAIN O iS WAiTi~c TO SEe v0u
- O aETUaNEO voua CAtt O WISHES AN APPOINTMENT utssmot , ,. <
<0
.M If' sv 't Lil j 4.h4 4 (w'?(gr . ./ , 9 )4f r
, W y $s y }$ .
') et 1 IJNR V y '3)a RECE4VED av 4.? s-OAT- , TIME l ,
- bl$51 1 0 j
sillo NSN 7540-00434 4013 STANDARD FORM 43 (How,344 4
- CPO 1986 0 - 157-353 NR C 01-11.6 1 i l I i
i I l
4x ( (l
~
i ,,.
!