ML20126G970
| ML20126G970 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Issue date: | 10/10/1984 |
| From: | Bunting J NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| To: | NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR MATERIAL SAFETY & SAFEGUARDS (NMSS) |
| Shared Package | |
| ML20126G220 | List: |
| References | |
| FOIA-85-170 NUDOCS 8506180198 | |
| Download: ML20126G970 (15) | |
Text
&
= CLL'D
[... .. . ,%, UNITED $TATES O' '% NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION j,
o a
l WAsHINofoN. D C. 20sss 5
4....*e OCT10 $
MEMORAN0UM FOR: The File FROM: Joseph 0. Bunting, Chief Policy and Program Control Branch Division of Waste Management
SUBJECT:
REPORT ON TRIP TO ATTEND AMFM PANEL MEETING On September 5 and 6, 1984, Neil Numark and I attended the seventh meeting of DOE's Advisory Panel on Alternative Means of Financing and Managing Radioactive Waste Facilities, in San Antonio, Texas.
With the exception of Sid Stoller, all members present at the meeting strongly supported taking the high-level waste program out of 00E. Based on guidance from Secretary Hodel, Chairman O'Scannlain conducted a vote to determine the members' views. The Panel voted that a mixed public private corporation best met criteria developed by the Panel of an acceptable waste management organization, followed by an independent federal agency or commission and a private corporation. Sid Stoller maintained that it was unrealistic to recommend taking the program out of 00E. The Chairman favors the mixed public private corporation option. Public comments were heard from Middle South Services and the Texas Governor's Office.
The next Panel meeting will be held September 25 and 26 at 00E headquarters.
Two additional meetings are scheduled prior to submission of the Panel's report to 00E, which has been retargeted for November 15.
'~
7
, ,, ! (, ,hi c 4.
Joseph 0. Bunting, Chief
, Policy and Program Control Branch y Division of Waste Management 0506100190 050423 PDit FOIA EYE 05-170 PDH
i" DISTRIBUTION f WM s/r ;
MfSS r/f i
NNumark i
! MKearney [
- 003/NN/84/9/20/0 JSurmeier l OCT 1019M DMattson ll PAltomare J8unting i
LHigginbotham MEMORANDUM FOR: The File LBarrett L i
HMiller '
FROM: Joseph 0. Bunting, Chief HKnapo Policy and Program Control Branch RBrowning Division of Waste Management MBe11
! SU8 JECT: REPORT ON TRIP TO ATTEN0 AMFM j PANEL MEETING i,
3 l On September 5 and 6, 1984 Neil Numark and I attended the seventh meeting of ;
DOE's Advisory Panel on Alternative Means of Financing and Managing Radioactive
!} Waste Facilities, in San Antonio, Texas. :
/ ,
With the exception of Sid Stoller, all members present at the meeting strongly L supported taking the high-level waste program out of 00E. Based on guidance !
from Secretary Hodel, Chairman O'Scannlain conducted a vote to determine the l 1 members' views. The Panel voted that a mixed public private corporation best ;
i met criteria developed by the Panel of an acceptable waste management !
organization, followed by an independent federal agency or commission and a !
I private corporation. Sid Stoller maintained that it was unrealistic to l
!- recommend taking the program out of 00E. The Chairman favors the mixed i
, public private corporation option. Public comments were heard from Middle !
j South Services and the Texas Governor's Office, f
i The next Panel meeting will be held September 25 and 26 at 00E headquarters. 5 i
Two additional meetings are scheduled prior to submission of the Panel's report i j to 00E, which has been retargeted for November 15.
r l
! I4 Joseph 0. Bunting, Chief
- Policy'and Program Control Branch l
! Olvision of Waste Management j I l k -
I i
- I l
l i
- See previous concurrence [
j
.....f............f............f........................
f NAMENNumark:ch :MKearney :J8uriting : : : :
l ....................h.....h...................................................................
DATE$84/09/20 $ ie i,(o f l l l l
{
O!STRIBUTION 91 sf NMSS r/f NNumark
MKea rney 003/NN/84/9/20/0 DMattson gg 1 0M JSurmeier PAltomare J8unting Uitgginbotham HEMORAN0UM FOR: Robert E. Browning, Director L8arrett Division of Waste Management MKnapp HMiller FROM: Joseph 0. Bunting, Chief MBell Policy and Program Control Bra h Division of Waste Management
SUBJECT:
REPORT ON TRIP TO ATTEN0 AMF PANEL MEETING On September 5 and 6, 1984, Neil Numark an/ I attended the seventh meeting of DOE'sAdvisoryPanelonAlternativeMeans/fFinancingandManagingRadioactive Waste Facilities, in San Antonio, Texas. /
/
WiththeexceptionofSidStoller,all,demberspresentatthemeetingstrongly supported taking the high-level waste program out of 00E, Based on guidance from Secretary Hodel, Chairman O'Sca lain conducted a vote to determine the members' views. The Panel voted th a mixed public private corporation best met criteria developed by the Panel f f an acceptable waste management organization, followed by an indeppndent federal agency or commission and a private corporation. Sid Sto11erjmaintained that it was unrealistic to recommend taking the program out/of 00E. The Chairman favors the mixed pubife private corporation opti n. Public comments were heard from Middle South Services and the Texas G ernor's Office.
The next Panel meeting will e held September 25 and 26 at 00E headquarters.
Two additional meetings are/ scheduled prior to submission of the Panel's report to 00E, which has been retargeted for November 15. -
)
Joseph 0. Bunting, Chief Policy and Program Control Branch Division of Waste Management
'E..l*"!!../3E.l..c. .y . . . . . l *"" ?. . . . . . . . l . . . . . . . . . . . . l . . . . .
NAME :NNumark:ch :MNea :J8unting : : : :
DATE :84/09/21 : : : : : :
494 3;e . cl 2 4 , % AVA
- o. od M c~ , +/4 v, en
/ .
- sc AfL # <<d /LJ; sus I
p sc#sc- ~4-
/R-sda y' a, >7 a'4A, ek .
rr ,Af
/~Ay !JS-,
c>alc<d A c% 4 sAy < c4 neuct. c .
c4 S'cL~s, t.
51Li - c!d/A es,c +/ sa /dblu > y',y y-w!;
Au ,-
0 Sc. . - clew h k n Sl~/ h M SR C. n
- c<ificok - l4!/}ww. cNu cJw/ nat:lz .
.. .e,4 ch.y ,uq h ,:, <.. ..- sy).'s 4~ ,.y/. ,,,, g '
c7
)fa) AsN[5L0ct, demn toy thy Ln 7 mk 4, i.u e % : gwp/xt,i:aC.0,p.;.usd,edAdQ m 4 % /ci /4/..x Dor Av d ,:w/ 27? A p% ,$Gn, , s vif L yl p./ Oc c:y:dk - W (fsld - lb vay tijs.
%dL ,ML . usAs .
~f C
- s,C, uu a --, ap ea
/Q/.2.2 l'NfA /YCW*'y a
SesAf
- i. / r pc<y,ec%u adJ 6> Ayy<- . .(
fy_y_de u .o, h-/y -
/. / ken /l& S d'evMfpe 00E, re. Ge,/ /%., p,y ed
- 2. (c)/Y Orp Cn/;, ac.4 -s. 6,<<cA + -
& ,. . i , e, / S w p y e r p Gi-, - 5 f.) / ., e -, > > F r /K o t?t' p m y e r
-s., - u -
7^. h ci.e p.,,,< s e c ,,,- ,e A a n cl'oAM-birem re b.cac,,!s s A p <ckr< ed 0 0 DbNH
~f$?nO Vcr ag/ /bW .kr rs! k41Avv picnl+u 'yid4eitn,syy e- er,Nic2c ina / sen e e 1 iud x l 4g : l(/t 3 x n d' / Y . (Pig hfenf!er Ve$'s day .
~
l !O l C b X q c l.o ///E3 2-30. ( b $cW.
1 l&$c,I(Nt:c/s,vcc C cu s'/ /c m .7in.l scosm )
l ke i H, Pr,, e
~
Oep n/s 0e &ci/W 7 l U
Pff Sc C s ? / L u Aw/m9.u ackp p/ ca i,.yu AJ a <nen,y .M 1 5, N + sal y -
coa .nre.,,vr en y esy n,yk /q, b>vkg fe te,cla . EM+S i:-s u n . Cr/ bevrht
/irtcutc6 lerms.
(cy.,t/J y,,4- -
i'?O h ec & unes s.,. On svLuic .
o ~ a n, , . n s u //~ s - sa u x
0 ' /?. k AM ddemzusu, 64. Ae/ppnjeef ?
/9 - Aec <cA~ pJ. H7 u p .~g, ><~, A -
cd3 >A4.u.
(be lidA4ea% Bu/c . pond c/--Ano(J lflllom.n 04 flel//. Ik4 Ahs f ;Gm 7~ w4 p Ae 4 (we id &/ervsfink is%/r k to rie.,
\ j'ap + ~
/4 + . T rn/e f /h .
Cl 00m las) - jou.i cue D/) sde se&cAf ?
A h chos e i/. Dor -
An asfu asadup i
- cep/a4 L . EM& nh czs .d< sA .
O L Guw reach-, ./' Ac / un en, N~ la 4<wn-su A.-<.
puddesiaa As. 36 .5'k. .u<a~ h .
l 9 Q .L 9 y,, -
AL/ <dk e.f y n?
A- e 0.&g Guhm .pe/m - 75,A bcA .How256 iced G /sach ise446 alvYars & c'
/f m p 4 cowdat ces schdkle .uad'aevy T,.
7ehp/rach
%Ar - c&s pyee/py kes k ~4 ? -
i f * & t. 9 - hav hase,. /S buj e. .
h'1kl. -t Yo ' be s ?
- n C l c yA
,tv(/
.u . p yA/'wA
/ eel.
L i n L , .
J ,, /.W. S yk O $ fl N W Q$
- Cr l E A$$D O'
\ tk kenf Fu scu,k. /Ar db't)oE
hrN!!"7 /0/)cpy e, o,i duYOm. A&w s, fo,d, +0gr.cyfr u ,
0ncern ,
tyar k l(d /g Ufoy _.c/csN na/
& A prop - cesencs air pe/6 o/
an Rn G A f .. .. . . ..
[ cod yorice S/W;y, rfe' / *jn< V, sc Ae Gs ePAci ed e><ce/Ame, lT o c/y/e, ae.
.98L -
35/ler,la: / ake mg/m f/mmiA-,/oadn,. -
hihmCJ///lrsk&IL. u
/9tnte. - /anc/ shen (beeesw&/ ,6(ar' eeaf S6/e. Am //s ocun %42 C, " //h N/Y's EES, os cu, .dynard C)%uleue -
/x s/<o,y . fisem /.5 AlJ /Lc.r4 , R'A af s/d fd Ms,a ccort{-givy/dFW-A Shtevap y d sv Cec.
N;an/gmA a~L
%f fluuldc-W iwy '
& -cbdmen6k/ -
!!m L A c+c many.
bOsb Naks l(noe fki% - kbc) fit 4-/Y'S nol sp&.
%,, sy, mye, M -J !. <eb 6 ces
%s -
~
no C+c a f s 11 N r$ 2 s & w g ng e . v
/Nm ~& t</ 9 fMN /C c) FCo<) .
AM/ ace - %
k 6Jha/
o ukaa au . 7 my/ue aa yeuA? dA c<
Y eyn+g . A/J h~Jgonir.
7 O%/aa psq SM a hdk - 4 s &c/A ws&M Ais e m + /4 W y'w W 4 4 sa,n /g ,ec m A rencons.
Gi Chance nw 44.ase a di&G,J api,m L&'LJ
. fo cLL s,aWA y is m
aihef a m aqf wh k incupor4 -
% Uaa "- flea ad yod /e,Q . yed 4 -
dud 9/ M oA ch on pak.
Lash ayees. /Je/ewaat y/Ack in ip,/,8 a, xs.
cal /7$4 clf so eAe- ec/0e e/ed -
> %L-SLMAd4M 0 Sc - ,ddJe eduaden .
byet,O' y%- LM Ab JA4 dM W
/t^-
5 r,, . s - wta. 44
$ 9 "1fA :
Scl<da tem udw M,M.
Dew reo) pLif OcE ed ev-Q m Tr.
N// af41 ciu/ hsed' on .M;g
. . - - _ + - . * * - - - - - - --- ""
.. *tr-* *"7* w***=r * * * ' * * * * * - " * * * * * * ' " " * ~ " ~ ' ' '
., e #
fe&M _ - cu / m m b pure.sfy. 9;yx,7Av Ym WAh w>u// glow olown fle. pas .
6,A - ed reo% >JM M ioJ~.. ~
&,y n. ex , .
Ww v4 .u d .4 M a r ej GJ3 rs e .Je %W.Afr*.h On,74 cen s La4- & pa4(y w d4 + mc,o A r .
bJd h ahn Amnuc 91+s%. - %. Ad (nf 4 df (kent acw J;p C>n LL ev&
4 my U cM) de~& ew J & s(w4a re . _ 7 EA
%g - d..JJ n J' /2e , _ c4. nu eue M 4/adw-&-
LX-4 r Mamd u y cro 0x Y - Gbm * -
Ozetsy 0 lcewk &&e .
w sem.a-w--+ee.-a wem,. - . - - .w -
..---e es-e ww w-e.s... emumm-O e e
c J d y oo p ch. & ,_ , / n / A r W r A G . S y /e n . bi/ m/ 44,/h m.
- MM. ara NA _ m
_ A L F 4 ,c 6 - d e ~ yA_ A C9.
L f-4/a//ece Mshe
- A 4ds, y 1, ,
+A /p u m e A6-og es4 as wy. /s 9 i4 nd & .
Nfjdm & ~
0ey%+v
/jeudAL~
OOI/KWS ~
l SOU/~CCS i O/*/ 75 G GJb C1 k 'S Sbhg ut A /ym
///Y /3 : > CJcy4 r 943 pn - ct. ? +ph, c&sJL r .
/?eb, are direbd 4 & 7 4,ed a#- TA;s
/gafihh #d-La4 - glad h rec-end th, , 7_A of vW yb rest % de e u- f r ,e hr.
fbl/act-d, dose yeenCt ore ekuh m/ par /of^4 erali //ay're A mdf.
- osc - 1
(<e, 9cwas , u i9, a ,A a ,o
] . W3 n~ y, h CA /0 .
.. - . - - . .. _.=. . . . - . . . ...-
0 % nn/w ncf /x u Am.
La>A af rec /co p ./Ls c /Niro.n . / ' Kr=- Y 00 . #' "'N ' -
o G/cc-75/nomw cn /4 / !/4. .ox, a///4 c/y/en .
ScAa4 - can alg- dscws vdiA faAmaA -
A4/ a bc -/y-Au eaGfy las4 - /m />yocL/ ph, co-neA. f a les / d n N M ,efkc} cja,p a} f4 /caf ,4 r
09ee-0%- Safec/ D aM A to/9c bo//oPPacw.
/) reen7e' [fn- ?
o{ W/d ans preA reg /G'U/~lr/ ec & clA hs/ /w2p ) .
Thi n L J <ec. , and adey~4 base of censemas hey nof , ore k o/ a l / A r FEf)C0RP Oviales ~?on puMc p,m/x - /E 1 4.e 4 ; G n .>'~ u.
a n d . oa, mgl -
CEO: B y c. W ./Layeeva t 5,4,cfm w x JL_
6xencine : c~v% e dee.4d'.
&couJ in d # so- ,wo4nwk 4
% p. m .n :
evalu b d i.4 ILeh feds.
(&llac<. -
Lfd lane 4 /%d ,A L cEo wt A /Pu
% yAA
% i
. . . .e.--mew w . . . . -.
f)w - /% un /cl a,yd fdd & BO ueld
.hte cro, non va6y, a/9 4 A (sy Ah paby .) . cro A & 6 M- , .
Mu6us aA f-ap&A Only 7Wyya fln Sed
&k. . 03, yew w o M k /s y A Me sy~ud
., wadec/ a L/-7%e boa &, Fads yf4- fedeu.
7/p/ Cm,r w . Ap f LasA - f)%y Cax// & L dae. 4-)# Am 6 f .So wh y is Ja(dJAa/y waQ y . j d cy>. de -, this , c.uW da . a/&a - .9A - cN m, J/ 4r - 4 A4 -
),sie- Si% g 4 ha,du f ) ryJ W A A d m /,a t ,,A J ,d; , a sc / < s. 5xy ne h AcLaJ W l00calaio/cf/er/ vira,y A '23/?yn .
Onc(.e< frDeuf, Ama/wL,f/af m . Sb3 - reW9 2 ot # p y k % , n f ce1/ + n% .s y-p ef a / s s -
~
L a & b a y " n L / W -, de s
<y .
henie - 6Boaro( san (c/ laec Oc. .c//sercny
~
l W //els f eas v e...
/>r Y u foes - S[ A & f/ ' A s:We /Ye'e'es froc s, /k .0$y 0ane//she~// kof de kbkW - Ef cutM Y N M , /IY confo l
}t Akr cy)wbacI d s/ '
<Sk aa //
be- P/r- Agreed hakce,/)ct kb - lobci { reccsu d s s/lt idy l c< Y < c e W & . W 70y Yi fjem.m(p<e/s /2 ~s-
?mmegen -
- e. vtsFrq Sf/Tc procec/m - a>w k' /4y p 4 .r/:6) & nc//'? Kf reAce.g #/ % pmsyk-kenie -
/8 d s{i;(l a dq/ k ve%<. Coune/f consensxs, if paible . C/heca e /3o<( o/m ;f .
deudes)b AA ed / cs /c ye/ g n e l v n s e ,s a s,. teepieeJ4 ofg% be9 ch<sfup)'i J 4/kg, e Wm/ I '1 " ^ ' ' OTc fby os #o/'774 6--ce! d on c!w / ad/s u ,j. fad sy / /> g ~ d,cy.
/urdi ireck /c QL lo d -
(< k (l N e SC enWaf 20ta/A'. 7%,
, 2 ow< ce&'s'c b, u n &
-/o FE0CortP-N .
Aul - hm ya A4 A / s.o dcu % C,-,-/n s . -
/W23 Ad " - ~ L ^- d6A .Au d4 c., 4 s,a w,o hhcc<.ssici, o 0b . 3, Y /)/sMJan of new dra// 0/Fracaeo jnpw _
(Shrkd an 4 Arnie tasi,,,y;/) s a i > cw ie n o k<zgtt fEACO/2 A b enst/wt *Y Cng-ss in asan .tn/ c-4
/saa eaaldds'jicypata/& p,es e . Ten &H. /h d'/6 yp a s a& ray & cn-ep' See macLp a f dra P/.
Tn g s i // o n / s a u 11 ~
/)ircu,, - f 9//7 54Ar pye -
(cs', %l64,efftq a,,(yg asy'l .& cinny % fc u, yth Ac, w ,, - 4 au_ y
4/yM AMpp w. f d> We a:,d L/ M mou.uw m .aoWd. a N v4 - di & f J-fe. O a. ~ <: / r nesrepe af hs/ d ing JL/ My am mGy m A pe & ,e/ M ScLedk
%fra&f chan up w n n s / ,ci.
fn'm's n peyer dea nWrefleol(hnnidbnp) in bew/ Ane!'yt s ll4/ . O n !c C # w a e f A L y l r f a n c~evdec
- s l
I}}