ML20024A276

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Forwards List of Documents Responsive to FOIA Request 82-528 Re Ee Kent Allegations Concerning Facilities from Oct 1980 to Present,Per 821104 Memo.Related Info Encl
ML20024A276
Person / Time
Site: San Onofre  Southern California Edison icon.png
Issue date: 11/17/1982
From: Engelken R
NRC OFFICE OF INSPECTION & ENFORCEMENT (IE REGION V)
To: Carr J
NRC OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATION (ADM)
Shared Package
ML20024A251 List:
References
FOIA-83-154 NUDOCS 8306160281
Download: ML20024A276 (5)
v • d • e


Text

'

,7

,,/ /

p *

  • r. s

/

1UJill D ST Alf s

[

U llCl r Sli !!' G lfl /J1 0 li Y C O f = r ! 0 N j ((j Rt 8 DON V e

J 1?' O M Af.l A t ANI. SusT E 210

c.

nAi Nut ct:t i K. c At ir OHNIA 9E.96 3.'0V 17 tw MEMORA"DUM FOR:

J. C. Carr, Chief, Freedom of Information and Privacy Acts Branch FROM:

R. H. Engelken, Regional Admiraistrator, RV

SUBJECT:

F01A REQUEST FROM ELLIE C0 HEN ET AL.,10R ALL DOCUMENTS REGARDING ALLEGA110NS MADE BY MR. E. EARL KLNT REGARDING THE SAN ON0FRE NUCLEAR GENERATING STATION, UNITS 1, 2 AND 3 FROM OCTOBER 1980 TO THE PRESENT (F01A-82-528)

The following information is provided in response to your memorandum dated November 4, 1982.

1.

The attached is a complete listing of materials and documents possessed by Region V that pertain to the request.

2.

The materials and documents identified as items 1, 2, 4, 9,10,15 and 'i 16 on the attached list are being submitted to be provided to the Alliance for Survival in response to their request.

3.

The materials and documents identified as Items 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, a 13, 14, and 17 are being withheld from public disclosure,at this time, in accordance with the provisions as contained within Sections 9.5(a)(5)(v) of 10 CFR Part 9.

The premature release of these materials and documents could be harmful to the performance of a special inspection currently being conducted at San Onofre Units 1, 2 and 3.

These materials and documents will be released concurrently with the release of the final report of this special inspection.

The report is scheduled for release by mid-December, 1982.

The materials and documents listed in paragraph 3 above will be submitted to you, along with a copy of the special inspection report, on or about mid-December, 1982.

Carol Reed, from your office, stated she would in turn send these materials and documents to the Alliance for Survival in response to their current request.

If you have any questions regarding the above, please contact Bob Faulkenberry 5 h p o(463-3738).

G o$hndW 8306160201 830425 l

PDR FOIA R. H. Engelken GARDEB3-154 PDR Regional Administrator l

cc: Carol Ann Reed Victor Stello, Jr.

H. R. Denton l

J. A. Fitzgerald L-

,' l:

E. EARL KENT ALLEGATIONS Documents 1.

NRC Inspection Report Nos. 50-361/82-27 and 50-362/82-19, da ted October 5, 1982 2.

Memorandum of telecon between John O' Dell (L. A. Times) and D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC; dated October 6, 1982 3.

Memorandum of telecon between E. Earl Kent (alleger) and D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC: dated October 6, 1982 4.

I etter from J. M. Curran (Southern California Edison Company) to D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC; dated October 7,1982; Subject - Transmittal of SCE/Bechtel Audit Package Regarding Allegations by Mr. E. Earl Kent 5.

Eight cassette tapes recording interview of E. Earl Kent on October 5, 1982 by 0. C. Shackleton, P. H. Joukoff and D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC and a 257 page typewritten transcript of these recordings 6.

Statement of E. Earl Kent, dated October 16, 1982 7.

Two cassette tapes recording interview of Donald C. Martin (Bechtel) on October 21,1982 by 0. C. Shackleton and D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC.

8.

One cassette tape recording interview of Woodrow W. Lahr (Bechtel) on October 21,1982 by 0. C. Shackleton and D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC 9.

Letter from D. F. Kirsch, Region V, NRC to Mr. Jarlath Curran (Southern California Edison Company); dated October 27, 1982; Subject - Areas of Kent Tour 10.

Confirmatory Action Ietter, dated October 29, 1982, from R. H. Engelken, Regior,al Administrator, NRC, Region V to Dr. L. T. Papay, Southern California Edison Company.

11. Memorandum for Darrell G. Eisenhut, NRR from J. L. Crews, Region V; dated October 29, 1982; Subject - Request for Technical Assistance, Allegations by E. Earl Kent (San Onofre)
12. Letter from Dr. L. T. Papay, Southern California Edison Company, to-R. H. Engelken, NRC, Region V; dated November 3 1982; Subject - Response to NRC letter dated October 29, 1982, on Allegations Regarding Construction Quality at San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Units 2 and 3, Docket Nos. 50-361 and 50-362.

13.

Letter from J. M. Curran, Southern California, Edison Company, to D. F. Kirsch, Region V, URC; dated November 3, 1982; Subject - Response to NRC Letter dated October 29, 1982,.on Allegations Regarding Construction Quality at San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station, Units 2 and 3

.?

. 14.

lemorandum for T. M. fiovak, NRR from W. V. Johnston, f?RR, dated fiovember 12, 1982; Subject - Allegations by Earl Kent Concerning Adequacy of Weldments at San Onofre Units 1, 2, and 3.

15.

Transmittal from E. Earl Kent, alleger, to 0. C. Shackleton,f!RC, Receited by Region V on ?!osember 12, 1982; Sub.iect - Copy of figure NB-4250-1 titled " Welding End Transitions - I:aximum rnselope" annotat ed by the alleger " Example of approximate slopes discosered 10-75-1982 a t 50'iGS. "

16.

Transmittal from E.'farl Kent, alleger, to 0. C. Shactieton, !;RC, received by Region V t'ovember 15, 1982; Subject - The two page docuw nt referred to in Item fio. 5 of the E. Earl Kent Statca.cnt.

17.

Mcmorandum from R. H. Enge1Len to H. R. Denton of Nascmber 12, 1982, Subject - Southern California Fdison Company, San Onofre Unit 3, Docket fio. 50-362.

., ~

(

(

.e l

Date ROUTING AND TRANSMITTAL SLIP 11/8/82 TO: (Name, office symbol. room number, initials Date building, Agency / Post) 2.

Owen Shackleton 2.

Tom Bishoo

%' ~ ky/3MQ

-'^

3.

Dan Sternbera 4.

5.

! Action File Note and Return Approval For Clearance Per Conversation As Requested For Correction Prepare Reply Circulate For Your Information see Me

. Comment Investigate signature

! Coordination

_ Justify g

d;fcm ch,,.wrrc(cf RE:

F0IA 82-528 vbuA cl Ple~ase provide me with the information requested by John Carr's mmorandum dated November 4,1982 -

and please remember to complete and return tihe sheet on which the processing " time is rec' rded.

esMBMN o

May I have your response by We'dnesdiy, November 10.

DO NOT use this form as a RECORD of approvals, concurrences, disposals.

clearances, and similar actions FROM: (Name, org. symbof, Agency / Post)

Room No.-Bidg.

Phone No.

  • y 5041-102 OPTIONAL FORM 41 (Rev. 7-76)

Prescribed b GSA e u. s. c..eeam*at Pc6attae 0"+se: is ts-a s t.s eats FPMR (41 CF 101-11.206

3. e z...,,. <

~*...,e.~.

i s

l l

'=.. ('

~J

..s,...

.... s.t.*r wVgh%dy.4 ggii y p @,h p I

O I_"A"

. '. '. m.~.* i.._

, m m_._._ m

- ~~

  • ~ ~ ~ ~ ~

). f.

SI

(~.

(..

./

~ RECORD Of FOI A PROCESSING TIPI

'~

INSTRUCTIONS:

Complete this form to establish the time assodiated Nith the ' i-d processing of this FOIA request.

the nearest 15 minutes, for all actions taken. Record the time-in man-h i

Include the number of. pages :

reproduced.

F 1

r;.

Your clerical overhead factor will be added by the F0IA/PA Branch.

v y

Negative results time will be reported to this office by telephone.

RETURN FORii TO:

Director, Division of Rules and Records, Room 11NBB-4210.

Form Date 11/8/82,

[.

Name,of Requester Orange County Alliance for Survival and Community Ene.rgy Action.,

lietwork, dan Diego FOIA Request Nuinber 82-528 4

ju DIRECT Tit 1E FOR SEARCH. I 1 ORGANIZATIdN L Clerical :

Professional _l Al.L OTHER 'AbTIVITY / '

f 2

c

,C COPY REPRODUCTION

')5 '

ORGANIZATION NUMBER OF PAGES REFRODUCED 5

~

.l, : '

,s.

C0!iPUIf.R SEARCil

~

Report actual machine time and applicable cost rate for machine used.

l

?

1/ Includes only the time actually spent in searching for or locating docur6ents.

2f Includes the time spent reviewing documents for exempt information, conferrin with the staff, reproduction, etc.

_A

.n.<

e

,A

)

,, e r,h,

(

)

(.

~f3

~

t:<n t s c. urs EECgy,ED

/ }

K.i i U "! gut..
* "W C u!,tr. in
..; ~

/

,/,g f.,,,s.

... c. m

'rm f-ilover.'r:r ?, MIL.'

jag h.

0' L-i.

hr%*

l 1

i l NEGOQ.

j MUt3RfJ:Nt1 TDR: Csvrt 114 Yin, j

M., G.. - ntnie r 1 ).

e stV

)

.e t-

--- s

!!ullis Uttsers Dmur imt!qs OlA 01 FROMi

.iw C. r.,rr, Chief rreedor or ii forrnien, nd Privacy.4 r r.

sr a.ii ti e.!!adECT:

brir. hr.giity r.P.rft r! ; I

' :trn u f.t... tw.".' : !:tc.o- "".

117 (M3101.*;G 9.i.: M TI CT. c'T U. DY m. t. F '1 7TT 111f. Sr.fi IElu. RE 7.UCLI. Ai Gl:Ul.Pl'.T 17;'; 31 N w i.

r.t i.m R!D t

e

'l TRi!" CTrXR 1900 TO Tile Pl!C5I'lli (F0" DJ

  • h'i P DJase find 'ent f ored a '.:hpy of tim essw.rr FCI A moir" M

N '.ht.z

  • e Cn/o1 IMn Recil or ey st.or rn; rlm er%,

" W, :"

yn.i-

~ nem.e

  • .e tr;c

~

lo!!cWing'

. [(1) Oces your of fice b.i te dar.u. int, ;ub ject F.o tm iciutst?

[

If yes linWr,sch ',c.treh tire will be..'.litiren?

  • i F -

I I c.tp0rt0tl St?D"Ch I,i'T 9;f COf4)*, (WU h!..t n..j0 riU, :. icy 17; f

s.e a r c..n.u..a..[.i..f f.i cu.~ ta l *o. n..g to.. I DTA. n. o. u.r..n m n

.aat.a.c.t..

.e l(2j Approxicately he..4 einy dm m enP. do yme in'. t :-W n.it i i bc

<l. -

wi thi. eld frce publir. distins.:? inia t 4,

4 it :,
9. e /

.(3) Da you.tistIcipate.mv prchico:, in brm m.ing thi r. request

_ l and responding in the.111otted tire *!

~

q(4) Libich other of f ices c:f r}ht ha* e docin::nte, subject to this

.;, ' (. '.'

request?

' P! base' provide,1);18 wi t5 a ll.httu mnts sub. ject to t.hi s rn.u".t. nn iaT. r than fl00.'i fieverh.'r

  • I A:'.
f. Iso enclosed l': si t.nuy tif t ha FatA tiro record for r wiii. 2

.nu its fr r.r:rpleted by the st.ut ii. mar ntfi<.a.ind r.e ui nt'n to IT!P. '. '.li vcur l' *? 5l ions tf.

l

.iniin C.,

t.ar r Encissure.:

As stated

~

C0ilTACT:

Carni Tnn Reed l

%' s.(1 D l

hpe ePf30ylbok l

.eew 9

,e l

4.y;,..i,. p ;s.<.n. s.,

7

'M '.1-if1.k'Ld84d dg @-df iggf.1...

[

t

.,9 m.5. m...__

,7. )...._.

7

..m 3. s ' t '..;) V G..

7.
s.,

s_

rni v..t c..

.v.

07,;.4 e,., q,p..

p.-r.

&,.,..f s

1

  • t-y'

~

. W.

s.

., T.

'O;. <:u r.:..

M

'" ' - f ', h..

u

'L.,. x un I

o

.<J e.

d v,,.z,y; L l \\b' f. E. s.m u. y.

n ef t t,

..r y.,. \\

~ -

1--

c.

c ---,.

r,.,...,_..,

. f:

s e..

'n 7 _......

f,m.

).M.h 3

. i%. @gert. fr. FeJtw'

/. s.e 3, ;,,, ',

.y

.n

/

2; v

r-

~

I l g,' Y h).

l: M.

3Dirm: tar [Divici,cq'cf.Nules.appt.IHea 6E M.,.,.jC.h 'M.i t jO. 'i, ~.9,. J.TNe1mr hc, ula tery Cet-i nn i on ;

~

-f. -~

c. F T,-$. W w.

1

,F.-

l

>~

..r,

~

,f w w aho, nNn.m. I I. t..

,. %.o..,

.y_,c,~.3.

,'l **..'

s

.. ~h. -r. ;%.. -

.f p.

p.*

~..

........~.. t.. ef.,.ap..

7 4,.y.

we 3 =

.e,..

a

,a, f;

y,_

j-

., :.D.N. fit @,st.;

W r R. " 1 + i' n.

il 3

.,l l s.,,

'p. j,U, Q

. Uh.& : t h t' Fr <m h r. of I n for e,.9 +..i cm.4 t. ', ~ ',0. 9, G We: <

'6 '.

),.:. (,F.:,a f t<h c p.. M.

~

w m'epp"-Unc. m ms t r' or e c r'i e v 0 f U. ll inv.e 5t i. ' 4.3:.I' 8.

q 'l.,

...f a L 1 Ve,f I'l W..

. - e :.,,.i.4i.c, t'

m..

w j

noton, reperf.r, TC rm arca., rt y r ae.e ^qi.

c. J i

vl M,

sJe'.,.*,g

.' { } d ' [g [f! P. t'i,' ) f* 1,Q f ' y (*f t. {.! O,7, i

.p e=.

4 W} g h 31 ) "f,t ;

{ y T'y M. *f C h.y.yeg.g ;,

g

.1 f,

i. -,* s l J,, [p, V.,: :..-

f ;Qn. i pj,1 y, r,* n t, q. <a pd irg,.. Jh C,5 f 6n t. r; r - M 1g gt-G a n h 3 t'irej't + Q }

g ;{w !,.A.::. b. r ul g jc, t.

n-i

  • L
j

,L R$tl. W :.: :Xco6h0ctober,~ 19p0 t.0. thr>_ J L'a Lion; Unit.n V.;.11 at:d u ;,W

..s ' f.r '.*. W:.C.#g,'

M ptc acn %. y, ~ 6

%F ~.

N

' [>$- a

& mc va v

e g-A,7 -. i....J a f,, 4. y,4 - ' m. _ t c.

.O "6

.N'P

+.

i a

=

v-C,

, J; 1 t.,

,..r.',.

r. '. <

!. 'lg, g G. J c. (

3 f,%l.th.e r f',c &. t* e any b'M $ f 01' C OWinF, OP 4 F',fm t f'h.. et t :r.'

^,

a

-r

. !.f-:q

, l;ql; 1.

n.

) 'l r,' j [..]f l A'.

.fGT-[. t)f f.[ Y PC r? f tk f.f. e'it t;c );ypp'} y tt q P, 3 t to :t tjn p i f]}Qt,d. f [. {

  • y}J

- y W< :o<, 4 f

. lif fe nd. n~., uc o r.the 'w t n J i f T.h o l'n s <io ' ndt e. dcM E

%r/.'!< #

. t e

t.

3.,

1 0., { p p...00'..'

L'

. g.. s.

. (<... s,,;..

w.c..

m u

~

' ' ' ' f i. c.r.

0,.

s,,,..,,..~.

s

. e.

s. 6,.t.,,

  • g.

j 8

j

-t.,,.

y-

~

,l

. **'t l '- g*s

~,

n c, o. -

r W,,.,9-

..%a.>

, }, c

+

.i b

'p p [e._. _l"'h [yT C*[r f)C i,l b G i l )Qt,vJ h.,tp' s o l'J ' br 1}g Of,; ove

'.h. f e ID

. n,ip.~. g., t-.M....

g,.,

b.

y,!y @4J.j) 'ji.'. M.'X:: h - i,.

r.

3., 5 >

. '3.0 t i t h t'.orn Ce lj.fpr6.{ n r3y Jhg ' 13 tll.10 wi l,i.tr n

.y-st. ele.'.i.r-Mi*.%g'.I. u'9, b m

w c

E. Q, b, v

,; ' ',6 o ": W3 w

.d.

.6

,1,' E,' _ n st,,Q,ty%

-ds g:;r. L %.'.g% g

il.,, ' a w a l,.~,. g.
< hp;t.M-r?

c

  • c. '.>,

c.-

3-l.

.g

,s..

..'>y;

. A,b;,

s ?.',e

.. Jo f

<g

'f,<'.

?,

e l,, h.. -,y..., S.1) '.Q. U..[ 'Q Q.y., p.h.{.{.I,-Q,{# jk. g.

',p.

6 "f (q u 't ;*

  • j 7/ U* JK.. y;.
="

,1-v "

  1. ./,,..
rg.* y b f.

..? e. 4..

.x.

r

'.pii,M; {4W,g..y.,',[; _. #j61.* W1,W. n.t. h.Q.+D.. h.

a.

t1

",3 f f qy y y $(r > ;. [" v EM,h/,j-

[.'

-p / 4 a'

.. ea-3, M+ pHC1T ~C[.NX(W.D.v. 00 jou thin. k,..i.GF.t.i.f i F

.p p {

u.c, t... f WC.MC e

i

.. n.-

+.r. [7% [U [*,8

(,}N.ik'j '.' /[ f dryp'h1Il ;#

..,;';h

. i

..f 03 C;180 [l..h0 7 U3 [Orf'Mi 1 OT i.$,r!E.j;. - (, s. fy U S.'O [. M ' 3. Q g

?,.

-. ~.

~

g.,b.C,y@if.ES"."Cp3NBb1e"110(*.Or.M.e.= 1.,.a. W. S.(7

.w:.

.,.:~ m9

7

, i.[ --%.v..*'

..M.

d

,$ t j

]Y$ $, 0n,il.." h**.% &. g.W"$ 0 I ? l Y'a v' ee.

v. x, s.

n,...m...g.. v.,

, 't w

>-t.-..,.

.- n N

. a

.g 7

W,Y W r'l O) p-l M. b 1 '; 1> "?&. n +.,. W.bj.~ /Q, ; W s'

( O ?.;$*C.!:

A,,,

s.

]i*wt. f* ES Y, ' U^w'L-t i k s.4 i, 1 Y'i.

p.,

'$ N '

s C '.. P c,,3. y l:,. 4 r.

4

. ~. ~, n.

ou.h

.. nny t r t

W.

> u.9 cayNtolpp. i.u,n s,L 10..n. o.. a bm,t hqpdl'ine.o-8$;1 #.

k yc

' WW, dk h]yt '

. %"liN

. 7 g.,..w. hrn!.e ue fa t.

.J A

.. g y4 w p. a,,s;y s'.' 0 *:' '."W'1 M [

.&L.. a r,Lt.;,d.50. :

g,;g:u&Y. s.Q's,O.;,l&y$y$y %&,.*2W {.&< Q.s$$EMY..

..% IQ *" '* d r;.;*,;-Wl,.

.p

a,.

Q l; g& N.- Q S... ; (> ;-d ',Uc, _

bNi G.- $1!M C r :ft N

?

'4 ' ':

N,N8, Nk

' W WFj Q @d,cy,re1 Qle,f1,p & l &

n h &.p Ws %:

ng:C,'.:..' '

s'X+t : y. ::.'. Y:..: h;.- W. s W ay.

. %;. a.; L.u {,...y Vy d.y +['a,*,.y y &. c}~n.;g,4. '.., ?>. y p, 2 :.

r t.

.m.

c

. 4, w +M W

.w

~ -.

c

y,<,;,*

f,

+f.

w a..u.x

,v c

n a.

, p'.

' g g 'p t,

I

,r.e n.. :... y4 ', c,' M. :g*',.y.w,. 9.

m.;. 4/ g ;, w'*(,p'.y.*~,'.[; 9, t.

y h) a*k y ; 'f.@ g,, ?g3,

. y'[.g-,g {(k

.3.,

s

,m.

y w

_ p...y. r'.. b;, e e

. - a.v>..

~

f. -.. w,

.s.,

.c

%s,..,rg, o.. +

A i., r*,. p.. t,v,s..g.

3

,p, i - 1x.a.

,. 4, ;. g p ;.M- @.g....,3..,..

4*,,, s p.e.6 -

.. n.,- i

.r

.o f.

s.

. qi9. ' >...,,;;,,f v,. 1,g... ; m<...p..,.

4

-(

(.w s.

w-

...y

.a a4 5..

t.

.t, 1

4 p

<wa

. y,..q.

p. ),.f f,Q'w'..
c. c _..,j, s

g(. y #y.L.. g ;

... n.. n,... p g; e., s.

h h... 3 ' s.h~,o.-.~..,.a... u..,.

.a s

-+

3)

,;,*,s...

'.,w

. A'.w x..+;W{n g \\

)+ N..s f

}.

..t..*g..? g

' G,s.

3..-

W:%,5;h* ?.:';.ff%';!$.. ?5,'(6,,- K i s b. s..'

r

. f,. p.

??e..

4

...,,s, 8

,, - ;.... {l v.,.s [.. g,.L.gi..

,,n g.

.i e,

s g

4

. : gr

.,; e< !

v

.,.s...

.e e

.,s,.

,, g.

sT& ?5

.l,.,

3'.Y LinLb,h* g..,

,. ),

^*

h}

V

?.N hR1

k',

N 'T 2?,fN, h' *

. v. w : m,w. yn..g..w~.,t.c &

k lS:Ypt %4

.U.M. :' fUQ'y

  • qiC.)ay~.. 4.Q;.. Y 4c

- t;.j %

.A, M. n v, y :. m%'y.&,~,p m%m.c el't,a:

W Z'

. y@ .

.m n Q w::l.

s~ e. W. :.n* %>e....

.v.

2

.+ v n:.s!y.w m.n,.l u

v ay p. w ; p.i..

Y; 6.i'u.>h. b -9.'

j.g h.

, ;,. ;.l%,~.vn...

3. W @9 / p M f';f d T'.Q@%e :..; 4. d [. 5
  • i' [ M NbNMfpW!E.

t y

9a ;fW

~.iMf*x@f.D;;.J.

i

- e p.

\\

., s :

., Y, ',,%'

e i 3.s,,.. '

s+

cQ JY' MM..,M.. 3 g2 $. 6.,y 4,'f.c..r/W('S.N.n'M, M,.s.9 9 O WW"F8'Ng. :.

E %D p'i 7G~

m'c 7b.

%Cb ydi,t,pT.n,q.p.At... M.u.r.n q.

.M.

. x 2,

', ' ~

.. i N.. -.b.,6f ',-%.

c f gM,', pie'?_.'@u., U.I 4..t,

t d.S W e A[ ; 4 '. i ~

o s

18 ' p. zh2. w..~

w,',,

..;h 9ji(('i"'

p+

-. n < M}fk.',

4 U

n.

w. - :y

. a.,, c., x ~

g'

+' +,r.,s p (n %y.,. s

. }. ' c; Ms. \\ e,.. M.y,j,,. t. m'. '.., > '. t

,g.

y5

. u.

?vp m'J 'J, ',

-.. e L +

,.; P, sj. ".

ss w',t

. 3.,. 'i '.

G/

~Q'v(f', '3 w

e

  • y fg... w-...s.

.i6.' % g,. Q 4* r. < :-y ",

g. y;',' ), sf v.. ;

Y,;,
,Q s W. w;y * ; M n;,. p.ts. :,

, 9!M f..

- '.u

.. c) l\\,.,

'yi:;9 W. %.a % Q. % Gi y:-[v'y$=

  • L.j '. W,a.

~','le. :[ :. 7 j. e5f.f.t].E.'.),./.M.$ Tf.

.,'.Q r Q O.. N. C O U M..,/,/,d.l.I A f )J C hl.g

! =' s

s'

,J

' i.

C..

y

Q,.. r.

ic 4.~..m,.... 1.rf.

'sf :g (.,', " ~ ll ef Q

.Q,l l, f,'. *;Q Q. *y'

.\\L;'l.',~.)ls's;.- is :.r; **,,s... ( ' %g x% v,.,.,. m,rEW h n y

,.,v...

-m.

f. m l

y. y.n*7

, ;{

y

, <.,e

,n. -

. 3 1 u,,., -

..d y,..

~.,.-.*:

~.

n.

,c y -~.,c,,.:%:.9

,w:,

.7

^

.... %. b.,g,.yx.._.,.

,.s 3

- ~... if.

  • 3

,jr,-

y :w, 9.

.x.m t..

m. w.%.

,g a.:,... -;}n,, %,,

w.

n y,'., g

>,. %. s,,,.

,.,a.,.,m.

a...

g k k h h, $. k. b.% h ? $ s W ' & ; D ?.'. Y A ?i'. W L U

)'e*!*'*A". s.,h!a$!5 S. M 2.h1W 4 6 $A A f=dLE $

?

IU

(~

Cduc g&

MEMORA!iDU?1 FOR: Roger A. Fortuna, Director, Policy and Program Support Staff, 01:HQ FROM:

Owen C. Shackleton Jr., Acting Director 01:RV

SUBJECT:

FOIA REQUEST FROM ELLIE COHEN ET AL, FOR ALL DOCUf1ENTS REGARDIrlG ALLEGATIONS MADE BY T1R. E. EARL KENT REG.ARDING THE SAN ON0FRE NUCLEAR GENERATIt!G STATION, UNITS 1, 2 AND 3 FROM OCTOBER 1980 TO THE PRESENT (F01A-82-528)

REFERENCES:

(a) Janes A. FITZGERALD, Acting Director, OI, memo to all Acting Field Directors captioned FREEDOM 0F INFORMATION/ PRIVACY ACT REQUESTS dated August 26, 1982 (b) Memo of John C. CARR, Chief, Freedom of Information

'. and Privacy Acts Granch to Roger FORTUNA et al.

captioned as above dated November 4, 1982 (c) Letter of Ellie M. C0HErl, Director, Orange County Alliance for Survival to Joseph M. FELTON, Director, Division of Rules and Records, dated October 27, 1982 It is to be noted the requestor denoted the period for which she wanted information concerning allegations made by Mr. E. Earl KENT regarding San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station was from October 1980_ to the present.

I believe that is a typographical error as KENT's allegations did not cone to the attention of Region V until approximately October 1982.

01:RVopeneditscase(5-82-021) on KENT's allegations on October 14, 1982 and closed our involvement on this matter on October 29, 1982. Our efforts were strictly as an assist to Region V's special inspection.

We assisted in three interviews and provided an investigator for the day KENT did an inspection at San Onofre.

Our investigative file contains 2S serials (documents of various types).

Copies of all documents in the file are enclosed. A listing of these documents in chronological order as they were placed in the file is cet out below:

Serial No.

Description of Serial 1

Memo of D. F. KIRSCH, Chief, Reactor Projects Section No. 3 to file captioned ALLEGED WELDING RELATED DEFICIEtlCIES AT SAN ONOFRE dated October 6, 1982, 11:20 a.n., with enclosure.

Ah Af I f A !1/ Q e [0W[ f WW lt j < O 4' l

' 'M-h,@

N h

Y$*,"Y5 yk.Ed[

Mfd hM -,$ my

[.lM. W.

'..'h

.,.7

l'l

(

(

Roger A. Fortuna -

2 flemo of KIRFCl!. supra, captioned ALLEGED WELDIllG RELATED DEFICIEt1CIE: AT SAtl ON0FRE dated October 6, 1982, 1:30 p.m.

3 flotes of Owen C. SilACKLET0tl Jr. on telecon with Jim F0 STER, 01:RIII, re. E. Earl KENT dated October 12, 1982 4

!!otes of Owen C. SHACKLET0t! Jr. on telecon with.

Jim FOSTER re. E. Earl KENT dated October 14, 1982 5

!!otes of Owen C. SHACKLETON Jr. re. Region V management meeting on allegations of E. Earl KENT dated October 14, 1982 6

!!ews clipping from Contra Costa Tines captioned s

"NRC Looking at ' Bad' Welds" dated October 14, 1982 7

SHACKLET0ti's notes on information received from

. Burns & Roe, re. his experience with E. Earl KEilT at Litton Industries dated October 15, 1982 8

SilACKLET0ti's notes on conducting the special inspection into KENT's allegations at SONGS dated October 14, 1982 9

SilACKLET0!!'s memo to file on 01's role in the special inspection of KEllT's allegations at SONGS dated October 14, 1982 10 PNO-V-82-41 dated October 14, 1982 captioned f1EDIA IflTEREST Ill UELDIflG ALLEGATIONS 11 Copy of L.A. Times news article captioned

" Groups Urge Wider Probe of fi-Plants" dated October 14, 1932 12 P. V. J0VV,0FF's notes on taned interview of E. Earl KEtiT conducted on October 15, 1982 13 SilACKLETON's notes of taped interview of E. Earl KEf!T made on October 15, 1982 14 Copy of the unsigned statement of E. Earl KEllT setting out his concerns dated October 16, 1932 l

l

{'

uAO

' Roger A. Fortuna '

15 Interview Report cover sheet for the interview of Donald C. liARTIll conducted on October 21, 1982 16 SHACKLET0ft's notes of the interview of Donald C. IIARTIrl on October 21, 1982 17 Interview Report cover sheet for the interview of Iloodrow ll. LAHR conducted on October 21, 1982 18 SHACKLET0!!'s notes of the interview of 11oodrow U. LAHR conducted on October 21, 1982 19 flotes of Jess CREllS on telecon with Vic STELLO concerning policy on releasing the interview tapes of E. Earl KEilT and the rough transcript of these tapes 20 fleno to the file dated riovember 4,1982 from SHACKLET0?! concerning GAP's reauest for a copy of the interview tapes of E. Earl KErlT and the rough transcript 21 lleno to the file dated flovember 4,1982 from SHACKLET0:1 concerning GAP's request for a copy of the interview tapes of E. Earl l'EilT and the rouah transcript 22 Investigative notes of P. V. JOUKOFF dated October 29, 1982 closing out any further participation in the special inspection of E. Earl KEllT's allegations by 01:RY 23 An undated news article from a Richland, Washington newspaper concerning Don HETZEL a senior welding engineer with Burns and Roe on UtiP-1, and Orville J0!!ES, a welding engineer with UPPSS experiences with E. Earl KENT 24 Uitness statement to E. Earl KEilT's unsigned statement as anended by him, as being true and correct as amended 25 A copy of E. Earl KEllT's unsigned statement F10dified to include all of his amendments I

I u.r... a.._...... a.._, ;. _. m. n. m. 1

~^

~

.., j

(

(

Poger A. Fortuna '

i Pegion V has also reviewed their special inspection file and is submitting to the FOIA Branch their documnts.

In some instances, there will probably be a duplication of documents submitted by Region V and DI:RV.

/

Sf Ot.>en C. Shackleton Jr.

Acting Director. 01:RV cc w/o encl:

FOIA File l

s 1

u i

1 I

l-

[

SHACKLETON/mn m

jf

(,-

.C R[ LORD OT I Ol A FROCL E51E T li'I li3.liill.110n5 :

Ccr:pl e t c t h i'. f u rrr. t o es t a bl i '.l. t he time i:ssociated with the prcte: sing of this f 01 A request.

Ret.nrd t he-t i rne i n ::.a n tours, rour.ded to the nr,isest ir, minutes., f or all fict ions t eken.

loclude the nu:r.ber of paces reproduced.

~

Your cli;rical overhead factor will be added l>y the TOI A/PA Bi anch.

1 Negative r esults time will be reported to this ofTice by telephone.

RETURN FORT! TO:

Director, Diyision of Rules and Records, Room IIN38-4710 Form Date llame of Regt ester _

i,-

F01A Request Nuinher _.. % _5-4 DIRECT 'I111E FOR SEARCH I

{_0RGANI/.ATION

'. Clerical'8 Professional ' All OTHER ACTIVITY./

I 2

_. 0 1.: _ % g v 4

/b ChdDaio

//uar bfendu/ 6he f56 COPY RFPRODUCTION ORGAN)ZAT1DN

?!UMSER OF PAGL5 REF AODUC ED 1_

.2 _

col *PUILP. $L ARCH Report.ictual r.ichine time and applicable cost rat.e for machine used.

l S-32 If locludes only tlnt time at tually spent in scarching for or loca ting documents.

.i 2/

In: lodes the tim spr nt i evie ing document s for exempt information, i.onferring t<

with the staff-e.aieent M i a a

(;

(~;

)H3 rv ot - -

llllaf&

/

~#

/(c SQ 5 5-82-uti kNG& -40e vlim re:

r L.vdd d l.y E.EAalt<LM i j

I Date ROUTING AND TRANSMITTAL SLIP

[]

/d g TO: (Name office symbol, room number, Initials Date Duilding. Agency / Post) 1.

h C-rbk.

OkIb O1 ! FL@

2.

s.

4.

5.

Action File Note and Return Approval For Clearance Per Conversation

.As Requested For Correction Prepare Reply Circulate For Your Information See Me Comment Investigate Signature Coordination Justify REMARKS Of DQ{ DUlO J 0 fY W

($!05 S 0

i b

ISl i h krds.

DO NOT use this form as a RECORD of approvals, concurrences, disposals, clearances, and similar actions FROM:(Name, org. symbol Agency / Post)

Room No.-Bldg.

+/gCA(G[Qg Phone No.

50'l-202 OPTIONAL FORM 41 (Rev. 7-76)

EEdil 4YcIIu :D-12.2os hs.' [-['2 -0.2 l

~

3-5T

.

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML20024A276&oldid=4629595"