ML050980131
| ML050980131 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Hope Creek |
| Issue date: | 04/01/2005 |
| From: | Bird E, Keating R, Schlaseman C MPR Associates |
| To: | Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation, Public Service Enterprise Group |
| References | |
| Task No. 1108-0502-0002-00 C-0142, Attach 16 | |
| Download: ML050980131 (14) | |
Text
-
i v ;
t:
s:
Z ;e s -
a b
4:
e bj!t :-i
\\ i:;.
6 )
t ',.
1--
i-..'-: !
t-t
,,:1-.
't '
X.
- 1. ' '.N'
['.,'.;',
- '
- s
',' ^,',
! at :.
S.
- F i,,
- e
- i'-'-
?'o'-.:
s
[i ..
t.
"i
_ s
.,.l.
.'i
"; 'I '
r r
S
>tv t i-MPR Associates, inc.
~M1 1)320'King Streedt:.
.....aMPR--.....1','
~Aie xandra A221 CALCULATION TITLE PAGE
,.Client i..
-Page1 of 11&
t
-ppendi__A P oject Task No.'
H -'
lope Cek Decon tamjination'Port.:,. '.....
.108-.0502k0o02,00U Titie:
Calculation No.
- Natu'ral FrequencyofLoop 'B',Port Attach 16 'o C'
.42.
r re.Date
.,-h.ckei..DateReviewer
& A--.ove-i Dae Rv No
,Sn Bir
' ' ;Ca lin' Schlm'
-"r.
Rober Keating 0
4i3Z t..wd Bid C aoii e Schiaseman.
Rober-t Keating 1
t -
2 1
- '--1 IA
- I 1.1,
'I 7-1 I:
i
.QUALITY ASSURANCE DOCUMENT
--Thsdocument has bin preparedtchecked, anId revewe lapprovcd inwaccordance withcQ Assuranc
-requirerientsof OCFRSO Appendix B, as specified in the MPR Quality Assurance Manual..
ii
-
,, 4,
- c.
.2 -,,
.: '. : :
w 1.
I 1, I 1, MPR-QA~~ IR'm Q3.1 -1, Rev.,
I[
1
1**
MPF 320'
-*M PR-P RECORD.'OF REVISIN S.
.Calculation No..Ched By Attach'1 to6 001'42
.Revision Affected P Description Associates,'Inic.
2.'.
King Sttreet' -';,.,~
- andnia,'A
\\A22314,:' -
Pae 2,,..j 0
1
'I I
[
I a[
I I
IILL-
..r.
- 1.
I2A 8.'
'-.1 I
I-Initial Issue Revised pipe'lengtih to3.75 inches for modified model consistent with'field'
.work. 'Corrected material propertics formodifiedmodel. U a
result for modified mo'deL..
frequ 1
I',.
Is 31 I
A Note:
The revision number found on each indiidualpage ofthe calculaton levelof the calculation in effctat the time that page was last revised.
icaRmos the revision
,MIPR QA Form QA3.1.2. Rw~. I
if:
.- 'MPRAssociates, Inc.
- 320 K~ng Street'.
- CalculationNo
'Prepared By Checked By Page: 3 Attach 16 to'C-0142 A/
Revision: 0O Table of Contents 52 Og u
- i.
';dh.
1..........
............... -.;.4r'.'
t
.0 Bacigeoi d t
A ; 5.
Geonietrlc l.te..
-, : f
.... !.4....d........ 1............e
-I -- 0; nces.......................--........ -;-.-
~--A oom et cKe' '6Wnts j
-F MPR OA orm: OA-3.1'.. Rv. 0
r I
- II&IMPR
-- :- - T...
MPR AsIodates, inc; 320 King Street AilexarddaVA 22314 Alexia~dn -N
- Calculafion No.
Attiach 6 to C-0142
- j
.ae:1~
Revision: O
- -.1.0'
PURPOSE,.'-
,'#.Ie purpose of this calculation is to estimate the first mode natural frequencyof the Hope.Creek-- -
Reatc'torRecirc'ulatioiLop :B',decbhtamination port. Two configurations are evaluated the
.'originaa-builtconfliguration and aimodified (shorteined),configuration.'
I K
K I
I I--.--
2.0
-.BACKGROUND,
'Thefailed decontamination por is located on the suction sideof the 'B' Reactor'Re.i'culation
,, ':Pup 'with 'the isolabile section of Re irc'ulation'-pipng. The"port is design'ed to be us'-ed-
,,,,inuently during outages to flush WaterbrougVthe Re iculation piping. D-ing normal pgant
.-operations, thepo'rtis sealed witi blted blak flange.
'..a
.p
.'fc
~ c's
,'fi
-. 'The origjai port' includes a 7.5 inch long n
c ssio4nc e8p fnsche2 nd 10). The failed port is'shown in Figure-1.
Fligure 2-1.: Loop 'B' Oecontamina'tion Port 1APRO~orn:QA4~3Rev.
I -i
- MPR Associates,' Inic.
320 King Street Alexandra, VA 22314..
Calculation No.
- Prepared By
.Checked By
'Page:.:
Attach 16 to C-142 Revision I
I I,,
LV
ji F:
. Ž
{7 i
3.0
SUMMARY
'OF RESULTS The' irst mode natural frequency for the origin'al failed configuration is'122 hz;' the first mode
.natuIral frequencyforthe moifed cofi itionis 179lhz'(Refence 9). In the modified configra tion, the length of the schedule.80 pipe is shortened om 7.5 inche to-3.75 inches (assumed).
4.0 ANALYTIC APROACH.
The deontaminiation port natural fruencies were determined with a tee-dmensional finite
, element mdel..The m6del represents one-half of the port with a plane of synunetry-through the
..- :port as. The model.wa'de'qelop'ed.ith'e ANSYS 'co'mputer p' '
'fere solid m-d4l of the' riinalgcvoiguration is shown in Fi gu e4-1;tefinite'element riodel of the'.'
'.'original configuration is shown in Fire 4. The original and'modified config rations are
'66m'.' o 'i nFi- 4-3.
Fiure 4-1. Solid Model for riginal Decontamination Port
-1 MPRIQA FOrm: t QA-3.14,
~v.
4.
j.
MPR Associts, Inc.
.M PR 320 King Street Alexandriai, VA 22314 '.
Calculation No.
Preipared By.CheckedBy,'
Page: 6
- .'Attach l6 to C-0142
{/' '
Revislon: '0 I
I
,I I
.a II II tI, Fig re 4-2. Finte'Ele ment Model fo rijina iecon tam a n Port J
t MPR QA Form,: CA431 -3.'Rev. 0.
UXMPR32 Calculaton No.
Prepared By' Checked By
- Attachl 6toC-142 Associates, Inc.
King Street (andaVA ;22314.
l.Page: "7
.Revision: 0 r;,
il.;
-. I t "
t Ni.
".e g ';
P:
.. s,',.
4_. ',*
- t.
i \\
t.. ' '-
iv,;
t i'
ii;"
t, i
t : '. _'
{:
S. ' '-
r F.;
Figuire 4.' Original and'. MPdfed Dconbrnina'Uon Po.rts
- -5.0 -
FINITE ELEMENT MODEL DESCRiPTION Th - ' - '
ifi ite elment model of he oaination potis a thre dimensiona solid mode'l
-epreSentation. The model in'clu'des" a short ength'fteRea'ctorcirculation'pipig ib e;'
- idolet decon'nination po piiigna 900W blind la'gei-.
ihe.;"'
btingh egohetr is not i'cluded; ebltie gardwareis icluded.
'ne-ialf of th'epo is modele recognizing symmetryperendicular to' the'Rcir t ion piping.
The-weight of water, instilation andbolting:Are included in themodel-withmass elements
- (ANSYS el ementsMASS2).
The model is meshed withan 8-node'hexahedral element With-three degrees-eof-freedom per-node (ANSYS element SOLID45).
5.1 -Geometriy The geometric dimensions for themodel ofthb decontamination poqrtwere&detei References'2 tugh 6 and Reference' 1. Table 5-'lists the primary dimensior rmni'ned from ;
is used to develop MPR OA Form: OA-3.1-3, Rev. O
V V
MF
- M P
^M32 Al(
Calculation No, Pepared By
-Checked By Attach 16 to C-0142
/:
PR Associates, Inc.
0 King Street 3xandria, VA '22313
- 4 Page
- ' 8
-Revision ; 1.
.,s,.,. I t : -..,
I t...-:,
- i. - I; T
^ w -.:
'.:'A'..
H..
' '"""' I 1"'- ';
t, -.
t i
'
t_.
a r
'..'.' R
- >--.<N
1S',
4,.,.5., 7.
^.,,
'..s,:'.,
- 's'."'..'
t ': ',
s '.A,'.
\\'
r,
's
-i"',.
i' f 'i,
- ,t, _
i
.s, a_ 1 ; b _.
- t.
8-
- i,' r ',
' 4.
, C,
. i
[. ' ': ;t
- t.
.the model Appenidix A 'shows an outline of the decontamination port with-the geometric.,
keypoints numbored.' Coordinates for the'Ieypoints are also provided in Appendix' A, The welding neckan'd blind flag'es ae 900 #,feren',ce 2). -The decontamination' ipeis 4.ij' Ch
...-.schedule 80 (Reference'2).:
Tabile 5-1.,Geometrac Parameters
.. ;Descriptlon DImension (inch)
Refereice
'Rec~rculatiori Pipe'OD 28 3
,. :Recirculation PipeThc:knwes 1.2 3
Weldolet Radius 4.1845
.4-Weldolet C ind ical S on Height
, 1.31 4
Weidolet Tapered Sectiorn eig'ht' 2.44 4.
- P iip&<OD
~'
'l-
.ipe ID (S&1ul 680).;'
,, 3'826 5
Pipe Length (origin lmodifed) 7.5/3.75.:
assur d.
BindFlangeOD 11.5 6
BlindFange ised Fa'c OD 6.i875.'
6
-Blin'd&Weldingii6' kFlange Thic kess 1
6 Blind & Welding Neck Raised Fae n-Thckess '.0.25 6
Wedn F.ng ConicalHeIght
,2 stima.e:
..2 Boundary d
sConditio The only stru abundyco'nditio' applie to, he fnite element model were displacement
.cohstqints.i'Atte nemetiry ethat isperndpcuaid toii iftteRekirculationpipin axis and ":
passes'through'the'centerineod rl c
mnathon'o the' dislacements n omal to'tle piane.
.(z) are restrained. At he end oft eciuia ion pipe porion of he noei pposite eport,
-displacemntsineac of thethre Catesian coo inate dirctions (ux, uy and uz) a'rera ine'.'
.The structural boundaryconditions areshownfi Figure :5-1.
4.,
.1' 4
1 MPR OA Form: OA4.143. Rev. 0
MP Ale Calculation' No.
Prepared By Checked By Attach 6 to C-0142.
4 43
,/.
i I.
I k
- ' Displacem'ents normal to this-face
,(uz),set to zero.4
-'6
t d k e.
I A1 VI R Associates, Inc.
King' Street xandna, VA 22314 Page:. 9 --
(
.'Revision:,.
xxuy an uz) set wll o zero on this fce.-
mnodu~lus, he elastic
.'3deg' i s d belowi:
MPRQForm: 'A-313 Rev. 0 t
FIgure 5-1. -StriuduraI Boundar Conditiions 5" 3 Material Propertles The matenal properties used in the natural frequ'ency calculation are'the elastic Pos-on Ratio,,h R cic atb
, Poisoins io and the material density. From Reference2, the Recirculationp
,decontainination port are=304-stainless steel.' Thetemperature Used to evahiatet modulus is§532 deg ' (ReferenceF7).
rom Reference 8, the Celastic modulus at 25.7e66si.
The values of Poisson's'Ratio and material density'used in the analysis are liste oissosiRation 0.3 Density
'0.284 lb/in3
MPR Associates, inc.
3206King Street Alexandria, VA -22314-Calculation No.
Prepared By
-Checked By Page: 10 Attach&16to'-0142 IRevision:
.0
.A
.VI..
- 5. 4 'Added Mass The weight of water.in'the decontarnination port,:insulation and 'bolting were included in the model with mass elements. Note that the fiite 'eleinent model rcpresents one-half of the
- geometry. Consequently, the total weights were ditided by two in the model.
For the bolting weitlits, note that the welding neck and blind flanges arerepresentd in,.the finite
.eleent'model without holesb.-The holes are nominaly filled withthe bolts. Consequently, the O.
bolting, weiiht
'that needs to be added'is te e 1/2 inch section'between the flanges and the'boited
'lenths outside the flanges.
. he weights in. T able 5-2 were assumed fore a.theani-ysis:
i 1-
'Table.' Weights Original * ! Modlfied.
.item Port Weight Pot Weight Comments
.i) llb)
,Water density of 4 9
ibIft 3, cylindrical water
.Water.5
.4 volume 3.826 inch diameter by5 irches l','.:.-.;ong (11 inhies' for modified),.
Insulation
- 5.
', -.'Refeence 7 foronal, estimated for modifed 6 blts, 1.125 Inch diameter, 0.5 inclength Bolting 7
between flanges; plus 8 bolts and nuts, estimated;i.5 Inch long, i.5.Inch diameter MPR OA Formn-OA-3.1;3. Pev., 0
i 4,-
-*IMPR 3
Calculation No.
'Prepared By Checked By Attach 16 to C-ii42 -
4,
I.
t 1**
z.
-6.0 R EFERENCES E
.S.
Tlhe finite elemnentmodel was developed and analyzed w.ith the ANSYS Aimlysissprog'ran'Versioi 8.1. The I
analysis w'a perforrn'd otn a Sun'28
.the Solans 8 Operating system.'The ANSYS installation verification is'
-QA-81-1.
-*2....General Electric drawing 761E350,Sheet '2,Revision'14.
PR Asscits, Inc.
20 King!Street',
lexandia,-VA 22314.
Page: 11 Revision: -0 F i n t E l m n locumented in
~5) 1-iR6Visfion
'3.-.
Asoiated Piping '&Engineering'drawing 10855-N1-B31-(G001-0194'(
- 4.
Gene'ral Electric drawing '31C7544,` Rvision C, "Weldolet Nozzle;"
5.'
'Crane Technical Paper'41O.'
.6. ;Tu'be Turn Catalognurmber 1 1 i-943.
7
-Email fom Philk ush,MR) todwar ird R) dated March 30,2005,
-Dec6ntiminanio& Line Details.
'8.. ASMEBo~iler &Prens 'Vs.elC'd
,2004 Prt'D; Properties,Tabl 1TM-G
'p'
- L9.
Coinp'uter output files 11080502.ebb-i 1 tru gh?
108-5 2-ebb -14
.10 Facs *ile fr A. GJcia PR K ting (MPR) datd M h30,205, '"Field ke c es."
L f
f l
t MPR QA Form: QA^3.143, Rev. O
t 1
Prepared By
'Checked By Attach 16 to C-0142
/,/.4 "Geo'Metrd Keypoint
.FiguiresA- 'and A-2 show an outlinebofthe decontaminationport'model.'The fli numbe'd gedom'etricckeypoints. Coordinates for the' kypointstare listed in table Associates, Inc.
'King Street afndria,VAA 22314, Page: A-I Revision:
0 l
prs'include.:~
A-1 Fe MORdA or: Q433~1Re.-
z.
Figu'reA-I. GeomieticKeypoints i
V r
1.
[
V I
UIA1 MPR MPR Associates, Inc.
- 320 KIng Street Alexandira,'VA 22314
-Calcuialon'No.
Prepared By Checked By
.Page:' iA-.2' Attach 16'to C-0142 Revision: :0
. I
.. i, Figure A-2..GeometIc Keyppints, Detail MPR QA Form: bA-3.1V3. Rev. 0
MPR Associates, Inc.
. ;E-M D.,
320 King Street Ale xandrnaVAA-22314,
-Calc'ulto'n'No.
Prepared By Checked By Page: A-3'
- Attach 16 to C-0142 Revislon: O a7 Table A1. Keypoint Coordinates No.
- 5.'00 6.00
7.00' 11.00 12.00 14.00 15 :00 16.00 19.00 22.00 23.00 26.00 28:00 A 0 33.00' 35.00'
-437.00 9O.00
- -41:00 43.00
'45 I.0
- -47.500 52.00'O t.53.00
. '56.00'.
'57:00
58.00
-60.0t0
'61 t00.
'6300 65.00.*
z66.00
- 69'.00 71.00
'7300 74.00
.76.00
- X Y
14.'00
'0.00
-2:-25' 25.25
'12.80 0.00
-3.09 27.25 0.00
-14.'00'
,0.00
-12.80
-5.75
'27.25 1.91 '
,27.25
'4:18
.s'15.3'1 1.1
.' 15.31
,5.75 29.00
- 225.
17.75 1.91*
'29;'00 3.09 !
29.00 1.91
- 9. 2
'1i91
-;13.87 1.91
)`
-*.12.66
-2.25 15.31
- 1.91.' 17.75
',2.25 A 2.;60,;
418 13.36 225'.
.13.82
'4.18.
12.10O r309.
z2925
- - 191 29.25
'225 31.25
.191 -.
31.25 0...00 29.25
- 3.09 '
r 29.50
- ' 7'5 ~29.50 5.75
- 31.25 0.00 3.25 3;09 2'
"31.25 2.25 27.25
- 1.91' 29.50 2.25
.29:00 2.225
'29.25
'2.25 "29.50 z
0.00.
0.00
.0200 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
-0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
-0.00
-0.00 0.00 0.00 O;00 0.00 0.00
' 0.00' 0.00
'0.00
'0.00
'0.00
.0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
'0;00
.0.00 0.00 i:
il i.;
S
. t
- ' i
/,
'.s i
, i
}
t; ms W
i;l.,'
a
- t
.S a
- s z
\\
..1 f
s f
4 A -,
m
.1 :
I i
J MPR OA Fonn: 0A3.-3. Rev. 0