ML20055D974

From kanterella
Revision as of 19:33, 13 November 2023 by StriderTol (talk | contribs) (StriderTol Bot insert)
(diff) ← Older revision | Latest revision (diff) | Newer revision → (diff)
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Discusses Reduction in Expected Consequences from Hardened Vent Mods to BWR Mark I Reactors.Estimates Based on Surrogate ATWS Sequences
ML20055D974
Person / Time
Site: Peach Bottom  Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 07/03/1990
From: Buslik A
NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH (RES)
To:
NRC OFFICE OF NUCLEAR REGULATORY RESEARCH (RES)
References
NUDOCS 9007100215
Download: ML20055D974 (25)


Text

_ _ . . . . . _ . . . . .

  1. Eto

~

.,. 'A - UNITED STATES

    • [

.E p,

tj=

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

- WASHINGTON, D. C 20555

[%,~~~,/

a,, ,

NOTE T0: File FROM: Arthur Buslik, PRAB/DSR/RES

SUBJECT:

REDUCTION IN EXPECTED. CONSEQUENCES FROM HARDENED VENT MODfFICATIONS TO BWR MARK I REACTORS Our, estimate of reduction in risk from the addition of hardened vents in BWR Mark I reactors depended-in part on consequence estimates for Peach Bottom, for sequences of the type averted by the addition of hardened vents.

'Thesa consequence estimates were based on surrogate anticipated-transient-without-scram sequences. The work was performed by Arthur Payne of Sandia National-Laboratories, and is documented in the enclosed telecopy from Arthur Payne to me, dated September 26, 1989.

hff Y$wb!

Arthur Busiik Probabilisitic Risk Analysis Branch Division of Systems Research w/ enclosure:

cc: -

PDR 1/6 0

900710021G 900 03 \

PDR ADOCK 05000277 w\\

P PDC

i s

c .

M 3 1990 NOTE 10: File FROM: Arthur Buslik, PRAB/DSR/RES

SUBJECT:

REDUCTION IN EXPECTED CONSEQUENCES FROM HARDENED VENT MODIFICATIONS TO BWR MARK 1 REACTORS Our estimate of reduction in risk from the addition of hardened vents in BWR Mark I reactors depended in part on consequence estimates for Peach Bottom, for sequences of the type averted by the addition of hardened vents.

These consequence estimates were based on surrogate anticipated-transient-without-scram sequences. The work was performed by Arthur Payne of Sandia National Laboratories, and is documented in the enclosed telecopy from Arthur Payne to me, dated September 26, 1989.

/<< J

,/Caj Arthur Buslik Probabilistic Risk Analysis Branch Division of Systems Research w/ enclosure: _ _ _ ,

cc: PDR - -

Distribution DSR Chron Circ /Chron PRAB Rdg PRAB Subj ABuslik Rdg HVanderMolen JGlynn MCunningham 0FFC: PRAB PRAB

NAME: ABuslik ', 4 PRAR HVanderMolEn ih MCtMhihaham DATE: 7///90 7/7-/90 7/e /9'O Y

,0 ..

= *~

- - - _ . . ... - - .. . 4

. .s.

FAC53 MILE " WHSKIDsIO11 l

a e. : __9sM JY// ,

(esse.ga to: .Id //4 ) _

Mhc ..- , , , , , , ,_. _

. _____ _ _ _ . . . . _ _ _ l

.l Telecopy Nur.bert 3 - Z d ._6 _. .

f h2 -dh_ 7 Ve rification Nurter: . _,, _ , . _ _ _ _

i This nessage consi.sts of pages (excitding covnr shee':).

/~I M4maage fron:

u..

j ,,

g WJL:. N.j 2 .,3on.

N Sandia Natiotuti L abo::stcelie s ziou Albuquerque, organisation ,_(6_j/ Hey Mp/13 _.

Building _ sas, Roo:a 34s1

'r e l e c o p y m u s.h : : (ti a s) a46 5270 verification :tusmer: (sos) 4 44..o c ss (1105) s44-93.oe e MWWWreldB __9 M G -_W SM ' N_M g g _ _ _

fi '

, Enclosure

~

L .. ,

t To Arthurt3ualik frian; Arthur : Payne

- luid ee t : consequenen In.timates for Peach.Doccom Source Terns

~

st: ached are the actral computer res.ilts for, the :hree caser, I

he eccident p::cgre ssions are specified by. a ataquence of

~

rait.

en . letters: 1) DXLXGAAAXX, 2) DKBXE VtAXX, MD 'i l ::XBXDA/AC(,

.hu pcssition Tapresents different charteteristi:s of the: accidant irogression and an X m ann that I did r et une taat position.

  • onition

, D- "'C CV AT'.'S with no S LC, go to low pre ssuro ad use ;ov pressure injection systems. .C ontainn.ent heata up . l 6 3- Vessel breach occurs' at low P.IV prussure and :here is no l injection. (i . e. . low pressure injection failed af':ar l containment failure). l l

i G- Containment Emils by wetwell renting befors core dam. ige starts. 3.elease is initia1L7 by SRV lines to SP and after vessel' broach by downcoaers to SP then to ree.euor building throu6h 18" vent lires.

E- Contaituent f: ails by drywell tupture eithor beforc core darnaga or during core damage bt..t befcre vess ul brs ach. ,

Initial release is by SRV lines to wetwell, back to

.drywell and out to- reactor building. After vesnel breach release is to drywell and out to. lib.

D- Containment f. alls by drywell lead ruptura sith. before core damage or during coro dama5e but before1 ve sual broach. Relaase is initially by SRV linet. to SP, back +

to drywe ll', - ' and then out tc refueling Elcor. /.ft:cr vessei bre act: release is to dryvell ane',' then out to  ;

refueling floor. '

i A- Containment fulls before vessel broach cc:ar5 A= No containment sprays are available.

O A- The core concesee interaction (C01' occurs alth no w:cr available.

n the SE and SD cases, I can not guarantee ths c contairmont

'aDure ' occurred before core damage stated. There r.r a two ways V

air a <: un-nt; n 7 - . r 25

L -

f

'. cur pre ss;ure inj ection can fail: 1) by valve cyclirs it.ilure: sad

!) by los a of NPSN afeer containment :eilure.

Cani ; can oc nar t ii Ser beifore or af ter contair.mont fal]urei.

'ha results are: .

nne 1: PD 50 mi - 4.15E 4/3.9E 8 - 1.6E+4 per-tieverts.

P3 1000 mL - 1.67E-3/3.9E-8 - 4.3E+4 per sieverts.

To:a1 cost - 124/3.9E.8 - 3.2E+9 DcIlirs.

nt.e 2: P3 50'mi - 3.00E-4/1.2E 6 - 6. .lE4 4 per sieverts. 1 PD 1000 mL - 2.00E 3/1.2E 8 - 1. 7E4 5 per sleverts. /

To:a1 Cost - 220/1.2E 8 - 1.9E+10 Dellire.

ni4 3: P3 50 mi - 7.62E-6/1.5E 10 - 5.0E+4 pe r sievert:s . I P3 1000 mL'- 2.96E 5/1.5E 10 - 1.9E+5 per sievert:s.

Total Cost - 3.39/1.5E 10 - 2.2E+10 Dc 11.s rc .

'.f you ha.ve any questions please call.

\ r liin.orely, -

. sri kur

. i i

E if d . 21-Y M i t':~ :V G 3, 9:? ' d ?5

_ r, -

's ,

.CCCCCCCCCC 88888888888888-- -- -- -_--_-- - -_ _ -

-_y --- --- --- - CCCCCCCCCC The STS VANClesster's SSES CCCCCCCCCC - . . . - . . --

- ----- ----- - --- _ - CCCCCCCCCC1 errrrrrre;r a n - ,- - - - U ECCCCCCC _

n GECE N N-M D.' AAA -AAA Y Y N ,

11 A A C P PA A Y Y N N E .

A A C P P A A YY Des N E A A C- PPPP A A Y NNN FFFF AAAAA C P AAAAA Y N ted E A A C P A A Y M N E A A CCCC P A A Y M N FFFFF PPPP RRRR AAA M M III SSSS 000 U U TTT1T  ;; 1 999 P P R R A A tal IAf I S O O U U T g3 11 3 9 P P R R A A WWW I S O e u u T .1 s' 9 PPPP Rf(M A A M -M I SSS O O U U T  ;; 1 9999 P RR MJU!A M M I S D D U U T  ;; 1 9 P R R A A M M I S .. S O U U T  : 1 9 P R R A -A M M III SSSS .. 000 uutAAf T'  ; 111 999 M -MT D UO D b) -

h

. .. s ..n s W 3DDDhklWb ,

Fi!: 22552"!A1: {ACPAYME.115"SEMS}P**.!!IS.Dt!T;19 (1918,443,9), !=st m ieed ee 21-SEP-19"9 19:51, ir e d bf 9 - ,- M*' M 'a "

by UIC [ACPAYME]. The records are variable length with FINrTRAM (F1M) carrings contret. Ylee leegroot record in 131 bytes.

% swauss s moy ya h es,aws.s an -n we-tesew tats / ey neer uPavse , etts: z

[ma Arse ], ennesw- weemms 7tteese we wrincity tee, started on print.wr TXA5: on 21-SEP-1989 IS:52 from qwwwe TAL.ARISI.

p ( ggcc ggg . .. . .. . .. ... .. ...... .. . ,

CCCCCCCCCC 5 CCCCCCCCCC 8 -- - . x88080808 Digital Esquipsment Corporateese - VAX/VMS Vervie= V4.5 -- - ~ -

CCCCCCCCCC d CCCCCCCCCC sancoanow.cocaccoouwwwwwwoowawwwwwwwwawwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww.wwww.wwwwww.i.m6 - CCCG (CCCC

=J J.

U m

7 u.

ti O .t

. - - -. - ,. . , . ., .m~ , _ , , , , , - --

,,,,v -

O O PRA MODEL INTECftATION SYSTEM -- $sLA (Jt2E 1989) . O O.-' . 3 ,

21-30' m7 IG;GG;32 ,

& .".l-@ C;M "X UG. ::l21l"

cl StaP LDB:[UtSMIT11.PBJRAMI5]P0_tJtS_HCUDE.DAT '

POS '109:(LMSMITH.PB PRAlf15]PB LHS_TDIAC.DAT 8 Ot toes:[LatSWITH.PB PRAesISjefe_t MS es01ftvfetme_IIASE tanSTER.IEP

/#8 . LD8: {LM5MITH.P8JRAMIS] DFUT_FRER.PB_ BASE.DAT 3De3Be5C48A47Ae8A PAR 109 : {tteWITH .P8_ PRAISIS] P ART $C .PNT .

CSQ LDS-[LMSifITH.PB PRAMIS]PBCGt2C_ BASE.0UT 5 6 7 &

Matt EP.!S _IM  !

IND APB Enel EAlmFLEE to-CnARACTER BIN Ib bESCR1rl'OR5 1 DF 9 PLANT DAMAGE STATES SPECIFIED 4 0F 8944 ACCIDOK PROCRESSIOpt BIMS SPECIFIED 8 0F - ' 8 SOURCE TEliti PAftTITIINES SPECIFIED e nF e CONSFEttH8CE tFAstlWES SPEC 1FTED ,

tAATRIX IRA TIPt.ICATIONS WILL BE TERIGMATED Fm i fWING CWATIqpt er AP9

- i

. 1 1

e 7

tN e

b 9

9 LL 1J t) s I

.- e p .tr gy,2,,., ,.a.. .. , , . , . ., ,..,,ny . , 4 ,_., y, ,,.y. o.,,,,._w..g m.

y m

m 4 e-. _esE Jo a m.. m..ar.,,

.._ ,. m y ._h _ A s _Au_

W J ,.

g- .

}

1. .,

4 I

l l

l l

.I M NN . M

-. g . ....

l> W t -

  1. I i Il IlI.II i

l .

e. ,. s i. -

$ I '*de 8  !!

e nE;;r

. - li W g WII.

g' T il Il 106ll 2 ,, n...

r k al I g g

  • R " g t;;" a

-E.

t-af  :

.j Sj!.ge- ;: dd e L la

.l li

..e m gl.*'2Ill!85 g

lfR Et.:ll 9 .

l,.g8 ... g5: .

's , ,

Q 48

~ r*

1 gangs!.Il -

(si. _- -

2 3"d C.t hM-cf k ri 2F M ' ci 9. ? ' d E

-- : , , a a .

CONSE,'JEPEE REAStRES FOR RELIM APS 2 * ,

12:25 MBSAY, SEPTnsFW 25, 1999 ..

'A$YEAlhK ' ,

, ,m y

... ~

_. . . ,,_. . -_ - - - . . ,,,,m. . --

o,,ce.

. p Q. '

1909EMTS N' 2ee Stad WCTS 295 ,

l nlEAN 3.39187423 Star S.334SES i STD DEv s.ss721987 YARDWEE .64 SMEWESS 5.21213 F1RTOSIS 43.ESF9 155 e.939937' CSS 8.9308726' CV 431.*u STD IEAN .WWEN

, TM.AMd 3.27984 PREB)lT) -5. m 27751 SO4 RA45C 7378.5 PROR>lSI - S.9531 Nuu - a e7 St3AstTILES MF=4) Natt 188% HAX S.SR64 995 9.944241 LEY NIEEEST 75% 43 a.9ns1535 955 9.9E 9196 9 9.9259 7 EFX IED 8 95K 9.m S S.9549 2ss 42 e les 9 e e.ess4 .

OT WIN 9 65 6 9 S.9443 1% W e 9.5884 oaucc a suut4  !

Q3-Q1 8.8881535

!dODE e

. 1 F

d.

N o,

<TJ 7

5h.

C'.  ?

  • 1)

=

u-u Ul e

I

.t.

{..

CONSCTdMCE tEASIAtES FOR SIElt IK APS 3 N- -

12:25 IImeAY; SEPTHEEft 2G, . asse .

13(IVARIATE .

m ..,. ......a.,.-  :

,y - .=-.; .. - -- . ....

n. .

w1aFNTS M- 2ste Sans scis see LEAN 123.895 Suti .24779.1

.STD DEV 646.525 VARIAIKE 297597 SKEBESS 6.29829 NtatTBSIS 44.6321 -

LISS -52293988 CSS 59221994 CV 448.311 STB GEAft 38.5744 T:N 2.9 M M PM B)]Tl S.m153814 5434 R M SC 2376.5 PRWl>lSt. S. Sept MJti ~= S 97 QUANTItES(DEF=4) N

' 19eX MAX 4716 99E 4337.7 1953T 9tItNEST 75% E3 7.4175 . 9 ESC E44.4C S 1948 585 tED 8 955 122.7 8 .2579 2sz qi e ass e e 213e SE WIN 9 55- 5 6 4388 1% 8 9 4716 o.w ana Q3-QL 7.4175 ucet e I

I b

i d,

i b e

n U5 17.

t.U i

J u

W m

[

- . ~__.__ . - _ _ _ _ - _ _ - _ _ _ _ . _ - _ . - - . . _

~

I

, AFD FRECDeCICS I OR IRJ5LIK APB - 5 -

l 12:31 INNEDAY, SEPTHSER 25, 1999

  • l UNIVAR* d iE. ,,.

n . . , . - . .. - - ..

tt . .

wasFNTS N 295 Stal SETS 2We EAN '3.887E 4 Stad 7.775E-88 STD DEV 1. 86SE-9F WARIABICE 2.425E-14 SKE W Fl;S '7.93E49 IGRTBSIS 71.5418.

135 5 7.115E-12 CSS 8.912E-12 CV 4 75.999 . S1D M 1.3SE-8B ,

T:WEAse=a 2.9h 21 PEBB>lTl 5.WSSSH SGN RANK 2378.5 -PROB)lSl s.8351 NUW *= 8 97 l

l QtlANTII ES(DEF=4) EXTpFeFE lee % WAX 1.09eE-e6 995 1.187E-as Lew.ST HItsCET  ;

754 Q3 G.673E-e9 96% t.4aeE-sF e 3.32E-87 SFX WED 9 95E 5.974E-ee s 7.79E-87

75% Q1 s 18E 8 8 8. 51E-67 9% WIN e s% s e 1.17eE-es 1% 8 9 1.9 E -86
  • * *5  ? . M *a Q3-41 S.823E-e9 MODE e I

e h l T

0-. 3

= n 4 t

'.1* y rs s s O.

u'

~

su tL ts.)i t

e h

., , ..m-. . . _ . , , . .. < . . _ . _ _. ,

i. -

(

l ~

TAR *AJUULAAJ r rr rers car r rr r s c c rrrrr r r rarr s ussa marssress sssss sest ran sassass s s ss se r assamasssersessressssserarsrassar naamanaamms . - -

[- imanaamanne UUUUUUUUUU 565555555$566655555555555555555555555 The 923 VAXCleseter's SSES ""?_"""""~"""""5"""""*"""""*E UUt?J'JL* """J 05"!!!!55555555!!!!!!!!TT'T!!T'"?Y5'i""**" "" "'"'"' " 'rarararrmcssesarmesasassa utaaaaaaeae ,

m

. AAA CCCC pppp .AAA Y YN 'N m E A A C P P A A-Y Y N N E '

A A C. P P A' A YY Set M E A A C PPPP A A Y M N N' FFFF AAAAA C P AAAAA Y: N '994 E A A C P A A Y N N E A A CCCC P A A Y N N FFFFF l

U U-N N III V V AAA IWIER - L III S$55 -;; 333 U U N N I V V A A_R R L I E  ;; 3 3

. U U 994 M I V V 'A A R R , t. I S 3 V V HMM I V Y A A WWIER *
t. :I SSS  ;; 3 0 'O M tet I V V AAAAA- R R ' L- I S  ;; 3 U U N N I VV A A R R . . ' L I S  ; 3 3  ;

I UUUUU M N III V A A- R R ..-' LLL1L III 5555 .; 313 NW D$ ) /

r;te  ::!,5.*.".,UA1 : (ACPA'fME.115SSEMS] tJMIYAR .LIS ; 3 (*154,39,9) , !=rt re-id en 2^-W-lene em:sas, 3. 4 hs a ,

-ting t i l. . ems t by UIU [ACPA' nee] . The records are variable leegth with FOR11tfee A corriego control . -The tengest. record le se bytes.

J-t '_my. {!!aa} ,. ; _r d a t - ' = ' as' t S *~ *a-St e-1*aso em : s.st e,y . c M Pawse , triC [AGAW, ur ser sceovest 171151= mL or.orii, IGG.

start d ,'L'3 e printer TXAE: wa 25-SEP-1983 90:58 frees <queous TALARISI.

p.

F UUUUUUUUUU Esss m u u s56LL56ES&55555555555 %565556665656566E5555555EG6666655555555555555565665556655665E&&6E555665 taAJUUUutAsu y tA)UULAEUUUU 555555555555555555555556 01sital Eseisument Corporation - VAX/vus Vereise V4.s errrrrasarsusssessersser uusmaananas q tAAAAJUUUUU 5556565555555555555555555555555555555555555656555665555555555656SE E5tr rr r r r rrrr r e r*E65566556E5566E555555s tmAAA.sama a n 9

55 l

m  ;

F AJ ij L1- 3 W

UI

-n. - - .

F

. APB FRECENCIES FOR mns ist Apg 1- _

9:58 RESDAY, SEPTEldInt 29, 1989 .

liruv*siilhiE c-

  • rs ..-. ,-. - . . - . . . . . .-

it' -

uow nTs .

M 299 SUte WCTS tes .

WEAN 1.15E-es SLA8 2.3170-48 STD DEV 5;447E-88 VARIApeCE 2.923E-15 SKEWeESS 8.373C9 I N TOSIS- 77.4988' t!SS -6.e90E-13 CSS 5.917E ..

CV 486.723' STD IEAN 3.323E-ee T :taEAN=e . . s.eMie6 PROB > lit S.W 275937-SCN RAteC 98E5.5 PROB >lSt. .S.8531 Muu - e les QUANTILES(DEF=4) EN tees uAI s.n6E-87 995 4.201E-er t.eEST HIGEEST 751 Q3 3.888E-89 SET 5. e2K-881 s 9.617E-se 58% LED 4.44eE-18 SsN 1.75sE-as 8 1.182E 75% Q1 S.218E-11 1eX 1.8seE-11 9.7esE-13 2.11SE-97 ex win e sw s.ssaE-12 1 .8 1 E E- 1 2 4.222E-97 1% 9.7seE-15 2.3 M -12 5.779E-57

  • 2 Y T.77*S *'

43-41 1.e2cE-89 1.CDE S i

s F

<1 c

bi t

m ,

U' i G

w 3-

.a- -- - - . - . ,

, .- 4 .., .. _

~

1

- CENSEEENCE GEASURES FM RA5L3K AFB 1 -.. ..

' S:53 14ESDAY, SEP1Em 26, .1999 .e

' iBiIVuiiIATE ' ,

m ,=..~,-.......~.-a. ,

.van n . .- .. -

n. .

amnarwis M 200 SUM WT5 255' ~.

4EAN STD DEY

.068498734 SAS 9.99265727 VARIA80CE 8.8997428 8.54E-Se } -

SMEDES3 -8.7435 MLNtTOSIS S4.3957 -l tES 9.21s135113 CSS 8.88138139 .

CV' 512.773 STD REAfd .958188828 T: TEAM =4 2.75797 PROSY lTl 4.48835700 sm RANK 9968.5 PROS)l5l S.SSSI Huu - e les ,

l EMNTILES @4) NR I leet leAX e.9292 99W 6.939199 RA EST MItBEST l 75% Q3 9.8051396 961C S.851789 9 9.95338 l EST RED 9.55551796 905 S.SMS18 G 1.M7 l 25% (1 2.988E-98 1sK 4.857E-s7 5.5 m m ;S.ese2 eT MP' W EN 1.398E-97 E.SAEF4  ! 8.9193 i 1X 5.sasE-18 7.asE-SS 's.9292

" *: " .-T '

Q3-Q1 .e80136513 '

WODE S f

a r.

f-

, f id

< s

-l

, O to t bN m  :

Y W

'6).:.

u Up

[

a ~ r a , , - + - - . . - . -- __ ___ __ ,,

u. ,

,~

- CONSEQUDEE adEASLRES f*OR ENSt_IK ' APS ' *

~*'

0:C3 TESSAY, SEPMBAER 26, 1999- .*

li'IVARIATE ,

V ' =* ~ = e T C .T1 % e ~ CC ;W **" "

n.

unaswTs M 299 SUte WGTS 2ee MEAN 5.aS200sS1 SLAI S.483332 STD DEV 9.9199458- VARIANCE .eestisems SKEWESS 9.55115 98R1951S '95.2135 ttSS '9.9246414 CSS -9.9239414 CV S47.277 ' STD 1EAN ' O.M397 T: eau =e_ 2.584ee PedB>lTl S.MS4795 sGN RADOC 9868.5 PROB)lSi 5.8531

. Nuw *. e . nee QUANTIt_ES (DEF-r4) EXTWFan leeSC MAX 9.127 99% S.atte3ne LgEST HISBEST 75% Q3 6.906696 96% S.8879175 9 S.9136 55% hED 5.999W7515 99E- S.852139 8 e.9161 26% Q1' .888813425 15% 1.887E-86 2.SeE-ST S.9275 85 WD8 9 5% 5.533E-97 2.15E-87 S.S m 1% 2.848E-99 . 2.18E-57 S.327 P_*f.T  ?.2??

Q3-Q1 .de6&S1575 200C 1.37eE-se bv

?>

. -4 IO m

i

.t.'

a Ls s U~i .,

21 .

~

CW8SEgJDeCE nasm4ES FtB RA5LIK APS ..

3 _

C . - . -

3:53 RESDAY, SEPTBSER 26, 1999 -*

~'-

j. Lai1 VARIATE ,

t, S------ - -

a w e sen. wearmeen s www,

, a.-

I L1. ,

M NTS' ,

H 299 ^ Stel WGTS 299 6EAM 219.31 StAl _43961.9 STD DEY _1271.23 VARIMECE 1618591 SKEDESS 9.45731 KURYD5IS 95.5246 USS 331253386 CSS 323599198 CV 578.333 S1D REAN 99.8897 T:tsee=s 2.44533 P90R>lTl S.815H17 SCN RMSC 9868.5 P5ttMB)l5 l 5.m mat '- e les QJANTILES(DEF=4) EXTERER 19M hLAX 144e9 994 9935 LSEST NIGEST 753 R3 51.576 9EE 732.45 9 3419 SM WD 7.73 9pE 187.8 9 1548 25% Q1 1.28 ISE S.1419 5.9114 36W 51 WIN S 55 S.946825 5.8119 m t

1% S.888114 5.9171 24498

  • * * ~
  • T* 2 .

G3-QI Ed.295 E000 6 i

e i i

n  ;

w  ; 2 E  : l j .  ;

e i s

di .

w N.

I i

.,f4, A J sa ,A - -:4 -w.a m - - + - , -----s A - - - r a---e .

  • I c ,: -

.h

'+

I i

)pl i

.r : i

,\\itll.*

d$

m '1 L

illil' 64 s

L liiiiiiijNE

'!!El?l!!i8

. ,ve w~n n w e a. sw as

d . -4+. . .

A dse a4-D__ .

a- .-

  • l' '

i

$1 jr

.i i , iE

.11 ll liN ,

di Es$j%, 1

'lili#

sew ed.-

g pg a

e _ e.ia i E ,

e "hEs t!!Bi!8 sw wwn wa -

a. v m

m

. n, - .

I i sp , j

r. ,,.

j E[C

-((g- --  : :

i  : ::

s? f

~

_. T l .!

l t' ) h.

!; l

n ,.,' e I..I .I l

+

i e -

t "..

j

$ 8 "# b l .!! f

:::: .. gt j,, .

<C ii

$ .. b 5 .

I ww ww n. e.

ll

. .R.

j ====n== ===;n== %V hj )7 j. }

l l azizarz s z I n:n z a  !! ' $

l' ,d .

lI u ( kl" C.

? ""; g --- g. 0  !'

l't. ! ""

o ,j j h

v. o 7

a "

.p - egt;":: .I 3~ " < "

o. 1 4 l,u g 2 a
l. nu -

IH L L, ,, . U h d.i. g .

N g h!

cg l-l u 5 -s,-g agummma w{iiit ge[ .ia. ,

.g w

l 1 h<<<

<<< << 3R===== O ,(9 &.,l %.. ,. .

[:-

i *  :

<u.u I (A .42 11 8 a I:

k:

{<ulo p t'I .[

l

!:.:. - 21 4

L  :  ;

. 3 " " !! = =

" 9 fg i

a fi$',

. !,;,j j.- t E=usl===- V_/ lj j :)2  :

, ! is l-: e-g5*b'*' .. . .

!<j ll.

.3 ,

1. .s j

.:- a -

5 I :: .

g < . L

{e  : $$ ! :CE y:- 0~ih'8  ;

> R ::  !. o 5l: : .'kl'" .2% :. -

4: ;I I .1 "Ob wa a.nen s:r . : ww

1 i

e 1

.=

l '

h 1a 7_:

lige.kt

,W i h'. i dl!ll!

4!E'

[lillil suiew

, sis L gip!!lls d!

'siiiiin i nam 8 era cumnnes:r s. u os

as__.._ 4 E44a~ . -s.,+w. - aa J 6 - . -- -s.- #

i

.i' e 1

. .l j- .

I l

>. l l

l

]

4

't L

i

- 94

>= b

.F

]8

  • I s t. i

,l!,l 'liu

~

lb!EO 8

.Hiii!i:5 1 GEE t ElLE E't't t'l!'E'.

W l" B "i! E" II""B" - H L i

'uman

. ce =

cueywr n. 3 a

- , . ;. - _ - : . ;~ . . _ .

g.

g- .; .

v :.: _ ; = . ;

-~. . . ~ -

APB F 6 JES FOR R85L1K APS .-?~

l' .

9:48 itKSDAY,. SEPTRAF9t gg,1999 - e >- .

= :. .

7 ,

i.adIVsEIATE .

& ._ama

^

c_

MouENTS N 299 SUti WGTS . 299 afAW 1.529E-lo Stad 3.sESE-es STD DEV 7.515E-19 VARIANCE 5.792E-19 SKEWESS s.38837 xtsrTUSIS '78.s351 (GS 1.13K.-28 CSS 1.153E-16 CV 497.762 STD REJWI 5.391E-11 T: TEAM =9 2.94115 PROB >lTl S.89493292 SGN rap 0( 3139 PROS >lSl S.8591 MUM *- S Sf WJANTILES(DEf=4) EXT N S tess WAX 7.748E-99 99K 6.es0E-e9 toWEST MiesEsf 75% Q3 9.41sE-12 95% 7.835E-le 8 1.?sE-89 Ee5 BED e 90% 2.14eE-le 9'1. Esse-es 2SX Q1 9 191G S S 2.22E-89 .

8% WIN S 5% 8 9 ' S.8EM'-49 1% 0 9 7.74E .T:.~  : . * * .%

G3-01 9.415E-37 WDDE 6

(.

b s

3 ,

c, r rn tJ t I,

sY d.

'_ . . . .m... , - . .; . - , . . . , , , . . . . . - , ,- -

1 - +

  • ~ -

COMSECUO4CE nEASURES FOR SUSLIK APS 1 9:44 TtE3 DAY, SEPTnMFD 26, 1999

.a east wav e a ls ,

N rw-._ n. -. . . . _ _ _ ...n- . _ . . _ . _ _ . _---

yl YPtMhf% M &

O_

MDIENTS N 298 $4.A8 WCTS . 239 WEAM 7.822E-ee Stad 8.8515244G STD DEV .598845879 VARIANCE 2.195E-89 SKEWESS 31.4363.K15ff0 SIS 145.554 (ASS 4.3eEE-57 ' CSS 4.1SSE-87 CY 661.983 STD EAN 3.244E-88 T: EAN-f 2.34957 PROS)lTl S.9197748 SW RAfe( 1139 P909)lSi 9.9001 i

NUW % S SF l

QUANT 1 TIS (DEF=4) EXNt i

'. 100% MAX 5.980094 995 S.98914373 LCEST MIesE3T j i

75% Q3 4.643E-57 96% .553527175 9 .9.5N5089 E85 MED e SWE 9.529E-e6 S S. m 1 l 25% Q1 f IWM e 5 f.m17 5% MIM e SW e S P. m &44 .

I 1M 6 5 0. 6 03-01 4.843E-87

  • l snxx e

=

y 7

Y LJ O

55 m

Qt .

Y$

9 tt ta ff) l

  • ' > ay -- w',- .s.*%- w g &___ _ ., _ v, _ , &w p 9f , ,

~ ;*" . .

  1. ~ i CONSEQtENCE 4EA50RES FM ERfSLEBC APS 2 :- .
  • S-9:44 TIF W Y,.SU*Trasta 26, 1989 sentwassate ,

^. aT ' r ~ - _ ~ FLiamIM Laas n ,6 h M ,

a .

~

N MIS N 290 SUM WGTS - 299 asEAN . ESSO 2982F $UW -9.99692641 1 SYD DEY .e98188986 VARIABEE' 3.589E-SS i~

SKEWESS 12.5796 NURTESIS 158.818

USS 7.277E-86' CSS 7.191E-SS CV 837.513 51D EM8 .500913358 T
EAft-6 2.21798 PROS)lTl S.927987 sees sueet 113e enoS)isI S.eSol i Ntml *z e 67 QUANTILES @Er=4) EX1erart 162% MAX 9.59254 99% 9.58049918 LDEST HIWEST' 755 Q3 1.65eE-es 95Y .988113296 9 9. 6 5eX LED e 99K S.98393547 e S.SSSS36 2E% QL 9 10% 0 0 9. M es urn e ss e e s.eWees 15 e S S.eSNA G3-Q1 1.654E-86 LEDE 6 l

dl ai e ~

s s A

m, U _.

61 >

Us

~ . . ~ . _ . . . . . .

c, =

L ,

.s . 1. .

.? i f + .. , .

8

~ ~

  • 9 * ::

l l22 3 8 "'

_g- .._ .

l I=

u o

1 l l .. . . . ..

g enazer l e.e*I28 i

-I .s- - B .ss gi5 $ Egg:

E L

E

. w

' ll . $W:

- g g- E i h g"' $$!!NE 4

  • i,E...

g gt;tg'2-Rt an.,I90: 9A.

I.  ! E " ,;

as-o I . nD .4.

y g .

. t1 l j.

n v

ii W*

f

.l$lEEt

e s s" e t ag .. gg.

mg ei g

. ~.

. e

,i i i

f gutut mu

,:l&wa,g

=.

tT d . .aa!-wr n 93 :2 " 6 3. 9:: s