ML20053D102

Interrogatory Re Probability of Meltdown Accident Propounded Pursuant to ASLB 820423 Order.Certificate of Svc Encl.Related Correspondence

ML20053D102
Person / Time
Site:	Indian Point
Issue date:	05/29/1982
From:	Fleisher Z WEST BRANCH CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION
To:	CONSOLIDATED EDISON CO. OF NEW YORK, INC., POWER AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK (NEW YORK
References
ISSUANCES-SP, NUDOCS 8206040084
Download: ML20053D102 (2)

Text

- - _ _ .

um.ATED COBRESPONDEMB UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSI0N, BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of p g CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF NEW YORK ) Docket'Nos.Y50-247 SP OO (Indian Point Unit 2) 50-286 SP ~~

POWER AUTHORIT[OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK May 29, 1982 (Indian Point Unit 3) '

WEST BRANCH CONSERVATION ASSOCIATION INTERROGATORY TO THE LICENSEES WBCA-5.14 Judge Carter in the Order of April 23 suggested that discovery shall continuo, soo footnoto .5f,p.22 ..3 Licensee's response of May 18 to UCS/NYPIRG

1. 88, p. 77, shows a probability higher than anything in WASH-1400. The Preliminary Report " Review and Evaluation of Zion Probablistic Safety Study" by Sandia Lab. , let-ter of transmittal of March 5, 1982 to the NRC, in Sec-tion 5 page 5-1 shows a chart of many various possible accidents. No meltdown accident has the probability of 1016 or an9 number close to it. A meltdown on that chart might he 4.2 X 10-5 and the total for the critique at the bottom of the columns is 1.3 X 10-4. Please ex-plain the methodology used to arrive at any higher figure and also for the one in Licensees reply #88.

l for West Branch Conservation Association /

914/634-2327 443 Buena N 109563 Vista Rd. ,New City,g.Y.ggg,g,,gfg "d ' -

/

Zipporah S. Fleisher 03 8206040084 820529 ecretary O PDR ADOCK 05000247 ' 5 C PDR ll1

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION e U

AT0 HIC SAFETY ANOL LICENSING BOARD ,

~ , ,: m, (

ac

• y L's Before Administrative Judges: $

s Louis J. Carter, Chairman E Frederick J. Shon - *82 , Pr/j28 e In the Hatter of \- Dr. Oscar H. Paris

~~~ ~

) _

y/// $

CONSOLIDATED EDISON COMPANY OF ) k[_i 5 .' $

NEW YORK, INC. (Indian Point, )

Unit No. 2) ) Docket Nos. 50-247-SP

) 50-286-SP POWER AUTHORITY OF THE STATE OF ) May 29' 1982 NEW YORK, (Indian Point, )

Unit No. 3) _

)

.g y

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE  :

This is to certify that I have placed in the first class mail's on May 29, 1982, to all parties in above captioned W case copies of ADDITIONAL UITNESS LIST, A HEARING SCHEDULE $

REOUEST and an INTERROGATORY REQUEST REPEATED from May 3.&_23. i r

3 B'*"'

Lat!gatten D6,uien , .

p eswei,q and Service erwach M*9" Oiaries A. Scheiner.Ca Chairpwson p 1R'cs' ',~ ,3 ;':".3,e . u ,

Castung='i, DC 2CD3 my C.-i er ~- v-% ~ L"' ,^.",%aie'C g,,y3wA PdY 30003 "" Yer% NY 30 '8

" "' "' "" '~'  :.73::ct;~' ~'-c~""

Thnta Plaina, NY 10602 i

2->= r_ --e. % ,a,,, ," Co

^ued m. D uie Heroy 3. anecnaven, Esq. 3,, 4 venchenw Cowny Essomve Ai.,,

u 3,,,on.,,,a,,,

p,,,,E q.

3"*3#' y, L**'*' vntchener Cowiry PameLa 3. N.rowtu. Esq. Cr. - - NY 10320 N.AC pm ggStaffy, Cas.e4 ta,ci,,;,, L,g,3 % g,g m,ggn, g,,,,,

413. Peuriser keguntry Commisa.en ' ""'

• Thine Pains, NY 10608

,,g Lama $darnan e = mn ,,,,o ,t,eet.N... , , , , ,

- e,-e.- a*e

' W 8'"* N Steve Le saa. Esq.

-.me ,Est,e Omnirman tmas 3. Cster.

Darles K Pran. Esq.

mnoPtect.- e- Yest 13th 5

,.e. Yo, NY , a .

Aemic Safety ard Lacerwing 8eard g,, y,,,, 3,,,, g n,,,,, g,,,,, 3 73IO City 3.tae Av. rue p,, y,y' of e State of New Yoria T Wernd Trade Carner Judit.h Keester .*

Phtiesial;.akia, Pa.19151 "Y*'** I

• Rockland Citiaeris for Safe Energy 80 Ceauneus Circ $e Dr. Cocar H. Paris N'* T"A # 300II Rertoe Sch.ortz. Esq. $

hew Caty,.(Y 80936 Adminantseve Juese Benean. Nys, salar & mreorg .

I,M E3',' ,I'9g g,q, Ammac Safrey and Laceau. rig board Attorneys la 34etr.polatan Transportaraon Auch &&ayw Cowge V. Begwy w C.wamana.on u.s. wahar aer aary g,,,,,,,,,;,,

m M An== viii.g..: ,,ca Cawgen, DC mM M** "'A 83' 234 Tate Averuse 8713 s Street. N.T. Sulu Joe washirigten, DC 2:306 Stanley a. Klineers

&4r. Fredernch 3. She no e, ,,4,gy Aem hghy haceraitig board Jean Holt. DW Yorts Esergy Ch

• gg,g

• • ' " "*** K""#*h trhit. Plaims, K.F.10601 g'O C I' 3 Lr Yo,s P*'h#

3 g

1. Y ioon

7. A.d,.. .. ..,,.. ....

l m: .-- -

er..:tse. , - - ,,

Paew Yseis P.al;c Luerest Research Cren,, c/o Dean R Carron. Directar

=:,m.i D$sraet #6 '

., ., ~. ,.r.

W= "w Rs. Amanda PetterfleLf. Esq.

2 0 Cenes2 A esa New Yorts Uriavers'rY City.N32 P.O. Bos 384 CMie P;aJns, NY LC604 6 vesaret Street N,, yarg Ny gooc7

- Itllage St.atloss 3 m,r , ,,. ,n. ,,,~ , m,c t. Fam ta . m.==...... -i-=. ee Y-s an New Yoris tr. waary Law Schoot Anemic Safety and L3censteg Board Penal .,Cesney Atanwy Elevid 38. Pitus Esq.. Richard Csaja, 'Esq l ggy ym, gig U.S. P& a.., Reggaeory Commlas;en Casiry et itecklaref

' * ,* pew Y.rk, N.Y. 1W Appeal 5.ard Panel ty. . 16 h g Pet Pe==ar, Spe'esPerson Parents Caricarnes Amaut indlan Petr't h ' ~ ~ ~ ~ ' P(Y 10320 Ne* Teris City Aushman Society I

78 nen 23re Sr.es. Suhe U23

[ ,?se. Yor%.4Y 1G012

~

l for West Branch Conservation Association - n l

443 Buena Vista Road, New City, N.Y. 1095 )-

914/634-2327 n, ,[ g by Zipporah S. Fleisher Secretary l

l t - - . - -