ML13039A464
| ML13039A464 | |
| Person / Time | |
|---|---|
| Site: | Indian Point  |
| Issue date: | 12/31/2008 |
| From: | Atomic Safety and Licensing Board Panel |
| To: | |
| SECY RAS | |
| References | |
| RAS 24028, ASLBP 07-858-03-BD01, 50-247-LR, 50-286-LR | |
| Download: ML13039A464 (23) | |
Text
United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Official Hearing Exhibit Entergy Nuclear Operations, Inc.
In the Matter of:
(Indian Point Nuclear Generating Units 2 and 3)
ASLBP #: 07-858-03-LR-BD01 Docket #: 05000247 l 05000286 NRCR00139 Exhibit #: NRCR00139-00-BD01 Identified: 1/30/2013 Submitted January 18, 2013 Admitted: 1/30/2013 Withdrawn:
Rejected: Stricken:
Other:
Environmental Impact Statement Scoping Process Summary Report Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station Unit Nos. 2 and 3 Village of Buchanan, New York December 2008 U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Rockville, Maryland
NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013
NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013
NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013
NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Introduction On April 30, 2007, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) received an application from Entergy Nuclear Operations dated April 23, 2007, for renewal of the operating licenses of Indian Point Nuclear Generating Station Unit Nos. 2 and 3 (IP2 and IP3), Village of Buchanan, New York. As part of the application, Entergy Nuclear Operations submitted an environmental report (ER) prepared in accordance with the requirements of Title 10, Part 51 of the Code of Federal Regulations (10 CFR Part 51). Part 51 of 10 CFR contains the NRC requirements for implementing the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) of 1969 and the implementing regulations promulgated by the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ). Section 51.53 outlines requirements for preparation and submittal of environmental reports to the NRC.
Section 51.53(c)(3) was based upon the findings documented in NUREG-1437, Generic Environmental Impact Statement for License Renewal of Nuclear Power Plants, (GEIS). The GEIS, which identified and evaluated the environmental impacts associated with license renewal, was first issued as a draft for public comment. The staff received input from Federal and State agencies, public organizations, and private citizens before developing the final document. As a result of the assessments in the GEIS, a number of impacts were determined to be small and generic to all nuclear power plants. These were designated as Category 1 impacts. An applicant for license renewal may adopt the conclusions contained in the GEIS for Category 1 impacts, absent new and significant information that may cause the conclusions to fall outside those of the GEIS. Category 2 impacts are those impacts that have been determined to be plant-specific and are required to be evaluated in the applicants ER.
The Commission has determined that the NRC does not have a role in energy planning decision-making for existing plants, which should be left to state regulators and utility officials.
Therefore, an applicant for license renewal need not provide an analysis of the need for power, or the economic costs and economic benefits of the proposed action. Additionally, the Commission has determined that the ER need not discuss any aspect of storage of spent fuel for the facility that is within the scope of the generic determination in 10 CFR 51.23(a) and in accordance with 10 CFR 51.23(b). This determination was based on the Nuclear Waste Policy Act of 1982 and the Commissions Waste Confidence Rule, 10 CFR 51.23.
On August 10, 2007, the NRC published a Notice of Intent in the Federal Register (72 FR 45075), to notify the public of the Staffs intent to prepare a plant-specific supplement to the GEIS (SEIS) regarding the renewal application for the IP2 and IP3 operating license. The SEIS will be prepared in accordance with NEPA, CEQ guidelines, and 10 CFR Part 51. As outlined by NEPA, the NRC initiated the scoping process with the issuance of the Federal Register Notice. The NRC invited the applicant, federal, state, local, and tribal government agencies, local organizations, and individuals to participate in the scoping process by providing oral comments at scheduled public meetings and/or submitting written suggestions and comments no later than October 12, 2007. The scoping process included two public scoping meetings, which were both held on September 19, 2007, at Colonial Terrace, 119 Oregon Road, Cortlandt Manor, New York. The NRC issued press releases and distributed flyers locally. Both sessions began with NRC staff members providing a brief overview of the license renewal process and the NEPA process. Following the NRCs prepared statements, the meetings were open for public comments. Approximately 50 attendees provided oral comments that were recorded and transcribed by a certified court reporter. The meeting summary, which was issued on October NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 24, 2007, and the associated transcripts are available for public inspection in the NRC Public Document Room (PDR), located at One White Flint North, 11555 Rockville Pike, Rockville, Maryland, 20852, or from the NRCs Agencywide Documents Access and Management System (ADAMS). The ADAMS Public Electronic Reading Room is accessible at http://www.nrc.gov/reading-rm/adams/web-based.html. The meeting summary can be found in ADAMS at Accession No. ML072851079. The transcripts of the meetings can be found in ADAMS at Accession Nos. ML072830682 and ML072890209. Persons who do not have access to ADAMS, or who encounter problems in accessing the documents located in ADAMS, should contact the NRCs PDR reference staff by telephone at 1-800-397-4209, or 301-415-4737, or by e-mail at pdr@nrc.gov.
The scoping process provides an opportunity for public participation to identify issues to be addressed in the SEIS and highlight public concerns and issues. The Notice of Intent identified the following objectives of the scoping process:
$ Define the proposed action
$ Determine the scope of the SEIS and identify significant issues to be analyzed in depth
$ Identify and eliminate peripheral issues
$ Identify any environmental assessments and other environmental impact statements being prepared that are related to SEIS
$ Identify other environmental review and consultation requirements
$ Indicate the schedule for preparation of the SEIS
$ Identify any cooperating agencies
$ Describe how the SEIS will be prepared.
At the conclusion of the scoping period, the NRC staff and its contractor reviewed the transcripts and all written material received, and identified individual comments. Each set of comments from a given commenter was given a unique alpha identifier (Commenter ID), allowing each set of comments from a commenter to be traced back to the transcript, letter, or email in which the comments were submitted (publicly available on ADAMS).
Comments were consolidated and categorized according to the topic within the proposed SEIS or according to the general topic if outside the scope of the SEIS. Comments with similar specific objectives were combined to capture the common essential issues that had been raised in the source comments. Once comments were grouped according to subject area, the staff and contractor determined the appropriate action for each comment. Table 1 identifies the individuals providing comments and the Commenter ID letter associated with each person's set(s) of comments. The Commenter ID letter is preceded by IPEC.
NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. Individuals Providing Comments During Scoping Comment Period Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ADAMS ID Accession Nos.
IPEC-A Riverkeeper Riverkeeper Staff Attorneys Written Comments ML071730115 IPEC-B FUSE Friends United for Written Comments ML071990093 Sustainable Energy (FUSE)
IPEC-C Susan Shapiro, Esq. Friends United for Written Comments ML071930400 Sustainable Energy (FUSE)
IPEC-D John J. Sipos New York State Assistant Written Comments ML072050210 Attorney General IPEC-E Chris Hogan Project Manager for Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 NYSDEC Meeting IPEC-F Taylor Palmer Representative for Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Congresswoman Nita Lowey Meeting IPEC-G Jim Knuebel NY AREA Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-H Sherwood Martinelli FUSE, Green Nuclear Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Butterfly Meeting IPEC-I Elizabeth Segal Resident, Tarrytown Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-J Gary Shaw Local Resident Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-K Phillip Musegaas Riverkeeper Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-L Lloyd Douglas Association of Minority and Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Women Entrepreneurs Meeting IPEC-M Glenn Rickles Riverkeeper Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-N Mike Otis Professor of Engineering at Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 SUNY New Paltz Meeting IPEC-O Charlie Donaldson Environmental Protection Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Bureau Meeting IPEC-P John Kelly Local Resident, Retired from Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Indian Point Meeting IPEC-Q Marilyn Elie Westchester Citizens Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Awareness Network, Indian Meeting Point Safe Energy Coalition (IPSEC)
IPEC-R Marie Quinten Pace Litigation Clinic Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-S Susan Shapiro President, FUSE Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-T Hazel Dukes New York State NAACP Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-U Michel Lee Council on Intelligent Energy Afternoon Scoping ML072830682
& Conservation Policy Meeting IPEC-V Ron Carpino Indian Point Senior Reactor Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Operator Meeting IPEC-W Dan Durett African American Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Environmental Association Meeting IPEC-X Ulrich Witte Citizen Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-Y Tom Hallsel Citizen Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-Z Susan Peale Resident, Phillipstown Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-AA Bill Maulmeister Entergy Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-BB Radmila Miletich Independent Power Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Producers of New York Meeting IPEC-CC Laura Seitz Resident, Croton-on-Hudson Afternoon Scoping ML072830682 Meeting IPEC-DD Chris Hogan Project Manager for Evening Scoping ML072830646 NYSDEC Meeting IPEC-EE Frank Giancimilli Office of Congressman John Evening Scoping ML072830646 Hall Meeting IPEC-FF Dan ONeill Mayor of the Village of Evening Scoping ML072830646 Buchanan Meeting IPEC-GG Manna Jo Greene Clearwater, Rosendale Evening Scoping ML072830646 Resident Meeting IPEC-HH Patrick Moore Greenspirit Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-II Susan Shapiro President, FUSE Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-JJ Norris McDonald African American Evening Scoping ML072830646 Environmental Association, Meeting Founder and President IPEC-KK Lisa Rainwater Policy Director, Riverkeeper Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-LL Jerry Kremmer Chairman of Advisory Board, Evening Scoping ML072830646 NY AREA Meeting NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-MM Andy OConnell Senior Business Agent, Evening Scoping ML072830646 Utility Workers Union of Meeting America Local 1-2 IPEC-NN Mark Jacobs IPSEC Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-OO Mark Cooperman Resident, Cortlandt Manor Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-PP Melvin Burruss President, African American Evening Scoping ML072830646 Men of Westchester Meeting IPEC-QQ Audrey Roberts Raging Grannies Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-RR Maureen Ritter FUSE Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-SS Tom Johnson President, Cortlandt Engine Evening Scoping ML072830646 Co. Meeting IPEC-TT Karen Kahn Resident, Westchester Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-UU Frank Fraley Mount Vernon Hospital Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-VV Margo Schepart Westchester Citizens Evening Scoping ML072830646 Awareness Network Meeting IPEC-WW Laurent Laurence NY AREA, on behalf Marcia Evening Scoping ML072830646 Gordon, President of the Meeting Business Council of Westchester IPEC-XX Tom Klein Boilermakers Local 5 Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-YY Dorice Madronero Rockland County Evening Scoping ML072830646 Conservation Association Meeting IPEC-ZZ Speaker on behalf of Al Rockland Business Council Evening Scoping ML072830646 Samuels Meeting IPEC-AAA Bob Seeger Business Manager, Evening Scoping ML072830646 Millwright local 740 Meeting IPEC-BBB Patrick Carlino Student, SUNY New Paltz, Evening Scoping ML072830646 NYPIRG Meeting IPEC-CCC Barbra Homyk Chemistry Specialist, Indian Evening Scoping ML072830646 Point Meeting NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-DDD David Green On behalf of Phillip Banks, Evening Scoping ML072830646 President, One Hundred Meeting Black Men IPEC-EEE Amanda Sisenstein NYPIRG Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-FFF Novia Butler Entergy Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-GGG Judy Allen IPSEC, Resident, Putnam Evening Scoping ML072830646 County Meeting IPEC-HHH Paul Richards Resident, Rockland County Evening Scoping ML072830646 Meeting IPEC-III Kathryn Wylde President and CEO, Written Submittals, ML072830629 Partnership for New York Afternoon City IPEC-JJJ Allan A. Samuels President/CEO, Rockland Written Submittals, ML072830629 Business Association, Inc. Afternoon IPEC-KKK Paul J. Vitale Vice President, Government Written Submittals, ML072830629
& Community Relations Afternoon IPEC-LLL Melvin Burruss President, African American Written Submittals, ML072830629 Men of Westchester Afternoon IPEC-MMM Patrick J. Curran Executive Director, The Written Submittals, ML072830629 Energy Association of N.Y. Afternoon State IPEC-NNN Radmila Miletich Independent Power Written Submittals, ML072830629 Producers of New York Afternoon IPEC-OOO Michael Otis Lecturer, SUNY-New Paltz Written Submittals, ML072830629 Afternoon IPEC-PPP Sherwood Martinelli Vice President, FUSE USA Written Submittals, ML072830629 Afternoon IPEC-QQQ Dan Durett Director, African American Written Submittals, ML072830629 Environmentalist Association Afternoon IPEC-RRR John Hall Congressman Written Submittals, ML072830613 Evening IPEC-SSS Michael R. Edelstein President, Orange Written Submittals, ML072830613 Environmentalist, Inc. Evening IPEC-TTT Norris McDonald Founder and President, Written Submittals, ML072830613 African American Evening Environmentalist Association IPEC-UUU Marc Jacobs Resident, Garrison, NY Written Submittals, ML072830613 Evening NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-VVV Lisa Rainwater Policy Director, Riverkeeper Written Submittals, ML072830613 Evening IPEC-WWW Mark Cooperman Resident, Courtlandt Manor, Written Submittals, ML072830613 NY Evening IPEC-XXX Phil Banks President, One Hundred Written Submittals, ML072830613 Black Men, Inc Evening IPEC-YYY Resident Resident of Peekskill and Written Submittals, ML072830613 Courtlandt Manor Evening IPEC-ZZZ Amanda Sisenstein NYPIRG Written Submittals, ML072830613 Evening IPEC-A4 Allan Samuels President/CEO, Rockland Written Submittals, ML072830613 Business Association Evening IPEC-B4 Paul Vitale Vice President, Government Written Submittals, ML072830613
& Community Relations Evening IPEC-C4 Kathryn Wylde President/CEO, Partnership Written Submittals, ML072830613 for New York City Evening IPEC-D4 Patrick Curran Executive Director, The Written Submittals, ML072830613 Energy Association of N.Y. Evening State IPEC-E4 Linda Conte Raging Grannies Written Submittals, ML072830613 Evening IPEC-F4 John Venier Sr. QA Engineer, Parsons Written Comments ML072820254 IPEC-G4 Danieala Nieto Delaware Nation of Written Comments ML072560367 Oklahoma Environmental Programs IPEC-H4 Paul Vitale Vice President, Government Written Comments ML072820244
& Community Relations IPEC-I4 Kathryn Wylde President/CEO, Partnership Written Comments ML072700254 for New York City IPEC-J4 Patrick Curran Executive Director, The Written Comments ML072820237 Energy Association of N.Y.
State IPEC-K4 Melvin Burruss President, African American Written Comments ML072700561 Men of Westchester, Inc.
IPEC-L4 Lloyd Douglas Association of Minority Written Comments ML072820252 Enterprises of New York IPEC-M4 William Mahlmeister Entergy Written Comments ML072820270 IPEC-N4 Joan Etzweiler Entergy Written Comments ML072820267 IPEC-O4 Thomas Pulcher Entergy Written Comments ML072820266 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-P4 Lisa Timm Resident Written Comments ML072820257 IPEC-Q4 Scott Vanderhoef County Executive, Rockland Written Comments ML072820274 County IPEC-R4 Doreen Constabile Written Comments ML072820263 IPEC-S4 Joan Matthews Senior Attorney for Special Written Comments ML072820746 Projects, NYSDEC IPEC-T4 Carolyn Cunningham Federated Conservationists Written Comments ML072841121 of Westchester County, Inc.
IPEC-U4 Kathleen Vorwick Written Comments ML072841164 IPEC-V4 Bob Seeger Business Manager, Written Comments ML072841167 Millwright and Machinery Erectors Local No. 740 IPEC-W4 Stephen Ballou Written Comments ML073100204 IPEC-X4 Elizabeth Bernard Resident, Westchester Written Comments ML073100209 County IPEC-Y4 Edmund Haffmans Written Comments ML073100322 IPEC-Z4 Jeannie Sunshine Resident Written Comments ML073100212 IPEC-A5 Al Hemberger Written Comments ML073100987 IPEC-B5 Jeff Young IPEC Chemist Written Comments ML073100328 IPEC-C5 Sharon and Chris Nolle Residents Written Comments ML073100314 IPEC-D5 Dorice Madronero President, Rockland County Written Comments ML073100308 Conservation Association IPEC-E5 Brian Skretney US Congressional Written Comments ML073030401`
Representatives IPEC-F5 Phillip Musegaas Riverkeeper Written Comments ML072960455 IPEC-G5 Paul Richards Professor, Columbia Written Comments ML073100319 University IPEC-H5 Dan Doinger Written Comments ML073100313 IPEC-I5 Michel Lee, Esq. Chairman, Council on Written Comments ML073100964 Intelligent Energy &
Conservation Policy IPEC-J5 Gary Shaw Written Comments ML073100310 IPEC-K5 Sherwood Martinelli Vice President, FUSE USA Written Comments ML073100331 IPEC-L5 Manna Jo Greene Hudson River Sloop Written Comments ML073090657 Clearwater NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-M5 Richard Blumenthal Attorney General, State of Written Comments ML072960359 Connecticut IPEC-N5 Christopher Crane Westchester County Board Written Comments ML073100317 of Legislators IPEC-O5 Gary Shaw Written Comments ML073100311 IPEC-P5 Susan Maggiotto Village of Hastings - on - Written Comments ML073100327 Hudson IPEC-Q5 Danieala Nieto Delaware Nation of Written Comments ML072820232 Oklahoma Environmental Programs IPEC-R5 Aaron Virgin Written Comments ML073100753 IPEC-S5 Abigail Jones Written Comments ML073100518 IPEC-T5 Adam Holland Written Comments ML073100913 IPEC-U5 Adrian Shanker Written Comments ML073100607 IPEC-V5 Alan Weiss Written Comments ML073100700 IPEC-W5 Aleta Chappelle Written Comments ML073100940 IPEC-X5 Alex Matthiessen Written Comments ML073100722 IPEC-Y5 Alexandra Siltow Written Comments ML073100669 IPEC-Z5 Alexi Griebsch Written Comments ML073100956 IPEC-A6 Alison Sussman Written Comments ML073100499 IPEC-B6 Allen Regar Written Comments ML073100906 IPEC-C6 Allie Bohm Written Comments ML073100548 IPEC-D6 Alma Evans Written Comments ML073100507 IPEC-E6 Amy Benesch Written Comments ML073100613 IPEC-F6 Amy Chender Written Comments ML073100549 IPEC-G6 Amy Goldsmith Written Comments ML073100727 IPEC-H6 Amy Harlib Written Comments ML073100208 IPEC-I6 Ana Cruz Written Comments ML073100735 IPEC-J6 Angelica Carrubba Written Comments ML073100657 IPEC-K6 Angela Garrone Written Comments ML073100557 IPEC-L6 Anita Ward-DAmico Written Comments ML073100608 IPEC-M6 Ann Sprayregen Written Comments ML073100658 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-N6 Anne Drennen Written Comments ML073100938 IPEC-O6 Anne Pope Written Comments ML073100690 IPEC-P6 Annette Lindbergh Written Comments ML073100916 IPEC-Q6 Annie Berkery Written Comments ML073100759 IPEC-R6 Barbara Abramowitz Written Comments ML073100564 IPEC-S6 Barbara Ladd Written Comments ML073100207 IPEC-T6 Barbara Lubell Written Comments ML073100603 IPEC-U6 Barbara Nelson Written Comments ML073100695 IPEC-V6 Barbara Riso Written Comments ML073100705 IPEC-W6 Barbara Tanguay Written Comments ML073100597 IPEC-X6 Barry Spielvogel Written Comments ML073100667 IPEC-Y6 Belgica Gonzalez Written Comments ML073100718 IPEC-Z6 Bettina Utz Written Comments ML073100662 IPEC-A7 Bill Murawski Written Comments ML073100923 IPEC-B7 Bob and Donna Janusko Written Comments ML073100654 IPEC-C7 Bobbie Flowers Written Comments ML073100571 IPEC-D7 Bonnie Stein Written Comments ML073100712 IPEC-E7 Bonnie Yassky Written Comments ML073100514 IPEC-F7 Brad Martin Written Comments ML073100676 IPEC-G7 Brenda Martin Written Comments ML073100714 IPEC-H7 Brian Martin Written Comments ML073100914 IPEC-I7 Carl W. Braun Written Comments ML073100948 IPEC-J7 Carol Brown Written Comments ML073100496 IPEC-K7 Carol Carson Written Comments ML073100926 IPEC-L7 Carol Goodwin Written Comments ML073100537 IPEC-M7 Carolyn Adessa Written Comments ML073100625 IPEC-N7 Carolyn Cunningham Written Comments ML073100947 IPEC-O7 Cas Trap Written Comments ML073100634 IPEC-P7 Catherine Tice Written Comments ML073100951 IPEC-Q7 Cathy Canepa Written Comments ML073100909 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-R7 Cecelia Byrnes Written Comments ML073100594 IPEC-S7 Charles Triolo Written Comments ML073100716 IPEC-T7 Cheri Morreale Written Comments ML073100528 IPEC-U7 Chris Cunniffe Written Comments ML073100748 IPEC-V7 Chris Hunt Written Comments ML073100653 IPEC-W7 Chris Saia Written Comments ML073100590 IPEC-X7 Christopher Grunke Written Comments ML073100649 IPEC-Y7 Christopher Meyer Written Comments ML073100509 IPEC-Z7 Clarice Guttmann Written Comments ML073100645 IPEC-A8 Curt Epstein Written Comments ML073100503 IPEC-B8 Cynthia Anderson Written Comments ML073100652 IPEC-C8 Damon Bishop Written Comments ML073100694 IPEC-D8 Dan Cohn Written Comments ML073100490 IPEC-E8 Dan Doniger Written Comments ML073100614 IPEC-F8 Dani Glaser Written Comments ML073100936 IPEC-G8 Daniel Wolff Written Comments ML073100206 IPEC-H8 Danielle Gerard Written Comments ML073100917 IPEC-I8 Dannah Ressler Written Comments ML073100907 IPEC-J8 David Block Written Comments ML073100659 IPEC-K8 David Dunkleberger Written Comments ML073100569 IPEC-L8 David Perle Written Comments ML073100960 IPEC-M8 David Wieder Written Comments ML073100704 IPEC-N8 Deborah DeWan Written Comments ML073100585 IPEC-O8 Denise Edelson Written Comments ML073100624 IPEC-P8 Denise Lytle Written Comments ML073100633 IPEC-Q8 Denise Romano Written Comments ML073100697 IPEC-R8 Diane Ennis Written Comments ML073100540 IPEC-S8 Diane Napolitano Written Comments ML073100589 IPEC-T8 Dinda Evans Written Comments ML073100606 IPEC-U8 Don Devine Written Comments ML073100922 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-V8 Donna Ostrau Written Comments ML073100744 IPEC-W8 Doreen Tiganelli Written Comments ML073100721 IPEC-X8 Dorothy Shays Written Comments ML073100910 Dangerfield IPEC-Y8 Dwight Author Written Comments ML073100205 IPEC-Z8 E. Risch Written Comments ML073100515 IPEC-A9 Ed Soph Written Comments ML073100581 IPEC-B9 Eddie Scher Written Comments ML073100534 IPEC-C9 Edith Kantrowitz Written Comments ML073100511 IPEC-D9 Edward Schreiber Written Comments ML073100698 IPEC-E9 Elanor Herman Written Comments ML073100517 IPEC-F9 Elizabeth Maucher Written Comments ML073100530 IPEC-G9 Elizabeth Phillips Written Comments ML073100637 IPEC-H9 Elizabeth Ronan Written Comments ML073100510 IPEC-I9 Elizabeth Segal Written Comments ML073100552 IPEC-J9 Ellen OConnell Written Comments ML073100562 IPEC-K9 Emilee Drobbin Written Comments ML073100556 IPEC-L9 Emily Scaife Written Comments ML073100728 IPEC-M9 Erica Chambers Written Comments ML073100541 IPEC-N9 Ethel Bock Written Comments ML073100927 IPEC-O9 Eve Propp Written Comments ML073100924 IPEC-P9 Gail Frank Written Comments ML073100599 IPEC-Q9 Garrick Bryant Written Comments ML073100903 IPEC-R9 Gene Binder Written Comments ML073100946 IPEC-S9 George Stadnik Written Comments ML073100729 IPEC-T9 Greg Simmons Written Comments ML073100646 IPEC-U9 Gregory Durniak Written Comments ML073100531 IPEC-V9 Gwendolyn Chambers Written Comments ML073100961 IPEC-W9 Heidi Jellinghaus Written Comments ML073100739 IPEC-X9 Helen Chayefsky Written Comments ML073100750 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-Y9 Helen Scholfield Written Comments ML073100638 IPEC-Z9 Helga Klessen Written Comments ML073100699 IPEC-A10 Henry Kelly Written Comments ML073100650 IPEC-B10 Holly Everts Bartow Written Comments ML073100755 IPEC-C10 Howard Tarragon Written Comments ML073100602 IPEC-D10 James Baretta Written Comments ML073100644 IPEC-E10 James Davis Written Comments ML073100561 IPEC-F10 James Marsh Written Comments ML073100943 IPEC-G10 James Mulder Written Comments ML073100615 IPEC-H10 James Prudden Written Comments ML073100930 IPEC-I10 James Schmitt Written Comments ML073100573 IPEC-J10 Jan Blaire Written Comments ML073100555 IPEC-K10 Jan Haber Written Comments ML073100572 IPEC-L10 Janet Baller Written Comments ML073100621 IPEC-M10 Janet Castle Written Comments ML073100920 IPEC-N10 Janet Connor Written Comments ML073100738 IPEC-O10 Janice Bernard Written Comments ML073100632 IPEC-P10 Jay Rosen Written Comments ML073100904 IPEC-Q10 Jeanne Perkins Written Comments ML073100678 IPEC-R10 Jeanne-Noel Mahoney Written Comments ML073100643 IPEC-S10 Jeff Washel Written Comments ML073100211 IPEC-T10 Jeffery Kalman Written Comments ML073100655 IPEC-U10 Jeffery Wright Written Comments ML073100745 IPEC-V10 Jeremy Scheinder Written Comments ML073100629 IPEC-W10 Jillian Mulvihill Written Comments ML073100640 IPEC-X10 Jim Gross Written Comments ML073100497 IPEC-Y10 Jimmy Bromer Written Comments ML073100925 IPEC-Z10 Joan Gussow Written Comments ML073100969 IPEC-A11 Joan Katen Written Comments ML073100610 IPEC-B11 Joann Keenan Written Comments ML073100952 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-C11 JoAnn Myers Written Comments ML073100493 IPEC-D11 JoAnn Pedersen Written Comments ML073100627 IPEC-E11 Joe Seeman Written Comments ML073100563 IPEC-F11 Joel Breitkopf Written Comments ML073100491 IPEC-G11 Joel Resnick Written Comments ML073100741 IPEC-H11 John Norman Written Comments ML073100715 IPEC-I11 John Prusinski Written Comments ML073100671 IPEC-J11 John Tiffany Written Comments ML073100533 IPEC-K11 Jonathan Rubin Written Comments ML073100565 IPEC-L11 Joni Mercado Written Comments ML073100213 IPEC-M11 Josefina Vidal Written Comments ML073100725 IPEC-N11 Joseph Chamberlin Written Comments ML073100908 IPEC-O11 Joseph Montuori Written Comments ML073100547 IPEC-P11 Joyce Bressler Written Comments ML073100915 IPEC-Q11 Judith Simon Written Comments ML073100588 IPEC-R11 Judith Yarme Written Comments ML073100203 IPEC-S11 Judy Allen Written Comments ML073100214 IPEC-T11 Judy Miller-Lyons Written Comments ML073100693 IPEC-U11 Judy W. Soffler Written Comments ML073100544 IPEC-V11 Julia Rellou Written Comments ML073100570 IPEC-W11 Julie Kessler Written Comments ML073100911 IPEC-X11 June Muller Written Comments ML073100504 IPEC-Y11 Karen Browning Written Comments ML073100743 IPEC-Z11 Karen Wells Written Comments ML073100663 IPEC-A12 Karin Greenfield-Sanders Written Comments ML073100620 IPEC-B12 Karl Volk Written Comments ML073100611 IPEC-C12 Katherine Babiak Written Comments ML073100622 IPEC-D12 Kathleen Kourie Written Comments ML073100635 IPEC-E12 Kathleen Schmaltz Written Comments ML073100505 IPEC-F12 Kathleen Vorwick Written Comments ML073100958 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-G12 Kathy Burpee Written Comments ML073100931 IPEC-H12 Kenneth Okin Written Comments ML073100526 IPEC-I12 Kerry Kennelly Written Comments ML073100578 IPEC-J12 Kimberly Lowe Written Comments ML073100711 IPEC-K12 Kimberly Vaughn Written Comments ML073100935 IPEC-L12 L. Lawrence Written Comments ML073100919 IPEC-M12 Larry Garner Written Comments ML073100575 IPEC-N12 Larry Siegel Written Comments ML073100601 IPEC-O12 Laura Bassi Written Comments ML073100740 IPEC-P12 Laura Ferran Written Comments ML073100592 IPEC-Q12 Laura Miner Written Comments ML073100677 IPEC-R12 Laura Sedlack Written Comments ML073100757 IPEC-S12 Laurie Lehay Written Comments ML073105520 IPEC-T12 Laurie Puca Written Comments ML073100546 IPEC-U12 Laurie Sholinsky Written Comments ML073100941 IPEC-V12 Laurie Spigel Written Comments ML073100595 IPEC-W12 Leslie Raicer Written Comments ML073100720 IPEC-X12 Lester LeViness Written Comments ML073100593 IPEC-Y12 Lillian Gruver Written Comments ML073100651 IPEC-Z12 Lisa Petek Written Comments ML073100560 IPEC-A13 Louis Albino Written Comments ML073100524 IPEC-B13 Lyn Borek Written Comments ML073100577 IPEC-C13 Lynn Teger Written Comments ML073100730 IPEC-D13 Marc Weber Written Comments ML073100567 IPEC-E13 Marcy Lynn Written Comments ML073100933 IPEC-F13 Margaret Leonard Written Comments ML073100959 IPEC-G13 Maria Ragucci Written Comments ML073100612 IPEC-H13 Marnie Andrews Written Comments ML073100539 IPEC-I13 Mary Cronin Written Comments ML073100661 IPEC-J13 Mary Maley Written Comments ML073100508 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-K13 Mary Noll Written Comments ML073100942 IPEC-L13 Mary Phillips Written Comments ML073100681 IPEC-M13 Maryanne Mullany Written Comments ML073100513 IPEC-N13 Maureen Ritter Written Comments ML073100618 IPEC-O13 Merry Mcloryd Written Comments ML073100682 IPEC-P13 Michael Heimbinder Written Comments ML073100905 IPEC-Q13 Michael Shimkin Written Comments ML073100558 IPEC-R13 Michael Weiss Written Comments ML073100668 IPEC-S13 Michelle Kassan Written Comments ML073100710 IPEC-T13 Michelle Squires Written Comments ML073100210 IPEC-U13 Mitchell Maricque Written Comments ML073100686 IPEC-V13 Moly McCoy Straus Written Comments ML073100732 IPEC-W13 Nancy Andreassi Written Comments ML073100492 IPEC-X13 Nancy Kennedy Written Comments ML073100723 IPEC-Y13 Nancy Maloy Written Comments ML073100724 IPEC-Z13 Nancy Syrop Written Comments ML073100656 IPEC-A14 Nancy Thomas Written Comments ML073100506 IPEC-B14 Natasha Shpiller Written Comments ML073100691 IPEC-C14 Nfn Esmee Written Comments ML073100672 IPEC-D14 Nick Alba Written Comments ML073100525 IPEC-E14 Nils Osterberg Written Comments ML073100600 IPEC-F14 Nina Carlson Written Comments ML073100949 IPEC-G14 Noel Kropf Written Comments ML073100583 IPEC-H14 Nora Prentice Written Comments ML073100666 IPEC-I14 Pamela Kray Gallivan Written Comments ML073100523 IPEC-J14 Pamela Slater Written Comments ML073100538 IPEC-K14 Pamela Thye Written Comments ML073100554 IPEC-L14 Patricia Chernoff Written Comments ML073100928 IPEC-M14 Patricia Korn Written Comments ML073100709 IPEC-N14 Pauline Juckes Written Comments ML073100689 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-O14 Peggy Harrington Written Comments ML073100746 IPEC-P14 Peter Bobrow Written Comments ML073100675 IPEC-Q14 Peter Kassan Written Comments ML073100550 IPEC-R14 Peter Lampke Written Comments ML073100542 IPEC-S14 Phyllis M. Andrews Written Comments ML073100707 IPEC-T14 Priscilla Liebowitz Written Comments ML073100516 IPEC-U14 Qiana Quartararo Written Comments ML073100628 IPEC-V14 Randi Childs Written Comments ML073100591 IPEC-W14 Randy Tashjian Written Comments ML073100579 IPEC-X14 Raquel Vidal-Chan Written Comments ML073100574 IPEC-Y14 Ray Tartaglione Written Comments ML073100747 IPEC-Z14 Renee Cho Written Comments ML073100954 IPEC-A15 Richard Heaning Written Comments ML073100756 IPEC-B15 Rob Moore Written Comments ML073100706 IPEC-C15 Robert Braun Written Comments ML073100953 IPEC-D15 Robert Evangelista Written Comments ML073100587 IPEC-E15 Robert Gold Written Comments ML073100494 IPEC-F15 Robert Lesko Written Comments ML073100495 IPEC-G15 Robert Rainer Written Comments ML073100660 IPEC-H15 Robin Hoffmann Written Comments ML073100630 IPEC-I15 Rocco Rizzo Written Comments ML073100713 IPEC-J15 Ron Wish Written Comments ML073100566 IPEC-K15 Roseanne Brumley Written Comments ML073100535 IPEC-L15 Roy Fuller Written Comments ML073100559 IPEC-M15 S. Rebecca Holland Written Comments ML073100692 IPEC-N15 Sally Espinosa Written Comments ML073100733 IPEC-O15 Sally Freeman Written Comments ML073100688 IPEC-P15 Sandy Bihn Written Comments ML073100731 IPEC-Q15 Sarah Gallagher Written Comments ML073100619 IPEC-R15 Sarah West Written Comments ML073100598 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-S15 Shannon Shea Written Comments ML073100551 IPEC-T15 Sharon Goodman Written Comments ML073100586 IPEC-U15 Sidney Goodman Written Comments ML073100616 IPEC-V15 Stasia Kay Written Comments ML073100950 IPEC-W15 Stephen Blot Written Comments ML073100719 IPEC-X15 Stephen Donnelly Written Comments ML073100945 IPEC-Y15 Stephen Safran Written Comments ML073100934 IPEC-Z15 Steve Fondilller Written Comments ML073100487 IPEC-A16 Steven Libby Written Comments ML073100944 IPEC-B16 Sue Casanova Written Comments ML073100596 IPEC-C16 Susan Fischer Written Comments ML073100737 IPEC-D16 Susan Goldfarb Written Comments ML073100527 IPEC-E16 Susan Groner Written Comments ML073100684 IPEC-F16 Susan Rukeyser Written Comments ML073100626 IPEC-G16 Teri Gibson Written Comments ML073100648 IPEC-H16 Theresa Matuck Written Comments ML073100580 IPEC-I16 Toby Shimin Written Comments ML073100749 IPEC-J16 Tomas Simon Written Comments ML073100674 IPEC-K16 Tracy Brown Written Comments ML073100520 IPEC-L16 Vicki Blucher Written Comments ML073100929 IPEC-M16 Vitalah Gayle Simon Written Comments ML073100681 IPEC-N16 Vivian Bergenthal Written Comments ML073100623 IPEC-O16 Wayne Burkey Written Comments ML073100932 IPEC-P16 Wilder Bellamy Written Comments ML073100685 IPEC-Q16 William Abranowicz Written Comments ML073100647 IPEC-R16 William Burgess Written Comments ML073100687 IPEC-S16 William Sipper Written Comments ML073100736 IPEC-T16 Zac Nicholson Written Comments ML073100501 IPEC-U16 Susan Shapiro President, FUSE USA Written Comments ML072960457 IPEC-V16 Thomas N. McKee Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML072960365 NRCR00139 Submitted January 18, 2013 Table A-1. (contd)
Commenters Commenter Affiliation (If Stated) Comment Source ML Number ID IPEC-W16 Jaroslav P. Bubniak Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML072960366 IPEC-X16 Dr. Muzaffer Karasulu Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML072960370 IPEC-Y16 John Bencwinga Written Comments ML072960368 IPEC-Z16 Joseph L. Barnes Written Comments ML072960375 IPEC-A17 John Hausner Written Comments ML073110127 IPEC-B17 Daria Zaluckyj Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML073110156 IPEC-C17 Robert J. Dolansky Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML073110161 IPEC-D17 Thomas Pulcher Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML073110131 IPEC-E17 Grace Musumeci US Environmental Written Comments ML072960360 Protection Agency IPEC-F17 Daniel Ropson Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML072960373 IPEC-G17 Randy Murray Fitzpatrick Employee Written Comments ML072960372 IPEC-H17 Robert L. Brown Written Comments ML072960362 IPEC-I17 Eliot Engel, John Hall, Members, U.S. House of Written Comments ML073030401 Maurice Hinchey, Nita Representatives Lowey IPEC-J17 Z. Cerry Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML072960465 IPEC-K17 Phillip Musegaas Riverkeeper Written Comments ML072960455 IPEC-L17 Richard Blumenthal Attorney General, State of Written Comments ML072960359 Connecticut IPEC-M17 David & Anne Yeadon Written Comments ML073030402 IPEC-N17 Joan Matthews NYSDEC & NYSAG Written Comments ML073090588 IPEC-O17 William M. Mooney, Jr. President, Westchester Written Comments ML072960374 County Association IPEC-P17 John Jawor Indian Point Employee Written Comments ML072960460 IPEC-Q17 Susan Shapiro President, FUSE USA Written Comments ML073100985 IPEC-R17 John J. Sipos Assistant Attorney General, Written Comments ML073600658 State of New York