ML18219D840: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
Line 15: Line 15:


=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:UW NUCLEAR REGULATORV COMMISS ON NRC FoRM 1="B (1 7S)ARC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 60 DOCKET MATERIAL OOCKET U gv-z]s 8/4 FII E NU BER TO: Mr, 8+'~Keppler 1%5na&Michigan Power Co, Bridgman, MI~49106 Di Vi Shaller OATE OF OOCUMENT 01/30/78 OATS RECEIVEO~TTER~ORIGINAL Clcopv 0ESCRIPTION ONOTORIZEO UNCLASSIFIED PROP INPUT FORM ENCLOSURE NUMBER OF COPIES RECEIVEO/grdce~Informing of condition discovered at Units 1&2 during the Unit No 2 preope test program concerning elec design probl when attempting to restart containment spr pumps following the switchover of the Pump suction from the refueling water storage t to the containment recirculation sump~ational I nk 2p PLANT NAME: COOK UNITS 1&2 jcm 02/24/78 FOR ACTION/INFORMATION EiiVIRONMENTAL C CHI:"F: PROJECT iiNAGER: LIC.ASST: wr pl lY~Crd ASSIGNED AD: BRANCH CHIEF: ES INTERNAL 0 IST B.HARLESS RI BUTtON SYSTEiiIS SITE SAFETY G ENVIRON ANALYSIS DENTON G MULLER GOSSICK Q STAFF NGIiiEERZCG CT RS RON TECH ERNST'fA T P S CTOR SAFETY ROSS NOVAK TECH%(ILL 2)ROSZTOCZY CHECK'OLLNER C YS IS LPDR:5~ns/TIC IC REG V (J.EQiCHETT)16 CYS SENT CATEGOR EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL NUMBER 7~OSSOO3O IN y~Dhmekoan G~rii" MN<~<CKBILIX DONALD C.COOK NUCLEAR PLANT P.O.Box 458, Bridgman, Michigan 49106 January 30, 1978 Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant Units 1 8 2 Docket Nos.50-315 and 50-316 DPR Nos.58 5 74 Mr.J.G.Keppler, Regional Director Office of Inspection and Enforcement United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
{{#Wiki_filter:NRC FoRM     1="B                                         UW NUCLEAR REGULATORV COMMISS ON OOCKET U (1 7S)                                                                                             gv - z]s 8/4 FII E NU BER ARC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 60 DOCKET MATERIAL Mr,                                                                                  OATE OF OOCUMENT TO:               8+'     ~ Keppler               1%5na   & Michigan Power Co,               01/30/78 Bridgman, MI~     49106 Di Vi Shaller                               OATS RECEIVEO
~TTER                         ONOTORIZEO           PROP                   INPUT FORM           NUMBER OF COPIES RECEIVEO
  ~ORIGINAL Clcopv UNCLASSIFIED
                                                                                                          / grdce~
0ESCRIPTION                                                        ENCLOSURE Informing of condition discovered at Units       1 & 2 during the Unit No 2 preope ational test program concerning elec design probl when attempting to restart containment spr pumps following the switchover of the Pump I suction from the refueling water storage t nk to the containment recirculation sump~
2p PLANT NAME:             COOK UNITS 1 & 2 jcm 02/24/78 FOR ACTION/INFORMATION             EiiVIRONMENTAL ASSIGNED AD:
C   CHI:"F:                         wr pl                  BRANCH  CHIEF:
PROJECT iiNAGER:                                 lY~Crd LIC. ASST:
B. HARLESS INTERNAL 0 IST RI BUTtON ES                                                            SYSTEiiIS           SITE SAFETY       G ENVIRON ANALYSIS DENTON G MULLER GOSSICK     Q   STAFF               NGIiiEERZCG RON TECH ERNST CT RS
                        'fA     T           CTOR SAFETY                                                   TECH ROSS                                                       %(ILL 2)
CHECK'OLLNER P              S                    NOVAK ROSZTOCZY                                                              YS IS C
EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION                                          CONTROL NUMBER LPDR:5~ ns           /
TIC IC                                                                                               7~OSSOO3O REG   V (J. EQiCHETT) 16 CYS SENT CATEGOR                                                                                             IN


==Dear Mr.Keppler:==
y  ~
.j This letter is to inform you of a,condition at the Donald C.Cook Nuclear Plant Units l,,and 2 that was di'scovered during the Unit No.2 preoperational test program while performing the emergency power system train independence test.An electrical design problem was identified when attempting to restart the containment spray pumps following the switchover of the pumps'uction from the refueling water storage tank to the containment recirculation sump as follows: When the pump control switch was removed from the"pull to lock-out" position the pump breaker closed due to the standing start signal from the containment Hi-Hi pressure signal.The control switch then v(as moved through, the"trip" position which reopened the breaker.The circuit design is such that the"standing closed" position is superseded by the"anti-pumping" protection feature of the breaker which prevents the breaker from closing when placed in the"run" position.During the testing the pump was restarted within fifteen seconds.The standing start (closed)signal can be removed by resetting the containment spray signal.How-ever, the reset push buttons are spring loaded to the non-reset position.As a result of these findi ngs all applicable operating procedures have been revised to read as follows: FEB 6)978 J C'Pl~I%~%~g 0 d d  
Dhmekoan G~rii" MN                    <        ~<CKBILIX DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT P.O. Box 458, Bridgman, Michigan 49106 January 30, 1978 Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant Units          1 8 2 Docket Nos. 50-315 and 50-316 DPR Nos. 58 5 74 Mr. J. G. Keppler, Regional Director Office of Inspection and Enforcement United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region    III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137
~+t J.G.Keppl er Glen Ellyn, IL.January 30, 1978 Page 2 1.Push and hold both spray actuation reset buttons 4'dlllEI 2.Start the affected containment spray pump 3.Release spray actuation reset button A design change has already been incorporated on Unit 2 such that the lockout feature will not reclose the pump breaker until the control switch is returned to the neutral position.The same design change will be instituted on Unit 1 during the next refueling outage.A safety evaluation was performed to establish the consequences of the above problem in the unlikely event of a loss of coolant accident.Results of this evaluation indicate that the consequences are consistent with the plant design basis.Therefore, the above cited incident does not consti-tute either an unreviewed safety question or an adverse affect on the health and safety of the public.Since the occurrence does not prevent the Plant from performing its intended design safety functions and steps required to circumvent the switch operation problem have already been instituted into existing pro-cedures, we conclude that no significant safety problem did exist or exists today on either Unit 1 or Uni t 2.Very truly yours, DVS:pk cc: J.E.Dolan R.W.Jurgensen G.E.Lien R.Kilburn R.J.Vollen BPI K.R.Baker RO:III R.C.Callen MPSC P.W.Steketee, Esq.R.Walsh, Esq.G.Charnoff, Esq.G.Olson J.M.Hennigan PNSRC J.F.Sti etzel D.V.Shaller Plant Manager RECElg EO 00CUHP.H l CO'lT lO~OESl(U,S.HRC DlSTRlBUTIOH SERVlCES BRAHCH}}
 
==Dear Mr. Keppler:==
 
                                                              .j This letter is to inform you of a,condition at the Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant Units l,,and 2 that was di'scovered during the Unit No. 2 preoperational test program while performing the emergency power system train independence test. An electrical design problem was identified when attempting to restart the containment spray pumps following the switchover of the pumps'uction from the refueling water storage tank to the containment recirculation sump as follows:
When the pump control switch     was removed from the "pull to lock-out" position the pump breaker closed due to the standing start signal from the containment Hi-Hi pressure signal. The control switch then v(as moved through, the "trip" position which reopened the breaker. The circuit design is such that the "standing closed" position is superseded by the "anti-pumping" protection feature of the breaker which prevents the breaker from closing when placed in the "run" position.
During the testing the pump was restarted within fifteen seconds. The standing start (closed) signal can be removed by resetting the containment spray signal.         How-ever, the reset push buttons are spring loaded to the non-reset position.
As a result of these findi ngs all applicable operating procedures         have been revised to read     as follows:
FEB   6 )978
 
J C'
Pl
            ~ I
% ~ % ~
g 0
d d
 
~+ t J. G. Keppl er Glen   Ellyn, IL.
January 30, 1978 Page   2
: 1. Push and   hold both spray actuation reset buttons 4 'dlllEI
: 2. Start the affected containment spray       pump
: 3. Release   spray actuation reset button A design change has already been incorporated on Unit 2 such that the lockout feature will not reclose the pump breaker until the control switch is returned to the neutral position. The same design change will be instituted on Unit 1 during the next refueling outage.
A safety evaluation was performed to establish the consequences of the above problem in the unlikely event of a loss of coolant accident.
Results of this evaluation indicate that the consequences are consistent with the plant design basis. Therefore, the above cited incident does not consti-tute either an unreviewed safety question or an adverse affect on the health and safety of the public.
Since the occurrence does not prevent the Plant from performing its intended design safety functions and steps required to circumvent the switch operation problem have already been instituted into existing pro-cedures, we conclude that no significant safety problem did exist or exists today on either Unit 1 or Uni t 2.
Very   truly yours, D. V. Shaller Plant Manager DVS:pk cc:   J. E. Dolan R. W. Jurgensen G. E. Lien R. Kilburn R. J. Vollen BPI K. R. Baker RO:III R. C. Callen MPSC P. W. Steketee, Esq.
R. Walsh, Esq.
G. Charnoff, Esq.
G. Olson J. M. Hennigan PNSRC J. F. Sti etzel
 
RECElg EO 00CUHP.H l CO'lT lO~OESl(
U,S. HRC DlSTRlBUTIOH SERVlCES BRAHCH}}

Latest revision as of 18:43, 20 October 2019

Reporting Electrical Design Problem, Identified When Attempting to Restart Containment Spray Pumps with Unit 2. Concluded No Significant Safety Problem
ML18219D840
Person / Time
Site: Cook  American Electric Power icon.png
Issue date: 01/30/1978
From: Shaller D
Indiana Michigan Power Co, (Formerly Indiana & Michigan Power Co), American Electric Power Service Corp, American Electric Power Company
To: James Keppler
NRC/RGN-III
References
Download: ML18219D840 (5)
v • d • e


Text

NRC FoRM 1="B UW NUCLEAR REGULATORV COMMISS ON OOCKET U (1 7S) gv - z]s 8/4 FII E NU BER ARC DISTRIBUTION FOR PART 60 DOCKET MATERIAL Mr, OATE OF OOCUMENT TO: 8+' ~ Keppler 1%5na & Michigan Power Co, 01/30/78 Bridgman, MI~ 49106 Di Vi Shaller OATS RECEIVEO

~TTER ONOTORIZEO PROP INPUT FORM NUMBER OF COPIES RECEIVEO

~ORIGINAL Clcopv UNCLASSIFIED

/ grdce~

0ESCRIPTION ENCLOSURE Informing of condition discovered at Units 1 & 2 during the Unit No 2 preope ational test program concerning elec design probl when attempting to restart containment spr pumps following the switchover of the Pump I suction from the refueling water storage t nk to the containment recirculation sump~

2p PLANT NAME: COOK UNITS 1 & 2 jcm 02/24/78 FOR ACTION/INFORMATION EiiVIRONMENTAL ASSIGNED AD:

C CHI:"F: wr pl BRANCH CHIEF:

PROJECT iiNAGER: lY~Crd LIC. ASST:

B. HARLESS INTERNAL 0 IST RI BUTtON ES SYSTEiiIS SITE SAFETY G ENVIRON ANALYSIS DENTON G MULLER GOSSICK Q STAFF NGIiiEERZCG RON TECH ERNST CT RS

'fA T CTOR SAFETY TECH ROSS  %(ILL 2)

CHECK'OLLNER P S NOVAK ROSZTOCZY YS IS C

EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION CONTROL NUMBER LPDR:5~ ns /

TIC IC 7~OSSOO3O REG V (J. EQiCHETT) 16 CYS SENT CATEGOR IN

y ~

Dhmekoan G~rii" MN < ~<CKBILIX DONALD C. COOK NUCLEAR PLANT P.O. Box 458, Bridgman, Michigan 49106 January 30, 1978 Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant Units 1 8 2 Docket Nos. 50-315 and 50-316 DPR Nos. 58 5 74 Mr. J. G. Keppler, Regional Director Office of Inspection and Enforcement United States Nuclear Regulatory Commission Region III 799 Roosevelt Road Glen Ellyn, IL 60137

Dear Mr. Keppler:

.j This letter is to inform you of a,condition at the Donald C. Cook Nuclear Plant Units l,,and 2 that was di'scovered during the Unit No. 2 preoperational test program while performing the emergency power system train independence test. An electrical design problem was identified when attempting to restart the containment spray pumps following the switchover of the pumps'uction from the refueling water storage tank to the containment recirculation sump as follows:

When the pump control switch was removed from the "pull to lock-out" position the pump breaker closed due to the standing start signal from the containment Hi-Hi pressure signal. The control switch then v(as moved through, the "trip" position which reopened the breaker. The circuit design is such that the "standing closed" position is superseded by the "anti-pumping" protection feature of the breaker which prevents the breaker from closing when placed in the "run" position.

During the testing the pump was restarted within fifteen seconds. The standing start (closed) signal can be removed by resetting the containment spray signal. How-ever, the reset push buttons are spring loaded to the non-reset position.

As a result of these findi ngs all applicable operating procedures have been revised to read as follows:

FEB 6 )978

J C'

Pl

~ I

% ~ % ~

g 0

d d

~+ t J. G. Keppl er Glen Ellyn, IL.

January 30, 1978 Page 2

1. Push and hold both spray actuation reset buttons 4 'dlllEI
2. Start the affected containment spray pump
3. Release spray actuation reset button A design change has already been incorporated on Unit 2 such that the lockout feature will not reclose the pump breaker until the control switch is returned to the neutral position. The same design change will be instituted on Unit 1 during the next refueling outage.

A safety evaluation was performed to establish the consequences of the above problem in the unlikely event of a loss of coolant accident.

Results of this evaluation indicate that the consequences are consistent with the plant design basis. Therefore, the above cited incident does not consti-tute either an unreviewed safety question or an adverse affect on the health and safety of the public.

Since the occurrence does not prevent the Plant from performing its intended design safety functions and steps required to circumvent the switch operation problem have already been instituted into existing pro-cedures, we conclude that no significant safety problem did exist or exists today on either Unit 1 or Uni t 2.

Very truly yours, D. V. Shaller Plant Manager DVS:pk cc: J. E. Dolan R. W. Jurgensen G. E. Lien R. Kilburn R. J. Vollen BPI K. R. Baker RO:III R. C. Callen MPSC P. W. Steketee, Esq.

R. Walsh, Esq.

G. Charnoff, Esq.

G. Olson J. M. Hennigan PNSRC J. F. Sti etzel

RECElg EO 00CUHP.H l CO'lT lO~OESl(

U,S. HRC DlSTRlBUTIOH SERVlCES BRAHCH

Retrieved from "https://kanterella.com/w/index.php?title=ML18219D840&oldid=1924891"