ML19345F377: Difference between revisions

From kanterella
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page by program invented by StriderTol)
 
(StriderTol Bot change)
 
(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)
Line 18: Line 18:
=Text=
=Text=
{{#Wiki_filter:-              - ..        . ..
{{#Wiki_filter:-              - ..        . ..
    .          .
                *
      .
LIC 2/9/81 I
LIC 2/9/81 I
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of                      )
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of                      )
Line 28: Line 25:
(Three Mile Island Nuclear            )
(Three Mile Island Nuclear            )
Station, Unit No. 1)                  )
Station, Unit No. 1)                  )
        .
                                                      -
LICENSEE'S TESTIMONY OF FRANCIS F. MANGANARO IN RESPONSE TO CLI-80-5, ISSUE 2, TMIA CONTENTION 5, SHOLLY CONTENTION 14(e),
LICENSEE'S TESTIMONY OF FRANCIS F. MANGANARO IN RESPONSE TO CLI-80-5, ISSUE 2, TMIA CONTENTION 5, SHOLLY CONTENTION 14(e),
AND ANGRY CONTENTION IV (GPU NUCLEAR'S MAINTENANCE AND CONSTRUCTION DIVISION) l l
AND ANGRY CONTENTION IV (GPU NUCLEAR'S MAINTENANCE AND CONSTRUCTION DIVISION) l l
:8102170 %
:8102170 %
  -
      - - - .                    -  .      .  -      - . -        . . - .    - .    . .


! .
OUTLINE This testimony, by Francis F. Manganaro, Director of the Maintenance and Construction Division of the GPU Nuclear Group and the prospective Vice President, Maintenance and Construction, of the GPU Nuclear Corporation, responds to CLI-80-5, Issue 2, TMIA Contention 5, Sholly Contention 14(e)
    .
OUTLINE This testimony, by Francis F. Manganaro, Director of the Maintenance and Construction Division of the GPU Nuclear Group and the prospective Vice President, Maintenance and Construction, of the GPU Nuclear Corporation, responds to
.
CLI-80-5, Issue 2, TMIA Contention 5, Sholly Contention 14(e)
I
I
(    and ANGRY Contention IV insofar as they relate to the conduct
(    and ANGRY Contention IV insofar as they relate to the conduct of maintenance activities within the GPU Nuclear organization.
!
of maintenance activities within the GPU Nuclear organization.
Mr. Manganaro describes a new concept in the management of maintenance at GPU's nuclear facilities.
Mr. Manganaro describes a new concept in the management of maintenance at GPU's nuclear facilities.
The two principal responsibilities of the Maintenance and Construction Division of GPU Nuclear are to establish uniform policies, practices and procedures and accomplish assigned modification, repair, construction activities and major and/or specialized maintenance work at GPU's nuclear generating stations. While the Plant Director of Maintenance and his staff will remain responsible for assuring the material condition of his plant, additional maintenance support wil, be provided from the corporate maintenance organization, as well as onsite Maintenance and Construction Directors with associated onsite personnel. In addition, the Headquarters Staff will provide planning and scheduling methods to the onsite Maintenance and Construction staff, and monitor the implementation of these control systems.
The two principal responsibilities of the Maintenance and Construction Division of GPU Nuclear are to establish uniform policies, practices and procedures and accomplish assigned modification, repair, construction activities and major and/or specialized maintenance work at GPU's nuclear generating stations. While the Plant Director of Maintenance and his staff will remain responsible for assuring the material condition of his plant, additional maintenance support wil, be provided from the corporate maintenance organization, as well as onsite Maintenance and Construction Directors with associated onsite personnel. In addition, the Headquarters Staff will provide planning and scheduling methods to the onsite Maintenance and Construction staff, and monitor the implementation of these control systems.
                                                                - - ____ . - - -__ ____-


_ _ . _ .
  .
    .
4 I am Francis F. Manganaro, Director of the Maintenance and Construction Division of the GPU Nuclear Group and the pro-spective Vice President, Maintenance and Construction, of the GPU Nuclear Corporation.        I joined GPU in June 1980 after my retirement f r om - the U . S . Navy. From 1959 until that time I was assigned to various positions involved in the design, construction, overhaul, refueling, conversion and maintenance of nuclear powered surface ships and submarines.          More details on my background were provided by Mr. Arnold in his testimony.
4 I am Francis F. Manganaro, Director of the Maintenance and Construction Division of the GPU Nuclear Group and the pro-spective Vice President, Maintenance and Construction, of the GPU Nuclear Corporation.        I joined GPU in June 1980 after my retirement f r om - the U . S . Navy. From 1959 until that time I was assigned to various positions involved in the design, construction, overhaul, refueling, conversion and maintenance of nuclear powered surface ships and submarines.          More details on my background were provided by Mr. Arnold in his testimony.
As Director, Maintenance and Construction, I report di-rectly to the Office of the Chief Operating Executive of the GPU Nuclear Group.      The Maintenance and Construction Division is one of six divisions which provide support to the three operating divisions.        Its establishment and formation resulted from one of the organizational changes which was initiated to increase and concentrate the technical resources and management strength being applied to all nuclear activities, including TMI Unit 1, within GPU.
As Director, Maintenance and Construction, I report di-rectly to the Office of the Chief Operating Executive of the GPU Nuclear Group.      The Maintenance and Construction Division is one of six divisions which provide support to the three operating divisions.        Its establishment and formation resulted from one of the organizational changes which was initiated to increase and concentrate the technical resources and management strength being applied to all nuclear activities, including TMI Unit 1, within GPU.
Line 63: Line 46:
l
l


                          ..      . . -
  - ,
a  Carry out assigned plant modifications, repair and construction activities and conduct major and specialized maintenance work in
a  Carry out assigned plant modifications, repair and construction activities and conduct major and specialized maintenance work in
       ,  accordance with corporate policies and all, applicable laws, regulations and licenses and technical requirements,              i In general, it is intended that the Maintenance and Con-struction Division provide direction and support in the functional areas of maintenance, repair and construction to permit maximum concentration of attention and resc=2rces by plant management on safe and efficient operation and main-tenance of the nuclear generating stations. The Plant Director and his staff will remain responsible for assuring the material condition of the plant. They will continue to carry out some of this work themselves using their Maintenance Department, but they may also identify work they cannot or do not wish to do.
       ,  accordance with corporate policies and all, applicable laws, regulations and licenses and technical requirements,              i In general, it is intended that the Maintenance and Con-struction Division provide direction and support in the functional areas of maintenance, repair and construction to permit maximum concentration of attention and resc=2rces by plant management on safe and efficient operation and main-tenance of the nuclear generating stations. The Plant Director and his staff will remain responsible for assuring the material condition of the plant. They will continue to carry out some of this work themselves using their Maintenance Department, but they may also identify work they cannot or do not wish to do.
Line 70: Line 51:
Division which would be responsible to complete it using my Division personnel or subcontractors.
Division which would be responsible to complete it using my Division personnel or subcontractors.
The initial organization of the Division has been defined and approved. Because the two principal responsibilities f
The initial organization of the Division has been defined and approved. Because the two principal responsibilities f
assigned -- establishing uniform policies, practices and procedures and accomplishing assigned modification, repair, construction activities and major and/or specialized mainte-nance work -- constitute.two different but parallel functions, my organization incorporates a similar arrangement. There will l    be a resident Maintenance and Construction Director at each
assigned -- establishing uniform policies, practices and procedures and accomplishing assigned modification, repair, construction activities and major and/or specialized mainte-nance work -- constitute.two different but parallel functions, my organization incorporates a similar arrangement. There will l    be a resident Maintenance and Construction Director at each site. Reporting to him will be four functional managers --
 
Planning, Production, Technical Support and Administrative Support -- who will be full-time at that site.                                    At the Corporate Headquarters there will also be four functional managers -- Planning, Production, Methods and Procedures and Administrative Support -- to provide consistent procedural direction and knowledgeable continuing oversight of the site l                    Maintenance and Constructi?n activities.                                  In this way each of the parallel principal                                  asponsibilities will receive proper
                -
                          ,. -                        _
_
                                                                                                                .-
,
        .          ,
site. Reporting to him will be four functional managers --
Planning, Production, Technical Support and Administrative Support -- who will be full-time at that site.                                    At the Corporate Headquarters there will also be four functional
!
managers -- Planning, Production, Methods and Procedures and Administrative Support -- to provide consistent procedural direction and knowledgeable continuing oversight of the site l                    Maintenance and Constructi?n activities.                                  In this way each of the parallel principal                                  asponsibilities will receive proper
;                    attention and control.
;                    attention and control.
The total work inventory will be managed in five catego-ries, each defined in such a way as to permit the development i                    and implementation of requirements and procedures unique to the type of work involved.                                  I believe this more specific clas-sification of work by categories, while it covers the same t
The total work inventory will be managed in five catego-ries, each defined in such a way as to permit the development i                    and implementation of requirements and procedures unique to the type of work involved.                                  I believe this more specific clas-sification of work by categories, while it covers the same t
!
scope of effort as our current terminology of preventive main-tenance, corrective maintenance and modifications, will enhance l
scope of effort as our current terminology of preventive main-
;
tenance, corrective maintenance and modifications, will enhance l
the administrative control of the werk.                                  The categories can be defined as follows:
the administrative control of the werk.                                  The categories can be defined as follows:
Maintenance - Work performed during plant operations, outages or equipment shutdowns to insure continued proper I                    operation.                    Such maintenance is preventive in intent and will be accomplished by plant personnel unless assigned by them to the Maintenance and Construction Division by Work Request because it is extensive, overly complex or requires special skills.
Maintenance - Work performed during plant operations, outages or equipment shutdowns to insure continued proper I                    operation.                    Such maintenance is preventive in intent and will be accomplished by plant personnel unless assigned by them to the Maintenance and Construction Division by Work Request because it is extensive, overly complex or requires special skills.
                                                                                                                                >
                                                                                      - _ - . _ . _ , _    -
                               . . _ _ _ . . _ , . , . . - . _ . . ~ . . _ . ,                -        _      _    _ _ -
                               . . _ _ _ . . _ , . , . . - . _ . . ~ . . _ . ,                -        _      _    _ _ -
                                                                                                                          .-- _


                                        .    -                                .-
1 Repairs - Corrective maintenance which rectifies deficiencies so that systems and equipment will perform adequately in support of plant operations.                        Such maintenance will be accomplished by plant personnel unless assigned by them to Maintenance and Construction.
_                            _
            *
* 1 Repairs - Corrective maintenance which rectifies deficiencies so that systems and equipment will perform adequately in support of plant operations.                        Such maintenance
,
will be accomplished by plant personnel unless assigned by them to Maintenance and Construction.
overhauls - Restorative maintenance which returns systems and equipment to plan and specification, design
overhauls - Restorative maintenance which returns systems and equipment to plan and specification, design
!                  criteria or rated performance capability, thereby contributing j
!                  criteria or rated performance capability, thereby contributing j
Line 108: Line 68:
Construction - New or added capital improvements
Construction - New or added capital improvements
-                  which result in enhanced and/or increased performance capacity or capability.              Such work generally will be done by Maintenance and Construction.
-                  which result in enhanced and/or increased performance capacity or capability.              Such work generally will be done by Maintenance and Construction.
By utilizing these categories in conjunction with appro-yriate and uniquely applicable controls and procedures, proper
By utilizing these categories in conjunction with appro-yriate and uniquely applicable controls and procedures, proper attention to priority and assignment of resources can be provided to achieve the requisite timeliness and quality of l
;
attention to priority and assignment of resources can be provided to achieve the requisite timeliness and quality of l
t maintenance and construction work.
t maintenance and construction work.
l i                                The Headquarters staff will provide planning and scheduling methods to the four onsite functional sections of i
l i                                The Headquarters staff will provide planning and scheduling methods to the four onsite functional sections of i
                                                            ,
                                                                                  . , _ , , , - _ . , .
                                                                                                            . - .
   . . , . . _.    . - . . . ,    ,    ,-    ..m -.  ,      . . , , . - -                            .
   . . , . . _.    . - . . . ,    ,    ,-    ..m -.  ,      . . , , . - -                            .


          . _ _ _ _  _        _          . _ _ _
  -
      .
    .
the staff of the site Maintenance and Construction Director and monitor the implementation of these control systems.                    The four functional sections will be as follows:                                          ;
the staff of the site Maintenance and Construction Director and monitor the implementation of these control systems.                    The four functional sections will be as follows:                                          ;
Planning - Manage the work inventory by coordinating                !
Planning - Manage the work inventory by coordinating                !
Line 129: Line 80:
l          technical support to the site department.
l          technical support to the site department.
Site Technical Support - Interface with the Technical Functions Division and supplement its efforts where appropriate i
Site Technical Support - Interface with the Technical Functions Division and supplement its efforts where appropriate i
_ _ _ . _      _ _ _  _
_ _ _        _ __            -      _
                                                                            .


              -  -                  ..      .
    .
      .
to insure proper technical support of the work force in the areas involving welding, materials, turbine, processes, qualifications, and mechanical and electrical auxiliaries.
to insure proper technical support of the work force in the areas involving welding, materials, turbine, processes, qualifications, and mechanical and electrical auxiliaries.
This functional area will also manage records, documentation,
This functional area will also manage records, documentation, methods and procedures for the Maintenance and Construction Division.                                                            . . . .
                                                                                  #
methods and procedures for the Maintenance and Construction Division.                                                            . . . .
Administrative Support - Assist the division in the areas of personnel support, budget administration, cost con-trols, training coordination, data processing and information system procedures, office services and radiation exposure control by providing needed interfaces with the Administrative, Nuclear Assurance and Radiation and-Environmental Controls
Administrative Support - Assist the division in the areas of personnel support, budget administration, cost con-trols, training coordination, data processing and information system procedures, office services and radiation exposure control by providing needed interfaces with the Administrative, Nuclear Assurance and Radiation and-Environmental Controls
                                             ~
                                             ~
Line 148: Line 91:
                                                                         ~~
                                                                         ~~
to the Division at its inception.
to the Division at its inception.
a
a I
                                                                -: -
                                                                      *
                                                              ,
I
,
,
_g_
_g_
                                                                                    ;
l i
l i
,
   ,            ~    ..                .}}
   ,            ~    ..                .}}

Latest revision as of 05:01, 18 February 2020

Testimony Responding to CLI-80-5,Issue 2,TMIA Contention 5, Sholly Contention 14(e) & Anti-Nuclear Group Representing York Contention 4.New Concept in Mgt of Maint at Gpu Nuclear Facilities Described
ML19345F377
Person / Time
Site: Three Mile Island Constellation icon.png
Issue date: 02/09/1981
From: Manganaro F
GENERAL PUBLIC UTILITIES CORP.
To:
Shared Package
ML19345F374 List:
References
CLI-80-5, ISSUANCES-SP, NUDOCS 8102170362
Download: ML19345F377 (8)


Text

- - .. . ..

LIC 2/9/81 I

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION BEFORE THE ATOMIC SAFETY AND LICENSING BOARD In the Matter of )

)

METROPOLITAN EDISON COMPANY ) Docket No. 50-289 SP

) (Restart)

(Three Mile Island Nuclear )

Station, Unit No. 1) )

LICENSEE'S TESTIMONY OF FRANCIS F. MANGANARO IN RESPONSE TO CLI-80-5, ISSUE 2, TMIA CONTENTION 5, SHOLLY CONTENTION 14(e),

AND ANGRY CONTENTION IV (GPU NUCLEAR'S MAINTENANCE AND CONSTRUCTION DIVISION) l l

8102170 %

OUTLINE This testimony, by Francis F. Manganaro, Director of the Maintenance and Construction Division of the GPU Nuclear Group and the prospective Vice President, Maintenance and Construction, of the GPU Nuclear Corporation, responds to CLI-80-5, Issue 2, TMIA Contention 5, Sholly Contention 14(e)

I

( and ANGRY Contention IV insofar as they relate to the conduct of maintenance activities within the GPU Nuclear organization.

Mr. Manganaro describes a new concept in the management of maintenance at GPU's nuclear facilities.

The two principal responsibilities of the Maintenance and Construction Division of GPU Nuclear are to establish uniform policies, practices and procedures and accomplish assigned modification, repair, construction activities and major and/or specialized maintenance work at GPU's nuclear generating stations. While the Plant Director of Maintenance and his staff will remain responsible for assuring the material condition of his plant, additional maintenance support wil, be provided from the corporate maintenance organization, as well as onsite Maintenance and Construction Directors with associated onsite personnel. In addition, the Headquarters Staff will provide planning and scheduling methods to the onsite Maintenance and Construction staff, and monitor the implementation of these control systems.

4 I am Francis F. Manganaro, Director of the Maintenance and Construction Division of the GPU Nuclear Group and the pro-spective Vice President, Maintenance and Construction, of the GPU Nuclear Corporation. I joined GPU in June 1980 after my retirement f r om - the U . S . Navy. From 1959 until that time I was assigned to various positions involved in the design, construction, overhaul, refueling, conversion and maintenance of nuclear powered surface ships and submarines. More details on my background were provided by Mr. Arnold in his testimony.

As Director, Maintenance and Construction, I report di-rectly to the Office of the Chief Operating Executive of the GPU Nuclear Group. The Maintenance and Construction Division is one of six divisions which provide support to the three operating divisions. Its establishment and formation resulted from one of the organizational changes which was initiated to increase and concentrate the technical resources and management strength being applied to all nuclear activities, including TMI Unit 1, within GPU.

The functional responsibilities and assigned areas of cog-nizance for the Maintenance and Construction Division can be i

summarized as follows

i

  • Establish and monitor uniform policies, practices and procedures for all maintenance, I

repair and construction activities in accordance l with corporate policies and all applicable laws, regulations and licenses and technical j requirements.

l l

l 1

l

a Carry out assigned plant modifications, repair and construction activities and conduct major and specialized maintenance work in

, accordance with corporate policies and all, applicable laws, regulations and licenses and technical requirements, i In general, it is intended that the Maintenance and Con-struction Division provide direction and support in the functional areas of maintenance, repair and construction to permit maximum concentration of attention and resc=2rces by plant management on safe and efficient operation and main-tenance of the nuclear generating stations. The Plant Director and his staff will remain responsible for assuring the material condition of the plant. They will continue to carry out some of this work themselves using their Maintenance Department, but they may also identify work they cannot or do not wish to do.

This work they would assign to my Maintenance and Construction l

Division which would be responsible to complete it using my Division personnel or subcontractors.

The initial organization of the Division has been defined and approved. Because the two principal responsibilities f

assigned -- establishing uniform policies, practices and procedures and accomplishing assigned modification, repair, construction activities and major and/or specialized mainte-nance work -- constitute.two different but parallel functions, my organization incorporates a similar arrangement. There will l be a resident Maintenance and Construction Director at each site. Reporting to him will be four functional managers --

Planning, Production, Technical Support and Administrative Support -- who will be full-time at that site. At the Corporate Headquarters there will also be four functional managers -- Planning, Production, Methods and Procedures and Administrative Support -- to provide consistent procedural direction and knowledgeable continuing oversight of the site l Maintenance and Constructi?n activities. In this way each of the parallel principal asponsibilities will receive proper

attention and control.

The total work inventory will be managed in five catego-ries, each defined in such a way as to permit the development i and implementation of requirements and procedures unique to the type of work involved. I believe this more specific clas-sification of work by categories, while it covers the same t

scope of effort as our current terminology of preventive main-tenance, corrective maintenance and modifications, will enhance l

the administrative control of the werk. The categories can be defined as follows:

Maintenance - Work performed during plant operations, outages or equipment shutdowns to insure continued proper I operation. Such maintenance is preventive in intent and will be accomplished by plant personnel unless assigned by them to the Maintenance and Construction Division by Work Request because it is extensive, overly complex or requires special skills.

. . _ _ _ . . _ , . , . . - . _ . . ~ . . _ . , - _ _ _ _ -

1 Repairs - Corrective maintenance which rectifies deficiencies so that systems and equipment will perform adequately in support of plant operations. Such maintenance will be accomplished by plant personnel unless assigned by them to Maintenance and Construction.

overhauls - Restorative maintenance which returns systems and equipment to plan and specification, design

! criteria or rated performance capability, thereby contributing j

to long-term reliable plant operations. Such maintenance i

generally will be performed by Maintenance and Construction.

Modifications - Alterations of plant systems and equipment which result in changes to plans, specifications, configurations, operating procedures or any other aspect of the planc defined by controlled documentation. Such work will be done by the plant staff or by Maintenance and Construction depending on the scope, complexity and schedule considerations.

Construction - New or added capital improvements

- which result in enhanced and/or increased performance capacity or capability. Such work generally will be done by Maintenance and Construction.

By utilizing these categories in conjunction with appro-yriate and uniquely applicable controls and procedures, proper attention to priority and assignment of resources can be provided to achieve the requisite timeliness and quality of l

t maintenance and construction work.

l i The Headquarters staff will provide planning and scheduling methods to the four onsite functional sections of i

. . , . . _. . - . . . , , ,- ..m -. , . . , , . - - .

the staff of the site Maintenance and Construction Director and monitor the implementation of these control systems. The four functional sections will be as follows:  ;

Planning - Manage the work inventory by coordinating  !

with the plant operators the establishment of schedules, controls and conditions to permit the accomplishment of work in a safe and controlled manner. Included in this effort is docu-menting the identity of the work backlog and the designation of the priority of each item. The planning function will also include job order planning, preparation, scheduling, estimating, materials control, cost estimating and analysis, schedule assessment and modifications control.

Production - Manage the Company work force and vendor / contractor services and direct the accomplishment of work in the plant. This will include a limited project staff as well as a Manager for any major outage. The Production De-partment will also be assigned responsibilities for specified plant support facilities and all tools anel equipment under the cognizance of the Division.

Methods and Procedures - Prescribe, direct and/or control all processes and procedures in the Maiatenance and l Construction Division. The approved Methods Improvement Program will be planned and accomplished by this group which I will also coordinate all efforts involved in providing l

l technical support to the site department.

Site Technical Support - Interface with the Technical Functions Division and supplement its efforts where appropriate i

to insure proper technical support of the work force in the areas involving welding, materials, turbine, processes, qualifications, and mechanical and electrical auxiliaries.

This functional area will also manage records, documentation, methods and procedures for the Maintenance and Construction Division. . . . .

Administrative Support - Assist the division in the areas of personnel support, budget administration, cost con-trols, training coordination, data processing and information system procedures, office services and radiation exposure control by providing needed interfaces with the Administrative, Nuclear Assurance and Radiation and-Environmental Controls

~

Divisions.

The site level departments of the Maintenance and Con-struction Division at TMI-l and at Oyster Creek were formally ,

I established in December, 1980. Efforts to complete staffing ,

are underway in parallel with managing and directing ongoing work at TMI-l and Oyster Creek with existing personnel assigned

~~

to the Division at its inception.

a I

_g_

l i

, ~ .. .