ML13261A164

0821NRC-154-Evening

ML13261A164
Person / Time
Site:	Braidwood
Issue date:	08/21/2013
From:	Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
To:
References
NRC-154
Download: ML13261A164 (62)

Text

Official Transcript of Proceedings

NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION

Title: Braidwood LRA Public Scoping Meeting Evening Session

Docket Number: 50-456 and 50-457

Location: Braidwood, Illinois

Date: Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Work Order No.: NRC-154 Pages 1-58

NEAL R. GROSS AND CO., INC. Court Reporters and Transcribers 1323 Rhode Island Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20005 (202) 234-4433

NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 1 + + + + +

2 BEFORE THE NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION 3 + + + + +

4 NUCLEAR MANAGEMENT COMPANY 5 BRAIDWOOD LRA PUBLIC SCOPING MEETING 6 + + + + +

7 Regarding the License Renewal Application 8 NEPA Required Scoping Meeting 9 + + + + +

10 WEDNESDAY 11 AUGUST 21, 2013 12 + + + + +

13 386 W. KENNEDY ROAD 14 BRAIDWOOD, ILLINOIS 15 + + + + +

16 7:00 p.m.

17 + + + + +

18 The above-entitled matter 19 commenced pursuant to Notice before Sheila Ray and 20 Cheryl Hausman, Facilitators.

21 22 23 24 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 2 PRESENT: 1 NRC STAFF:

2 Yoira Diaz 3 Tam Tran 4 Alex Garmo[e]

5 Stuart Sheldon 6 Anita Ghosh 7 Prema Chandrathil 8 Elizabeth Pool 9 Jacob Steff[e]s 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 3 P R O C E E D I N G S 1 (7:01 P.M.)

2 MS. HAUSMAN: My name is Cheryl and I'm 3 going to be the facilitator for this evening's 4 meeting, and my role as a facilitator is to help make 5 sure that the meeting runs smoothly, that everybody 6 who wishes to speak gets a chance a chance to speak, 7 and to kind of keep us on time. Before we get 8 started this evening I just want to let everybody 9 know that this meeting is being transcribed, so we'll 10 try and keep the background noise and any sidebar 11 conversations to a minimum so the transcriptionist 12 can get an accurate record of this evening's meeting.

13 Just a couple ground rules. If you have 14 any electronic devices, please put them on vibrate or 15 mute for this evening's meeting. And, while other 16 people are speaking, just please be respectful of the 17 comments. The restrooms are outside to the left if 18 anybody doesn't know. There's two exits to the room, 19 one over here on the side and then in the back 20 corner. And we also have Officer Vern Reid here this 21 evening from the Braidwood Police Department, just in 22 case of an emergency.

23 The purpose of today's meeting is to 24 discuss the licensing renewal process to identify 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 4 significant issues related to the proposed license 1 renewal activity for Braidwood, Units 1 and 2, and to 2 determine the scope of issues to be addressed in the 3 environmental impact statement.

4 The agenda for this evening's meeting 5 will be a presentation by the NRC staff to discuss 6 the license renewal process, and when the 7 presentation concludes we'll have a brief 10 or 15 8 minute question and answer period about the 9 presentation, if there's any questions you have about 10 the presentation or anything you've seen on the 11 slides. And then we'll open it up into the public 12 comment period. And we're going to discuss the 13 public comment period a little bit later on in the 14 meeting, but just you know, if you have a comment, if 15 you have not filled out one of the yellow cards, 16 there's some on the tables out front. If you would 17 like to make a comment, just please fill out the card 18 and give it to me or Sheila and we'll add you to the 19 list of people to be speaking.

20 And I'm going to introduce a few of the 21 NRC staff that are here tonight. First Yoira.

22 MS. DIAZ: Good evening. I'm Yoira Diaz, 23 I'm the Supervisor, Branch Chief in headquarters. My 24 staff is in charge of the safety review of the 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 5 License Renewal Application for Braidwood.

1 MS. HAUSMAN: Tam?

2 MR. TRAN: My name is Tam Tran, I'm the 3 Project Manager for the Environmental Review of the 4 License Renewal Application for Braidwood Stations.

5 I will be one of the speakers today.

6 MS. HAUSMAN: Alex?

7 MR. GARMO[E]: My name is Alex Garmo[e], 8 I'm the Acting Senior Resident Inspector at 9 Braidwood, so I'm one of the two inspectors that 10 reports there on a daily basis for inspections.

11 MR. SHELDON: Good evening. My name's 12 Stuart Sheldon, I'm a Senior Inspector out of our, 13 the NRC Regional Office up in Lisle, Illinois. I 14 will be leading the regional inspections associated 15 with the safety review for the license application.

16 MS. GHOSH: Good evening. My name is 17 Anita Ghosh and I'm with the Office of the General 18 Counsel. 19 MS. CHANDRATHIL: Good evening everyone.

20 My name is Prema Chandrathil, I'm the Public Affairs 21 Officer for the NRC, the Regional Office, located in 22 Lisle, Illinois. I deal mainly with members of the 23 public and reporters who have inquiries about NRC 24 activities. Thanks.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 6 MS. HAUSMAN: And, is there anybody else 1 from any other federal agencies?

2 MS. POOL: Hi, I'm Elizabeth Pool, I'm 3 from USEPA in the Chicago Office, Region 5. I'm in 4 the NEPA Compliance Division and I'm going to head up 5 the EPA's review of the document.

6 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Okay, we're 7 going to start this evening's presentations. Tam 8 Tran. And if you have any questions about the 9 presentation please hold them until the end. Thank 10 you. 11 MR. TRAN: My name is Tam Tran. I'm one 12 of the two project managers for the NRC Division of 13 License Renewal, associates with the Braidwood 14 Station, License Renewal Review. I am the 15 Environmental Project Manager. The Safety Manager is 16 John [D]ailey. John's not here today. And thank you 17 for taking the time to come out to help us with this 18 public meeting, to provide your comments. We value 19 your comments. Thank [you].

20 Today I will provide an overview of the 21 license renewal review process, which include[s] both 22 a safety review and environmental review. I will 23 describe in more detail the environmental review 24 process for the Braidwood Station, but the most 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 7 important part of today's meeting is to receive any 1 comments that you may have on the scoping of the 2 environmental review. I will also provide 3 information about how comments can be submitted 4 outside of this meeting.

5 I hope the information that we provide to 6 you will help you to better understand the license 7 renewal review process, and the role that you can 8 play in helping us to make sure that NRC 9 Environmental Review considers the relevant 10 information that it should.

11 Before I get into the discussion of 12 license renewal review process, I would like to 13 briefly talk about NRC in terms of what we do and our 14 missions. The NRC is a federal agency established by 15 the Energy Reorganization Act that regulates the 16 civilian use of nuclear material in the commercial 17 sense. The Atomic Energy Act authorized the NRC to 18 grant a 40-year operating license for nuclear power 19 reactors. This 40-year term was based primarily on 20 economic considerations, and anti-trust factors, not 21 on safety or technical limitations.

22 The Atomic Energy Act also allows for a 23 license renewal. The National Environmental Policy 24 Act established the national policy for considering 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 8 the impact of federal decisions on the human 1 environment. As a matter of policy, the Commission 2 determined that reactor license renewal constitutes a 3 major federal action for which an environmental 4 impact statement is warranted.

5 And exercise as regulatory authority, the 6 NRC mission is three-fold; to ensure adequate 7 protection of the public health and safety, to 8 promote the common defense and security of the 9 nations, and to protect the environment. The NRC 10 accomplished [its] mission [through] a combination of 11 regulatory programs and processes, such as 12 establishing rules and regulations, conducting 13 inspections, issuing enforcement actions, assessing 14 licensee performance, and evaluating operating 15 experience from nuclear plants across the country and 16 internationally.

17 The NRC has resident inspectors at all 18 operating nuclear power plants. These inspectors are 19 considered the eyes and ears for the agency. They 20 carry out safety missions on a daily basis and are on 21 the front lines of ensuring acceptable safety 22 performance and compliance with the regulatory 23 requirement for the plant.

24 Now turning to the Braidwood Station, 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 9 Exelon Generation Company filed an application dated 1 May 29th seeking to renew the operating licenses of 2 the Byron and Braidwood plants for an additional 20 3 years of operations. The current operating license 4 for Braidwood expires on October 17, 2026 for unit 5 one, and December 18, 2027 for unit two.

6 Exelon, in submitting a single 7 application to cover both Byron and Braidwood plants, 8 cited extensive similarity in the system structures 9 and components that are analyzed in the license 10 renewal review. The NRC will conduct a separate 11 environmental review for Braidwood because of the 12 differences and the environmental and cultural 13 resources surrounding the Braidwood Station in 14 comparison to the Byron.

15 A license renewal application is required 16 to contain certain sets of information. General 17 information such as the applicant's name, address, 18 business and administrative information, and 19 technical information which pertain to aging 20 managements. This information is the focus of the 21 safety review. The application also includes an 22 environment report, which is the applicant assessment 23 of the environmental impact of continued operations.

24 This information serves as a starting point for the 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 10 staff to review the environmental aspect of the 1 license renewal for the Braidwood stations.

2 This diagram illustrates the safety and 3 environment review processes. It's also featured 4 t[w]o other consideration and the Commission decision 5 of whether or not to renew an operating license. One 6 of these considerations is the independent review 7 performed by the Advisory Committee on Reactor 8 Safeguards. The so-called ACRS is a group of 9 scientists and nuclear safety experts who serve as a 10 consulting body to the Commissions. The ACRS reports 11 its findings and recommendations directly to the 12 Commissions. The ACRS review would also include a 13 public meeting.

14 Hearings may also be conducted. Before 15 September 23, 2013 Braidwood interested stakeholders 16 may submit concerns or contentions and request a 17 hearing. A panel of the Atomic Safety Licensing 18 Board will be established to review the contentions 19 for the admissibility. If hearing is approved, the 20 Commission will consider the outcome of the hearing 21 process, and its decision of whether or not to issue 22 a renewal of operating license.

23 License renewal involves two parallel 24 reviews; the safety review and the environmental 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 11review. The safety review focuses on the aging 1 effects of passive and long-lived components and 2 structures that the NRC deems important to plant 3 safety. The staff's main objective in this review is 4 to determine whether effects of aging will be 5 adequately managed by the applicant. The review also 6 considered generic and site-specific operating 7 experience related to the effects of aging. The 8 results of the safety review are documented in the 9 Safety Evaluation Report, and sometimes we may refer 10 to that document as the SER.

11 For the environment review, the staff 12 considers, evaluates and discloses the environmental 13 impacts of continued plant operation for an 14 additional 20 years. The staff also evaluates 15 environmental impacts of alternatives to license 16 renewal. The objective of the review is to determine 17 of the environmental impact of license renewal is so 18 great that license renewal would not be a reasonable 19 option. Or more plainly, it is, whether or not[,] is 20 license renewal acceptable from an environmental 21 standpoint. The staff prepared an environmental 22 impact statement to document its review, and you may 23 hear us to refer to that document as EIS.

24 Before I go into more depth about the 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 12 safety environmental reviews, I want to mention a few 1 areas that are very important and part of the NRC 2 oversight process. These are emergency planning, 3 security and current safety performance. NRC 4 addresses this area of performance every day as 5 part[s] of the ongoing regulatory oversight provided 6 for all currently operating power reactors.

7 Current license issues [are] addressed on 8 an ongoing basis under the current operating 9 licensing term. License renewal issues are addressed 10 separately as a part of the license renewal review.

11 Now we will cover a little bit more 12 detail about the safety review. The regulation 13 governing license renewals for the safety review has 14 two guiding princip[le]s. The first princip[le] is 15 that the current regulatory process is adequate to 16 ensure the licensing basis of all our operating 17 plants, and it provide[s] an acceptable level of 18 safety. 19 The second princip[le] is that the 20 current plan's specific licensing basis must be 21 maintained during the license renewal in the same 22 manner and to the same extent as during the original 23 license term. In other words, the same rules that 24 apply under the current license will continue to 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 13 apply during the new term, or the additional 20 years 1 of operations.

2 In addition, a renewal license will 3 include conditions that must be met to ensure aging 4 [of] components, important safety adequately managed 5 so that the plant's current licensing basis is 6 maintained during the period of extended operations.

7 For safety, the staff will perform 8 [multi] levels review. First, the staff reviews the 9 license renewal application and supporting 10 documentations. This review includes an evaluation 11 of new and existing programs and surveillance 12 activity to determine with reasonable assurance that 13 effect of aging of certain plant structure and 14 component [will be] adequately manage[d] or 15 monitor[ed].

16 Second, the staff will perform site 17 audits to verify the technical basis of the license 18 renewal application, and to confirm that the 19 applicant's aging management programs and activities 20 conform with how they are described in the 21 applications. The staff documents the basis and 22 conclusion of its review in the safety [evaluation]

23 report, which is publicly available.

24 In addition, a team of specialized 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 14 inspectors from the NRC Region III travel[s] to the 1 reactor site to verify that aging management programs 2 are being implemented, modified or planned consistent 3 with the license renewal applications.

4 Finally, as I have mentioned, the 5 advisory committee on reactor safeguards will 6 [per]form an independent review of the license 7 renewal application, and the staff safety 8 [evaluation] report, and makes a recommendation to 9 the Commission regarding the proposed action 10 iss[uance] of a renewal of operating license.

11 For the environmental review, the staff 12 [will] perform an environmental review in accordance 13 with the National Environmental Policy Act or so-14 called NEPA. NEPA provides the basic architectures 15 for the federal environmental review requirements.

16 It requires that all federal agenc[ies] [to] follow a 17 systematic approach in evaluating potential impacts 18 associated with the major federal actions, and 19 alternative to those actions[.]

20 The NEPA process involves public 21 participations and public involvement, as well as 22 public disclosure. The NRC environmental regulations 23 contained in 10CFR, part 51, are largely based on 24 implementing regulations for NEPA. NRC environmental 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 15 review considered the impact associated with the 1 license renewal, and any mitigation for those impacts 2 we consider to be significant. We also considered 3 the impacts of alternatives to license renewal, 4 including the impact of not issuing a renewal 5 license.

6 In conducting the review, the NRC staff 7 will look at various impacts to the affected 8 environment. This review involves a wide range of 9 [expertise]-- illustrated on this slide. The expert 10 [will] examine environment justice, ecology, land 11 use, regulatory compliance, climate change, et cetera 12 for the EIS. As illustrated on this slide, some of 13 the agencies that we work with will include U.S. Fish 14 and Wildlife Service, Environmental Protection 15 Agency, state's Historical Preservation Offices as 16 well as many local and state agencies, and any 17 affected Indian tribes.

18 The NRC staff, we also review cumulative 19 impacts associated with the continued operation of 20 the Braidwood Station. For cumulative impacts, the 21 staff will look at the [e]ffects on the environment 22 from past, present and reasonably foreseeable future 23 [human] actions. The cumulative impacts will include 24 both from the Braidwood Station operations and other 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 16activities near Braidwood. In other words, the 1 cumulative impacts analysis consider[s] potential 2 impacts through the end of the 20 year renewal term.

3 4 For the term beyond the 20 year period of 5 extended operations, the NRC Waste Confidence 6 addresses the environmental impact of the management 7 of the spent nuclear fuel after the license life, 8 including renewal. Previous license renewal EIS 9 noted that environmental impacts of temporary storage 10 of spent nuclear fuel for the period following the 11 reactor operating license term were addressed by the 12 NRC Waste Confidence Rule.

13 The Waste Confidence environmental impact 14 statement is expected to be issued in 2014. In 15 August, 2012 the Commission decided that the agency 16 will not issue a final licensing decision for 17 reactors, including license renewal, until the Waste 18 Confidence regulatory activities are completed. If 19 at that time any license renewal related site-20 specific issue[s] at Braidwood station remain 21 unresolved, they will be addressed separately.

22 The environmental review begins with the 23 scoping process, which is where we are today. The 24 purpose of the scoping process is to identify 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 17 significant issues that should be considered in the 1 environmental review. We are now gathering 2 information that we will use to prepare an 3 environmental impact statement for the Braidwood 4 Station license renewal, that is, the environmental 5 impact[s] that are loca[l] to this area, and that are 6 important to the staff to consider.

7 The staff has developed a generic 8 environmental impact statement that addresses a 9 number of issues common to all nuclear power plants.

10 The staff is supplementing that generic EIS with a 11 site-specific supplemental EIS for the Braidwood 12 Stations. The staff [will] also reexamined the 13 conclusion reached in that generic EIS to determine 14 if there are any new and significant information that 15 would change the conclusion and the generic EIS. The 16 scoping period started on July 31st and we will 17 continue to take comments until September 27th.

18 In general, we are looking for 19 information about environmental impacts from 20 continued operation of the Braidwood Station during 21 the extended period of operation. You can assist us 22 in that process by telling us, for example, what 23 aspect of your local community we should focus on, 24 what local environmental social and economic issue 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 18 that NRC should examine, and what reasonable 1 alternatives are most appropriate for this region.

2 This slide illustrates the NRC various 3 considerations for deciding if a renewed operating 4 license will be issued. It's a rigorous review 5 involving the EIS, safety [evaluation] report, 6 regional inspections, and so on. But, what's 7 important to point out here is that the public 8 comments are an important part of the license renewal 9 process. We consider all comments that we receive 10 today and throughout the scoping period, and the 11 comments will help us to inform and to shape the 12 supplemental environmental impact statement.

13 In addition to providing comments at 14 today's meeting, there are other ways that you can 15 submit comments on the environmental review. You can 16 provide written comments by mail to the NRC Chief of 17 Rules at direct[ive] branch at the address provided 18 on this slide, and there [are] copies of this slide 19 for you to use. Or you can send your comment 20 electronically by going to regulation.gov. You can 21 also make your comment in person if you happen to be 22 in Rockville, Maryland. We ask that you get in touch 23 with one of the NRC project managers beforehand so 24 that we can set up appropriate arrangements. The 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 19 comments should be submitted by September 27th.

1 This slide shows some important 2 milestones for the environmental review process. The 3 petition to request for hearing [dues] on September 4 23rd, 2013. We plan to issue the draft environmental 5 impact statement in 2014. Once the draft is issued, 6 there will be a comment period where again there will 7 be an opportunity for the public to read through the 8 draft EIS and to comment on the draft.

9 The contact for the NRC environmental 10 review is myself. John Daly is the contact for the 11 safety review, and John's contact information is on 12 the meeting handout. The Fossil Ridge Library has 13 agreed to make the license renewal application 14 available for public review, and when it's published 15 for comment, the draft supplemental EIS will also be 16 available at the library. In addition, these 17 documents will be on the NRC website listed on this 18 slide. As you came in, you were asked to fill out a 19 reservation card at our reception desk. If you have 20 included your address on that card and indicated you 21 would like to be on the distribution list, we will 22 send you a copy of the draft and the final EIS for 23 your information. If you didn't have an opportunity 24 to fill out that card, please feel free to do [so]

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 20 before you leave[;] to fill out a card, and then add 1 your address to it.

2 And that concludes my presentation.

3 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you, Tam. Before we 4 move into the public comment period, the NRC staff 5 would like to offer the opportunity to answer any 6 questions about the presentation you've just seen.

7 Does anybody have any questions about the 8 presentation or the material that was presented?

9 Okay. Then we'll go into the public 10 comment period, and I'll be calling everybody up one 11 at a time. When you get to the microphone, the 12 podium, please state your name and spell your last 13 name so the court reporter can get the correct 14 spelling of your name for the transcript. First I 15 would like to invite Sue Rezin, State Senator.

16 MS. REZIN: Thank you. Rezin, R-e-z-i-n.

17 Since I won't be near Rockville, Maryland anytime 18 soon, thank you for the opportunity to make the 19 comments here tonight. It's much more convenient.

20 Just briefly I'd like to say, my senate district is a 21 high energy producing district, and with it we have 22 three nuclear power plants in here. Exelon has been 23 an excellent company for our communities in terms of, 24 you know, reaching out to the communities, but also 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 21providing good paying jobs in the area as well. So, 1 we appreciate them. We also appreciate you being 2 here as they're going through the re-licensing, and 3 anytime that we've had any questions with them, 4 they're very responsive to us and we appreciate that 5 as well. Thank you.

6 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Next I would 7 like to invite Greg Ridenour from Representative 8 Kissinger's office.

9 MR. RIDENOUR: It's R-i-d-e-n-o-u-r. The 10 congressman couldn't make it here tonight, but he 11 gave me a statement he would like me to read for him.

12 It's addressed to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory 13 Commission. I write to express my full support for 14 the renewal of the operating license of the nuclear 15 generating station at Braidwood, Illinois. This 16 facility provides lower energy costs for residents 17 and businesses, and supports hundreds of high paying 18 jobs in Illinois, while helping to ensure state 19 compliance with federal clean air act regulations.

20 It will undoubtedly play an important role in meeting 21 the energy needs of Illinoisans well into the future.

22 23 Nuclear energy production plays a 24 critical role in Illinois where nuclear energy 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 22 generates 48 percent of the state's electricity and 1 employs nearly 5,000 skilled workers. Having visited 2 the Braidwood Generating Facility, I can attest to 3 the value it has to local residents and communities, 4 which benefit through reduced energy costs, high 5 quality jobs, and significant tax revenue.

6 While many areas of Illinois struggle to 7 meet clear air standards, the generating station at 8 Braidwood offers affordable, abundant energy with a 9 fraction of the greenhouse gas admissions as other 10 conventional energy sources. As Americans and 11 Illinoisans' demand for energy rises, nuclear 12 generating stations like Braidwood will be vital to 13 meeting the energy needs for our citizens.

14 I fully support the operating license 15 renewal for this generating station, and believe it 16 will play a critical role in making America and the 17 state of Illinois more energy secure. Signed, Adam 18 Kissinger, member of Congress.

19 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I'd like to 20 invite Bill Rulien, Mayor of Braidwood.

21 MR. RULIEN: When I was about 10 years 22 old I used to read my dad's newspaper, and the first 23 commercial nuclear power plant in about 1960 came 24 online, and it was an amazing thing to me. It 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 23produced power with almost no fuel, no pollution.

1 Commonwealth Edison, the parent company of Exelon, 2 was the cutting edge of technology, the company that 3 brought that to us.

4 When I was about 20, I built a solar 5 collector, and I also experimented with a wind 6 generator. It didn't take too long to realize when 7 the breeze quit that it was great supplemental power 8 but it wasn't something you could really rely on as a 9 source of power. In the 43 years since then, there 10 hasn't been anything much that's changed. If you 11 want reliable, mass produced pollution free electric 12 power, nuclear power is the proven technology and the 13 way to go for now, and as far as we can see into the 14 future. 15 In about 1980 I was doing a little 16 construction work out by Goose Lake, and it seemed 17 that folks were starting to build houses out by 18 nuclear power plants, and I thought that was a pretty 19 remarkable thing. Well, for 25 years we in the 20 Braidwood area now have lived side by side with 21 working nuclear power plant, and it's brought many 22 benefits to our area. They include good jobs, 23 contribution to our tax base has been enormous, for 24 our library, our schools and our fire district.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 24 They've been generous to our community.

1 Kindly they've given millions of dollars to create a 2 water system there in Braceville, millions of dollars 3 in subsidy, food pantry, thousands of dollars in help 4 to our food pantry, help our needy, and many other 5 projects too numerous to mention. Last year they 6 helped out the city when I asked them to help us buy 7 the electronic sign outside of city hall, and to help 8 us create a tourism spot that we hope will help us 9 create tourism energy and economic benefit on Route 10 66. 11 So, they've been a really good neighbor, 12 and I just wanted to say that a guy here earlier 13 today, he mentioned that, you know, his whole thing 14 was what's going to happen if the power plant was to 15 close down. Well, you know, we think about those 16 things, and my administration's planned on those 17 things, and we're planning to use the money we get in 18 this area from our nuclear power plant and the good 19 jobs and everything to help prepare us for that 20 future. We've set aside acreage for industry and 21 things like that, and we intend to be ready for that 22 date. 23 But I also, personally, believe that the 24 infrastructure that's there on that power plant site 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 25 now, they will develop a way to use that, because 1 they're going to have a major investment in that 2 site, and they might build Braidwood three and four 3 there, I don't know, it'll probably be after I'm long 4 gone, but I look forward to that, and we look forward 5 to you giving them a license to continue operations 6 into the future. Thank you.

7 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I'd like to 8 invite Mark Kavanos, site VP for Braidwood.

9 MR. KANAVOS: Kanavos, K-a-n-a-v-o-s.

10 Good evening, I'm Mark Kanavos, I'm the Site Vice 11 President at Braidwood Generating Station. I have 12 the overall responsibility for the safe and reliable 13 operation of the facility, and the coordination and 14 management of personnel, and overall station 15 performance.

16 A little bit about my background. I have 17 over 32 years of progressive nuclear power plant 18 experience. Before I took my current role as Site 19 Vice President, I was the Plant Manager at Braidwood.

20 Prior to that I was the Plant Manager at Clinton 21 Nuclear Station in Clinton, Illinois, and at Comanche 22 Peak Nuclear Station in Glen Rose, Texas. I've had 23 experience in project management, maintenance and 24 engineering.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 26 Operating the station safely and reliably 1 is a key responsibility of all of the employees at 2 the Braidwood Generating Station, one that we take 3 very seriously and as a personal commitment to 4 ourselves, to the community and to our industry.

5 Proud to say that we've been a key part of this 6 community for over 25 years.

7 Braidwood Generating Station operates 8 under the manner that preserves the environment. We 9 maintain a comprehensive, radiological monitoring 10 program that extensively monitors the air, water and 11 food products around the facility to ensure that we 12 did not adversely impact the environment.

13 We have a comprehensive on-site 14 environmental groundwater protection program for 15 monitoring and detecting the presence of 16 radioactivity in the ground water before it has a 17 chance to migrate off of our property. This program 18 includes 19 on-site monitoring wells designed to 19 protect, detect and alert us of any unusual events, 20 levels of radiation in the groundwater, so that we 21 can assess and address any changes quickly.

22 We have detailed procedures that outline 23 how we test all the water leaving our station.

24 Radiation monitors are staged at 40 locations within 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 27 a ten mile radius around the planet to monitor any 1 radiation levels and dose to ensure the safety of the 2 community.

3 We also have had great success in our 4 tritium remediation efforts. In the last seven years 5 Braidwood has made significant progress.

6 Hydrogeologists have confirmed that remediation is 7 having the intended effect. As of today the square 8 footage of land affected by tritium has been reduced 9 by 96 percent, and the highest concentrations of 10 tritium in the groundwater have been reduced by 99 11 percent. We'll continue to monitor and retain the 12 ability to remediate via pumping, should that become 13 necessary.

14 Braidwood's environmental management 15 systems are certified under the strictest criteria, 16 the International Organization of Standardization, or 17 ISO, specifically we have received the ISO 14001 18 certification, an industry standard recognition.

19 This is an internationally recognized benchmark for 20 environmental management. The ISO 14000 21 certification requires a commitment to excellence in 22 meeting our regulatory requirements, and the 23 prevention of pollution and continuous improvement in 24 our environmental programs and systems.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 28 Last year the Wildlife Habitat Counsel 1 recognized Braidwood Generating Station's commitment 2 to the environmental stewardship by awarding us the 3 Wildlife award certification. This distinction was 4 awarded to our commitment for ensuring that the 5 continuance of the healthy wildlife around our 6 planet, through our fish habitat restoration project.

7 This project places artificial habitats in the 8 Braidwood Lake, and that greatly benefits the fish 9 throughout their life, and greatly enhances the 10 fishery. 11 To ensure that Braidwood continues to 12 operate safely for years to come, Exelon continues to 13 invest in Braidwood. We've spent millions of dollars 14 each year to improve and modernize our equipment and 15 enhance our plan operations and safety systems. Our 16 investment in the future doesn't stop with the 17 equipment. We've hired 152 new employees in the last 18 two years, and we maintain a workforce of 19 approximately 850 employees.

20 During our annual maintenance and 21 refueling outage, that population grows by another 22 1,500 to 2,000 employees, bringing a boost to the 23 local economy. We also take pride in our investments 24 in the community. Last year employees contributed 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 29 over 240,000 to the United Way Crusade of Mercy, and 1 our signature annual event, Fishing for a Cure, has 2 generated over $300,000 to charity over the years.

3 We also support the Braidwood Summer Fest, the 4 Braidwood Shootout, and numerous other community 5 activities.

6 Our employees host blood drives, toy 7 drives and fund drives for various community groups 8 and agencies. They also volunteer, and in short, we 9 do our very best to be a good neighbor.

10 For over 25 years Braidwood has performed 11 reliably and safely, and has set numerous benchmarks 12 in the nuclear power industry. We work towards 13 license renewal every day through dedication to 14 continuous improvement.

15 In conclusion, we look forward to working 16 with the Nuclear Regulatory Commission in the review 17 of our license renewal application. Thank you for 18 this opportunity to address the public.

19 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I would like to 20 invite Mike Gallagher, the VP for License Renewal, 21 Exelon. 22 MR. GALLAGHER: Okay, good evening. My 23 name is Mike Gallagher, and that's G-a-l-l-a-g-h-e-r, 24 and I'm the Vice President of License Renewal for 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 30Exelon. I have overall responsibility for the 1 Braidwood Generating Station license renewal 2 application.

3 First of all I'd like to thank the NRC 4 for this opportunity to speak on behalf of Exelon for 5 this very important project for us. Exelon has a 6 great deal of experience with license renewal, as we 7 have already obtained the renewed licenses for our 8 Dresden and Quad Cities plants here in Illinois, and 9 for three of our other facilities in Pennsylvania and 10 New Jersey. We've also, an application for our 11 Limerick Plant in Pennsylvania under NRC review.

12 Just a little, briefly, about myself.

13 I've been working in the nuclear industry for 32 14 years. I was a licensed senior reactor operator and 15 plant manager at our Limerick Generating Station 16 facility in Pennsylvania, and I worked at two other 17 nuclear power plants and our corporate office.

18 Mr. Kanavos, the Site Vice-President for 19 Braidwood spoke to us all here about how rigorously 20 we safely operate Braidwood, and about the reasons 21 for renewing the license. I'd like to speak briefly 22 about the process for preparing this license renewal 23 application, and the amount of the work and 24 engineering analysis that was put into preparing the 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 31 application.

1 Because the Braidwood Station can operate 2 safely and reliably, Exelon decided to pursue license 3 renewal. Braidwood's safe, efficient operation 4 promotes a critical supply of carbon free electricity 5 for Illinois and beyond. Braidwood produces enough 6 clean power to supply more than two million homes.

7 So in 2011 we announced our intention to 8 seek license renewal for Braidwood and a similar 9 plant, or Byron Generating Station up in Ogle County.

10 Later that year we started the work necessary to 11 prepare the application, and after over two years of 12 work we submitted the application to the Nuclear 13 Regulatory Commission on May 29th, 2013.

14 So safe and reliable operations has been 15 hallmark at Braidwood Station since it came online, 16 and our goal during the license renewal process is to 17 demonstrate to the NRC and to our neighbors that we 18 will continue that legacy throughout the 20 year 19 extended operating period.

20 The application is a very large 21 application. When you print it out it's about 3,500 22 pages, and when you put it in binders, it's in four 23 large binders about this thick. It's a huge amount 24 of information. But that only represents a small 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 32 part of the work that was done for the engineering 1 analysis. The total amount of engineering analysis 2 if we printed it all out would be about 400 binders 3 of information. We invested over 90,000 man hours of 4 engineering work. Once we completed the engineering 5 work to prepare the application, we brought in 6 experts from outside Exelon to review the 7 application, to ensure that it was complete, thorough 8 and accurate. Our total cost to prepare this 9 application and to get it reviewed by the Nuclear 10 Regulatory Commission for both Byron and Braidwood 11 will be approximately $45 million.

12 There are two different parts of the 13 application, the safety review and the environmental 14 review. For the safety review we took an in-depth 15 look at the history and the condition of the safety 16 equipment in the plant. We did that to determine 17 whether the necessary maintenance was being performed 18 on that equipment, to make sure that the equipment 19 will be able to operate when it's needed, not only 20 for today, but for the additional 20 year period.

21 When you look back at Braidwood, when it 22 was built, it was brand new, it was all thoroughly 23 tested to make sure it would work properly, but like 24 anything else the equipment does age, and therefore 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 33we have to do certain activities to it. Preventative 1 maintenance is performed, sometimes equipment is 2 refurbished, some equipment may be replaced, there 3 may be modifications done to the plant to upgrade 4 equipment. In fact, Exelon has invested over $230 5 million in the last four years alone at Braidwood, to 6 improve and modernize the equipment, to enhance plant 7 operations and safety.

8 We also reviewed the calculations that 9 were performed as part of the design of the plant, 10 that were originally done to, for the plant to 11 operate for the original 40 year period. We analyzed 12 all those calculations and were able to confirm that 13 the plant was able to operate safely for an 14 additional 20 years, up to 60 years. So overall our 15 conclusion from an engineering review was that 16 Braidwood could operate safely for 60 years.

17 We also took a look at the environmental 18 aspects, and the impacts to continue to operate 19 Braidwood. We looked at all the aspects of the, 20 well, the impact of the plant on the environment, and 21 our conclusion is that these impacts on the 22 environment are small, and I use the term small in 23 the sense of the regulation. The regulation defines 24 small as the environmental effects are not detectable 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 34 or minor.

1 We've also reviewed the alternatives if 2 Braidwood would not have its license renewed and 3 another source of electric generation would have to 4 be installed, either here on site or someplace else 5 to generate the replacement electricity. We 6 concluded that any other means of generating the 7 replacement electricity would have more an impact to 8 the environment than the continued operation of 9 Braidwood.

10 So in conclusion, we operate Braidwood 11 safely, and we can continue to operate safely for an 12 additional 20 years. Braidwood will provide 13 approximately 2,340 megawatts of baseload generation 14 that's not only safe, but it's clean, it's reliable, 15 and it's economical. Continued operation of 16 Braidwood will benefit this community, the state of 17 Illinois and our nation. Thanks again for the 18 opportunity to make my statement.

19 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Next I would 20 like to invite John Greuling, Will County Center for 21 Economic Development.

22 MR. GREULING: Thank you, and that's 23 Greuling, G-r-e-u-l-i-n-g. The Will County Center 24 for Economic Development is a private, not for profit 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 35 economic development corporation that's served Will 1 County for 32 years. Our membership includes 2 representatives from the largest corporations in Will 3 County, along with other private sector leaders as 4 well as governmental leaders. Our mission is to 5 assist in the retention, the expansion and the 6 recruitment of business to Will County.

7 We support critical infrastructure 8 investments as well, such as energy infrastructure, 9 to make sure that the investments and reinvestments 10 are being made appropriately to serve our rapidly 11 growing area. Since 1990 Will County has more than 12 doubled in population to where today we're just under 13 700,000 people, and we've become one of the fastest 14 growing job generators in the metro Chicago area.

15 We're also home to the largest Inland Container Port 16 in North America, supporting global freight movement.

17 18 The Will County Center for Economic 19 Development is here today in support of Braidwood 20 Generating Station's license renewal application 21 submitted to the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission 22 on May 29th of this year. Since 1987 the Braidwood 23 facility has been producing emissions-free energies 24 in Northeastern Illinois. The Center for Economic 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 36 Development believes by granting this renewal the NRC 1 will allow Exelon Generation to continue to provide 2 thousands of megawatts of clean energy to the tens of 3 thousands of businesses in the region. Adequate, 4 reliable and affordable energy supply has become one 5 of the most important factors when businesses are 6 considering an expansion or relocation today.

7 Without it we cannot successfully compete for good 8 jobs for our residents.

9 The Braidwood facility itself is an 10 economic engine for the region. With over 850 good 11 paying jobs and an annual payroll of $82 million, 12 Braidwood is one of the largest employers in Will 13 County, and certainly one of its most significant.

14 In addition, the facility made $20.7 million in tax 15 payments in 2012. The significant contributions that 16 Exelon generation and its employees made to the local 17 economy cannot be overstated. Support for groups 18 like the United Way, Fishing for a Cure, and other 19 local and business, local business and civic 20 associations are critical to the fabric of our 21 community in this part of Will County.

22 The CED recognizes what a good 23 environmental steward Exelon has been and will 24 continue to be at their Braidwood facility. The 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 37 radiological monitoring and the groundwater 1 protection programs in place today give the community 2 a sense of safety and environmental protection we 3 expect from a world class facility like Braidwood.

4 To close, the CED again supports the 5 renewal application for the Braidwood Generating 6 Station, and I think you for your time.

7 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I would like to 8 next invite Don Moran.

9 MR. MORAN: Good evening. Don Moran, M-10 o-r-a-n. From 1984 until 1987 I worked at the 11 Braidwood Station as a young construction worker, or 12 sheet metal worker. Today I'm employed as a business 13 representative for sheet metal workers, but I'll 14 speak on behalf of not only my own local union, but 15 the Will and Grundy building and construction trades 16 as well. 17 Beginning in the fall of 2007, a full 18 year before the rest of the country's economy was 19 effected, the construction industry was decimated by 20 the worse case of unemployment it had seen since the 21 great depression. Literally thousands of our members 22 lost their jobs, their homes, their families, during 23 the next five and a half years of economic blight.

24 One bright spot during all those years 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 38 has been the construction jobs provided during the 1 refueling and upgrading of the Braidwood Station.

2 Having been involved in the building and maintenance 3 of the station over the past 30 years, I'm very 4 confident in the continued safe operation of this 5 plant into the future, and I'm thankful for their 6 commitment to local trades by providing good jobs and 7 benefits to people.

8 My frustration with the high unemployment 9 led me to run for office. Earlier today the Will 10 County Executive, Larry Walsh, and the Will County 11 Board Speaker were both here, and spoke on behalf of 12 our county board, where we passed a unanimous 13 resolution supporting the re-licensing at our July 14 board meeting. I voted in favor of that resolution.

15 As Illinois struggles in today's 16 competitive business market, we cannot afford to 17 ignore any of the things that helped put us on a 18 better footing. One of the building blocks to 19 economic development is affordable and reliable 20 electricity. Illinois' diverse network of 21 electricity generation coming from coal, wind and 22 nuclear gives us an advantage in enticing new and 23 retaining existing businesses to the area.

24 Unlike the rolling blackouts experienced 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 39 in California during 2000 and 2001, our local 1 electric generation and transmission systems have 2 provided consistent, reliable electricity and have 3 done so with a diminishing cost to consumers, as 4 compared to the CPI.

5 I remember cooling my first home, a tiny, 6 900 square foot house, with summer monthly electric 7 bills of over $200 in the mid 80's. Today I live in 8 a modest town home about three times that large and I 9 pay about $150 in the summer months to cool it, quite 10 the bargain compared to nearly 30 years ago, 11 especially if considered next to the costs associated 12 with fuel in your car or paying for healthcare.

13 As President of the Illinois State Rifle 14 Association, I represent the interest of many 15 outdoors people, including fisherman and water foul 16 hunters, many of whom have benefitted greatly from 17 the public access to Braidwood Station's cooling 18 lake. In addition to being a source of reliable 19 electricity generation, Braidwood Station has been a 20 benefit to local school districts, fire protection 21 and other taxing bodies in the community, not to 22 mention its commitment to local charities and 23 community events. They've been a good steward to our 24 communities, and I'd ask that the NRC renew the 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 40 license for Braidwood Station. Thank you.

1 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Next I would 2 like to invite Dee deGroh, who's a member of the 3 Community Advisory Board.

4 MS. DEGROH: Good evening, and thank you, 5 Sheila. My name is Dee deGroh, and that is spelled 6 d-e-G-r-o-h. I, my family's from the Braidwood/Essex 7 area, my parents and my grandparents and my great 8 grandparents were from Essex and Braidwood. I moved 9 here about eight years ago, and was just concerned 10 that I wanted to be involved in the community, so I 11 became quite involved, as a matter of fact I'm 12 President of the Historical Society, Secretary of the 13 Library Board, a member of CAP, the Community Advisor 14 Panel, and the Chamber of Commerce. School district 15 has a group called the Community Involvement 16 Committee, to get the students involved in our 17 communities and vice versa, and of course I'm 18 involved in church groups. So, I'm an involved 19 person. 20 I recall there was excitement when it was 21 announced that there was going to be a power plant 22 built in the Braidwood area in 1976. They started 23 construction then, and my mother and my sister and 24 many others were on committees to talk to 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 41 Commonwealth Edison at the time about how is this 1 going to effect us, what is it? People didn't even 2 know what it was and how it was going to effect our 3 community. And they did form various committees to 4 talk to ComEd, and they felt somewhat, I'm sure, very 5 relieved, because not only was it going to improve 6 the economics of the area, but they were also taking 7 over some of the spoiled lands left by the coal 8 companies, and it was considered spoiled land at that 9 time. Now they're wonderful recreation clubs for 10 many people, but at that time there weren't a lot.

11 At any rate, the concerns about the 12 safety and health issues were alleviated during 13 those, that time, and it took 12 years to build the 14 plant and open it, it opened in '88, and at that time 15 the community was allowed to go in and see the plant.

16 I was fortunate enough to be one of them, and very, 17 very impressed with all of the security concerns and 18 health issues and just getting in and out at that 19 time. 20 And then I joined this Community Advisory 21 Panel a few years ago when it was started, and we got 22 to tour the plant, and with the changes and additions 23 due to 911, it's unbelievable what security one goes 24 through, on a daily basis if you're an employee and 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 42have to get into the plant everyday. It took us, 1 well of course there was about 15 of us, 12 of us 2 maybe going on that tour, but it took us a good 20 3 minutes or more. You may have read in the Braidwood 4 Journal last week the reporter had just taken a tour 5 and she was just in awe of what she saw and all the 6 security she went through.

7 At any rate, this advisory panel helps 8 the community because anyone who asks us a question 9 about an issue that they're concerned with, we can 10 take that concern to the CAP meeting, and Exelon 11 either addresses it right then and there or our next 12 meeting they'll have someone who is knowledgeable 13 about that issue, such as tritium, and bring it to 14 the committee, and we'll spend the entire evening 15 maybe discussing that issue. It's wonderful that 16 they're so concerned about our safety and acceptance 17 of Exelon.

18 We're all interested in public health and 19 safety. We all want it. I know I want it for 20 myself. I would not have moved here if I didn't feel 21 comfortable doing so eight years ago, and I have 22 never felt uncomfortable being in the area. The 23 station, the Braidwood Station has been really a 24 wonderful neighbor, because they're not only 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 43 employing people in the area and helping to feed tax 1 money into our schools and fire department and police 2 and library, et cetera. They are interested in 3 community organizations and help all of us, including 4 the Historical Society and the Lions Club and Park 5 District and many such groups, Chamber of Commerce 6 and so on. So, they're really wonderful neighbors 7 and they support all of these groups, and when they 8 do that it makes our town more viable, more lively, 9 more full of life because they're helping us to 10 continue in day to day issues.

11 And, I went to the presentation August 12 8th at City Hall by NRC, and at that meeting they 13 made it very clear that Exelon has met, if not 14 exceeded, all their expectations regarding safety.

15 And because of that, I just welcome the approval of 16 the renewal license for our good neighbor, Exelon.

17 Thank you very much.

18 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I would like to 19 invite Doug O'Brien from the Illinois Clean Energy 20 Coalition.

21 MR. O'BRIEN: Thank you very much, it's 22 O-B-r-i-e-n. And I'm the Executive Director of the 23 Illinois Clean Energy Coalition. Our group that is 24 supported by business, labor and policy leaders 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 44 across the state promotes the development and use of 1 clean energy in a competitive market that benefits 2 both the environment and our economy. And regardless 3 of where people are individually on what various 4 policy courses they favor, I think everybody across 5 the country wants to see our country move towards 6 cleaner, a cleaner environment, and the cleaner 7 generation of energy.

8 Now, we've heard a lot about the positive 9 impacts that Braidwood has on the surrounding 10 communities, the jobs, the economic impact, the 11 millions of dollars that are invested in the 12 community, but the positive impacts reach much 13 further than the areas that benefit directly from the 14 plant operations. Nuclear has also brought a broad 15 benefit to the energy market in Illinois. It has 16 impacted, had a positive impact on rates, and 17 certainly on reliability, and as we've heard that is 18 oftentimes a key factor in attracting and retaining 19 good jobs.

20 And the benefits derived at Braidwood and 21 other nuclear plants are not limited to the economy.

22 It's an enormous benefit that the generation of 18 23 million megawatts of electricity at Braidwood last 24 year produced no carbon air emissions. And that's an 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 45 objective, that's a goal we all want to strive to in 1 our country.

2 Earlier this year NASA's 3 Goddard Institute, which is a leading research 4 organization studying the impacts of climate change, 5 sought to quantify the impact of nuclear power's 6 carbon free emissions. Goddard's study found that 7 replacing nuclear power with fossel fuel generation, 8 would lead to approximately 76,000 deaths globally 9 every year, primarily as a result of increased cardio 10 and pulmonary disease.

11 This is even more important here in 12 Illinois, as we all know the Chicago metropolitan 13 area is designated as a non-attainment area by the 14 EPA due to air pollution, and this situation would be 15 greatly exacerbated without the existence of the 16 Braidwood Generating Station, which produces energy 17 to power up to two million homes, without adding to 18 our existing environmental problems.

19 And I think it's also important to note 20 that while we care tremendously about the local 21 impacts, the environmental impact statement that 22 we're talking about primarily here looks at a broad 23 range of issues. In addition to local environmental 24 issues, it looks at quality of life issues, revenues 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 46 that are created, job creation and economic impact 1 are all part of the environmental impacts of the 2 Braidwood Generating Station.

3 And for these reasons the Illinois Clean 4 Energy Coalition strongly urges the renewal of the 5 operating license for the Braidwood station. Thank 6 you. 7 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I would like to 8 invite Angie Hutton from the Braidwood Chamber.

9 MS. HUTTON: It's Angie Hutton, H-u-t-t-10 o-n, and on behalf of the Chamber, and I sent a blast 11 e-mail out before I left the house, I got nothing 12 derogatory from any of them again, Exelon supports 13 our schools, all of our businesses, and not only with 14 what they do for us but the people that work there, 15 which is, definitely helps our businesses in town, 16 and our schools couldn't do without them. I mean, 17 they're just, they've been wonderful. Anything we've 18 asked for, they've helped us as the chamber, and for 19 that we say thank you.

20 And there was an issue with the tritium, 21 and as being a good neighbor, which they promised 22 when they started, they did remediate the area, they 23 bought the property that was impacted, and with that 24 they took aggressive action so that it doesn't happen 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 47again. And with that they also opened up great 1 communications.

2 And as Dee said, the CAP, we go in there 3 and they have no idea what questions we're bringing.

4 Anything that the public wants to know, anything 5 that we want to know, and they do answer it right 6 away, and if not, it's at the next meeting, but they 7 have no idea. And with all that they do for support, 8 they're meeting people everyday with no idea what 9 people on the street are going to ask, and they do 10 answer it. And that, in this day and age, is a big 11 deal, there's no, well, I'll get back to you or let 12 me see what I can find out, they do answer it.

13 So, with that and the support that 14 they've given us, and Exelon will be speaking at our 15 next chamber meeting, so, and they'll have no idea 16 what those people are going to ask that morning.

17 With that, we would like the license for the station 18 to be renewed.

19 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I would like to 20 invite K. Denise Forrest from the community and 21 Exelon. 22 MS. FORREST: Hello. Last name's 23 Forrest, F-o-r-r-e-s-t. So first I'll talk to you as 24 a community member. So my dad grew up in Braidwood 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 48 and attended the one-room schoolhouse on Center 1 Street, and I didn't venture far from home because I 2 bought a house in Braidwood five years ago. My 3 future son-in-law just bought a house in Braidwood in 4 January. We're both employees of Braidwood Station 5 and grateful to be employees of Braidwood Station.

6 We do all of our shopping in Braidwood, 7 we see the physicians in Braidwood, even the people 8 who don't live in Braidwood still use all the 9 services that Braidwood offers. When I hear the 10 truck go by spraying for mosquitoes at night I think, 11 Braidwood may have impacted that by their tax money, 12 so. 13 How, the impact, so I live on Bodeen 14 Drive. My neighbors on both sides of my house are 15 directly impacted by Braidwood Station, either as a 16 contractor or as an employee. My neighbor on the 17 back side of me is an operator. A block away from 18 me, two employees from Braidwood Station. My son-in-19 law lives on Third Street, his neighbor is a 20 contractor. So Exelon and Braidwood Station has a 21 direct impact on the economy, just from a personal 22 perspective.

23 Whenever I go to the grocery store or I'm 24 at the mine, I'm always running into people that I 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 49 work with, even the people who don't live locally, 1 just out of convenience they'll stop at the grocery 2 store, our gas is cheaper here, we gas our cars here.

3 Our taxes are cheaper here, so purchases are 4 sometimes cheaper.

5 So, not only for the Exelon employees but 6 also family-owned contractors. We support a lot of 7 contractors by bidding out business at the plant, so 8 a lot of them are also impacted directly.

9 As an employee, I'm a maintenance analyst 10 at Braidwood. I'm proud to say that I was part of 11 the start-up team from the 1980's, so I've been there 12 quite a while. Not only is the equipment updated, 13 but the people are updated as well, we are developed, 14 so thank you to Exelon, they've developed me as well.

15 As I get new employees into the site, I'm 16 so proud of our plant and the way that it looks and 17 the perception when you see it, that I take my people 18 for tours out in the plant so that they can talk to 19 their neighbors and say, wow, that is just a great 20 operation. It's not scary when you actually see it.

21 It's all the talk behind the scenes, when you don't 22 actually get to witness it and see how clean and how 23 professional it is.

24 Safety, so I am a community, I am 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 50community, Mark knows I say that all the time. So 1 when we tied into the septic, or the sewer, selfishly 2 I was worried about how that would, how my toilet 3 would handle that at home. Pleased to announce no 4 problems at all. So I'm always worried about the 5 community aspect.

6 They are an excellent neighbor. The 7 plant doesn't stink, it's not loud. When we do night 8 activities we notify the community. It's just a 9 respectful company to work for.

10 Lastly, industrial safety, radiation 11 safety, I have no fears at all being, living in the 12 community and living my entire life in the community.

13 We have so many systems, so many controls and so 14 many monitors in place, and even with all that, you 15 still, you have to have a culture. If you have the 16 people and the equipment in place but you have a 17 culture that doesn't support that questioning 18 attitude of being your brother's keeper and looking 19 out for everything, then you're not going to have a, 20 you're not going to succeed in this business.

21 The expectation at Braidwood, and at any 22 Exelon plant, is that if you see something that 23 doesn't look right, you bring it up. We don't hide 24 anything, we put it out there in the open and then we 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 51address it. And that's everybody's, everybody's 1 responsibility, it's not just for Mark, it's not just 2 for the manager, it's for the clerical person all the 3 way up, the contractor, anybody to bring it up.

4 So knowing that culture, and that is the 5 expectation, I'm grateful to be at Braidwood and I 6 would like to be extended as well.

7 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. I would like to 8 invite Philip O'Connor from Proactive Strategies, 9 Inc. 10 MR. O'CONNOR: My name is Philip R.

11 O'Connor, that's O-'-C-o-n-n-o-r. And first of all, 12 thank you to the NRC for holding this meeting. In 13 the early 1980's, during the peak construction period 14 at both Braidwood and Byron, I was serving as 15 Chairman of the Illinois Commerce Commission, which 16 is the utility regulatory body for our state. At 17 that time I was also serving as the representative of 18 all of the other state utility regulators on the 19 board of, the Advisory Board of the Institute for 20 Nuclear Power Operations. And one of the things that 21 we came to an appreciation of during that period, and 22 even more so since, is the connection between the 23 safe practices in a nuclear plant and economic 24 performance.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 52 That peak period of construction in the 1 early 80's was one of substantial controversy about 2 both the economics of the projects and the long run 3 impact on electricity prices in northern Illinois, I 4 know, because my home used to be regularly picketed, 5 and I would be yelled at on the bus.

6 But let me tell you, and we all know it, 7 things have worked out extraordinarily well, far 8 better than most expected. Just three quick points.

9 First, both Braidwood and Byron have proven to be 10 stellar performers with capacity factors well over 90 11 percent. Second, in an era in which there's been 12 both great uncertainty about the economics as well as 13 the environmental aspects of fossil fuels, these two 14 stations have had the advantage of a low cost, non-15 fossil fuel supply and all of the intended 16 consequences of that.

17 Third, and this is particularly dear to 18 my heart, Illinois was a pioneer in moving away from 19 traditional electricity price regulation and toward 20 customer choice and competition in the generation and 21 supply sectors. The high performance and the low 22 production costs at both Braidwood and Byron have 23 been important factors in a successful transition 24 from traditional regulation and competition.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 53 Let me just illustrate this. In the 1 decade prior to Illinois' 1997 restructuring law, the 2 average Illinois electricity price was consistently 3 about 10 percent above the national average. In the 4 more than a decade since the full implementation of 5 choice, average Illinois electricity prices have been 6 seven to eight percent below the national average.

7 That 18 point swing has been worth about 35 billion 8 dollars so far, and is growing every day.

9 As of the end of May, Illinois had the 10 11th lowest electricity prices in the United States.

11 I mean, the only ones who have lower prices are 12 those with, in the west, with a lot of hydroelectric 13 power and so forth. And I think that just, you know, 14 Mr. Moran's comment about his bill now compared to 15 what it was, I think helps to illustrate the point.

16 So Byron and Braidwood are no longer 17 owned by a utility, it's true they're affiliated with 18 ComEd, but they are not part of the utility rate 19 base, and they have been operating successfully as 20 fully competitive assets in a highly competitive 21 generation market. So the bottom line here is that 22 Braidwood and Byron, if they are allowed to operate 23 well into the future by being re-licensed, are likely 24 to continue to play a positive role in maintaining 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 54 Illinois' advantageous electricity price position, 1 and that, of course, is a big plus for job creation 2 and prosperity in Illinois.

3 So let me end where I began, and that is 4 simply noting that Exelon's ongoing adherence to best 5 practices for nuclear safety will be an important 6 underpinning of ongoing strong economic performance 7 of both those plants and of the Illinois electricity 8 market. Thank you.

9 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Next I would 10 like to invite Steve Quigley from the Will County 11 Governmental League.

12 MR. QUIGLEY: Quigley, Q-u-i-g-l-e-y.

13 Hi, I'm Steve Quigley, Will County Governmental 14 League on behalf of the 32 communities that the Will 15 County Governmental League represents. We would 16 endorse the licensor to be renewed. On a personal 17 note, in 1992 I became the Public Information 18 Director for the Illinois Emergency Management 19 Office, and, or agency actually, and as a public 20 information director I had the opportunity and chance 21 to view all the nuclear power stations in Illinois, 22 and I learned a lot.

23 Number one, I didn't know that we had 24 more active nuclear sites, or reactors in Illinois 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 55than any other state in the nation. Upon doing that, 1 that was back in the ComEd days, I saw how safety was 2 an important aspect to what goes on in any nuclear 3 power station, and I also learned subsequently when I 4 took this position how the Exelon/ComEd, it was ComEd 5 when I started, now Exelon, took their community 6 outreach. Community outreach to 7 individuals in the communities I represent is 8 paramount to having a utility such as a nuclear 9 safety or nuclear production site like this, to what 10 the mayors that I represent, they want to know, they 11 want information, it's not just Braidwood, it's the 12 communities throughout Will County. And one of the 13 things, Mr. Greuling took about half my speech so I 14 just left my notes on the thing, but we do represent 15 almost 700,000 residents. Economic 16 development is a very important aspect of what mayors 17 do in their communities. John does it in a bigger 18 picture, our mayor's do it, you know, for their own 19 communities. Having clean, efficient service and 20 reliability is a great economic benefit when mayors 21 are going out and trying to do outreach to bring 22 businesses into their communities, and the Will 23 County community as a whole.

24 But I cannot commend the staff at this 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 56local station more for the outreach. They get in 1 touch with me two or three times a year, ask if 2 there's any meetings that they can attend, we have 3 monthly meetings with our mayors and our city 4 administrators, are there things they can come, is 5 there anything they can do on the behalf to 6 enlighten. They offer opportunities for the 7 community leaders to come and tour the plant. I had 8 the privilege of going right before they did the last 9 generator turnover, which I think was a couple years 10 ago. 11 I've had the opportunity to go since then 12 but they were gearing up and the safety on the inside 13 of the plant and the security on the outside of the 14 plant in my humble opinion, as somebody who's seen 15 this over the last 15 years, can't be matched. And 16 we would endorse fully the NRC's extension for the 17 next 20 years of this licensor. Thank you.

18 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Mr. Frank Antos 19 from the Community Advisory Panel.

20 MR. ANTOS: That's A-n-t-o-s. As a long 21 time resident of the area, I don't see any problem 22 with them getting renewed on their license. They've 23 been excellent, good neighbors. All I can tell you, 24 that's, go for it.

25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 57 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you. Nancy Ammer 1 from the Grundy Economic Development.

2 MS. AMMER: Good evening, last name 3 Ammer, A-m-m-e-r. Like Mr. Quigley I'm tempted to 4 say ditto and sit back down as I know you're all 5 anxious to get home, but I just want to make a few 6 quick comments. I'm with the Grundy Economic 7 Development Counsel in Grundy County, the adjacent 8 County over. And so we find ourselves really in an 9 enviable position in that we are sandwiched by 10 nuclear stations with LaSalle Station on our western 11 border in the next county over, Braidwood here in 12 Will County and then we're home to Dresden Station, 13 all operated by Exelon and all excellently operated.

14 I also have the opportunity then from 15 looking at them as existing businesses in our area, 16 but then also what they bring to the table as we're 17 trying to track new business to Illinois and to 18 Grundy County. The robust energy market has been 19 good for consumers, and it has also been good for 20 existing businesses as well as in the attraction 21 efforts of new businesses, especially as we're seeing 22 some reemergence of manufacturing in our area, that 23 have very energy-intensive types of businesses so 24 that we are now, have statistically, the employment, 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 58the lowest in the country. It just gives more 1 validation to what we've been working on.

2 The quality jobs that we see at 3 Braidwood, that we see at Dresden, that we see at 4 Exelon cannot be understated, especially in this 5 environment of high unemployment. When you take 6 those 800 plus jobs with excellent payroll, excellent 7 benefits, multiple it by three, by all three of the 8 stations, and all of a sudden you start to see 9 significant impacts of payrolls in excess of $80 10 million here, multiply that by three with the three 11 stations, employment of over 2,500.

12 And then also to not forget the 13 multipliers that we see when there are the refueling 14 outages. I can assure you as an economic development 15 person, I can't speak on behalf of Mr. Greuling, but 16 there's not a lot of people knocking on our doors to 17 bring in $80 million payroll to our community. We 18 are thankful that they are here, we are thankful the 19 commitment that they make to our taxing bodies, and 20 on behalf of the Grundy Economic Development Counsel 21 I would encourage the renewal of the license. Thank 22 you. 23 MS. HAUSMAN: Thank you everyone for your 24 comments. I'd like to open it up to the floor, and 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 59 if there's anybody who has not made a comment yet 1 that would like to speak, please step up to the 2 podium. Everybody wants to go home.

3 Okay, and I've got a few closing comments 4 here. Thank you everyone again for your 5 participation, for the comments, for attending the 6 meeting this evening. And the comments provided will 7 be addressed in the Scoping Summary Report for 8 openness and transparency the Scoping Summary Report 9 will be available publicly on the NRC license renewal 10 website, and the address is in the handout.

11 And if there are any further comments you 12 can provide them either in writing or electronically.

13 Please do so by September 27th. And the NRC is 14 always looking for ways to improve our public meeting 15 process, so there are feedback forms on the table, if 16 you would like to fill one of those out. They're 17 postage paid and you can send them in, and any 18 improvements would be welcome.

19 Does anybody have any comments before we 20 close the meeting? Then this meeting is adjourned.

21 Thank you very much.

22 (Whereupon at 8:20 p.m. the meeting was 23 adjourned.)

24 25 NEAL R. GROSS COURT REPORTERS AND TRANSCRIBERS 1323 RHODE ISLAND AVE., N.W.

(202) 234-4433 WASHINGTON, D.

C. 20005-3701 www.nealrgross.com 60 1 2 3 4