ML22194A184
Text
{{#Wiki_filter:V.C. Summer Power Station Safety Analysis Report Electric Power Chapter 8 Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 1 of 1 This Revision summary replaces the List of Effective pages of the VC Summer FSAR, effective June 30, 2021. It will appear in Chapter 00 of the VC Summer FSAR and is the best history available of all the changes made to the original VC Summer FSAR. As changes are made now, only a REV bar will appear in the right margin next to a change. All other REV bars from previous NRC updates will eventually be removed. These changes were made to accommodate VC Summer fleet integration efforts.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8-i Electric Power Table of Contents Section Title Page 8.0 ELECTRIC POWER . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-1
8.1 INTRODUCTION
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-1 8.1.1 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-2 8.2 OFFSITE POWER SYSTEM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-1 8.2.1 Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-1 8.2.1.1 Unit Auxiliary, Emergency Auxiliary, and Safeguards Transformers . . . . . . 8.2-3 8.2.1.2 Transmission System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-4 8.2.2 Analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-7 8.2.2.1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-7 8.2.2.2 Stability Study Results. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-7 8.2.3 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-10 8.3 ONSITE POWER SYSTEMS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-1 8.3.1 A-C Power Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-1 8.3.1.1 Description. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-1 8.3.1.2 Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-16 8.3.1.3 Conformance with Appropriate Quality Assurance Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-17 8.3.1.4 Independence of Redundant Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-17 8.3.1.5 Physical Identification of Safety-Related Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-21 8.3.1.6 Electrical Penetration Areas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-22 8.3.2 D-C Power Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-22 8.3.2.1 Description. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-22 8.3.2.2 Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-31 8.3.2.3 Physical Identification of Safety-Related Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-32 8.3.3 Fire Protection for Cable Systems. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-32 8.3.3.1 Cable Derating, Cable Tray Fill, and Cable Construction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-33 8.3.3.2 Fire Detection and Protection Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-36 8.3.3.3 Fire Barriers and Separation Between Redundant Cable Trays . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-37 8.3.3.4 Fire Stops . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-37 8.3.4 Safety Related Cable . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-37 8.3.5 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-38 8.4 STATION BLACKOUT. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-1
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8-ii Electric Power Table of Contents (Continued) Section Title Page 8.4.1 Station Blackout Duration. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-1 8.4.2 Coping Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-1 8.4.2.1 Class 1E Battery Capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-2 8.4.2.2 Condensate Inventory For Decay Heat Removal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-2 8.4.2.3 Compressed Air . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-2 8.4.2.4 Effects of Loss of Ventilation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-2 8.4.2.5 Containment Isolation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-2 8.4.2.6 Reactor Coolant Inventory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-2 8.4.3 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4-3 Appendix 8A Additional Cable and Tray Design Considerations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8A-i Appendix 8B Cable Raceway Fire Barriers Design. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8B-i Appendix 8C Summary of Analysis of Separation Between Tray for Non-Class 1E Circuits and Tray for Class 1E Circuits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8C-i Appendix 8D Analysis of the Acceptable Voltage Range to be Applied to the ESF System . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8D-i Appendix 8E Analysis of the Voltage Drops on the ESF System When Starting a 6900 or 460 Volt Motor With the Diesel Generator as the Source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8E-i Appendix 8F Starting Sequence of ESF Equipment Following an Accident Coincident With a Degraded Voltage Condition. . . . . . . . . 8F-i Appendix 8G Electrical Containment Penetration Conductor Overcurrent Protection Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8G-i
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8-iii Electric Power List of Tables Table Title Page Table 8.1-1 Transmission System Ties to Other Utilities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-3 Table 8.1-2 Implementation of IEEE Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-5 Table 8.1-3 List of Applicable Criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-7 Table 8.2-1 Distances of Lines to First Major Substation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-11 Table 8.2-2 Allowable Variation in Offsite System Voltage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2-12 Table 8.3-1 Major Electrical Equipment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-39 Table 8.3-2 Symmetrical Interrupting Capacity For 480 Volt Unit Substation Cubicles. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-40 Table 8.3-3 (Part A1) Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-41 Table 8.3-3 (Part A2) Basis for Diesel Generator Fuel Oil Consumption . . . . . . . . 8.3-42 Table 8.3-3 Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-42 Table 8.3-3 (Part B1) Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-43 Table 8.3-3 (Part B2) Basis for Diesel Generator Fuel Oil Consumption Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-44 Table 8.3-3a Diesel Generator Protective Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-45 Table 8.3-3b Engineered Safety Features Bus Indicators . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-46 Table 8.3-4 Identification of Safety-Related Cable Trays and Cables . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-47 Table 8.3-5 Sequence of Operation Following a Loss or Degraded Voltage Condition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-48 Tables 8C-8 through 8C-39 Construction Bidding Purposes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.C-11 Table 8.D-2 Calculated Motor Voltages for Maximum Offsite Voltage . . . . . . . . . . 8.D-4 Table 8.E-1 Calculated Voltage Level of ESF System Buses and Motor Terminals With a Diesel Generator as a Source and Starting the 6900 Volt Charging/Safety Injection Pump Motor . . . . . . 8.E-5 Table 8.E-2 Calculated Voltage Level of ESF System Buses and Motor Terminals With a Diesel Generator as a Source and Starting the 460 Volt Service Water Pump Motor. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.E-6 Table 8.F-1 Degraded Grid Voltage Coincident With LOCA. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.F-2
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8-iv Electric Power List of Tables Table Title Page Table 8.F-2 Degraded Grid Voltage Coincident With MSLB. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.F-4
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8-v Electric Power List of Figures Section Title Page Figure 8.1-1 Transmission System Map . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.1-11 Figure 8.3-0m Main Control Board Annunciator Station B-804-636 SH.1 & 637 SH.1 Rev. 9 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-63 Figure 8.3-0n Diesel Generator Local Annunciator Stations DWG. NO. 1MS-32-120 REV. 0. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-64 Figure 8.3-3 Containment Penetration Separation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.3-77 Figure 8.B-1 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-5 Figure 8.B-2 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-6 Figure 8.B-3 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-7 Figure 8.B-4 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-8 Figure 8.B-5 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-9 Figure 8.B-6 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-10 Figure 8.B-7 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-11 Figure 8.B-8 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-12 Figure 8.B-9 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-13 Figure 8.B-10 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-14 Figure 8.B-11 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-15 Figure 8.B-12 Electrical Fire Barrier Details . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.B-16 Figure 8C-1 Case 041-C. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.C-8 Figure 8C-2 Case 102-A. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.C-9 Figure 8C-3 Case 073-A. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.C-10
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-1 CHAPTER 8 - ELECTRIC POWER 8.0 ELECTRIC POWER
8.1 INTRODUCTION
The Licensees transmission system, along with points of interconnection with neighboring utilities, is shown in Figure 8.1-1. The Licensee is a member utility of the Virginia-Carolinas (VACAR) Subregion Reliability Agreement which is a part of the Southeastern Reliability Council. As a member of such a group, the Licensee can supply power to, or consume power from other members, as its system allows or demands. Transmission system ties to other utilities are as listed in Table 8.1-1. The specific interface between the transmission grid and the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station is discussed in Section 8.2. The Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station 230 kV switchyard has a single bus, single breaker arrangement, with three main bus sections. The center section is designated bus section 3, the east section designated bus section 1 and the west section designated bus section 2. A tap from bus section 2 provides a subsection of this bus with two bay positions for the Fairfield No. 1 and No. 2 lines. The Parr 115 kV engineered safety features (ESF) line terminates in a bay in bus section 3, crosses over bus section 3 with rigid bus construction, and continues to the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. There is an Alternate AC (AAC) source of power installed that is fed from an underground 13.8kV cable to the Parr Hydro Power Station (Separate from Parr Generating Complex). This line feeds a 13.2/7.2kV weather event hardened transformer located in the VCS Substation that is connected on the low side to a non-safeguards bus in the turbine building. This source of power was designed to the requirements of NUMARC 87-00 App B and can power one entire safeguards train of equipment. The onsite power network consists of three non-Class 1E distribution networks and two independent, redundant Class 1E distribution networks. The voltage levels of each network are 7200 volts, 480 volts and 120 volt a-c and 125 volt d-c. The main source of power for the non-Class 1E networks is the unit auxiliary transformer which is connected to the output of the main generator between the generator circuit breaker and the low voltage bushings of the main power transformer (see Figure 8.2-3). The emergency auxiliary transformers provide an emergency source of power for the non-Class 1E distribution network. The normal source of power for the two independent Class 1E distribution networks are the ESF transformers and a winding of the emergency auxiliary transformers. These two sources of power also serve as an alternate source of power to each other (see Figures 8.2-3 and 8.2-4).
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-2 Two diesel generators are provided, one for each of the Class 1E buses to serve as an emergency source of power. The safety-related loads their safety functions and power requirements, supplied by the two emergency diesel generators are listed in Table 8.3-3. The ESF battery buses, inverter buses and associated loads are shown by Figures 8.3-1 and 8.3-2. The Class 1E power network provides an adequate and reliable source of electric power for safe reactor shutdown following any design basis event, including loss of offsite power and for all normal modes of station operation. The Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station electrical systems are designed to comply with the scope of IEEE-308 (Reference 1) as specified in Section 1 of IEEE-308. Onsite power systems are designed to satisfy the applicable criteria of (Reference 1), as well as the criteria of Regulatory Guides 1.6 and 1.9 (see Appendix 3A). Implementation of IEEE Standards and the extent to which any alternative approaches are used is itemized in Table 8.1-2. Applicable criteria, including: General Design Criteria, Appendix A to 10 CFR 50; Regulatory Guides; and Branch Technical Positions are listed in Table 8.1-3 with references to appropriate sections of this FSAR. Implementation of Regulatory Guides is discussed in Appendix 3A. 8.1.1 References
- 1. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Criteria for Class 1E Electric Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Stations, IEEE-308-1971.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-3 Table 8.1-1 Transmission System Ties to Other Utilities South Carolina Electric South Carolina and Gas Company Public Service Authority Voltages (kV) VCS1 Blythewood 230 VCS1 Winnsboro 230 Williams Charity 230 Lyles Sandy Run 115 Lyles Columbia 115 St. George St. George 115 Faber Place Carnes 115 Faber Place North Charleston 115 Pepper Hill Mateeba 230 Southeastern Power Administration CLM Tap Clark Hill 115 Duke Energy - Carolinas VCS1 Newport 230 VCS2 Bush River 230 Saluda Hydro #2 Bush River (W) 115 Saluda Hydro #1 Bush River (B) 115 Duke Energy - Progress Wateree Sumter 230 St. George Sumter 230 Eastover Sumter 115
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-4 Table 8.1-1 (continued) Transmission System Ties to Other Utilities South Carolina Electric South Carolina and Gas Company Public Service Authority Voltages (kV) Georgia Power Company Calhoun Falls Hart 115 (N.O.) Okatie McIntosh 115 Savannah River Services Savannah River Plant Vogtle 230
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-5 Table 8.1-2 Implementation of IEEE Standards
- 1. IEEE-279-1971, Criteria for Protection Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Stations, (ANSI N42.7, 1972).
Refer to Sections 7.1, 7.2, 7.3 and 7.6.
- 2. IEEE-308-1971, Criteria for Class 1E Electric Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Stations.
Onsite and offsite electrical power systems are designed to satisfy the applicable criteria of IEEE-308-1971. Refer to Sections 7.1.2.1.3, 7.6.1.2, 8.1, and 8.2.2.1.
- 3. IEEE-317-1972, Electric Penetration Assemblies in Containment Structures for Nuclear Power Generating Stations.
Electrical penetrations are designed and fabricated in accordance with the requirements of IEEE-317-1972. Refer to Sections 3.11.2.2.2 and 7.1.2.9 and the discussion of Regulatory Guide 1.63 in Appendix 3A. IEEE-323-1971, General Guide for Qualifying Class 1E Electrical Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations. Environmental Qualification (EQ) of Class 1E electrical equipment is addressed in Section 3.11, which identifies the commitment to NUREG-0588, Cat. II (IEEE-323-1971) for the original plant design. NUREG-0588, Cat. I (IEEE-323-1974), 10CFR50.49, and NRC RG 1.89 requirements have also been used as the bases for environmental qualification, as described in FSAR Section 3.11 and Appendix 3A, under NRC RG 1.89.
- 4. IEEE-336-1971, Installation, Inspection and Testing of Nuclear Power Generating Station Protection Systems, (ANSI N45.2.4., 1972).
Refer to Section 8.3.1.1 and Chapters 14.0 and 17.0.
- 5. IEEE-338-1971, IEEE Standard Criteria for the Periodic Testing of Nuclear Power Generating Station Class 1E Power and Protection Systems.
Refer to Section 7.1.2.11 and Chapter 14.0.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-6 Table 8.1-2 (continued) Implementation of IEEE Standards
- 6. IEEE-344-1975, IEEE Recommended Practices for Seismic Qualification of Class 1E Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations.
Class 1E electric equipment is tested and data is recorded to ensure that equipment satisfies design performance requirements during and following a safe shutdown earthquake (SSE). The qualification program meets the requirements of IEEE-344-1975 as discussed in Section 3.10.
- 7. IEEE-379-1972, Guide for the Application of the Single Failure Criteria to Nuclear Power Generating Station Protection Systems, (ANSI N41.2).
Refer to Section 7.1.2.7 and the discussion of Regulatory Guide 1.53 in Appendix 3A.
- 8. IEEE-384-1974, Criteria for Separation of Class 1E Equipment and Circuits, (ANSI N41.14).
Refer to Sections 7.1.2.2.1, 8.3.1.4 and 8.3.1.5 and the discussion of Regulatory Guide 1.75 in Appendix 3A.
- 9. IEEE-387-1972, Criteria for Diesel Generator Units Applied As Standby Power Supplies for Nuclear Power Stations.
IEEE-387-1972 is used as the basis for design criteria for the diesel generators and accessories. Included among the referenced standards in IEEE-387-1972, Section 4.1, are IEEE-308-1971 and IEEE-323-1971. Diesel generators are designed to satisfy these standards.
- 10. IEEE-450-1987, Recommended Practice for Maintenance, Testing and Replacement of Large Stationary Type Power Plant and Substation Lead Storage Batteries.
Refer to Section 8.3.2.2.2.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 Table 8.1-3 List of Applicable Criteria Criteria Title Reference FSAR Section(s)
- 1. General Design Criteria (GDC), Appendix A to 10 CFR 50 GDC-1 Quality Standards and Records 3.1.2 GDC-2 Design Bases for Protection Against Natural 3.1.2, 3.10, 3.11 Phenomena GDC-3 Fire Protection 3.1.2, 7.1.2.2.3, 8.3.3.2 GDC-4 Environmental and Missile Design Bases 3.1.2 GDC-5 Sharing of Structures, Systems and Components 3.1.2 GDC-13 Instrumentation and Control 3.1.2, 7.3.1, 7.3.2 GDC-17 Electric Power Systems 3.1.2, 8.2.1, 8.2.2.2, 8.3.1.2.1, 8.3.2.2.1 VC SUMMER FSAR GDC-18 Inspection and Testing of Electric Power Systems 3.1.2, 8.2.1, 8.3.1.2.1, 8.3.2.2.1 GDC-21 Protection System Reliability and Testability 3.1.2, 7.2.2.2, 7.3.1, 7.3.2 GDC-22 Protection System Independence 3.1.2, 7.2 GDC-33 Reactor Coolant Makeup 3.1.2, 8.3 GDC-34 Residual Heat Removal 3.1.2, 8.3 GDC-35 Emergency Core Cooling 3.1.2, 8.3 GDC-41 Containment Atmosphere Cleanup 3.1.2, 8.3 8.1-7 GDC-44 Cooling Water 3.1.2, 8.3
Table 8.1-3 (continued) Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 List of Applicable Criteria Criteria Title Reference FSAR Section(s)
- 2. Regulatory Guides (RG)
RG 1.6 Independence Between Redundant App. 3A, 8.1, 8.3.1.2.1, 8.3.2.2.1 Standby (Onsite) Power Sources and Between Their Distribution Systems RG 1.9 Selection of Diesel Generator Set Capacity App. 3A, 8.1,8.3.1.1.2.4, 8.3.1.2.1 for Standby Power Supplies RG 1.22 Periodic Testing of Protective System App. 3A, 7.1.2.5, 7.3.2 Actuation Functions RG 1.29 Seismic Design Classification App. 3A RG 1.30 Quality Assurance Requirements for the App. 3A, Chapter 17.0 Installation, Inspection and Testing of Instrumentation and Electric Equipment RG 1.32 Use of IEEE Std. 308-1971, Criteria for App. 3A, 8.2.1, 8.3.1.2.1, 8.3.2.2.1 VC SUMMER FSAR Class 1E Electric Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Stations 8.1-8
Table 8.1-3 (continued) Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 List of Applicable Criteria Criteria Title Reference FSAR Section(s) RG 1.41 Preoperational testing of redundant onsite Electric App. 3A, 8.3.1.1.2.6, Chapter 14.0 Power Systems to verify proper load group assignments. RG 1.47 Bypassed and Inoperable Status Indication for App. 3A, 7.1.2.6 Nuclear Power Plant Safety Systems RG 1.53 Application of the Single Failure Criterion to Nuclear App. 3A, 7.1.2.7 Power Plant Protection Systems RG 1.63 Electric Penetration Assemblies in Containment App. 3A, 7.1.2.8, 8.3.1.1.4 Structures for Water-Cooled Nuclear Power Plants RG 1.68 Preoperational and Initial Startup Test Programs for App. 3A, Chapter 14.0 Water-Cooled Power Reactors RG 1.70 Standard Format and Content of Safety Analysis App. 3A Reports for Nuclear Power Plants VC SUMMER FSAR RG 1.75 Physical Independence of Electric Systems App. 3A, 7.1.2.2.1, 8.3.1.4.3 RG 1.81 Shared Emergency and Shutdown Electric Systems App. 3A for Multi-Unit Nuclear Power Plants RG 1.89 Qualification of Class IE Equipment for Nuclear App. 3A, 3.11, 8.3.1.2.2.1 Power Plants RG 1.93 Availability of Electric Power Sources App. 3A 8.1-9
Table 8.1-3 (continued) Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 List of Applicable Criteria Criteria Title Reference FSAR Section(s)
- 3. Branch Technical Positions (ETCSB)
ETCSB1 Backfitting of the Protection and Emergency Power Chapters 7.0 and 8.0 Systems of Nuclear Reactors ETCSB2 Diesel-Generator Reliability Qualification Testing 8.3.1.1.6 ETCSB6 Capacity Test Requirements of Station 8.3.2.2.2 Batteries-Technical Specifications ETCSB8 Use of Diesel-Generator Sets for Peaking 8.3.1.1.2.4 ETCSB10 Electrical and Mechanical Equipment Seismic 3.10, 8.3.2.2.1 Qualification Program ETCSB11 Stability of Offsite Power Systems 8.2.2.2 ETCSB17 Diesel Generator Protective Trip Circuit Bypasses 8.3.1.1.2.8, Table 8.3-3 a ETCSB21 Guidance for Applicable of Regulatory Guide 1.47 App. 3A (discussion of RG 1.47), 7.1.2.6 VC SUMMER FSAR ETCSB27 Design Criteria for Thermal Overload Protection for App. 3A (discussion of RG 1.106), Motors of Motor-Operated Valves 8.3.1.1.4 8.1-10
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.1-11 Figure 8.1-1 TRANSMISSION SYSTEM MAP
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-1 8.2 OFFSITE POWER SYSTEM 8.2.1 Description The SCE&G transmission system supplies offsite a-c power for operating the engineered safety features (ESF) buses as well as for startup and shutdown of the station. Two (2) separate sources of offsite power are provided for the Class 1E electric system, which is in compliance with General Design Criterion 17 and Regulatory Guide 1.32 (see Appendix 3A). One (1) source is the SCE&G transmission grid terminating at the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station 230 kV switchyard bus, which feeds the plant through a step down transformer. The second source is from the existing Parr Generating Complex over a 115 kV transmission line (see Figure 8.2-1). This source is connected to the plant through onsite step down transformers and a separate regulating transformer. These 2 sources have sufficient separation and isolation so that loss of the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station with the Fairfield Hydro Units offline will not degrade either of the sources below their acceptable voltage limit. Thus, loss of the station output, in conjunction with an accident, will not result in a degraded voltage condition on either source. Likewise, loss of a line or generation on the 115 kV network will not cause a degraded condition on the Emergency Auxiliary Transformer which is fed power from the 230 kV bus. Also, no single event such as an insulator or bushing failure, transformer failure, transmission line tower failure, line breakage, or similar event can cause simultaneous disruption of both sources. The offsite power system is not designed to withstand tornadoes, exceptionally severe hurricanes or ice storms. However, the circuit breakers for isolation of the 2 separate onsite power systems from the offsite power system are located within 2 separate, missile protected rooms. Therefore, any failure of the offsite power system, including the bus duct system between the offsite power system and the ESF buses, is isolated from the ESF buses before the emergency diesel generators are started (see Figure 8.2-2). The allowable system voltage fluctuations for each of the 2 preferred offsite sources are defined in Table 8.2-2. As noted in the table, the allowable voltage range is dependent on generating unit availability, the number of buses connected to the source, and on the configuration of the transformers for the 115 kV line. The SCE&G dispatchers are provided with instructions to make every effort to maintain the system voltage fluctuations within these allowable ranges. The instructions require maintenance of the voltage limits during shutdown, as well as during operation, of Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. The transmission system voltage drop due to loss of the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station is included within the allowable voltage ranges during plant operation with the unit online. The transmission system voltage drop is not included within the allowable voltage ranges during plant operation with the unit offline because the unit is not generating. A direct communications link is provided between the SCE&G Dispatch Office in Columbia, SC, and all SCE&G generating plants. Through this communications link, the plant operators receive the instructions from the dispatch office for setting generator kilowatt, kilovar output, voltage level, and for controlling the VAR output on the Fairfield units when they are used for pumping. The plant operators are provided with indicators for the engineered safety features (ESF) bus network as discussed in Section 8.3.1.2.1. Also, voltmeters, ammeters, kilowatt meters, kilovar meters, and frequency meters are provided for the main generator bus. If generator output differs
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-2 from that specified by the dispatch office, the operator notifies the dispatch office and receives a new set of operating levels for the generator. Control and indication are provided locally at the substation relay house and/or the Unit 1 relay house and remotely in the system dispatchers office for each of the incoming 230 kV transmission line circuit breakers and the 230 kV bus tie circuit breakers. Circuit breaker control consists of tripping and closing capability. Indication includes circuit breaker status (open or closed) and the amount and direction of the power being transmitted over each transmission line. Control power for the substation relay house is supplied from a 125 VDC battery, with a backup feed from the plant non-1E. Control power for the Unit 1 relay house is supplied from two (2) 125 volt d-c batteries, each sized to serve as back-up to the other. The 230 kV buses are protected by bus differential relays. Each 230 kV line and the 115 kV line is protected by primary and backup relaying. Each 230 kV line terminal has relays that provide breaker failure protection that trips the appropriate bus lockout relay when the breaker fails to trip. Each line relays also provide a multi-shot, static reclosing function that is active in some breakers. The 230 kV circuit breakers associated with the plant main transformer and emergency auxiliary transformers, as well as the circuit switches associated with the ESF transformers, are controlled from, and provide indication in, the control room. Also, the 230 kV circuit breakers can be tripped at the circuit breaker control panels mounted on the circuit breaker structures. Manually operated disconnect switches are provided for the 230 kV circuit breakers to isolate each from the bus and associated lines. These manual disconnects permit testing and maintenance of each circuit breaker on an individual basis while allowing the 230 kV substation to remain energized, which satisfies General Design Criterion 18. Testing and maintenance are performed periodically in accordance with a SCE&G program. As shown by Figure 8.2-2, the 115 kV line terminates in a rigid bus construction for the crossover of the 230 kV middle bus section. The 115 kV bus has no connection to the 230 kV bus. Therefore, any problems associated with the 230 kV bus do not affect the 115 kV bus. The rigid bus construction offers high reliability by eliminating the possibility of line dropping at this crossover point. The preferred power source transformers, which are the emergency auxiliary transformers and the combination of the safeguard transformers and the voltage regulator are located out of doors and are physically separated from each other. Lightning arrestors are used where applicable for lightning protection. The transformers are protected by automatic water spray systems to extinguish oil fires quickly, thus preventing spreading. The transformer area is provided with a gravel filled sump pit to contain transformer oil should a rupture occur. Power from both the emergency auxiliary transformer and from the combination of the 2 safeguard transformers and the voltage regulator is brought into the plant by independent 7200 volt buses. These buses are physically separated and independently supported throughout their length to the 2 separated, missile protected rooms which contain the separate Class 1E electric system 7200 volt buses, thus maintaining redundancy.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-3 8.2.1.1 Unit Auxiliary, Emergency Auxiliary, and Safeguards Transformers Normal station service power for non-Class 1E equipment, which includes that required during normal operation, startup, shutdown, and following shutdown, is provided from the unit auxiliary transformer. The primary side of the unit auxiliary transformer is connected to the generator isolated phase bus duct at a point between the generator circuit breaker and the low voltage connections to the main step up transformer as shown by Figure 8.2-3. The unit auxiliary transformer is rated 22 kV - 7200 volts. The three 7200 volt secondaries are used to feed 3 independent 7200 volt non-Class 1E auxiliary buses. The 2 ESF system 7200 volt buses are fed independently from other sources. Two (2) emergency auxiliary transformers are provided. The primary sides of these 2 transformers are connected in parallel to the 230 kV substation bus. The 2 secondary windings on each bank are rated 7200 volts. Three (3) of the 4 windings are used as an emergency power source for the three 7200 volt non-Class 1E auxiliary system buses. The fourth winding is a preferred offsite power source for either or both of the ESF system power trains (see Figures 8.2-3 and 8.2-4). Normally this winding is used to supply the 7200 volt ESF bus 1DB. The primary windings of the 2 safeguard transformers, XTF-4 and 5, are connected in parallel to the 115 kV line. These 2 transformers, in combination with the regulating transformer, XTF-6, are the second preferred offsite power source for either or both of the ESF system power trains. Normally, safeguard transformer 4 is used in combination with the voltage regulator to supply 7200 volt ESF system bus 1DA. If the voltage regulator is out of service, the 2 safeguard transformers can be used in parallel to supply either or both of the 7200 volt ESF system buses; or 1 of the 2 transformers can be used to supply either or both of the buses (see Figure 8.2-4). Connected to the same intermediate bus (1DX) as transformers XTF-4, 5 and 6 is the VC Summer Alternate AC Source (AAC). The AAC source is fed from an underground 13.8kV cable to the Parr Hydro Power Station main generator bus via Parr BKR 13123. This line feeds a 13.2/7.2 kV transformer located in the VCS Substation that feeds into the 1DX bus. All cabling and lightning protection equipment associated with this feed is weather protected. The installed cable is oversized for the potential load attached to it such that the 105º C normal rating of the cable cannot be reached with the maximum loading of a single ESF bus (750 mcm AL cable with most limiting rating of 490 amps will be loaded to a running maximum of 245 amps, 5.9MW load equivalent or 50% cable rating). Direct monitoring of underground cable temperature is not required as long as total ESF bus loading does not exceed 5.9MW (5MW calculated load with 15% conservatism). The loading of the AAC source onto either one of two ESF buses is to be done manually (sequencer Out-of-Service). Each of the 2 principle 7200 volt ESF buses is provided with a manually initiated transfer scheme to shift the bus power supply between the 2 preferred offsite power sources.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-4 8.2.1.2 Transmission System The network interconnections between the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station and the SCE&G transmission system consist of eight 230 kV transmission lines which approach the site from 3 directions. The 230 kV transmission lines interconnect the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station with the major sources of generation on the SCE&G system through major transmission grid substations as shown by Figures 8.1-1 and 8.2-1. The lines are designed to meet or exceed NESC (ANSI-C2) 1973 edition, medium loading, grade B construction requirements. Two of these eight transmission lines extend directly from the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station 230 kV bus section 2 to the SCE&G Fairfield Pumped Storage Facility. In addition, two 230 kV transmission lines interconnect the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station with the South Carolina Public Service Authority (SCPSA) system. One (1) 115 kV transmission line extends from the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station to the SCE&G Parr Generating Complex. The Parr 115kV substation and associated Transmission Grid connections serve as one of the preferred power sources for the ESF buses at the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. Within the Parr 115kV substation are four gas-fired combustion turbines that with the substation form the Parr Generating Complex. The Parr Hydro station is connected to the Parr 115kV substation via a 115/13.2kV tap changing transformer, but is not considered part of the Parr Generating Complex even with its close proximity. The 115 kV transmission line has no direct ties to the Parr Generating Complex 230 kV switchyard. This switchyard does have a tie from the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station 230 kV switchyard bus. The Parr Generating Complex 115 kV switchyard bus receives power from the Parr Generating Complex and from a 115 kV tie line to the Denny Terrace substation. With this arrangement, an outage at the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station 230 kV switchyard does not have a direct effect on the 115 kV ESF transmission line. Figures 8.2-2 and 8.2-2a through 8.2-2d indicate the physical relationship between transmission lines entering the switchyard, between the switchyard and the plant and within the switchyard. All 230 kV transmission tie lines to other major interconnection points converge on the switchyard. All transmission line structures have a minimum of 60 feet center to center as they approach the switchyard. Each transmission line has adequate capacity for the supply of the preferred power source emergency auxiliary transformer. The 230 kV transmission lines, 230 kV circuit breakers and 230 kV buses in the switchyard are designed to withstand and interrupt the maximum fault level at the bus.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-5 Details of the construction of each transmission line are as follows:
- 1. Parr-Summer Safeguard 115 kV Line This line is about 2.6 miles long. Wood, H-frame construction and steel monopole structures are used. The line extends from the Parr 115 kV substation to the vicinity of the Parr 230 kV substation and then to Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. An approximately 600 foot segment of this line is routed from above ground to an underground duct bank and then returns to above ground routing. This underground segment eliminates the crossing of the 115 kV line over 230kV transmission lines near the Parr Substation.
There is a switchable tie to the Parr-Winnsboro No. 1 line. It also crosses over the Norfolk-Southern Railroad at Parr and over a railroad spur at Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. The last 2 line structures at Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station are steel monopole structures which raise this line above a VCS1-VCS2 tie. There are no structure or circuit conflicts since a failure of the towers would not result in loss of both sources of offsite power, as the VCS1-VCS2 tie breaker would trip leaving the other 230 kV lines intact.
- 2. Summer-Edenwood Line, 230 kV This line is about 33.02 miles long. At Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station it is on 3 double circuit, 230 kV steel towers. The end of this line ties to the Edenwood 230 kV line about 1.2 miles from Parr. The line crosses over the Parr-Denny Terrace 230 kV line and the double circuit Parr-Denny Terrace 115 kV line. The line is of wood H-frame construction on a right-of-way with no other lines. The line continues past McMeekin Station on to Edenwood Substation.
- 3. Deleted
- 4. Summer-Pineland Line, 230 kV This line is on 3 double circuit, steel towers with the Summer-Denny Terrace line. These lines then are on wood H-frame structures designed for double circuits. The structures are in the center of a 240 foot wide right-of-way which extends for about 17.24 miles. In this area, the line parallels the SCPSA Summer-Blythewood 230 kV H-frame. There are structure conflicts in this area. For the next 1.62 miles, this line is on single circuit wood H-frame on a common right-of-way with the Summer-Denny Terrace line. There are no structural conflicts in this area. For the next 5.0 miles, this line is on single circuit, wood H-frame on its own right-of-way. For about the final 0.54 mile, this line is on double circuit, improved appearance, steel poles at Pineland substation. This line crosses over several transmission lines but none cross over it. Total length is about 24.4 miles.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-6
- 5. Summer-Denny Terrace Line, 230 kV This line is attached to the same structures as the Summer-Pineland line at the Virgil C.
Summer Nuclear Station and for the first 17.24 miles. From this point the Summer-Denny Terrace line is attached to single circuit H-frame structures and shares a common 240 foot right-of-way with the Summer-Pineland line for 1.62 miles. It is then on its own right-of-way for 5.91 miles. The Summer-Denny Terrace line then parallels the Denny Terrace-Rader double circuit 115 kV lines (crossing over them twice) to Denny Terrace, a distance of about 1.48 miles. Total length is 26.25 miles.
- 6. Deleted
- 7. South Carolina Public Service Authority, VCS1-Blythewood Line, 230 kV This line is installed on multi-pole single circuit (MPSC) structures with 1272 ACSR single conductor and is operated and owned by SCPSA. This line is located on variable width right-of-way (R/W) that extends for 20 miles from the VCS1 to SCPSAs Blythewood substation.
This line is on common R/W with SCPSAs VCS1-Winnsboro 230 kV line and SCE&Gs VCS1-Killian, Denny Terrace and Pineland 230 kV lines for 1.0 mile to a point referred to as Winnsboro Junction. From Winnsboro Junction, the line extends 2.8 miles to SCPSA Pomaria-Winnsboro 69 kV line. From the Pomaria-Winnsboro 69 kV line, the line extends 13.4 miles on common R/W with SCE&Gs VCS1-Denny Terrace and Pineland 230 kV lines. From this point, the line veers off and extends 2.9 miles to SCPSAs Blythewood substation.
- 8. VCS2 Bus 2 Tie Line, 230 kV This line connects V. C. Summer Unit 1, Bus 2 to V. C. Summer Unit 2 switchyard. It parallels the Duke-Newport line for approximately 0.63 mile. Total length is 0.87 mile.
- 9. South Carolina Public Service Authority, Summer-Winnsboro Line, 230 kV This line is operated and owned by the SCPSA. It parallels the Summer-Blythewood line for a distance of 3.7 miles on the east side and abutting the existing right-of-way. From that point the line heads in a northeasterly direction and double circuits with the existing SCPSA Pomaria-Winnsboro 69 kV line. Total length is about 14 miles.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-7
- 10. VCS1-Killian Line, 230 kV This line is installed on single pole single circuit (SPSC) and single pole double circuit (SPDC) steel monopole structures with bundled 1272 ACSR conductor. The line is located on variable width right-of-way (R/W) that extends for 35 miles from the VCS1 Switchyard to the Killian 230/115 kV Transmission substation. A SPSC section of this line is on common R/W with SCPSAs VCS1-Winnsboro and Blythewood 230 kV lines and SCE&Gs VCS1-Denny Terrace and Pineland 230 kV lines for 1 mile to a point referred to as Winnsboro Junction. From Winnsboro Junction, the line extends 13 miles to Winnsboro and is constructed SPDC with the second circuit being the Parr-Winnsboro 115 kV Line #1. This line section is on common R/W with the Parr-Winnsboro 115 kV Line #2. From Winnsboro, the line extends 15 miles to a point referred to as Blythewood PMSS and is constructed SPDC with the second circuit being the Blythewood-Winnsboro 115 kV line. From Blythewood PMSS, the line extends 6 miles to the Killian 230/115 kV Transmission substation and is constructed SPDC with the second circuit being the Blythewood-Killian 115 kV line.
- 11. VCS1, Bus 1-VCS2 Tie, 230 kV This line is installed on single pole single circuit (SPSC) steel monopole structures with bundled 1272 ACSR conductor. This is one of three 230 kV bus ties each approximately 1 mile in length that runs between the VCS1 and VCS2 Switchyards.
Distances of all lines from the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station terminal to the first major substation are listed in Table 8.2-1. 8.2.2 Analysis 8.2.2.1 Introduction The basis for design of DESC transmission facilities is such that a defined system will maintain stability with the loss of any system generator, including Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station, or the most critical transmission line, or the loss of the largest system load. The system will also remain stable for the most severe fault condition on any transmission line or substation bus. As such, the loss of any single system generator, including Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station, does not degrade the alternate system to where it cannot furnish shutdown power to Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station on an uninterrupted basis. The Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station buses and the location of the emergency auxiliary transformers and ESF transformers supplying shutdown power are such that no single permanent fault condition can prevent at least 1 of the auxiliary transformers from being available to furnish shutdown power. Table 8.2-1 lists the distances of lines from the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station switchyard to each first major substation. 8.2.2.2 Stability Study Results The System Stability study was performed using power system simulator software. The dynamic simulation cases and dynamics data were updated versions of cases and data which were issued
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-8 by the NERC and which were modified to meet the specific requirements of this study. The dynamic simulation cases and data were validated using the simulator software case initialization and model testing features. This was followed by a 30 second steady state simulation in order to demonstrate that the cases and data represented non-disturbed conditions prior to simulating system contingencies. The results of the steady state simulations are not included in this report but are available for review. Special attention was given to the analysis of disturbances in the vicinity of the V. C. Summer Nuclear Station during various system conditions. The simulations that were performed were selected as a result of discussions between V. C. Summer Design Engineering and DESC Transmission Planning. The simulations which were performed for each contingency began with a 1 second steady state period which was followed by a sequence of contingency events and a subsequent new steady state period for a total of 30 seconds for each contingency simulation. Both peak and light system load conditions were studied. System faults during peak load conditions are generally more challenging for offsite power voltage adequacy. System faults during light load conditions are generally more challenging for generator angular stability. The base year chosen for summer peak and light load conditions is the year of the Study and is typically 3-4 years in the future. Since the previous study was completed, a number of changes have been made or have been planned for the DESC generating and transmission systems. All actual and planned system improvements are incorporated in the simulation models used for the current study. The base year chosen for summer peak and light load conditions is the year of the Study and is typically 3-4 years in the future. The study includes any actual system changes since the last study and any changes planned for 3-4 years beyond the base year. The VCS FSAR required scenarios assume three MVAR levels (170, 330, and 484 MVAR). The peak load cases assume the VCS exciter provides 330 MVAR and 484 MVAR. The light load cases assume the VCS exciter provides 170 MVAR and 330 MVAR. 170 MVAR was modeled for a specific ESF bus alignment. Use of the 484 MVAR and 330 MVAR levels for the VCS FSAR required scenarios is considered conservative for several reasons. The VCS generator exciter has a maximum momentary rating of 484 MVAR and a typical maximum continuous rating of 330 MVAR. Therefore, these values represent the maximum MVAR load the station can support for any loading scenario. These values can also represent a substantial portion of the total typical MVAR load seen on the DESC transmission system. Therefore, these values are consistent with the VCS generator exciter providing a significant portion of the voltage support for the entire DESC system. Therefore, these loadings conditions are considered extremely conservative and unlikely to occur. V. C. Summer Balance of Plant (BOP) station loads were updated. In addition, because it is possible for Engineered Safeguard Features (ESF) bus loads to all be served from one bus, these loads were simulated as being located fully at each ESF bus (i.e., two ESF trains of equipment connected to each of the GDC 17 credited offsite sources).
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-9 For this study, the V. C. Summer generator governor model was disengaged from the simulation. A review of neighboring utilities' practices in modeling nuclear generators for transient stability simulations confirms that this is the accepted practice for representing block loaded nuclear generator governors. The transfer of the Balance of Plant loads to the Emergency Auxiliary Transformers following a generator breaker operation has been incorporated into the study. The study models various contingencies and transmission operating scenarios. These scenarios resulted in a combined effect to lessen the available transmission voltage and angular stability support of V.C. Summer for the conditions studied. The practice of maintaining reactive power reserves in three separate areas of the Dominion Energy South Carolina system ensures that reactive power sources are available to provide voltage support to V.C. Summer. The V. C. Summer 7.2 kV Engineered Safeguard Features (ESF) buses are supplied from the 230 kV and the 115 kV Offsite Power Supply buses. Protection from unacceptable voltage conditions is provided by Loss of Voltage and Degraded Voltage Relays that monitor the voltages of the 7.2 kV buses. The Loss of Voltage Relay scheme is modeled to operate after a 13.5 cycle (0.225 seconds) time delay at 82.00% of the nominal 7.2 kV bus voltage unless the voltage recovers to 82.75% during the time delay period of 0.225 seconds. The Degraded Voltage Relay scheme is set to operate after a 174.0 cycle (2.9 seconds) time delay at 91.75% of the nominal 7.2 kV bus voltage unless the voltage recovers to 92.328% during the 2.90 seconds time delay period. Because of the number of variables involving load tap changer settings and step change times, and ESF bus loads, no attempt has been made to report the voltages at the 7.2 kV ESF buses. Descriptions of loss of voltage and degraded voltage timer and relay operations assume that the per unit value of the 7.2 kV bus voltages are the same as those at the 230 kV and 115 kV Offsite Power Supply buses. The voltage results of the simulations are reported to V. C. Summer Design Engineering for use in calculations to determine acceptability of the voltage responses. DESC load under frequency and generator over frequency/under frequency responses as a result of the studied conditions were also identified. The VCS generator frequency responses were monitored and evaluated in order to assess whether the VCS generator reactor coolant pump under frequency or over frequency relays would trip for frequency excursions. CONCLUSIONS Each of the contingencies which were simulated for this study were evaluated for generator rotor angle, generator frequency deviation, tie line flows, system under frequency load shedding, under/over frequency tripping operations, and system voltage responses. In addition, the effects of each contingency on the 230 kV and 115 kV V. C. Summer Offsite Power Supply buses were examined as well as the resulting steady state power flows on the transmission lines which are connected to the V. C. Summer transmission substation. The generator rotor angle responses demonstrated that no conditions existed in which a generator would become unstable. None of the transmission lines connected to the V. C. Summer substation DESC system to neighboring systems remained in service throughout all conditions studied. No
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-10 conditions were found that would result in the islanding of the DESC system or neighboring systems. Generator and system frequency responses were all within the normal operating ranges and there was no indication of system under frequency load shedding or generator under I over frequency tripping, Reactor Protection System under frequency operation, or Reactor Coolant Pump under frequency tripping. The results of this study demonstrate that the DESC generating and transmission system is stable for the conditions that were studied. The contingencies were selected so as to test the capability and capacity of the 115 kV and 230 kV Offsite Power Supply buses at the V. C. Summer Station Unit 1 to supply the loads assigned in normal, abnormal, accident, or plant shutdown conditions. No contingency conditions were found to result in the simultaneous loss of both GDC 17 credited Offsite Power Supply buses. Also, no conditions were found to result in under frequency load shedding operations or generator under/over frequency tripping. In addition, no System Operating Limits (SOLs) or Interconnection Reliability Operating Limits (IROLs) were identified. Finally, there were no indications of voltage instability or stability limits. None of the contingencies that were simulated in this study indicated generator rotor angle instability would develop for generators in neighboring systems. 8.2.3 References
- 1. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Criteria for Class 1E Electric Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Stations, IEEE-308-1971.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-11 Table 8.2-1 Distances of Lines to First Major Substation Distance from Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station First Major Substation Terminal (miles) Denny Terrace 26.25 Pineland No. 1 24.4 Fairfield No. 1 1.24 Fairfield No. 2 1.24 Blythewood 20.0 VCS2 Bus 2 Tie 0.87 VCS2 Bus 3 Tie 0.91 Winnsboro 14.0 Killian 38.6 VCS2 Bus 1 Tie 1.0 Newport 55.62
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-12 Table 8.2-2 Allowable Variation in Offsite System Voltage Allowable Range of Offsite Voltage Transformer(s) Connected Buses (Kilo Volts) Unit Online Unit Online 115 kV Source 330 Mvar 484 Mvar Unit Offline XTF4 with XTF6 1DA(1) or 1DB (5) 105.5 to 131.3 106.4 to 131.3 102.3 to 131.3 XTF4 with XTF6 1DA and 1DB (3) 112.8 to 131.3 113.7 to 131.3 109.5 to 131.3 XTF4 and XTF5 1DA(2) or 1DB (2, 5) 113.4 to 119.8 113.4 to 119.8 109.3 to 119.8 XTF4 and XTF5 1DA and 1DB (2 3) 114.8 to 119.8 115.7 to 119.8 111.6 to 119.8 XTF4 or XTF5 1DA(2) or 1DB (5) 114.7 to 119.8 115.6 to 119.8 111.5 to 119.8 XTF4 or XTF5 1DA and 1DB (2, 3) 119.5 to 119.8 (4) 119.5 to 119.8 (4) 117.5 to 119.8 230kV Source XTF31 1DB(1) or 1DA(5) 225.7 to 239.6 228.4 to 239.6 218.3 to 239.6 XTF31 1DA and 1DB (3) 233.0 to 239.6 235.8 to 239.6 225.7 to 239.6 XTF31 1DB and 1C or 226.4 to 239.6 229.1 to 239.6 219.0 to 239.6 1DA and 1C (5) XTF31 1DA, 1DB, and 1C (3) 233.7 to 239.6 236.5 to 239.6 226.4 to 239.6 (1) Normal operating alignment (2) Used only if regulator is out of service (3) Maintenance only, LCO in effect, if in Modes 1-4 (4) Limit Mvar generation output to 170 Mvar (5) Alternate operating alignment
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-13 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-1 DRAWING E-747-035
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-14 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-2 DRAWING E-229-054
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-15 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-2a DRAWING E-229-001
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-16 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-2b DRAWING E-229-002
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-17 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-2c DRAWING E-229-003
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-18 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-2d DRAWING E-229-006
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-19 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-3 DRAWING E-206-011
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.2-20 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.2-4 DRAWING E-206-012
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-1 8.3 ONSITE POWER SYSTEMS 8.3.1 A-C Power Systems 8.3.1.1 Description The a-c power systems consist of the various auxiliary and engineered safety features electrical systems designed to provide reliable electrical power during all modes of station operation and under shutdown conditions. The a-c power systems are shown by Figures 8.2-3 and 8.2-4. The major electrical equipment is described in Table 8.3-1. Engineered safety features (ESF) auxiliaries are arranged so that loss of a single bus, for any reason, still leaves sufficient auxiliaries to safely perform required functions. In general, auxiliaries related to functions other than engineered safety features are connected to 3 auxiliary buses. A generator circuit breaker is provided to permit isolation of the generator from the system, which eliminates the necessity for a transfer from the emergency auxiliary transformer to the normal auxiliary transformer on plant startups. Engineered safety features loads are divided between 2 additional essential system buses in observance of the single failure criteria. Controls are provided in the control room for selected 7200 volt and 480 volt switchgear units. These units are selected to provide the operator with control of the distribution network and remote control of selected loads. 8.3.1.1.1 Plant Distribution Network
- 1. 7200 Volt Network The 7200 volt network is arranged in 5 medium voltage primary bus sections. There are 2 additional medium voltage bus sections located in the Service Water Pumphouse. Each of these 2 buses is fed as a stub bus from the related ESF primary bus. Each bus consists of a separate, metal clad type, dead front construction, rated 7.2 kV nominal (8.25 kV max) volt, 500 MVA switchgear assembly. Each circuit breaker cubicle is isolated from the adjacent cubicle by metal barriers. Interrupting ratings for the switchgear breakers are 66 kA momentary, and 41 kA symmetrical at 6.6 kV, or 37.8 kA symmetrical at 7.2 kV (based on the symmetrical rating of 33 kA at 8.25 kV). These interrupting ratings are greater than any of the fault current levels on the various buses. Control power for tripping and closing the switchgear is obtained from the station batteries.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-2 The 7200 volt buses 1A, 1B, and 1C supply power to non-safety-related auxiliaries. Each of these 3 buses supplies power to a reactor coolant pump. The normal power source for these buses is the main generator through the unit auxiliary transformer or back feed from the 230 kV bus through the main power transformer and unit auxiliary transformer. Upon tripping of the normal feeder breaker to these bus sections, the balance of plant (non-Class 1E) electrical system is automatically transferred to the emergency auxiliary transformers which are the emergency power sources. This automatic transfer is initiated when the normal feeder is tripped by main and unit transformer lockout relaying, generator differential protection relaying, generator and main transformer backup and field failure relaying, overall backup lockout relaying, and the condition of both the main transformer breaker and the generator breaker open. There is no automatic transfer when a bus over-current condition exists. Provisions are also available for manual transfer, as required. In addition to the protective relays discussed above, there are 3 undervoltage sensing relays (1 for each phase) and 1 underfrequency sensing relay connected for each reactor coolant pump. These devices provide the reactor coolant pump undervoltage trip signal described in Section 7.2.1.1.2, Item 4.b, and the reactor coolant pump underfrequency trip signal described in Section 7.2.1.1.2, Item 4.c. These relays, together with the potential transformers from which they receive a voltage signal, are located in the reactor protection undervoltage and underfrequency relay panel. This panel is housed in the Seismic Category 1 Intermediate Building. Power feeds to the reactor coolant pumps are routed through this panel. Therefore, the voltage signal is sensed on the pump side of the supply circuit breaker. To satisfy the single failure criteria, the panel is constructed in 3 sections, 1 section for each of the 3 reactor coolant pump power circuits. Each section is physically isolated from adjacent sections by a double, metal side sheet barrier. Any terminal blocks or fuse blocks mounted on a barrier side sheet are mounted on a polyester glass material. Polyester glass material is also placed under any wiring on a barrier side sheet. Thus, complete isolation of power cables, potential transformers and relays for each pump is maintained within the panel. The panel has been qualified to satisfy the requirements of IEEE-323 (Reference 11) and IEEE-344 (Reference 12). Electrical separation of circuits associated with the reactor protection inputs is in accordance with the criteria outlined in Section 8.3.1.4. The 7200 volt buses 1DA and 1DB supply power to the ESF equipment. These ESF buses provide an adequate and reliable source of electrical power for safe reactor shutdown under conditions resulting from any design basis event and/or during loss of offsite power, as well as for all modes of normal station operation. The normal and preferred power source for bus 1DA is the emergency auxiliary transformer XTF-4 in conjunction with the voltage regulator XTF-6. In the event that the voltage regulator is out of service, either or both of the 2 emergency auxiliary transformers, XTF-4 and XTF-5, can be used to supply bus 1DA. When the voltage regulator is out of service, parallel operation of the 2 transformers is preferred since it provides more flexibility and a greater range of allowable offsite voltage for the 115 kV system. The normal and preferred power source for bus 1DB is also the backup power supply for 1DA. In addition to the normal power sources, each 7200 volt ESF bus has an onsite emergency power source. The AAC source ties into the same plant bus (1DX) as the ESF transformers.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-3 The physical layout of the cable bus system for connecting the 2 power transformers (emergency auxiliary and safeguard transformers) and the voltage regulator or the AAC source to the 7.2 kV ESF buses is shown by Figures 8.3-0 through 8.3-0g. Figure 8.3-0b.1 shows the modifications to the bus shown in Figure 8.3-0b for the addition of the voltage regulator and its by-pass switches. Each onsite power source is capable of carrying the total ESF load required for safe shutdown. The onsite standby power system consists of 2 fully equipped diesel generators which provide 7200 volt power to buses 1DA and 1DB, respectively, within 10.25 seconds after detection of a loss of the associated preferred power sources by loss of voltage relays and 13 seconds after detection of a degraded voltage condition. Buses 1DA and 1DB are provided with a manually initiated transfer to the alternate offsite power source. Transfer switches are used to select power from 7.2 kV Channel A or Channel B sources for the C pump motors in the Service Water, Component Cooling and Safety Injection Systems. The switches are manually operated locally and are equipped with Kirk key interlock to prevent simultaneous closure of circuit breakers from both sources. Speed switches are used to control the 2 speed, single winding motors used for the 3 component cooling water pumps.
- 2. 480 Volt Network The 480 volt network distributes and controls power for all 480 volt and 120 volt a-c station demands. This network consists of 22 unit substations and 28 motor control centers. The unit substation switchgear is of metal clad, dead front construction, with 125 volt d-c operated air circuit breakers. Transformers for the 480 volt unit substations are air cooled and are directly connected to the switchgear. Except in special cases, motors rated above 50 hp to 350 hp are controlled directly by circuit breakers in the 480 volt switchgear. Motor control centers are used for control of motors 50 hp and smaller.
The maximum symmetrical interrupting capacity of the 480 volt motor control centers is 22,000 amperes. This interrupting capacity is greater than any of the fault levels on the motor control center buses. Current limiting reactors are provided in series with selected non-Class 1E motor control centers where the maximum symmetrical fault current that could otherwise occur at the motor control center would have exceeded 22,000 amperes. The maximum symmetrical interrupting capacity of the 480 volt unit substations is dependent upon the frame size of individual unit substation cubicles. In each case the interrupting capacity of a cubicle exceeds the maximum symmetrical fault current. Frame size rating and capacity is listed in Table 8.3-2.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-4
- a. Balance of Plant 480 Volt Network The balance of plant 480 volt network consists of 18 unit substations and 18 motor control centers. Fifteen (15) of the unit substations are 4 wire, consisting of transformers and metal clad switchgear; 3 are 3 wire, consisting of transformers and power distribution panels. The 3 wire 480 volt unit substations provide power to the pressurizer heaters. Two (2) of these unit substations are connected to redundant safety-related (Class 1E) buses.
These are loaded manually from the 7.2 Kv diesel generator buses 1DA and 1DB and furnish power to the 2 groups of heaters designated as backup groups. The third unit substation is connected to a balance-of-plant bus (1C) which powers the control group of heaters which are the normally energized heaters. Main feeder breakers for the 2 backup groups have been qualified in accordance with safety-grade equipment. Safety class heater cables and trays are protected by jet spray shields in the event of a PRT diaphragm rupture. Procedures for energizing the pressurizer heaters are addressed in Emergency Operating Procedures and System Operating Procedures as appropriate. These procedures describe (1) precautions to be observed if pressurizer heaters are to be used to prevent overloading diesel generators, (2) suggested loads to trim, (3) the time required to accomplish the connection. This time shall be consistent with the timely initiation and maintenance of natural circulation conditions. This meets the requirements of NUREG-0578, Section 2.1.1, Position 3.1. All motor control centers are fed by 4 wire unit substations. The unit substations receive power from 7200 volt balance of plant buses 1A, 1B, and 1C through 7200 - 480/277 volt transformers. Each motor control center has a separate feed from the 480 volt unit substations. Selected motor control centers are provided with automatic transfer to an alternate power source.
- b. Engineered Safety Features 480 Volt Network The ESF 480 volt network consists of 6 unit substations and 9 motor control centers. The 480 volt ESF buses are fed through transformers with 7200 volt primaries and 480/277 volt secondaries which feed motor control centers, motors, and miscellaneous loads.
These buses are independent from each other and there is neither automatic nor manual transfer capability. ESF 7200 - 480/277 volt transformers and switchgear are redundant and are located in separate areas of Seismic Category 1 structures to maintain isolation. ESF motor control centers are powered from the 480 volt ESF buses and have neither manual nor automatic transfer capability. The motor control centers are redundant and are located in separate areas of Seismic Category 1 structures or are separated by fire walls to maintain isolation. Under loss of offsite power conditions, power may be supplied to selected non-Class 1E 480 volt buses by the diesel generators. Equipment which is not safety-related but is considered essential for protection of the turbine or desired for convenience is manually activated by the operators.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-5 The voltage fluctuates on the preferred sources within the limits defined in Table 8.2-2, as described in Section 8.2.1. Appendix 8D discusses the analytical method used for determining the optimum tap settings for the step down transformers in the plant distribution network. Also, included in the appendix is a tabulation of, or a referenced calculation for, the calculated voltages at the 7.2 kV and 480 volt distribution levels in the plant during light and accident load conditions with power being supplied from the offsite sources. The voltage fluctuation will be less than those given in Appendix 8E during diesel generator operation as the diesels output is held to approximately + 0.5% of the voltage regulators setting, and the regulator is set within the range of + 2%, - 5% of 7.2 kV. The light and accident condition loads were determined to be the worst case loads. The results indicate that with the design tap settings the motors terminal voltages will remain within the design limits of +/- 10% of their rated voltages for the anticipated range of transmission system voltages. If a degraded voltage occurs, with the established relay setting, the lowest voltage which could exist at a motor terminal is 90.0% of rated voltage (460 volts) and at a motor control center bus is 87.71% of rated voltage (480 Volts). When the plant is at the startup stage and the design tap settings have been applied to the step down transformers, the voltages on the buses will be verified to ensure that they are not out of the range for proper equipment operation. Prior to fuel loading when the loads on the distribution system reflects the values to be expected during plant operation, the voltages and loads of the ESF system buses will be measured and the data used to verify the calculation of voltage levels. Appendix 8D discusses the calculation procedures and method of this verification of the calculation. Results were provided in a March 1, 1982 letter to the NRC. As part of the results, a tolerance study will be made and presented to show that the variations between the measured and calculated values are within the expected ranges. The voltages on the buses are monitored during plant operation and recorded as part of operator logs to verify the proper range for equipment operation. No load break, 480 volt a-c transfer switches are used to transfer power from 480 volt channel A or channel B sources for the motors for HVAC water chiller C and chilled water pump C. These switches are equipped with a walking beam interlock to prevent simultaneous closure of circuit breakers from both sources. 8.3.1.1.2 Onsite Standby Power Supplies The onsite standby a-c power supplies for Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station are 2, 12 cylinder, V configuration diesel engine driven generator sets. The generators operate at 514 rpm and provide 3 phase, 60 Hz, 7200 volt power. Each diesel generator has the following ratings:
- 1. Continuous, 4250 kW.
- 2. Short time, 4676 kW.
- 3. Overload (2000 hour), 4548 kW.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-6
- 4. Seven (7) days, 4676 kW.
- 5. Thirty (30) minutes, 5100 kW.
The diesel generators are located in a building designed to satisfy Seismic Category 1 requirements and to protect the diesel generators against tornadoes, hurricanes and missiles. Within this building, the diesel generators, including associated starting equipment and other auxiliaries, are completely isolated from one another by a wall designed to withstand a safe shutdown earthquake (SSE). Each diesel generator is provided with a separate, missile protected combustion air intake as shown by Figure 1.2-13 and a separate air discharge and engine exhaust. The diesel generators, together with associated fuel storage tanks, auxiliaries and related piping are designed to remain functional during an SSE and remain in a condition suitable for the performance of their function in shutting down and maintaining the plant in a safe condition. Essential subsystems for each of the diesel generators and the physical arrangement of these subsystems are discussed in Sections 9.5.4 through 9.5.8. 8.3.1.1.2.1 Deleted by Amendment 98-01, April 1998 8.3.1.1.2.2 Deleted by Amendment 98-01, April 1998 8.3.1.1.2.3 Deleted by Amendment 98-01, April 1998 8.3.1.1.2.4 Diesel Generator Operation Each 7200 volt ESF bus is continually energized from either the 230 kV or the 115 kV preferred power source transformer or from the onsite emergency diesel generators, as shown by Figures 8.2-2 and 8.2-3. The transfer from preferred power source to emergency diesel generator is accomplished automatically, when required, by the opening of the preferred power source air circuit breakers and closing of the emergency diesel generator air circuit breaker. The emergency buses and power supplies for all essential components are normally connected to the preferred offsite power sources. The emergency diesel generators are automatically started upon receipt of an undervoltage signal from the associated bus from either the loss of voltage relays or degraded voltage relays, or upon receipt of a safety injection signal. They are also started upon receipt of a manually initiated signal from the control room. Loss of voltage on an ESF bus opens the normal or alternate supply circuit breaker (whichever is closed) and, when emergency diesel generator voltage and frequency are established, closes the emergency power source circuit breaker. In the case of a safety injection signal and/or ESF bus undervoltage, the ESF loading sequencer (see Section 7.3.1 for a detailed discussion) trips selected bus loads including all non-Class 1E loads. The bus is then reloaded in the sequence shown in Table 8.3-3, Parts A1 and B1. Items indicated by 0 second loading sequence in Table 8.3-3 are not tripped and, therefore, are immediately loaded when the emergency power source circuit breaker is closed. All other required loads are loaded in sequence by the ESF loading sequencer.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-7 The 7.2 Kv ESF buses are each provided with 3 loss of voltage relays set at approximately 81% of the nominal bus voltage level and 3 degraded voltage relays set at approximately 91.34% of the nominal bus voltage level. Operation of a set of loss of voltage or degraded voltage relays will initiate a diesel generator start, a permissive for EFW turbine pump start, an ESF load sequence operation and a permissive for diesel generator circuit breaker close. These operations occur in a timed sequence as outlined in Table 8.3-5. The logic of the controls are illustrated in Figure 8.3-0o. As illustrated in Table 8.3-5 the 7.2 Kv bus circuit breakers are tripped 4 seconds after the diesel generator is started on a degraded voltage condition as compared to 2 seconds for a loss of voltage condition. The delay in tripping for a degraded voltage condition allows the bus to be energized during the time the diesel generator is coming up to speed. Therefore, with the degraded voltage condition, the maximum dead bus time is 6 seconds as compared to a 10.25 seconds dead bus time allowed for a loss of voltage condition. Appendix 8F provides a discussion of the time sequence of equipment operation with a degraded voltage condition coincident with an accident condition. When the diesel generators are started and loaded as a result of an undervoltage condition, the ESF loading sequencer logic prevents further undervoltage tripping of the safety related loads. When the buses are returned to the offsite power sources, the undervoltage tripping feature is automatically reinstated. The emergency diesel generators and normal station service are synchronized only during periodic testing. Synchronizing capability is provided to reconnect the emergency diesel generators to the offsite power network when voltage is restored subsequent to the loss of offsite power. Synchronization is performed manually, when required. ESF equipment is duplicated on separate 7200 volt and 480 volt (as appropriate) buses as listed in Table 8.3-3, Parts A1 and B1. All equipment does not start simultaneously but is programmed to start automatically in sequenced steps. The first group, indicated by 0 load sequence seconds in Table 8.3-3, Parts A1 and B1, is connected to the ESF buses when the buses are energized. During recovery from step load increase, or from disconnection of the complete load, emergency diesel generator speed change will not exceed 75% of the difference between nominal speed and the overspeed trip setpoint or 115% of nominal speed, whichever is lower. Voltage is restored to within 10% and frequency to within 2% of the nominal values in less than 40% of each load sequence time interval. This complies with Regulatory Guide 1.9 (see Appendix 3A). Subsequent groups are each connected in sequence after short time delays. The load profile after an accident, without offsite power, is generally outlined by Table 8.3-3, Parts A1 and B1. At no time following an accident will the load exceed the short time rating (110% of the continuous rating) of the diesel generators nor is it expected that the load will fall below 30% of the diesel generator rating. In the event of an accident with offsite power available, the diesel generators will start and run at no load. Should a subsequent loss of offsite power occur, the diesel generators would be loaded automatically. If offsite power is not subsequently lost, the diesel generators would continue to run at no load until manually stopped by the operator.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-8 The injection phase of a loss of coolant accident should not exceed 1 hour and the short term phase of a main steam line break accident is estimated to be 2 hours. Therefore, it is expected that both diesel generators can be stopped within 4 hours after an accident if offsite power is available. If the diesel generators are operated at no load or less than 20% load for a period of time longer than 4 hours, operating procedures will require paralleling of each machine with the bus and loading the generator to at least 50% of rated load. Only 1 diesel generator will be paralleled with a bus at a time. Criteria discussed are conservative with respect to the manufacturers recommendations (see Colt Industries, Fairbanks Morse Engine Division, Operating and Maintenance Manual, South Carolina Electric and Gas Co., Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station - Unit 1, Standby Diesel Generator Set, Colt-13-206152, Chapter 1, Tab 1, page 5-1) which, in part, are as follows: In the event it is necessary to operate the engine for extended periods of time (over 24 hrs.) at from no load up to 20% of the engine rating, the engine should run at above 50% load for at least 1 hour in each 24 hour period in order to minimize the accumulation of products of combustion and lubricating products in the exhaust systems. Above 20% load rating, the engine may run continuously as required with the recommendation that the engine parameters be monitored closely and logged at least daily so as to be able to discover any problems early. (Changes in exhaust temperatures are of particular interest.) 8.3.1.1.2.5 Diesel Generator Permissives After the emergency diesel generator has received a starting signal, the following conditions must be satisfied before the generator is automatically connected to the ESF bus:
- 1. The diesel generator must be at approximately 90% of rated voltage and approximately 98%
of rated frequency, based upon 2 out of 3 relaying schemes in each case.
- 2. The ESF bus normal and alternate power supply circuit breakers must be open.
- 3. There must be no electrical faults in the 7200 volt bus.
Figures 8.3-0h through 8.3-0j present diesel generator logic diagrams. Logic diagrams for the bus 1DA normal and alternate power supply circuit breakers are shown by Figures 8.3-0K and 8.3-0l. The bus 1DB normal and alternate supply circuit breakers use similar control schemes. 8.3.1.1.2.6 Diesel Generator Testing The diesel generators are tested as follows at the manufacturers plant prior to shipment to the plant site:
- 1. The diesel generators are initially started and run in accordance with the manufacturers standard procedure which includes the following:
- a. Operation at reduced RPM for approximately 50 minutes.
- b. Operation at rated RPM and variable load for approximately 6-1/2 hours.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-9
- 2. The engine overspeed setting is tested and operation at 115% overspeed is demonstrated.
- 3. Diesel generator starting system capacity is demonstrated.
- 4. Diesel generator speed governing system is tested for steady state and transient performance, including load rejection tests at 25, 50, 75, and 100% of rated load.
- 5. The diesel generators are started and automatically loaded with a combination of resistive and inductive loads to simulate design loading conditions for the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. This test is performed 10 times on each diesel generator.
- 6. The ability of the diesel generators to start and accept load without service water flow and without 480 volt auxiliary power is demonstrated.
- 7. The starting margin of each diesel generator is demonstrated by simultaneously starting and accelerating a 1750 horsepower motor and a 500 horsepower motor with the generator carrying a resistive load of approximately 50% of rated capacity.
- 8. Operation of the diesel generator in parallel with a utility system is demonstrated.
- 9. The diesel generators are operated at variable load for a total of 11 hours, including 3 hours at 100% of rated load followed by 2 hours at 110% of rated load.
Certified evidence is supplied by the manufacturer of the diesel generators that a total of 300 start and load tests, with a maximum of 3 failures, have been performed on a diesel generator of the design supplied for Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. Each start and load test consisted of starting the diesel generator and applying load within 10 seconds after the start signal, increasing load to at least 50% of the continuous rating within 30 seconds and operating under load for a minimum of 5 minutes. Some of these tests are initiated from design cold ambient conditions (keep warm temperatures) and some from hot equilibrium temperature conditions. Tests and inspections are performed to ensure that all components are properly mounted, connections are correct, circuits are continuous and components are operational. Tests are performed to ensure that emergency loads do not exceed diesel generator rating and that each diesel generator is suitable for starting and operating required loads. Proper operation of the onsite standby power supply is tested periodically. An availability test is performed periodically when the plant is in operation. Only 1 diesel generator is tested at a given time. The test consists of a manually initiated start of the diesel generator, followed by manual synchronization with and connection to the station ESF buses and assumption of load by the diesel generators. Normal station operation is not affected by this test. The operational test, automatic starting, load shedding and loading of the diesel generators, initiated by a simulated loss of voltage on the ESF buses are performed normally during reactor shutdown for refueling. Preoperational testing according to Regulatory Guide 1.41 is discussed in Chapter 14 and Appendix 3A.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-10 8.3.1.1.2.7 Deleted by Amendment 98-01, April 1998 8.3.1.1.2.8 Instrumentation and Control Systems Control power required for operation of each diesel generator is supplied from the 125 volt d-c distribution system. Control power for the diesel generator breaker to the ESF bus is supplied from the 125 volt d-c distribution system associated with the corresponding ESF bus. Controls are provided locally and in the control room for manual start and stop of each diesel generator. An automatic control system is provided for automatic startup and adjustment of speed and voltage to a ready-to-load condition. A start diesel signal overrides all other operating modes and immediately returns the controls for the diesel generator to the emergency mode except under the following conditions:
- 1. Engine tripped due to overspeed.
- 2. Engine tripped due to low lube oil pressure.
- 3. Generator tripped due to generator differential relay operation.
- 4. When maintenance is in progress.
A matrix arrangement is provided for tripping the diesel generator for low lube oil pressure. This matrix consists of 4 pressure relays set at 70, 65, 60, and 60 psi. To cause a diesel generator trip due to low lube oil pressure, 2 of the low pressure switches must be activated and at least 1 of the 2 activated switches must be 1 of the 2 with 60 psi setpoints. The other protective functions for the diesel generator are able to cause a diesel generator trip only during testing. Under emergency conditions, these protective functions actuate alarms only and do not trip the diesel generator. Table 8.3-3a is a list of the protective devices provided for the diesel generators. This list also includes the function of these devices under emergency start and test start conditions. Also, the engine manual stop pushbutton cannot override an ESF signal. Instrumentation is provided locally and in the control room to monitor diesel generator frequency, voltage, loading and circuit breaker position. Alarms are provided locally for all critical variables and trip functions as shown in Figure 8.3-0n. The local annunciator provides first out indication to aid in determining the cause of any trips or malfunctions. Alarms and status indication are also provided in the control room as shown in Figure 8.3-0m to indicate diesel generator status and permit remote operation of the diesel generators. Most of the instrumentation is designed and installed to permit inplace calibration. Logic diagrams for the diesel generator starting and shutdown controls are presented by Figures 8.3-0h and 8.3-0i.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-11 8.3.1.1.2.9 Diesel Generator Environment Combustion air for the diesel generators is taken directly from the outside through an intake which is completely independent of the ventilation air intake. The bottom of the ventilation air intake is located 29 feet above grade, as shown in the Figures 1.2-13 and 1.2-14. This high elevation will minimize the amount of dust taken in by the ventilation system. In addition, all cabinets containing control relays and associated devices have gasketed doors and openings. Therefore, the ventilation system will introduce a minimum of dust into the building and the controls are protected from whatever dust does enter the building. There are several elements which interact to assure the cleanliness of the Diesel Generator Room and the supportive electronic and electrical components contained therein. They are as follows:
- 1. All electrical and electric component cabinets are weather sealed with rubber gaskets and have filtering media provided where air is circulated through the cabinets.
- 2. The Diesel Generator Building is to be designated as a Cleanliness Zone IV, which requires periodic inspections, specifically for cleanliness.
- 3. The mandatory surveillances for assuring the diesels ability to start are supported by a periodic preventive maintenance task which requires inspection of the electrical and electronic components to determine operability and condition. Cleanliness is one of the areas that is inspected during the performance of the preventive maintenance task.
8.3.1.1.3 120 Volt A-C Vital Bus System Six (6) 120 volt a-c vital buses are provided. Each of 4 buses is supplied by 1 of 4 single phase static inverters. The normal feed to Panel APN5907 is from APN5901. The normal feed to Panel APN5908 is from APN 5903. One (1) Channel A and 1 Channel D inverters are connected to ESF battery 1A, and 1 Channel B and 1 Channel E inverters are connected to ESF battery 1B. The 120 volt a-c vital buses constitute a reliable electrical system which provides a stable power supply to vital equipment and guarantees proper action when power is required while eliminating spurious shutdowns. Controls for the backup groups of heaters, the pressurizer level transmitters and for the pressurizer relief block valve operators receive their power from this vital a-c bus source through the emergency power buses. The control power for the block valves is supplied from an emergency power bus different from that which supplies the associated PORV. Safety grade circuit breakers and fuses are used for circuit protection. The normal source of power for the 120 volt a-c vital bus inverters is through the inverter static rectifier. These inverter rectifiers are fed from 480 volt buses 1DA2 and 1DB2. The station batteries and battery chargers constitute the standby power source. The battery chargers are fed from 480 volt buses 1DA2 and 1DB2. In the event of loss of 480 volt power, the power source for the vital bus inverters is the station batteries. These batteries are floating, on standby service. The change in power source, from normal to standby, occurs without exceeding the stated inverter
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-12 output voltage and frequency regulation. The station batteries are sized to carry this additional inverter load without being charged for no less than 4 hours. The battery chargers are sized to recharge from a design minimum charge to full charge in 12 hours while carrying the largest combined demand from the various steady-state loads. An alternate power supply for the 120 volt a-c vital buses is provided through 480-120 volt transformers from 480 volt buses 1DA2 and 1DB2 for use when the inverters are out of service. 8.3.1.1.4 Equipment Criteria
- 1. Motor Size The criterion for motor size is that the motor develops sufficient horsepower to drive the mechanical load under maximum expected flow and pressure. Motors are sized to permit the driven equipment to develop its specified capacity without exceeding the temperature rise rating of the motor when operated at the duty cycle of the driven equipment. Motors are furnished with service factors ranging from 1.0 to 1.15. The service factor is a ratio of the safe load to the nameplate load and identifies the margin available for motor operation under overload conditions. When a motor is furnished with a service factor greater than 1.0, it is the design intent to size the motor to handle the normal operating requirements of the driven equipment without taking credit for the service factor. Motor size is determined based on the driven equipment load characteristics.
- 2. Engineered Safety Features Motor Starting Torque Motors are designed for across the line starting. ESF motors rated 6900 volts are capable of accelerating the driven equipment to rated speed at 70% of the motor nameplate voltage. ESF motors rated 460 volts are capable of accelerating the driven equipment to rated speed at 80% of rated voltage. The motors are designed to operate at +/- 10% of rated voltage, +/- 5% of rated frequency or a combined variation in voltage and frequency of +/- 10% of absolute values, provided that frequency variation does not exceed +/- 5% of rated frequency.
Calculations based on the diesel generator factory test data indicate that the motor terminal voltage during starting will not go below 90% of the rated voltage for 6,900 volt motors or below 82% for 460 volt motors. The motor terminal voltage for the 6900 volt motors was calculated using the diesel generator voltage regulation for starting of a 1750 Hp motor. The motor terminal voltage for the 460 volt motors was calculated using the diesel generator voltage regulation for starting a 500 Hp motor and considering the voltage drop through the 7200/480 volt transformers. The actual largest system motors are 900 Hp and 350 Hp for the 7200 volt and 480 volt systems respectively (Refer to Appendix 8E). These voltage levels are well above those allowed by Regulatory Guide 1.9. The adequacy of bus voltage regulation during motor starting is confirmed during the preoperational testing program.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-13
- 3. Motor Insulation Motor insulation is a minimum of Class B outside the Reactor Building and Class F inside the Reactor Building. The insulation temperature rating is greater than the sum of the motor temperature rise and the ambient temperature at the motor location.
Service life is extended when necessary by 1, or a combination, of the following methods:
- a. Derating - use of a larger motor than required by the motor sizing criteria previously discussed.
- b. Insulation type - use of motor insulation with a higher temperature limit than specified for the operating conditions (e.g., specifying Class F insulation to Class B temperature limitations).
- c. Service factor - motors with 1.15 service factor are operated under normal conditions without encroaching upon the service factor.
- 4. Engineered Safety Features Motor Temperature Protection ESF motors rated 6900 volts and 600 Hp and larger are provided with 6 stator winding embedded, resistance type, 10 ohm, copper at 25°C, resistance temperature detectors (RTDs). Smaller horsepower motors are not equipped with stator RTDs due to the problems involved in embedding them in the stator. The exceptions are the 400 Hp reactor building spray pump motors which do have stator RTDs.
Motors rated 6900 volts and selected 460 volt motors are provided with bearing thermocouples. Outputs from each of the 2 motor temperature measuring devices are routed to the plant computer which actuates an alarm and provides a printed output if the stator RTD or bearing thermocouple measured value exceeds a predetermined setpoint.
- 5. Interrupting Capacity Switchgear, unit substations, motor control centers and distribution panels are sized for interrupting capacity greater than the maximum short circuit availability at their location.
The calculations to document this application take into account the fault contributions of all rotating machines and source transformers. Source impedances are selected to ensure adequate starting voltage for all motors and to limit short circuit currents at unit substation buses and motor control center buses.
- 6. Network Protection Each major motor or other major item of electrical equipment is protected by overcurrent relays that disconnect the equipment if the load current becomes excessive. Prior to plant operation protective relays are set and calibrated. Availability and proper operation of standby equipment are periodically tested during normal operation.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-14 The protection philosophy for the 7200 volt and 480 volt systems is based upon the following considerations:
- a. A faulted piece of equipment is cleared by isolating the smallest possible portion of the system.
- b. A faulted piece of equipment is cleared in the minimum possible time to reduce damage to that equipment and limit the stress on the remainder of the system.
- c. Protective devices are selected and set for fault sensing and overload sensing as required for applicable system/component protection.
- d. Motor control centers that serve loads located inside the Reactor Building typically have starters, (with thermal overloads) magnetic molded case circuit breakers, and a current limiting circuit breaker in series. The current limiting circuit breakers have thermal and magnetic elements incorporated in their protection circuit. Loads that do not require a starter, that use a contactor without overload protection, or have overloads bypassed under accident conditions, or are mentioned in Section 8.3.1.4.1; have an additional thermal element provided in the molded case circuit breaker. This arrangement provides primary and backup protection in compliance with Regulatory Guide 1.63 (see Appendix 3A).
- e. Overload elements provided for safety-related valve operators are bypassed under accident conditions by the safety injection signal contact that initiates the valve operation.
This is in compliance with Regulatory Guide 1.106 (see Appendix 3A).
- 7. Grounding Requirements Design criteria for grounding of safety-related systems are as follows:
- a. All equipment hardware, exposed surfaces and potential induced voltage hazards are adequately grounded to assure that no danger to plant personnel exists.
- b. A low impedance ground return path is provided to facilitate the operation of ground fault detection or protective devices in the event of ground fault or insulation failure on any electrical load or circuit.
The following are the methods for grounding electrical equipment:
- a. A ground wire is connected to the equipment frame and the ground grid. The ground wire is run through the equipment conduit or lashed to the power cable for the equipment where no conduit is provided. The wire is either connected directly to the ground grid or to other equipment, such as a cable tray which is connected to the grounding grid.
- b. Where conduit is used as the grounding path, the conduit is connected to the equipment and the grounding grid. The connection to the grounding grid is either a direct connection or is connected to other equipment such as a cable tray which is connected to the grounding grid.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-15 The cable tray system is solidly grounded. Ground connections are made to the station grounding grid or building steel work, which is connected to the station grounding grid. The station grounding grid is designed to maintain the station area at an effective ground potential during a worst case ground fault in any installed electrical equipment, including transmission facilities and unit main generators, as well as lightning effects. An effective ground is considered to be the maintenance of voltage potentials below a safe touch level for plant personnel.
- 8. Maintenance Program A maintenance program, in accordance with the recommendations of the manufacturers, is followed. This program includes periodic visual inspection and lubrication for each motor. A record is maintained for each motor indicating the date when each action is performed.
- 9. Starter Voltages Starter coils for motor control centers are designed to pull in at 85% of rated voltage and to hold in at 65% of rated voltage. The coils are energized through a 480/120 volt instrument transformer.
- 10. Heat tracing is provided for Nuclear Safety Related and Non-Nuclear Safety Related equipment, piping, and/or tubing for the purpose of process temperature maintenance and freeze protection of liquids and for prevention of condensation in instrument air lines.
The heat tracing equipment protecting Safety Related systems (i.e., reactor makeup water storage tank and piping, refueling water storage tank and piping, and sodium hydroxide) includes redundant centralized control panels, temperature measuring equipment, wiring and conduit, and heat tracing cables, except for the refueling water storage tank and reactor makeup water storage tank. These tanks are monitored by redundant temperature instrumentation and are provided with 1 set of heat tracing each. Based upon the thermal capacity and insulated design of these tanks, the redundant instrumentation provides adequate operator control to prevent freezing. The centralized control panels provide power distribution, control and alarm functions from signals received from temperature measuring equipment attached to the piping systems. The primary and redundant heat trace circuits are each designed with the capability to provide the necessary freeze protection, or maintain the necessary process temperature. In the event of a failure to the primary heat trace circuit, the redundant heat trace circuit provides the necessary heat trace function. The heat tracing cables are of the parallel self-limiting type. The centralized control panels are powered from Class 1E Channel A and Channel B motor control centers. Alarms are transmitted to the control room from a local annunciator panel.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-16 8.3.1.2 Analysis 8.3.1.2.1 Compliance Analysis The basic design criteria are that the Class 1E electric power systems satisfy the single failure criterion and Regulatory Guide 1.32 (see Appendix 3A). The safety-related loads are assigned to 2 independent, separate 7200 volt ESF buses. Either of these buses is capable of supplying required ESF or shutdown loads. Each of these buses is continuously energized from the preferred source ESF transformer(s), 1 set of windings in emergency auxiliary transformer (XTF-31), or from 1 of the diesel generators. Each 7200 volt ESF bus serves as a power source for the safety-related loads on the 480 volt buses and for equipment which is not safety-related but is considered essential for protection of the turbine or desired for convenience. This design, including the ties to the non-ESF buses, satisfies the independence and redundancy requirements of Regulatory Guide 1.6 (see Appendix 3A) and General Design Criterion 17. The main control board is provided with indicators to monitor the ESF bus operating levels. A voltmeter, ammeter, wattmeter, varmeter and kilowatt hour meter are provided on each of the incoming, preferred power sources. The onsite power source has a voltmeter, frequency meter, wattmeter and ammeter provided on the main control board to indicate the ESF bus operating levels. Figures 8.2-3 and 8.2-4 indicate the metering provided on the plant electrical system. Table 8.3-3b is a listing of the indicator types associated with the ESF electrical network. The ESF buses have sufficient redundancy to allow testing of each safety-related item as a system, or in some cases as individual components to comply with General Design Criteria 17 and 18. Two (2) diesel generators provide onsite power to the 7200 volt ESF buses. Each diesel generator is assigned exclusively to 1 bus and each is automatically started upon a loss of bus voltage, degradation of bus voltage or receipt of a safety injection actuation signal. Under conditions outlined in Section 7.3.1, normal loads, with the exception of the group indicated by 0 seconds in Table 8.3-3 Parts A1 and B1, are disconnected and the ESF loads are automatically loaded in sequence on each diesel generator in accordance with the sequence presented in Table 8.3-3. If a loss of preferred power is not concurrent with a postulated accident, certain ESF equipment is not required. Under these conditions, other plant auxiliary equipment may be manually operated. Safety injection loads are sequenced on by the load sequencer in this case, but loads are not disconnected prior to the sequencing. Instrumentation is provided to indicate emergency diesel generator loading. The onsite standby power supply complies with Regulatory Guide 1.9, including load limits, (see Appendix 3A). The diesel generators have a continuous rating of 4250 kw, a short time rating of 4676 kw for up to 7 days, and a 30 minute rating of 5100 kw. The limiting accident load is calculated to be 4390 kw and the maximum load under loss of offsite power conditions is calculated to be 4920 kw. These short time and continuous rating loads are verified by test during each periodically. (The largest bus connected load is calculated to be approximately 5450 kVA.)
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-17 8.3.1.2.2 Hostile Environments 8.3.1.2.2.1 Equipment Identification The most severe environmental conditions expected to be imposed upon the equipment which would operate inside and outside the Reactor Building during normal operation and subsequent to a LOCA or main steam line break are presented in Section 3.11. Regulatory Guide 1.89 is discussed in Appendix 3A. 8.3.1.2.2.2 Loss of Ventilation To ensure that loss of the air conditioning and/or ventilation systems does not adversely affect the operability of safety-related control and electrical equipment located throughout the plant, the environmental systems for these areas satisfy the single failure criterion. Section 9.4 presents a detailed discussion of ventilation systems. Section 3.11.4 discusses loss of ventilation. 8.3.1.2.2.3 Qualification Tests See Section 3.11 for a discussion of the hostile environment for which electrical equipment is procured and the maximum DBA environmental conditions to which it may be subjected. 8.3.1.3 Conformance with Appropriate Quality Assurance Standards The quality assurance procedures used during equipment design, fabrication, shipment, field storage, field installation and system and component checkout and the records pertaining to each of these during the construction and preoperational test phases are described in Chapter 17. The Quality Assurance Program, as discussed in Chapter 17, is in conformance with IEEE-336 (Reference 1). 8.3.1.4 Independence of Redundant Systems 8.3.1.4.1 Criteria for Independence of Redundant Electric Systems The electrical power supply, control and instrument cables for mutually redundant equipment are physically separated to preserve the redundancy and to ensure that no single, credible event will prevent operation of the associated function because of electrical conductor damage. Critical circuits and functions include power, control and instrumentation associated with reactor protection, ESF and reactor shutdown. Credible events include, but are not limited to, the effects of short circuits, pipe ruptures, fires, earthquakes, and missiles. The minimum electrical separation required for protection against design basis accidents is included in the basic plant design. The separation of electrical circuits has been reviewed to the criteria of IEEE 384 (Reference 14) as modified by Regulatory Guide 1.75 (see Appendix 3A). The plant design complies with these criteria as described below:
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-18
- 1. Redundant Class 1E circuits are run in separate and independent raceways. In general plant areas, not subject to hazards, such as missiles, open ventilated cable trays for redundant circuits are separated by a minimum of 3 feet horizontally or 5 feet vertically. In cable spreading rooms open ventilated cable trays are separated by a minimum of 1 foot horizontally or 3 feet vertically. Totally enclosed raceways for redundant circuits are separated by a minimum of 1 inch. Where these separation criteria cannot be satisfied, suitable barriers are placed between the raceways. The design of these barriers is described in Appendix 8B.
- 2. In areas where redundant circuits are exposed to hazards, such as missiles, the minimum spacing between mutually redundant wireways is 20 feet. Where this spacing cannot be achieved, a suitable missile proof barrier is used to ensure that no common hazard could render more than 1 mutually redundant circuit inoperative. Barriers have been provided to protect trays for Class 1E circuits from the effects of jet impingement and piping is restrained to prevent pipe whip as described in Section 3.6.
- 3. Where non-Class 1E circuits are connected to Class 1E equipment or are routed in the same raceways with Class 1E circuits, they are designated as associated circuits. Circuits designated as associated are routed with the designated separation channel throughout their length. Where non-Class 1E circuits are connected to Class 1E equipment, an isolation device is provided to protect the Class 1E equipment. These isolation devices are further discussed in Appendix 3A under the discussion of Regulatory Guide 1.75.
- 4. Non-Class 1E circuits are routed in raceways independent from the raceways for Class 1E circuits. Where the separation between the raceways for non-Class 1E circuits and raceways for Class 1E circuits do not satisfy the criteria for raceways carrying redundant Class 1E circuits, as described in Item 1, above, a case by case analysis has been performed to ensure that adequate separation exists. This analysis reviewed 2 types of violations, single and multiple. Single violations are those in which a non-1E tray violates the minimum separation required at one point along its path. These cases are summarized in Appendix 8C. A multiple violation is defined as a non-Class 1E tray which violates the minimum separation required at 1 point, and then, within the same fire area, the same non-Class 1E tray violates another Class 1E tray which is of a redundant channel to the initial 1E tray. For identified multiple violations in control (4000 series) trays, tray covers have been provided between the non-Class 1E tray and one of the Class 1E trays. The remaining violation is then analyzed as a single violation (Appendix 8C). For power trays (1000, 2000 and 3000 series) which cannot be covered, periodic testing of certain cable protective devices is performed in accordance with a controlled breaker surveillance program. This testing ensures that adequate overcurrent protection exists for the cables in the non-Class 1E trays so that they cannot be a hazard to the Class 1E trays whose separation distance has been violated. The results of the analysis for identified multiple violations are summarized in the Fire Barriers Raceway Database.
All 5000 series instrument trays are deemed as acceptable barriers for multiple violations without the use of top hats, Kaowool, or any other fire related enhancements. Because of this, multiple violations in which 1 or more of the trays involved were 5000 series were classified as single or no violations as appropriate.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-19
- 5. The Class 1E circuits routed to the service water intake structure are installed in underground concrete duct banks. These duct banks are seismic Category 1 structures and, as such, are designed to protect the cables from postulated natural phenomena, including SSE. The layout of the duct banks and associated manholes is illustrated by Figures 8.3-2a through 8.3-2g.
- 6. Separation of safety-related circuits is maintained in the electrical penetrations of the Reactor Building. Circuits for nuclear and protection instrumentation are not mixed with other type circuits in the same penetration. The redundant circuits for the 4 nuclear and protection instrumentation channels enter containment through penetrations located around the periphery with a minimum horizontal separation of 20 feet, centerline to centerline, between any 2 channels (see Figure 8.3-3). Physical separation between penetrations containing redundant circuits, other than the 4 nuclear instrument channels, is maintained in accordance with Section 8.3.1.4.3, Item 2.
The 4 penetrations containing the nuclear and protection instrumentation are provided with metal barriers. The metal barriers are used to separate the nuclear and protection instrumentation. These barriers are grounded and are arranged to provide an effective electromagnetic shield over the full length of the penetration assembly. Structural criteria require that penetrations be spaced on minimum horizontal and vertical centerlines as shown by Figure 8.3-3. This provides a 3 foot minimum separation between any electrical penetration and any other type of penetration. The design objective is to maintain maximum separation between safety related electrical penetrations and any large piping penetrations to minimize mechanical damage from the postulated rupture of steam or water lines. The design objective is also to maintain maximum separation between any safety-related penetrations and large power penetrations, such as those for reactor coolant pump or pressurizer heater power cables. Separation of safety-related electrical penetrations from main steam lines is maintained by a concrete floor or a minimum horizontal distance of 40 feet. One (1) exception is the penetrations for the power feeds to the Channel A Reactor Building cooling unit fans. The main steam lines and cooling unit fan power feeds both penetrate the Reactor Building above the operating floor. A 20 foot minimum separation is maintained between these penetrations. Separation from any other steam, high pressure water or large power electrical penetration is maintained by a concrete floor or by an 8 foot minimum horizontal centerline separation.
- 7. Cable trays, conduits and cables are marked for ready identification of the channel and to guard against violation of separation. Specific color coding is discussed in Section 8.3.1.5.
- 8. SP-834, Electrical Construction Guideline for Electrical Circuit Physical Separation, and Electrical Maintenance Procedure EMP-405.012, Guide for Electrical Physical Separation, identify the minimum separation guidelines for internal wiring and components within control boards, panels, relay racks, etc. A minimum separation distance of 6 inches between redundant components and/or wiring and between Class 1E and non-Class 1E components and/or wiring within the enclosures is required. Where 6 inches of air separation is not available, a suitable fire barrier is installed or an analysis is performed to demonstrate that
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-20 the separation distance is adequate. Design exceptions to the separation guidelines are addressed in Attachment 1 to SP-834. 8.3.1.4.2 Compliance with Criteria for Independence of Redundant Electric Systems A discussion of the administrative responsibility and control provided to ensure compliance with the criteria, set forth in Section 8.3.1.4.1, during design and installation is presented in Chapter 17. 8.3.1.4.3 Criteria for Design and Installation of Electrical Cable The recommendations of IEEE Proposed Guide P-422, (Reference 3) IEEE STD 384, (Reference 14) and Regulatory Guide 1.75 (see Appendix A) are used, except as modified by Items 1 through 6, below, as the general design criteria for the design of the power, control and instrument cable and cable tray systems related to all Class 1E electrical systems.
- 1. Power cable capacities are determined using derating factors listed in IPCEA P-46-426, (Reference 4) supplemented by IPCEA-NEMA P54-440. (Reference 5) Cable derating and cable tray fill are discussed in Section 8.3.3.1.
- 2. Cable routing in the Reactor Building, penetration areas, cable spreading room, control room, etc., is arranged following the recommendations in IEEE Proposed Guide P-422.
(Reference 3) Channel separation and cable tray physical separation requirements are maintained in these areas in accordance with Section 8.3.1.4.1, item 6. Cables which must enter areas surrounded by shield walls are routed to minimize the cable length within the shields area.
- 3. Fire and/or smoke detection equipment is installed in areas of heavy cable concentration, as recommended by IEEE Proposed Guide P-422. (Reference 3) Fire stops are provided at cable tray penetrations through floors and fire barrier walls.
- 4. An exception is taken to IEEE Proposed Guide P-422 (Reference 3) recommendations for 30% cable tray fill. Experience has indicated that a design objective of 50% physical fill, including all anticipated future cables, is satisfactory. This fill calculation is based upon the summation of the cable diameter squared divided by the cross-sectional area in the tray. The tables referred to in Item 1, above, are used as the basis for ampacity rating. The allowable depth is determined from the physical fill calculations outlined above and in Section 8.3.3.1.
- 5. The design objective for the minimum physical vertical spacing between the power, control and instrument cable trays of the same redundant channel is 12 inches, measured from the top of the lower tray to the bottom of the upper tray and a 9 inch clearance between the top of a tray and beams, piping, etc., to facilitate installation of cables in the tray. However, in areas where physical limitations govern, the physical separation may be less than the 12 inches and 9 inches, respectively.
- 6. The same basic design considerations are incorporated for tray and conduit supports as for the structures to which they are attached. Therefore, the same supports can be used for redundant raceways or for a redundant and non-safety raceway.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-21 8.3.1.5 Physical Identification of Safety-Related Equipment Identification of cable and raceways is readily apparent in the design and installation stages and is such that any safety-related cable can be readily identified. Raceways and cables (particularly for redundant systems) are adequately identified to prevent violation of separation criteria. Channel identification for safety-related and associated circuits is based upon the 4 reactor protection process control channel colors: red, orange, blue, and yellow. In addition, green is used for C train and tan is used for non-safety-related circuits. Cable trays and cables for these circuits, as well as for power, control and instrumentation circuits for ESF Channels A and B are identified relative to the 6 colors as indicated in Table 8.3-4. Cable identification is as follows:
- 1. Color coding Cables are marked at 5 foot intervals. The circumference of the cable is marked such that the marking is visible no matter how the cable is turned.
- 2. Tagging Tags are placed at each end of the cable. These tags are marked to indicate the circuit and channel. Any nonengineered safety feature cables in a safety-related tray are marked to distinguish them from the safety-related cables.
- 3. Conduits Conduits are marked with identification markers. Color coding is done with colored tape at 15 foot intervals. Tags for embedded conduit are attached to the concrete above the conduit.
- 4. Cable Trays Cable trays for safety-related cables are identified with tags. The color coded tags are located on the trays so they are visible from easily accessible vantage points, such as walkways, etc.
- 5. Equipment Identification Each piece of equipment has an identification (ID) tag attached which identifies the equipment. Channel designation for safety related and associated equipment is identified by a strip of color coded tape.
Tags mounted on equipment inside the Reactor Building are of stainless steel and have the required information engraved. Where there is not room to mount the tag to the equipment, it will be attached by wire. In these cases, the color coded tape will be attached to the back of the tag. Stainless steel ID tags are also used outside the Reactor Building. Tags for associated equipment have 2 colors.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-22 8.3.1.6 Electrical Penetration Areas Electrical penetration areas are located as follows:
- 1. Fuel Handling Building penetration area (penetration access area - North). Number of penetrations is 7.
- 2. Intermediate Building penetration area (penetration access area - East). Number of penetrations is 5.
- 3. Intermediate and Auxiliary Building penetration area (penetration access area - West).
Number of penetrations is 33. No special designations have been assigned areas where penetrations enter the Reactor Building. Redundant circuits are spatially separated by 40 feet or a concrete floor, except for nuclear instrumentation penetrations, which are spatially separated by 20 feet. Provisions for fire detection and protection in the penetration access areas consist of the following:
- 1. An early warning fire detection system comprised of smoke detectors.
- 2. A fire hose/standpipe system.
- 3. Manual fire extinguishers.
Protection to ensure that missiles inside the Reactor Building will not jeopardize plant safety are discussed in Section 3.5.1. All containment penetration seal assemblies are protected against major incidents, such as missiles and rupture of high energy piping. Additionally safety related penetrations are protected on both sides of the nozzle. Therefore, based upon good design practice, a separation of 3 feet from other penetrations, the failure of which could inflict only minor or insignificant damage to an electrical penetration, was provided. 8.3.2 D-C Power Systems 8.3.2.1 Description Separate Class 1E and non-Class 1E d-c power systems are provided. Two (2) Class 1E 125 volt d-c systems provide sources of reliable, uninterruptible d-c power for control and instrumentation for normal operation and orderly shutdown of ESF equipment. A separate non-Class 1E 125 volt d-c system is provided to supply non-ESF d-c loads, including large power non-ESF loads. This system is also a manually switched backup d-c source for the Substation Relay House d-c system. The 125 volt d-c battery systems, located in the Substation Relay House and in the Unit 1 Relay House, are provided for 230 kV substation protection and control. These systems are shown in Figures 8.3-1, 8.3-2, 8.3-4, 8.3-5 and 8.3-5a.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-23 The Class 1E d-c system for control and instrumentation consists of 2 full capacity, 125 volt d-c, lead calcium, 60 cell batteries, 2 125 volt d-c battery buses and 3 static battery chargers. Two (2) of the 3 battery chargers are supplied from separate, redundant motor control centers. One (1) of these 3 chargers serves as a standby charger and is provided for use during maintenance of, and to backup, either of the normal power supply chargers. The standby battery charger, 1A-1B, is provided with a set of 2 transfer switches which consist of mechanically interlocked circuit breakers on the a-c input and d-c output. These circuit breakers, as shown by Figures 8.3-6 and 8.3-7, are interlocked to allow only the 2 breakers associated with Channel A or the 2 breakers associated with Channel B to close at the same time. The battery chargers remain connected to the respective a-c source buses upon loss of offsite power. Each battery charger is protected by the molded case circuit breakers in the input and output circuits. The d-c circuit has a voltage adjustment of 100 to 145 volts d-c. During an equalizing charge, d-c voltage may be set at 140 volts. All Class 1E d-c loads can operate at 140 volts d-c without damage. An overvoltage alarm is provided to annunciate in the control room upon detection of voltages greater than 140 volts d-c. The non-Class 1E 230 kV Substation d-c systems provided for the 230 kV substation control and relaying consists of the following:
- 1. For the Substation Relay House, the d-c system consists of a 125 volt battery with a main battery bus, two battery changers and two separate distribution panels for 230 kV circuit breaker tripping. Backup for non-1E loads is also provided by this system.
- 2. For the Unit 1 Relay House, the d-c system consists of two independent d-c systems. Each system is comprised of a 125 volt battery with two distribution panels, a battery charger and common bus-tie fuse-disconnect switch. One d-c system supplies the 230 kV substation system primary protection and control. The second d-c system supplies backup protection and control. Other 230 kV substation systems and relay house d-c loads and can be supplied from either d-c system.
The second non-Class 1E d-c system provided for the 230 kV substation control and relaying in the substation relay house consists of a 125 volt battery with a battery bus, 2 static battery chargers and 2 separate distribution panels for power circuit breaker tripping. Backup for large power non-ESF loads is also provided by the system. The non-Class 1E d-c system in the Unit 1 relay house consists of two 125 volt d-c batteries, each with its battery charger, feeding 2 separate distribution panels for power circuit breaker tripping. The non-Class 1E battery has adequate storage capacity to power the following loads for a period of 1 hour:
- 1. Main generator emergency seal oil pump.
- 2. Circuit breaker closing and tripping (non-ESF buses).
- 3. Miscellaneous non-ESF loads.
- 4. Non-ESF instrumentation inverter and computer inverter.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-24
- 5. D-C turbine bearing oil pump.
- 6. Feedwater pump d-c oil pump (3 pumps).
- 7. Reactor and Diesel Generator Building emergency panels.
A 1 hour period is considered to be the minimum time for use in sizing the batteries. Complete loss of offsite and onsite a-c power for such a period of time is considered highly unlikely. Loss of both diesel generators during an assumed prolonged loss of offsite power is not postulated nor is complete loss of all battery chargers postulated. Battery chargers are considered to be available to sustain the bulk of the battery loads well within the 1 hour period of time. The non-Class 1E battery supplying power to the d-c turbine bearing oil pumps is of sufficient capacity to power the pumps during turbine coastdown to avoid turbine bearing damage. Battery capacity in addition to that which is absolutely essential is provided. 8.3.2.1.1 Uninterruptible Non-Class 1E System The uninterruptible non-Class 1E 125 volt d-c system is an ungrounded system. The system is operated ungrounded with the battery floating on the system. Dual input inverter No. 5 (450 volt a-c normal input, 125 volt d-c backup input) provides uninterruptible 120 volt a-c power for the AMSAC system, secondary plant digital control systems, the station computer and other non-Class 1E loads. No Class 1E loads are supplied from this system. The secondary plant digital control system can also be powered by the ISFSI Electrical Building uninterruptible power supply. The dual input inverter No. 5 provides continuous power to non-Class 1E 120 volt vital secondary digital control system and computer loads. Transfer from one input to the other is accomplished without interruption to the load. The inverter is protected by circuit breakers on the 480 volt a-c input side and the 125 volt d-c input side. Abnormal conditions in the dual input inverter cause alarms to occur in the control room. The output of inverter No. 5 is connected to a distribution panel through an automatic static transfer switch. An alternate backup 480-120 volt transformer non-Class 1E power source is provided through the automatic static transfer switch. The feed to the transformer is from a 480 volt motor control center as indicated by Figures 8.3-4 and 8.3-4b. All metering and monitoring is performed by a digital control system that includes a microprocessor. The operation of the microprocessor has no impact on the ability of inverter No. 5 to perform its function. Inverter No. 6 is also powered from the non-Class 1E 125 volt d-c bus. A static switch is provided on the output of this inverter to switch the feed to the inverter distribution panel from the inverter output to a 120 volt ac supply upon detection of loss of inverter output.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-25 8.3.2.1.2 Uninterruptible Class 1E Systems Each uninterruptible Class 1E system contains a separate 125 volt d-c and 120 volt ac system. The 125 volt d-c system is a 2 wire, ungrounded system centered around a full capacity 125 volt, lead calcium battery, 125 volt d-c main distribution panel and solid state battery chargers. Figures 8.3-2aa and 8.3-2ab show connection of the battery, battery charger and main distribution panel of each redundant Class 1E power system. No ties are provided between the redundant Class 1E 125 volt d-c systems. All non-Class 1E loads connected to the Class 1E d-c system are identified by Figure 8.3-1 (see Note 4, Figure 8.3-1). Connection of non-Class 1E loads to the Class 1E d-c system is discussed in the statement concerning Regulatory Guide 1.75 in Appendix 3A. Eight (8) separate 125 volt d-c distribution panels including the 2 main distribution panels are provided. Each panel provides d-c instrumentation and control power as necessary for proper functioning of the plant. The battery, battery charger and main distribution panel of each system are located in protected areas of the Intermediate Building, separate from the location of redundant channel equipment. The protected areas are separated by a fire resistant barrier. The inverters and other distribution panels are also located in protected areas. Each ESF battery has a rated capacity of 2175 ampere hours (with an 8 hour discharge cycle to 1.75 volts per cell). This capacity is sufficient to power essential loads and normally connected non-essential loads for a 4 hour duty cycle following loss of all a-c power. The 4 hour duty cycle is based on coping requirements for Station Blackout (Reference 15) defined by NUMARC 87-00 (Reference 17) and endorsed by NRC Regulatory Guide 1.155 (Reference 16). The 4 hour duty cycle with loss of all a-c power envelopes the previous 2 hour duty cycle based on a LOCA in conjunction with the loss of all a-c. The 2 hour duty cycle represents standard industry practice for sizing batteries for generating stations and does not reflect V. C. Summer design basis requirements for demonstrating d-c system operability. Essential loads include the following:
- 1. Instrumentation inverters - with ESF and non-ESF loads.
- 2. Engineered safety features control.
- 3. Diesel generator control and field flashing.
- 4. Circuit breaker closing and tripping (ESF buses).
- 5. Controls and alarms, including Auxiliary Relay Racks, Isolator Cabinets, Main Control Boards, HVAC Boards and Control Room Annunciators.
- 6. Control Room emergency lighting.
During normal operation, the 125 volt d-c load is supplied from the battery chargers with the batteries floating on the system. Upon loss of station a-c power, the entire d-c load is supplied from the batteries until the a-c power to the chargers is restored by the emergency diesel generator or the preferred power source. The function of the battery is to provide sufficient stored energy to operate necessary d-c loads for as long as each load is required during the loss of a-c power. The
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-26 time duration for the loss of a-c power is the time required for the diesel generator to start and accept load. For the V. C. Summer Station, the diesel generator breaker will close and energize the battery charger within 10.25 seconds after a loss of a-c power. Failure of a battery charger or failure of a diesel generator to start would be a single failure for which there is a redundant train of electrical systems that will be used to achieve safe shutdown and mitigate design basis events. A failure of a battery charger would not prevent either start of the diesel generator or closure of the necessary breakers to re-establish a-c power to the auxiliary a-c system. In the event of a charger failure, a backup charger has been provided and can be connected well within the batterys 4 hour duty cycle. Thus, the minimum 4 hour battery capacity provides considerable margin for the battery to perform its intended function. Separate evaluations were performed to demonstrate sufficient battery capacity and to demonstrate system operability based on sufficient voltage at d-c equipment/device terminals. The evaluation to demonstrate sufficient Class 1E battery capacity was based on ampere loads associated with Class 1E and non-Class 1E equipment as shown on Figures 8.3-1, 8.3-2, 8.3-2aa, and 8.3-2ab. The evaluation to demonstrate d-c equipment/device operability was based on ensuring that the available operating voltage (or current) for required equipment was equal to or greater than the minimum operating voltage recommended by the applicable vendor or by actual tests to demonstrate component operability with margin. Available operating voltages (or currents in the case of D.G. field flashing) were evaluated to ensure operability of Class 1E devices based on the required time of operation and the applicable system losses resulting from voltage drop. Operability of non-Class 1E loads which are supplied from the 1A and 1B batteries was not evaluated. System operating voltages were determined based on the battery as the sole source during the first 10.25 seconds following LOOP with only 59 cells or 58 cells connected. System operating voltages after 10.25 seconds were determined based on the battery at float voltage following restoration of a-c power to the battery charger. The evaluation conservatively determined voltage drop based on the d-c load currents established by the battery capacity evaluation, as modified to include design margins, and the equivalent circuit resistance, as modified to compensate for worst case conductor temperatures. Although there is no accident analysis that requires d-c system operability with the battery as the sole source after 10.25 seconds, the design objective was to ensure the ESF 125 v d-c system is capable of supporting/operating normal and required emergency d-c loads in the event of a DBA, or required SBO loads in the event of a 4 hour station blackout. Required SBO loads are normal (non-accident) loads necessary to ensure the reactor core is cooled and containment integrity is maintained in the event all a-c power is lost for a 4 hour period.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-27 8.3.2.1.3 Capacity The ampere demand of each ESF battery was calculated for the loads listed in the preceding Items 1 through 6, as well as for other connected d-c loads, to establish the worst case 4 hour duty cycle. This calculation resulted in the following 4 hour load profile.
- 1. Battery 1A - 376.9 amperes for the first minute, 200.3 amperes for the next 238 minutes, and 246.3 amperes for the last minute.
- 2. Battery 1B - 392.4 amperes for the first minute, 215.8 amperes for the next 238 minutes, and 261.8 amperes for the last minute.
The capacity of each ESF battery was then checked to ensure that the batteries are capable of supplying required d-c loads for the duty cycle. In addition the battery capacity includes design margin, accounts for battery degradation with age, and considers the reduction of battery capacity due to temperature variations. The capacity evaluation was based on a final (end of discharge) battery terminal voltage of 108 V d-c (or greater), which provides sufficient margin to ensure device operability with a reduction of up to 2 cells (58 cells connected) on either battery. The calculated ampere demand includes normally connected devices with no distinction as to whether devices are required to operate or are desirable loads. The inclusion of the latter precludes the need for any load shedding and no operator action is required to maintain power to essential safety related loads during the 4 hour duty cycle. However, any load shedding performed during the battery duty cycle adds to the existing capacity margin and results in a higher battery voltage at the end of the duty cycle. The d-c system is designed so that the loads with common a-c and d-c power supplies, such as inverters, are powered by the batteries during blackout, but are automatically returned to the a-c system upon ac bus voltage restoration. As a result, the battery chargers are required to have a minimum capacity of 150 amperes to provide the necessary 12 hour recharge. This is well within the systems 300 ampere battery charger rating. 8.3.2.1.4 Ventilation The battery rooms and battery charger rooms are located in the Intermediate Building and are provided (as a group) with a once through ventilation system consisting of two (2) 100% capacity supply fans and two (2) 100% capacity exhaust fans as shown in Figure 9.4-16. The ventilation system is designed for continuous operation. Therefore, the chance of producing an explosive atmosphere due to evolution of hydrogen during the process of battery charging is minimized. The system is provided with high and low temperature alarm inputs to the HVAC control board annunciator system. The battery room ventilation system is discussed further in Section 9.4.6.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-28 8.3.2.1.5 Equipment 8.3.2.1.5.1 Batteries and Battery Racks All batteries are of the central station, lead calcium type and are designed for continuous float duty. Each cell is of the sealed type, assembled in a shock absorbing clear plastic container, with covers bonded in place to form a leakproof seal. The batteries are mounted on protected, corrosion resistant, steel racks for security and to facilitate maintenance. The Class 1E batteries and racks are designed to remain functional during a safe shutdown earthquake and remain in a satisfactory condition to perform their function in shutting down the reactor and maintaining the station in a safe condition. 8.3.2.1.5.2 Battery Chargers Each solid state battery charger has an output for float and equalize modes with an input of 480 volt 3-phase, a-c power. Each charger is equipped with a d-c voltmeter, d-c ammeter, a-c failure relay, a ground detection annunciator alarm, low battery voltage alarm relay and fan failure alarm. A battery charger malfunction activates an alarm in the control room. Each battery charger is designed to prevent the 480 volt a-c system from becoming a load on the battery as a result of loss of 480 volt a-c input. Tests have verified that battery charger stability is not load dependent. There is no annunciator to alarm when the battery charger goes into a current limiting condition. In addition to the charger output ammeter, a 0 center scale ammeter is connected to a shunt in the leads between the battery and the battery bus to indicate current flow to and from the battery. These 2 ammeters show the status of battery charging or discharging currents and d-c system loads at all times. Main breakers, as shown on Figures 8.3-1, 8.3-2, and 8.3-4 are equipped with auxiliary switches to operate indicator lights in the control room for an off normal position. Thus, the operator is provided with system status information. Following a loss of normal station power, the battery chargers are energized from the diesel generators. Additional monitoring is provided by a special, narrow band, d-c voltage relay to monitor Class 1E battery voltage. The relay initiates an alarm in the control room if battery voltage falls slightly below normal float voltage. Voltage monitoring in this manner provides a backup alarm if a charger fails since a fully charged battery suffers a rapid drop in voltage if its floating charge fails. Such a rapid voltage drop causes the voltage monitoring relay to initiate the associated alarm. Battery ground detection annunciation is provided on the main control board for both Class 1E and non-Class 1E Plant d-c systems.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-29 The ratings for each battery charger continuous output are as follows:
- 1. Charger 1A - 300 amperes
- 2. Charger 1B - 300 amperes
- 3. Charger 1A-B - 300 amperes
- 4. Charger 1X - 400 amperes
- 5. Charger 1X-2X - 400 amperes Each battery charger has capacity adequate to restore its associated battery to full charge while providing power to the largest combination of the various steady-state loads. The charging capacity is based upon restoring the battery to full charge from the design minimum charge within 12 hours after discharge regardless of the status of the station.
8.3.2.1.5.3 Main D-C Distribution Panels Each battery distribution switchboard consists of a metal clad structure with 125 volt d-c, 2 wire, ungrounded main bus. Two (2) pole, manually operated, air circuit breakers protect each feed. 8.3.2.1.5.4 Class 1E Dual Input Inverters The dual input inverter in each system provides continuous power to the 120 volt vital a-c buses. The output of the inverter is a regulated supply. Transfer from 1 input to the other is accomplished without interruption of the output. Each inverter is protected by circuit breakers on the 480 volt a-c input side, 120 volt vital a-c output side and 125 volt d-c input side. Each dual input inverter is provided with an a-c and a d-c ammeter. Abnormal conditions in the dual input inverter, including loss of a-c input, loss of d-c input, and loss of a-c output voltage cause alarms to occur in the control room. The output of each inverter is connected to a distribution cabinet through an automatic static transfer switch and a normally closed circuit breaker. An alternate backup 480-120 volt transformer Class 1E power source is provided through the automatic static transfer switch. The feed to the transformers is from a 480 volt motor control center as indicated by Figures 8.3-1 and 8.3-2. The distribution cabinets have appropriately sized branch circuit breakers to feed reactor protection and other vital instrument channels. Most reactor protective schemes have 3 or 4 channels. Redundant instrument channels are fed from redundant vital buses. Because of the preferred failure mode defined for the reactor protective instrumentation, failure of an instrument channel power source results in a reactor trip signal from the affected channel. Multiple power supplies are provided to prevent a single power supply failure from initiating a false reactor trip. The vital bus rectifiers and inverters are assembled from high quality components, conservatively designed for long life and continuous operation.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-30 By avoiding the use of electromechanical devices, routine maintenance downtime is greatly reduced. There are no vacuum tubes or moving parts in the completely static vital bus supply systems. The ratings of each inverter are as follows:
- 1. Inverter No. 1 - 10 kVA.
- 2. Inverter No. 2 - 10 kVA.
- 3. Inverter No. 3 - 10 kVA.
- 4. Inverter No. 4 - 10 kVA.
8.3.2.1.5.5 Non-Class 1E Inverters There are 2 non-Class 1E (balance of plant) inverters. Inverter No. 5 is a dual input inverter. The dual input inverter No. 5 provides continuous power to non-Class 1E 120 volt vital digital control systems and computer loads. Transfer from one input to the other is accomplished without interruption to the load. The output of inverter No. 5 is connected to a distribution panel through an automatic static transfer switch. An alternate backup 120 volt non-Class 1E power source is provided through the automatic static transfer switch. The AMSAC system, secondary plant digital control systems and the station computer constitutes the primary loads on this inverter. The secondary plant digital control system can also be powered by the ISFSI Electrical Building uninterruptible power supply. Inverter No. 6 is a single input inverter supplied from the 125 volt d-c non-ESF system. Output from this inverter is paralleled with a supply from a 480-120 volt transformer which is connected, through a static transfer switch to the inverter main distribution panel. The transformer source serves as an alternate supply to the inverter main distribution panel. Upon loss of inverter output, automatic transfer of the inverter main distribution panel to the alternate supply is initiated. The primary load on inverter No. 6 is non-ESF instrumentation. An alternate power source circuit breaker is provided in the distribution cabinet to permit manual transfer from the inverter or transformer power source to a backup power source as indicated by Figure 8.3-4. Inverter ratings are as follows:
- 1. Inverter No. 5 - 10.0 kVA.
- 2. Inverter No. 6 - 10.0 kVA.
8.3.2.1.5.6 480-120 Transformer and Static Transfer Switch An alternate source of power to each of the 120 volt vital a-c buses is provided by a 480-120 volt Class 1E, single phase transformer. The 480-120 volt transformer in each system is designed to supply the total 120 volt vital a-c bus load when the dual input inverter is out of service.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-31 A static transfer switch is provided for inverter No. 6 to switch the 120 volt vital a-c bus loads from the single input inverter to the 480-120 volt transformer. The static transfer switch is a solid state device. Its operation is unaffected by load and power factor variations. Transfer of the 120 volt vital a-c bus loads from the single input inverter to the 480-120 volt transformer causes an alarm to occur in the control room. Transfer back to the inverter is performed manually at the discretion of the operator. 8.3.2.1.5.7 Nominal 120 Volt Vital A-C Bus System The nominal 120 volt a-c vital bus system consists of 6 panels and 4 inverters which provide power to 4 independent channels of ESF instrumentations. Channels A and B consist of 2 panels and 1 inverter each while Channels C and D consist of 1 panel and 1 inverter each. Figures 8.3-1, 8.3-2, 8.3-2aa, and 8.3-2ab depict the system. The vital bus system is a very reliable electrical system. It provides a stable supply to vital equipment and guarantees proper action when power is required, while eliminating spurious shutdowns. The normal power source for each vital bus inverter is through the inverter static rectifier from a 480 volt ESF bus. Should the normal power source fail completely or be subject to transient voltage or frequency variations, the vital bus inverter power source becomes the battery charger or battery which is floating on standby service. This transition from static rectifier to battery power supply takes place without disturbing vital bus voltage or frequency. The station batteries are sized to carry this additional inverter load without chargers for no less than 4 hours. The chargers are sized to bring a fully discharged battery up to equalize charge voltage with the inverter load connected in 12 hours. 8.3.2.2 Analysis 8.3.2.2.1 Compliance The Class 1E uninterruptible systems satisfy the criteria of Regulatory Guides 1.6 and 1.32 (see Appendix 3A), and General Design Criteria 17 and 18. The uninterruptible systems are designed so no action, automatic or manual, needs to be taken to make d-c or vital a-c power available to the equipment required immediately following LOCA or after a loss of a-c power. No operator action is required to maintain d-c or vital a-c power availability, based on single failure criteria, for safe shutdown or accident mitigation following a loss of a-c power. Class 1E system components are identified and seismically qualified as described in Section 3.10. The battery was connected to a resistive load of approximately 20 amperes during seismic testing. Class 1E equipment and the hostile environment to which it is subjected are discussed in Section 3.11. Each uninterruptible system includes power sources and a distribution system arranged to provide power to associated system loads. No ties exist between Class 1E systems. Figures 8.3-1, 8.3-2,
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-32 8.3-2aa, and 8.3-2ab illustrate the independence of the Class 1E uninterruptible systems. Equipment, cables and other components are designed, identified and located in accordance with the criteria given herein. Sections 8.3.1.4 and 8.3.1.5 discuss general design criteria applicable to the uninterruptible systems as well as to the a-c systems. 8.3.2.2.2 Maintenance and Testing The uninterruptible systems are subjected to periodic maintenance tests to determine the condition of each individual component. Batteries are checked for electrolyte level, specific gravity, cell voltage and visual signs of deterioration. A battery performance discharge test is performed according to IEEE-450 (Reference 7). Battery chargers, and inverters are checked by visual inspection weekly and performance tests are conducted periodically. Maintenance and testing procedures for batteries are in accordance with IEEE-450 (Reference 7). Testing and inspection are performed according to the following:
- 1. General inspections and recording of data are performed in accordance with IEEE-450 (Reference 7).
- 2. Quarterly tests, inspections, and recording of data are performed in accordance with IEEE-450 (Reference 7).
- 3. Yearly inspections are performed in accordance with IEEE-450 (Reference 7).
- 4. Battery service tests are performed in accordance with IEEE-450 (Reference 7). The time interval between tests is based on a nominal 18 month refueling outage schedule. Service tests are not performed during outages that require performance of a capacity (performance discharge) test. (See Regulatory Guide 1.32 discussion in Appendix 3A.)
- 5. Battery capacity tests are performed in accordance with IEEE-450 (Reference 7) and IEEE-308 (Reference 8).
8.3.2.3 Physical Identification of Safety-Related Equipment The physical identification of safety-related equipment is discussed in Section 8.3.1.5. 8.3.3 Fire Protection for Cable Systems The 15,000 volt rated power cable, the 8,000 volt rated power cable, 600 volt rated power cable for 480 volt and 120 volt a-c systems and 125 volt d-c systems, 600 volt rated control cable for 120 volt a-c and 125 volt d-c controls and 300 volt instrument cable are constructed with an overall fire retardant outer jacket. Cable for external circuits is type tested in accordance with Section 2.5 (Flame Tests) of IEEE-383 (Reference 9) and the cables are certified to be of fire retardant construction.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-33 8.3.3.1 Cable Derating, Cable Tray Fill, and Cable Construction Cables are derated to compensate for ambient temperatures and for the presence of adjacent power cables. Power cables are sized and derated on the basis of IPCEA P-46-426 (Reference 4), supplemented by IPCEA-NEMA P54-440 (Reference 5). Motor feeders, power panel feeds and small lighting and receptacle panel transformer feeds are sized for 125% of full load current. Large power transformer feeders are sized for 140% of full load current at maximum rating. Motor control center feeders are sized for 140% of the calculated normal diversified load current. Feeders to resistive loads are sized on the basis of 110% of rated current at rated voltage. In selecting IPCEA ampacity tables, a load factor of 100% is assumed. Ampacities of 7200 volt power cables are in accordance with IPCEA P-46-426 (Reference 4) in air ratings, derated by factors of 0.70 in 40°C areas and 0.63 in 50°C areas. Ampacities of 480 volt cables or large d-c cables in single layer power trays are in accordance with IPCEA P-46-426 (Reference 4) in air ratings and are derated by factors of 0.70 in 40°C areas and 0.63 in 50°C areas. Ampacities of 480 volt cables or d-c cables in a random lay power tray are in accordance with IPCEA-NEMA P-54-440 (Reference 5). Derating factors for 3 inch depth are used. Ampacities of small 480 volt cables or small 125 volt d-c cables (#10 AWG and smaller), when run in control trays, are in accordance with IPCEA P-46-426 (Reference 4) in air ratings derated by a factor of 0.50. Ampacities for 7.2 kV and 480 V 3 conductor cables in conduit wrapped in Kaowool at 40°C ambient temperature are calculated to ensure a maximum copper surface temperature of 90°C. Basis for these calculations are data obtained from IPCEA P-46-426. The application ampacities of the cables are determined by applying a 1.25 derating factor to the design ampacities. The cable sizes are then selected so that the cable application ampacity is equal to or greater than the design current value determined from the cable sizing criteria. No ampacity derating factors are applied to control and instrument cables. Ampacities are determined on the basis of 90°C tables at 40°C ambient in all interior areas except containment. Containment or ESF motors in areas requiring forced ventilation of the motor are determined on the basis of 50°C ambient. Pressurizer heater cables are sized by special ratings due to the operating environment. The Reactor Building cooling unit fan motor power cables and the post accident hydrogen recombiner unit power cables (Reference 10) require special consideration since these motors must operate in the post accident containment environment. These cables are sized to carry the
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-34 required current during the post accident temperature and pressure transient without exceeding the recommended emergency operating temperature rating for the cable and to continue to operate for a minimum of 6 months after the accident. A preventive maintenance program to test the insulation values of circuits and equipment is followed. Ladder type tray systems are used for power and control trays. Instrument trays are solid bottom trays with top cover plates. The 5 basic tray systems are as follows:
- 1. The 7200 volt power trays.
- 2. The 480 volt and below, single layer power trays.
- 3. The 480 volt and below, random lay power trays.
- 4. Control trays.
- 5. Instrument trays.
In vertical stacking the 7200 volt power trays are on top, 480 volt power trays next lower, control trays next lower, and instrument trays on the bottom. 8.3.3.1.1 7200 Volt Power Trays No other type cable is mixed in the same tray with 7200 volt power cable. These trays are 4 inches deep (inside dimension). There is 1 layer of cable with no spacing between cables. 8.3.3.1.2 480 Volt and Below, Single Layer Power Trays The 480 volt and below, single layer power tray system is exclusively for 480 volt, 3-conductor power cables or d-c power cables. This tray system is 4 inches deep (inside dimensions) and contains only large (MCM sizes) and 4/0 cables. There is 1 layer of cables with no spacing between cables. 8.3.3.1.3 480 Volt and Below, Random Lay Power Trays The 480 volt and below, random lay power cable tray is for 480 volt power cables 4/0 and smaller. The tray is 6 inches deep (inside dimensions). d12 d22 . . . . dn2 x 100 Percent fill = Tray Depth x Tray Width where: d1, d2, . . . . dn = Diameters of all cables in the tray presently planned plus all known future cables.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-35 Small 480 volt power cables (#10 AWG and smaller) may be run either in the random lay power cable tray or the control tray. Circumstances may dictate running an MCM size power cable in a random lay power tray. The cable is then derated with the derating factor appropriate to the random lay trays. 8.3.3.1.4 Control Trays The control trays contain control cables, small 480 volt power cables (#10 AWG and smaller, except for selected motor operated valves which use larger sized cables) and small d-c power cables (#10 AWG and smaller). All of these cables carry either intermittent current or continuous current of 5 Amps or less. Single phase, 120 volt a-c circuits (#10 AWG and smaller) carrying 5 amps or less may also be run in the control trays. The amount of heat generated from cables which carry intermittent current is negligible based on the large majority of time the load is not operating. The control trays are 6 inches deep (inside dimensions). The design limit for control tray fill is based on verifying that the weight of new and existing cable is within the tray and tray support weight capability. 8.3.3.1.5 Instrument Trays Instrument trays contain low level analog signals cables. These trays are 6 inches deep (inside dimensions). The design limit for instrument tray fill is based on verifying that the weight of new and existing cable is within the tray and tray support weight capability. In addition to all low level analog signal cables, the instrument trays are used for digital contact (breaker contact) cables where the source of power is the reactor protection or computer packages, otherwise all digital circuits are in the control trays. 8.3.3.1.6 Cable Tray Fill Criteria The 50% cable tray fill criteria is the design objective that applies only to random lay power trays. Random lay power trays contain 480 volt power cables smaller than MCM sizes. Power cables, No. 10 and smaller, may be run either in random lay power tray or in control tray. The 30% fill criteria recommendation in IEEE Propose Guide P-422 (Reference 3) is based upon the summation of cross sectional areas of cables. The 50% fill noted in Section 8.3.1.4.3 is based upon the summation of the cable diameter squared areas. Fill of 50% on this basis is equivalent to 39% fill on the IEEE Propose Guide P-422 (Reference 3) basis (i.e., 3.1416/4.0 times 50%). Through experience, it has been found that approximately 40% fill on the basis of cross sectional area or 50% fill on the basis of diameter squared area is satisfactory with respect to physical tray loading and uses the tray more efficiently. Power cables are rated on the basis of this 3 inch physical depth, using the derating factors of IPCEA-NEMA P-54-440 (Reference 5).
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-36 These derating factors are in agreement with the 50% or 3 inch depth physical loading. Control and instrument cables require no derating. Where random lay power tray fill exceeds 50%, worst case conditions have been analyzed to assure the capability of the tray hangers to support the additional weight and, that sufficient margin exists in the cable sizing to account for the heating effects (Reference IEEE Transaction Paper 70TP557PWR Ampacities for Cables in Randomly Filled Trays, also, see FSAR Section 8A.1.2). For each random lay power tray, a calculation was performed to address the additional heat loading from the new power cable and its effect on the ampacity (heat loading) of other power cables in that tray. The existing and new power cables were derated if the total heat loading of the cables in the tray was not within the allowable heat loading based on the percent fill. In addition, this calculation determined the weight of the new and existing cables to ensure that their combined weight was less than the maximum weight that the tray support can carry. For trays filled to the maximum weight allowed by the tray supports, the maximum allowable cable sidewall pressures will not be exceeded (Reference FSAR Section 8A.1.3). In the event overfill occurs at tray intersections, protection will be provided to preclude cable damage. The cable tray fill criteria for control and instrument trays is controlled by the cable management system computer program. This program contains an alarm limit for the maximum weight allowed for each tray size used. Therefore, manual calculations to monitor cable weight are not required since this calculation is done by the cable management system and an alarm is provided if the tray or tray support weight capability is exceeded. Heat loading is not a concern for control and instrumentation cables due to their small currents and/or intermittent operation. For expanded cable and tray design considerations, see Appendix 8A. 8.3.3.1.7 Cable Construction Feeder and motor cables in 7200 volt service are insulated cables rated at a minimum of 8000 volts. Single conductor cables or each conductor of multi-conductor cables in 7200 volt service are shielded. Power cables for 480 volt service are insulated cable rated at a minimum of 600 volts. Single conductor cables and multi-conductor cables are provided with an overall flame retardant jacket. Control cables are of single or multi-conductor construction with a 600 volt (minimum) insulation, total coverage electrostatic shield and overall flame retardant jacket. Low voltage instrument cables are insulated cables rated at 300 volts, minimum. Where required, these cables are provided with a total coverage electrostatic shield and with an overall flame retardant jacket. 8.3.3.2 Fire Detection and Protection Devices Fire detection and protection systems, either automatically or manually initiated, are provided in those areas required to preserve the integrity of circuits for redundant safety-related systems. A
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-37 fixed, low pressure carbon dioxide fire extinguishing system is installed in the relay room and computer room at elevation 436 of the Control Building. A preaction sprinkler system is installed in the following areas of the Control Building:
- 1. Cable spreading room - elevation 425.
- 2. Cable spreading room - elevation 448.
- 3. Cable chase areas.
Smoke detection systems are installed in the switchgear rooms and penetration access areas. Section 9.5.1 provides greater detail concerning fire detection and protection. The fire hazard to cables is reduced by cable construction as described in Section 8.3.3.1.7. 8.3.3.3 Fire Barriers and Separation Between Redundant Cable Trays Criteria used for the separation between different Class 1E system trays and between Class 1E and non-Class 1E trays are given in Section 8.3.1.4. Where the required separation cannot be maintained, fire barriers are installed in accordance with IEEE P-422 (Reference 3), Section 8.3.2. The fire barriers are qualified in accordance with criteria given in Section 9.5.1. In cases of multiple separation violations between non-safety related trays and redundant safety related trays in the same fire area, tray covers or circuit breaker surveillance has been provided as a resolution. Refer to FSAR Section 8.3.1.4.1, item 4 for details. 8.3.3.4 Fire Stops Openings in walls, floors, and ceilings, which are provided for the routing of raceways, are protected by fire stops. Fire stops are designed with a fire rating equivalent to that required for the wall, floor or ceiling with which it is associated. The materials used in fabricating fire stops are rated in accordance with ASTM E 119. In addition to preventing the spread of fire, fire stops are designed to be reasonably leaktight, thereby limiting the propagation of smoke and gases from one area to another. 8.3.4 Safety Related Cable No natural polyethylene materials are used in safety related inter-connecting circuits between equipment in the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station. Cables which have cross linked polyethylene are used for various plant applications.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-38 8.3.5 References
- 1. Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers, Installation Inspection, and Testing Requirements for Instrumentation and Electric Equipment during the Construction of Nuclear Power Generating Stations, IEEE-336-1971.
- 2. Deleted (RN 99-037)
- 3. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Design and Installation of Cable Systems in Power Generation Stations, IEEE Proposed Guide P-422, prepared by the Working Group on Wire and Cable Systems Station Design Subcommittee, Power Generation Committee.
- 4. Insulated Power Cable Engineers Association, Power Cable Ampacities, IPCEA P-46-426-1962.
- 5. Insulated Power Cable Engineers Association - National Electrical Manufacturers Association, Ampacities of Cables in Open-Top Cable Trays, IPCEA-NEMA P-54-440.
- 6. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Guide for Class 1E Control Switch Boards for Nuclear Power Generating Stations, IEEE-420-1973.
- 7. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Recommended Practice for Maintenance, Testing, and Replacement of Large Stationary Type Power Plant and Substation Lead Storage Batteries, IEEE-450-1987.
- 8. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Criteria for Class 1E Electric Systems for Nuclear Power Generating Systems, IEEE-308-1971.
- 9. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Standard for Type Test of Class 1E Electric Cables, Field Splices, and Connections for Nuclear Power Generating Stations, IEEE-383-1974.
- 10. Electric Hydrogen Recombiner for PWR Containments, WCAP-7709-L, Supplement 7, (Proprietary) and WCAP-7820, Supplement 7 (non-Proprietary), August, 1977.
- 11. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Qualifying Class 1E Electric Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations, General Guide, IEEE-323-1971.
- 12. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Seismic Qualification of Class 1E Equipment for Nuclear Power Generating Stations,
- 13. Fire Protection (FP) DBD
- 14. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers, Criteria for Separation of Class 1E Equipment and Circuits, IEEE-384, 1974.
- 15. 10 CFR Part 50, Section 50.63, Loss of all Alternating Current Power.
- 16. U. S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission Regulatory Guide 1.155, Station Blackout.
- 17. NUMARC 87-00, Nuclear Management and Resources Council, Inc., Guidelines and Technical Bases for NUMARC Initiatives Addressing Station Blackout at Light Water Reactor.
- 18. Calculation No. DC08500-022, Determination of Maximum Sidewall Pressure Imposed on Cable in Cable Tray as a Result of Cable Weight.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-39 Table 8.3-1 Major Electrical Equipment Equipment Tag Numbers Description and Ratings Unit Generator XGN1-EG 1,137,680 kVA, 0.905 pf, 22 kV, 1800 rpm, 3, 60 Hz Standby Diesel Generator XEG0001A, B-E (Engine) 4250 kW, 7.2 kV, 0.8 pf, 3, XEG0001A, B-G 60 Hz (Generator) Main Transformer XTF1-EG 940/1052.8 MVA, 55C/65C, FOA, 242-22 kV, 3, 60 Hz Unit Auxiliary Transformer XTF2-ES 48/64 MVA, 55C, 22-7.2/7.2/7.2 kV Emergency Auxiliary XTF31-ES 24/32/40/44.8 MVA, Transformer XTF32-ES 55/55/55/65 with nominal 8.0% impedance from HV to LV, based upon 24 MVA base, 230-7.2/7.2 kV Engineered Safety XTF4-ES 10/12.5/14 MVA, 115/7.2 Transformer XTF5-ES kV 7.2 kV Line Voltage Regulator XTF6-ES 1500 kVA, 55° C rise, Class OA, 7.2 kV +/- 10% in 32 - 5/8% steps, 1200 Amps, 1.12% based on 15 MVA, 3, 60 Hz Generator Circuit Breaker XCB0010-EG 1, 60 Hz, 22 kV (nominal) 36 kV (max), interrupting rating of 210 kA (Sym System Source) and 150 kA (Sym Gen Source).
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-40 Table 8.3-2 Symmetrical Interrupting Capacity For 480 Volt Unit Substation Cubicles Symmetrical Interrupting Capacity Frame Size (amps) Instantaneous Trip (amps) Delayed Trip (amps) 600 30,000 22,000 1600 50,000 50,000 2000 65,000 55,000 3000 65,000 65,000
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 Table 8.3-3 (Part A1) Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel A (see following page inserts) VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-41
Table 8.3-3 Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 (Part A2) Basis for Diesel Generator Fuel Oil Consumption Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel A (see following page inserts) VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-42
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 Table 8.3-3 (Part B1) Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel B (see following page inserts) VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-43
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 Table 8.3-3 (Part B2) Basis for Diesel Generator Fuel Oil Consumption Connected Automatic and Manual Loading and Unloading of the Diesel Generator Channel B (see following page inserts) VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-44
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-45 Table 8.3-3a Diesel Generator Protective Devices Protective Relay Function if Diesel Start is Initiated By: ESF OR Test Device Undervoltage Start Switch 67 DG Motoring - reverse power flow Alarm Trip (2) 51 DG Ground Overcurrent Alarm Trip (2) 51VDG Time overcurrent - voltage controlled Alarm Trip (2) 46 DG Negative phase sequence Alarm Trip (2) 64 FDG Field ground relay Alarm Alarm 87 DG Generator differential Trip (3) Trip (3) 40 DG Field failure relay Alarm Trip (2) Lube oil pressure low (4 switches) Trip (1)(3) Trip (3) Engine overspeed Trip (3) Trip (3) Crankcase pressure high Alarm Trip (3) Lube Oil temperature high Alarm Trip (3) Jacket coolant temperature high Alarm Trip (3) 59 Overvoltage Alarm Alarm Fuel Oil Pressure Low Alarm Alarm Start failure Alarm Alarm Barring Device Engaged Prevent Start Prevent start (1) Trip occurs on actuation of 2 of 4 switches if at least 1 of the 2 actuated switches has setpoint of 60 psi. Setpoints are at 70, 65, 60, and 60 psi. (2) Trips Diesel Generator Breaker only. (3) Trips Diesel Generator Breaker and Diesel Generator Engine.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 Table 8.3-3b Engineered Safety Features Bus Indicators Indicator Type Function Location GE Type AB-40, Frequency Meter Diesel generator A, frequency Main Control Board (MCB) panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Wattmeter Diesel generator A, watts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Voltmeter Diesel generator A, volts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Wattmeter ESF transformer, watts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Voltmeter ESF bus 1DA, volts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Varmeter ESF transformer, vars MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type 180, A-C Ammeter Diesel generator A, amperes MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type 180, A-C Ammeter ESF transformer, amperes MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type 180, A-C Ammeter 7.2 kV bus 1DA feeder, amperes MCB panel XCP6117 VC SUMMER FSAR GE Type AB-40, Frequency Meter Diesel generator B, frequency MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Wattmeter Diesel generator B, watts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Voltmeter Diesel generator B, volts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Voltmeter 7.2 kV bus 1DB, volts MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type 180, A-C Ammeter Diesel generator B, amperes MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type 180, A-C Ammeter 7.2 kV bus 1DB feeder, amperes MCB panel XCP6117 GE Type AB-40, A-C Ammeter 7.2 kV bus tie 1DX2DX, amperes MCB panel XCP6117 8.3-46 Red Lion PAX, A-C Voltmeter 115 kV incoming, volts MCB panel XCP6117
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-47 Table 8.3-4 Identification of Safety-Related Cable Trays and Cables Engineered Safety Reactor Protection Process Control Features Actuation & Color Channel Channel Equipment Channel Red I 1 A, J Orange II 2 D, L Blue III 3 B, K Yellow IV 4 E, M Green - - C Tan, plus Channel color Associated - X, plus channel Tan or no color Non-Safety-Related - X
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-48 Table 8.3-5 Sequence of Operation Following a Loss or Degraded Voltage Condition Loss of Voltage Degraded Voltage Items of Operation (Time in Seconds) (Time in Seconds) Loss or Degraded Voltage Condition 0 0 Diesel Generator Start 0.25 3 Permissive to EFW Pump Start 0.25 3 Initiate ESFLS Operation 2.25 7 7.2Kv Bus Circuit Breaker Trip 2.25 7 Permissive to Close Diesel Generator Circuit Breaker 5.25 10 Diesel Generator Ready to Load (Initiate Block Loading) 10.25 13
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-49 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0 DRAWING 1MS-33-007
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-50 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0a DRAWING 1MS-33-008
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-51 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0b DRAWING 1MS-33-009
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-52 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0b.1 DRAWING 1MS-33-191
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-53 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0c DRAWING 1MS-33-028
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-54 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0d DRAWING 1MS-33-029
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-55 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0e DRAWING 1MS-33-030
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-56 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0f DRAWING 1MS-33-033
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-57 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0g DRAWING 1MS-33-034
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-58 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0h DRAWING C-203-005
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-59 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0i DRAWING C-203-006
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-60 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0j DRAWING C-203-007
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-61 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0k DRAWING C-203-008
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-62 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0l DRAWING C-203-009
Figure 8.3-0m Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 MAIN CONTROL BOARD ANNUNCIATOR STATION B-804-636 SH.1 & 637 SH.1 REV. 9 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-63
Figure 8.3-0n Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 DIESEL GENERATOR LOCAL ANNUNCIATOR STATIONS DWG. NO. 1MS-32-120 REV. 0 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-64
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-65 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-0o DRAWING C-203-010
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-66 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-1 DRAWING E-206-062
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-67 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2 DRAWING E-206-062
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-68 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2a, Sheet 1 DRAWING E-216-011
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-69 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2aa DRAWING E-206-062
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-70 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2ab DRAWING E-206-062
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-71 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2b DRAWING E-216-012
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-72 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2c DRAWING E-216-013
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-73 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2d DRAWING E-216-014
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-74 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2e DRAWING E-434-006
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-75 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2f DRAWING E-434-007
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-76 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-2g DRAWING E-441-001
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-77 Figure 8.3-3 CONTAINMENT PENETRATION SEPARATION
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-78 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-4, Sheet 1 DRAWING E-206-061
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-79 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-4a, Sheet 2 DRAWING E-206-061
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-80 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-4b, Sheet 3 DRAWING E-206-061
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-81 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-5 DRAWING E-229-025
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-82 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-5a DRAWING E-229-152
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-83 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-6 DRAWING 1MS-37-043
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-84 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-7 DRAWING 1MS-37-041
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.3-85 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8.3-8 DRAWING E-203-201
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.4-1 8.4 STATION BLACKOUT V. C. Summer Nuclear Station Unit No. 1 conforms to 10CFR50.63 entitled Loss of All Alternating Current Power (Station Blackout). V. C. Summer's program meets the guidance provided by Regulatory Guide (RG) 1.155, Station Blackout; Nuclear Management and Resources Council, Inc. (NUMARC) 87-00, Guidelines and Technical Bases for NUMARC Initiatives addressing Station Blackout at Light Water Reactors; and NUMARC 87-00 Supplemental Questions/Answers and Major Assumptions dated December 27, 1989. Virgil C. Summer Technical Report TR08200-003 entitled Compliance to NRC Rule 10CFR50.63 (Station Blackout), documents VCSNS compliance. Additional details are provided in the NRC issued Safety Evaluations References 1 and 2. 8.4.1 Station Blackout Duration NUMARC 87-00 was used to determine an SBO duration of four hours. The following plant factors were identified in determining the proposed Station Blackout duration:
- 1. AC Power Design Characteristic Group is P1 based on:
- a. Independence of offsite power classification of Group 1 1/2
- b. Severe weather (SW) classification of Group 1
- c. An extreme severe weather (ESW) classification of Group 3
- 2. The emergency AC power configuration group is C based on:
- a. There are two EDGs credited as AC power supplies
- b. One emergency AC power supply is necessary to operate safe shutdown equipment following a loss of offsite power.
- 3. The target EDG reliability is 0.95.
- a. A target EDG reliability of 0.95 was based on the Virgil C. Summer Station having an average EDG greater than 0.95 over the last 100 demands.
- b. EDG failure statistics for the last 20 and 50 demands, in accordance with the requirements of RG 1.155 was provided, which confirms that the target selection is appropriate.
8.4.2 Coping Method The V. C. Summer Nuclear Station coping method is in accordance with the AC-Independent Approach delineated in NUMARC 87-00 for the required coping duration of four hours and recovery therefrom. In this approach for VCSNS, DC power is required to be available for the coping duration to operate equipment necessary to achieve safe shutdown conditions until offsite or emergency AC power is restored. The following plant systems and components are required to have the availability, adequacy, and capability to achieve and maintain a safe shutdown and to recover from an SBO for a four-hour coping duration.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.4-2 8.4.2.1 Class 1E Battery Capacity The V. C. Summer Nuclear Station has sufficient battery capacity and size to support decay heat removal during a Station Blackout for the required four-hour coping duration in accordance with NUMARC 87-00 without load stripping, as discussed in Section 8.3.2.1.2. The battery analysis is documented/maintained in SCE&G Calculation DC08320-005. 8.4.2.2 Condensate Inventory For Decay Heat Removal The V. C. Summer plant has adequate condensate inventory for decay heat removal during a Station Blackout for a required duration of four hours. The necessary condensate inventory is assessed by a bounding analysis based on the NUMARC 87-00 Equation. The minimum permissible condensate storage tank level per technical specification requirements provides 172,700 gallons, which exceeds the required quantity for coping with a four-hour Station Blackout per SCE&G Technical Report TR08200-003. 8.4.2.3 Compressed Air The V. C. Summer air operated valves required for decay heat removal have been evaluated and accepted for manual operation under Station Blackout conditions for the four-hour duration. 8.4.2.4 Effects of Loss of Ventilation The effects of loss of ventilation within areas of the plant containing equipment necessary to achieve and maintain safe shutdown during a Station Blackout is evaluated per NUMARC 87-00. The dominant areas of concern (DACs) and analysis are documented in SCE&G Technical Report TR08200-003. 8.4.2.5 Containment Isolation Containment isolation valves that must be operated under SBO conditions must have the ability to be positioned, with indication, independent of the preferred and Class 1E AC power supplies and that no modifications or procedure changes are necessary to ensure containment integrity can be obtained if it is needed under SBO conditions. Containment isolation valve design and operation at VCSNS meet the intent of the guidance described in RG 1.155. 8.4.2.6 Reactor Coolant Inventory The ability to maintain adequate reactor coolant system (RCS) inventory to ensure that the core is cooled has been assessed for four hours. The generic analysis listed in NUMARC 87-00 was used in this assessment. The expected rates of RCS inventory loss under SBO conditions do not result in core uncovery.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER FSAR 8.4-3 8.4.3 References
- 1. USNRC Letter to SCE&G dated January 30, 1992,
Subject:
Safety Evaluation Regarding Station Blackout Analysis, Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station, Unit No. 1 (TAC No. M68610).
- 2. USNRC Letter to SCE&G dated June 1, 1992,
Subject:
Supplemental Safety Evaluation Regarding Station Blackout, Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station, Unit No. 1 (TAC No. M68610).
- 3. U. S. Nuclear Commission Regulatory Guide 1.155, Station Blackout.
- 4. NUMARC 87-00, Nuclear Management and Resources Council, Guidelines and Technical Bases for NUMARC Initiatives Addressing Station Blackout at Light Water Reactors.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8A-i Appendix 8A Additional Cable and Tray Design Considerations
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8A-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8A-1 APPENDIX 8A ADDITIONAL CABLE AND TRAY DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS 8A.1 METHODS EMPLOYED Sections 8A.1.1 through 8A.1.3 describe methods employed to show sufficient conservatism in the cable and tray design to assure that adequate cable tray hanger strength exists, that cables are sufficiently sized, and that the weight of upper cables in trays does not damage bottom layer cables. 8A.1.1 Weight on Hangar Cables are routed in tray in two different configurations (e.g., single lay and random lay). The weight of the cables, tray, tray covers, fire barrier materials on the tray, and any conduits and pipes hung from the tray supports were used to establish the tray support capability. The allowable cable weight limit is based on the capability of the cable tray (e.g., 35 lbs/ft2 of tray bottom area for single lay 4" deep trays and 45 lbs/ft2 of tray bottom area for random lay 6" deep trays). For single lay cable tray, percent fill and cable heating were not the deciding factors for limiting tray fill. Engineering determined that the maximum number of cables that a single lay tray can accommodate is based on the cable diameters versus the width of the tray. The initial design criteria for random lay tray was based on a maximum of 50% fill. Engineering performed calculations to ensure that cable heating and cable weight were acceptable whenever the tray fill was less than 50%. Because the tray fill was conservatively calculated based on the square of the cable diameter in lieu of the cross sectional area of the cable, the actual tray fill is less than the calculated tray fill. The cable management system computer program was used to monitor tray fill. The 50% limit originally established was found to be inadequate as cables were added over the life of the plant. Therefore, calculations were performed whenever a random lay cable tray fill exceeded 50%. Subsequently the criteria for random lay power cable trays was changed to weight per tray support with an alarm point of either 50% fill for trays presently less than 50% filled or the last calculated allowable % fill for trays whose fill exceeded 50%. In addition, the criteria and alarm point for instrument and control tray were changed to weight only per tray support only, since heat loading was not a concern. Whenever a power cable is added to a random lay power tray and the associated tray fill exceeds the previously accepted percent tray fill limit, a calculation is performed. The calculation addresses additional loading from the new power cables to ensure that the combined weight of the new and existing cables is less than the allowable design weight capability of the tray support. Heat loading is also evaluated to ensure that the existing ampacity derating factors are still applicable.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8A-2 Engineering determined that cable heating was not a concern for the small currents and intermittent operating conditions associated with control and instrument cables and therefore only total cable weight needed to be considered. The design limit for control and instrumentation cable tray fill is based on verifying that the weight of the new and existing cable does not exceed the tray and tray support weight capability. The cable tray fill criteria for control and instrument trays is controlled by the cable management system computer program. This program contains an alarm limit for the maximum weight allowed for each tray size used. Therefore, manual calculations to monitor cable weight are not required because this calculation is performed by the cable management system and an alarm is provided if the tray or tray support weight capability is exceeded. 8A.1.2 Cable Heating Single layer kV and 480 volt cable trays need not be considered with respect to possible cable overheating since, inherently, the fill is limited to the single layer of cable with appropriate derating factors applied. Rated ampacities are in accordance with ICEA P-46-426 (Reference 1); the free air ratings for the applicable ambient temperatures were derated for the presence of adjacent power cables. In addition, a load factor of 100 percent was assumed and feeders are sized for 110, 125, or 140 percent of rated current, depending upon type of service (resistive loads; motors, power panels and small transformers; and large power transformers, respectively). No ampacity derating factors are applied to control and instrument cables due to the type of service and low current levels. For random lay power trays (Reference 2, Table 12), a 3 inch depth was used to determine cable ampacity. Therefore, derating due to tray fill need only be considered for trays with fill greater than 50 percent design objective, since the 50 percent design fill is equivalent to a 3 inch depth. The 100 percent load factor feeder sizing considerations previously noted were also applied, along with appropriate derating where required for higher ambient temperatures. In selected cases fill above 50% was authorized to larger values after specific evaluation of heat dissipation and weight loading. Heat dissipation was evaluated using the methods described in Reference 3.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8A-3 From Figure 4 of Reference 3 the following linear approximation can be made for the allowable heat generation versus tray fill: 6 .5 Qd = (1) d1.47 Where: Q d = Allowable heat generation per unit area of cable cross-section to limit conductor temperature to 90°C d = Depth of tray fill in inches Since heat generation in a given cable at a fixed temperature is proportional to the square of the current, the following relationships can be established: Q d = KI2d (2) Where: Id = Ampacity of cable for tray fill depth d K = Constant Combining into equation (1) and developing a ratio: Q d' KI2d' (d)1.47
= =
Qd KI2d (d' )1.47 Using the relationship, the curve of Figure 4 in Reference 3 was extended to cover larger fills of six inch deep tray. Because Reference 3 was developed for three inch deep tray, the tray fill permitted is one-half the value shown in Figure 4. As long as the tray fill meets this criterion, the cable ampacities of Reference 2 are still permissible. There is an additional margin of conservatism in the heat dissipation calculation. Tray fill is calculated using diameter squared to represent cable cross-sectional area instead of actual cable area. This represents a margin of 27.3 percent above actual tray fill. In addition, non-continuous current carrying cables are not included in heat density calculations but are included in tray fill and weight calculations, which ensures conservatism. No ampacity derating of cables has been necessary because of heat dissipation. 8A.1.3 Cable Side Wall Pressure In accordance with manufactures published information the maximum allowable side wall pressure of typical cables used is considerably higher than the pressure that cables on the bottom of a tray will experience from cables above, even for fills in excess of 50 percent. The minimum
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8A-4 allowable side wall pressure is 50 lb/ft, while the maximum loading per cable in a tray filled to the tray support limit, or 100% physical fill, will be less than 7 lb/ft [18] *. 8A.2 CONCLUSIONS Tray fill is monitored by computer. Any tray that exceeds the design fill is reported on a separate printout. This printout is used in routing design, and cables are routed through other, less full trays. Late in construction other trays may exceed the maximum values justified in Sections 8A.1.1 through 8A.1.3. When this occurs, the situation will be evaluated and action will be taken to relieve such a condition. Alternatives are to calculate the actual tray load and verify that the load does not exceed the design capacity, enlarge the existing tray, strengthen the existing hangers, or in the case of random lay power trays where the concern is ampacity, each individual circuit application can be evaluated and the total ampacity calculated. 8A.3 REFERENCES
- 1. Insulated Cable Engineers Association, Power Cable Ampacities, ICEA P-46-426-1962.
- 2. Insulated Cable Engineers Association, Ampacities of Cables in Open-Top Cable Trays, ICEA P-54-440.
- 3. Stolpe, J. Ampacities for Cables in Randomly Filled Trays, Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers Transaction Paper 70TP557PWR.
- Refers to Section 8.3, Reference [18], Calculation No. DC08500-022, Determination of Maximum Sidewall Pressure Imposed on Cable in Cable Tray as a Result of Cable Weight. See Amendment 00-01, Revision Notice 99-14.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-i Appendix 8B Cable Raceway Fire Barriers Design
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-1 NOTE: Appendix 8B is being retained for historical purposes only. APPENDIX 8B CABLE RACEWAY FIRE BARRIERS DESIGN 8B.1 PURPOSE This report describes the criteria, assumptions and design used by Gilbert Associates, Inc. (GAI) to locate and construct cable raceway fire barriers on the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station for the South Carolina Electric and Gas Company. 8B.2 CRITERIA Fire barriers were designed to comply with IEEE Standard 384-1977 Criteria for Independence of Class 1E Equipment and Circuits. Fire barriers are required to prevent propagation of a fire between two, or more, raceways of redundant divisions or non-class 1E to Class 1E cable trays which do not maintain minimum physical separation. This minimum physical separation is specified in IEEE-384, and in SP-834 - Electrical Construction Guideline for Electrical Circuit Physical Separation. In summary, the minimum separation distances are based on open ventilated cable trays and are as follows:
- 1. Cable spreading area - one foot horizontally and three feet vertically.
- 2. General plant area - three feet horizontally and five feet vertically.
Where the above separation is not provided the following specified criteria extracted from IEEE-384 are used:
- 1. The use of physical barriers or enclosed raceways, which qualify as barriers, shall be separated by a minimum distance of one inch.
- 2. Vertical barriers, separating redundant horizontal tray running parallel requiring horizontal separation will have a minimum of one foot (or to ceiling) extension above the top of the tray at the highest elevation in a stack.
- 3. Horizontal barriers, separating redundant horizontal trays crossing requiring vertical separation will have a minimum of three feet extension beyond each side of the widest tray (one foot in the cable spreading area).
- 4. Horizontal barriers, separating redundant horizontal trays running parallel requiring vertical separation will have a minimum of six inches extension beyond each side of the widest tray.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-2 These barriers are intended to prevent redundant raceway-to raceway fires which are self-initiated only. Based on the above, the following was extrapolated:
- 1. Solid tray covers and bottoms, referred to in this report as fire shields, may be added to open ladder tray to qualify it as an enclosed raceway. Trays containing power cables (480 volt and higher) may require barriers in lieu of fire shields since fire shields may inhibit ventilation.
- 2. Channel tray (4 inch open top, solid bottom) will be considered an enclosed, open top tray and may require covers only.
- 3. Instrument trays, in this plant are installed with solid covers and bottoms and constitute an enclosed raceway.
- 4. Conduit alone constitutes an enclosed raceway.
- 5. Conduit installed beneath or alongside of an open tray of a redundant division does not require a barrier.
- 6. Conduit installed less than five feet (three feet in a cable spreading area) above a tray of a redundant division requires a barrier.
- 7. Conduits may be wrapped with a flexible fireproof material which will suffice as a barrier.
This may be used where space permits installation. 8B.3 MATERIALS AND INSTALLATION 8B.3.1 Fire Shields Tray covers and bottoms will be made of 18 gauge steel. They will be attached to the tray by one of several methods described in detail by the tray vendor for other applications in the plant. Basically, the covers are strapped or clamped to the tray. Covers will be peaked to 1 inch, except for covers for fittings which will be flat; bottoms will be flat. 8B.3.2 Barriers Board barriers will be made from Babcock and Wilcox M-Board in one inch thickness. Installation techniques are under development. 8B.3.3 Conduit Wrapping Conduit wrapping will be done with Johns-Manville Cerablanket, or Babcock and Wilcox Kaowool blanket materials. These are high-temperature fiber blankets in a thickness of one inch and, typically, a width of 24 inches. The blanket will be wrapped around the conduit and fastened with fire resistant tape or by other similar method.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-3 8B.4 ACTUAL CASES Detailed in Figures 8.B-1 through 8.B-12 are representatives cases found in the Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station where physical separation of redundant channels could not be maintained. The type of fire barrier designed for each case and the installation methods are described below. Options are provided for each case and an option may be selected, for individual cases, based on economics, available space and complexity (e.g., it may be more advantageous to use one board barrier rather than many covers and bottoms where several trays are involved).
- 1. Detail 1 - Redundant Horizontal Trays Crossing, Requiring Vertical separation.
- a. Option A - shows the use of fire shields on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows the use of a horizontal board barrier.
- 2. Detail 2 - Redundant Horizontal Trays Running Parallel Requiring Vertical Separation.
- a. Option A - shows the use of fire shields on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows the use of a horizontal board barrier.
- 3. Detail 3 - Redundant Horizontal Trays Running Parallel Requiring Horizontal Separation
- a. Option A - shows the use of fire shields on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows the use of a vertical board barrier.
- 4. Detail 4 - Horizontal Tray Crossing Redundant Vertical Tray Requiring Horizontal Separation.
- a. Option A - shows the use of a fire shield on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows the use of a vertical board barrier.
- 5. Detail 5 - Horizontal Conduit Crossing Over Redundant Horizontal Tray Requiring Vertical Separation.
- a. Option A - shows the use of a fire shield on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows the wrapping of conduit.
- c. Option C - shows the use of a horizontal board barrier.
- 6. Detail 6 - Horizontal Conduit Above Redundant Horizontal Tray Running Parallel Requiring Vertical Separation.
- a. Option A - shows the use of a fire shield on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows wrapping of the conduit.
- c. Option C - shows the use of a horizontal board barrier.
- 7. Detail 7 - Vertical Conduit Crossing Redundant Horizontal Tray Requiring Horizontal Separation.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-4
- a. Option A - shows the use of a fire shield on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows wrapping of the conduit.
- c. Option C - shows the use of a vertical board barrier.
- 8. Detail 8 - Horizontal Conduit Crossing Redundant Vertical Tray Requiring Horizontal Separation.
- a. Option A - shows the use of a fire shield on each tray.
- b. Option B - shows wrapping of the conduit.
- c. Option C - shows the use of a vertical board barrier.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-5 Figure 8.B-1 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-6 Figure 8.B-2 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-7 Figure 8.B-3 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-8 Figure 8.B-4 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-9 Figure 8.B-5 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-10 Figure 8.B-6 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-11 Figure 8.B-7 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-12 Figure 8.B-8 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-13 Figure 8.B-9 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-14 Figure 8.B-10 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-15 Figure 8.B-11 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8B-16 Figure 8.B-12 ELECTRICAL FIRE BARRIER DETAILS
".&/%.&/5 "6(645
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-i Appendix 8C Summary of Analysis of Separation Between Tray for Non-Class 1E Circuits and Tray for Class 1E Circuits
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-1 APPENDIX 8C
SUMMARY
OF ANALYSIS OF SEPARATION BETWEEN TRAY FOR NON-CLASS 1E CIRCUITS AND TRAY FOR CLASS 1E CIRCUITS 8C.1 OBJECTIVE Perform an analysis in accordance with IEEE 384-1974, Section 5.1.1.2, to ensure acceptable separation between trays for non-class 1E circuits and trays for Class 1E circuits. 8C.2 CRITERIA Separation shall be sufficient that no single electrically initiated fire can result in the loss of a safety system function. 8C.3 BASIS The Fire Protection Research Program tests performed at Sandia Laboratories for the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) were used as a source of data on the characteristics of cable fires. The following conclusions drawn from the reports were used in the analysis of individual situations:
- 1. It is difficult to initiate a fire from an electrical fault or overload in trays with cables which satisfy the flame retardant criteria of IEEE 384-1974.
- 2. If a fire can be started and propagated, it spreads through a stack of trays with an angle of spread of approximately 35 degrees from vertical.
- 3. In horizontal trays, the fire does not propagate horizontally within a given tray.
- 4. Fire does not propagate downward from one tray to the tray below.
The results of the IEEE 383 flammability tests for cable actually used at Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station were also used to determine that the flammability of the cable used at Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station is less than that used for the full scale tests at Sandia Laboratories. 8C.4 METHOD The tray drawings for plant areas containing trays for Class 1E circuits are reviewed and each case where a tray for non-Class 1E circuits approaches a tray for Class 1E circuits is noted and given an identification number. Each case is then clarified with sections and details as necessary to determine separation distances and to categorize the situation. The cases are then individually reviewed using the basis given above to determine the adequacy of the separation. If
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-2 the criteria stated above are not satisfied by the existing design, suitable barriers are added to the raceway system design so that the final design satisfies the criteria.
- 1. Tray for non-Class 1E circuits parallel to tray for Class 1E circuits. Subcategories include:
above, below, beside, and between.
- 2. Tray for non-Class 1E circuits crossing tray for Class 1E circuits. Subcategories include:
above, below, and between.
- 3. Tray for non-Class 1E circuits bridging between routes of trays for redundant Class 1E circuits. Subcategories include: above, below, and between.
- 4. Trays for non-Class 1E circuits diagonally parallel trays for Class 1E circuits. Subcategories include: above and below.
- 5. Trays for non-Class 1E circuits vertical. Subcategories include: parallel to or crossing tray for class 1E circuits.
8C.5 ANALYSIS A listing of cases analyzed is provided by Section 8C.6. In addition, detailed analyses for three typical cases are presented in Sections 8C.5.1 through 8C.5.3. 8C.5.1 CASE NO. 041-C 8C.5.1.1 Description
- 1. Location Control Building, Elevation 425-0
- 2. Figure Figure 8C-1
- 3. Type of Area Cable spreading room
- 4. General Description A tray for non-Class 1E (channel X) control circuits passes over a vertical stack of trays for Class 1E, channel A circuits and further north passes over a vertical stack of trays for Class 1E, channel B circuits.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-3
- 5. Category Bridging - above
- 6. Types of Trays All trays shown in Figure 8C-1 are open ventilated ladder type, except tray 5144 (A) which is the totally metal enclosed type.
- 7. Number of Circuits Tray 4290 (x) - 316 control circuits Tray 4351 (x) - 103 control circuits Tray 4650 (x) - 38 control circuits Tray 4314 (A) - 337 control circuits Tray 4284 (A) - 182 control circuits Tray 5144 (A) - 124 instrument circuits Tray 4326 (B) - 435 control circuits Tray 4325 (B) - 209 control circuits
- 8. Significant Circuits Both the channel A and B trays contain a number of circuits for the component cooling water, emergency feedwater, safety injection, and service water systems; as well as circuits for other safety systems.
8C.5.1.2 Analysis All circuits are for control or instrumentation and have very low internal energy levels. Therefore, energy is not available to initiate a fire. Any fire which might start in the trays for non-class 1E circuits will not propagate to either of the stacks of trays for the Class 1E circuits since tests have demonstrated that cable fires do not propagate downward. In addition, the tests have shown that a cable fire will not propagate horizontally over the 5 foot-8 inch distance between the stacks of trays for the Class 1E circuits. A fire which might start in the trays for the Class 1E circuits could propagate to trays for the non-Class 1E circuits but, as stated above, tests have shown that the fire would not propagate
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-4 horizontally to the trays for the redundant Class 1E circuits nor would the fire propagate downward to the other stack. Although the preceding analysis documents that a fire barrier is not required, a barrier was installed in the Channel B control trays in compliance with the licensing commitment to provide barriers for multiple separation violations as described in paragraph 8.3.1.4.1, Item 4. 8C.5.2 Case No. 102-A 8C.5.2.1 Description
- 1. Location Reactor Building Elevation, 436'-0"
- 2. Figure Figure 8C-2
- 3. Type of Area General plant area
- 4. General Description Trays for Class 1E circuits, channels A and D, run parallel to trays for non-Class 1E (channel X) circuits throughout this elevation of the Reactor Building. No trays of other channels are present.
- 5. Category Parallel - beside
- 6. Types of Trays The trays, as shown by Figure 8C-2, consist of both open ventilated ladder trays and totally metal enclosed trays.
- 7. Number of Circuits Tray 3098 (X) - 13 480 volt random layed power circuits Tray 4168 (X) - 33 control circuits Tray 5063 (X) - 22 instrument circuits
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-5 Tray 4174 (A) - 62 control circuits Tray 5069 (A) - 3 instrument circuits Tray 5077 (D) - 3 instrument circuits
- 8. Significant Circuits Tray 4174 contains a number of circuits from the chemical and volume control system, reactor coolant system, and safety injection system; as well as from other systems.
8C.5.2.2 Analysis The Class 1E, channel D circuits are in a totally metal enclosed raceway at the bottom of the stack. Therefore they are adequately separated from other trays. The lower of the two trays for Class 1E channel A circuits is totally metal enclosed and therefore, is adequately separated. Any fires which might start in the upper of the two trays for Class 1E channel A circuits would not propagate to the tray for the channel D circuits nor to the trays for non-Class 1E circuits. The bottom tray for non-Class 1E circuits is totally metal enclosed and therefore, is adequately separated from other trays. The middle tray for non-Class 1E circuits contains control circuits which do not have adequate energy to initiate a fire. Should a fire occur, it could propagate to the top tray for the Class 1E, channel A circuits and to the top tray for non-Class 1E circuits. However, this is acceptable because only one channel of Class 1E circuits would be affected and, therefore, system safety functions would be maintained. The top tray for non-Class 1E circuits contains power circuits which potentially could initiate a fire. However, the tests have shown that such a fire is very unlikely and should such a fire occur, it would not propagate to any other trays in this configuration. Although the preceding analysis documents that a fire barrier is not required, a barrier was installed in the Channel D control trays in compliance with the licensing commitment to provide barriers for multiple separation violations as described in paragraph 8.3.1.4.1, Item 4. 8C.5.3 Case No. 073-A 8C.5.3.1 Description
- 1. Location Auxiliary Building Elevation, 388'-0"
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-6
- 2. Figure Figure 8C-3
- 3. Type of Area General plant area
- 4. General Description Trays for Class 1E circuits, channels A and B, run parallel to trays for non-Class 1E circuits, channel X. This situation exists for a distance of 20 feet.
- 5. Category Parallel - above and beside
- 6. Types of Trays Both trays for Class 1E circuits contain control circuits. Trays for non-Class 1E circuits include instrument, control, and random layed power circuits.
- 7. Number of Circuits Tray 4062 (A) - 28 control circuits Tray 4064 (B) - 27 control circuits Tray 5022 (X) - 38 instrument circuits Tray 4059 (X) - 106 control circuits Tray 3033 (X) - 49 random layed power circuits
- 8. Significant Circuits Both trays 4062 and 4064 contain circuits for the chemical and volume control system and the leak detection system, as well other systems.
8C.5.3.2 Analysis Tray 4064 for Class 1E, channel B circuits is separated by considerably more than 5 feet vertically and 3 feet horizontally from all other trays and, therefore, is adequately separated.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-7 Tray 4062 for Class 1E, channel A circuits is 14 inches away from tray 5022 for non-Class 1E, channel X circuits. However, tray 5022 is totally metal enclosed and, therefore, is not a hazard to tray 4062. Tray 4062 is more than 5 feet horizontally and 3 feet vertically from all other trays and therefore, is adequately separated. 8C.6 CASES ANALYZED The following pages list the cases analyzed.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-8 Figure 8C-1 CASE 041-C
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-9 Figure 8C-2 CASE 102-A
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-10 Figure 8C-3 CASE 073-A
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8C-11 Tables 8C-8 through 8C-39 CONSTRUCTION BIDDING PURPOSES see next pages
* :,;--l~- !'~ _'-!:_- 01tl1t1t61!ss-200-91tt a
I Il t 1i It N IIJ I I INOit~: I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l 1->vu 1H t;Anv._ INA tLECTR IC GAS COMPANY D*AWING NO. aM. -,,.
- lo*u-t ID
... v VIRGIL C. Sl/dER HI/CLEAR SUflOH UNIT II C
8 = BRIDGING
= CROSSING I rttn J IICITI U( Un J IICIIS tf CHU TUY tUWlllf IU* ll1; !;Olli l-114-UI.
- 1. JOI IUIIIIIH If ClttUIT CM&H(l IUIHIIIIH. SU nu TIil( 1.3-4.
ElECTRICAl ?.#£_ __ ~*r
- Cll.8£9'T ASSOCIAtl*.. IMC.
i: _ -I
~HGtNf';.'!'.!~!'o~=~ULTUt11 =
TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS tC*L* I .... ~*, r~~/ :~-.* ,*ft..., D DIAGONAL J * - JIU£ HIRIOS IUt lttlUD!I II IIICllll JUT SHftl IUIU.
,.., 1 or,.* -
P = PAIIAlUl Y = YlRJICAL
- OtW8fCHU $P[CUl Mt!U - sn fNHI s*-1 CONfROL BUllOING ABOVE 1125' -0"
- 0 V
0 4411--129 r-t,-iiWc: C. Ill>" I " I"""!""*
- oirT. -
I f= I LH I L I . ,J *,, c11n HUMBER ORAIING CATEGORY Sl1UA110N (NOTl 2) 'IUTICAL HORIZONTAL iittiti',i11Efo RfMAR!IS fNOTE l l COOROINAIU SH lEGlNO (t(lt£RS RtPRES(NJ CHANNH Of CIRCUIIS IN CAIU TRATS) 01S1ANC£ OISIANCE !NOTE 3) 041-* . E -11 I' * *t0n 8 ~*-1* - ns* z 041-11 G-11 , l ABD'fE A :z*-1* - ,u* 1/,fl-C f-6 I' t 8 BHOII l 12" - NO tj) (<a 0 041-D H-1 C 0 ABO'fE l 12" NO *l* C D ABOVE A 2*-1* - ns* zt: C)
-a..
C>
....ac:
C) 041--E E-5 p B ABOVE E 12* - NO ( lOTAll Y tNCl 05£0 CX> () I CX> ac: U:::,
~ .,. z:
Cl
-c 0
C B BHOI ( 8 BltOI E I *-t
- I '-11
- 12*
- ns*
NO B IOIALLT ENCLOSED 14-z- ~ Do
<->a ~ 041-f 0-3 p 8 &HOW X 12" - NO ~
041-G H-8 ,. 0 NUJ 10 l - **- NO (I' p o uon l 12* HO ; (2)
~-- ~-
041 H H 12 C 8 BELOW l 12 * - NO I)
-c C) 041-1 E-8 p ( BtlOW X 12* NO (1) 041-K C-3 p B ABOvt l 12" - NO ,2'. (3) (£di D 041-t £-3 p I ABO¥£ E 1*-z* - NO l IOTAllT ENCLOSED 041-M H-6 I'. y 0 H[ll TO l - &" NO (1,* 0 lOTAltY EHCLOS(O 041-N E-10 C I BUOW l 4'-2" - NO (D 041-P £-9 C I ABOVl 8 2*-1* - ns*
)> )> cs:: G) m CZ Cf) 0 -; s::: ...... m c.o z ~ -; c.o
--.J I
0
I I I I I I LEGE HD I I I IIOlt s * - I I I I I I I I I I I _Li__J_W_l_Ll_J* ',01/Til ( IPOI IHI fl [(!RICA GAS COHPAHY *--;~CHOO
~o~ :~~~ ()~ /*1~:;r;~~2;~ 9ij I lo':, N02 f,p~
ilR"l_ C _Sllllfl HiJClllR S!lllOH UNIT If B =BRIDGING ~~ ~ GILHU AS10Cl,.TIS, IHC. IQ LOIII 1 I Jtall J IICIII UI LISI J IICIII e, CIIII 1111 1111111 IUIIII II 1111 I lll Ill El !C lRICll i:'J P fHOIHftU AMO COHSUL UMU C = CROSSING l. IDI OIIIIIIIOI Ir CtatVII COU!l IIIIUIIIOWI Ill 1111 11111 I I I ---------~ ---------- - - - - - IIIADIHO, Po\. IPA! _S!PIRIIIOH AHll!SIS (n 0 =DIAGONAL P =PA RALL H l * - INISI UUIUS IUI IIClUDU II ea"IUI JUI 111111 111111
' Qt* 0ICIIIS SPIClll MOHS SIi !HIii SI I - - - - - -COH-------*
lROL BUILOIIIG
~--- tr.HI *lll J ,,,:-::___1:_, /.', l~
- ~*4s,~!lfd:~*if.t;,.-;."
V H L,., .,. o..
-- o,. ,.- ...,. .,,, 1 1 ~ "'Yfw.ti'IDl or, -
V = YlRIICAL ABOVE 1125' -0" c.-!~u I - I llE'l'l'i;.tlU- r-fl' 1* I *
~ASE ORUING CAHGORY SIIUAflON (HOH 2) VERTICAL HORIZONTAL HUWBER ll!uWEi REMARKS l(HOH I l CO ORD INA 1E S SH LEGEHD (LElURS REPRESEHI CHAHH(l or CIRCUITS IN ClBlE lRAYS) DISIAHC£ DI SIAHCE (HOIE ll 041-0 G-9 p L ABOVE I 12* - HO @
C l ABOVE A 2 '-1" - HO Q* l IOJAll Y (HCLOS(O cc t!I C I ABOVE A 12* - HO (VI IOIALL Y ENCLOSED z UJ
-041--R 011 PV BNEHIOX - a* NO {J). (!)
0O-S 0-1 p £ 8£LOI X 2 1-1* - HO ,J UI UJ 041-l C-5 p A HEIT TO K - 6" HO (l' ii§ :g 0: 0
-a. u. ..... £-4 p r - '-!' .... 0: 041-U A ABOVE X HO 1I iG. ffi U::,
UI ~ ti t!I UJ J;. J z~ c:, Cl 041-V C-5 p B ABOVE X 12" - NO (<s,) D UJ Uc, 0: m 041-1 G-5 C B HElT ID A - 2 1 -8" YES*
' I 04H C~4 D 8 BHOI A I *- 1* . I NO l1J i
0 (:. ( ..
~ :. :
I I I I I -I l E GE H0 I I I HO I! S I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SOUTlt CAROLINA ELECTRIC & GAS COMPANY e""'f""" _DJJ _-<y_ DAAWINQ MO. 011 j 111t61!ss-200 94 I 1 H HO I 0 12 I I C VIRGIL C. SUMMER NUCLEAR STATION UNIT II 8 = BR IDGIHG I flm J fll&IIS II! LISI J 015IIS Of till! JUI ORIIINI NUll!R; SUl!S !-Ill-Ill IQ l.0111: 1 CllHRT ASSOCIATES IMC C = CROSSING I. FOi OlflNIIION Of CUCUII CHIUH O!SICNIIIONS. !IE fSII lllll I.J-1. ELECTRICAL 5'!."!..':_ ~ ~ fMC1Hlfl11S 1.Ho CON~ut lAHH
- ICAt04H6H)10
.f - - - - ftfAOIHO, ll'A ! TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS I)?/' NL;;;-
0 = OIAGONIL J - IH!S! IIUl!IS l!R! INCLUO!O IN ORl,CINll JRII SISHM O!SICN O~J I o/.ir/71 CONTROL BUILDING
- 0 r ll'JlloVii: - ou*r - out -
1 Q IHOICIHS SP!Clll NOl!S Jll_°!ti_;JCH_,~U~-w;;' 1 A_T:t!!~r*~~lll9!:F~
-tHOUfUfl ,._
P = PARAll!l !(( SHH! SN I Y = YlRIICAl ABOVE 1136' O" C - - 10 ti o ,a #. CASE
- ORAIING CA IE GORY SITUATION (HOT£ 2) YER! !CAL IIORIZONIAl B*nn It" NUMBER REOUIREO REMAR~S (HOH I) COOROIHAHS SH LEGEND (lflHRS REPRESENI CHANNEL OF CI RCU 11 S IN CABLE TRAYS) DISTANCE DISTANCE (HOH J)
OH-A C -14 p B ABOVE X 10" - NO (?) X IO!All Y ENCl0S£0 C.
,.....,.....~ ----- "'z C,
041-8 0 -II p V 8 Hf XI TO I - 6" HO (1), (D c.. w 041-C C5 p A NE 11 TO X 6" HO (D.(I) C
--~----- -- --*- p 041-0 ** - - - ' - - -£ -
A ABOVE X 8" HO ~' (_
.~
0* 2-E C5 p A ABOV[ X 8" ct
~~
HO C
...u f"' u. -
(.)) 042-f H-6 p V 0 NEXI TO X 6" HO k:.. co :::> tr:
;::, 0 CL .,,
UJ
~
t;; "' (Ji I I z -z UJ __, f--- 041- G 0-4 C A ABOVE I I 1 --8" - NO (]) k:.. 01 - "' I-' I oo UJ Uo I a,
- --~--- -
UJ 0
I I I 111 I I I I I I I I I I I I IJ I I I I I I I I I SOUTII CAROllNA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY l"' 010.* u*o J+O_
- !! - .}_ 01q111161!ss-200 9111 !0113 1 i'o tH, ttO. *rv IC LEGIHD HO TES* VIRGIL C SUUER NUCLEAR SIAIIOH UHi! #I *** '", :o, 'GllllRT UIOCIUU, IHC.
__-J- _ IQ LOA U; URIOGIHG I f IRS! J OICIIS lRI LISI l Dims Of Cl,U fall OilJINC IUMIII. 111111 1-111-111 ELECTRICAL i?}~I_:'_ ~ fMGIHfflllAHOCOHIUll'ANU C; CROSSING ' I fO! O(flllllOI Of tllCUII CHIIN!l D£SICNl1101!. SI£ ISU TIil£ I J-1 IHA01140, fl'A. 0 ; OIAGOHAL J *
- IH£lf IIU1£RS IU[ INCLUD[O IN OAIGIWIL !All ll!HI O(SICN --* TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS ,cau o*mMt ............;;r.c- ***, -
Id,-::? ft~. _1r. ...£.*. 0-IJ / ~.1 s/->,- P; PARAtl IL Y ; YlRIICAL
, CASE I O INDl(llfl SP!Clll MDI£! Ill Iliff f SH I COIITROL BU I LO I UG ABOVE 11118' O" rrtJ
- 0
, IBt~,~;;~i~t~ r::t;;i H
0
!tQt1 u L OAT( -
ORAi iNG CATEGORY SITUATION (HOH 7) VERTICAL HOR I IOHTAL oMnl[R HUMBER RE OU IRED REMAR~S i(HOT[ I) COOROINms SH UGEHO (LEITERS REPRESEHI CHAHHEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) DISIAHCE OISUHCE (NOIE 3) 1 OU-A 0 .I] C A ABOVE B 8" - YES' Cl<~
<:J f-4 C A HOT 10 0 ;- 6" NO G)' (J) L z
UJ p C A ABOVE X I '-3" - HO Q)
-043-C - - f - ! II C 043-0 [ .8 p C A ABOVE X I '**3" HO <D (._
043-[ [ 14 p B ABOVE X 12" - HO !(D X IOTALLY EHCLOSEO UJ a: C ~ :g 0 p B NfXT TO l - 1 '-0" NO (1) (i) (_ -o. u. - ... 0:: u::, 0 p 8 NEXI TO A - * '-0" HO 4) C. ii! ... UJ IL VI I- <:J VI Z _, w p A NEXT TO l - I' 6" NO (D ~,. If z-oo UJ tlo uo a:
<D 043-f G4 p C A ABOVE 0 4' -5" - 0 TOI All Y £HCLOSEO 043-G G5 C A ABOVE X 12" - NO (1 ':::.
P. 0 A ABOVE D 4 I -5" J,. o** HO :i '-i (_ C A BELOW X 9" - NO (f' J) (.
......... 00-H H5 C A ABOVE 0 4 '-5" NO .© C.
Cl 043-J C-5 p A BELOW X II" - NO (l. Qi C. p A HE ll TO X - 6" NO !) '(7) c... 04J-K 0-11 p. y BHEXTTOX - 6" HO Q). (V ~
---- -----~.
(:. :.<'>
( _Jjr/ch~l -1 \o~Ei _ Ll 1 I I I I I I I I I.LU LJ __LJJLl i
* ,r;,r,-,.i.,"lTi1irT11r1n1( & GA', (OHPAll! *'r; .r:,
_:_ =-!.-u --,-P*":'"'"o **t-'01111
.!'* 11c*** *I'".-~!i-.
HO. "°c o11 11111r, 1:ss .;,oo CJII 1 YIPf.11 [ \\UIR s1'1flR lll!IOM UHi! fl
=
8 BRIOGING I I IRS! J DIGlll UI LISI J DIGIIS Of Ciel[ !RI! OIIIIMG IUl!II. lflll! f 111 Ill ---- IQ LO* _," 0 GILBERT ASSOCIATES IHC.
! l [I.Iµ I l Al -:' _w_,c:' - '_ . 'HG<Hff., AHO (OHIUll**HH 7 (01 O[IINIIION or CIRCUIT CHUN[l Q[SICNIIIOMS. SIi FSIR JIil! I H '"" -- -r=- , . '.- ,,
C = CROSSING - -- --- - ---- - - -- ,.,,.ou,u:;, ....
*. lRAI-. S[PARAllOH AtlAUSIS =
0 DIAGONAL J
- IHl!I 81RRIUS llll INCLUOIO IN DIIGINll !ill srnu DESIGN - -- -*- **-----------~---
04H61*-070 I ~,.~
~/k;,Fl nlrf!fP~JwlV1/2f. ~f 0 ,. ( *:, IHOILIIIS SP!l:lll HOIIS S[I SKF! f SH I COtllflOL BIJllOltlG
- t:HGt"'ff:" AP,.flo~i._ ou*T OAt -
P = PARAllfl -------- . V = VERIICH ABOVE ~GJ' -0" 11L11 ~ /,./,1 8 ~~~~ ., CASE *DRAWING CAHGORY SITUATION (HOH 2) YER! IC Al HORI ZOHTAl o*nrOttt HUMBER REQUIRED REMARKS
,tNOIE ll COOHOINH[S SH lEGEHO (lEllERS REPRESENI CHANNEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) DISTANCE OISIAHC[ (NOTE 3) 044-*A U 4 C A ABOYI 0 12" HO (i). (2) 0 IO!All Y lNClOS[O C. --------- p A B!LOI 0 7 '-3" NO @.(i C a:
lll *------- z p '3), (i) UJ OH-8 I 4 A BELOW 0 2 '-3" HO C.
- p. y A NEXT TO 0 - 12" HO (_}'. (2) C.
OH-C G-5 C A ABOVE X 2 '-6" HO IW L p A BllOW X 12" NO 'I) ~i' A IO 1All Y ENCL OSEO r_ V, li f~~ u
~ fi:
044 0 (. I 0 C p p 8 HlXI IO X 8 ABOVE X (I YIRIICAL1 12" 6" NO NO CD rn (I) a: 0- " ' 8 BEL 01 X 1 '-1 HO ~.. 0:, t; zWlll * (") z - ...I w oo I f-' N Uo a: I I I w 0
*- -----~----
_J J~GlHl- 1.I 11lo~rl -1 I I I I I I I I I I LLJ I I I I I I "'I S011111 r.hR0l lllA fl ECTRIC & GAS C0MPAHY
~ , """'"" "" 1o~ '!'! ~~*- r11d,;i11ilis;--;;~ '" . , lc...
VI RG II C SUOER HUClEAR S!AIIOH IQ,.. ~7r.:rl GILBERT ASIOCIA TEI. IHC.
~~--r,,-:;,
UHi l NI 8 = BRIOG!NG I flRSI J DICIIS U( LISI l D"11S Of CIBl! !Ill OAIIINC N11~8£1. SllllS £ /14 Ill
- --- --- [llClHICAI ~!._,:__._ -- .J (f-l'C.l!HflH.l.~0C0HSULTUOS CC CROSSING 1 fDR O!flNIIIOM Of CIACUII CHUN!l D!SIGNIIIONS_ SH flll lllll 8 l-4 l'lfAOli,i<,. ,0A
- THAY S[PARAll0II ANALYSIS 0 = OIAGOHAl J IH[Sf 8URl(IS l(A[ INCLUDlO IM ORIGIMll IRII Sllf!W O!SICN - -*-----~---- *u::;,. ,,.,,, !1/2*1/?y fyt~~~,.q[ft1iJ:,rar!Q!1~,~q~r-~
COIi TR0L BIJ I L0I IIG
- 0 0H461 -070 iMGiffrfi' APPflo~,.t - Df,T -Di°"1i -
P = PARAllfl I.
- !Nill I 111 I !PHI II NO II\ 111 IHI 11 .IN ' --~-----
Y = YlRIICAl A00V( 118?' 0" U5t ORAIIIIG CAHG0RI SITUATI0H (HOH 1) YER! ICAl HOR I ION!Al BlRRllR HUMBER REOUIREO RI MARKS I< HOil I> COORO I HAif S SH llGEH O (lElHRS RlPRESEHf CIIAHHEI Of CIRCUIIS IH CABLE TRAYS) 0 !STANCE 0 IS I AHCl (HOH 3) 045-A f 8 C A BELOW l 5 '-0" -
---- --- HO CD C Cl --
o*~ -e C- I
- C 8 BflOI I l '-4" - NO (D
-~---*----
(_ z w
~--~ ---- ---- ----- ~ - - - - - - - - ~~ ...u .,_.,,
'~ f u. gfil
~ 14---
I- Cl
- lllz w ..J Z-w 8g "'
co ' l w 0
---- ~----~---~~
(**-- (: - J
- lj I
__L rtGCNO l l I .I j I I ifo!Ts--*-L.L. JI l_j j j II II j JJ I I I I j j j J*'j SOl!TII J------ CAROLI HA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY 1 7,*~*,~:~ _ ,-E.y'!'***o
~:c'i_.:'_ 01q1111u1:SS-?OO q111 ** ~
1owr ljC B BRIOGING I flRII J DIGIIS IA[ LISI l DIGIIS or CIBl[ !All ORIIING MUNI!!. S!RIIS !-111111 VIRG!l C SUMMER NUCLEAR STATION UHi! 11 10
,o*
f I GILBERT AIIOCIHB IHC
;o:;:.----f . -: ,;*/t, .
c C OtROSSIH~ I fOR O!IINl!ION Of CIRCUII CHINNll OISICNIIIONS, SI[ rm 11111 I l-4 ELECTRICAL :o!:'-!...:'_ - -
- t: - fHGIHf~:-.~:::i.c~~IUIUHH 0 - OIAGOHAI 1 ' fH!SI !IRil!RS lfA[ INClUOIO IN ORIGINII JIii S!SHM OlSIGN -
TRAY_ SEPARATION AHAL_ YSIS
---- - - ), " , *O' ~z:'71 r : rARAltfl
- o ,M1111111s 1P1c1*L No11s 111 1"'" \M, _ ---~--=--COt/TRoL ou 11011iG ____ -~ ~~M~~,~ ~i!'jt1 _t~itiffi'\¥i~rf.._'fk~-
....,.,..,..,...,.,.,,_..----------------*----"-T--~-,
v ~ Y£RllCAl 1,~m:~l 2 C0~:~~1'.:~~ S~:l::~;:O !llTHRS REPR£SENtc 1~:H H£0toiHcOiRECU i1s IN CABLE TRAYS) ~::::~~: H~~~:~~~:l fiffi' ~) 1 11 ABOVE 1125* O" 1 c (tu . _-:_ ~-~!'.1.§._LL Rf MARKS
*~*A:':.!:~ ----1--'-='-'-_c..,_-+--------------------*---------- ~-'-A_ __ _I)_! ___ , ___c_ _,_A_B_[_l_OW_X___________ - - - - - - - - __l_'.:.!.._ .. -- -- ___ NO_ _ ,_(i)=I_A_T_o_r_Al_l_l_E_N_C_lO_S_[_O_____________ --- C 17" --------t--N-0--1;,sl, - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ~
a: 041 B f. I P C A BEL 01 I
~ --*-**-------1-----1--------------------------- -------------+----I-'=----------------- ....... -- ---------------- '-
u.l
--*-----* - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ----- --- .... ---- * - - - - - t i - , - , , - - - - - - - - - - - - - * * - - - - - - - - - - - - .......
O* 1- C
- _ _ _ _O:.....:*------J..--.:.P_--1.....::...B...::B~E:.:lO:.::J.....::...l_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ --l_ _.c..:12.:."_+.-----l------'-'N.c.O__p=-:I___________________________________ C.
---- - --- ---- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - * - ... - - - - - + - - - - - + - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---------t------+-----------------------------
t-------1/4-------tl------~-----------------------1----1-----+-----t-------------------*----------------- VI UJ ls :g ~
- ... u. - - - ---------tl-----* - - - - - - - - - - - * - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ------~*--11-------------- ------------- ... a:
g a:
~ ~1----*-------1-----1------------- ----------1-----<------+----........- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
VI IA.. .-~
- t - - - - t - - - - - - - l t - - - - - + - - - - - - - - - - - - . - - - - - - - - - - t - - - - ; - - - -........- - - - + - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 1
~~ 0 0 U C a:
~t-----1/4------1------+-------------- --------t-----t-----t---'..--*+--------------------~------
UJ
-----+-----+------------------------*-*---
t----t-------1t-----+----------------------t----+------1t----+----------------* ------------------ t---------->-----+-----------------------+-----+------1>-----+----------------*-- ____________, t-------1/4--------tl------+------------------------1----+------11-----+------------------------------ , . . .w.,-r--.1-----1--------t-----+-----------------------+----+-----1-----+--------------------------------
!;;1------t-------lt-----1-----------------------t----+-----11----+-----------------------*-----
o L.-JL-J_jt---t------+---+-------------------+----t-----Jt-----t---------------------------- r---+-------11------+------------------------1-----1--*----t1-----+----------------- *------------1
* - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ---------+----f------lf------,------------------*---**--- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + - - - - - - - - - - - - - ----*---------+------- .. ---+-----f----------------------*-* *-* ----------------- - - - - < ! - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + - - - - *--------+-----,------------------- -------- ---~--- --~-- - - - ---- ------ -~----- -*----------*--------------------ii---- - - - - * - - ----- ----------------*-- - - - -------**-----1------------- ----------+------t,------- ...- - - - + - - - - - - - ----------- ... - -- ----~-------1------+-----------------------+----- -------+-----1--------------------- --------------- ~.....,...----------,~---...,_ _____________________ __. ______~------"----'----------------*----------- **----. *-------- . ---- ~ - - - - I - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + - - - - - - - - ~ - - - - - - + - - - - - * - - - - - - - - - - - - - * - -**- * - - - - - - * - - - - - - - - - ~
LL~~clni_rrlifillffl-LLLLJ I I I LLLLLLlJ I I I I _JJ__
* $011111 CAROi ltlA ELECTnlC&GAS COMPAHY'~~~~:r~:: 0'11T1111r~Js*~**;~o-9111 ,~~fl~JI.
SUUEERLHEUCCTlREAIRCASLIAIIOH
-;,'!~!";;~:'!
a= BRIOG1H1; :1 , 1Rs1 i 01c11s m l1s1 1 01c11s or cntr 1111 0R111Nc NUNBfR; sirns c-114-111 VIRGIL c UHi! NI ,*~,'~~ ,'"-" !*jieflc;1LBERT usoc1ATH;1t1c.
,._,_, ,-- (IIGIH(flUA!lO(OIHllll.t.HlS C = CR0SSlllG fOR OlflNIIJON Of CIRtul! CKINNll O{SIGNIIIONS. MC fSIR llBl[ ! )-4 ** - - * * *** 0 ** 0 **
1 lRAY SEPARATIOII ANALYSIS iT,;:.--
----COl!TROLBUIIOIJIG _________ - ']!~f_;\t,t- ~~;~r,- 1°*iw.r~t:J~~1~~,-r!_q1~~
0 OIA!iONAl 1
- IH(S{ BIRAl(RS IIR! INClUO(O U ORIGINH IRIT Slll(N O[SICN -- ~oO!H~l-!}_10 _ ,. ,i~-
p ~::::~~~ ,0 ,,u,,,11, SPlllll NUii, s,1 SHIii s,. _________ ABOV[--i, 3
~---------
1 0 H~~~~ R 011 AiitiG-* -,-..,.r..,..,A1~1"'co..,R..,.Y-,---------s-,1-u_A_T1_0_11-(-Ho-,-E-2-)-------,-Vc-:£,.,.R""1,,..c.... At-,-110R I IOH !Al f£1Ji'Jto RE MAR~ s --
- 1HO t I I) r.uoRll !NA l.;_f_,:_S +S:.:l.;_f_;l.::l.::G:.:IH:..:Dl'!-l_ll_l_f_RS_R_[r_R_E_Sl_H_T_C_II_AH_H_l_l_O_f_t_lR_c_u_11_s_u1_CA_B_l_l_l_R_AY_S_;,)+-0-1_sl_A_u_cr-+_,_i1_s_1A_H_C_I+-'(__H.;_OTC.C{-"3-+-=--------------- ---------
0* 8 A Co
* -PY - * - AHDl!Ol J'O HO 'lJ -----**-~-------*------* ----
C
.,,a:
z UJ
- - - - - - - ** - - - - - r - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - + - - - - * - - - - -*~,----* - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -----s>-----1----------------------- ~- ---
1-----3/4-------1----1----------------------+-----11-----+-----3/4,---------------------- - - - - - - z:::"' a:t-----3/4-------,1-----+-----------------------t----;-------1r----;------------------ o O 0 t-a.. a: u.1------f--------11-----+----------------------t----;-----,1----+-----------------------------; 00 g f filt----t----- - - -* - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - t - - - -* - - - - - - j C - - - - - + - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - * - - - - - * - 1.... n a: "' I t- u,
.,, z Ct----+-----*-+----+------------~----------+-----t------+----t----------------------------____.
UJ
~
r-' V, ~ u 0 C> ii! a:
,---1>-------t----+------------------------+------i I ----<-------* -----+----------------------* -----+-----,-----+--------------------- - - - - - - - "' --* *----t----------------------------*------
1-----3/4------,1-----* -----------------------t----+------t-----t-----------------*-----------
....cw t----1-----
0
~ ~ -------* 1-----,------------------------1------ ~-----if------------------------------------
C') M c::: z (/) H t:;I _____
. *----1/2-----+--------------*------ - - * - - - - - - - - * ,__ ., -----~-------- ~
r-' z ---- ~------ ---- --- - - * ! - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -.. -----*-*- I..O I..O H --- ----t------* --------------------------1----- -- -*----+---------------- ---*--- -.,J I..O
-.,J !----+-----*-
I --- -------- ----- -------------------------+--- --11----* - - - - - - - - * - - - - - ----------------- - - - - - - - - - - - 0 r-' , (***:,
*., ~': . : ' /** ' '~
l~-f clHk LLJwJri _LL! I I Il I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SOUTII CAROLIJIA ELECTRIC & GAS COMPANY ,;) :~ ,,, - -*,- .. 0
~.,** ""*t~-t~ C T'~-- !:J { - !.{ - _-1_ Oli jlillfdiSS-?00 ')lll Oll'J I VI RG ll C SUMMER HUCl £AR STAii OH UHi I #I srrns ~**!*_ GILURT ASSOCIATES IHC 5:,*~-1-:! -
B= BRIOGIHG *. I FIRS! l OIGlll II! LI!! 3 DIGIIS OF CUL! !UY DRIIING NUM8!R, 1-lll Ill 10 LO*
;:" ---~l::: -:~_,,~ ---_,, _,_, -
HE CTR I CAL I~ - NGIHf[ RI AHO COHWl ,*... HTS C= CROSS ING 1 fOR DfllNlllON Of CIRCUII CKINNIL DISIGNlflDMS. S£I fSIR llftlE 8 JI ---* ,.,..,o,Ho, ,..., lRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS D= DI AGONAl 1 IH!!f URRlfRS IUI INCIUOID IN DRIGINll JAIi SYSIIM DISICN ,_, - *- - -
~ p'!_t_,,1 _
coin ROL BUllOltlG o,,.t aiyw[!r~-11 - °' f'~W,;~J~l~llip!!r!llf~f~ O~HGI MO fH'11HH11 ..,,.,.. ~lo. o-.u: P = PARALlll l Q1wo10111 SPIClll MOHS Sil SHl[I SH I -* V= V!R II CH ABOV( ljljij' O" C I illl 1 /1, [3 ; , ~f) UH DRAWING CA IE GORY SI IUAIIOH (HOH 2) VER! ICAL IIOR I ZON!Al BARR I ER NUMB! R REQUIRED RlMARKS 1HOH ll COORII IHA fl S Sll l £GEN O(l£1HRS REPRESENT CIIAHNH Of CI RCU 11 S IN CABLE !RAYS) DISIAHt:I OISIAHC[ {HOIE 3) 049 A
----- ll 13 p B HEX! JO K I '-4" HO Ci: ----*- -*- ---------------- C ---- -------~-- - - - - -* -- ,,-, ---*-
a< 049 8 I I3 p 8 HIX I f O K _______
- I' 6" HO \..' (
Cl UJ 1-- *I-----* --------- zu, "' UJ Q: oo ..... 0 1-- Q: U::> 0 ~.,_ UJ I.ii Ii; Cl "' z~ ....J w '
- I 00 w :
c..>o UJ 1--
*Cl ---- - - - - - - --------- ---~------~--------- --*-- -- *-- **------* ----------~---* - - -
I I I I I I I I I .I sourn CAROii HA ELECTRIC&GAS COMPANY !~ ;"'" IH NO. I 1111¥ ahl--LLl11oLlJ- '*'1/f ,.."'\ ~-T--*-T-- O>AW<HO HO. I I I I I I I I I I I
~H~~"- -1 __-1 IL _-' _ "- 0 I 111116 l,SS -200 <JIii jo!,I , j c VIRGIL C. SUMMER HUCL EAR SI All OH UHi l NI B =BRIOGIHr. I f IRSI J 016115 m llSl J DIGIIS Of CUll IRII DRIIING MUNIER; SUl!S 1-114-111 !* LO*-, ,_:.!'e CILIERT AISOCIA TES, IHC.
ELECTRICAL s*J:.~~- __ C =CROSSING
*. 1 IOR DlflMIIION Of CIRCUII CHINN!l OlSIGMlllOMS m rm mu e H -- fUCIHfll!SAHOCOH1UllAHfS ,ir.1.011to, ,...,
TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS ICH~-----t/;*i P1!~r:c51~I.,o, I*H I""&vl:r~ 0 =OllGOHAL l - !HIS£ 8UilllS *£Rl INClUO[O IN ORIGINll IRII llll[N OfllCN -- /,:,_,i'. _,,, ~.;,/;y
- 0 OH
- 6
'0 ~t*EiF1-9IVE' CONTROL BIii LOi NG -0:/0 -tHa114r.il'l*.;;,.(ov:. *- Of,-'f -*-oiYi
- P = PARAlLll INOlfllll SPlCIH HOil! II[ SHH I SH I -
V = VlRIICll ABOVE 11110' -0" r,;- - ll!;: '%*!* ~ '.$:,
~A~I ORAIING CA IE GORY . SITUATION (IIOIE 2) .V£Rl IC Al HOR I ZOHTll BAHHl[H NUMBER REOU IRED REMARKS 1 NOH II COORO IHA ff S SE£ lEGlNO (LEIHRS REPRES£Hl CHAHHEl Of CIRCIIIIS IH CABLE TRAYS) DISTAHd OISIAHC£ (HOH 3) 051
- A l-12
----- -~--*-- ---*------
p l HEX I JO X 12" HO 0 ----- *--~ C p A NEXI 10 B 4' O" HO (.;) (i I C c>: (i) -------- C. p 8 HE XI 10 l 1' O" HO
}i - - - -*-- -- --*-- *-------*----
UJ
- *--- - ----------*----~------ "'~~ -------------------
'! f U- *-----
... a:
U::::, Cl ii! ...
... u, Ulz UJ UJ I ~
z- -' ' *-----* Oc:, UJ Uc:,
- a:
UJ 0 C \ .
I lu c!"~-U-~JJ IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII I I I I SOUTH CAROLINA ELECTRIC & GAS COMPANY *--: ~ ';J.'"" OAAWIMO HO.
~[>! - A ~ otljllll61!ss-?.OO 9lll I IH. iio:
1071 OIV 116-
-r-
_I VIRGIL C. SUMMER HUCLUR SJAIIOH 'UNIJ II 8 = BRIDGING : I fllll l IICIIS U[ usr J IICIIS Of CAIL! IUI DRIIIIC NUIIU; S!Al!S f-m-m _,o lo* r '" --~ CILIUT ASSOCIATES, IIIC. C = CROSSING 7. IOI CHIIIIIOI or tlltUII tHAIIH llSICllllONS. Sil IUI llllf 1.3-1. ELECTRICAL !t!P.. _ __ fHGIH(~~~~~/~~~ULUNU I . .
~lO Ift~ll*~f - .. J TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS IC Alt D = DIAGONAL J - mu IIUIUS 1111 IIClUDU II IRICllll UII SISIII emu ,) ~ f' A~ *,;;-* CNJ I o/,i~ t P = PAAAllH V " VERIICAL l O lNOIClllS SP!Cllt NOl(S SH SHIii SN I AUX I LI ARY BUILDING ABOVE 374' -0" lnwnffl-~
- o 1141\1
~ - - . .,. O (.-¥,~F1~-~r; ~ or*i" - -OAT[ -
oalt !!!Y ...
'l110 'Y,{,o CA St DRAWING CAHGORY SIJUAflOH (NO!E 2) VERJICAL HOR I ZONfAl B~Kff l[R NUMBER RlOUIRE,~ REMARKS IHOIE ll COOROINAl!S S[( l[G(N D (l(IHRS REPRESEHf CHANNEL or CIRCUIIS IN CABLE fRAYS) DISJANCE DISIANC( (HOfE 3 011-A ~
p A ABOVE X 3 '-5"
- - HD 6 a: 011 8 ------*r s p 8 BELOW X 1' ,fl* NO (i' Q; (j}
UI z -'- ---------------- w 011-C (-9
--- p 8 NEXI 10 X 6" NO (I) (<D) ~ - -* -
071-D f------- - r -11 p 0 HIX! 10 X - 6" HO (l) (~)
----------~-----*----
w a: 011-[ G-12 C B ABOVE X 4 '-5" - HO (2) li :g CJ -11. u.. ~f e i. t; UI ~ I w z~ ..J : 88 UJ a:
...w *CJ t
- 1*~ufMKO GLJl l lt1o1/2l~JJ I I I I I I I I I I I I l I I l l l I l 50UTII CAROLINA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY o,u.w1wo HO. Ill!~
I 1t E IH. MO
~§ '.:'~- o;f41l61lss -?00 911 I I073 ,jc B = BRIDGING VIRGIL C. SUMMER NUCLEAR STATION UHi T #I SO LOIi RWP ~ ~***T'"'j I FIRS! l Ol&IIS IRI LISI 3 0IGIIS Of ClBll IRII ORIIING NUMB!R; SEIIIS l-11Hll GILaERT usoc1A ns. IHC.
HE CTR I CAL [HGIHfUU AHO fOH\UL TAHU C = CROSSING l FOR OHINIIIDN Of CIRCUIT CHINN[l DISICNIIIONS. SI! FSIR IUll 8.l-4. -- -* - - J'U AOIMG. ""-* TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS 0 = DIAGOHAI l - IHI SI URRII RS WI RI INClUOfD IN ORIGIOL !Rll SlSl!N OfSIGN $CAL( I .. :_ - - :. ::. ~~ - - ~"(_J_ _ -~!if'~"- P = PARAllEl V = VERTICAL
\
4 C IHOICll!S SPIClll HOil! SH SH{I I SH I AUXILIARY BUI LO ING ABOVE 388' -0"
,.,y C
MAD! ~~-t!9.ro:J;-~,!!~t~
*O~lO)Of' *****<<**n*ov~_orrt - /,,11, iJ ~119.~r~~ our *, 11 CASE DRAWING CA TC GORY SITUATION (HOH 1) VERTICAL HORIZOH!Al n'to"ui 1iEi REMARKS HUMBER '<HOH I) COORD ItlA ll S SEE LEGEN0 ( LEI HRS RlPRESENI CHANNEL Of CIRCUITS IH CABLE TRAYS) 0 ISi AHCE DISTANCE (NOTE 3) - - -~--*----
Oil-A H- 9 p A HEX! 10 X - 11" ___ .......t ____ HO (}21 ---~---- C Pi
"'z -- *-- - ---- . - - -------*-----
UJ
-- ----- ~--- --*--*-- *-- *------* ---------*----- -*---- --- -- -- ---- ----* --------------~-
uJ ZV> a: I oo u.
-.... a:
IL C)
~
U::, C> I UJ
~IL VI % w ,ct z- ..J oo w Uo a: ...- ' I i
UJ C)
~
0 ~ q Cl) ~- -- i H -- I-' ----- ----- \JJ H \JJ -.._J \JJ
-.._J I
0 I-' (\,(:,* t<*
(*/:'/ I I I I I I sourn CARllrlllA l:lECTR IC & GAS COMPANY ,---~~ *~ ..... "° "°* ...., l 6M. NO . I I I I I I I I I I l I I I I I I I I I I I I ltGtffll NllHS: - ~1 ~~-!. 011j111161!ss-200 9,11 071, 1 10 VIRGIL C. SUMIIEA NUCLEAR SUJION UNlf 11 B = BRIDGING I 11111 ! IICIIS II[ LISI J tlCIIS If tlll[ IUI IUIING *u*eu; suns l-11f-lll ELECTRICAL 0 RwP __
~ **n~~ CILIIUT AUOCI.UU, IHC.
fHClt-f((IIIS *~o (ONIUL UNYI C,. CROSSING : 7. IOI DlflllllON Of cmu11 CMIUll lUICNIIIOO. S!I JIii !Alli 11.!-4. IJlfAOINO, f'A. uu~FI ~l~ffii~,..fofi r~A~f-'~fl.2!:rPf!f~ .... _ TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS 0 = 0 I AGOHAL J *
- IH[lf UUIIIS lrH INCLUDII II DIICINll 1111 STSIII HSIU ICAI.I 1/";_r
__ ~.."'.!~- __ .::*~~ _ '!:":'!?{- P = PARllLH I O IMOICIIIS SP!tlll MOIU SIi Sff[lf SM I AUXILIARY BUILDING 00 IIC~lfA5t ~!!. - ~ DA
~~ OU Y = YERIICAl ABOVE 397' -0" C Fit - - ~%i;.,
CASE DRAWING CAl£GORY SIJUAJIOH (HOH 2) VERTICAL HOR I ZOHJAl BiHH l[R NUMBER RE OU IRED R(URKS c HOil I l COORO IHA IE S SH lEGEH 0 (LEllCRS REPRESENT CltANNEl Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) DISJANC[ OISUHCE tNOIE Jl 014-A 0-9 p A NE ll 10 I - I '-2" NO* (i) c,:: 014-B I *-2* 12' NO (D (lo)
~---0 I* 17 8 UOY( l t!I
- z:
~:fl oc:
0
-a. u. ... oc:
u::, C
~a.. ....,. ~
co
.,. z "" --
88 ...
... t!I C")
z- ~ ' I I N 0 - m *-- *--
~
0 I
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 15UUIII CAROLINA ELECTRIC& GAS COHPANY :e;;y;;v OJltAWINO MO. I IH. WO, ID
- j;'I --~ 0 11j 111161!ss-200 9111 jo76 1 LECENO 8 = BRIDGING C = CROSSING NOl£S:
- I fllll 3 IICIIS U! LISI J 111111 If CUL( IHI UIIIU IUIIU; sum (-1"-111
!. ro* 11r1i1m* er ClltWII tNUIH IUICNAII0U, SU rsu IIIU 1.3-C.
VIRGIL C. SUMMER NUCLEAR SUflON ELECTRICAL UNIT II
<'NP 1ouu, 1,-!!'~-l~~, - - - - ~
GILIEltT USOCIUU, IHC. f HCINHJU AHO CONSUL U.Mfl fl(AOIMO, , ** 0 = DIAGONAL l *. IHI!( umus ,m UClUDII II HISIUL IHI SUl(I om,~. TRAY SEP AR AT ION ANALYSIS ICALI 1/-:.~-. /c,-1"/ r* -i"ttoiM*i*Ai-'rii~"":'
~,1 ~,1,, - OlrT - p;:-;J' -
AUXILIARY BUILDING
- 0 UH&*-1110
' -1 ~-,rn,~:.,,:ioyt~lr"l=r "!~
P = PARALLEL l O1101UJIS SP[tlll N0IIS SH SHlll SN- 1 l:V WAD* Ui V = VERTICAL ABOVE 1112' -0" c. l'f--ll I
~AU ORUIHG CAHGORY SITUATION (NOif 2) VERJICAl HORI ZONTA HUMBER L /l!uWEi REMARKS 11 HOil I l COOROINAHS SH l[G[HD (LHHRS REPRlSEHT CHAHHlL Of CIRCUIIS IN CABLE JRAYS) OISIAHCE OISUHCE fHOlf l) 016-A f-9 r ANCIIIOk - 2 '-4
- HO Q)
D A BHOI X 9* I '-IO' HO (!J a:: c:, z w 016-8 0 6 p A HEIi 10 I
---- - 2*.9* NO CD Cfo) 0 016-C 1-9 p A HU I TO I - 3' -9" HO 'I) p A BHOI l 12" - HO (I) .,, 016-0 G-9 p AHEIITOX - 2'-4" NO (I) !~ ...-CL ~ p A BELOI X 12* - HO (i) l I u::, @
~I oo I iCL ~ 016-( H p &,HUT TO l - I '-&* HO (f) !+ t; z~ tll w (f, 88 I.LI a: 016-f G-5 p B BELOI k 9*
- HO I II>
I I-
*C>
I i I I I
I* (, .. '. ~ .*' *. *. LUJJJ-L l -'HOhW I I I I I I I I I I I II I r I I r r*I SOUIII CAROlfNA El[CTRIC & GAS COMPANY 'e_i:J;;y~u o,u..1HO HO tH HO 111:rv 8 = BRIOGIHG VIRGIL C SUMMER NUCLEAR STATION UNIT 11 ewP
-~
IQ LOR
~r'"'-~
OlliJ1116 IISS-200 911 I 1 077 , , C I FIRS! J DICIIS IR[ LISI l Dl&IJS Of tl8l£ !RI! DRIIING NUUU; SERl!S f-l!C-111 GllftUT ASSOCIATES. IHC.
*. ,___________ ELECTRICAL [HGIHHR\ AHO COHJUL UHlS C = CROSSING I fOR DfflNIIION Of CIRCUII CHINMH 0£SIGNIIIONS, SH HIR !Ill£ I.H. - - - - - - "t:&01NG ,. ...
TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS *m*i~t . l1/2_Y.,_ 0 = OIAGONAt J - lHllf BIRRllRS l!RI INCLUO!D IN ORIGINll !UY S!SHM O[SIGM. -- ;.-:01w~'~.!,.~~v,.-'._,,~;,., :_ ~ :-.:::- P = PARAlt[t '0 IHOICllfl IPIClll HOIES SH SH((I IH I AUXILIAHY BUILDltlG
- 0 04HGl--010 l f~trAi71~!i1.SQ~~f QittJ~!_':119~f~~-pf~f,iJ, V = VERTICAL ABOVE 1112' -0" C ~l - - 1 '/1 8 1 -~ '~
CASE OHWING CAHGORY SITUA!IOH (HOT£ 2) YER TIC Al IIOR I ZOH! Al BARRIER NUMB[R REOU I REO REMARKS I HO!( I l COOROINAlfS Sf£ l[G(HO (lEllERS REPR[SEH! ClllNHll Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE !RAYS) OISTAHCE 0 I STAHCl (HOIE 3) 011-A H-9 p A NEXI JO X - 6" HO (!) C 0: Cl Oil B G9 ._ p A HEX l TO X JI .. 311 HO (I;.' 4 ----- ----- *- ~ z w 011 C p A BELOW X 12" - NO ._()
---*--- - -B- 8 (._
011- 0 B8 p A BELOW X 1 '-IO" - HO I
- C.
.,, Oll-E 8-6 C A BllOW X I '-2" NO I C Ul -~
0:
~~ u. 0
();) (') I
.... 0:
U::> Cl
- >~ w 0: .
I- Cl ,c 011-f R5 p B NEXT TO X - I' 6" HO ,I (._ v,z w I NO N N z-c::IQ w
..J 011-G E* 5 p B HEX! TO X ' I' .9"
{l) (_ UQ 0: tn B l ABOVE A AHO B 5" - / HO X GOES TIIROiiGII flR! STOP IH WAil ' ( 011-H 11-5 p BN!HTOX - 6" HO 1,1, (_ Oll-l 11-2 p 8 HEX I TO E I '-2" YES" 0 8 BHOI ( 11" I '**2" YES*
....,c w
CJ 017-K G-2 p 8 HEX I TO £ - 2'-6" YES*
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I
- I SOUTH CAf!ULIHA EUCTRIC& GAS COMPANY
'"'o;y;;* DflA91N0 NO, I 01e '1 D I ht. NO. ,- 17
_'§ _}_ 011 j111161!ss-200 9111 lfGlNO NOTES:. VIRGIL C. SUMNER HUCLUR STATION UNIT 11 B = BRIDGING 1. mu l mm 111 LISI l urns er mu m, mmc *u*m: mm 1-m-111 ELECTRICAL IQ LOtt ft.!:_ - - - GILIUT AUOCIATII, INC. fHGIHf(IH AHO COHSULUHJI C " £ROSS ING !. ro* llflNIIIDN er CIICVII tMlUll t!SIGMlllDNS, Ill flll 1111.[ l.l-4. - IIIIAOltiiO, PA. r-************.:::- - or*T - ;;/,£?, lRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS I Jc /,, *y c:rt.u I-~, ~it:,Wl~fET"l, I *, D : DIAGONAL l * - IHISI UUIUS 1£11 INClvtlt IN OIICIUL Ulf SUl!N IIS ICI. IC.Cl I"-<'. ,.?<' l I P = PARAllH I Q INOltlllS SPltlll MOHS - SIi !Hl!I SN I AUXILIARY BUILDING
- 0 04U&Hl10 -o .. r-Y = VERTICAL ABOVE ll36' -0" *~l cm DRAWING CATEGORY SIIUAll0N (NOi! 2) V[RTICAl HOR I Z0HUl lttti'Ji\ REMARKS HUMB£R INOI( I I C00R0 IHA IE S SH UGEHO(UTlERS REPRESENT CHAHHEl Of CIRCUIIS IN CAELE TRAYS) DISUHCE 0ISIAHCE (HOIE 3) 018-A H-9 p A BH0I l I '-2 * - HO Ci) or:
u, 018-8 J 5 p A ABOVE l * *-2* NO (.) z Ul 079-C H-6 C A ABOVE 8 5 1 -2* - NO (i'; Cp 8 ABOVE X 3 '-0' - NO /5 I (~) D 078-0 J-6 C A ABOVE I 5 1-2* - NO (f;
&ti Cp A BELOI I 3 '-0" - HO IJ (~) D -a. ...
I.II
!~
. t~ 0
- :n .~
078-( G-6 C.P A ABOVE 8 8 '-2
- NO iQ. ffl &ti I+
t; UI C
**)
z~ ~ 078-f J-6 p A ABOVE I 8 '-2 * - NO 3g ~ Cl> Oll-6 H-6 p A ABOVE 8 8 1 -2 * - ' NO ' 018-H f-3 p A BHOI I 12* - NO ( i'; 078-J G-5 p A BH0I I 12 * - NO i I) I.II I-C 0 018-K G-1 C A BELOI l 6" - HO .*,: p A BHOI I 8'-3" - NO iJ ( .. *.:::, ( \::.
*,*:* )
I I I I I I l l U l H(J I I I NOTES:* I I I I I I I I I I LLUJ_LJJJJJ
- 1.1'111!11 1 ln 1! Tlll II ff.fAIC & GAS COHPAHY ';~0 ;r 0
******"°*
_ rJ _"':3_ 011j111161lss-200.9111 jo79-I
'"*"°* .!!!.'!.
ID
-r _ **c***~~*.~~...
IIRG!l C sv111* NUU!lA SllllOH UHi! II 8 = SRl~GfHG ' I. fllSI J IICIIS U[ Ult J IICIIS If Clllf 1111 OIIIIIC IUIIII. 111111 1-111 Ill IQ to* **c '" , ... I CILIUT ASSOCtUn, IMC. C = CROSSING
- 1. fOI DHINIIIU Gf CIICUII CNlU!l IESICUIIOIS, II[ flll !IHI I l-1 Ell c IR, C~l !:'!'!.J:>_ __ ~ /~:IUl .....
D = DIAGONll J. *. !MIS[ IURlllS Ill[ IMtlUD!t ll OIICIIIL nn nm
- l[SICl lRA¥ SEPARATION ANALYSIS ,c .. , T:'. A* ,1_,u* 0 ,.,, ,-{tr P = PlRAllH V = VERIICAL I ,,..)IIDltlllS lr!CIAL IOIIS - II[ INIII SN I AUKILIARY BUILDING ABO\!£ 1136' -0
BARRllK __:. .,W-" **f:*rwr~r*:Pr,~!!,~r~
"°04H51-1110t-,* .,.-,!i'*?,-----.,,,- ;;,r- ** o I - - .P *7i,1,, D f CAS[ ORlllHG CAHCORY SIIUAIIOH (HOH 2) VERTICAL HORI ZOHTAL HUIBER REQUIRED REMARKS ,(NOTE I) CDOROINAT(S SH UGEHD (LUHRS REPRESEHI CHAHHEL Of CIRCUllS IH CASH TRAYS) DISUHC[ DISUHCE IHOIE l) 019-A G-12 C 8 HUT TO X (B VERIICALJ - J'-9" HO ,.,-,. '4) cc ,..,
UI 019-8 l -12 C 8 N£XI TO J (B VERIICAl J - J '-9" HO .I*. \.4)
- z:
UJ 019-C 0-9 p A BHOI l
- I '*I 0" . HO 'I) p A Hllf 10 l - &* NO (Jl 019*0 8-9 p A BELOW J I '*2" - NO (I) w a:
!~ -o..
C>
- u. 019-E G-9 p A BHOI X II* - HO CD
... a: p A HEU 10 X 8" HO (J) <w) D I
i~ Cit ti *
!~ !~)
UI z! !.j 019-1 r-6 C A ABOVE l ' Io* - i NO aUc,a w 019-G 0-6 p A NEIi 10 X - 2'-0" HO 'J) 019-H 0-6 C A ABOVE l 2'-1" - NO (5) (6) D I w 019-J C-6 D A ABOVE l 5" 6" HO m (ti>) 0 r
*a t~
c::'z C/) it-::t ' H~ rx:l 1-',z ! '° 'H Ii ---- I..O '--1 I..O
,'--1 I
0 1-'i I I. I
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ~uurn CAROLINA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY
~
0
~f~; oii"fi,lj:;,;t2:~ -9*11 i;;*o~d o*
LIGE HO NOHS:
- B = BRIOGIHG I. fllSI l IICIII UC llll J 111111 Ir tllll UII tllllU 1011(1; 1!1111 1-114-111 VIRGIL C. SUMIER NUCLEAR STAllOH ELECTRICAL UNIT 11 J* to* fr-!l!l'*'.f~ CILUlll AHOCIUU, IMC.
C = CROSS IHG it,/_/~_ _ _ _ *- _ (MG!Mt~~S-~~/~~~Ulf.lHU I. rOI D[IIIIIIDI or CUCUII Ulllll HIIGNIIIDWI, Ill rsu llll[ I.H. 0 =DIAGONAL *, TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS -1/? /* "'" 'i <*~ ~ I Y,', J77,.
]. *
- IN!I[ 11111[11 l[I[ ucmn II D116!Nll UH 111111 ICIICI.
1u4,1--0'.j-~Hl~n***"*"".; ATll5f.. -.... - ... ICHI P = PARALLEL 4 0 IIDICIII! SPICIIL IDH! Sil !HUI SI- I. AU~ILIARY BUILDING
- 0
.., au.ou ~.!! _ Aflll' r-rr-CH 'JOL V = YlRTICAL ABOVE l!6J' -011 L l't.ul -
- t~l'Yll/i,10 I I t I .,
USE HUMBER DRAWING COORDINATES CATEGORY SH SITUAYIOH (HOH 2) LEGEHD (LETTERS REPRESENT CHAHHEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE i~AYS) DISIANCC VERT ICU HOR I ZOHUL fto"J'i'/lo DISTANCE (NOi£ 31 REURiS IHOI( 11 080--A 1-12 p B BHDI I 12" - HO (i'\ p B ABDYE l 1* - NO S} a: I.O p 8 HUI ID I - J '-J" HO (i),Q) z UJ oeo. e f -11 p B ABOYE I ,. - HO m p B BClDI I 12* - HO C_I) UJ a: D80-C £-ID p B ABOVE I 8 BElOI I I" 12* NO HO (~) (I) li~ Cl D B NEil TD I 2 '-1
- 4 *-** HO ffi. {i)
.m.,, -o.. u.. ... a:
- ~
U::, i! 0.. 080-0 0-6 B ABOVE I r - HO (l. t; tll z~ ~ p 8 BHDI X 12* - NO (I' (lo) 0 I Bg UJ I .-.. a: 080-E K-8 , D NEU TD l
- a*
I I NO (Jl (G,) D UJ 0 r.?.,:::
~:. .... \,.* ' (\,;-. ~.' :.: : '
( . *..
((\::- 11 l ( G 1µ I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I ISOUlH CAROLINA ELECTRIC II GAS COMPANY *-**; ~ "'"" Co _t -~
,,_., D*UIWQ NO.
011j111161/ss-200.9111 l 001 IH. ""* I - 1lP AfV (N NOHs: - 8 = BRIOGIHG C = CROSS ING ' I. 11111 3 IUIIS lR( USI 3 IICIIS If CUL( UII IIUINC 1u1m; suns 1-114-111
- l. fOl 1111111101 GI ClltUII tMlUll DISIGUIIOIS, lfl flll llll! 1.3-4.
VIRGIL C. SUHEA NUCLEAR STAllOH ELECTRICAL UNIT 11 2J.../;.J _ -1 _
. 10 Lo_* L!!!~J*TI*'-j CILHRT AUOCIUES, IHC.
(HCIMf(ltiAHO(OHSULTANll
,.,,.ou*o. ""*
- lRAY SEPARAllOH ANALYSIS .mr--r .:c t/:J'!/...
D = DIAGONAL P = PARAllfl J.
- INIII llUlll! IU! lltlUD!I II GllCIUl Ill! SISIIW DUIGI.
l Q1101u11s SPICIU KOl!l * $!! SHIii IN-I AUXILIARY BUILDING
- 0 ocu111.fF!l~~W,j!f~**"'
...~ /f ,t. * /
1 ,., ) I
!¥f"}!!l~tl4!:.~ / ';I J' oi°TI -
V = VERIICAL ABOVE 1163' O" c ltd M.Afl!_I~ Ql
- lt"* r" o r,;
CASE DRAWING CAHCORY SllUAIIOH (HOH 2) YER! ICAL HOR I ZOHIAL Ul!l!JER HUIBIR REQUIRED REMARKS I HOH II COORD IHAI[ S SH LEGEHD(LHIERS REPRESENI CHAHHEl Of CIRCUIIS IH CAell TRAYS) DISTAHCE OISIAHC( (HOH 3) 081-A H-1 J p 0 HEH TO X " J" HO (i).(2) 0 lOflLLY EflCIOSEO ________ p 0 ABOVE A 11 * - HO (3
. ---- '------- ---3* ----*-~-------
a:
~--- ---- p ANUIJOX - --- 110 (i)' G1.tL (G,) **---*- --- -- -***- *-
0 IU _I!~-'-~!... G-16 p B_ ABOVE X 8"
- HO I5 p . HO I) ------- -- p BNIXIIOI 8 BHOI X I '-I" --- . HO 1 ~-** -- ... 081-C f -14 p B ABOVE X I* - NO. m VI a:: . -~
i!i~ .... p 12" a NO (i) I - 0. I- a: 0 8 8£l01 I - ---------------* 001 .. 7\ Cl
~£ UJ p B BHOI l 12" - NO I)
N, t; VI C 081-0 0-12 I tll UI z:!: p B ABOVE X II' - HO (5 ° 88
..J UJ a: p 0 BHOI l 12" - HO I), (1}_0 IOTALLY EHClOSEO - ---~
a, 081-E ! -12 p B BHOI X 12" - HO (!J P. B ABOVE X r - HO (5) p 0 BHOI l 12" - NO I) ,1) 0 lOIAllY (HClOS!O UJ I- 081-f 8-12 C B BElOI l 3" - NO (! I <D -- C Cl B ABOVE X IO" HO (51 D BELOI l 12' - NO (f , (2) 0 IOIAll Y ENCLOSlO 081-G 8-12 p 8 BHOf X 12* - HO (I) p 8 ABOVE X IO" - NO (s) 081-H B-10 p 0 BHOI l 12" - HO Q) . I' D HEIi 10 X - 6" HO (l) (<o) .. D 081-1 8--8 p 0 H!ll 10 X . 6" HO ffi (G,) ,D
[_J_\J-lNt- Li I I I NII I£ S * - I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I l I I I .L SOlllH CAROI.INA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY'~";~;;" - - , - - 2 ~ *
.?~ :.'!.~ 01q111u:,1!ss-200 9111 loa1 2 '" "° RIV IC, I'"'!!'-- .!-:I VIRGIL C. SUMMER NUCLEAR STAIION 8 = BRIOGING I. fliSI J 016111 IR[ LISI 3 DIGIIS or Cl8lE IRll DRIIIMG NUMB[R; S!il£S !-ll * -111 UNIT #I !!!9 GILBERT AUOCIATES IHC . ?.J::!.!.;~ - ~ -- ~-
- i:~/.
IQ LO* ELECTRICAL EHGIH[(IU AHO COt-fSUU,AHH. C = CROSSING 1 fOR OHINIIION Of CIRCUII CHIMN[l 0£SIGNIIIONS, SH fSIR 118l£ !.H RtAOIHG, ""*
.. TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS 0 = OIAGOIIAl l fH!SE BIRRHRS l[lf INClUOfO IN ORIGIHIL IRIY Slll!W O[SIGN 1 1,.1 .**,u; Y,/',-/1, w O 0H46f--0~ '"'W~r~1-~1~~l-~P!!!1Y1.r:~ '. AUX I LI ARY lllllLDING -- fHOll-i[t" A~OU Df PT O~Tf P = PARALL! l I Q1NOICIHS SPlCIII HOIIS
- SH SH[!! SN I V = VERIICAL ABOVE ~63' .on 1 '.l,l . .~ ,.,,, io a ¢,_, 1/2, CASE ORAIING CHE CORY SITUATION (HOH 2) VERTICAL IIOR I ZOHI AL l'AHHltH HUMBFR REOUIRED R[ MAR~S (NOH ll
- COOROINAIES SH lEGENO (Ll!IERS REPRESENT CHANllEL Of CIRCUIIS IH CABLE TRAYS) DISTAHCE DISTANCE (NOIE 3) 081-K
---*- G-9 -~------
p V A NEXT TO X -
**- ---- J" NO CD -------------------- C w "'"' 081
- l G-10 p
c__ - A NCXI JO X A BflOI X I '-5" J '-2" NO NO CD (j'.
~-
t
--- --- -- ----~- -- - i(5) ---- *-- ------- ----~----
081-N 0 B V A ABOVE X 4 '-0" - NO
*------ C J
NO ,5' t
.,, -081-H G-11 - C 8 ABOVE X IO" 1'--1" 3" '1),(2) D TOTAL LY Et/CLOSED 0 8 ABOVE 0 NO
( w *-*-- *- ~~ -o.. """- ---- --------- 0 0 0 ABOVE A II" 1 '--0" HO eorn TRAYS IO!AlLY INCLOSED I- IX U:::, 0 - - - ------ io.. .,, Ii; Cl w
*w
%~ .J Oo w --- uo 0:: w
*0 *- . --*----~-----
i;::.
( .* .... (. I Il E GII HOI I I I I I *I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SOUTH CAROL TIil ELECTRIC & GAS CO!-ll'AHY ~U
~
OOAW,MO MO,
--;:i-*---.--
_ Olljll1161lSS-200 91lt lt01 I I J0 IM. lol>. I ** v NOTES:* VIRGIL C. SUHER NUCLEAR STATION UNIT #I B = BRIOGIHG I flUI 3 DIGl!S U( USI 3 IIUIS Of Clll( Ill! au11*~ *uHIR; SUit! (-!11-111 IQ LOO fr!-~*.l** '""---_f GILHR T ASSOC IA TU IHC. 1
- ELECTRICAL ~i,J? ( fHGIMf(,tS .&NO CONIUl T ANTI
.... t C = CROSSING l fOl DlflMIIIOI Of ClltUII CHlUll O!SICUIIONS, Sil Ull !Ill( 1.3-1. ---- - - - - - fl(AOINO,PA.
0 = OIAGOHAl P = PARAllH Y = VERII CAL
!. *
- IHISI llllllll Ill! tlCLUO!I II CRIGIUl Ul! SUH
- IISIU I Q1u1c1111 !P!Clll NOIIS. II( !HIii SH-I
-- TRAY SEPARATION A~ALYSIS REACTOR*BUILOIHG ABOVE llf 2' -0" ICAL<
e
~ 44 Mf1 --.:~**jm¥.h[Fl~Fr~n i;w
[ *;::
- Qi ,. , m 1ir,;,* -: -=- f# *~
\f Di /, la!
1'fV Pt.
/' ~ .1~. .'-I-GAS( ORUIHG CATI GORY* SITUATION (HOH l) YER II CAL HOA I ZOHIAL IARRttff HUM8£R REQUIRED REMARKS tHOIE ll COORO IHA IE S SH UGEH O(UTTERS AEPR[S(Hf CHAHHCL Of CIRCUITS IN UBU JRAYS) 0 ISTAHCE OISTAIICE (HOH 3)
I I 01-A 0-1 p 8 ABOVE E 12*
-- e*- HO Ha 0)
I . ( 2) D I
. - - *------ (a>)
I p E Nut TO I I a: p - a* r I _(2' l : - - ------ 8 NEXT TO l HO H1 p B ABOVE I 12* - (2
---I 01-B . K-9 p B ABOVE f I '--I* - HO JI C 8 BHOI I I '-J* - HO I . 21 p E NEXT TO I . &" HO I (2)
I
~~ C, IX p
p 8 IICXT 10 l B ABOVE I I '*I* 6" NO HC fl, 2)
'21
- u. --
I 0..
... a:
c.>:::, Cl col ni
~o.. ... tD II)
- z -
- z ......_, I 01-C K-10 p B ABOVE E E HUT 10 I 6"
6" 1 HO HO J I .ffi
~
I' 88 ' co N, I II
- a:
m t p B ABOVE l 8 ABOY[ I 6" I '-1
- 110 NO (21 2
p 8 HUI lO I - e* HO (I; I 01-0 K-17 C 8 ABOVE I &* - HO ii 3 I~ D
......... p C
8 ABOVE E
£ BHOI l I '-1" a*
NO HO J I 31
~
(I) () 0 C, p E HUT TO I - s* HD P.l2J ~ D p B ABOVE l I,_ 1" - HO (i'J p B NUT TO l - 6" !lO (I}
. I I 01-( 11-1
- p B A~OVE ( I'- l" . HO (3 .(G,)
-- 0 p E IIElT 10 I 8 ABOVE I I '-1" .
HO HO (2
.l2) ((p) D p B HUI JO I - 6" NO ,(I .m
I LLl 11 LE GE°lfO I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SUUTH CAROL !HA ELECTRIC & GAS COMPANY , - * * ;~ <HWO
*3>~
O*AWIMO HO I IH ""* ID
. .V 8 = BRIDGING C = CROSSING HOHS:*
I I mr J DIUIS U( llSI J IICIIS OF Cllll 1111 DIAIIIC IUIIIA: SUl!I .1-714-UI. 1 IOI DIIIWIIIOI Of CIICUII CNIOll BISICWIIIONI, SH FSU JIil! 1.3-C. VIRGIL C. SUMMER NUCLEAR SIATIOH. ELECTRICAL UNI! II
' i;:'f,./P ~"!.-! .** L**- _ _ _ ...!""-n 0 11j1J1J61Iss-20~-9111 j1oi 2 CILIIERT ... ssoc,uu. ,HC.
rweINH1UAwocoH1utuNu llltAOIMQ, P'A. TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS ,./~;,z-D = DIAGONAL l * - IH!Sf UIIIUS IU! IIClUD!t II ORIGllll 1111 SlSIII HSIU. ICAU f .:... /r'" f-4 .I~; Ufl) / P = PARAllfl 4 INOltlllS SPltUI MOIi$. Ill SHfll SN-I REACTOR BUILDING ~4\~-r\~~!1* y cl H ~ .., .. ,. OAtr: L 14' .. I l~l'lfol iv1ITT~
****o""- - *****
r:: I I I
- D ,r 1*m * * * * * ,.. .. ,
Y = YERIICAL ABOVE 1112' -0" CAH HUIB[R DRU ING CAHGORY SIIUAJIOH (HOIE 2) VERTICAL HORI ZOHU DISIAHC[ OISIAHCE (HOH 3) L ltou'Wto R£MAR~S 111101[ ll COORD IHA IE S SH lfG[HD(lEIHRS R£PRES£HT CHANNEL Of CIRCUIIS IN CABLE TRAYS) i-- I 01-f f -15 p ( BHOI l 12* - HO ::P (Co) D p E NEIi TO l - I '-J* NO J\ (lo) D
<< p B HEH TO E - I '-6" NO (3) *' '* '2:1 C,
z p 8 NEXT TO X - 12" NO I UJ
- -- C B BHOI X I '-10" - NO ' 1) ({p) D 101-G C-15 p 8 BHOf l 10" - HO .1.) (to) ol ii p 8 HEH TO £ - g* NO iJ1 UJ a:
p E HEU TD X - 1 '-6" NO If ((0) li~
-a..
C,
µ.
p E BELOI X 2'-5" - NO : i) ((Ji)
.... a: ...j.,,
u::, @ (X) jj;llL ~ ? I- C, u,z Z-N Bg UJa: '° - m ' i i UJ I-
*0 I
I C (. *,*-: *.
- }*.>_
(,* ..'.*****
,, I I Il f 6 H~L LIil), J _I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I f T I sourn CAllOl1Rl HECTRIC& GAS COMPANY 'e'"~~*"*u
_otJ ~~ o*AWIMO NO, IM. NO. 011j 11116'fss.200 9111 1102 1 ,0. I
'!!'f.
C YIRGtl C. SUlMER NUCLEAR SUJIOH. UNIT II I. flm J 11;111 U£ UII 3 IICIII tr Clll( 1111 HIIING NUH(R: IUIU r-m-111. 10
- 0 * ~-'"'~!..~ GILIUT ASSOCIATES, IHC.
B = BRIDGING t'c:!..P
', ELECTRICAL (HOIHft'tlAHOCONIULfAHU C = CROSSING I. IOI l!flNIIIOI or CIRCIIII CMIH(l 1mm11ou, SU fSU !Ill( 1.3-f. - - - - - - - "tAOIMO, t'A.
TRAY SEPARAHON ANALYSIS euu -a10 * -r.. o,;. I*-* ,.,. ... - - o,,., -oa.,r - D = DIA GOH Al J - IMISI 11111111 IU! INCLUOII ,. 811CIUl un IUl(I tlSICW. *.. ICAU ~-',' /,.~ ,/,IJ/ ~,;!.*7~ P = PARAtLH I O INDICIIIS SPIC Ill NOii! - SI! SKIii !W-l 0 REAClOR BUILDlttG " 0 mrr..!~f~~f t.~Wr~~~,!~Fr.'f Y = VERIICAl ABOVE 1136'*0" C 1'1'11 I - * ~ r,,,. D 'r *, ORA II HG CAHG0RY YERIICAl HOR IZ0HTAL BARR llH HUMBER SIIUAII0H (NOH 2) REOUIRE0 REMARKS tN0H I) CO0R0IHAHS SH l£GEN0 (UTHRS REPRESENT CHAHHH0F CIRCUIIS IN CABLE TRAYS) 0 ISfAHCl DISTANCE (HOH J) __!.0?-A r -1 p A HUT TO X - 12. HO G)
*--- D p A ABOVE 0 12' - HO J) ..,z C,
p D NEXI 10 l -
-- 6' I *.. 3* HO 10) ((o) 102-8 C-14 p ANEUI0X - HO I --- ---- p p
A ABOVE D D HUT 10 X
'*-1*
6" HO HO JI ((I))
- ------ D - J - ----~----------- D ~
r'-15 C D ABOVE l I '-2' HO J
"' 102--C ls~ -a.
UJ ti: 0 C D BElOI X I *-s*
-- - HO r.m ---- D I-"'
u ::> @-- C A ABOVE D 2 '-6', HO l Q. p
"'ti I.II "',c A HUT ID l l '-9" HO !, %~
oc ~
~ I uc - I 02--0 H-15 p A BHOI l e* - / HD 11.m a,
p A ABOVE 0 ** - HD '1 , D fOIAll Y ENCLOSED p A HUT TO D - 6' HO 1, 102-( K-10 p A HEIi TO X - -2. HO I p A ABOVE D 12* - HO J UJ I-
,c p D NEXT to X - I '-5* HO (J CJ I
I llEGlH-~TI NOTES.* I II I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SOIITII CAROLINA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY ***;~:** *u 00UIH0 HO,
*~v.v ~.)_ ~~146.tiSS-200 9111 1131 I IH. MO. O!V jt 8 = BRIOGING C = CROSS ING I flASI 3 01611! IRE UST 3 DICIIS Of Clell TAIT DAIIIM& NUN!lR; $!RIIS E-!H-Ul 1 FOR D!rlMIIIOM or CIRCUIT CHIMNIL OfSIGNIIIONS, SH rsu lllll 1.3-t.
VIRGIL C. SUMNER NUCLEAR STATION ELECTRICAL TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS UNIT #I IQ LDO I? }:I_f_ ___ -r _
~~.!*!!.**~,GILBERT ASSOCIATH IHC. ~ fHGIHf~:SA!~~/~:~Ul fAHU 0 = DIAGOtlAI
- IHISI UIRl!RS l!RE IMCLUOCO IM ORIGINll !All SISHN DESIGN. - - * ,cur ~,.._ *~r-f
!!~~;:r :~~~~-i~~~i[f[~µ-~f ', ) 0 ,.,/ ~/,,/,,-
INTERMEOIA1E BUILDING 0 P = PARAllfl t Q1NOIClllS SP£Clll MOHS. SH SHH! SN I *:
~-;- l.a-*1,111 ~ ,,, ,1,,
V = VERT ICAl ABOVE *412* O" CASI HUMBER ORAWlllG CA IE GORY SIIUATIOH (NOTE 2) VERT ICAl IIOR I ZOHTAl ;t;;,'lto REMARKS ( HOH I) coono1t1AHS SH tEGENO (LETHRS REPRESENT CHANNEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) DISTANCE 0 I STANCE (HOT£ 3) 131-A 0- 16 p 8 ABOVE X 17" HO G) p BNEXITOX __6" NO CD U1
"' p 12" - NO (D (2) l!I z
8 BELOW X *----~-- -- w . ..
.Jl!*L E-15 p 8 ABOVE E I '-2" - HO E TO!AllY ENGLOSEO p B H£Xl TO E . I '-3" HO [ TOTALLY ENCLOSED --~-- - *--- -I - -
JI -C U 14 p B ABOVE E I '-2" .. NO l TOTALLY ENCLOSED p 8HEXTJO[ I '-3" HO E TOIALLY ENCLOSED
"' 0"'
Ul
!~ ~ f mfEr~ I l*-1*
D8 ~ m *- C.
...-a.
I I
- lL U::, "' UJCl I JI -0 C-1 J p B HEX! TO X . 6" HO i co
(") I
~Q..
I-- <.!I v>z UJ
"' 0 0
B ABOVE X B BELOW X 12" 12" 6" 6" HO NO w t . w z - ....J co w I-' Uc, a, IX 131-E C -11 p B NEXT TO E
- I '-3 NO E TOTALLY fNClOSEO u B OHOW E 11" I '-3" NO F TOTALLY ENCLOSED 131-f f -12 p B ABOVE E I '-2" . HO l TOIALL Y ENCLOSED p 8 NEXT 10 E - I '*2
- HO f TOIALLY EHCLOSEO UJ Cl 131-G f -10 p B ABOVE E 3 '-3" . HO E IOTALL Y ENCLOSED C B ABOVE E 12" . HO I TOIALLY £HCLOSEO p 2 '-5" . X TO!AUY INCLOSED
-131-H- - -0 1 p
B ABOYI X BHEXTTOX - 6" HO HO {IJ, X TOTALLY ENCLOSED C. 131 -J f 13 C 8 BELOW X J" . NO *----- B ABOVE X 4" . HO
--- - - - - C --- -* *----
( I I I Il I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 1~uurn CAROLINA ELECTRIC&GAS COMPANY R;;~~,;'." ....... MO. * ...... LEGEND NOTES:* _<j! _"!-! 01J 11 11161Jss.200 9111 jtJ1 21D VIRGIL C. SUIIIIER NUCLEAR STATION UNIT fl ...!* LOO *** , . . . . . . I CILIEltT ASSOCIATES, IMC. 8 = BRIDGING I. rim J IICIII Ill 1111 l IICIII If CULi m, UAIIH IUIIU: 1nm (-211-111 C = CROSSING ' 1. ru em111101 Of tlltUll tHlO!l DISICllllONI. SU rsu TUI( 1.3-f. ELECTRICAL "5'~/P__ __ -~ _ ~ fHCIH((IIA.H:OCONJUL1AMU flllAOINO, PA.. TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS I~;, . .J=,~:r~,, r/2r/_*, D = DIAGONAL 3. *
- IHISI IIUIIII Ill[ IIClUl[t II 0llCtlll JUI l!Slll t(SICI.
IO INIERMEOIATE BUILOIHG
,cu* ** 0 OU41U-02t)I -IN01Ntt.-Ai-P ~1 * .,,, ~DWAOl;t' - - Olri - DATf -
Wul- IQ~l~!if:J*"' ~ *" I I I P = PUAllEl 1181Cllfl srttlll 10111 - Ill SHH! SN-I , I/ .. V = YERIICAL ABOVE II 12'
- O" C CASE ORA II HG CAHGORY SITUAllOH (HOIE 2) VERT ICAl HORI ZOHU l BARRltK HUMBER REQUIRED REMARKS l HOil 11 C0ORD1t1Al£S SH LEGEH0 (UlllRS REPRESENT CHANNEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) DIST AHCE 01 STANCE I HOil 3) 131-K G-11 C B ABOVE l s* - HO 5) a: I Jl-l G-1 p A ABOVE l 10" - HO \S) t!I z ---
w p A NH! lO X - ~ -** r HO I© -*- e--- D A ABOY( l 10* HO (S) (0) 0 e* -- 131-11 J-JO CD A BEL0I C 2 '-3"
- HS*
.,, IJI-H l-1 CV A BEL0I I (I VERIICAl) &" - NO' j) w a:
i!'l~
-a. C>
u. p A HE IT TO X - 6" NO (i)
... a:
00: u:, ia. ,.: .,, fi1 I ~ ZI
... t!I v,z z- ~
I ag I N' I ll
~
w
~
C>
I
*1 *I r;;;J' {"""
I ILEGE.I HDI I l I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I 11 SOllTH CAROLINA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY 0 o*AWIHO HO.
./>. !°1.d. 01q111J61!ss-200.9111 1132 IH NO. *iv j c, '".!~*ii HOJES*
- _ 1 VIRGIL C. SUMMER NUCLEAR STATION UHIT #I 9 = BRIOGIHG I FIRS! 3 DIGITS UE us, J DIGITS or CIBll TRI! ORIIING NUMB!R; S[Rl£S E-214-111 r,E<* GILBERT AUOCIUU IMC C = CROSSING l FOR DfflNITION or CIRCUIT CHINN[l O[SIGNIIIOMS, $£1 rsu !Ill[ 1,3-L ELECTRICAL f.Wp_
IQ LO*
~ ~~
fHGIHfffU4HOCOH1Ult AHTS* fl.lAOIHG, P4. 1 TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS I,.b.'. /r ,<c~L-'f: .,.,,, , 1/~r /77 0 = DIAGONAL l. * - IHISI IIUIIU lfRI INClUOIO IN ORIGINll !RU SYSTIM OISIGN IC All P = PARAllfl ' 1 0 INOICIIIS SP!Clll NOIIS - SIi SHFII SN-I INTERMEDIATE BUILOING
- O OHlSI--Om!li:t,***""'7 - cfrf - - **Tr -
lllltt~J;.!;!. l:_ ,.,.,. Q..lllf ~yru.n( CH nnL ! _ ~ ~ V = Y[RTI CAL ABOVE 412'
- 0" I; 0 *"IJ,/10 B I I 1~,.. \91 t:ASE HUMBER ORAIIHG l<HOH ll COOROIHAl[S CATEGORY SI TUATIOH ( NOTE 2)
SH lEGEHO <LETTERS REPRESENT CHANNEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) YERIICAL HOR t ZOHTAL DISTANCE ltaWlto 0 I STANCE (NOTE 3l REMARKS I 32-A J-11 C A BELOW X 4* - HO 0 ( C A ABOVE l IO" - NO '~) C. a: Cl z UJ 132-8 f -II p 8 ABOVE X I '-IO" - NO (1). l TOTAll Y ENCLOSED I'. p 8 NEXT TO X - 6" HO 1(1),(2) l Cl) uJ 0: i li~
-a.
0 u. cor ...
._ 0:
U:::, c> ii a. UJ Cl) v,z *..J (') ._ <.O I UJ w z-oo UJ w U c 0: a, I I UJ
*0 I
C. (
( I-I,
/'-c:-,
[_JJLLi Iirk _I -.,I _!NOii [ !' I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I . I "'L SOllTII CAR01. I NA ETECTR IC & GAS COMPANY r 1~" o~T~l~6Js-s. _0A ~,If>-. o*rn*o NO,
?00 911 I SN j 1:Ll NO_fcV I l,-
VIRGIL C SUMMER NUCLEAR STAIIOH
** LO* _!c~~-**1!.!:-:J GILBERT ASSOCIATES UHIT II B = BRIOGING I flRSl 3 DIGIIS IRI LISI 3 D"IIS Of Cllll IRII DRUINC NUU!R, S!RlfS !-114-111 IHC .fJff'__ ~-.- . ~1~ EHC111f~:s11 ~~~G~~:~uL T.. Hrs
- ELECTRICAL C = CROSSING 1 IOR D!f INll lOM Of CIACUII CHINNH D[SIGNII IONS. SI[ f!U lllll 8 H TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS
. rnrsr umos ,m INCLUO!O IN O!IGINll Ill! SYSfU OISICN. . -- -*
0 = DIAGONAL
- or,., -0*o.-H* - ] IOlf [; I . ~-,'~ r.*l'J, i'/l, IHT[RMEOIAJE.BUILDING 04H61*010 -.fHG1Wti,.-.-ai* .. 111ou1 0 ~!fS!!l-9J~f:~fi~31~**r.~F' p?;N~
P =*PARALLEL Q1NOICIIII SPICIII MOHS - S(f IH!fl SN I V = Y!RIICAl ABOVE 1136' O" . ICl' /11 I* 8 *+ If) CASE OR AW IHI: CAHGORY .SIIUAIION (HOH 2) VERT IC Al HOR I ZOHTAL BARRlttt HUM Bf R REOUIREO Rf MARKS
;( HOH I) COORO INA 1l S SH l(GlH O (UTTERS REPR£S£Nl CIIANIIH OF CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) OISIANCE 0 IS UNCl (HOH J) 133-A H-10 CV A NEil JO X (A VERTICAL/ - -- *---- 2 '-6" NO CD *---
(_ C A DHOW X IO" HO 1(1) (_ tr. CJ z - - - - ------ -- -- ----*---- ----------- w I JJ-B H 13 C. V A HEX! 10 X I A VERTICAL) I '-2" NO I IOTALlY ENCLOSED I JJ-r. [ 14 C A ABOVE I 1" NO (5) c:._ w a: -- ls~ Cl
- <L u. ... a:
u::, Cl
- , <L a:
.,, z w ... CJ ...
w z - _, oo w Uc,
-"' a: -
w
,c Cl
~ C") C: C/l
!s -*--- - - - -------*-- --~----
>-3 ::s: t;rj -*---- ----* -- --*- ****--- - ---------------* r' z *- *--- --- '° ,o' f--3 --.J '°
--.J 0
I f r'
_L~-h~Hl- I !_ _LHJ-J_lJ I I I I I I l I I I LW_LLLLL1 L
* *,mi III rrnrii1HA fl fCIRlr& GAS COMPANY l_iigf:,iL Ot11A*111Q JIIO.
o-;;-fi.,161!ss. ;,oo 9111 I IM, JIG. 1135 I It I flRSI J 01611! Ill llSI J OIGIIS Of CUii till DUIIN& NU*a!l; 11111! f-114-111 VIRGIL C SUIIER NUCLEAR SIAIIOH UHII II IQ""' ,*-~j,""-:1
--=t ; .~
8 = BRIDGING GllllUT AlSOCIUU, IHC.
. i?WJ~ -
ELECIRICAL f HGtHH II AND CONWI. UHTS
=
C CROSSltlG 1 FOR Dlfl~l110N Of c1acu11 CHINNll Df!IGNIIIONS. !fl 1111 llllf l.l-4. - - - - - - Al'AOIJtG-.~A. IRAY SEP ARA Tl ON ANALYSIS 0 = DIAGONAi l * !HIil !IRRl!IS IIRI INCLUDID IN ORIGINIL IRll 11!111 DISIGN *m* /,i,/6:c-- o+:J.I J/!q~, 0 !rf~~,f-!1-'f~~J***,-*otpfm~ INHRHEOIA IE BUIIDING
- 0 0U46 .*-020 . ,-KG1Wr:i,t"*rl'1!il.Wii - OCrf 0.oi -
P = 'PA RALL fl 4 INOICll!S IP!Clll NOl!I SIi SHI 11 IN- I Y = Y[RIICAl ABOVE 1163' -0" 'r_lj ' :;:!e /I~ .,- I CASE ORAWIHG CA l[ GORY SIIUAllOH (NOi! 2) YERI ICAL HORI ZOH!Al BARRl[H HUM8£R REQUIRED Rf MARKS
!HOil II COORO IHA l[ S SH lf G!HO (llllERS REPRESEHI CHAHNH Of GIRCUIIS IN CABlf IRAYS) 0 ISIANC( 01 STANCE (NOTE 3) 135 -A l u p A 8£LOW l 12" - HO © C .-* C A 8£LOI l 12" NO I) t ex C,
- z: *--*
w I 35- B
---- -~-----* G I* p A ABOV[ l ----12'----- .. HO -
( p A BHOI X I '-3" - HO 1) ('
*- -~---- -
Vl I UJ ex lil:1
-CL 0
u.. t--o::
!;l U::, ....i .....,,:z:
Vl Vl w z: - 00 _J w U Cl a: a, UI 0 r--- ----*
I It E 6 LJLLJ;Ar~I_Ul_[I I I I I I [I I I I I I I I I*I S0U111 CAflOl. lNA Hf CTR IC & GAS COMPANY ~ "
~ ;;-;,i't%Jss _200 O*AW,HGHO, q111 ht. *u.o-T l111 I I Tc.,
tllY VIRGll C, SUMMER HUClEAR SUTIOH UHIT #I
~~~ -r[*!!~.I_. CllaERT ASSOCIUU IMC 8 = BRIDGING I f IRS! l 0IGIIS Ill llll l 01&1!$ Of Cl!l[ Ull 0RIIING Nu*eo; SEWS 1-114--111 IQ LOO J{l:/.P_ _ __
rt;~ ELECTRICAL fNGINHIU.lt.NOCOHSULr'_,,HI$, C = CROSSING I FOR 0fflNlll0N Of CIICUll CHINNH 0[IICMIII0MS, SH ISIR ll8ll l.l-4. ftfAO*HG, ,.,_ TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS 0 = OIAG0HAl J !HIS[ IIUHRS 1111 INClU0I0 IN 0RICIMll 1111 SYSII* DESIGN. -* --*--- ICALf ,r u:P.- O~J/ *01/?7
~iw~,\f~ 1~f!!n~J!fEl"' ~fl~t1~~~
- O 04446 ..{)]O fHc*,.;,1,.-... ?.:jio7.A- - t)f,.f - -Di°'ff -
P = PARM! [l 4 QIMOltlllS SPltlll MOHS - Sfl IHlf! IN-I - PENEIRAIION ACCESS Al!EA t, t:'"' '/1, 0
-*, 0 V = VERIICAl ABOVE 412' O" '.Ji .
- CAS! DRAWING CA IE GORY S,ITUAT ION (HOH 2) YERllCAl HOR I lOHTAl lJARRltR HUNB[ R REQUIRED REMARKS
( NOT( ll COORO IHAIE S SH LEGlH O (lETIERS REPRESENT CHAHHfl Of CIRCUIIS IH CABLE TRAYS) OISTAHCE 01S TAHCE (HOIE l) 1* 1-A *---* G-11 0 8 AHOY! l I ' 9"
--- l' 6" HO ©, l IO!All Y EHClOS[O L Cl z
uJ
-*- *--~ - - -----
f------- --* V> uJ z V> a: Oo 0u.
-CL --- ~I' ... a:
U::, 0 iCL UJ 14-V, I , - Cl W, V>z uJ I '°' Z - ..J oo uJ ; uo a: Ul C
- - ~------- ------- - ---*-------- ------------- ~---- f-.---*---- - ---- - - - * - - -----------------
_LlrlrjJ-lJ_Jiial, E!*I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I I SUU 111 CARUl.lHA ELECTRIC& GAS COMPANY 1>:*;~
!!{}
CH*U ****oWO
'_'."_,s_ oi~;~16tlss-200 9 111 II<),
I161
' ~
1 C:
*tv 8 =
C= BRIDGING CROSS ING
' l I 11111 3 IICIJS ur LISI J !ICIIS er CUL[ 1111 DIIIIWG IUl!IR; 1!111!
FOi DHIIIIIOI Of CIICUII CHIINH OISIUl!IOU, S(( rm um
- J-l, f-lll-111 YI RG IL C SUMMER NUCLEAR SIAIIOH ELECTRICAL UHi! #I
~* LP KvJ .'-*Jt"'i G!LIUT ASSOCIATES. IHC, fHG!Hff*S AHO COHiULUHH Jlf AOIMO, ,.,..
TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS ~- ':-~/,...~-A~i5c: O'f'tl s;,,**,r/;,, 0 = OIAGONAt ) * - IM!!I Utll!IS l!I[ IICIUDII IN OIIGINll UII IISIIM HSIU O IIOICIIIS
~ct~r1-~\1~~ffw f£fill~
FUEL IIAUDL I HG BUILDIUG ~44461-070.J:I"'. iHG"1N,i,.-,.~,." *~ - *ofrl *- -oi"Yf - P= PARAILH l Sf!Clll 101!S SH SHH! S" I 1 1 Y= YERllCAL ABOVE 412' -0" AtlD 1136' -0" US[ DRAWING CAHGORY S11UA1 IOH (HOH 2) VERIICAL HOR I ZOHIAl o,nrl ltH NUMBER REOU I REO RI MARKS
;I HOH II COORO INA l£ S SEE l EGE NO ( l El HRS RE PRE SEHi CIIANHEL Of Cl RCU 11 S IN CABLE TRAYS) OISTAHCE DIS!AHCE (HOH ])
161 A H I~ p A BELOI X 12" - HO ( I)
*---~-
t ex - - - --------- u, z uJ
-A- ...
uJ
!~ 0 IX 1-- IX L)::, 0 ii!"- .,,UJ .... ~
1-- CJ v,z z-co "'
...J UJ ' I I
uo
-.., a:
I-0 g; ~ ----- ------ --- ---------- G) trj C: [fl zt::::I - - * - * ----- ----- ... 1-3 ::.:: --*--- ------- - - - - - - - - trj f-' z I.O 1-3
-.,~~--- - ---- ---- **- ---------*-----------------
I.O ----- ---- - -- --~-------~---------- " "II.O 0 f-' (/}\:
- ,*.* r,.. :,
(-:c**:: I ll[G+J1.:J IHOHr I: *I I I I I I I I I I I LLtLLLLIJJJI * ,-'"'7,, < I. '* , 'I Pd fl [Cllll[& r,AS COHPANY , **v~
~DjJ j C HKD ~~J_
OIUWIHQ N<), oll , 11116 i!ss-200.9111 1162 I
-J SH. HO. -T lll(V I C.
t -- VI RGI l C SUO[R NUCLEAR SIAIIOH UNIT #I CILIERT ASSOCIATES, IHC. B= BRIDGING I FIRS! J DIGIIS IR[ UST J DIGITS Df CIII! Till ORIIIN, NUW!U, S!RI!! 1-11
- Ill IQ LD* ' , ** ' " ; ' ~
ELECTRICAL f?!:-!_P - - (HCIHf(lt\ AHO COHSULTANU C= CROSS ING l FOR DHINIIION Of CllCUII CHUN£l O[SIGNl!IONS, SH fSll ll!lf I.J- *. ,.lADIHO, PA
. TRAY SfPARATlON ANALYSIS f !!~Fl~f:~F-ifi~~IJri~,v,,
0 = 0 I AG OH Al ). * !HIS! etU!IRS IIRI INClU0£0 IN ORIGINIL !RIY SISIIN OISICN. ICAlt J~ /r. /q_£1. 01' l / 1/H/1}' P= PARAllH
- 0 INOICIHS !P[Clll NOH!* !£1 !Hfll SN I FUEL HANDLING BUILDING 0 V= VER! I CAL ABOVE 463' -0" :.:
(',flf.11 I* . G- /11 II B ..,. CASE OR AWING CAHGORY SITUATION (NOH 2) VERTICAL HOR I ZOHIAL U~ttNIER HUMBER REQUIRED REMARKS
<NOif I\ COORO IUA HS SE£ l£G£H O ( lE ll£RS REPRESENT CHANNEL Of CIRCUITS IN CABLE TRAYS) DISTANCE 0 I STANCE (NOTE J) 162-A G-15 p B ABOVC X 9" - - NO © ('.
p 8 BELOW X 12" - HO (I) ('_ a: Cl --~~ z p (I) w G- I 3 8 HEX! TO X . 12" NO p - (i), (2)
- B BHOI X 12" HO (,
w a:
, II ~:g C> u.. - 0. ..... a:
u::, 0 ...,.,, co/ 61"- ' ! i..-- 71 u>z
- I- Cl w
z - ...I w e>o w co Uc a: a, w
*a t
_j
i S0!1111 CAROLINA tlfCTRIC & GAS COMPANY I VI RGI l C SUNIIE R HUClE AR SIA II OH UH 11 I I l---'-~-+-.....t-~~...--.,._,....,_ _.____,,.,...-.:;,--i
;i ELECTRI CAL ,l TRAY SEPARATION ANALYSIS SPECIAL NOTES *i** *.1 .'l ,\ .~' *i . NOTES fOR SN- I
. '~ p: I FIRE Will HOI PROPAGAI( 00111 OR HORIZOHIAl
"'z UJ 2 COHIROl OR IHSIRUNEHI !RAY HAVE YERY LOI IHIERHAl !HEAGY UVHS IHfRHOR(,
ENERGY IS NOi AVlllABlE 10 IHIIIATE A FIRE 3 !RAYS ARE lO!AllY (HClOSEO AO(OUAH SPACIAL SEPARAIIOHS IIAIH!AIHED 5 OHlY OHE CltANHfl or ClASS IE CIRCUITS HFECIEO THEREFORE. SYSH* SUHY fUHCIIOHS I IUINUIHEO
- 6. This analysis concluded a barrier was not required. However, a barrier was subsequently installed in compliance with the licensing connnitrnent to provide barriers for multiple separation violations as described
.~ in paragraph 8.3.1.4.1, Item 4.
w C) (;; ~ .'; ', (.*.*.*,. (:(.*.**: (
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8D-i Appendix 8D Analysis of the Acceptable Voltage Range to be Applied to the ESF System
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8D-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8D-1 APPENDIX 8D ANALYSIS OF THE ACCEPTABLE VOLTAGE RANGE TO BE APPLIED TO THE ESF SYSTEM 8D.1 CRITERIA This calculation was based on two criteria:
- The voltage at each piece of safety related equipment must be within the safe operating range for that piece of equipment.
- The voltage of the offsite sources must be sufficient to operate the required loads in the event of an accident without actuating the degraded voltage relays.
NOTE: This section is being retained for historical purposes only. 8D.2 METHOD In preparation for the development of the calculations, a Feeder/Load Data Base was developed and verified. This data base contains information on the characteristics of the safety related loads and their feeder circuits, including the demand load for various plant operating conditions. The characteristics for the system equipment and materials, such as transformers and cables, were taken from the as-built data for the specific equipment and materials. The system calculations were performed using electrical analysis software. The first calculation established a base case model of the electrical power distribution system. This model includes the existing transformer tap settings which include a 2.5% boost for the 480 volt unit substation transformers 1DA1, 1DA2, 1DB1, and 1DB2. For unit substations, 1EA1 and 1EB1 and for the emergency auxiliary and safeguards transformers, the taps are set at the nominal position. Throughout the calculation process, the transformer tap settings were reviewed to determine if revised settings could improve the overall performance of the system. (Reference Calculation DC-820-001.) The next calculation modified the base case system model to evaluate the system under the worst case loading conditions. This condition results from the large break LOCA accident during the injection phase. The source voltage in this model was manually reduced and the system was repeatedly analyzed in an iterative process until the worst case motor terminal voltage was reduced to 90% of its rated voltage. The motors in V. C. Summer Station were specified and designed for steady state operation with a terminal voltage in the range of +/- 10% of their rated voltage. The voltage at the motor control center (MCC) buses was also checked and found to exceed 420 volts.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8D-2 This ensures that there is sufficient voltage for the pick-up of the MCC contactors. The resulting system model established that a voltage equal to or greater than 90.2% on 7.2 kV buses 1DA and 1DB is sufficient to ensure adequate voltage at the terminals of the safety related motors. Since the purpose of this part of the evaluation is to determine the minimum 7.2 kV bus voltage to provide adequate terminal voltage for all Class 1E loads, the number of buses connected to the offsite source and the voltage of the offsite source are not significant. The results of this model are summarized in Table 7.3.3 of Calculation DC-820-001. With the minimum 7.2 kV bus voltage established, the next effort determined the minimum setpoint for the degraded voltage relays. Since these relays have a tolerance on both their calibration and operation, a detailed evaluation of the total tolerance band was performed. This determined a total tolerance band of +/- 0.328%. Since the relay must operate before the 7.2 kV buses reach the minimum acceptable voltage, the setpoint value must exceed the minimum value by an amount at least equal to the tolerance. To provide both a margin and consistency with the previous settings, the setpoint was established at 91.34% of rated voltage. (Reference Calculation DC-820-001.) Based on the degraded voltage relay setting, the tolerance on the relay calibration and operation, and the response of the SCE&G transmission system to a trip of the V. C. Summer Nuclear Station, the next part of the effort determined the minimum acceptable offsite source voltages during normal plant operation. Studies of the transmission system under extreme loading and system configuration conditions have determined that 230 kV system voltage will dip to 95.5% of the pre-trip voltage in the event of a unit trip. After less than 3 seconds, the system voltage will recover to 97.1% of the pre-trip voltage. Similarly, the 115kV system voltage will dip to 95.6% of the pre-trip voltage in the event of a unit trip and will recover in less than 3 seconds to 97.3% of the pre-trip voltage. Electrical analysis software was used to model the effects of motor starting conditions due to an accident loading sequence on the 230 kV and 115 kV offsite sources. Based on the tolerance band of the relays and the motor inrush conditions, the 7.2 kV bus voltage must be at least 93.9% of rated voltage prior to motor starting to avoid relay actuation (including a 1% margin which was determined to be unnecessary subsequent to the completion of the calculation). The minimum pre-accident voltage is also dependent on the number of plant buses connected to each offsite source. In a further evaluation, the capabilities of the various combinations of safeguard transformers and the voltage regulating transformer were determined and combined with the worst case voltage dip resulting from a unit trip. The results of these evaluations are summarized in Table 8.2-2. (Reference Calculation DC-820-001.) The final part of the analysis determined the maximum allowable offsite system voltages. Additional system models were developed with electrical analysis software for plant operation in modes 5 or 6, cold shutdown or refueling. One model evaluated the system using the emergency
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8D-3 auxiliary transformer, XTF-31, as the source and the second model used the safeguard transformers, XTF-4 and 5, as the source. The loading consisted of the minimum set of equipment that would be expected to be operational during plant shutdown and only one of the two trains of ESF equipment was supplied from each offsite source. The models were repeatedly analyzed with increased source voltages until the worst case motor terminal voltage reached 110% of motor rated voltage. The results of these models are summarized in Table 8.D-2, and the maximum voltage limits are included in Table 8.2-2. 8D.3 CONCLUSION As described above, the 7.2 kV bus voltage must be at least 90.2% of rated voltage to ensure the voltage at motor terminals exceeds the rated minimum motor voltage for steady state operation. This voltage is also sufficient to ensure MCC contactor pick-up. (Reference Calculation DC-876-007.) The setpoint for the degraded voltage relays must be at least 90.528% of rated voltage to ensure that the relays actuate when the 7.2 kV bus voltage reaches the minimum defined above. The actual relay setpoint is 91.34% of rated voltage. The offsite system voltages must exceed the minimum values listed in Table 8.2-2 (Reference Calculation DC-820-001) in order to ensure that the degraded voltage relays will reset after the first loading step and will not (inadvertently) drop-out on subsequent steps in the event of an accident. These minimum voltages are dependent on the number of buses connected to each offsite source, the arrangement of transformers, and on whether the voltage regulator is in service. The voltage of the offsite sources must not exceed 104.2% of rated in order to avoid excessive voltage on motor terminals. The 115 kV line voltage can be higher than this if the voltage regulator is in service. No improvement in overall system performance can be obtained with alternative transformer tap settings.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8D-4 Table 8.D-2 CALCULATED MOTOR VOLTAGES FOR MAXIMUM OFFSITE VOLTAGE Two (2) cases, BLLXTF45 (115 kV source) and BLLXTF31 (230 kV source), were created to determine the maximum offsite system voltage allowable without producing excessive voltages at the motor terminals. Since A train was chosen as the worst case bus (heaviest load), B train was chosen as the bus to study under light load conditions (Mode 6). The criterion for evaluating worst case conditions was a running motor reaching 110% of rated terminal voltage (NEMA standard maximum). The source used for the evaluation of the 230 kV system was an emergency auxiliary transformer, XTF-31. The source used for the evaluation of the 115 kV system was 2 ESF transformers, XTF-4 and 5, in parallel. The offsite voltage was decreased by small increments of voltage from 1.0 per unit until the worst case motor was found. Maximum Offsite Voltage Maximum 115kV Source 230kV Source Operating B Allowable Case BLLXTF45 Case BLLXTF31 Dapper Bus # Train Motors Voltage 120 kV (1.042 pu) 240 kV (1.042 pu) 55 XPP1B 7590 7477 7476 72 XPP39B 7590 7472 7471 502 XHX1B 506 506
- 506
- 504 XPP31B 506 504 504 509 MFN97B 506 501 501 601 XPP48B 506 497 497 602 XFN23B 506 495 495 604 XPP32B 506 496 496 5004 ALOP2 506 497 497 5007 XFN36B 506 496 496 5504 XFN46B 506 496 496 5507 XFN133 506 498 498 5509 XFN32B 506 497 497 6002 XPP4B 506 498 498 6003 XPP141B 506 498 498 6004 XFN45B 506 497 497 6006 XPN48 506 497 497 6007 XFN45A 506 497 497 7006 XFN80B 506 494 494 9003 XFN38B 506 498 498 9005 XFN39B 506 499 499 9013 XFN83B 506 498 498
- Worst Case Motor
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-i Appendix 8E Analysis of the Voltage Drops on the ESF System When Starting a 6900 or 460 Volt Motor With the Diesel Generator as the Source
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-1 APPENDIX 8E ANALYSIS OF THE VOLTAGE DROPS ON THE ESF SYSTEM WHEN STARTING A 6900 OR 460 VOLT MOTOR WITH THE DIESEL GENERATOR AS THE SOURCE 8E.1 CRITERIA The criteria was to determine (1) the voltage at the terminals of the largest safety related 6900 and 460 volt motors when they are started and (2) the voltage at the other Safety Related buses during the same period. The power source was considered to be the diesel generator with the safety injection signal loads operating on the buses. 8E.2 BACKGROUND The 6900 volt charging/safety injection (CH/SI) pump motors and the 460 volt service water booster pump (SWBP) motors are the largest safety related motors for their respected voltages. Therefore, their characteristics were used in the calculations. Electrical analysis software was used to simulate the restart of the largest motors and to determine the effect on system voltages. The diesel generator can be modeled as an infinite source with zero impedance when modeling the system under steady state conditions since the generator voltage regulator will hold the terminal voltage to within +/- 1/2% of the setting. However, for transient conditions, the diesel generator model needs to include an internal impedance since the voltage regulator can not respond immediately to changes in loading. The source impedance for the transient model was based on the short circuit impedance of the generator as described below in section 8E.3. To obtain the internal source voltage, the source voltage of the model was manually adjusted to produce a machine terminal voltage of 0.945 per unit (under steady state conditions) with the generator load equal to the maximum system load, minus the load of the motor to be restarted. A terminal voltage of 0.945 per unit was used because the lower administrative limit for setting the voltage regulator is 95% and the regulator has a tolerance of +/- 1/2%. To find the voltage levels during the initial inrush for motor starting, the source voltage was held constant and the starting load of the motor was added to the system. The system voltages were then calculated. As described in Section 8D.2, the safety injection signal load is the largest load to be applied to the ESF system buses at any one time. Thus, this load was used as the running load on the buses.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-2 8E.3 METHOD An analytical software model (from calculation DC-836-008, case DSTEP8S) of the diesel generator steady state full load condition was used as a base case for developing the large motor restart model (Reference calculation DC-8360-012). This DSTEP8S case model determines the voltage at the A train buses when the Safety Injection loads are operating and when the Diesel Generator is supplying the load. To evaluate the restart of large motors on the diesel generator, the steady state analytical software model was modified to incorporate a source impedance and to create two new cases. The first analytical software model, case DS825R, simulates the restart of the 6900 Volt Charging/SI pump (XPP43, 900 HP) and the second, case DS8101R, simulates the restart of the 480 volt service water booster pump (XPP45, 350 HP). The source impedance was taken as equal to the short circuit impedance of the generator. This short circuit impedance was based on the generator test data which includes the following information: Generator rating: 5845 KVA Generator X/R ratio: 16 Short circuit reactance: 0.13 per unit The steady state analytical software model was copied and modified by adding the source impedance and turning pumps XPP43A and XPP45A off-line in order to simulate the pumps tripping. The source voltage for the model was manually adjusted until the generator terminal voltage was equal to 0.945 per unit. This is the lowest value allowed by the combination of the regulator setting limit of 95% and the +/- 1/2% tolerance of the regulator. The resulting source voltage was then held constant and the starting load for each of the two motors was added into each of the two respective models. The following are the load values used: Model Bus TAG KW KVAR 25 XPP43A 485 2992 101 XPP45A 231 1074 The resulting bus voltage from the two new model cases DS825R and DS8101R were then evaluated to determine the following:
- a. Acceptance of the motor starting voltage by comparing the model case voltage with the motors minimum required starting voltage.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-3
- b. Verification that the motor control center (MCC) contactors do not drop out during large motor restart.
The 6900 volt safety related motors were designed to start at 70% of rated voltage and, therefore, have a minimum starting voltage of 4830 volts. The 460 volt safety related motors were designed to start at 80% of rated voltage and, therefore, have a minimum starting voltage of 368 volts. The contactors in the SQUARE D motor control centers have a dropout of 65% of nominal voltage. A value of 5% was added to account for voltage drop within the control circuit. Since the 480/120 Volt power transformers are wound to produce 120 volts on the secondary when fully loaded, a value of 70% of 480 volts (336V) on the MCC busses was used in the evaluation. 8E.4 CONCLUSION Considering the diesel generator as the power source, the calculated voltage at the terminals of the 6900 volt CH/SI pump motor and 460 volt SWBP motor is above the minimum design starting voltage as mentioned in Section 8.3.1.1.4.2 and listed below: VOLTAGE Model Bus TAG MIN Start Calculated Margin 25 XPP43A 4830 6323 31% 101 XPP45A 368 415 13% Since other safety related motors are smaller than the CH/SI pump motor and the SWBP motor for their respective voltage levels, the motor terminal voltage during the starting of all safety related motors will be above the design starting voltage for these motors.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-4 The following table lists the voltages at each MCC bus for each of the two restart conditions. The table shows that all voltages are substantially above the 336 volt criteria and, therefore, verifies that the energized contactors will not drop out during large motor restart. Model Bus TAG START XPP43A START XPP45A 1000 XMC1DA1X-P 410 431 1500 XMC1DA2X-S 409 430 2000 XMC1DA2Y-P 408 429 2500 XMC1DA2Y-S 409 430 3000 XMC1DA2Z 407 428 4000 XMC1EA1X 418 438 8000 XMC1EC1X* 418 438
- Loads on this MCC are not energized. Therefore, the voltages are the same as for bus 4000.
Tables 8.E-1 and 8.E-2 list the calculated voltages of the ESF system buses and the motor terminals.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-5 Table 8.E-1 CALCULATED VOLTAGE LEVEL OF ESF SYSTEM BUSES AND MOTOR TERMINALS WITH A DIESEL GENERATOR AS A SOURCE AND STARTING THE 6900 VOLT CHARGING/SAFETY INJECTION PUMP MOTOR Condition: Initial voltage: 6804 (94.5% of 7200 volts at diesel generator terminals prior to starting motor) Initial Load: 3505 KW Power Source: Diesel Generator Motor: Charging/Safety Injection Pump Mtr. (6900 Volt) Resulting Voltages: Percent of ESF System Points Voltages Nominal Bus Voltage Diesel Generator 6339 88.04 7200 Volt Bus 1DA 6328 87.88 6900 Volt CH/SI Pump 6323 91.63 of motor nominal rating 480 Volt Bus 1DA1 418 87.08 480 Volt Bus 1DA2 410 85.41 480 Volt MCC 1DA2Z 407 84.79 7200 Volt Bus 1EA 6322 87.8 480 Volt MCC 1EA1X 418 87.08
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8E-6 Table 8.E-2 CALCULATED VOLTAGE LEVEL OF ESF SYSTEM BUSES AND MOTOR TERMINALS WITH A DIESEL GENERATOR AS A SOURCE AND STARTING THE 460 VOLT SERVICE WATER PUMP MOTOR Condition: Initial voltage: 6804 (94.5% of 7200 volts at diesel generator terminals prior to starting motor) Initial Load: 4087 kW Power Source: Diesel Generator Motor: Service Water Booster Pump Motor (460 Volt) Resulting Voltages: ESF System Points Voltages Percent of Nominal Bus Voltage Diesel Generator 6627 92.04 7200 Volt Bus 1DA 6618 91.92 460 Volt SWBP Pump 415 90.21 of motor nominal rating 480 Volt Bus 1DA1 423 88.12 480 Volt Bus 1DA2 431 89.79 480 Volt MCC 1DA2Z 428 89.16 7200 Volt Bus 1EA 6612 91.83 480 Volt MCC 1EA1X 438 91.25
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-i Appendix 8F Starting Sequence of ESF Equipment Following an Accident Coincident With a Degraded Voltage Condition
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-1 APPENDIX 8F STARTING SEQUENCE OF ESF EQUIPMENT FOLLOWING AN ACCIDENT COINCIDENT WITH A DEGRADED VOLTAGE CONDITION 8F.1 INTRODUCTION The following study identifies the timed sequence of starting the ESF system equipment for an accident coincident with degraded voltage on the offsite power system. The accidents considered are (1) Loss of Coolant Accident (LOCA) and (2) Main Steam Line Break (MSLB). The study compares the equipment starting times during accident conditions, with a degraded voltage to the starting times assumed in the accident analyses with total loss of voltage. See Tables 8.F-1 and 8.F-2. 8F.2 DISCUSSION During these two accident scenarios, the diesel generator will start when safety injection is initiated at time zero. A maximum of 10 seconds is then required for the generator to reach the speed and voltage necessary to connect to the ESF buses. The degraded voltage relays are set to actuate at 91.34% of nominal voltage. If the voltage drops below 80% of nominal, the undervoltage relays will actuate. A time delay of 3 seconds is provided before the degraded voltage relays signal a start to the diesel to allow for voltage dips caused by a large motor starting. However, it should be noted that for these accidents the diesel was started at time zero by safety injection; therefore the signal to start the diesel generated by the degraded voltage relay is duplicative. If the degraded voltage condition persists for 4 more seconds (now a total of 7 seconds), the 7.2 kV ESF buses are cleared. An additional time delay of 3 seconds is then provided to allow residual motor voltage to decay. 8F.3 CONCLUSION Under the accidents discussed here, a maximum of 10 seconds is required before the diesel generator can be connected to the ESF buses. However, if there is no accident and a degraded voltage condition exists, a maximum of 13 seconds would be required before the diesel is connected.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-2 Table 8.F-1 DEGRADED GRID VOLTAGE COINCIDENT WITH LOCA Time (Seconds) Description of Event 0 Degraded voltage condition on 7.2 kV ESF Buses Loss of Coolant Accident (SI Signal - Start Diesel Generator signal). 3 Degraded voltage detection signal. 7 Clear 7.2 kV ESF bus (Trip incoming and feeder breakers). 10 Close Diesel Generator breaker. Start load block #1(Start SI/Charging Pump, Start opening valves). 12 SI/Charging Pump at full speed Note 1 (~ 2 sec starting time). 15 Start RHR Pump. 19 RHR Pump at full speed Note 1 (~ 4 sec starting time). 20 Start SW Pump. Start Chilled Water Pump. 24.5 SW Pump at full speed Note 2 (~ 4.5 sec starting time). 25 Start Component Cooling Pump. Component Cooling Pump at full speed (~ 4 sec starting time). 27 Safety Injection related valves at their final position Note 1 (27 sec. includes EDG start time, valve stroke time, and signal processing time). 30 Start Emergency Feedwater Pump. 35 Start Reactor Building Cooling Units. Start Fuel Handling Building Exhaust Fan. 40 Start SW Booster Pump. 42 Emergency Feedwater Pump at Full Speed. (~ 12 sec starting time).
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-3 Table 8.F-1 (continued) DEGRADED GRID VOLTAGE COINCIDENT WITH LOCA Time (Seconds) Description of Event 43 Reactor Building Cooling Units at full speed and air flow Note 4 has reached operating values (8 sec delay from time of starting the fans to the time of having reached operating values of air flow per FSAR, Section 6.2.2.2.2.2). 45 Start HVAC Chiller. SW Booster Pump at full speed (5 sec starting time per FSAR, Section 6.2.2.2.2.2). (1) Refer to Section15.4 for discussions on LBLOCA. (2) Critical case is the requirement to provide cooling water to the Diesel Generator within 1 minute from the time of starting. (3) See FSAR, Section 15.4.2.2.2.1. (4) See FSAR, Section 6.2.1.3.4.3.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-4 Table 8.F-2 DEGRADED GRID VOLTAGE COINCIDENT WITH MSLB Time (Seconds) Description of Event 0 Degraded voltage condition on 7.2 kV ESF Bus on Main Steam Line Break Accident (SI Signal - Start Diesel Generator signal). 3 Degraded voltage detection signal. 7 Clear 7.2 kV ESF bus (Trip incoming and feeder breakers). 10 Close Diesel Generator breaker. Start load block #1 (Start SI/Charging Pump, Start opening valves). 12 SI/Charging Pump at full speed Note 1 (~ 2 sec starting time). 15 Start RHR Pump. 19 RHR Pump at full speed Note 1 (~ 4 sec starting time). 20 Start SW Pump. Start Chilled Water Pump. 24.5 SW Pump at full speed Note 2 (~ 4.5 sec starting time). 25 Start Component Cooling Pump. 27 Safety Injection related valves at their final position Note 1 (27 sec. includes EDG start time, valve stroke time, and signal processing time). 29 Component Cooling Pump at full speed (~ 4 sec starting time). 30 Start Emergency Feedwater Pump. Start Reactor Building Cooling Units. 35 Start Fuel Handling Building Exhaust Fan. 40 Start SW Booster Pump.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8F-5 Table 8.F-2 (continued) DEGRADED GRID VOLTAGE COINCIDENT WITH MSLB Time (Seconds) Description of Event 42 Emergency Feedwater Pump at Full Speed. (60) Note 3 (~ 12 sec starting time). 43 Reactor Building Cooling Units at full speed and air flow Note 4 has reached operating values (8 sec delay from time of starting the fans to the time of having reached operating values of air flow per FSAR, Section 6.2.2.2.2.2). 45 Start HVAC Chiller. SW Booster Pump at full speed (5 sec starting time per FSAR, Section 6.2.2.2.2.2). (1) See FSAR Section 15.4.2.1.2.1. (2) Critical case is the requirement to provide cooling water to the Diesel Generator within 1 minute from the time of starting. (3) See FSAR, Section 15.4.2.2.2.1. (4) See FSAR, Section 6.2.1.3.4.3.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-i Appendix 8G Electrical Containment Penetration Conductor Overcurrent Protection Devices
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-ii Intentionally Blank
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-1 Electrical Containment Penetration Conductor Overcurrent Protection Devices The following drawings identify overcurrent protection devices required to protect containment penetration assembly conductors in accordance with the requirements of Regulatory Guide 1.63. Regulatory Guide 1.63 is discussed in further detail in Appendix 3A.
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-2 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-1, Sheet 1 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-3 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-2, Sheet 2 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-4 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-3, Sheet 3 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-5 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-4, Sheet 4 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-6 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-5, Sheet 5 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-7 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-6, Sheet 6 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-8 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-7, Sheet 7 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-9 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-8, Sheet 8 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-10 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-9, Sheet 9 DRAWING E-224-532
Revision 22--Updated Online 05/27/22 VC SUMMER UFSAR 8G-11 FSAR FIGURE REFERENCE FIGURE 8G-10, Sheet 10 DRAWING E-224-532}}